-
Joint Electromagnetic and Gravitational Wave Inference of Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 Using Forward-Modeling Ejecta Predictions
Authors:
Marko Ristić,
Richard O'Shaughnessy,
Kate Wagner,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Chris L. Fryer,
Oleg Korobkin,
Matthew R. Mumpower,
Ryan T. Wollaeger
Abstract:
We reassess the capacity for multimessenger inference of AT2017gfo/GW170817 using both kilonova and gravitational wave emission within the context of a recent simulation-based surrogate model for kilonova emission. Independent of the inclusion of gravitational wave observations, comparisons between observations that incorporate our kilonova model favor a narrow range of ejecta properties, even whe…
▽ More
We reassess the capacity for multimessenger inference of AT2017gfo/GW170817 using both kilonova and gravitational wave emission within the context of a recent simulation-based surrogate model for kilonova emission. Independent of the inclusion of gravitational wave observations, comparisons between observations that incorporate our kilonova model favor a narrow range of ejecta properties, even when allowing for a wide range of systematic uncertainties in our modeling approach. Conversely, we find that astrophysical conclusions about the neutron star itself, including its mass and radius, depend strongly on assumptions about how much material is ejected from the neutron star. Looking forward, our analysis highlights the importance of systematic uncertainty in general, the need for better modeling of neutron star merger mass ejection from first principles, and warns against uncontextualized applications of ejecta predictions using fits to numerical relativity simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Kilonova Light-Curve Interpolation with Neural Networks
Authors:
Yinglei Peng,
Marko Ristić,
Atul Kedia,
Richard O'Shaughnessy,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Chris L. Fryer,
Oleg Korobkin,
Matthew R. Mumpower,
V. Ashley Villar,
Ryan T. Wollaeger
Abstract:
Kilonovae are the electromagnetic transients created by the radioactive decay of freshly synthesized elements in the environment surrounding a neutron star merger. To study the fundamental physics in these complex environments, kilonova modeling requires, in part, the use of radiative transfer simulations. The microphysics involved in these simulations results in high computational cost, prompting…
▽ More
Kilonovae are the electromagnetic transients created by the radioactive decay of freshly synthesized elements in the environment surrounding a neutron star merger. To study the fundamental physics in these complex environments, kilonova modeling requires, in part, the use of radiative transfer simulations. The microphysics involved in these simulations results in high computational cost, prompting the use of emulators for parameter inference applications. Utilizing a training set of 22248 high-fidelity simulations (composed of 412 unique ejecta parameter combinations evaluated at 54 viewing angles), we use a neural network to efficiently train on existing radiative transfer simulations and predict light curves for new parameters in a fast and computationally efficient manner. Our neural network can generate millions of new light curves in under a minute. We discuss our emulator's degree of off-sample reliability and parameter inference of the AT2017gfo observational data. Finally, we discuss tension introduced by multi-band inference in the parameter inference results, particularly with regard to the neural network's recovery of viewing angle.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2024; v1 submitted 8 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
The Effect of the Velocity Distribution on Kilonova Emission
Authors:
Chris L. Fryer,
Aimee L. Hungerford,
Ryan T. Wollaeger,
Jonah M. Miller,
Soumi De,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Oleg Korobkin,
Atul Kedia,
Marko Ristic,
Richard O'Shaugnessy
Abstract:
The electromagnetic emission from the non-relativistic ejecta launched in neutron star mergers (either dynamically or through a disk wind) has the potential to probe both the total mass and composition of this ejecta. These observations are crucial in understanding the role of these mergers in the production of r-process elements in the universe. However, many properties of the ejecta can alter th…
▽ More
The electromagnetic emission from the non-relativistic ejecta launched in neutron star mergers (either dynamically or through a disk wind) has the potential to probe both the total mass and composition of this ejecta. These observations are crucial in understanding the role of these mergers in the production of r-process elements in the universe. However, many properties of the ejecta can alter the light-curves and we must both identify which properties play a role in shaping this emission and understand the effects these properties have on the emission before we can use observations to place strong constraints on the amount of r-process elements produced in the merger. This paper focuses on understanding the effect of the velocity distribution (amount of mass moving at different velocities) for lanthanide-rich ejecta on the light-curves and spectra. The simulations use distributions guided by recent calculations of disk outflows and compare the velocity-distribution effects to those of ejecta mass, velocity and composition. Our comparisons show that uncertainties in the velocity distribution can lead to factor of 2-4 uncertainties in the inferred ejecta mass based on peak infra-red luminosities. We also show that early-time UV or optical observations may be able to constrain the velocity distribution, reducing the uncertainty in the ejecta mass.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Heavy element nucleosynthesis associated with a gamma-ray burst
Authors:
James H. Gillanders,
Eleonora Troja,
Chris L. Fryer,
Marko Ristic,
Brendan O'Connor,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Yu-Han Yang,
Nanae Domoto,
Salma Rahmouni,
Masaomi Tanaka,
Ori D. Fox,
Simone Dichiara
Abstract:
Kilonovae are a novel class of astrophysical transients, and the only observationally-confirmed site of rapid neutron capture nucleosynthesis (the r-process) in the Universe. To date, only a handful of kilonovae have been detected, with just a single spectroscopically-observed event (AT 2017gfo). Spectra of AT 2017gfo provided evidence for the formation of elements heavier than iron; however, thes…
▽ More
Kilonovae are a novel class of astrophysical transients, and the only observationally-confirmed site of rapid neutron capture nucleosynthesis (the r-process) in the Universe. To date, only a handful of kilonovae have been detected, with just a single spectroscopically-observed event (AT 2017gfo). Spectra of AT 2017gfo provided evidence for the formation of elements heavier than iron; however, these spectra were collected during the first ~ 10 days, when emission from light r-process elements dominates the observations. Heavier elements, if synthesised, are expected to shape the late-time evolution of the kilonova, beyond the phases for which we have spectral observations. Here we present spectroscopic observations of a rapidly-reddening thermal transient, following the gamma-ray burst, GRB 230307A. Early (2.4 day) optical spectroscopy identifies the presence of a hot (T ~ 6700 K) thermal continuum. By 29 days, this component has expanded and cooled significantly (T ~ 640 K), yet it remains optically thick, indicating the presence of high-opacity ejecta. We show that these properties can only be explained by the merger of compact objects, and further, leads us to infer the production of the heavy lanthanide elements. We identify several spectral features (in both absorption and emission), whose cause can be explained by newly-synthesised heavy elements. This event marks only the second recorded spectroscopic evidence for the synthesis of r-process elements, and the first to be observed at such late times.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Interpolated kilonova spectra models: necessity for a phenomenological, blue component in the fitting of AT2017gfo spectra
Authors:
Marko Ristic,
Richard O'Shaughnessy,
V. Ashley Villar,
Ryan T. Wollaeger,
Oleg Korobkin,
Chris L. Fryer,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Atul Kedia
Abstract:
In this work, we present a simple interpolation methodology for spectroscopic time series, based on conventional interpolation techniques (random forests) implemented in widely-available libraries. We demonstrate that our existing library of simulations is sufficient for training, producing interpolated spectra that respond sensitively to varied ejecta parameter, post-merger time, and viewing angl…
▽ More
In this work, we present a simple interpolation methodology for spectroscopic time series, based on conventional interpolation techniques (random forests) implemented in widely-available libraries. We demonstrate that our existing library of simulations is sufficient for training, producing interpolated spectra that respond sensitively to varied ejecta parameter, post-merger time, and viewing angle inputs. We compare our interpolated spectra to the AT2017gfo spectral data, and find parameters similar to our previous inferences using broadband light curves. However, the spectral observations have significant systematic short-wavelength residuals relative to our models, which we cannot explain within our existing framework. Similar to previous studies, we argue that an additional blue component is required. We consider a radioactive heating source as a third component characterized by light, slow-moving, lanthanide-free ejecta with $M_{\rm th} = 0.003~M_\odot$, $v_{\rm th} = 0.05$c, and $κ_{\rm th} = 1$ cm$^2$/g. When included as part of our radiative transfer simulations, our choice of third component reprocesses blue photons into lower energies, having the opposite effect and further accentuating the blue-underluminosity disparity in our simulations. As such, we are unable to overcome short-wavelength deficits at later times using an additional radioactive heating component, indicating the need for a more sophisticated modeling treatment.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2023; v1 submitted 13 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Surrogate light curve models for kilonovae with comprehensive wind ejecta outflows and parameter estimation for AT2017gfo
Authors:
Atul Kedia,
Marko Ristic,
Richard O'Shaughnessy,
Anjali B. Yelikar,
Ryan T. Wollaeger,
Oleg Korobkin,
Eve A. Chase,
Christopher L. Fryer,
Christopher J. Fontes
Abstract:
The electromagnetic emission resulting from neutron star mergers have been shown to encode properties of the ejected material in their light curves. The ejecta properties inferred from the kilonova emission has been in tension with those calculated based on the gravitational wave signal and numerical relativity models. Motivated by this tension, we construct a broad set of surrogate light curve mo…
▽ More
The electromagnetic emission resulting from neutron star mergers have been shown to encode properties of the ejected material in their light curves. The ejecta properties inferred from the kilonova emission has been in tension with those calculated based on the gravitational wave signal and numerical relativity models. Motivated by this tension, we construct a broad set of surrogate light curve models derived for kilonova ejecta. The four-parameter family of two-dimensional anisotropic simulations and its associated surrogate explore different assumptions about the wind outflow morphology and outflow composition, keeping the dynamical ejecta component consistent. We present the capabilities of these surrogate models in interpolating kilonova light curves across various ejecta parameters and perform parameter estimation for AT2017gfo both without any assumptions on the outflow and under the assumption that the outflow must be representative of solar r-process abundance patterns. Our parameter estimation for AT2017gfo shows these surrogate models help alleviate the ejecta property discrepancy while also illustrating the impact of systematic modeling uncertainties on these properties, urging further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023; v1 submitted 8 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Constraining inputs to realistic kilonova simulations through comparison to observed $r$-process abundances
Authors:
M. Ristic,
E. M. Holmbeck,
R. Wollaeger,
O. Korobkin,
E. Champion,
R. O'Shaughnessy,
C. L. Fryer,
C. J. Fontes,
M. R. Mumpower,
T. M. Sprouse
Abstract:
Kilonovae, one source of electromagnetic emission associated with neutron star mergers, are powered by the decay of radioactive isotopes in the neutron-rich merger ejecta. Models for kilonova emission consistent with the electromagnetic counterpart to GW170817 predict characteristic abundance patterns, determined by the relative balance of different types of material in the outflow. Assuming the o…
▽ More
Kilonovae, one source of electromagnetic emission associated with neutron star mergers, are powered by the decay of radioactive isotopes in the neutron-rich merger ejecta. Models for kilonova emission consistent with the electromagnetic counterpart to GW170817 predict characteristic abundance patterns, determined by the relative balance of different types of material in the outflow. Assuming the observed source is prototypical, this inferred abundance pattern in turn must match $r$-process abundances deduced by other means, such as what is observed in the solar system. We report on analysis comparing the input mass-weighted elemental compositions adopted in our radiative transfer simulations to the mass fractions of elements in the Sun, as a practical prototype for the potentially universal abundance signature from neutron-star mergers. We characterize the extent to which our parameter inference results depend on our assumed composition for the dynamical and wind ejecta and examine how the new results compare to previous work. We find that a dynamical ejecta composition calculated using the FRDM2012 nuclear mass and FRLDM fission models with extremely neutron-rich ejecta ($Y_{\rm{e}} = 0.035$) along with moderately neutron-rich ($Y_{\rm e} = 0.27$) wind ejecta composition yields a wind-to-dynamical mass ratio of $M_{\rm{w}}/M_{\rm{d}}$ = 0.47 which best matches the observed AT2017gfo kilonova light curves while also producing the best-matching abundance of neutron-capture elements in the solar system.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2023; v1 submitted 5 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Kilonova Detectability with Wide-Field Instruments
Authors:
Eve A. Chase,
Brendan O'Connor,
Christopher L. Fryer,
Eleonora Troja,
Oleg Korobkin,
Ryan T. Wollaeger,
Marko Ristic,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Aimee L. Hungerford,
Angela M. Herring
Abstract:
Kilonovae are ultraviolet, optical, and infrared transients powered by the radioactive decay of heavy elements following a neutron star merger. Joint observations of kilonovae and gravitational waves can offer key constraints on the source of Galactic $r$-process enrichment, among other astrophysical topics. However, robust constraints on heavy element production requires rapid kilonova detection…
▽ More
Kilonovae are ultraviolet, optical, and infrared transients powered by the radioactive decay of heavy elements following a neutron star merger. Joint observations of kilonovae and gravitational waves can offer key constraints on the source of Galactic $r$-process enrichment, among other astrophysical topics. However, robust constraints on heavy element production requires rapid kilonova detection (within $\sim 1$ day of merger) as well as multi-wavelength observations across multiple epochs. In this study, we quantify the ability of 13 wide field-of-view instruments to detect kilonovae, leveraging a large grid of over 900 radiative transfer simulations with 54 viewing angles per simulation. We consider both current and upcoming instruments, collectively spanning the full kilonova spectrum. The Roman Space Telescope has the highest redshift reach of any instrument in the study, observing kilonovae out to $z \sim 1$ within the first day post-merger. We demonstrate that BlackGEM, DECam, GOTO, the Vera C. Rubin Observatory's LSST, ULTRASAT, and VISTA can observe some kilonovae out to $z \sim 0.1$ ($\sim$475 Mpc), while DDOTI, MeerLICHT, PRIME, $Swift$/UVOT, and ZTF are confined to more nearby observations. Furthermore, we provide a framework to infer kilonova ejecta properties following non-detections and explore variation in detectability with these ejecta parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
A Broad Grid of 2D Kilonova Emission Models
Authors:
R. T. Wollaeger,
C. L. Fryer,
E. A. Chase,
C. J. Fontes,
M. Ristic,
A. L. Hungerford,
O. Korobkin,
R. O'Shaughnessy,
A. M. Herring
Abstract:
Depending upon the properties of their compact remnants and the physics included in the models, simulations of neutron star mergers can produce a broad range of ejecta properties. The characteristics of this ejecta, in turn, define the kilonova emission. To explore the effect of ejecta properties, we present a grid of 2-component 2D axisymmetric kilonova simulations that vary mass, velocity, morph…
▽ More
Depending upon the properties of their compact remnants and the physics included in the models, simulations of neutron star mergers can produce a broad range of ejecta properties. The characteristics of this ejecta, in turn, define the kilonova emission. To explore the effect of ejecta properties, we present a grid of 2-component 2D axisymmetric kilonova simulations that vary mass, velocity, morphology, and composition. The masses and velocities of each component vary, respectively, from 0.001 to 0.1 M$_{\odot}$ and 0.05 to 0.3$c$, covering much of the range of results from the neutron star merger literature. The set of 900 models is constrained to have a toroidal low electron fraction ($Y_e$) ejecta with a robust r-process composition and either a spherical or lobed high-$Y_e$ ejecta with two possible compositions. We simulate these models with the Monte Carlo radiative transfer code SuperNu using a full suite of lanthanide and 4th row element opacities. We examine the trends of these models with parameter variation, show how it can be used with statistical tools, and compare the model light curves and spectra to those of AT2017gfo, the electromagnetic counterpart of GW170817.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Interpolating Detailed Simulations of Kilonovae: Adaptive Learning and Parameter Inference Applications
Authors:
M. Ristic,
E. Champion,
R. O'Shaughnessy,
R. Wollaeger,
O. Korobkin,
E. A. Chase,
C. L. Fryer,
A. L. Hungerford,
C. J. Fontes
Abstract:
Detailed radiative transfer simulations of kilonovae are difficult to apply directly to observations; they only sparsely cover simulation parameters, such as the mass, velocity, morphology, and composition of the ejecta. On the other hand, semianalytic models for kilonovae can be evaluated continuously over model parameters, but neglect important physical details which are not incorporated in the…
▽ More
Detailed radiative transfer simulations of kilonovae are difficult to apply directly to observations; they only sparsely cover simulation parameters, such as the mass, velocity, morphology, and composition of the ejecta. On the other hand, semianalytic models for kilonovae can be evaluated continuously over model parameters, but neglect important physical details which are not incorporated in the simulations, thus introducing systematic bias. Starting with a grid of 2D anisotropic simulations of kilonova light curves covering a wide range of ejecta properties, we apply adaptive-learning techniques to iteratively choose new simulations and produce high-fidelity surrogate models for those simulations. These surrogate models allow for continuous evaluation across model parameters while retaining the microphysical details about the ejecta. Using a new code for multimessenger inference, we demonstrate how to use our interpolated models to infer kilonova parameters. Comparing to inferences using simplified analytic models, we recover different ejecta properties. We discuss the implications of this analysis which is qualitatively consistent with similar previous work using detailed ejecta opacity calculations and which illustrates systematic challenges for kilonova modeling. An associated data and code release provides our interpolated light-curve models, interpolation implementation which can be applied to reproduce our work or extend to new models, and our multimessenger parameter inference engine.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2022; v1 submitted 14 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Minimum Orbital Period of Pre-Cataclysmic Variables
Authors:
L. Nelson,
J. Schwab,
M. Ristic,
S. Rappaport
Abstract:
More than 20 pre-cataclysmic variable (pre-CV) systems have now been discovered with very short orbital periods ranging from 250 min down to 68 min. A pre-CV consists of a white dwarf or hot subdwarf primary and a low-mass companion star, where the companion star has successfully ejected the common envelope of the primary progenitor, but mass transfer from the companion star to the primary has not…
▽ More
More than 20 pre-cataclysmic variable (pre-CV) systems have now been discovered with very short orbital periods ranging from 250 min down to 68 min. A pre-CV consists of a white dwarf or hot subdwarf primary and a low-mass companion star, where the companion star has successfully ejected the common envelope of the primary progenitor, but mass transfer from the companion star to the primary has not yet commenced. In this short-period range, a substantial fraction of the companion stars are likely to be either brown dwarfs with masses $\lesssim 0.07 \, M_\odot$ or stars at the bottom of the MS ($\lesssim 0.1 M_\odot$). The discovery of these short-period pre-CVs raises the question -- what is the shortest possible orbital period of such systems? We ran 500 brown dwarf/low-mass main sequence models with {\tt MESA} that cover the mass range from 0.002 to 0.1 $M_\odot$. We find the shortest possible orbital period is 40 min with a corresponding brown dwarf mass of 0.07 $M_\odot$ for an age equal to a Hubble time. We discuss the past evolution of these systems through the common envelope and suggest that many of the systems with present day white dwarf primaries may have exited the common envelope with the primary as a helium burning hot subdwarf. We also characterize the future evolution of the observed systems, which includes a phase as CVs below the conventional period minimum.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
