-
High-Resolution Optical IFU Spectroscopy of the Complex Galaxy Merger II Zw 096
Authors:
C. Riesco,
E. Treister,
G. Venturi,
F. Bauer,
G. Privon,
C. Finlez,
S. Zamora,
D. Tubin,
Y. Song,
I. del Moral-Castro,
C. Ricci,
C. Ramos,
N. Levenson,
V. U,
A. Medling,
S. Aalto,
G. D'Ago,
V. Olivares,
L. Barcos-Muñoz,
F. Ricci,
G. Olander,
F. Muller-Sanchez,
P. Tissera
Abstract:
Luminous and Ultra-luminous IR galaxies ((U)LIRGs) are critical for investigating feedback mechanisms due to a combination of intense star formation (SF) episodes and active galactic nuclei (AGN), particularly in the context of complex galaxy interactions. We conduct a detailed analysis of the II ZW 096 merging system using the Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) on the Very Large Telescope (…
▽ More
Luminous and Ultra-luminous IR galaxies ((U)LIRGs) are critical for investigating feedback mechanisms due to a combination of intense star formation (SF) episodes and active galactic nuclei (AGN), particularly in the context of complex galaxy interactions. We conduct a detailed analysis of the II ZW 096 merging system using the Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) on the Very Large Telescope (VLT), combining high-resolution Narrow Field Mode (NFM) and large-area Wide Field Mode (WFM) observations. We mapped the morphology, kinematics, and ionizing radiation of the system's gas by fitting atomic emission lines and the optical continuum. We identify three or more distinct galaxies within II ZW 096, revealing rotational patterns and complex interactions consistent with a collapsing small galaxy group. The kinematics and ionization structures suggest high star formation rates and shock-driven processes, which align with this proposed scenario. Focusing on the D1 compact region, which contributes 40-70% of the system's IR emission, and combining information from archival multi-wavelength observations, we find strong evidence of a heavily obscured AGN powering it. Our analysis of the internal structure, interactions, and merger state of II ZW 096 offers novel insights into the galaxy evolution processes in this dynamic and highly chaotic system
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
The Rise of Ionized Gas Filaments in Early-Type Galaxies
Authors:
Ryan Eskenasy,
Valeria Olivares,
Yuanyuan Su
Abstract:
Multiphase filamentary nebulae are ubiquitous in the brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) of cool-core clusters, providing key insights into the cycle of baryons and the feeding and feedback of supermassive black holes. However, BCGs account for less than 1% of all early-type galaxies (ETGs). To broaden our understanding of how multiphase filamentary nebulae form in ETGs and connect to the greater pi…
▽ More
Multiphase filamentary nebulae are ubiquitous in the brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) of cool-core clusters, providing key insights into the cycle of baryons and the feeding and feedback of supermassive black holes. However, BCGs account for less than 1% of all early-type galaxies (ETGs). To broaden our understanding of how multiphase filamentary nebulae form in ETGs and connect to the greater picture of galaxy evolution, it is crucial to explore ETGs that are outside of the dense centers of galaxy clusters or groups. We present VLT-MUSE IFU observations of 126 nearby non-central ETGs, detecting warm ionized gas in 54 of them. 35 out of 54 display rotating disks that are morphologically and kinematically aligned with their stellar components, suggesting stellar mass loss as the origin of their warm gas. The remaining 19 host filamentary nebulae that are decoupled from the stellar components, resembling those observed in BCGs. These filamentary sources display unique emission line properties that cannot be fully explained by photoionization from post-asymptotic giant branch stars, active galactic nuclei, or fast gas shocks. For the eight filamentary sources that have been observed with Chandra, their soft X-ray emission indicates the presence of hot gas. We posit that their emission lines may be powered by EUV and X-ray radiation from the cooling of the hot gas, similar to cool-core clusters, but the detailed mechanisms and physical conditions may be different. As a detailed study case, we investigate NGC 4374, a non-central ETG with extensive Chandra observations, and find that its warm filaments are over pressured compared to the hot filaments - opposite with what is observed in cool-core clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
H$α$-X-ray Surface Brightness Correlation for Filaments in Cooling Flow Clusters
Authors:
Valeria Olivares,
Adrien Picquenot,
Yuanyuan Su,
Massimo Gaspari,
Marie-Lou Gendron-Marsolais,
Fiorella L. Polles,
Paul Nulsen
Abstract:
Massive galaxies in cooling flow clusters display clear evidence of feedback from Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Joint X-ray and radio observations have shown that AGN radio jets push aside the surrounding hot gas and form cavities in the hot intracluster medium (ICM). These systems host complex, kiloparsec-scale, multiphase filamentary structures, from warm ionized (10,000 K) to cold molecular (…
▽ More
Massive galaxies in cooling flow clusters display clear evidence of feedback from Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Joint X-ray and radio observations have shown that AGN radio jets push aside the surrounding hot gas and form cavities in the hot intracluster medium (ICM). These systems host complex, kiloparsec-scale, multiphase filamentary structures, from warm ionized (10,000 K) to cold molecular ($<$100 K). These striking clumpy filaments are believed to be a natural outcome of thermally unstable cooling from the hot ICM, likely triggered by feedback processes while contributing to feeding the AGN via Chaotic Cold Accretion (CCA). However, the detailed constraints on the formation mechanism of the filaments are still uncertain, and the connection between the different gas phases has to be fully unveiled. By leveraging a sample of seven X-ray bright cooling-flow clusters, we have discovered a tight positive correlation between the X-ray surface brightness and the H$α$ surface brightness of the filaments over two orders of magnitude, as also found in stripped tails.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2025; v1 submitted 3 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
A hot core in the group-dominant elliptical galaxy NGC 777
Authors:
Ewan O'Sullivan,
Kamlesh Rajpurohit,
Gerrit Schellenberger,
Jan Vrtilek,
Laurence P. David,
Arif Babul,
Valeria Olivares,
Francesco Ubertosi,
Konstantinos Kolokythas,
Iurii Babyk,
Ilani Loubser
Abstract:
NGC 777 provides an example of a phenomenon observed in some group-central ellipticals, in which the temperature profile shows a central peak, despite the short central cooling time of the intra-group medium. We use deep Chandra X-ray observations of the galaxy, supported by uGMRT 400 MHz radio imaging, to investigate the origin of this hot core. We confirm the centrally-peaked temperature profile…
▽ More
NGC 777 provides an example of a phenomenon observed in some group-central ellipticals, in which the temperature profile shows a central peak, despite the short central cooling time of the intra-group medium. We use deep Chandra X-ray observations of the galaxy, supported by uGMRT 400 MHz radio imaging, to investigate the origin of this hot core. We confirm the centrally-peaked temperature profile and find that entropy and cooling time both monotonically decline to low values (2.62 [+0.19, -0.18] keV cm$^2$ and 71.3 [+12.8, -13.1] Myr) in the central ~700 pc. Faint diffuse radio emission surrounds the nuclear point source, with no clear jets or lobes but extending to ~10 kpc on a northwest-southeast axis. This alignment and extent agree well with a previously identified filamentary H$α$+[NII] nebula. While cavities are not firmly detected, we see X-ray surface brightness decrements on the same axis at 10-20 kpc radius which are consistent with the intra-group medium having been pushed aside by expanding radio lobes. Any such outburst must have occurred long enough ago for lobe emission to have faded below detectability. Cavities on this scale would be capable of balancing radiative cooling for at least ~240 Myr. We consider possible causes of the centrally peaked temperature profile, including gravitational heating of gas as the halo relaxes after a period of AGN jet activity, and heating by particles leaking from the remnant relativistic plasma of the old radio jets.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2024; v1 submitted 22 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
The composition and thermal properties of a cool core lacking a brightest cluster galaxy
Authors:
Yuanyuan Su,
Francoise Combes,
Valeria Olivares,
Gianluca Castignani,
Pablo Torne,
Reinout van Weeren
Abstract:
We present a multiwavelength observation of a cool core that does not appear to be associated with any galaxy, in a nearby cluster, Abell~1142. Its X-ray surface brightness peak of $\lesssim2$ keV is cooler than the ambient intracluster gas of $\gtrsim3$ keV, and is offset from its brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) by 80 kpc in projection, representing the largest known cool core -- BCG separation. T…
▽ More
We present a multiwavelength observation of a cool core that does not appear to be associated with any galaxy, in a nearby cluster, Abell~1142. Its X-ray surface brightness peak of $\lesssim2$ keV is cooler than the ambient intracluster gas of $\gtrsim3$ keV, and is offset from its brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) by 80 kpc in projection, representing the largest known cool core -- BCG separation. This BCG-less cool core allows us to measure the metallicity of a cluster center with a much-reduced contribution from the interstellar medium (ISM) of the BCG. XMM-Newton observation reveals a prominent Fe abundance peak of $1.07^{+0.16}_{-0.15}$ Z$_{\odot}$ and an $α/$Fe abundance ratio close to the solar ratio, fully consistent with those found at the centers of typical cool core clusters. This finding hints that BCGs play a limited role in enriching the cluster centers. However, the discussion remains open, given that the $α/$Fe abundance ratios of the orphan cool core and the BCG ISM are not significantly different. Abell~1142 may have experienced a major merger more than 100 Myr ago, which has dissociated its cool core from the BCG. This implies that the Fe abundance peak in cool core clusters can be resilient to cluster mergers. Our recent IRAM 30-m observation did not detect any CO emission at its X-ray peak and we find no evidence for massive runaway cooling in the absence of recent AGN feedback. The lack of a galaxy may contribute to an inefficient conversion of the ionized warm gas to the cold molecular gas.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
The formation channels of multiphase gas in nearby early-type galaxies
Authors:
Ryan Eskenasy,
Valeria Olivares,
Yuanyuan Su,
Yuan Li
Abstract:
The processes responsible for the assembly of cold and warm gas in early-type galaxies (ETGs) are not well-understood. We report on the multiwavelength properties of 15 non-central, nearby ($z \leq$ 0.00889) ETGs primarily through Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) and Chandra X-ray observations, to address the origin of their multiphase gas. The MUSE data reveals 8/15 sources contain warm i…
▽ More
The processes responsible for the assembly of cold and warm gas in early-type galaxies (ETGs) are not well-understood. We report on the multiwavelength properties of 15 non-central, nearby ($z \leq$ 0.00889) ETGs primarily through Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) and Chandra X-ray observations, to address the origin of their multiphase gas. The MUSE data reveals 8/15 sources contain warm ionized gas traced by the H$α$ emission line. The morphology of this gas is found to be filamentary in 3/8 sources: NGC 1266, NGC 4374, and NGC 4684 which is similar to that observed in many group and cluster-centered galaxies. All H$α$ filamentary sources have X-ray luminosities exceeding the expected emission from the stellar population, suggesting the presence of diffuse hot gas which likely cooled to form the cooler phases. The morphology of the remaining 5/8 sources are rotating gas disks, not as commonly observed in higher mass systems. Chandra X-ray observations (when available) of the ETGs with rotating H$α$ disks indicate that they are nearly void of hot gas. A mixture of stellar mass loss and external accretion was likely the dominant channel for the cool gas in NGC 4526 and NGC 4710. These ETGs show full kinematic alignment between their stars and gas, and are fast rotators. The H$α$ features within NGC 4191 (clumpy, potentially star-forming ring), NGC 4643 and NGC 5507 (extended structures) along with loosely overlapping stellar and gas populations allow us to attribute external accretion to be the primary formation channel of the cool gas in these systems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2023; v1 submitted 3 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
X-ray Cavity Dynamics and their Role in the Gas Precipitation in Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) Selected Clusters
Authors:
V. Olivares,
Y. Su,
W. Forman,
M. Gaspari,
F. Andrade-Santos,
P. Salome,
P. Nulsen,
A. Edge,
F. Combes,
C. Jones
Abstract:
We study active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback in nearby (z<0.35) galaxy clusters from the Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) sample using Chandra observations. This nearly unbiased mass-selected sample includes both relaxed and disturbed clusters and may reflect the entire AGN feedback cycle. We find that relaxed clusters better follow the one-to-one relation of cavity power versus cooling luminosity…
▽ More
We study active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback in nearby (z<0.35) galaxy clusters from the Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) sample using Chandra observations. This nearly unbiased mass-selected sample includes both relaxed and disturbed clusters and may reflect the entire AGN feedback cycle. We find that relaxed clusters better follow the one-to-one relation of cavity power versus cooling luminosity, while disturbed clusters display higher cavity power for a given cooling luminosity, likely reflecting a difference in cooling and feedback efficiency. Disturbed clusters are also found to contain asymmetric cavities when compared to relaxed clusters, hinting toward the influence of the intracluster medium (ICM) weather on the distribution and morphology of the cavities. Disturbed clusters do not have fewer cavities than relaxed clusters, suggesting that cavities are difficult to disrupt. Thus, multiple cavities are a natural outcome of recurrent AGN outbursts. As in previous studies, we confirm that clusters with short central cooling times, tcool, and low central entropy values, K0, contain warm ionized (10000 K) or cold molecular (<100 K) gas, consistent with ICM cooling and a precipitation/chaotic cold accretion (CCA) scenario. We analyzed archival MUSE observations that are available for 18 clusters. In 11/18 of the cases, the projected optical line emission filaments appear to be located beneath or around the cavity rims, indicating that AGN feedback plays an important role in forming the warm filaments by likely enhancing turbulence or uplift. In the remaining cases (7/18), the clusters either lack cavities or their association of filaments with cavities is vague, suggesting alternative turbulence-driven mechanisms (sloshing/mergers) or physical time delays are involved.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
The Nature of the Motions of Multiphase Filaments in the Centers of Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Shalini Ganguly,
Yuan Li,
Valeria Olivares,
Yuanyuan Su,
Francoise Combes,
Sampadaa Prakash,
Stephen Hamer,
Pierre Guillard,
Trung Ha
Abstract:
The intracluster medium (ICM) in the centers of galaxy clusters is heavily influenced by the ``feedback'' from supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Feedback can drive turbulence in the ICM and turbulent dissipation can potentially be an important source of heating. Due to the limited spatial and spectral resolutions of X-ray telescopes, direct observations of turbulence in the hot ICM have been chall…
▽ More
The intracluster medium (ICM) in the centers of galaxy clusters is heavily influenced by the ``feedback'' from supermassive black holes (SMBHs). Feedback can drive turbulence in the ICM and turbulent dissipation can potentially be an important source of heating. Due to the limited spatial and spectral resolutions of X-ray telescopes, direct observations of turbulence in the hot ICM have been challenging. Recently, we developed a new method to measure turbulence in the ICM using multiphase filaments as tracers. These filaments are ubiquitous in cluster centers and can be observed at very high resolution using optical and radio telescopes. We study the kinematics of the filaments by measuring their velocity structure functions (VSFs) over a wide range of scales in the centers of $\sim 10$ galaxy clusters. We find features of the VSFs that correlate with the SMBHs activities, suggesting that SMBHs are the main driver of gas motions in the centers of galaxy clusters. In all systems, the VSF is steeper than the classical Kolmogorov expectation and the slopes vary from system to system. One theoretical explanation is that the VSFs we have measured so far mostly reflect the motion of the driver (jets and bubbles) rather than the cascade of turbulence. We show that in Abell 1795, the VSF of the outer filaments far from the SMBH flattens on small scales to a Kolmogorov slope, suggesting that the cascade is only detectable farther out with the current telescope resolution. The level of turbulent heating computed at small scales is typically an order of magnitude lower than that estimated at the driving scale. Even though SMBH feedback heavily influences the kinematics of the ICM in cluster centers, the level of turbulence it drives is rather low, and turbulent heating can only offset $\lesssim10\%$ of the cooling loss, consistent with the findings of numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Waking the monster: the onset of AGN feedback in galaxy clusters hosting young central radio galaxies
Authors:
Francesco Ubertosi,
Myriam Gitti,
Fabrizio Brighenti,
Valeria Olivares,
Ewan O'Sullivan,
Gerrit Schellenberger
Abstract:
The investigation of the feedback cycle in galaxy clusters has historically been performed for systems where feedback is ongoing ("mature-feedback" clusters), that is where the central radio galaxy has inflated radio lobes, pushing aside the intracluster medium (ICM). In this pilot study we present results from "pre-feedback" clusters, where the central newly active radio galaxies (age $<10^{3}$ y…
▽ More
The investigation of the feedback cycle in galaxy clusters has historically been performed for systems where feedback is ongoing ("mature-feedback" clusters), that is where the central radio galaxy has inflated radio lobes, pushing aside the intracluster medium (ICM). In this pilot study we present results from "pre-feedback" clusters, where the central newly active radio galaxies (age $<10^{3}$ yr) may not yet have had time to alter the thermodynamic state of the ICM. We analyze $Chandra$ and MUSE observations of two such systems, evaluating the hot gas entropy and cooling time profiles, and characterizing the morphology and kinematics of the warm gas. Based on our exploratory study of these two sources, we find that the hot gas meets the expectations for an as-yet unheated ICM. Specifically, the entropy and cooling time of pre-feedback clusters within 20 kpc from the center fall below those of mature-feedback clusters by a factor $\sim$2. We speculate that with an estimated mechanical power of $\sim10^{44} - 10^{45}$ erg s$^{-1}$, the two young radio galaxies may restore the entropy levels in a few tens of Myr, which are typical values of power outbursts and lifetimes for radio galaxies in clusters. Conversely, the properties of the gas at $\sim10^{4}$ K seem to remain invariant between the two feedback stages, possibly suggesting that the warm gas reservoir accumulates over long periods ($10^{7}$ - $10^{8}$ yr) during the growth of the radio galaxy. We conclude that the exploratory results obtained from our analysis of two cluster-central young radio galaxies are crucial in the context of understanding the onset of active galactic nuclei feedback, and they provide enough motivation for further investigation of similar cases.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2023; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Spatially-resolved properties of early-type group-dominant galaxies with MUSE: gas content, ionisation mechanisms and metallicity gradients
Authors:
P. Lagos,
S. I. Loubser,
T. C. Scott,
E. O'Sullivan,
K. Kolokythas,
A. Babul,
A. Nigoche-Netro,
V. Olivares,
C. Sengupta
Abstract:
With the goal of a thorough investigation of the ionised gas and its origin in early-type group-dominant galaxies, we present archival MUSE data for 18 galaxies from the Complete Local-Volume Groups Sample (CLoGS). This data allowed us to study the spatially-resolved warm gas properties, including the morphology of the ionised gas, EW(H$α$) and kinematics as well as the gas-phase metallicity (12 +…
▽ More
With the goal of a thorough investigation of the ionised gas and its origin in early-type group-dominant galaxies, we present archival MUSE data for 18 galaxies from the Complete Local-Volume Groups Sample (CLoGS). This data allowed us to study the spatially-resolved warm gas properties, including the morphology of the ionised gas, EW(H$α$) and kinematics as well as the gas-phase metallicity (12 + log(O/H)) of these systems. In order to distinguish between different ionisation mechanisms, we used the emission-line ratios [O III]/H$β$ and [N II]/H$α$ in the BPT diagrams and EW(H$α$). We find that the ionisation sources in our sample have variable impacts at different radii, central regions are more influenced by low-luminosity AGN, while extended regions of LINER-like emission are ionised by other mechanisms with pAGBs photoionisation likely contributing significantly. We classified our sample into three H$α$+[N II] emission morphology types. We calculate the gas-phase metallicity assuming several methods and ionisation sources. In general, 12 + log(O/H) decreases with radius from the centre for all galaxies, independently of nebular morphology type, indicating a metallicity gradient in the abundance profiles. Interestingly, the more extended filamentary structures and all extranuclear star-forming regions present shallow metallicity gradients. Within the uncertainties these extended structures can be considered chemically homogeneous. We suggest that group-dominant galaxies in our sample likely acquired their cold gas in the past as a consequence of one or more mechanisms, e.g. gas-clouds or satellite mergers/accretion and/or cooling flows that contribute to the growth of the ionised gas structures.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
AGN feedback duty cycle in Planck SZ selected clusters using Chandra observations
Authors:
V. Olivares,
Y. Su,
P. Nulsen,
R. Kraft,
T. Somboonpanyakul,
F. Andrade-Santos,
C. Jones,
W. Forman
Abstract:
We present a systematic study of X-ray cavities using archival Chandra observations of nearby galaxy clusters selected by their Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) signature in the Planck survey, which provides a nearly unbiased mass-selected sample to explore the entire AGN feedback duty cycle. Based on X-ray image analysis, we report that 30 of the 164 clusters show X-ray cavities, which corresponds to a de…
▽ More
We present a systematic study of X-ray cavities using archival Chandra observations of nearby galaxy clusters selected by their Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) signature in the Planck survey, which provides a nearly unbiased mass-selected sample to explore the entire AGN feedback duty cycle. Based on X-ray image analysis, we report that 30 of the 164 clusters show X-ray cavities, which corresponds to a detection fraction of 18%. After correcting for spatial resolution to match the high-$z$ SPT-SZ sample, the detection fraction decreases to 9%, consistent with the high-z sample, hinting that the AGN feedback has not evolved across almost 8 Gyrs. Our finding agrees with the lack of evolution of cool-core clusters fraction. We calculate the cavity power, P_{\rm cav}, and find that most systems of our sample have enough AGN heating to offset the radiative losses of the intracluster medium.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Merger histories of brightest group galaxies from MUSE stellar kinematics
Authors:
S. I. Loubser,
P. Lagos,
A. Babul,
E. O'Sullivan,
S. L. Jung,
V. Olivares,
K. Kolokythas
Abstract:
Using Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) spectroscopy, we analyse the stellar kinematics of 18 brightest group early-type (BGEs) galaxies, selected from the Complete Local-Volume Groups Sample (CLoGS). We analyse the kinematic maps for distinct features, and measure specific stellar angular momentum within one effective radius ($λ_{e}$). We classify the BGEs as fast (10/18) or slow (8/18) ro…
▽ More
Using Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) spectroscopy, we analyse the stellar kinematics of 18 brightest group early-type (BGEs) galaxies, selected from the Complete Local-Volume Groups Sample (CLoGS). We analyse the kinematic maps for distinct features, and measure specific stellar angular momentum within one effective radius ($λ_{e}$). We classify the BGEs as fast (10/18) or slow (8/18) rotators, suggesting at least two different evolution paths. We quantify the anti-correlation between higher-order kinematic moment $h_{3}$ and V/$σ$ (using the $ξ_{3}$ parameter), and the kinematic misalignment angle between the photometric and kinematic position angles (using the $Ψ$ parameter), and note clear differences between these parameter distributions of the fast and slow rotating BGEs. We find that all 10 of our fast rotators are aligned between the morphological and kinematical axis, consistent with an oblate galaxy shape, whereas the slow rotators are spread over all three classes: oblate (1/8), triaxial (4/8), and prolate (3/8). We place the results into context using known radio properties, X-ray properties, and observations of molecular gas. We find consistent merger histories inferred from observations for the fast-rotating BGEs, indicating that they experienced gas-rich mergers or interactions, and these are very likely the origin of the cold gas. Observational evidence for the slow rotators are consistent with gas-poor mergers. For the slow rotators with cold gas, all evidence point to cold gas cooling from the intragroup medium.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
AGN jets do not prevent the suppression of conduction by the heat buoyancy instability in simulated galaxy clusters
Authors:
Ricarda S. Beckmann,
Yohan Dubois,
Alisson Pellissier,
Fiorella L. Polles,
Valeria Olivares
Abstract:
Centres of galaxy clusters must be efficiently reheated to avoid a cooling catastrophe. One potential reheating mechanism is anisotropic thermal conduction, which could transport thermal energy from intermediate radii to the cluster center. However, if fields are not re-randomised, anisotropic thermal conduction drives the heat buoyancy instability (HBI) which reorients magnetic field lines and sh…
▽ More
Centres of galaxy clusters must be efficiently reheated to avoid a cooling catastrophe. One potential reheating mechanism is anisotropic thermal conduction, which could transport thermal energy from intermediate radii to the cluster center. However, if fields are not re-randomised, anisotropic thermal conduction drives the heat buoyancy instability (HBI) which reorients magnetic field lines and shuts off radial heat fluxes. We revisit the efficiency of thermal conduction under the influence of spin-driven AGN jets in idealised magneto-hydrodynamical simulations with anisotropic thermal conduction. Despite the black hole spin's ability to regularly re-orientate the jet so that the jet-induced turbulence is driven in a quasi-isotropic fashion, the HBI remains efficient outside the central 50 kpc of the cluster, where the reservoir of heat is the largest. As a result, conduction plays no significant role in regulating the cooling of the intra-cluster medium if central active galactic nuclei are the sole source of turbulence. Whistler-wave driven saturation of thermal conduction reduces the magnitude of the HBI but does not prevent it.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022; v1 submitted 26 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Cosmic rays and thermal instability in self-regulating cooling flows of massive galaxy clusters
Authors:
Ricarda S. Beckmann,
Yohan Dubois,
Alisson Pellissier,
Valeria Olivares,
Fiorella L. Polles,
Oliver Hahn,
Pierre Guillard,
Matthew D. Lehnert
Abstract:
One of the key physical processes that helps prevent strong cooling flows in galaxy clusters is the continued energy input from the central active galactic nucleus (AGN) of the cluster. However, it remains unclear how this energy is thermalised so that it can effectively prevent global thermal instability. One possible option is that a fraction of the AGN energy is converted into cosmic rays (CRs)…
▽ More
One of the key physical processes that helps prevent strong cooling flows in galaxy clusters is the continued energy input from the central active galactic nucleus (AGN) of the cluster. However, it remains unclear how this energy is thermalised so that it can effectively prevent global thermal instability. One possible option is that a fraction of the AGN energy is converted into cosmic rays (CRs), which provide non-thermal pressure support, and can retain energy even as thermal energy is radiated away. By means of magneto-hydrodynamical simulations, we investigate how CR injected by the AGN jet influence cooling flows of a massive galaxy cluster. We conclude that converting a fraction of the AGN luminosity as low as 10\% into CR energy prevents cooling flows on timescales of billion years, without significant changes in the structure of the multi-phase intra-cluster medium. CR-dominated jets, by contrast, lead to the formation of an extended, warm central nebula that is supported by CR pressure. We report that the presence of CRs is not able to suppress the onset of thermal instability in massive galaxy clusters, but CR-dominated jets do significantly change the continued evolution of gas as it continues to cool from isobaric to isochoric. The CR redistribution in the cluster is dominated by advection rather than diffusion or streaming, but the heating by CR streaming helps maintain gas in the hot and warm phase. Observationally, self-regulating, CR-dominated jets produce a \gammaray~ flux in excess of current observational limits, but low CR fractions in the jet are not ruled out.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022; v1 submitted 7 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Gas condensation in Brightest Group Galaxies unveiled with MUSE
Authors:
V. Olivares,
P. Salome,
S. L. Hamer,
F. Combes,
M. Gaspari,
K. Kolokythas,
E. O'Sullivan,
R. S. Beckmann,
A. Babul,
F. L. Polles,
M. Lehnert,
S. I. Loubser,
M. Donahue,
M. -L. Gendron-Marsolais,
P. Lagos,
G. Pineau des Forets,
B. Godard,
T. Rose,
G. Tremblay,
G. Ferland,
P. Guillard
Abstract:
The origin of the cold gas in central galaxies in groups is still a matter of debate. We present Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) observations of 18 optically selected local Brightest Group Galaxies (BGGs) to study the kinematics and distribution of the optical emission-line gas. MUSE observations reveal a distribution of gas morphologies including ten complex networks of filaments extendi…
▽ More
The origin of the cold gas in central galaxies in groups is still a matter of debate. We present Multi-Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) observations of 18 optically selected local Brightest Group Galaxies (BGGs) to study the kinematics and distribution of the optical emission-line gas. MUSE observations reveal a distribution of gas morphologies including ten complex networks of filaments extending up to 10 kpc to two compact (<3 kpc) and five extended (>5 kpc) disk-dominated structures. Some rotating disks show rings and elongated structures arising from the central disk. The kinematics of the stellar component is mainly rotation-dominated, which is very different from the disturbed kinematics and distribution found in the filamentary sources. The ionized gas is kinematically decoupled from the stellar component for most systems, suggesting an external origin for the gas. We also find that the Halpha luminosity correlates with the cold molecular mass. By exploring the thermodynamical properties of the hot atmospheres, we find that the filamentary sources and compact disks are found in systems with small central entropy values and tcool/teddy ratios. This suggests that, like for Brightest Cluster Galaxies in cool core clusters, the ionized gas are likely formed from hot halo gas condensations, consistently with the Chaotic Cold Accretion simulations (as shown via the C-ratio, Tat, and k-plot). We note that gaseous rotating disks are more frequent than in BCGs. An explanation for the origin of the gas in those objects is a contribution to gas fueling by mergers or group satellites, as qualitatively hinted by some sources of the present sample. Nonetheless, we discuss the possibility that some extended disks could also be a transition stage in an evolutionary sequence including filaments, extended disks and compact disks, as described by hot gas condensation models of cooling flows.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Excitation mechanisms in the intracluster filaments surrounding Brightest Cluster Galaxies
Authors:
F. L. Polles,
P. Salomé,
P. Guillard,
B. Godard,
G. Pineau des Forêts,
V. Olivares,
R. S. Beckmann,
R. E. A. Canning,
F. Combes,
Y. Dubois,
A. C. Edge,
A. C. Fabian,
G. J. Ferland,
S. L. Hamer,
M. D. Lehnert
Abstract:
The excitation of the filamentary gas structures surrounding giant elliptical galaxies at the center of cool-core clusters, a.k.a BCGs (brightest cluster galaxies), is key to our understanding of active galactic nucleus feedback, and of the impact of environmental and local effects on star formation. We investigate the contribution of the thermal radiation from the cooling flow surrounding BCGs to…
▽ More
The excitation of the filamentary gas structures surrounding giant elliptical galaxies at the center of cool-core clusters, a.k.a BCGs (brightest cluster galaxies), is key to our understanding of active galactic nucleus feedback, and of the impact of environmental and local effects on star formation. We investigate the contribution of the thermal radiation from the cooling flow surrounding BCGs to the excitation of the filaments. We explore the effects of small levels of extra-heating (turbulence), and of metallicity, on the optical and infrared lines. Using the Cloudy code, we model the photoionization and photodissociation of a slab of gas of optical depth AV{\leq}30mag at constant pressure, in order to calculate self-consistently all of the gas phases, from ionized gas to molecular gas. The ionizing source is the EUV and soft X-ray radiation emitted by the cooling gas. We test these models comparing their predictions to the rich multi-wavelength observations, from optical to submillimeter. These models reproduce most of the multi-wavelength spectra observed in the nebulae surrounding the BCGs, not only the LINER-like optical diagnostics: [O iii]λ 5007 Å/H\b{eta}, [N ii]λ 6583 Å/Hα and ([S ii]λ 6716 Å+[S ii]λ 6731 Å)/Hα but also the infrared emission lines from the atomic gas. The modeled ro-vib H2 lines also match observations, which indicates that near and mid-IR H2 lines are mostly excited by collisions between H2 molecules and secondary electrons produced naturally inside the cloud by the interaction between the X-rays and the cold gas in the filament. However, there is still some tension between ionized and molecular line tracers (i.e. CO), which requires to optimize the cloud structure and the density of the molecular zone.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Dense gas formation and destruction in a simulated Perseus-like galaxy cluster with spin-driven black hole feedback
Authors:
R. S. Beckmann,
Y. Dubois,
P. Guillard,
P. Salome,
V. Olivares,
F. Polles,
C. Cadiou,
F. Combes,
S. Hamer,
M. D. Lehnert,
G. Pineau des Forets
Abstract:
Extended filamentary H$α$ emission nebulae are a striking feature of nearby galaxy clusters but the formation mechanism of the filaments, and the processes which shape their morphology remain unclear. We conduct an investigation into the formation, evolution and destruction of dense gas in the center of a simulated, Perseus-like, cluster under the influence of a spin-driven jet. We particularly st…
▽ More
Extended filamentary H$α$ emission nebulae are a striking feature of nearby galaxy clusters but the formation mechanism of the filaments, and the processes which shape their morphology remain unclear. We conduct an investigation into the formation, evolution and destruction of dense gas in the center of a simulated, Perseus-like, cluster under the influence of a spin-driven jet. We particularly study the role played by condensation of dense gas from the diffuse intracluster medium, and the impact of direct uplifting of existing dense gas by the jets, in determining the spatial distribution and kinematics of the dense gas. We present a hydrodynamical simulation of an idealised Perseus-like cluster using the adaptive mesh refinement code {\sc ramses}. Our simulation includes a supermassive black hole (SMBH) that self-consistently tracks its spin evolution via its local accretion, and in turn drives a large-scale jet whose direction is based on the black hole's spin evolution. We show that the formation and destruction of dense gas is closely linked to the SMBH's feedback cycle, and that its morphology is highly variable throughout the simulation. While extended filamentary structures readily condense from the hot intra-cluster medium, they are easily shattered into an overly clumpy distribution of gas during their interaction with the jet driven outflows. Condensation occurs predominantly onto infalling gas located 5 - 15 kpc from the center during quiescent phases of the central AGN, when the local ratio of the cooling time to free fall time falls below 20, i.e. when $t_{\rm cool}/t_{\rm ff} < 20$. We find evidence for both condensation and uplifting of dense gas, but caution that purely hydrodynamical simulations struggle to effectively regulate the cluster cooling cycle and produce overly clumpy distributions of dense gas morphologies, compared to observation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019; v1 submitted 3 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Driving massive molecular gas flows in central cluster galaxies with AGN feedback
Authors:
H. R. Russell,
B. R. McNamara,
A. C. Fabian,
P. E. J. Nulsen,
F. Combes,
A. C. Edge,
M. Madar,
V. Olivares,
P. Salome,
A. N. Vantyghem
Abstract:
We present an analysis of new and archival ALMA observations of molecular gas in twelve central cluster galaxies. We examine emerging trends in molecular filament morphology and gas velocities to understand their origins. Molecular gas masses in these systems span $10^9-10^{11}\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, far more than most gas-rich galaxies. ALMA images reveal a distribution of morphologies from filament…
▽ More
We present an analysis of new and archival ALMA observations of molecular gas in twelve central cluster galaxies. We examine emerging trends in molecular filament morphology and gas velocities to understand their origins. Molecular gas masses in these systems span $10^9-10^{11}\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$, far more than most gas-rich galaxies. ALMA images reveal a distribution of morphologies from filamentary to disk-dominated structures. Circumnuclear disks on kiloparsec scales appear rare. In most systems, half to nearly all of the molecular gas lies in filamentary structures with masses of a few $\times10^{8-10}\mathrm{M}_{\odot}$ that extend radially several to several tens of kpc. In nearly all cases the molecular gas velocities lie far below stellar velocity dispersions, indicating youth, transience or both. Filament bulk velocities lie far below the galaxy's escape and free-fall speeds indicating they are bound and being decelerated. Most extended molecular filaments surround or lie beneath radio bubbles inflated by the central AGN. Smooth velocity gradients found along the filaments are consistent with gas flowing along streamlines surrounding these bubbles. Evidence suggests most of the molecular clouds formed from low entropy X-ray gas that became thermally unstable and cooled when lifted by the buoyant bubbles. Uplifted gas will stall and fall back to the galaxy in a circulating flow. The distribution in morphologies from filament to disk-dominated sources therefore implies slowly evolving molecular structures driven by the episodic activity of the AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2019; v1 submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Ubiquitous cold and massive filaments in cool core clusters
Authors:
V. Olivares,
P. Salomé,
F. Combes,
S. Hamer,
P. Guillard,
M. D. Lehnert,
F. Polles,
R. S. Beckmann,
Y. Dubois,
M. Donahue,
A. Edge,
A. C. Fabian,
B. McNamara,
T. Rose,
H. Russell,
G. Tremblay,
A. Vantyghem,
R. E. A. Canning,
G. Ferland,
B. Godard,
M. Hogan,
S. Peirani,
G. Pineau des Forets
Abstract:
Multi-phase filamentary structures around Brightest Cluster Galaxies are likely a key step of AGN-feedback. We observed molecular gas in 3 cool cluster cores: Centaurus, Abell S1101, and RXJ1539.5 and gathered ALMA and MUSE data for 12 other clusters. Those observations show clumpy, massive and long, 3--25 kpc, molecular filaments, preferentially located around the radio bubbles inflated by the AG…
▽ More
Multi-phase filamentary structures around Brightest Cluster Galaxies are likely a key step of AGN-feedback. We observed molecular gas in 3 cool cluster cores: Centaurus, Abell S1101, and RXJ1539.5 and gathered ALMA and MUSE data for 12 other clusters. Those observations show clumpy, massive and long, 3--25 kpc, molecular filaments, preferentially located around the radio bubbles inflated by the AGN (Active Galactic Nucleus). Two objects show nuclear molecular disks. The optical nebula is certainly tracing the warm envelopes of cold molecular filaments. Surprisingly, the radial profile of the H$α$/CO flux ratio is roughly constant for most of the objects, suggesting that (i) between 1.2 to 7 times more cold gas could be present and (ii) local processes must be responsible for the excitation. Projected velocities are between 100--400 km s$^{-1}$, with disturbed kinematics and sometimes coherent gradients. This is likely due to the mixing in projection of several thin unresolved filaments. The velocity fields may be stirred by turbulence induced by bubbles, jets or merger-induced sloshing. Velocity and dispersions are low, below the escape velocity. Cold clouds should eventually fall back and fuel the AGN. We compare the filament's radial extent, r$_{fil}$, with the region where the X-ray gas can become thermally unstable. The filaments are always inside the low-entropy and short cooling time region, where t$_{cool}$/t$_{ff}$<20 (9 of 13 sources). The range t$_{cool}$/t$_{ff}$, 8-23 at r$_{fil}$, is likely due to (i) a more complex gravitational potential affecting the free-fall time (e.g., sloshing, mergers); (ii) the presence of inhomogeneities or uplifted gas in the ICM, affecting the cooling time. For some of the sources, r$_{fil}$ lies where the ratio of the cooling time to the eddy-turnover time, t$_{cool}$/t$_{eddy}$, is approximately unity.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Cold gas in a complete sample of group-dominant early-type galaxies
Authors:
E. O'Sullivan,
F. Combes,
P. Salomé,
L. P. David,
A. Babul,
J. M. Vrtilek,
J. Lim,
V. Olivares,
S. Raychaudhury,
G. Schellenberger
Abstract:
We present IRAM 30m and APEX telescope observations of CO(1-0) and CO(2-1) lines in 36 group-dominant early-type galaxies, completing our molecular gas survey of dominant galaxies in the Complete Local-volume Groups Sample. We detect CO emission in 12 of the galaxies at >4sigma significance, with molecular gas masses in the range 0.01-6x10^8 Msol, as well as CO in absorption in the non-dominant gr…
▽ More
We present IRAM 30m and APEX telescope observations of CO(1-0) and CO(2-1) lines in 36 group-dominant early-type galaxies, completing our molecular gas survey of dominant galaxies in the Complete Local-volume Groups Sample. We detect CO emission in 12 of the galaxies at >4sigma significance, with molecular gas masses in the range 0.01-6x10^8 Msol, as well as CO in absorption in the non-dominant group member galaxy NGC 5354. In total 21 of the 53 CLoGS dominant galaxies are detected in CO and we confirm our previous findings that they have low star formation rates (0.01-1 Msol/yr) but short depletion times (<1Gyr) implying rapid replenishment of their gas reservoirs. Comparing molecular gas mass with radio luminosity, we find that a much higher fraction of our group-dominant galaxies (60+-16%) are AGN-dominated than is the case for the general population of ellipticals, but that there is no clear connection between radio luminosity and the molecular gas mass. Using data from the literature, we find that at least 27 of the 53 CLoGS dominant galaxies contain HI, comparable to the fraction of nearby non-cluster early type galaxies detected in HI and significantly higher that the fraction in the Virgo cluster. We see no correlation between the presence of an X-ray detected intra-group medium and molecular gas in the dominant galaxy, but find that the HI-richest galaxies are located in X-ray faint groups. Morphological data from the literature suggests the cold gas component most commonly takes the form of a disk, but many systems show evidence of galaxy-galaxy interactions, indicating that they may have acquired their gas through stripping or mergers. We provide improved molecular gas mass estimates for two galaxies previously identified as being in the centres of cooling flows, NGC 4636 and NGC 5846, and find that they are relatively molecular gas poor compared to our other detected systems.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2018; v1 submitted 24 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Discovery of a diffuse optical line emitting halo in the core of the Centaurus cluster of galaxies: Line emission outside the protection of the filaments
Authors:
S. L. Hamer,
A. C. Fabian,
H. R. Russell,
P. Salomé,
F. Combes,
V. Olivares,
F. L. Polles,
A. C. Edge,
R. S. Beckmann
Abstract:
We present the discovery of diffuse optical line emission in the Centaurus cluster seen with the MUSE IFU. The unparalleled sensitivity of MUSE allows us to detect the faint emission from these structures which extend well beyond the bounds of the previously known filaments. Diffuse structures (emission surrounding the filaments, a northern shell and an extended Halo) are detected in many lines ty…
▽ More
We present the discovery of diffuse optical line emission in the Centaurus cluster seen with the MUSE IFU. The unparalleled sensitivity of MUSE allows us to detect the faint emission from these structures which extend well beyond the bounds of the previously known filaments. Diffuse structures (emission surrounding the filaments, a northern shell and an extended Halo) are detected in many lines typical of the nebulae in cluster cores ([NII]$_{λ6548\&6583}$ ,[SII]$_{λ6716\&6731}$, [OI]$_{λ6300}$, [OIII]$_{λ4959\&5007}$ etc.) but are more than an order of magnitude fainter than the filaments, with the faint halo only detected through the brightest line in the spectrum ([NII]$_{λ6583}$). These structures are shown to be kinematically distinct from the stars in the central galaxy and have different physical and excitation states to the filaments. Possible origins are discussed for each structure in turn and we conclude that shocks and/or pressure imbalances are resulting in gas dispersed throughout the cluster core, formed from either disrupted filaments or direct cooling, which is not confined to the bright filaments.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2019; v1 submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Spatially Resolved Spectroscopy of Sub-mm Galaxies at z~2
Authors:
V. Olivares,
E. Treister,
G. C. Privon,
S. Alaghband-Zadeh,
Caitlin M. Casey,
K. Schawinski,
P. Kurczynski,
E. Gawiser,
N. Nagar,
S. Chapman,
F. E. Bauer,
D. Sanders
Abstract:
We present near-infrared integral-field spectroscopic observations targeting H$α$ in eight sub-millimeter galaxies (SMGs) at $z$=1.3-2.5 using VLT/SINFONI, obtaining significant detections for six of them. The star formation rates derived from the H$α$ emission are $\sim$100 M$_\odot$yr$^{-1}$, which account for only $\sim$ 20-30\% of the infrared-derived values, thus suggesting that these systems…
▽ More
We present near-infrared integral-field spectroscopic observations targeting H$α$ in eight sub-millimeter galaxies (SMGs) at $z$=1.3-2.5 using VLT/SINFONI, obtaining significant detections for six of them. The star formation rates derived from the H$α$ emission are $\sim$100 M$_\odot$yr$^{-1}$, which account for only $\sim$ 20-30\% of the infrared-derived values, thus suggesting that these systems are very dusty. Two of these systems present [NII]/H$α$ ratios indicative of the presence of an Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN). We mapped the spatial distribution and kinematics of the star forming regions in these galaxies on kpc-scales. In general, the H$α$ morphologies tend to be highly irregular and/or clumpy, showing spatial extents of $\sim$3-11~kpc. We find evidence for significant spatial offsets, of $\sim$0.1-0.4$"$ or 1.2-3.4 kpc, between the H$α$ and the continuum emission in three of the sources. Performing a kinemetry analysis we conclude that the majority of the sample is not consistent with disk-like rotation-dominated kinematics. Instead, they tend to show irregular and/or clumpy and turbulent velocity and velocity dispersion fields. This can be interpreted as evidence for scenario in which these extreme star formation episodes are triggered by galaxy-galaxy interactions and major mergers. In contrast to recent results for SMGs, these sources appear to follow the same relations between gas and star forming rate densities as less luminous and/or normal star forming galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
