Showing 1–50 of 63 results for author: Richstone, D

The Black Hole Mass and Photometric Components of NGC 4826

Authors: Kayhan Gültekin, Karl Gebhardt, John Kormendy, Adi Foord, Ralf Bender, Tod R. Lauer, Jason Pinkney, Douglas O. Richstone, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We present IR photometry and HST imaging and spectroscopy of Sab galaxy NGC 4826. Schwarzschild dynamical modeling is used to measure its central black hole mass $M$. Photometric decomposition is used to enable a comparison of $M$ to published scaling relations between black hole masses and properties of host bulges. This decomposition implies that NGC 4826 contains classical and pseudo bulges of… ▽ More We present IR photometry and HST imaging and spectroscopy of Sab galaxy NGC 4826. Schwarzschild dynamical modeling is used to measure its central black hole mass $M$. Photometric decomposition is used to enable a comparison of $M$ to published scaling relations between black hole masses and properties of host bulges. This decomposition implies that NGC 4826 contains classical and pseudo bulges of approximately equal mass. The classical bulge has best-fit Sérsic index $n=3.27$. The pseudobulge is made up of three parts, an inner lens ($n=0.18$ at $r\lesssim4^{\prime\prime}$), an outer lens ($n=0.17$ at $r \lesssim 45^{\prime\prime}$), and a $n=0.58$ component required to match the surface brightness between the lens components. The total $V$-band luminosity of the galaxy is $M_{VT}=-21.07$, the ratio of classical bulge to total light is $B/T\simeq0.12$, and the ratio of pseudobulge to total light is $PB/T\simeq0.13$. The outer disk is exponential ($n=1.07$) and makes up $D/T=0.75$ of the light of the galaxy. Our best-fit Schwarzschild model has a black hole mass with $1σ$ uncertainties of $M=8.4^{+1.7}_{-0.6}\times10^6\ M_\odot$ and a stellar $K$-band mass-to-light ratio of $Υ_K=0.46\pm0.03\ M_{\odot}\ \mathrm{L}_{\odot}^{-1}$ at the assumed distance of 7.27 Mpc. Our modeling is marginally consistent with $M=0$ at the $3σ$ limit. These best-fit parameters were calculated assuming the black hole is located where the velocity dispersion is largest; this is offset from the maximum surface brightness, probably because of dust absorption. The black hole mass -- one of the smallest measured by modeling stellar dynamics -- satisfies the well known correlations of $M$ with the $K$-band luminosity, stellar mass, and velocity dispersion of the classical bulge only in contrast to total (classical plus pseudo) bulge luminosity. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ. 27 or so pages, 18 figures I think. Online data is available at https://doi.org/10.7302/kr8z-fj98

A Black Hole Mass Determination for the Compact Galaxy Mrk 1216

Authors: Jonelle L. Walsh, Remco C. E. van den Bosch, Karl Gebhardt, Akın Yıldırım, Kayhan Gültekin, Bernd Husemann, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Mrk 1216 is a nearby, early-type galaxy with a small effective radius of 2.8 kpc and a large stellar velocity dispersion of 308 km/s for its K-band luminosity of 1.4x10^11 L_sun. Using integral-field spectroscopy assisted by adaptive optics from Gemini North, we measure spatially resolved stellar kinematics within ~450 pc of the galaxy nucleus. The galaxy exhibits regular rotation with velocities… ▽ More Mrk 1216 is a nearby, early-type galaxy with a small effective radius of 2.8 kpc and a large stellar velocity dispersion of 308 km/s for its K-band luminosity of 1.4x10^11 L_sun. Using integral-field spectroscopy assisted by adaptive optics from Gemini North, we measure spatially resolved stellar kinematics within ~450 pc of the galaxy nucleus. The galaxy exhibits regular rotation with velocities of \pm 180 km/s and a sharply peaked velocity dispersion profile that reaches 425 km/s at the center. We fit axisymmetric, orbit-based dynamical models to the combination of these high angular resolution kinematics, large-scale kinematics extending to roughly three effective radii, and Hubble Space Telescope imaging, resulting in a constraint of the mass of the central black hole in Mrk 1216. After exploring several possible sources of systematics that commonly affect stellar-dynamical black hole mass measurements, we find a black hole mass of (4.9\pm1.7)x10^9 M_sun and a H-band stellar mass-to-light ratio of 1.3\pm0.4 M_sun/L_sun (1-sigma uncertainties). Mrk 1216 is consistent with the local black hole mass - stellar velocity dispersion relation, but is a factor of ~5-10 larger than expectations from the black hole mass - bulge luminosity and black hole mass - bulge mass correlations when conservatively using the galaxy's total luminosity or stellar mass. This behavior is quite similar to the extensively studied compact galaxy NGC 1277. Resembling the z~2 quiescent galaxies, Mrk 1216 may be a passively evolved descendant, and perhaps reflects a previous era when galaxies contained over-massive black holes relative to their bulge luminosities/masses, and the growth of host galaxies had yet to catch up. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: accepted for publication in ApJ

A 5x10^9 Solar Mass Black Hole in NGC 1277 from Adaptive Optics Spectroscopy

Authors: Jonelle L. Walsh, Remco C. E. van den Bosch, Karl Gebhardt, Akın Yıldırım, Douglas O. Richstone, Kayhan Gültekin, Bernd Husemann

Abstract: The nearby lenticular galaxy NGC 1277 is thought to host one of the largest black holes known, however the black hole mass measurement is based on low spatial resolution spectroscopy. In this paper, we present Gemini Near-infrared Integral Field Spectrometer observations assisted by adaptive optics. We map out the galaxy's stellar kinematics within ~440 pc of the nucleus with an angular resolution… ▽ More The nearby lenticular galaxy NGC 1277 is thought to host one of the largest black holes known, however the black hole mass measurement is based on low spatial resolution spectroscopy. In this paper, we present Gemini Near-infrared Integral Field Spectrometer observations assisted by adaptive optics. We map out the galaxy's stellar kinematics within ~440 pc of the nucleus with an angular resolution that allows us to probe well within the region where the potential from the black hole dominates. We find that the stellar velocity dispersion rises dramatically, reaching ~550 km/s at the center. Through orbit-based, stellar-dynamical models we obtain a black hole mass of (4.9 \pm 1.6) x 10^9 Msun (1-sigma uncertainties). Although the black hole mass measurement is smaller by a factor of ~3 compared to previous claims based on large-scale kinematics, NGC 1277 does indeed contain one of the most massive black holes detected to date, and the black hole mass is an order of magnitude larger than expectations from the empirical relation between black hole mass and galaxy luminosity. Given the galaxy's similarities to the higher redshift (z~2) massive quiescent galaxies, NGC 1277 could be a relic, passively evolving since that period. A population of local analogs to the higher redshift quiescent galaxies that also contain over-massive black holes may suggest that black hole growth precedes that of the host galaxy. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: accepted for publication in ApJ

The Black Hole in the Compact, High-dispersion Galaxy NGC 1271

Authors: Jonelle L. Walsh, Remco C. E. van den Bosch, Karl Gebhardt, Akın Yıldırım, Kayhan Gültekin, Bernd Husemann, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Located in the Perseus cluster, NGC 1271 is an early-type galaxy with a small effective radius of 2.2 kpc and a large stellar velocity dispersion of 276 km/s for its K-band luminosity of 8.9x10^{10} L_sun. We present a mass measurement for the black hole in this compact, high-dispersion galaxy using observations from the integral field spectrograph NIFS on the Gemini North telescope assisted by la… ▽ More Located in the Perseus cluster, NGC 1271 is an early-type galaxy with a small effective radius of 2.2 kpc and a large stellar velocity dispersion of 276 km/s for its K-band luminosity of 8.9x10^{10} L_sun. We present a mass measurement for the black hole in this compact, high-dispersion galaxy using observations from the integral field spectrograph NIFS on the Gemini North telescope assisted by laser guide star adaptive optics, large-scale integral field unit observations with PPAK at the Calar Alto Observatory, and Hubble Space Telescope WFC3 imaging observations. We are able to map out the stellar kinematics on small spatial scales, within the black hole sphere of influence, and on large scales that extend out to four times the galaxy's effective radius. We find that the galaxy is rapidly rotating and exhibits a sharp rise in the velocity dispersion. Through the use of orbit-based stellar dynamical models, we determine that the black hole has a mass of (3.0^{+1.0}_{-1.1}) x 10^9 M_sun and the H-band stellar mass-to-light ratio is 1.40^{+0.13}_{-0.11} M_sun/L_sun (1-sigma uncertainties). NGC 1271 occupies the sparsely-populated upper end of the black hole mass distribution, but is very different from the Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) and giant elliptical galaxies that are expected to host the most massive black holes. Interestingly, the black hole mass is an order of magnitude larger than expectations based on the galaxy's bulge luminosity, but is consistent with the mass predicted using the galaxy's bulge stellar velocity dispersion. More compact, high-dispersion galaxies need to be studied using high spatial resolution observations to securely determine black hole masses, as there could be systematic differences in the black hole scaling relations between these types of galaxies and the BCGs/giant ellipticals, thereby implying different pathways for black hole and galaxy growth. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2015; originally announced June 2015.

Comments: accepted for publication in ApJ

The Black Hole Mass and the Stellar Ring in NGC 3706

Authors: Kayhan Gültekin, Karl Gebhardt, John Kormendy, Tod R. Lauer, Ralf Bender, Scott Tremaine, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We determine the mass of the nuclear black hole ($M$) in NGC 3706, an early type galaxy with a central surface brightness minimum arising from an apparent stellar ring, which is misaligned with respect to the galaxy's major axis at larger radii. We fit new HST/STIS and archival data with axisymmetric orbit models to determine $M$, mass-to-light ratio ($Υ_V$), and dark matter halo profile. The best… ▽ More We determine the mass of the nuclear black hole ($M$) in NGC 3706, an early type galaxy with a central surface brightness minimum arising from an apparent stellar ring, which is misaligned with respect to the galaxy's major axis at larger radii. We fit new HST/STIS and archival data with axisymmetric orbit models to determine $M$, mass-to-light ratio ($Υ_V$), and dark matter halo profile. The best-fit model parameters with 1$σ$ uncertainties are $M = (6.0^{+0.7}_{-0.9}) \times 10^8\ M_{\scriptscriptstyle \odot}$ and $Υ_V = 6.0 \pm 0.2\ M_{\scriptscriptstyle \odot}\ L_{{\scriptscriptstyle \odot},V}^{-1}$ at an assumed distance of 46 Mpc. The models are inconsistent with no black hole at a significance of $Δχ^2 = 15.4$ and require a dark matter halo to adequately fit the kinematic data, but the fits are consistent with a large range of plausible dark matter halo parameters. The ring is inconsistent with a population of co-rotating stars on circular orbits, which would produce a narrow line-of-sight velocity distribution (LOSVD). Instead, the ring's LOSVD has a small value of $|V|/σ$, the ratio of mean velocity to velocity dispersion. Based on the observed low $|V|/σ$, our orbit modeling, and a kinematic decomposition of the ring from the bulge, we conclude that the stellar ring contains stars that orbit in both directions. We consider potential origins for this unique feature, including multiple tidal disruptions of stellar clusters, a change in the gravitational potential from triaxial to axisymmetric, resonant capture and inclining of orbits by a binary black hole, and multiple mergers leading to gas being funneled to the center of the galaxy. △ Less

Submitted 17 December, 2013; originally announced December 2013.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ, 14 pages, 9 figures, 1 Table

The Gravitational Universe

Authors: The eLISA Consortium, :, P. Amaro Seoane, S. Aoudia, H. Audley, G. Auger, S. Babak, J. Baker, E. Barausse, S. Barke, M. Bassan, V. Beckmann, M. Benacquista, P. L. Bender, E. Berti, P. Binétruy, J. Bogenstahl, C. Bonvin, D. Bortoluzzi, N. C. Brause, J. Brossard, S. Buchman, I. Bykov, J. Camp, C. Caprini , et al. (136 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The last century has seen enormous progress in our understanding of the Universe. We know the life cycles of stars, the structure of galaxies, the remnants of the big bang, and have a general understanding of how the Universe evolved. We have come remarkably far using electromagnetic radiation as our tool for observing the Universe. However, gravity is the engine behind many of the processes in th… ▽ More The last century has seen enormous progress in our understanding of the Universe. We know the life cycles of stars, the structure of galaxies, the remnants of the big bang, and have a general understanding of how the Universe evolved. We have come remarkably far using electromagnetic radiation as our tool for observing the Universe. However, gravity is the engine behind many of the processes in the Universe, and much of its action is dark. Opening a gravitational window on the Universe will let us go further than any alternative. Gravity has its own messenger: Gravitational waves, ripples in the fabric of spacetime. They travel essentially undisturbed and let us peer deep into the formation of the first seed black holes, exploring redshifts as large as z ~ 20, prior to the epoch of cosmic re-ionisation. Exquisite and unprecedented measurements of black hole masses and spins will make it possible to trace the history of black holes across all stages of galaxy evolution, and at the same time constrain any deviation from the Kerr metric of General Relativity. eLISA will be the first ever mission to study the entire Universe with gravitational waves. eLISA is an all-sky monitor and will offer a wide view of a dynamic cosmos using gravitational waves as new and unique messengers to unveil The Gravitational Universe. It provides the closest ever view of the early processes at TeV energies, has guaranteed sources in the form of verification binaries in the Milky Way, and can probe the entire Universe, from its smallest scales around singularities and black holes, all the way to cosmological dimensions. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2013; originally announced May 2013.

Comments: 20 pages; submitted to the European Space Agency on May 24th, 2013 for the L2/L3 selection of ESA's Cosmic Vision program

Dynamical Measurements of Black Hole Masses in Four Brightest Cluster Galaxies at 100 Mpc

Authors: Nicholas J. McConnell, Chung-Pei Ma, Jeremy D. Murphy, Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, James R. Graham, Shelley A. Wright, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We present stellar kinematics and orbit superposition models for the central regions of four Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs), based upon integral-field spectroscopy at Gemini, Keck, and McDonald Observatories. Our integral-field data span radii from < 100 pc to tens of kpc. We report black hole masses, M_BH, of 2.1 +/- 1.6 x 10^10 M_Sun for NGC 4889, 9.7 + 3.0 - 2.6 x 10^9 M_Sun for NGC 3842, an… ▽ More We present stellar kinematics and orbit superposition models for the central regions of four Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs), based upon integral-field spectroscopy at Gemini, Keck, and McDonald Observatories. Our integral-field data span radii from < 100 pc to tens of kpc. We report black hole masses, M_BH, of 2.1 +/- 1.6 x 10^10 M_Sun for NGC 4889, 9.7 + 3.0 - 2.6 x 10^9 M_Sun for NGC 3842, and 1.3 + 0.5 - 0.4 x 10^9 M_Sun for NGC 7768. For NGC 2832 we report an upper limit of M_BH < 9 x 10^9 M_Sun. Stellar orbits near the center of each galaxy are tangentially biased, on comparable spatial scales to the galaxies' photometric cores. We find possible photometric and kinematic evidence for an eccentric torus of stars in NGC 4889, with a radius of nearly 1 kpc. We compare our measurements of M_BH to the predicted black hole masses from various fits to the relations between M_BH and stellar velocity dispersion, luminosity, or stellar mass. The black holes in NGC 4889 and NGC 3842 are significantly more massive than all dispersion-based predictions and most luminosity-based predictions. The black hole in NGC 7768 is consistent with a broader range of predictions. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2012; v1 submitted 7 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 24 pages, 18 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ

A Chandra Survey of Supermassive Black Holes with Dynamical Mass Measurements

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Edward M. Cackett, Jon M. Miller, Tiziana Di Matteo, Sera Markoff, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We present Chandra observations of 12 galaxies that contain supermassive black holes with dynamical mass measurements. Each galaxy was observed for 30 ksec and resulted in a total of 68 point source detections in the target galaxies including supermassive black hole sources, ultraluminous X-ray sources, and extragalactic X-ray binaries. Based on our fits of the X-ray spectra, we report fluxes, lum… ▽ More We present Chandra observations of 12 galaxies that contain supermassive black holes with dynamical mass measurements. Each galaxy was observed for 30 ksec and resulted in a total of 68 point source detections in the target galaxies including supermassive black hole sources, ultraluminous X-ray sources, and extragalactic X-ray binaries. Based on our fits of the X-ray spectra, we report fluxes, luminosities, Eddington ratios, and slope of the power-law spectrum. Normalized to the Eddington luminosity, the 2--10 keV band X-ray luminosities of the SMBH sources range from $10^{-8}$ to $10^{-6}$, and the power-law slopes are centered at $\sim2$ with a slight trend towards steeper (softer) slopes at smaller Eddington fractions, implying a change in the physical processes responsible for their emission at low accretion rates. We find 20 ULX candidates, of which six are likely ($>90%$ chance) to be true ULXs. The most promising ULX candidate has an isotropic luminosity in the 0.3--10 keV band of $1.0_{-0.3}^{+0.6} \times 10^{40}$ erg/s. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2012; originally announced February 2012.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ. 16 pages, 8 figures, 5 tables

Two ten-billion-solar-mass black holes at the centres of giant elliptical galaxies

Authors: Nicholas J. McConnell, Chung-Pei Ma, Karl Gebhardt, Shelley A. Wright, Jeremy D. Murphy, Tod R. Lauer, James R. Graham, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Observational work conducted over the last few decades indicates that all massive galaxies have supermassive black holes at their centres. Although the luminosities and brightness fluctuations of quasars in the early Universe suggest that some are powered by black holes with masses greater than 10 billion solar masses, the remnants of these objects have not been found in the nearby Universe. The g… ▽ More Observational work conducted over the last few decades indicates that all massive galaxies have supermassive black holes at their centres. Although the luminosities and brightness fluctuations of quasars in the early Universe suggest that some are powered by black holes with masses greater than 10 billion solar masses, the remnants of these objects have not been found in the nearby Universe. The giant elliptical galaxy Messier 87 hosts the hitherto most massive known black hole, which has a mass of 6.3 billion solar masses. Here we report that NGC 3842, the brightest galaxy in a cluster at a distance from Earth of 98 megaparsecs, has a central black hole with a mass of 9.7 billion solar masses, and that a black hole of comparable or greater mass is present in NGC 4889, the brightest galaxy in the Coma cluster (at a distance of 103 megaparsecs). These two black holes are significantly more massive than predicted by linearly extrapolating the widely-used correlations between black hole mass and the stellar velocity dispersion or bulge luminosity of the host galaxy. Although these correlations remain useful for predicting black hole masses in less massive elliptical galaxies, our measurements suggest that different evolutionary processes influence the growth of the largest galaxies and their black holes. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: To be published in the December 8 edition of Nature. Body: 4 pg, 3 figures. Supplement: 8 pg, 7 figures, 4 tables

Is there a black hole in NGC 4382?

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Douglas O. Richstone, Karl Gebhardt, S. M. Faber, Tod R. Lauer, Ralf Bender, John Kormendy, Jason Pinkney

Abstract: We present HST STIS observations of the galaxy NGC 4382 (M85) and axisymmetric models of the galaxy to determine mass-to-light ration (M/L, V-band) and central black hole mass (M_BH). We find M/L = 3.74 +/- 0.1 (solar units) and M_BH = 1.3 (+5.2, -1.2) \times 10^7 M_sun at an assumed distance of 17.9 Mpc, consistent with no black hole. The upper limit, M_BH < 9.6 \times 10^7 M_sun (2σ) or M_BH < 1… ▽ More We present HST STIS observations of the galaxy NGC 4382 (M85) and axisymmetric models of the galaxy to determine mass-to-light ration (M/L, V-band) and central black hole mass (M_BH). We find M/L = 3.74 +/- 0.1 (solar units) and M_BH = 1.3 (+5.2, -1.2) \times 10^7 M_sun at an assumed distance of 17.9 Mpc, consistent with no black hole. The upper limit, M_BH < 9.6 \times 10^7 M_sun (2σ) or M_BH < 1.4 \times 10^8 M_sun (3σ) is consistent with the current M-σ relation, which predicts M_BH = 8.8 \times 10^7 M_sun at σ_e = 182 km/s, but low for the current M-L relation, which predicts M_BH = 7.8 \times 10^8 M_sun at L_V = 8.9 \times 10^10 L_sun,V. HST images show the nucleus to be double, suggesting the presence of a nuclear eccentric stellar disk, in analogy to the Tremaine disk in M31. This conclusion is supported by the HST velocity dispersion profile. Despite the presence of this non-axisymmetric feature and evidence of a recent merger, we conclude that the reliability of our black hole mass determination is not hindered. The inferred low black hole mass may explain the lack of nuclear activity. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2011; originally announced August 2011.

Comments: 10 pages, 8 figures, accepted by ApJ

Orbit-Based Dynamical Models of the Sombrero Galaxy (NGC 4594)

Authors: John R. Jardel, Karl Gebhardt, Juntai Shen, David Fisher, John Kormendy, Jeffry Kinzler, Tod R. Lauer, Douglas Richstone, Kayhan Gültekin

Abstract: We present axisymmetric, orbit-based models to study the central black hole, stellar mass-to-light ratio, and dark matter halo of NGC 4594 (M104, the Sombrero Galaxy). For stellar kinematics, we use published high-resolution kinematics of the central region taken with the Hubble Space Telescope, newly obtained Gemini long-slit spectra of the major axis, and integral field kinematics from the SAURO… ▽ More We present axisymmetric, orbit-based models to study the central black hole, stellar mass-to-light ratio, and dark matter halo of NGC 4594 (M104, the Sombrero Galaxy). For stellar kinematics, we use published high-resolution kinematics of the central region taken with the Hubble Space Telescope, newly obtained Gemini long-slit spectra of the major axis, and integral field kinematics from the SAURON instrument. At large radii, we use globular cluster kinematics to trace the mass profile and apply extra leverage to recovering the dark matter halo parameters. We find a black hole of mass M_{\bullet}=(6.6 +/- 0.4) x 10^8 M_{\odot}, and determine the stellar M/L_I=3.4 +/- 0.05 (uncertainties are the 68% confidence band marginalized over the other parameters). Our best fit dark matter halo is a cored logarithmic model with asymptotic circular speed V_c=376 +/- 12 km/s and core radius r_c= 4.7 +/- 0.6 kpc. The fraction of dark to total mass contained within the half-light radius is 0.52. Taking the bulge and disk components into account in our calculation of σ_e puts NGC 4594 squarely on the M-σrelation. We also determine that NGC 4594 lies directly on the M-L relation. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 13 pages, 10 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

Observational selection effects and the M-sigma relation

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Scott Tremaine, Abraham Loeb, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We examine the possibility that the observed relation between black-hole mass and host-galaxy stellar velocity dispersion (the M-sigma relation) is biased by an observational selection effect, the difficulty of detecting a black hole whose sphere of influence is smaller than the telescope resolution. In particular, we critically investigate recent claims that the M-sigma relation only represents t… ▽ More We examine the possibility that the observed relation between black-hole mass and host-galaxy stellar velocity dispersion (the M-sigma relation) is biased by an observational selection effect, the difficulty of detecting a black hole whose sphere of influence is smaller than the telescope resolution. In particular, we critically investigate recent claims that the M-sigma relation only represents the upper limit to a broad distribution of black-hole masses in galaxies of a given velocity dispersion. We find that this hypothesis can be rejected at a high confidence level, at least for the early-type galaxies with relatively high velocity dispersions (median 268 km/s) that comprise most of our sample. We also describe a general procedure for incorporating observational selection effects in estimates of the properties of the M-sigma relation. Applying this procedure we find results that are consistent with earlier estimates that did not account for selection effects, although with larger error bars. In particular, (i) the width of the M-sigma relation is not significantly increased; (ii) the slope and normalization of the M-sigma relation are not significantly changed; (iii) most or all luminous early-type galaxies contain central black holes at zero redshift. Our results may not apply to late-type or small galaxies, which are not well-represented in our sample. △ Less

Submitted 6 June, 2011; originally announced June 2011.

Comments: 8 pages, ApJ accepted

The Black-Hole Mass in M87 from Gemini/NIFS Adaptive Optics Observations

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Joshua Adams, Douglas Richstone, Tod R. Lauer, S. M. Faber, Kayhan Gultekin, Jeremy Murphy, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We present the stellar kinematics in the central 2" of the luminous elliptical galaxy M87 (NGC 4486), using laser adaptive optics to feed the Gemini telescope integral-field spectrograph, NIFS. The velocity dispersion rises to 480 km/s at 0.2". We combine these data with extensive stellar kinematics out to large radii to derive a black-hole mass equal to (6.6+-0.4)x10^9 Msun, using orbit-based axi… ▽ More We present the stellar kinematics in the central 2" of the luminous elliptical galaxy M87 (NGC 4486), using laser adaptive optics to feed the Gemini telescope integral-field spectrograph, NIFS. The velocity dispersion rises to 480 km/s at 0.2". We combine these data with extensive stellar kinematics out to large radii to derive a black-hole mass equal to (6.6+-0.4)x10^9 Msun, using orbit-based axisymmetric models and including only the NIFS data in the central region. Including previously-reported ground-based data in the central region drops the uncertainty to 0.25x10^9 Msun with no change in the best-fit mass; however, we rely on the values derived from the NIFS-only data in the central region in order to limit systematic differences. The best-fit model shows a significant increase in the tangential velocity anisotropy of stars orbiting in the central region with decreasing radius; similar to that seen in the centers of other core galaxies. The black-hole mass is insensitive to the inclusion of a dark halo in the models --- the high angular-resolution provided by the adaptive optics breaks the degeneracy between black-hole mass and stellar mass-to-light ratio. The present black-hole mass is in excellent agreement with the Gebhardt & Thomas value, implying that the dark halo must be included when the kinematic influence of the black hole is poorly resolved. This degeneracy implies that the black-hole masses of luminous core galaxies, where this effect is important, may need to be re-evaluated. The present value exceeds the prediction of the black hole-dispersion and black hole-luminosity relations, both of which predict about 1x10^9 Msun for M87, by close to twice the intrinsic scatter in the relations. The high-end of the black hole correlations may be poorly determined at present. △ Less

Submitted 10 January, 2011; originally announced January 2011.

Comments: 12 pages, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal

The Black Hole Mass in Brightest Cluster Galaxy NGC 6086

Authors: Nicholas J. McConnell, Chung-Pei Ma, James R. Graham, Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, Shelley A. Wright, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We present the first direct measurement of the central black hole mass, M_BH, in NGC 6086, the Brightest Cluster Galaxy (BCG) in Abell 2162. Our investigation demonstrates for the first time that stellar dynamical measurements of M_BH in BCGs are possible beyond the nearest few galaxy clusters. We observed NGC 6086 with laser guide star adaptive optics and the integral-field spectrograph (IFS) OSI… ▽ More We present the first direct measurement of the central black hole mass, M_BH, in NGC 6086, the Brightest Cluster Galaxy (BCG) in Abell 2162. Our investigation demonstrates for the first time that stellar dynamical measurements of M_BH in BCGs are possible beyond the nearest few galaxy clusters. We observed NGC 6086 with laser guide star adaptive optics and the integral-field spectrograph (IFS) OSIRIS at the W.M. Keck Observatory, and with the seeing-limited IFS GMOS-N at Gemini Observatory North. We combined the two IFS data sets with existing major-axis kinematics, and used axisymmetric stellar orbit models to determine M_BH and the R-band stellar mass-to-light ratio, M*/L_R. We find M_BH = 3.6(+1.7)(-1.1) x 10^9 M_Sun and M*/L_R = 4.6(+0.3)(-0.7) M_Sun/L_Sun (68% confidence), from models using the most massive dark matter halo allowed within the gravitational potential of the host cluster. Models fitting only IFS data confirm M_BH ~ 3 x 10^9 M_Sun and M*/L_R ~ 4 M_Sun/L_Sun, with weak dependence on the dark matter halo structure. When data out to 19 kpc are included, the unrealistic omission of dark matter causes the best-fit black hole mass to decrease dramatically, to 0.6 x 10^9 M_Sun, and the best-fit stellar mass-to-light ratio to increase to 6.7 M_Sun/L_Sun. The latter value is at further odds with stellar population studies favoring M*/L ~ 2 M_Sun/L_Sun,R. Biases from dark matter omission could extend to dynamical models of other galaxies with central stellar cores, and new measurements of M_BH from models with dark matter could steepen the empirical scaling relationships between black holes and their host galaxies. △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2010; v1 submitted 3 September, 2010; originally announced September 2010.

Comments: 22 pages, 19 figures; accepted for publication in ApJ

The Fundamental Plane of Accretion Onto Black Holes with Dynamical Masses

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Edward M. Cackett, Jon M. Miller, Tiziana Di Matteo, Sera Markoff, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Black hole accretion and jet production are areas of intensive study in astrophysics. Recent work has found a relation between radio luminosity, X-ray luminosity, and black hole mass. With the assumption that radio and X-ray luminosity are suitable proxies for jet power and accretion power, respectively, a broad fundamental connection between accretion and jet production is implied. In an effort… ▽ More Black hole accretion and jet production are areas of intensive study in astrophysics. Recent work has found a relation between radio luminosity, X-ray luminosity, and black hole mass. With the assumption that radio and X-ray luminosity are suitable proxies for jet power and accretion power, respectively, a broad fundamental connection between accretion and jet production is implied. In an effort to refine these links and enhance their power, we have explored the above relations exclusively among black holes with direct, dynamical mass-measurements. This approach not only eliminates systematic errors incurred through the use of secondary mass measurements, but also effectively restricts the range of distances considered to a volume-limited sample. Further, we have exclusively used archival data from the Chandra X-ray Observatory to best isolate nuclear sources. We find log(L_R) = (4.80 +/- 0.24) + (0.78 +/- 0.27) log(M_BH) + (0.67 +/- 0.12) log(L_X), in broad agreement with prior efforts. Owing to the nature of our sample, the plane can be turned into an effective mass predictor. When the full sample is considered, masses are predicted less accurately than with the well-known M-sigma relation. If obscured AGN are excluded, the plane is potentially a better predictor than other scaling measures. △ Less

Submitted 9 October, 2009; v1 submitted 17 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: Accepted by ApJ. 13 pages, 6 figures, updated to include changes to match accepted version

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.706:404-416,2009

The M-sigma and M-L Relations in Galactic Bulges and Determinations of their Intrinsic Scatter

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Douglas O. Richstone, Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, Scott Tremaine, M. C. Aller, Ralf Bender, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Christos Siopis

Abstract: We derive improved versions of the relations between supermassive black hole mass (M_BH) and host-galaxy bulge velocity dispersion (sigma) and luminosity (L) (the M-sigma and M-L relations), based on 49 M_BH measurements and 19 upper limits. Particular attention is paid to recovery of the intrinsic scatter (epsilon_0) in both relations. We find log(M_BH / M_sun) = alpha + beta * log(sigma / 200… ▽ More We derive improved versions of the relations between supermassive black hole mass (M_BH) and host-galaxy bulge velocity dispersion (sigma) and luminosity (L) (the M-sigma and M-L relations), based on 49 M_BH measurements and 19 upper limits. Particular attention is paid to recovery of the intrinsic scatter (epsilon_0) in both relations. We find log(M_BH / M_sun) = alpha + beta * log(sigma / 200 km/s) with (alpha, beta, epsilon_0) = (8.12 +/- 0.08, 4.24 +/- 0.41, 0.44 +/- 0.06) for all galaxies and (alpha, beta, epsilon_0) = (8.23 +/- 0.08, 3.96 +/- 0.42, 0.31 +/- 0.06) for ellipticals. The results for ellipticals are consistent with previous studies, but the intrinsic scatter recovered for spirals is significantly larger. The scatter inferred reinforces the need for its consideration when calculating local black hole mass function based on the M-sigma relation, and further implies that there may be substantial selection bias in studies of the evolution of the M-sigma relation. We estimate the M-L relationship as log(M_BH / M_sun) = alpha + beta * log(L_V / 10^11 L_sun,V) of (alpha, beta, epsilon_0) = (8.95 +/- 0.11, 1.11 +/- 0.18, 0.38 +/- 0.09); using only early-type galaxies. These results appear to be insensitive to a wide range of assumptions about the measurement errors and the distribution of intrinsic scatter. We show that culling the sample according to the resolution of the black hole's sphere of influence biases the relations to larger mean masses, larger slopes, and incorrect intrinsic residuals. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: 27 pages, 18 figures, 7 tables, ApJ accepted

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.698:198-221,2009

Probing Stellar Dynamics in Galactic Nuclei

Authors: M. Coleman Miller, Tal Alexander, Pau Amaro-Seoane, Aaron J. Barth, Curt Cutler, Jonathan R. Gair, Clovis Hopman, David Merritt, E. Sterl Phinney, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Electromagnetic observations over the last 15 years have yielded a growing appreciation for the importance of supermassive black holes (SMBH) to the evolution of galaxies, and for the intricacies of dynamical interactions in our own Galactic center. Here we show that future low-frequency gravitational wave observations, alone or in combination with electromagnetic data, will open up unique windo… ▽ More Electromagnetic observations over the last 15 years have yielded a growing appreciation for the importance of supermassive black holes (SMBH) to the evolution of galaxies, and for the intricacies of dynamical interactions in our own Galactic center. Here we show that future low-frequency gravitational wave observations, alone or in combination with electromagnetic data, will open up unique windows to these processes. In particular, gravitational wave detections in the 10^{-5}-10^{-1} Hz range will yield SMBH masses and spins to unprecedented precision and will provide clues to the properties of the otherwise undetectable stellar remnants expected to populate the centers of galaxies. Such observations are therefore keys to understanding the interplay between SMBHs and their environments. △ Less

Submitted 2 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: 8 pages, Science white paper for the Astro2010 Decadal Survey

Massive Black Holes Across Cosmic Time

Authors: P. Madau, T. Abel, P. Bender, T. Di Matteo, Z. Haiman, S. Hughes, A. Loeb, E. Phinney, J. Primack, T. Prince, M. Rees, D. Richstone, B. Schutz, K. Thorne, M. Volonteri

Abstract: This White Paper to the National Academy of Sciences Astro2010 Decadal Review Committee outlines some of the outstanding questions regarding the assembly history of Massive Black Holes in the nuclei of galaxies and the revolutionary contributions anticipated in this field from low-frequency gravitational wave astronomy. This White Paper to the National Academy of Sciences Astro2010 Decadal Review Committee outlines some of the outstanding questions regarding the assembly history of Massive Black Holes in the nuclei of galaxies and the revolutionary contributions anticipated in this field from low-frequency gravitational wave astronomy. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: Science White Paper submitted to the Astro2010 Decadal Survey

A Quintet of Black Hole Mass Determinations

Authors: Kayhan Gultekin, Douglas O. Richstone, Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, Jason Pinkney, M. C. Aller, Ralf Bender, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, Christos Siopis

Abstract: We report five new measurements of central black hole masses based on STIS and WFPC2 observations with the Hubble Space Telescope and on axisymmetric, three-integral, Schwarzschild orbit-library kinematic models. We selected a sample of galaxies within a narrow range in velocity dispersion that cover a range of galaxy parameters (including Hubble type and core/power-law surface density profile)… ▽ More We report five new measurements of central black hole masses based on STIS and WFPC2 observations with the Hubble Space Telescope and on axisymmetric, three-integral, Schwarzschild orbit-library kinematic models. We selected a sample of galaxies within a narrow range in velocity dispersion that cover a range of galaxy parameters (including Hubble type and core/power-law surface density profile) where we expected to be able to resolve the galaxy's sphere of influence based on the predicted value of the black hole mass from the M-sigma relation. We find masses in units of 10^8 solar masses for the following galaxies: NGC 3585, M_BH = 3.4 (+1.5, -0.6); NGC 3607, M_BH = 1.2 (+0.4, -0.4); NGC 4026, M_BH = 2.1 (+0.7, -0.4); and NGC 5576, M_BH = 1.8 (+0.3, -0.4), all significantly excluding M_BH = 0. For NGC 3945, M_BH = 0.09 (+0.17, -0.21), which is significantly below predictions from M-sigma and M-L relations and consistent with M_BH = 0, though the presence of a double bar in this galaxy may present problems for our axisymmetric code. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2009; v1 submitted 27 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Comments: 15 pages, 21 figures, 13 tables. Accepted by ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.695:1577-1590,2009

A Stellar Dynamical Measurement of the Black Hole Mass in the Maser Galaxy NGC 4258

Authors: Christos Siopis, Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, John Kormendy, Jason Pinkney, Douglas Richstone, S. M. Faber, Scott Tremaine, M. C. Aller, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Magorrian

Abstract: We determine the mass of the black hole at the center of the spiral galaxy NGC 4258 by constructing axisymmetric dynamical models of the galaxy. These models are constrained by high spatial resolution imaging and long-slit spectroscopy of the nuclear region obtained with the {\em Hubble Space Telescope}, complemented by ground-based observations extending to larger radii. Our best mass estimate… ▽ More We determine the mass of the black hole at the center of the spiral galaxy NGC 4258 by constructing axisymmetric dynamical models of the galaxy. These models are constrained by high spatial resolution imaging and long-slit spectroscopy of the nuclear region obtained with the {\em Hubble Space Telescope}, complemented by ground-based observations extending to larger radii. Our best mass estimate is $\MBH = (3.3 \pm 0.2) \times 10^7 \MSun $ for a distance of 7.28 Mpc (statistical errors only). This is within 15% of $ (3.82\pm 0.01) \times 10^7 \MSun$, the mass determined from the kinematics of water masers (rescaled to the same distance) assuming they are in Keplerian rotation in a warped disk. The construction of accurate dynamical models of NGC 4258 is somewhat compromised by an unresolved active nucleus and color gradients, the latter caused by variations in the stellar population and/or obscuring dust. These problems are not present in the $\sim 30$ other black hole mass determinations from stellar dynamics that have been published by us and other groups; thus, the relatively close agreement between the stellar dynamical mass and the maser mass in NGC 4258 enhances our confidence in the black hole masses determined in other galaxies from stellar dynamics using similar methods and data of comparable quality. △ Less

Submitted 28 August, 2008; originally announced August 2008.

Comments: 58 pages, submitted to ApJ. Some figures excluded due to size. The entire paper is at http://www.noao.edu/noao/staff/lauer/nuker_papers.html

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.693:946-969,2009

The Black Hole Mass and Extreme Orbital Structure in NGC1399

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, Jason Pinkney, Ralf Bender, Douglas Richstone, Monique Aller, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, Sandra Faber, Alexei Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis Ho, John Kormendy, Christos Siopis, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: The largest galaxies, and in particular central galaxies in clusters, offer unique insight into understanding the mechanism for the growth of nuclear black holes. We present Hubble Space Telescope kinematics for NGC1399, the central galaxy in Fornax. We find the best-fit model contains a black hole of 5.1 +-0.7 x 10^8 Msun (at a distance of 21.1 Mpc), a factor of over 2 below the correlation of… ▽ More The largest galaxies, and in particular central galaxies in clusters, offer unique insight into understanding the mechanism for the growth of nuclear black holes. We present Hubble Space Telescope kinematics for NGC1399, the central galaxy in Fornax. We find the best-fit model contains a black hole of 5.1 +-0.7 x 10^8 Msun (at a distance of 21.1 Mpc), a factor of over 2 below the correlation of black hole mass and velocity dispersion. We also find a dramatic signature for central tangential anisotropy. The velocity profiles on adjacent sides 0.5" away from the nucleus show strong bimodality, and the central spectrum shows a large drop in the dispersion. Both of these observations point to an orbital distribution that is tangentially biased. The best-fit orbital model suggests a ratio of the tangential to radial internal velocity dispersions of three. This ratio is the largest seen in any galaxy to date and will provide an important measure for the mode by which the central black hole has grown. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2007; originally announced September 2007.

Comments: 9 pages, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal

Selection Bias in Observing the Cosmological Evolution of the Mbh-sigma and Mbh-L Relationships

Authors: Tod R. Lauer, Scott Tremaine, Douglas Richstone, S. M. Faber

Abstract: Programs to observe evolution in the Mbh-sigma or Mbh-L relations typically compare black-hole masses, Mbh, in high-redshift galaxies selected by nuclear activity to Mbh in local galaxies selected by luminosity L, or stellar velocity dispersion sigma. Because AGN luminosity is likely to depend on Mbh, selection effects are different for high-redshift and local samples, potentially producing a fa… ▽ More Programs to observe evolution in the Mbh-sigma or Mbh-L relations typically compare black-hole masses, Mbh, in high-redshift galaxies selected by nuclear activity to Mbh in local galaxies selected by luminosity L, or stellar velocity dispersion sigma. Because AGN luminosity is likely to depend on Mbh, selection effects are different for high-redshift and local samples, potentially producing a false signal of evolution. This bias arises because cosmic scatter in the Mbh-sigma and Mbh-L relations means that the mean log(L) or log(sigma) among galaxies that host a black hole of given Mbh, may be substantially different than the log(L) or log(sigma) obtained from inverting the Mbh-L or Mbh-sigma relations for the same nominal Mbh. The bias is particularly strong at high Mbh, where the luminosity and dispersion functions of galaxies are falling rapidly. The most massive black holes occur more often as rare outliers in galaxies of modest mass than in the even rarer high-mass galaxies, which would otherwise be the sole location of such black holes in the absence of cosmic scatter. Because of this bias, Mbh will typically appear to be too large in the distant sample for a given L or sigma. For the largest black holes and the largest plausible cosmic scatter, the bias can reach a factor of 3 in Mbh for the Mbh-sigma relation and a factor of 9 for the Mbh-L relation. Unfortunately, the actual cosmic scatter is not known well enough to correct for the bias. Measuring evolution of the Mbh and galaxy property relations requires object selection to be precisely defined and exactly the same at all redshifts. △ Less

Submitted 28 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 28 pages, 6 figures, submitted to the Astrophysical Journal

Host Galaxy Bulge Predictors of Supermassive Black Hole Mass

Authors: M. C. Aller, D. O. Richstone

Abstract: A variety of host galaxy (bulge) parameters are examined in order to determine their predictive power in ascertaining the masses of the supermassive black holes (SMBH) at the centers of the galaxies. Based on a sample of 23 nearby galaxies, comprised of both elliptical galaxies and spiral/lenticular bulges, we identify a strong correlation between the bulge gravitational binding energy ($E_g$),… ▽ More A variety of host galaxy (bulge) parameters are examined in order to determine their predictive power in ascertaining the masses of the supermassive black holes (SMBH) at the centers of the galaxies. Based on a sample of 23 nearby galaxies, comprised of both elliptical galaxies and spiral/lenticular bulges, we identify a strong correlation between the bulge gravitational binding energy ($E_g$), as traced by the stellar light profile, and the SMBH mass ($M_{\bullet}$), such that $M_{\bullet} \propto E_g^{0.6}$. The scatter about the relationship indicates that this is as strong a predictor of $M_{\bullet}$ as the velocity dispersion ($σ$), for the elliptical galaxy subsample. Improved mass-to-light ratios, obtained with IFU spectroscopy and I-band photometry by the SAURON group, were used for those sample galaxies where available, resulting in an energy predictor with the same slope, but with reduced scatter. Alternative $M_{\bullet}$ predictors such as the gravitational potential and the bulge mass are also explored, but these are found to be inferior when compared with both the bulge gravitational binding energy and bulge velocity dispersion predictors, for the full galaxy sample. △ Less

Submitted 8 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: accepted for publication in ApJ

NGC 5548 in a Low-Luminosity State: Implications for the Broad-Line Region

Authors: Misty C. Bentz, Kelly D. Denney, Edward M. Cackett, Matthias Dietrich, Jeffrey K. J. Fogel, Himel Ghosh, Keith D. Horne, Charles Kuehn, Takeo Minezaki, Christopher A. Onken, Bradley M. Peterson, Richard W. Pogge, Vladimir I. Pronik, Douglas O. Richstone, Sergey G. Sergeev, Marianne Vestergaard, Matthew G. Walker, Yuzuru Yoshii

Abstract: We describe results from a new ground-based monitoring campaign on NGC 5548, the best studied reverberation-mapped AGN. We find that it was in the lowest luminosity state yet recorded during a monitoring program, namely L(5100) = 4.7 x 10^42 ergs s^-1. We determine a rest-frame time lag between flux variations in the continuum and the Hbeta line of 6.3 (+2.6/-2.3) days. Combining our measurement… ▽ More We describe results from a new ground-based monitoring campaign on NGC 5548, the best studied reverberation-mapped AGN. We find that it was in the lowest luminosity state yet recorded during a monitoring program, namely L(5100) = 4.7 x 10^42 ergs s^-1. We determine a rest-frame time lag between flux variations in the continuum and the Hbeta line of 6.3 (+2.6/-2.3) days. Combining our measurements with those of previous campaigns, we determine a weighted black hole mass of M_BH = 6.54 (+0.26/-0.25) x 10^7 M_sun based on all broad emission lines with suitable variability data. We confirm the previously-discovered virial relationship between the time lag of emission lines relative to the continuum and the width of the emission lines in NGC 5548, which is the expected signature of a gravity-dominated broad-line region. Using this lowest luminosity state, we extend the range of the relationship between the luminosity and the time lag in NGC 5548 and measure a slope that is consistent with alpha = 0.5, the naive expectation for the broad line region for an assumed form of r ~ L^alpha. This value is also consistent with the slope recently determined by Bentz et al. for the population of reverberation-mapped AGNs as a whole. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2007; originally announced February 2007.

Comments: 24 pages, 3 tables, 7 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.662:205-212,2007

The Centers of Early-Type Galaxies with HST. VI. Bimodal Central Surface Brightness Profiles

Authors: Tod R. Lauer, Karl Gebhardt, S. M. Faber, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine, John Kormendy, M. C. Aller, Ralf Bender, Alan Dressler, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho

Abstract: We combine the results from several HST investigations of the central structure of early-type galaxies to generate a large sample of parameterized surface photometry. The studies included were those that used the "Nuker law" to characterize the inner light distributions of the galaxies. The sample comprises WFPC1 and WFPC2 V band observations published earlier by our group, R band WFPC2 photomet… ▽ More We combine the results from several HST investigations of the central structure of early-type galaxies to generate a large sample of parameterized surface photometry. The studies included were those that used the "Nuker law" to characterize the inner light distributions of the galaxies. The sample comprises WFPC1 and WFPC2 V band observations published earlier by our group, R band WFPC2 photometry of Rest et al., NICMOS H band photometry by Ravindranath et al. and Quillen et al., and the BCG WFPC2 I band photometry of Laine et al. The distribution of the logarithmic slopes of the central profiles strongly affirms that the central structure of elliptical galaxies with Mv < -19 is bimodal, based on both parametric and non-parametric analysis. At the HST resolution limit, most galaxies are either power-law systems, which have steep cusps in surface brightness, or core systems, which have shallow cusps interior to a steeper envelope brightness distribution. A rapid transition between the two forms occurs over the luminosity range -22 < Mv < -20, with cores dominating at the highest luminosities, and power-laws at the lowest. There are a few "intermediate" systems that have both cusp slopes and total luminosities that fall within the core/power-law transition, but they are rare and do not fill in the overall bimodal distribution of cusp slopes. These results are inconsistent with the Ferrarese et al. Virgo Cluster Survey (VCS) analysis. However, using galaxies common to the VCS samples, we demonstrate that the VCS models of the cusps are either a poor match to the observations or consist of forms fitted to the galaxy envelopes and extrapolated inward to the HST resolution limit. △ Less

Submitted 27 September, 2006; originally announced September 2006.

Comments: Submitted to the Astrophysical Journal; 60 pages and 20 postscript figures

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.664:226-256,2007

The Mass of the Black Hole in the Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4593 from Reverberation Mapping

Authors: Kelly D. Denney, Misty C. Bentz, Bradley M. Peterson, Richard W. Pogge, Edward M. Cackett, Matthias Dietrich, Jeffrey K. J. Fogel, Himel Ghosh, Keith Horne, Charles Kuehn, Takeo Minezaki, Christopher A. Onken, Vladimir I. Pronik, Douglas O. Richstone, Sergey G. Sergeev, Marianne Vestergaard, Matthew G. Walker, Yuzuru Yoshii

Abstract: We present new observations leading to an improved black hole mass estimate for the Seyfert 1 galaxy NGC 4593 as part of a reverberation-mapping campaign conducted at the MDM Observatory. Cross-correlation analysis of the H_beta emission-line light curve with the optical continuum light curve reveals an emission-line time delay of 3.73 (+-0.75) days. By combining this time delay with the H_beta… ▽ More We present new observations leading to an improved black hole mass estimate for the Seyfert 1 galaxy NGC 4593 as part of a reverberation-mapping campaign conducted at the MDM Observatory. Cross-correlation analysis of the H_beta emission-line light curve with the optical continuum light curve reveals an emission-line time delay of 3.73 (+-0.75) days. By combining this time delay with the H_beta line width, we derive a central black hole mass of M_BH = 9.8(+-2.1)x10^6 M_sun, an improvement in precision of a factor of several over past results. △ Less

Submitted 18 August, 2006; originally announced August 2006.

Comments: 22 pages, 3 tables, 5 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.653:152-158,2006

A Reverberation-Based Mass for the Central Black Hole in NGC 4151

Authors: Misty C. Bentz, Kelly D. Denney, Edward M. Cackett, Matthias Dietrich, Jeffrey K. J. Fogel, Himel Ghosh, Keith Horne, Charles Kuehn, Takeo Minezaki, Christopher A. Onken, Bradley M. Peterson, Richard W. Pogge, Vladimir I. Pronik, Douglas O. Richstone, Sergey G. Sergeev, Marianne Vestergaard, Matthew G. Walker, Yuzuru Yoshii

Abstract: We have undertaken a new ground-based monitoring campaign to improve the estimates of the mass of the central black hole in NGC 4151. We measure the lag time of the broad H beta line response compared to the optical continuum at 5100 A and find a lag of 6.6 (+1.1/-0.8) days. We combine our data with the recent reanalysis of UV emission lines by Metzroth et al. to calculate a weighted mean of the… ▽ More We have undertaken a new ground-based monitoring campaign to improve the estimates of the mass of the central black hole in NGC 4151. We measure the lag time of the broad H beta line response compared to the optical continuum at 5100 A and find a lag of 6.6 (+1.1/-0.8) days. We combine our data with the recent reanalysis of UV emission lines by Metzroth et al. to calculate a weighted mean of the black hole mass, M_BH = 4.57 (+0.57/-0.47) x 10^7 M_sun. The absolute calibration of the black hole mass is based on normalization of the AGN black hole mass - stellar velocity dispersion (M_BH - sigma_*) relationship to that of quiescent galaxies by Onken et al. The scatter in the M_BH - sigma_* relationship suggests that reverberation-mapping based mass measurements are typically uncertain by a factor of 3-4. △ Less

Submitted 5 July, 2006; originally announced July 2006.

Comments: 17 pages, 3 tables, 3 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.651:775-781,2006

The Masses of Nuclear Black Holes in Luminous Elliptical Galaxies and Implications for the Space Density of the Most Massive Black Holes

Authors: Tod R. Lauer, S. M. Faber, Douglas Richstone, Karl Gebhardt, Scott Tremaine, Marc Postman, Alan Dressler, M. C. Aller, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney

Abstract: Black hole masses predicted from the Mbh-sigma relationship conflict with those predicted from the Mbh-L relationship for the most luminous galaxies, such as brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs). This is because stellar velocity dispersion, sigma, increases only weakly with L for BCGs and other giant ellipticals. The Mbh-L relationship predicts that the most luminous BCGs may have Mbh approaching 1… ▽ More Black hole masses predicted from the Mbh-sigma relationship conflict with those predicted from the Mbh-L relationship for the most luminous galaxies, such as brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs). This is because stellar velocity dispersion, sigma, increases only weakly with L for BCGs and other giant ellipticals. The Mbh-L relationship predicts that the most luminous BCGs may have Mbh approaching 10^{10}M_sol, while the M-sigma relationship always predicts Mbh<3X10^9M_sol. We argue that the Mbh-L relationship is a plausible or even preferred description for BCGs and other galaxies of similar luminosity. If cores in central stellar density are formed by binary BHs, then the inner-core cusp radius, r_gamma, may be an independent witness of Mbh. Using structural parameters derived from a large sample of early-type galaxies observed by HST, we argue that L is superior to sigma as an indicator of r_gamma in luminous galaxies. The observed r_gamma-Mbh relationship for 11 core galaxies with measured Mbh appears to be consistent with the Mbh-L relationship for BCGs. BCGs have large cores appropriate for their large luminosities that may be difficult to generate with the modest BH masses inferred from the Mbh-sigma relationship. Mbh~L may be expected to hold for BCGs, if they were formed in dissipationless mergers, which should preserve ratio of BH to stellar mass. This picture appears to be consistent with the slow increase in sigma with L and the more rapid increase in effective radii with L seen in BCGs. If BCGs have large BHs commensurate with their luminosities, then the local BH mass function for Mbh>3X10^9M_sol may be nearly an order of magnitude richer than that inferred from the Mbh-sigma relationship. The volume density of QSOs at earlier epochs may favor the predictions from the Mbh-L relationship. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2007; v1 submitted 29 June, 2006; originally announced June 2006.

Comments: 62 pages, 18 figures, submitted to the Astrophysical Journal; revised after initial review

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.662:808-834,2007

HST STIS spectroscopy of the triple nucleus of M31: two nested disks in Keplerian rotation around a Supermassive Black Hole

Authors: Ralf Bender, John Kormendy, Gary Bower, Richard Green, Jens Thomas, Anthony C. Danks, Theodore Gull, J. B. Hutchings, C. L. Joseph, M. E. Kaiser, Tod R. Lauer, Charles H. Nelson, Douglas Richstone, Donna Weistrop, Bruce Woodgate

Abstract: We present HST spectroscopy of the nucleus of M31 obtained with STIS. Spectra taken around the CaT lines at 8500 see only the red giants in the double bright- ness peaks P1 and P2. In contrast, spectra taken at 3600-5100 A are sensitive to the tiny blue nucleus embedded in P2, the lower surface brightness red nucleus. P2 has a K-type spectrum, but the embedded blue nucleus has an A-type spectrum… ▽ More We present HST spectroscopy of the nucleus of M31 obtained with STIS. Spectra taken around the CaT lines at 8500 see only the red giants in the double bright- ness peaks P1 and P2. In contrast, spectra taken at 3600-5100 A are sensitive to the tiny blue nucleus embedded in P2, the lower surface brightness red nucleus. P2 has a K-type spectrum, but the embedded blue nucleus has an A-type spectrum with strong Balmer absorption lines. Given the small likelihood for stellar collisions, a 200 Myr old starburst appears to be the most plausible origin of the blue nucleus. In stellar population, size, and velocity dispersion, the blue nucleus is so different from P1 and P2 that we call it P3. The line-of-sight velocity distributions of the red stars in P1+P2 strengthen the support for Tremaine s eccentric disk model. The kinematics of P3 is consistent with a circular stellar disk in Keplerian rotation around a super-massive black hole with M_bh = 1.4 x 10^8 M_sun. The P3 and the P1+P2 disks rotate in the same sense and are almost coplanar. The observed velocity dispersion of P3 is due to blurred rotation and has a maximum value of sigma = 1183+-201 km/s. The observed peak rotation velocity of P3 is V = 618+-81 km/s at radius 0.05" = 0.19 pc corresponding to a circular rotation velocity at this radius of ~1700 km/s. Any dark star cluster alternative to a black hole must have a half-mass radius <= 0.03" = 0.11 pc. We show that this excludes clusters of brown dwarfs or dead stars on astrophysical grounds. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2005; originally announced September 2005.

Comments: Astrophysical Journal, Sep 20, 2005, 21 pages including 20 figures

Gemini Near Infrared Spectrograph observations of the central supermassive black hole in Centaurus A

Authors: Julia D. Silge, Karl Gebhardt, Marcel Bergmann, Douglas Richstone

Abstract: The infrared spectrograph GNIRS on Gemini South unlocks new possibilities to study the central black holes in dusty galaxies that have been inaccessible to previous black hole studies. We exploit good near-infrared seeing to measure the central black hole (BH) of Centaurus A (NGC 5128). We measure the stellar kinematics of NGC 5128 using the region around the CO bandheads at 2.3 microns and dete… ▽ More The infrared spectrograph GNIRS on Gemini South unlocks new possibilities to study the central black holes in dusty galaxies that have been inaccessible to previous black hole studies. We exploit good near-infrared seeing to measure the central black hole (BH) of Centaurus A (NGC 5128). We measure the stellar kinematics of NGC 5128 using the region around the CO bandheads at 2.3 microns and determine the black hole mass using orbit-based models. Black holes are believed to be essential components of galaxies, and their evolutionary states appear to be closely linked to those of their hosts. Our current knowledge does not go much beyond this; galaxies such as NGC 5128 (an AGN and recent merger) can further develop this knowledge. However, NGC 5128 and galaxies like it contain large amounts of dust which hamper optical spectroscopy, making near-infrared measurements an attractive alternative. We find a BH mass of 2.4e8 solar masses for an edge-on model, 1.8e8 solar masses for a model with inclination of 45 degrees, and 1.5e8 solar masses for a model with inclination of 20 degrees. We adopt the value for the edge-on model, which has significantly lower chi^2. These estimates are consistent with a previous gas dynamical estimate and are five to ten times higher than that predicted by the correlation between BH mass and velocity dispersion. If NGC 5128 will eventually follow the trend for quiescent galaxies, this result suggests that its BH assembled first before its host component. NGC 5128 thus provides an important example for our knowledge of central black holes; this technique can be applied to other such galaxies to further explore this question. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2005; v1 submitted 20 January, 2005; originally announced January 2005.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures, to appear in August 2005 issue of AJ (130, 406)

The Centers of Early-Type Galaxies with HST. V. New WFPC2 Photometry

Authors: Tod R. Lauer, S. M. Faber, Karl Gebhardt, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine, Edward A. Ajhar, M. C. Aller, Ralf Bender, Alan Dressler, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl J. Grillmair, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Christos Siopis

Abstract: We analyze HST+WFPC2 images of 77 early-type galaxies. Brightness profiles are classed into "core" or "power-law" forms. Cores are typically rounder than power-law galaxies. Nearly all power-laws with central ellipticity >=0.3 have stellar disks, implying that disks are present in power-laws with epsilon <0.3, but are not visible due to unfavorable geometry. A few low-luminosity core galaxies al… ▽ More We analyze HST+WFPC2 images of 77 early-type galaxies. Brightness profiles are classed into "core" or "power-law" forms. Cores are typically rounder than power-law galaxies. Nearly all power-laws with central ellipticity >=0.3 have stellar disks, implying that disks are present in power-laws with epsilon <0.3, but are not visible due to unfavorable geometry. A few low-luminosity core galaxies also have disks; these may be transition forms from power-laws. Cores and power-laws both have twisting isophotes at small radii. Core galaxies have somewhat weaker color gradients than power-laws. Nuclei are found in 29% of the cores and 60% of the power-laws. Nuclei are typically bluer than the surrounding galaxy. NGC 4073 and 4382 have central minima in their intrinsic starlight distributions; NGC 4382 resembles the double nucleus of M31. In general, the peak brightness location is coincident with the photocenter of the core to <1 pc. Five galaxies, however, have centers significantly displaced from their cores; these may be unresolved asymmetric double nuclei. Central dust is visible in half of the galaxies. The presence and strength of dust correlates with nuclear emission. The prevalence of dust and its morphology suggests that dust clouds form, settle to the center, and disappear repeatedly on ~10^8 yr timescales. We discuss the hypothesis that cores are created by the decay of a massive black hole binary. Apart from their brightness profiles, there are no strong differences between cores and power-laws that demand this scenario; however, the rounder shapes of cores, their lack of disks, and their reduced color gradients may be consistent with it. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 2004; originally announced December 2004.

Comments: 76 pages, 40 figures, submitted to the Astronomical Journal. The complete postscript version of the paper is available at http://www.noao.edu/noao/staff/lauer/nuker.html (the Nuker Team page)

Mapping stationary axisymmetric phase-space distribution functions by orbit libraries

Authors: J. Thomas, R. P. Saglia, R. Bender, D. Thomas, K. Gebhardt, J. Magorrian, D. Richstone

Abstract: This is the first of a series of papers dedicated to unveil the mass composition and dynamical structure of a sample of flattened early type galaxies in the Coma cluster. We describe our modifications to the Schwarzschild code of Richstone et al. (in preparation). Applying a Voronoi tessellation in the surface of section we are able to assign accurate phase-space volumes to individual orbits and… ▽ More This is the first of a series of papers dedicated to unveil the mass composition and dynamical structure of a sample of flattened early type galaxies in the Coma cluster. We describe our modifications to the Schwarzschild code of Richstone et al. (in preparation). Applying a Voronoi tessellation in the surface of section we are able to assign accurate phase-space volumes to individual orbits and to reconstruct the full three-integral phase-space distribution function (DF) of any axisymmetric orbit library. Two types of tests have been performed to check the accuracy with which DFs can be represented by appropriate orbit libraries. First, by mapping DFs of spherical gamma-models and flattened Plummer models on to the library we show that the resulting line-of-sight velocity distributions and internal velocity moments of the library match those directly derived from the DF to a precision better than that of present day observational errors. Second, by fitting libraries to the projected kinematics of the same DFs we show that the distribution function reconstructed from the fitted library matches the input DF to a rms of about 15 per cent over a region in phase-space covering 90 per cent of the mass of the library. The achieved accuracy allows us to implement effective entropy-based regularisation to fit real, noisy and spatially incomplete data. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2004; originally announced June 2004.

Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

HE 0047-1756: A new gravitationally lensed double QSO

Authors: Lutz Wisotzki, Paul L. Schechter, Hsiao-Wen Chen, Douglas Richstone, Knud Jahnke, Sebastian F. Sanchez, Dieter Reimers

Abstract: The quasar HE 0047-1756, at z=1.67, is found to be split into two images 1.44" apart by an intervening galaxy acting as a gravitational lens. The flux ratio for the two components is roughly 3.5:1, depending slightly upon wavelength. The lensing galaxy is seen on images obtained at 800 nm and 2.1 μ; there is also a nearby faint object which may be responsible for some shear. The spectra of the t… ▽ More The quasar HE 0047-1756, at z=1.67, is found to be split into two images 1.44" apart by an intervening galaxy acting as a gravitational lens. The flux ratio for the two components is roughly 3.5:1, depending slightly upon wavelength. The lensing galaxy is seen on images obtained at 800 nm and 2.1 μ; there is also a nearby faint object which may be responsible for some shear. The spectra of the two quasar images are nearly identical, but the emission line ratio between the two components scale differently from the continuum. Moreover, the fainter component has a bluer continuum slope than the brighter one. We argue that these small differences are probably due to microlensing. There are hints of an Einstein ring emanating from the brighter image toward the fainter one. △ Less

Submitted 19 March, 2004; originally announced March 2004.

Comments: 4 pages, submitted to A&A Letters

Journal ref: Astron.Astrophys. 419 (2004) L31-L34

Black Hole Mass Determinations From Orbit Superposition Models are Reliable

Authors: Douglas Richstone, Karl Gebhardt, Monique Aller, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, Tod R. Lauer, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Christos Siopis, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We show that orbit-superposition dynamical models (Schwarzschild's method) provide reliable estimates of nuclear black hole masses and errors when constructed from adequate orbit libraries and kinematic data. We thus rebut two recent papers that argue that BH masses obtained from this method are unreliable. These papers claim to demonstrate that the range of allowable BH masses derived from a gi… ▽ More We show that orbit-superposition dynamical models (Schwarzschild's method) provide reliable estimates of nuclear black hole masses and errors when constructed from adequate orbit libraries and kinematic data. We thus rebut two recent papers that argue that BH masses obtained from this method are unreliable. These papers claim to demonstrate that the range of allowable BH masses derived from a given dataset is artificially too narrow as a result of an inadequate number of orbits in the library used to construct dynamical models. This is an elementary error that is easily avoided. We describe a method to estimate the number and nature of orbits needed for the library. We provide an example that shows that this prescription is adequate, in the sense that the range of allowable BH masses is not artificially narrowed by use of too few orbits. A second point raised by critics is that kinematic data are generally obtained with insufficient spatial resolution to obtain a reliable mass. We make the distinction between unreliable determinations and imprecise ones. We show that there are several different properties of a kinematic dataset that can lead to imprecise BH determinations, but none of the attributes we have investigated leads to an unreliable determination. In short, the degree to which the BH radius of influence is resolved by spectroscopic observations is already reflected in the BH-mass error envelope, and is not a hidden source of error. The BH masses published by our group and the Leiden group are reliable. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2004; originally announced March 2004.

Comments: submitted to the Astrophysical Journal Letters

Kinematics of Ten Early-Type Galaxies from HST and Ground-Based Spectroscopy

Authors: Jason Pinkney, Karl Gebhardt, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, Tod Lauer, John Magorrian, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We present stellar kinematics for a sample of 10 early-type galaxies observed using the STIS aboard the Hubble Space Telescope, and the Modular Spectrograph on the MDM Observatory 2.4-m telescope. The spectra are used to derive line-of-sight velocity distributions (LOSVDs) of the stars using a Maximum Penalized Likelihood method. We use Gauss-Hermite polynomials to parameterize the LOSVDs and fi… ▽ More We present stellar kinematics for a sample of 10 early-type galaxies observed using the STIS aboard the Hubble Space Telescope, and the Modular Spectrograph on the MDM Observatory 2.4-m telescope. The spectra are used to derive line-of-sight velocity distributions (LOSVDs) of the stars using a Maximum Penalized Likelihood method. We use Gauss-Hermite polynomials to parameterize the LOSVDs and find predominantly negative h4 values (boxy distributions) in the central regions of our galaxies. One galaxy, NGC 4697, has significantly positive central h4 (high tail weight). The majority of galaxies have a central velocity dispersion excess in the STIS kinematics over ground-based velocity dispersions. The galaxies with the strongest rotational support, as quantified with v_MAX/sigma_STIS, have the smallest dispersion excess at STIS resolution. The best-fitting, general, axisymmetric dynamical models (described in a companion paper) require black holes in all cases, with masses ranging from 10^6.5 to 10^9.3 Msun. We replot these updated masses on the BH/sigma relation, and show that the fit to only these 10 galaxies has a slope consistent with the fits to larger samples. The greatest outlier is NGC 2778, a dwarf elliptical with relatively poorly constrained black hole mass. The two best candidates for pseudobulges, NGC 3384 and 7457, do not deviate significantly from the established relation between black hole and sigma. Neither do the three galaxies which show the most evidence of a recent merger, NGC 3608, 4473, and 4697. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2003; originally announced June 2003.

Comments: 43 pages, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal, high resolution version found at http://hoku.as.utexas.edu/~gebhardt/pinkney.ps

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.596:903-929,2003

Formation of Supermassive Black Holes in Galactic Bulges: A Rotating Collapse Model Consistent with the $\mbh-σ$ Relation

Authors: Fred C. Adams, David S. Graff, Manasse Mbonye, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: Motivated by the observed correlation between black hole masses $\mbh$ and the velocity dispersion $σ$ of host galaxies, we develop a theoretical model of black hole formation in galactic bulges (this paper generalizes an earlier ApJ Letter). The model assumes an initial state specified by a a uniform rotation rate $Ω$ and a density distribution of the form $ρ= \aeff^2 / 2 πG r^2$ (so that… ▽ More Motivated by the observed correlation between black hole masses $\mbh$ and the velocity dispersion $σ$ of host galaxies, we develop a theoretical model of black hole formation in galactic bulges (this paper generalizes an earlier ApJ Letter). The model assumes an initial state specified by a a uniform rotation rate $Ω$ and a density distribution of the form $ρ= \aeff^2 / 2 πG r^2$ (so that $\aeff$ is an effective transport speed). The black hole mass is determined when the centrifugal radius of the collapse flow exceeds the capture radius of the central black hole (for Schwarzschild geometry). This model reproduces the observed correlation between the estimated black hole masses and the velocity dispersions of galactic bulges, i.e., $\mbh \approx 10^8 M_\odot (σ/200 {\rm km s^{-1}})^4$, where $σ= \sqrt{2} \aeff$. To obtain this normalization, the rotation rate $Ω\approx 2 \times 10^{15}$ rad/s. The model also defines a bulge mass scale $M_B$. If we identify the scale $M_B$ with the bulge mass, the model determines the ratio $\mrat$ of black hole mass to the host mass: $\mrat$ $\approx$ 0.0024 $(σ/200 {\rm km s^{-1}})$, again in reasonable agreement with observed values. In this scenario, supermassive black holes form quickly (in $\sim10^5$ yr) and are born rapidly rotating (with $a/M \sim 0.9$). This paper also shows how these results depend on the assumed initial conditions; the most important quantity is the initial distribution of specific angular momentum in the pre-collapse state. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2003; originally announced April 2003.

Comments: 31 pages, 4 figures, accepted to ApJ

Journal ref: Astrophys.J. 591 (2003) 125-137

The Cosmic Density of Massive Black Holes from Galaxy Velocity Dispersions

Authors: M. C. Aller, D. O. Richstone

Abstract: Supermassive black holes are thought to be relics of quasars, and their numbers and masses are therefore related to the quasar luminosity function and its evolution with redshift. We have used the relationship between black hole mass and bulge velocity dispersion (the M_bullet - sigma relation) to make an improved estimate of the mass density and mass spectrum of supermassive black holes. Uncert… ▽ More Supermassive black holes are thought to be relics of quasars, and their numbers and masses are therefore related to the quasar luminosity function and its evolution with redshift. We have used the relationship between black hole mass and bulge velocity dispersion (the M_bullet - sigma relation) to make an improved estimate of the mass density and mass spectrum of supermassive black holes. Uncertainties in the M_bullet - sigma relation have little effect on the mass density. We find a mass density of (4.8 +/- 1.6) h^2 x 10^5 M_sun Mpc^-3. Some of the variance in published density estimates comes from the use of different values of the Hubble constant. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2002; originally announced October 2002.

Comments: To appear in the December 2002 issue of The Astronomical Journal

Axisymmetric Dynamical Models of the Central Regions of Galaxies

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine, Tod R. Lauer, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl Grillmair, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney

Abstract: We present axisymmetric, orbit superposition models for 12 galaxies using data taken with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and ground-based observatories. In each galaxy, we detect a central black hole (BH) and measure its mass to accuracies ranging from 10% to 70%. We demonstrate that in most cases the BH detection requires both the HST and ground-based data. Using the ground-based data alone d… ▽ More We present axisymmetric, orbit superposition models for 12 galaxies using data taken with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and ground-based observatories. In each galaxy, we detect a central black hole (BH) and measure its mass to accuracies ranging from 10% to 70%. We demonstrate that in most cases the BH detection requires both the HST and ground-based data. Using the ground-based data alone does provide an unbiased measure of the BH mass (provided they are fit with fully general models), but at a greatly reduced significance. The most significant correlation with host galaxy properties is the relation between the BH mass and the velocity dispersion of the host galaxy; we find no other equally strong correlation, and no second parameter that improves the quality of the mass-dispersion relation. We are also able to measure the stellar orbital properties from these general models. The most massive galaxies are strongly biased to tangential orbits near the BH, consistent with binary BH models, while lower-mass galaxies have a range of anisotropies, consistent with an adiabatic growth of the BH. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2002; v1 submitted 23 September, 2002; originally announced September 2002.

Comments: 25 pages, accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal

Journal ref: Astrophys.J. 583 (2003) 92-115

Galaxies with a Central Minimum in Stellar Luminosity Density

Authors: Tod R. Lauer, Karl Gebhardt, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl J. Grillmair, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, S. Laine, Marc Postman, Roeland P. van der Marel

Abstract: We used HST WFPC2 images to identify six early-type galaxies with surface- brightness profiles that decrease inward over a limited range of radii near their centers. The implied luminosity density profiles of these galaxies have local minima interior to their core break radii. NGC 3706 harbors a high surface brightness ring of starlight with radius ~20 pc. Its central structure may be related to… ▽ More We used HST WFPC2 images to identify six early-type galaxies with surface- brightness profiles that decrease inward over a limited range of radii near their centers. The implied luminosity density profiles of these galaxies have local minima interior to their core break radii. NGC 3706 harbors a high surface brightness ring of starlight with radius ~20 pc. Its central structure may be related to that in the double-nucleus galaxies M31 and NGC 4486B. NGC 4406 and NGC 6876 have nearly flat cores that on close inspection are centrally depressed. Colors for both galaxies imply that this is not due to dust absorption. The surface brightness distributions of both galaxies are consistent with stellar tori that are more diffuse than the sharply defined system in NGC 3706. The remaining three galaxies are the brightest cluster galaxies in A260, A347, and A3574. Color information is not available for these objects, but they strongly resemble NGC 4406 and NGC 6876 in their cores. The thin ring in NGC 3706 may have formed dissipatively. The five other galaxies resemble the endpoints of some simulations of the merging of two gas-free stellar systems, each harboring a massive nuclear black hole. In one version of this scenario, diffuse stellar tori are produced when stars initially bound to one black hole are tidally stripped away by the second black hole. Alternatively, some inward-decreasing surface-brightness profiles may reflect the ejection of stars from a core during the hardening of the binary black hole created during the merger. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2002; originally announced June 2002.

Comments: 35 pages, 17 postscript figures, submitted to the Astronomical Journal

The slope of the black-hole mass versus velocity dispersion correlation

Authors: Scott Tremaine, Karl Gebhardt, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl Grillmair, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, Tod R. Lauer, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Douglas Richstone

Abstract: Observations of nearby galaxies reveal a strong correlation between the mass of the central dark object M and the velocity dispersion sigma of the host galaxy, of the form log(M/M_sun) = a + b*log(sigma/sigma_0); however, published estimates of the slope b span a wide range (3.75 to 5.3). Merritt & Ferrarese have argued that low slopes (<4) arise because of neglect of random measurement errors i… ▽ More Observations of nearby galaxies reveal a strong correlation between the mass of the central dark object M and the velocity dispersion sigma of the host galaxy, of the form log(M/M_sun) = a + b*log(sigma/sigma_0); however, published estimates of the slope b span a wide range (3.75 to 5.3). Merritt & Ferrarese have argued that low slopes (<4) arise because of neglect of random measurement errors in the dispersions and an incorrect choice for the dispersion of the Milky Way Galaxy. We show that these explanations account for at most a small part of the slope range. Instead, the range of slopes arises mostly because of systematic differences in the velocity dispersions used by different groups for the same galaxies. The origin of these differences remains unclear, but we suggest that one significant component of the difference results from Ferrarese & Merritt's extrapolation of central velocity dispersions to r_e/8 (r_e is the effective radius) using an empirical formula. Another component may arise from dispersion-dependent systematic errors in the measurements. A new determination of the slope using 31 galaxies yields b=4.02 +/- 0.32, a=8.13 +/- 0.06, for sigma_0=200 km/s. The M-sigma relation has an intrinsic dispersion in log M that is no larger than 0.3 dex. In an Appendix, we present a simple model for the velocity-dispersion profile of the Galactic bulge. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2002; originally announced March 2002.

Comments: 37 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.574:740-753,2002

M33: A Galaxy with No Supermassive Black Hole

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Tod R. Lauer, John Kormendy, Jason Pinkney, Gary A. Bower, Richard Green, Theodore Gull, J. B. Hutchings, M. E. Kaiser, Charles H. Nelson, Douglas Richstone, Donna Weistrop

Abstract: Galaxies that contain bulges appear to contain central black holes whose masses correlate with the velocity dispersion of the bulge. We show that no corresponding relationship applies in the pure disk galaxy M33. Three-integral dynamical models fit Hubble Space Telescope WFPC2 photometry and STIS spectroscopy best if the central black hole mass is zero. The upper limit is 1500 M_sun. This is sig… ▽ More Galaxies that contain bulges appear to contain central black holes whose masses correlate with the velocity dispersion of the bulge. We show that no corresponding relationship applies in the pure disk galaxy M33. Three-integral dynamical models fit Hubble Space Telescope WFPC2 photometry and STIS spectroscopy best if the central black hole mass is zero. The upper limit is 1500 M_sun. This is significantly below the mass expected from the velocity dispersion of the nucleus and far below any mass predicted from the disk kinematics. Our results suggest that supermassive black holes are associated only with galaxy bulges and not with their disks. △ Less

Submitted 19 July, 2001; v1 submitted 6 July, 2001; originally announced July 2001.

Comments: 8 pages, AJ accepted, November issue

Evidence of a Supermassive Black Hole in the Galaxy NGC 1023 from the Nuclear Stellar Dynamics

Authors: G. A. Bower, R. F. Green, R. Bender, K. Gebhardt, T. R. Lauer, J. Magorrian, D. O. Richstone, A. Danks, T. Gull, J. Hutchings, C. Joseph, M. E. Kaiser, D. Weistrop, B. Woodgate, C. Nelson, E. M. Malumuth

Abstract: We analyze the nuclear stellar dynamics of the SB0 galaxy NGC 1023, utilizing observational data both from the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph aboard the Hubble Space Telescope and from the ground. The stellar kinematics measured from these long-slit spectra show rapid rotation (V = 70 km/s at a distance of 0.1 arcsec = 4.9 pc from the nucleus) and increasing velocity dispersion toward the… ▽ More We analyze the nuclear stellar dynamics of the SB0 galaxy NGC 1023, utilizing observational data both from the Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph aboard the Hubble Space Telescope and from the ground. The stellar kinematics measured from these long-slit spectra show rapid rotation (V = 70 km/s at a distance of 0.1 arcsec = 4.9 pc from the nucleus) and increasing velocity dispersion toward the nucleus (where sigma = 295 +/- 30 km/s). We model the observed stellar kinematics assuming an axisymmetric mass distribution with both two and three integrals of motion. Both modeling techniques point to the presence of a central dark compact mass (which presumably is a supermassive black hole) with confidence > 99%. The isotropic two-integral models yield a best-fitting black hole mass of (6.0 +/- 1.4) x 10^7 M_sun and mass-to-light ratio (M/L_V) of 5.38 +/- 0.08, and the goodness-of-fit (chi^2) is insensitive to reasonable values for the galaxy's inclination. The three-integral models, which non-parametrically fit the observed line-of-sight velocity distribution as a function of position in the galaxy, suggest a black hole mass of (3.9 +/- 0.4) x 10^7 M_sun and M/L_V of 5.56 +/- 0.02 (internal errors), and the edge-on models are vastly superior fits over models at other inclinations. The internal dynamics in NGC 1023 as suggested by our best-fit three-integral model shows that the velocity distribution function at the nucleus is tangentially anisotropic, suggesting the presence of a nuclear stellar disk. The nuclear line of sight velocity distribution has enhanced wings at velocities >= 600 km/s from systemic, suggesting that perhaps we have detected a group of stars very close to the central dark mass. △ Less

Submitted 9 November, 2000; originally announced November 2000.

Comments: 21 pages, 12 figures, accepted in the Astrophysical Journal

A Theoretical Model for the $M_{\rm bh}-σ$ Relation for Supermassive Black Holes in Galaxies

Authors: Fred C. Adams, David S. Graff, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We construct a model for the formation of black holes within galactic bulges. The initial state is a slowly rotating isothermal sphere, characterized by effective transport speed $\aeff$ and rotation rate $Ω$. The black hole mass is determined when the centrifugal radius of the collapse flow exceeds the capture radius of the central black hole. This model reproduces the observed correlation betw… ▽ More We construct a model for the formation of black holes within galactic bulges. The initial state is a slowly rotating isothermal sphere, characterized by effective transport speed $\aeff$ and rotation rate $Ω$. The black hole mass is determined when the centrifugal radius of the collapse flow exceeds the capture radius of the central black hole. This model reproduces the observed correlation between black hole masses and galactic velocity dispersions, $\mbh \approx 10^8 M_\odot (σ/200 \kms)^4$, where $σ= \sqrt{2} \aeff$. This model also predicts the ratio $\mrat$ of black hole mass to host mass: $\mrat$ $\approx$ 0.004 $(σ/200 \kms)$. △ Less

Submitted 26 October, 2000; originally announced October 2000.

Comments: 9 pages, 2 figures, submitted to Astrophysical Journal Letters

Black Hole Mass Estimates from Reverberation Mapping and from Spatially Resolved Kinematics

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, John Kormendy, Luis Ho, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl Grillmair, Tod Lauer, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: Black hole (BH) masses that have been measured by reverberation mapping in active galaxies fall significantly below the correlation between bulge luminosity and BH mass determined from spatially resolved kinematics of nearby normal galaxies. This discrepancy has created concern that one or both techniques suffer from systematic errors. We show that BH masses from reverberation mapping are consis… ▽ More Black hole (BH) masses that have been measured by reverberation mapping in active galaxies fall significantly below the correlation between bulge luminosity and BH mass determined from spatially resolved kinematics of nearby normal galaxies. This discrepancy has created concern that one or both techniques suffer from systematic errors. We show that BH masses from reverberation mapping are consistent with the recently discovered relationship between BH mass and galaxy velocity dispersion. Therefore the bulge luminosities are the probable source of the disagreement, not problems with either method of mass measurement. This result underscores the utility of the BH mass -- velocity dispersion relationship. Reverberation mapping can now be applied with increased confidence to galaxies whose active nuclei are too bright or whose distances are too large for BH searches based on spatially resolved kinematics. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2000; v1 submitted 10 July, 2000; originally announced July 2000.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure, ApJ Letters accepted, minor revisions

Journal ref: Astrophys.J. 543 (2000) L5

A Relationship Between Nuclear Black Hole Mass and Galaxy Velocity Dispersion

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Ralf Bender, Gary Bower, Alan Dressler, S. M. Faber, Alexei V. Filippenko, Richard Green, Carl Grillmair, Luis C. Ho, John Kormendy, Tod R. Lauer, John Magorrian, Jason Pinkney, Douglas Richstone, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We describe a correlation between the mass M_BH of a galaxy's central black hole and the luminosity-weighted line-of-sight velocity dispersion sigma_e within the half-light radius. The result is based on a sample of 26 galaxies, including 13 galaxies with new determinations of black hole masses from Hubble Space Telescope measurements of stellar kinematics. The best-fit correlation is M_BH = 1.2… ▽ More We describe a correlation between the mass M_BH of a galaxy's central black hole and the luminosity-weighted line-of-sight velocity dispersion sigma_e within the half-light radius. The result is based on a sample of 26 galaxies, including 13 galaxies with new determinations of black hole masses from Hubble Space Telescope measurements of stellar kinematics. The best-fit correlation is M_BH = 1.2 (+-0.2) x 10^8 M_sun (sigma_e/200 km/s)^(3.75 (+-0.3))over almost three orders of magnitude in M_BH; the scatter in M_BH at fixed sigma_e is only 0.30 dex and most of this is due to observational errors. The M_BH-sigma_e relation is of interest not only for its strong predictive power but also because it implies that central black hole mass is constrained by and closely related to properties of the host galaxy's bulge. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2000; v1 submitted 20 June, 2000; originally announced June 2000.

Comments: 4 pages, accepted ApJ Letters, figure added and minor corrections

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.539:L13,2000

Axisymmetric, 3-Integral Models of Galaxies: A Massive Black Hole in NGC3379

Authors: Karl Gebhardt, Douglas Richstone, John Kormendy, Tod Lauer, Edward Ajhar, Ralf Bender, Alan Dressler, Sandra Faber, Carl Grillmair, John Magorrian, Scott Tremaine

Abstract: We fit axisymmetric 3-integral dynamical models to NGC3379 using the line-of-sight velocity distribution obtained from HST/FOS spectra of the galaxy center and ground-based long-slit spectroscopy along four position angles, with the light distribution constrained by WFPC2 and ground-based images. We have fitted models with inclinations from 29 (intrinsic galaxy type E5) to 90 degrees (intrinsic… ▽ More We fit axisymmetric 3-integral dynamical models to NGC3379 using the line-of-sight velocity distribution obtained from HST/FOS spectra of the galaxy center and ground-based long-slit spectroscopy along four position angles, with the light distribution constrained by WFPC2 and ground-based images. We have fitted models with inclinations from 29 (intrinsic galaxy type E5) to 90 degrees (intrinsic E1) and black hole masses from 0 to 1e9 M_solar. The best-fit black hole masses range from 6e7 to 2e8 M_solar, depending on inclination. The velocity ellipsoid of the best model is not consistent with either isotropy or a two-integral distribution function. Along the major axis, the velocity ellipsoid becomes tangential at the innermost bin, radial in the mid-range radii, and tangential again at the outermost bins. For the acceptable models, the radial to tangential dispersion in the mid-range radii ranges from 1.1 < sigma_r / sigma_t < 1.7. Compared with these 3-integral models, 2-integral isotropic models overestimate the black hole mass since they cannot provide adequate radial motion. However, the models presented in this paper still contain restrictive assumptions-namely assumptions of constant M/L and spheroidal symmetry-requiring yet more models to study black hole properties in complete generality. △ Less

Submitted 1 December, 1999; originally announced December 1999.

Comments: 15 pages, emulateapj sty, accepted for publication in The Astronomical Journal

The Role of a Massive Central Singularity in Galactic Mergers on the Survival of the Core Fundamental Plane

Authors: Kelly Holley-Bockelmann, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: In order for the core Fundamental Plane (cFP) to endure, small ellipticals must not survive mergers with giant ellipticals, despite the fact the small secondary galaxy can be as much as a million times more dense than the primary. However, our previous set of experiments has shown that, for purely stellar galaxies, the secondary does in fact survive mergers with primaries up to 100 times more ma… ▽ More In order for the core Fundamental Plane (cFP) to endure, small ellipticals must not survive mergers with giant ellipticals, despite the fact the small secondary galaxy can be as much as a million times more dense than the primary. However, our previous set of experiments has shown that, for purely stellar galaxies, the secondary does in fact survive mergers with primaries up to 100 times more massive. In this paper, we demonstrate the effect that a massive central black hole has on mergers of cFP galaxies. Our results indicate that the addition of a massive central singularity inside the primary galaxy provides strong enough tidal forces to destroy dense cFP companions when the secondary's orbital decay is sufficiently elongated. The destruction of the secondary acts to preserve the original low central density profile of the primary in the giant merger remnant, which allows the remnant to remain on the cFP. On more circular orbits, though, the secondary is only disrupted near the end of the merger, and the degree to which the secondary particles disperse depends on the amount of orbital energy left in the merger. Hence, there are some mergers for which the cFP is not preserved in our experiments. We find that if the secondary is not dispersed, it forms a spinning stellar disk with a central density that forces the merger remnant off the cFP. △ Less

Submitted 23 August, 1999; originally announced August 1999.

Comments: 26 pages, 17 figures, submitted to ApJ

The Survival of The Core Fundamental Plane Against Galactic Mergers

Authors: Kelly Holley-Bockelmann, Douglas O. Richstone

Abstract: We have developed an effective simulation method and applied it to the problem of the accretion of very dense secondary companions by tenuous primaries. We have studied the accretion of objects of varying luminosity ratios, with sizes and densities drawn from the core Fundamental Plane for elliptical galaxies under the assumption that the mass distribution in the central parts of the galaxies fo… ▽ More We have developed an effective simulation method and applied it to the problem of the accretion of very dense secondary companions by tenuous primaries. We have studied the accretion of objects of varying luminosity ratios, with sizes and densities drawn from the core Fundamental Plane for elliptical galaxies under the assumption that the mass distribution in the central parts of the galaxies follows the light. The results indicate that in mergers with mass ratios greater than 10, the smaller object is only stripped down to the highest density encountered in the primary during the accretion process. Thus, the form of the core Fundamental Plane suggests that the mass distribution in these galaxy centers is different than the light distribution, or that mergers on the core Fundamental Plane require more than the dynamics of visible stars. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 1998; originally announced November 1998.

Comments: 30 pages LaTeX, 18 figures

Supermassive Black Holes Then and Now

Authors: D. Richstone

Abstract: Recent surveys suggest that most or all normal galaxies host a massive black hole with 1/100 to 1/1000 of the visible mass of the spheroid of the galaxy. Various lines of argument suggest that these galaxies have merged at least once in our past lightcone, and that the black holes have also merged. This leads to a merger rate of massive black holes of about 1/\yrs. Recent surveys suggest that most or all normal galaxies host a massive black hole with 1/100 to 1/1000 of the visible mass of the spheroid of the galaxy. Various lines of argument suggest that these galaxies have merged at least once in our past lightcone, and that the black holes have also merged. This leads to a merger rate of massive black holes of about 1/\yrs. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 1998; originally announced October 1998.

Comments: 7 pages, to appear in The Proceedings of the Second International LISA Symposium on Graviational Waves, ed. W. Folkner

Supermassive Black Holes and the Evolution of Galaxies

Authors: D. Richstone, E. A. Ajhar, R. Bender, G. Bower, A. Dressler, S. M. Faber, A. V. Filippenko, K. Gebhardt, R. Green, L. C. Ho, J. Kormendy, T. Lauer, J. Magorrian, S. Tremaine

Abstract: Black holes, an extreme consequence of the mathematics of General Relativity, have long been suspected of being the prime movers of quasars, which emit more energy than any other objects in the Universe. Recent evidence indicates that supermassive black holes, which are probably quasar remnants, reside at the centers of most galaxies. As our knowledge of the demographics of these relics of a vio… ▽ More Black holes, an extreme consequence of the mathematics of General Relativity, have long been suspected of being the prime movers of quasars, which emit more energy than any other objects in the Universe. Recent evidence indicates that supermassive black holes, which are probably quasar remnants, reside at the centers of most galaxies. As our knowledge of the demographics of these relics of a violent earlier Universe improve, we see tantalizing clues that they participated intimately in the formation of galaxies and have strongly influenced their present-day structure. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 1998; originally announced October 1998.

Comments: 20 pages, - This is a near-duplicate of the paper in Nature 395, A14, 1998 (Oct 1)

Journal ref: Nature 395:A14-A19,1998