-
Unveiling a 36 Billion Solar Mass Black Hole at the Centre of the Cosmic Horseshoe Gravitational Lens
Authors:
Carlos R. Melo-Carneiro,
Thomas E. Collett,
Lindsay J. Oldham,
Wolfgang J. R. Enzi,
Cristina Furlanetto,
Ana L. Chies-Santos
Abstract:
Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are found at the centre of every massive galaxy, with their masses tightly connected to their host galaxies through a co-evolution over cosmic time. For massive ellipticals, the SMBH mass ($M_\text{BH}$) strongly correlates with the central stellar velocity dispersion ($σ_e$), via the $M_\text{BH}-σ_e$ relation. However, SMBH mass measurements have traditionally re…
▽ More
Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are found at the centre of every massive galaxy, with their masses tightly connected to their host galaxies through a co-evolution over cosmic time. For massive ellipticals, the SMBH mass ($M_\text{BH}$) strongly correlates with the central stellar velocity dispersion ($σ_e$), via the $M_\text{BH}-σ_e$ relation. However, SMBH mass measurements have traditionally relied on central stellar dynamics in nearby galaxies ($z < 0.1$), limiting our ability to explore the SMBHs across cosmic time. In this work, we present a self-consistent analysis combining 2D stellar dynamics and lens modelling of the Cosmic Horseshoe gravitational lens system ($z = 0.44$), one of the most massive galaxies ever observed. Using integral-field spectroscopic data from MUSE and high-resolution imaging from HST, we model the radial arc and stellar kinematics, constraining the galaxy's central mass distribution and SMBH mass. Bayesian model comparison yields a $5σ$ detection of an ultramassive black hole (UMBH) with $\log_{10}(M_\text{BH}/M_{\odot}) = 10.56^{+0.07}_{-0.08} \pm (0.12)^\text{sys}$, consistent across various systematic tests. Our findings place the Cosmic Horseshoe $\sim$$1.5σ$ above the $M_\text{BH}-σ_e$ relation, supporting an emerging trend observed in BGCs and other massive galaxies. This suggests a steeper $M_\text{BH}-σ_e$ relationship at the highest masses, potentially driven by a different co-evolution of SMBHs and their host galaxies. Future surveys will uncover more radial arcs, enabling the detection of SMBHs over a broader redshift and mass range. These discoveries will further refine our understanding of the $M_\text{BH}-σ_e$ relation and its evolution across cosmic time.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2025; v1 submitted 19 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Euclid: A complete Einstein ring in NGC 6505
Authors:
C. M. O'Riordan,
L. J. Oldham,
A. Nersesian,
T. Li,
T. E. Collett,
D. Sluse,
B. Altieri,
B. Clément,
K. Vasan G. C.,
S. Rhoades,
Y. Chen,
T. Jones,
C. Adami,
R. Gavazzi,
S. Vegetti,
D. M. Powell,
J. A. Acevedo Barroso,
I. T. Andika,
R. Bhatawdekar,
A. R. Cooray,
G. Despali,
J. M. Diego,
L. R. Ecker,
A. Galan,
P. Gómez-Alvarez
, et al. (173 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report the discovery of a complete Einstein ring around the elliptical galaxy NGC 6505, at $z=0.042$. This is the first strong gravitational lens discovered in Euclid and the first in an NGC object from any survey. The combination of the low redshift of the lens galaxy, the brightness of the source galaxy ($I_\mathrm{E}=18.1$ lensed, $I_\mathrm{E}=21.3$ unlensed), and the completeness of the ri…
▽ More
We report the discovery of a complete Einstein ring around the elliptical galaxy NGC 6505, at $z=0.042$. This is the first strong gravitational lens discovered in Euclid and the first in an NGC object from any survey. The combination of the low redshift of the lens galaxy, the brightness of the source galaxy ($I_\mathrm{E}=18.1$ lensed, $I_\mathrm{E}=21.3$ unlensed), and the completeness of the ring make this an exceptionally rare strong lens, unidentified until its observation by Euclid. We present deep imaging data of the lens from the Euclid Visible Camera (VIS) and Near-Infrared Spectrometer and Photometer (NISP) instruments, as well as resolved spectroscopy from the Keck Cosmic Web Imager (KCWI). The Euclid imaging in particular presents one of the highest signal-to-noise ratio optical/near-infrared observations of a strong gravitational lens to date. From the KCWI data we measure a source redshift of $z=0.406$. Using data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) we measure a velocity dispersion for the lens galaxy of $σ_\star=303\pm15\,\mathrm{kms}^{-1}$. We model the lens galaxy light in detail, revealing angular structure that varies inside the Einstein ring. After subtracting this light model from the VIS observation, we model the strongly lensed images, finding an Einstein radius of 2.5 arcsec, corresponding to $2.1\,\mathrm{kpc}$ at the redshift of the lens. This is small compared to the effective radius of the galaxy, $R_\mathrm{eff}\sim 12.3\,\mathrm{arcsec}$. Combining the strong lensing measurements with analysis of the spectroscopic data we estimate a dark matter fraction inside the Einstein radius of $f_\mathrm{DM} = (11.1_{-3.5}^{+5.4})\%$ and a stellar initial mass-function (IMF) mismatch parameter of $α_\mathrm{IMF} = 1.26_{-0.08}^{+0.05}$, indicating a heavier-than-Chabrier IMF in the centre of the galaxy.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Stars as cosmic scales: measuring stellar mass with microlensed supernovae
Authors:
Luke Weisenbach,
Thomas Collett,
Wolfgang Enzi,
Lindsay Oldham,
Ana Sainz de Murieta
Abstract:
Gravitational microlensing is a unique probe of the stellar content in strong lens galaxies. Flux ratio anomalies from gravitationally lensed supernovae (glSNe), just like lensed quasars, can be used to constrain the stellar mass fractions at the image positions. Type Ia supernovae are of particular interest as knowledge of the intrinsic source brightness helps constrain the amount of (de)magnific…
▽ More
Gravitational microlensing is a unique probe of the stellar content in strong lens galaxies. Flux ratio anomalies from gravitationally lensed supernovae (glSNe), just like lensed quasars, can be used to constrain the stellar mass fractions at the image positions. Type Ia supernovae are of particular interest as knowledge of the intrinsic source brightness helps constrain the amount of (de)magnification from the macromodel predictions that might be due to microlensing. In addition, the presence or absence of caustic crossings in the light curves of glSNe can be used to constrain the mass of the microlenses. We find that a sample of 50 well-modeled glSNe Ia systems with single epoch observations at peak intrinsic supernova luminosity should be able to constrain an average stellar mass-to-light ratio to within $\sim 15\%$. A set of systems with light curve level information providing the location (or absence) of caustic crossing events can also constrain the mass of the microlenses to within $\sim 50\%$. Much work is needed to make such a measurement in practice, but our results demonstrate the feasibility of microlensing to place constraints on astrophysical parameters related to the initial mass function of lensing galaxies without any prior assumptions on the stellar mass.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2025; v1 submitted 3 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Correcting for Selection Biases in the Determination of the Hubble Constant from Time-Delay Cosmography
Authors:
Tian Li,
Thomas E. Collett,
Philip J. Marshall,
Sydney Erickson,
Wolfgang Enzi,
Lindsay Oldham,
Daniel Ballard
Abstract:
The time delay between multiple images of strongly lensed quasars has been used to infer the Hubble constant. The primary systematic uncertainty for time-delay cosmography is the mass-sheet transform (MST), which preserves the lensing observables while altering the inferred $H_0$. The TDCOSMO collaboration used velocity dispersion measurements of lensed quasars and lensed galaxies to infer that ma…
▽ More
The time delay between multiple images of strongly lensed quasars has been used to infer the Hubble constant. The primary systematic uncertainty for time-delay cosmography is the mass-sheet transform (MST), which preserves the lensing observables while altering the inferred $H_0$. The TDCOSMO collaboration used velocity dispersion measurements of lensed quasars and lensed galaxies to infer that mass sheets are present, which decrease the inferred $H_0$ by 8$\%$. Here, we test the assumption that the density profiles of galaxy-galaxy and galaxy-quasar lenses are the same. We use a composite star-plus-dark-matter mass profile for the parent deflector population and model the selection function for galaxy-galaxy and galaxy-quasar lenses. We find that a power-law density profile with an MST is a good approximation to a two-component mass profile around the Einstein radius, but we find that galaxy-galaxy lenses have systematically higher mass-sheet components than galaxy-quasar lenses. For individual systems, $λ_\mathrm{int}$ correlates with the ratio of the half-light radius and Einstein radius of the lens. By propagating these results through the TDCOSMO methodology, we find that $H_0$ is lowered by a further $\sim$3\%. Using the velocity dispersions from \citet{slacs9} and our fiducial model for selection biases, we infer $H_0 = 66\pm4 \ \mathrm{(stat)} \pm 1 \ \mathrm{(model \ sys)} \pm 2 \ \mathrm{(measurement \ sys)} \ \mathrm{km} \ \mathrm{s}^{-1} \ \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1}$ for the TDCOSMO plus SLACS dataset. The first residual systematic error is due to plausible alternative choices in modeling the selection function, and the second is an estimate of the remaining systematic error in the measurement of velocity dispersions for SLACS lenses. Accurate time-delay cosmography requires precise velocity dispersion measurements and accurate calibration of selection biases.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2025; v1 submitted 21 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Project Dinos II: Redshift evolution of dark and luminous matter density profiles in strong-lensing elliptical galaxies across $0.1 < z < 0.9$
Authors:
William Sheu,
Anowar J. Shajib,
Tommaso Treu,
Alessandro Sonnenfeld,
Simon Birrer,
Michele Cappellari,
Lindsay J. Oldham,
Chin Yi Tan
Abstract:
We present a new measurement of the dark and luminous matter distribution of massive elliptical galaxies, and their evolution with redshift, by combining strong lensing and dynamical observables. Our sample of 56 lens galaxies covers a redshift range of $0.090 \leq z_{\rm l} \leq 0.884$. By combining new Hubble Space Telescope imaging with previously observed velocity dispersion and line-of-sight…
▽ More
We present a new measurement of the dark and luminous matter distribution of massive elliptical galaxies, and their evolution with redshift, by combining strong lensing and dynamical observables. Our sample of 56 lens galaxies covers a redshift range of $0.090 \leq z_{\rm l} \leq 0.884$. By combining new Hubble Space Telescope imaging with previously observed velocity dispersion and line-of-sight measurements, we decompose the luminous matter profile from the dark matter profile and perform a Bayesian hierarchical analysis to constrain the population-level properties of both profiles. We find that the inner slope of the dark matter density profile ("cusp"; $ρ_{\rm DM} \propto r^{-γ_{\rm in}}$) is consistent ($μ_{γ_{\rm in}}=0.97^{+0.03}_{-0.03}$ with $\leq0.07$ intrinsic scatter) with a standard Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW; $γ_{\rm in}=1$) at $z=0.35$. Additionally, we find an appreciable evolution with redshift ($d\log(γ_{\rm in})/dz=-0.44^{+0.14}_{-0.15}$) resulting in a shallower slope (of $> 2 σ$ tension from NFW) at redshifts $z \ge 0.49$. This is in excellent agreement with previous population-level observational studies, as well as with predictions from hydrodynamical simulations such as IllustrisTNG. We also find the stellar mass-to-light ratio at the population level is consistent with that of a Salpeter initial mass function, a small stellar mass-to-light gradient ($κ_{*}(r)\propto r^{-η}$, with $\overlineη \leq 5 \times 10^{-5}$), and isotropic stellar orbits. Our averaged total mass density profile is consistent with a power-law profile within 0.25 to 4 Einstein radii ($\overlineγ = 2.24 \pm 0.14$), with an internal mass-sheet transformation parameter $\overlineλ = 0.96 \pm 0.03$ consistent with no mass sheet. Our findings confirm the validity of the standard mass models used for time-delay cosmography.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2025; v1 submitted 19 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
A precise extragalactic test of General Relativity
Authors:
Thomas E. Collett,
Lindsay J. Oldham,
Russell J. Smith,
Matthew W. Auger,
Kyle B. Westfall,
David Bacon,
Robert C. Nichol,
Karen L. Masters,
Kazuya Koyama,
Remco van den Bosch
Abstract:
Einstein's theory of gravity, General Relativity, has been precisely tested on Solar System scales, but the long-range nature of gravity is still poorly constrained. The nearby strong gravitational lens, ESO 325-G004, provides a laboratory to probe the weak-field regime of gravity and measure the spatial curvature generated per unit mass, $γ$. By reconstructing the observed light profile of the le…
▽ More
Einstein's theory of gravity, General Relativity, has been precisely tested on Solar System scales, but the long-range nature of gravity is still poorly constrained. The nearby strong gravitational lens, ESO 325-G004, provides a laboratory to probe the weak-field regime of gravity and measure the spatial curvature generated per unit mass, $γ$. By reconstructing the observed light profile of the lensed arcs and the observed spatially resolved stellar kinematics with a single self-consistent model, we conclude that $γ= 0.97 \pm 0.09$ at 68% confidence. Our result is consistent with the prediction of 1 from General Relativity and provides a strong extragalactic constraint on the weak-field metric of gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Dark matter contraction and stellar-mass-to-light ratio gradients in massive early-type galaxies
Authors:
Lindsay Oldham,
Matthew Auger
Abstract:
We present models for the dark and luminous mass structure of 12 strong lensing early-type galaxies (ETGs). We combine pixel-based modelling of multiband HST/ACS imaging with Jeans modelling of kinematics obtained from Keck/ESI spectra to disentangle the dark and luminous contributions to the mass. Assuming a gNFW profile for the dark matter halo and a spatially constant stellar-mass-to-light rati…
▽ More
We present models for the dark and luminous mass structure of 12 strong lensing early-type galaxies (ETGs). We combine pixel-based modelling of multiband HST/ACS imaging with Jeans modelling of kinematics obtained from Keck/ESI spectra to disentangle the dark and luminous contributions to the mass. Assuming a gNFW profile for the dark matter halo and a spatially constant stellar-mass-to-light ratio $Υ_{\star}$ for the baryonic mass, we infer distributions for $Υ_{\star}$ consistent with IMFs that are heavier than the Milky Way's (with a global mean mismatch parameter relative to a Chabrier IMF $μ_{αc} = 1.80 \pm 0.14$) and halo inner density slopes which span a large range but are generally cuspier than the dark-matter-only prediction ($μ_{γ'} = 2.01_{-0.22}^{+0.19}$). We investigate possible reasons for overestimating the halo slope, including the neglect of spatially varying stellar-mas-to-light ratios and/or stellar orbital anisotropy, and find that a quarter of the systems prefer radially declining stellar-mass-to-light ratio gradients, but that the overall effect on our inference on the halo slope is small. We suggest a coherent explanation of these results in the context of inside-out galaxy growth, and that the relative importance of different baryonic processes in shaping the dark halo may depend on halo environment.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2018; v1 submitted 5 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Galaxy structure from multiple tracers: III. Radial variations in M87's IMF
Authors:
Lindsay Oldham,
Matthew Auger
Abstract:
We present the first constraints on stellar mass-to-light ratio gradients in an early-type galaxy (ETG) using multiple dynamical tracer populations to model the dark and luminous mass structure simultaneously. We combine the kinematics of the central starlight, two globular cluster populations and satellite galaxies in a Jeans analysis to obtain new constraints on M87's mass structure, employing a…
▽ More
We present the first constraints on stellar mass-to-light ratio gradients in an early-type galaxy (ETG) using multiple dynamical tracer populations to model the dark and luminous mass structure simultaneously. We combine the kinematics of the central starlight, two globular cluster populations and satellite galaxies in a Jeans analysis to obtain new constraints on M87's mass structure, employing a flexible mass model which allows for radial gradients in the stellar mass-to-light ratio. We find that, in the context of our model, a radially declining stellar-mass-to-light ratio is strongly favoured. Modelling the stellar mass-to-light ratio as following a power law, $Υ_{\star} \sim R^{-μ}$, we infer a power-law slope $μ= -0.54 \pm 0.05$; equally, parameterising the stellar-mass-to-light ratio via a central mismatch parameter relative to a Salpeter IMF, $α$, and scale radius $R_M$, we find $α> 1.48$ at $95\%$ confidence and $R_M = 0.35 \pm 0.04$ kpc. We use stellar population modelling of high-resolution 11-band HST photometry to show that such a steep gradient cannot be achieved by variations in only the metallicity, age, dust extinction and star formation history if the stellar initial mass function (IMF) remains spatially constant. On the other hand, the stellar mass-to-light ratio gradient that we find is consistent with an IMF whose inner slope changes such that it is Salpeter-like in the central $\sim 0.5$ kpc and becomes Chabrier-like within the stellar effective radius. This adds to recent evidence that the non-universality of the IMF in ETGs may be confined to their core regions, and points towards a picture in which the stars in these central regions may have formed in fundamentally different physical conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Discovery of three strongly lensed quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
Authors:
Peter R. Williams,
Adriano Agnello,
Tommaso Treu,
Louis E. Abramson,
Timo Anguita,
Yordanka Apostolovski,
Geoff C. -F. Chen,
Christopher D. Fassnacht,
J. -W. Hsueh,
Veronica Motta,
Lindsay Oldham,
Karina Rojas,
Christian E. Rus,
Anowar J. Shajib,
Xin Wang
Abstract:
We present the discovery of 3 quasar lenses in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), selected using two novel photometry-based selection techniques. The J0941+0518 system, with two point sources separated by 5.46" on either side of a galaxy, has source and lens redshifts $z_s = 1.54$ and $z_l = 0.343$. The AO-assisted images of J2211+1929 show two point sources separated by 1.04", corresponding to…
▽ More
We present the discovery of 3 quasar lenses in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), selected using two novel photometry-based selection techniques. The J0941+0518 system, with two point sources separated by 5.46" on either side of a galaxy, has source and lens redshifts $z_s = 1.54$ and $z_l = 0.343$. The AO-assisted images of J2211+1929 show two point sources separated by 1.04", corresponding to the same quasar at $z_s = 1.07,$ besides the lens galaxy and Einstein ring. Images of J2257+2349 show two point sources separated by 1.67" on either side of an E/S0 galaxy. The extracted spectra show two images of the same quasar at redshift $z_s = 2.10$. In total, the two selection techniques identified 309 lens candidates, including 47 known lenses, and 6 previously ruled out candidates. 55 of the remaining candidates were observed using NIRC2 and ESI at Keck Observatory, EFOSC2 at the ESO-NTT (La Silla), and SAM and the Goodman spectrograph at SOAR. Of the candidates observed, 3 were confirmed as lenses, 36 were ruled out, and 16 remain inconclusive. Taking into account that we recovered known lenses, this gives us a success rate of at least 50/309 (16%). This initial campaign demonstrates the power of purely photometric selection techniques in finding lensed quasars. Developing and refining these techniques is essential for efficient identification of these rare lenses in ongoing and future photometric surveys.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
SHARP - IV. An apparent flux ratio anomaly resolved by the edge-on disc in B0712+472
Authors:
J. -W. Hsueh,
L. Oldham,
C. Spingola,
S. Vegetti,
C. D. Fassnacht,
M. W. Auger,
L. V. E. Koopmans,
J. P. McKean,
D. J. Lagattuta
Abstract:
Flux ratio anomalies in quasar lenses can be attributed to dark matter substructure surrounding the lensing galaxy and, thus, used to constrain the substructure mass fraction. Previous applications of this approach infer a substructure abundance that potentially in tension with the predictions of a $Λ$CDM cosmology. However, the assumption that all flux ratio anomalies are due to substructure is a…
▽ More
Flux ratio anomalies in quasar lenses can be attributed to dark matter substructure surrounding the lensing galaxy and, thus, used to constrain the substructure mass fraction. Previous applications of this approach infer a substructure abundance that potentially in tension with the predictions of a $Λ$CDM cosmology. However, the assumption that all flux ratio anomalies are due to substructure is a strong one, and alternative explanations have not been fully investigated. Here, we use new high-resolution near-IR Keck~II adaptive optics imaging for the lens system CLASS B0712+472 to perform pixel-based lens modelling for this system and, in combination with new VLBA radio observations, show that the inclusion of the disc in the lens model can explain the flux ratio anomalies without the need for dark matter substructures. The projected disc mass comprises 16% of the total lensing mass within the Einstein radius and the total disc mass is $1.79 \times 10^{10} M_{sun}$. The case of B0712+472 adds to the evidence that not all flux ratio anomalies are due to dark subhaloes, and highlights the importance of taking the effects of baryonic structures more fully into account in order to obtain an accurate measure of the substructure mass fraction.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2017; v1 submitted 23 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
The fundamental plane of evolving red nuggets
Authors:
Lindsay Oldham,
Matt Auger,
Chris Fassnacht,
Tommaso Treu,
L. V. E. Koopmans,
David Lagattuta,
John McKean,
Simona Vegetti
Abstract:
We present an exploration of the mass structure of a sample of 12 strongly lensed massive, compact early-type galaxies at redshifts $z\sim0.6$ to provide further possible evidence for their inside-out growth. We obtain new ESI/Keck spectroscopy and infer the kinematics of both lens and source galaxies, and combine these with existing photometry to construct (a) the fundamental plane (FP) of the so…
▽ More
We present an exploration of the mass structure of a sample of 12 strongly lensed massive, compact early-type galaxies at redshifts $z\sim0.6$ to provide further possible evidence for their inside-out growth. We obtain new ESI/Keck spectroscopy and infer the kinematics of both lens and source galaxies, and combine these with existing photometry to construct (a) the fundamental plane (FP) of the source galaxies and (b) physical models for their dark and luminous mass structure. We find their FP to be tilted towards the virial plane relative to the local FP, and attribute this to their unusual compactness, which causes their kinematics to be totally dominated by the stellar mass as opposed to their dark matter; that their FP is nevertheless still inconsistent with the virial plane implies that both the stellar and dark structure of early-type galaxies is non-homologous. We also find the intrinsic scatter of their FP to be comparable to the local value, indicating that variations in the stellar mass structure outweight variations in the dark halo in the central regions of early-type galaxies. Finally, we show that inference on the dark halo structure -- and, in turn, the underlying physics -- is sensitive to assumptions about the stellar initial mass function (IMF), but that physically-motivated assumptions about the IMF imply haloes with sub-NFW inner density slopes, and may present further evidence for the inside-out growth of compact early-type galaxies via minor mergers and accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Red nuggets grow inside-out: evidence from gravitational lensing
Authors:
Lindsay Oldham,
Matt Auger,
Chris Fassnacht,
Tommaso Treu,
Brendon J. Brewer,
L. V. E. Koopmans,
David Lagattuta,
Philip Marshall,
John McKean,
Simona Vegetti
Abstract:
We present a new sample of strong gravitational lens systems where both the foreground lenses and background sources are early-type galaxies. Using imaging from HST/ACS and Keck/NIRC2, we model the surface brightness distributions and show that the sources form a distinct population of massive, compact galaxies at redshifts $0.4 \lesssim z \lesssim 0.7$, lying systematically below the size-mass re…
▽ More
We present a new sample of strong gravitational lens systems where both the foreground lenses and background sources are early-type galaxies. Using imaging from HST/ACS and Keck/NIRC2, we model the surface brightness distributions and show that the sources form a distinct population of massive, compact galaxies at redshifts $0.4 \lesssim z \lesssim 0.7$, lying systematically below the size-mass relation of the global elliptical galaxy population at those redshifts. These may therefore represent relics of high-redshift red nuggets or their partly-evolved descendants. We exploit the magnifying effect of lensing to investigate the structural properties, stellar masses and stellar populations of these objects with a view to understanding their evolution. We model these objects parametrically and find that they generally require two Sérsic components to properly describe their light profiles, with one more spheroidal component alongside a more envelope-like component, which is slightly more extended though still compact. This is consistent with the hypothesis of the inside-out growth of these objects via minor mergers. We also find that the sources can be characterised by red-to-blue colour gradients as a function of radius which are stronger at low redshift -- indicative of ongoing accretion -- but that their environments generally appear consistent with that of the general elliptical galaxy population, contrary to recent suggestions that these objects are predominantly associated with clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
The most massive galaxies in clusters are already fully grown at $z \sim 0.5$
Authors:
L. J. Oldham,
R. C. W. Houghton,
Roger L. Davies
Abstract:
By constructing scaling relations for galaxies in the massive cluster MACSJ0717.5 at $z=0.545$ and comparing with those of Coma, we model the luminosity evolution of the stellar populations and the structural evolution of the galaxies. We calculate magnitudes, surface brightnesses and effective radii using HST/ACS images and velocity dispersions using Gemini/GMOS spectra, and present a catalogue o…
▽ More
By constructing scaling relations for galaxies in the massive cluster MACSJ0717.5 at $z=0.545$ and comparing with those of Coma, we model the luminosity evolution of the stellar populations and the structural evolution of the galaxies. We calculate magnitudes, surface brightnesses and effective radii using HST/ACS images and velocity dispersions using Gemini/GMOS spectra, and present a catalogue of our measurements for 17 galaxies. We also generate photometric catalogues for $\sim 3000$ galaxies from the HST imaging. With these, we construct the colour-magnitude relation, the fundamental plane, the mass-to-light versus mass relation, the mass-size relation and the mass-velocity dispersion relation for both clusters. We present a new, coherent way of modelling these scaling relations simultaneously using a simple physical model in order to infer the evolution in luminosity, size and velocity dispersion as a function of redshift, and show that the data can be fully accounted for with this model. We find that (a) the evolution in size and velocity dispersion undergone by these galaxies between $z \sim 0.5$ and $z \sim 0$ is mild, with $R_e(z) \sim (1+z)^{-0.40\pm0.32}$ and $σ(z) \sim (1+z)^{0.09 \pm 0.27}$, and (b) the stellar populations are old, $\sim 10$ Gyr, with a $\sim 3$ Gyr dispersion in age, and are consistent with evolving purely passively since $z \sim 0.5$ with $Δ\log M/L_B = -0.55_{-0.07}^{+0.15} z$. The implication is that these galaxies formed their stars early and subsequently grew dissipationlessly so as to have their mass already in place by $z \sim 0.5$, and suggests a dominant role for dry mergers, which may have accelerated the growth in these high-density cluster environments.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Is there substructure around M87?
Authors:
L. J. Oldham,
N. W. Evans
Abstract:
We present a general method to identify infalling substructure in discrete datasets with position and line-of-sight velocity data. We exploit the fact that galaxies falling onto a brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) in a virialised cluster, or dwarf satellites falling onto a central galaxy like the Milky Way, follow nearly radial orbits. If the orbits are exactly radial, we show how to find the probabi…
▽ More
We present a general method to identify infalling substructure in discrete datasets with position and line-of-sight velocity data. We exploit the fact that galaxies falling onto a brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) in a virialised cluster, or dwarf satellites falling onto a central galaxy like the Milky Way, follow nearly radial orbits. If the orbits are exactly radial, we show how to find the probability distribution for a satellite's energy, given a tracer density for the satellite population, by solving an Abel integral equation. This is an extension of Eddington (1916)'s classical formula for the isotropic distribution function. When applied to a system of galaxies, clustering in energy space can then be quantified using the Kullback-Leibler divergence, and groups of objects can be identified which, though separated in the sky, may be falling in on the same orbit. This method is tested using mock data and applied to the satellite galaxy population around M87, the BCG in Virgo, and a number of associations are found which may represent infalling galaxy groups.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2016; v1 submitted 8 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Galaxy structure from multiple tracers: II. M87 from parsec to megaparsec scales
Authors:
L. J. Oldham,
M. W. Auger
Abstract:
Following a number of conflicting studies of M87's mass profile, we undertake a dynamical analysis of multiple tracer populations to constrain its mass over a large radius range. We combine stellar kinematics in the central regions with the dynamics of 612 globular clusters out to 200 kpc and satellite galaxies extending to scales comparable with the virial radius. Using a spherical Jeans analysis…
▽ More
Following a number of conflicting studies of M87's mass profile, we undertake a dynamical analysis of multiple tracer populations to constrain its mass over a large radius range. We combine stellar kinematics in the central regions with the dynamics of 612 globular clusters out to 200 kpc and satellite galaxies extending to scales comparable with the virial radius. Using a spherical Jeans analysis, we are able to disentangle the mass contributions from the dark and baryonic components and set constraints on the structure of each. Assuming isotropy, we explore four different models for the dark matter halo and find that a centrally-cored dark matter distribution is preferred. We infer a stellar mass-to-light ratio $Υ_{\star,v} = 6.9 \pm 0.1$ -- consistent with a Salpeter-like IMF -- and a core radius $r_c = 67 \pm 20$ kpc. We then introduce anisotropy and find that, while the halo remains clearly cored, the radial stellar anisotropy has a strong impact on both $Υ_{\star,v}$ and the core's radius; here we find $Υ_{\star,v} = 3.50_{-0.36}^{+0.32}$ -- consistent with a Chabrier-like IMF -- and $r_c = 19.00_{-8.34}^{+8.38}$ kpc. Thus the presence of a core at the centre of the dark halo is robust against anisotropy assumptions, while the stellar mass and core size are not. We are able to reconcile previously discrepant studies by showing that modelling the globular cluster data alone leads to the very different inference of a super-NFW cusp, thus highlighting the value of multiple-population modelling, and we point to the possible role of M87's AGN and the cluster environment in forming the central dark matter core.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Galaxy structure from multiple tracers: I. A census of M87's globular cluster populations
Authors:
L. J. Oldham,
M. W. Auger
Abstract:
We present a new photometric catalogue of the rich globular cluster (GC) system around M87, the brightest cluster galaxy in Virgo. Using archival Next Generation Virgo cluster Survey (NGVS) images in the ugriz bands, observed with CFHT/MegaPrime, we perform a careful subtraction of the galaxy's halo light in order to detect objects at small galactocentric radii as well as in the wider field, and f…
▽ More
We present a new photometric catalogue of the rich globular cluster (GC) system around M87, the brightest cluster galaxy in Virgo. Using archival Next Generation Virgo cluster Survey (NGVS) images in the ugriz bands, observed with CFHT/MegaPrime, we perform a careful subtraction of the galaxy's halo light in order to detect objects at small galactocentric radii as well as in the wider field, and find 17620 GC candidates over a radius range from 1.3 kpc to 445 kpc with g < 24 magnitudes. By inferring their colour, radial and magnitude distributions in a Bayesian way, we find that they are well described as a mixture of two GC populations and two distinct contaminant populations, but confirm earlier findings of radius-dependent colour gradients in both GC populations. This is consistent with a picture in which the more enriched GCs reside deeper in the galaxy's potential well, indicating a role for dissipative collapse in the formation of both the red and the blue GCs.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
