-
Orbit injection of planet-crossing asteroids
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Solar system Centaurs originate in transneptunian space from where planet orbit crossing events inject their orbits inside the giant planets' domain. Here, we examine this injection process in the three-body problem by studying the orbital evolution of transneptunian asteroids located at Neptune's collision singularity as a function of the Tisserand invariant, T. Two injection modes are found, one…
▽ More
Solar system Centaurs originate in transneptunian space from where planet orbit crossing events inject their orbits inside the giant planets' domain. Here, we examine this injection process in the three-body problem by studying the orbital evolution of transneptunian asteroids located at Neptune's collision singularity as a function of the Tisserand invariant, T. Two injection modes are found, one for T>0.1, or equivalently prograde inclinations far from the planet, where unstable motion dominates injection, and another for T<= 0.1, or equivalently polar and retrograde inclinations far from the planet, where stable motion dominates injection. The injection modes are independent of the initial semi-major axis and the dynamical time at the collision singularity. The simulations uncovered a region in the polar corridor where the dynamical time exceeds the solar system's age suggesting the possibility of long-lived primordial polar transneptunian reservoirs that supply Centaurs to the giant planets' domain.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
On retrograde orbits, resonances and stability
Authors:
M. H. M. Morais,
F. Namouni
Abstract:
We start by reviewing our previous work on retrograde orbital configurations and on modeling and identifying retrograde resonances. Then, we present new results regarding the enhanced stability of retrograde configurations with respect to prograde configurations in the low mass ratio regime of the planar circular restricted 3-body problem. Motivated by the recent discovery of small bodies which ar…
▽ More
We start by reviewing our previous work on retrograde orbital configurations and on modeling and identifying retrograde resonances. Then, we present new results regarding the enhanced stability of retrograde configurations with respect to prograde configurations in the low mass ratio regime of the planar circular restricted 3-body problem. Motivated by the recent discovery of small bodies which are in retrograde resonance with the Solar System's giant planets we then explore the case with mass ratio 0.001 and show new stability maps in a grid of semi-major axis versus eccentricity for the 2/1 and 1/2 retrograde resonances. Finally, we explain how the stability borders of the 2/1 and 1/2 retrograde resonances are related to the resonant orbits' geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Inclination pathways of planet-crossing asteroids
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Long-term statistical simulations of the past evolution of high-inclination Centaurs showed that their orbits tend to be polar with respect to the solar system's invariable plane over a large semi-major axis range in trans-neptunian space. Here, we lay the analytical foundation of the study of the inclination pathways of planet-crossing asteroids that explains these findings. We show that the Tiss…
▽ More
Long-term statistical simulations of the past evolution of high-inclination Centaurs showed that their orbits tend to be polar with respect to the solar system's invariable plane over a large semi-major axis range in trans-neptunian space. Here, we lay the analytical foundation of the study of the inclination pathways of planet-crossing asteroids that explains these findings. We show that the Tisserand relation partitions the inclination-semi-major axis parameter space of the three-body problem into distinct regions depending on the asteroid's Tisserand parameter T or equivalently its orbital inclination I_infinity far from the planet. The Tisserand relation shows that asteroids with I_infinity > 110 deg. (T < -1) cannot be injected inside the planet's orbit. Injection onto retrograde orbits and high-inclination prograde orbits occurs inside the inclination corridor 45 deg. < I_infinity < 110 deg. (-1< T < 2). Inclination dispersion across the inclination pathway for moderate and high inclinations is explained by the secular perturbations from the planet and is smallest for polar orbits. When a planet-crossing asteroid temporarily leaves the inclination pathway, its long term evolution still depends on its Tisserand parameter as evidenced by its eccentricity dispersion. Simulations of asteroid orbits using the equations of motion with Neptune as the perturbing planet confirm these results for moderate to high inclinations, forward and backward in time because the Tisserand relation is time independent. The Tisserand inclination pathways will provide important constraints on comet delivery from the outer solar system as well as on the possible presence of unknown planets in trans-neptunian space.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2022; v1 submitted 21 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
A study of the 1/2 retrograde resonance: Periodic orbits and resonant capture
Authors:
M. H. M. Morais,
F. Namouni,
G. Voyatzis,
T. Kotoulas
Abstract:
We describe the families of periodic orbits in the 2-dimensional 1/2 retrograde resonance at mass ratio 0.001, analyzing their stability and bifurcations into 3-dimensional periodic orbits. We explain the role played by periodic orbits in adiabatic resonance capture, in particular how the proximity between a stable family and an unstable family with a nearly critical segment, associated with Kozai…
▽ More
We describe the families of periodic orbits in the 2-dimensional 1/2 retrograde resonance at mass ratio 0.001, analyzing their stability and bifurcations into 3-dimensional periodic orbits. We explain the role played by periodic orbits in adiabatic resonance capture, in particular how the proximity between a stable family and an unstable family with a nearly critical segment, associated with Kozai separatrices, determines the transition between distinct resonant modes observed in numerical simulations. Combining the identification of stable, critical and unstable periodic orbits with analytical modeling, resonance capture simulations and computation of stability maps helps to unveil the complex 3-dimensional structure of resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2021; v1 submitted 12 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
On the interstellar origin of high-inclination Centaurs
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
Following our identification of the probable interstellar origin of high-inclination Centaurs, Morbidelli et al. (2020) issued a rebuttal criticizing our methods and conclusions. Here, we show that the criticism is unfounded. Entropy's increase in the past is not an obstacle to accessing the statistical properties of Centaur past orbits as entropic expansion occurs around a time-independent conser…
▽ More
Following our identification of the probable interstellar origin of high-inclination Centaurs, Morbidelli et al. (2020) issued a rebuttal criticizing our methods and conclusions. Here, we show that the criticism is unfounded. Entropy's increase in the past is not an obstacle to accessing the statistical properties of Centaur past orbits as entropic expansion occurs around a time-independent conserved quantity that explains the probable orbits' clustering in parameter space, known as the polar corridor. The Copernican principle does not imply that unstable motion does not exist in the solar system. It clarifies the meaning of the dynamical lifetime ensuring that Centaurs originating in the planetesimal disc are able to return to it in the time-backward simulation. Our conclusions are supported by published independent research that shows conventional disc relaxation models do not explain the abundance of high inclination Centaurs and that enrichment from the interstellar medium is required. Future physical observations of the identified Centaurs and TNOs are likely to reveal the similarities and differences between solar system-born and interstellar origin Centaurs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
An interstellar origin for high-inclination Centaurs
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Helena Morais
Abstract:
We investigate the possible origins of real high-inclination Centaurs and trans-neptunian objects using a high-resolution statistical search for stable orbits that simulates their evolution back in time to the epoch when planet formation ended 4.5 billion years in the past. The simulation is a precise orbit determination method that does not involve ad hoc initial conditions or assumptions such as…
▽ More
We investigate the possible origins of real high-inclination Centaurs and trans-neptunian objects using a high-resolution statistical search for stable orbits that simulates their evolution back in time to the epoch when planet formation ended 4.5 billion years in the past. The simulation is a precise orbit determination method that does not involve ad hoc initial conditions or assumptions such as those found in planetesimal disk relaxation models upon which their conclusions depend. It can therefore be used to independently test origin theories based on relaxation models by examining the past orbits of specific real objects. Here, we examined 17 multiple-opposition high-inclination Centaurs and the two polar trans-neptunian objects 2008 KV42 and (471325) 2011 KT19. The statistical distributions show that their orbits were nearly polar 4.5 Gyr in the past, and were located in the scattered disk and inner Oort cloud regions. Early polar inclinations cannot be accounted for by current Solar system formation theory as the early planetesimal system must have been nearly flat in order to explain the low-inclination asteroid and Kuiper belts. Furthermore, the early scattered disk and inner Oort cloud regions are believed to have been devoid of Solar system material as the planetesimal disk could not have extended far beyond Neptune's current orbit in order to halt the planet's outward migration. The nearly polar orbits of high-inclination Centaurs 4.5 Gyr in the past therefore indicate their probable early capture from the interstellar medium.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Resonance libration and width at arbitrary inclination
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Helena Morais
Abstract:
We apply the analytical disturbing function for arbitrary inclination derived in our previous work to characterize resonant width and libration of mean motion resonances at arbitrary inclination obtained from direct numerical simulations of the three-body problem. We examine the 2:1 and 3:1 inner Jupiter and 1:2 and 1:3 outer Neptune resonances and their possible asymmetric librations using a new…
▽ More
We apply the analytical disturbing function for arbitrary inclination derived in our previous work to characterize resonant width and libration of mean motion resonances at arbitrary inclination obtained from direct numerical simulations of the three-body problem. We examine the 2:1 and 3:1 inner Jupiter and 1:2 and 1:3 outer Neptune resonances and their possible asymmetric librations using a new analytical pendulum model of resonance that includes the simultaneous libration of multiple arguments and their second harmonics. The numerically-derived resonance separatrices are obtained using the Mean Exponential Growth factor of Nearby Orbits (MEGNO chaos indicator). We find that the analytical and numerical estimates are in agreement and that resonance width is determined by the first few fundamental resonance modes that librate simultaneously on the resonant timescale. Our results demonstrate that the new pendulum model may be used to ascertain resonance width analytically, and more generally, that the disturbing function for arbitrary inclination is a powerful analytical tool that describes resonance dynamics of low as well as high inclination asteroids in the solar system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Periodic orbits of the retrograde coorbital problem
Authors:
M H M Morais,
F Namouni
Abstract:
Asteroid (514107) Kaepaokaawela is the first example of an object in the 1/1 mean motion resonance with Jupiter with retrograde motion around the Sun. Its orbit was shown to be stable over the age of the Solar System which implies that it must have been captured from another star when the Sun was still in its birth cluster. Kaepaokaawela orbit is also located at the peak of the capture probability…
▽ More
Asteroid (514107) Kaepaokaawela is the first example of an object in the 1/1 mean motion resonance with Jupiter with retrograde motion around the Sun. Its orbit was shown to be stable over the age of the Solar System which implies that it must have been captured from another star when the Sun was still in its birth cluster. Kaepaokaawela orbit is also located at the peak of the capture probability in the coorbital resonance. Identifying the periodic orbits that Kaepaokaawela and similar asteroids followed during their evolution is an important step towards precisely understanding their capture mechanism. Here, we find the families of periodic orbits in the two-dimensional retrograde coorbital problem and analyze their stability and bifurcations into three-dimensional periodic orbits. Our results explain the radical differences observed in 2D and 3D coorbital capture simulations. In particular, we find that analytical and numerical results obtained for planar motion are not always valid at infinitesimal deviations from the plane.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
An interstellar origin for Jupiter's retrograde co-orbital asteroid
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
Asteroid (514107) 2015 BZ509 was discovered recently in Jupiter's co-orbital region with a retrograde motion around the Sun. The known chaotic dynamics of the outer Solar System have so far precluded the identification of its origin. Here, we perform a high-resolution statistical search for stable orbits and show that asteroid (514107) 2015 BZ509 has been in its current orbital state since the for…
▽ More
Asteroid (514107) 2015 BZ509 was discovered recently in Jupiter's co-orbital region with a retrograde motion around the Sun. The known chaotic dynamics of the outer Solar System have so far precluded the identification of its origin. Here, we perform a high-resolution statistical search for stable orbits and show that asteroid (514107) 2015 BZ509 has been in its current orbital state since the formation of the Solar System. This result indicates that (514107) 2015 BZ509 was captured from the interstellar medium 4.5 billion years in the past as planet formation models cannot produce such a primordial large-inclination orbit with the planets on nearly-coplanar orbits interacting with a coplanar debris disk that must produce the low-inclination small-body reservoirs of the Solar System such as the asteroid and Kuiper belts. This result also implies that more extrasolar asteroids are currently present in the Solar System on nearly-polar orbits.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
The disturbing function for asteroids with arbitrary inclinations
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
The classical disturbing function of the three-body problem widely used in planetary dynamics studies is an expansion of the gravitational interaction of the three-body problem with respect to zero eccentricity and zero inclination. This restricts its validity to nearly coplanar orbits. Motivated by the dynamical study of asteroids, Centaurs and transneptunian objects with arbitrary inclinations,…
▽ More
The classical disturbing function of the three-body problem widely used in planetary dynamics studies is an expansion of the gravitational interaction of the three-body problem with respect to zero eccentricity and zero inclination. This restricts its validity to nearly coplanar orbits. Motivated by the dynamical study of asteroids, Centaurs and transneptunian objects with arbitrary inclinations, we derive a series expansion of the gravitational interaction with respect to an arbitrary reference inclination that generalises our work on the polar and retrograde disturbing functions. The new disturbing function, like the polar one, may model any resonance as expansion order is unrelated to resonance order. The powers of eccentricity and inclination of the force amplitude of a $p$:$q$ resonance depend only on the parity of the resonance order $|p-q|$. Disturbing functions with non zero reference inclinations are thus physically different from the classical disturbing function as the former are based on the three-dimensional three-body problem and the latter on the two-dimensional one. We illustrate the use of the new disturbing function by showing that what is known as pure eccentricity resonances are intrinsically dependent on inclination contrary to the prediction of the classical disturbing function. We determine the inclination dependence of the resonance widths of the 2:1 and 3:1 prograde and retrograde inner resonances with Jupiter as well as those of the asymmetric librations of the 1:2 and 1:3 prograde outer resonances with Neptune.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
First transneptunian object in polar resonance with Neptune
Authors:
M. H. M. Morais,
F. Namouni
Abstract:
Capture in mean motion resonance has been observed in the Solar System for small objects with prograde as well as retrograde orbits of moderate inclinations. However, no example of an object with a nearly polar orbit was known to be in resonance with a planet. In this Letter, we report that the nearly-polar transneptunian object (471325), nicknamed Niku, is in a 7:9 resonance with Neptune, with a…
▽ More
Capture in mean motion resonance has been observed in the Solar System for small objects with prograde as well as retrograde orbits of moderate inclinations. However, no example of an object with a nearly polar orbit was known to be in resonance with a planet. In this Letter, we report that the nearly-polar transneptunian object (471325), nicknamed Niku, is in a 7:9 resonance with Neptune, with a mean lifetime in resonance of 16 +- 11 million years. While entrance and exit in the 7:9 resonance is caused by close encounters with Neptune the resonant configuration provides a temporary protection mechanism against disruptive close encounters with this planet. The other nearly polar transneptunian objects do not seem to be in resonance with the planets with the possible exception of 2008 KV42, also known as Drac, that has a small chance of being in the 8:13 resonance with Neptune.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
The disturbing function for polar Centaurs and transneptunian objects
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
The classical disturbing function of the three-body problem is based on an expansion of the gravitational interaction in the vicinity of nearly coplanar orbits. Consequently, it is not suitable for the identification and study of resonances of the Centaurs and transneptunian objects on nearly polar orbits with the solar system planets. Here, we provide a series expansion algorithm of the gravitati…
▽ More
The classical disturbing function of the three-body problem is based on an expansion of the gravitational interaction in the vicinity of nearly coplanar orbits. Consequently, it is not suitable for the identification and study of resonances of the Centaurs and transneptunian objects on nearly polar orbits with the solar system planets. Here, we provide a series expansion algorithm of the gravitational interaction in the vicinity of polar orbits and produce explicitly the disturbing function to fourth order in eccentricity and inclination cosine. The properties of the polar series differ significantly from those of the classical disturbing function: the polar series can model any resonance as the expansion order is not related to the resonance order. The powers of eccentricity and inclination of the force amplitude of a $p$:$q$ resonance do not depend on the value of the resonance order $|p-q|$ but only on its parity. Thus all even resonance order eccentricity amplitudes are $\propto e^2$ and odd ones $\propto e$ to lowest order in eccentricity $e$. With the new findings on the structure of the polar disturbing function and the possible resonant critical arguments, we illustrate the dynamics of the polar resonances 1:3, 3:1, 2:9 and 7:9 where transneptunian object 471325 could currently be locked.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Coorbital capture at arbitrary inclination
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Helena Morais
Abstract:
The process of capture in the coorbital region of a solar system planet is studied. Absolute capture likelihood in the 1:1 resonance is determined by randomly constructed statistical ensembles numbering $7.24\times 10^5$ of massless asteroids that are set to migrate radially from the outer to the inner boundaries of the coorbital region of a Jupiter-mass planet. Orbital states include coorbital ca…
▽ More
The process of capture in the coorbital region of a solar system planet is studied. Absolute capture likelihood in the 1:1 resonance is determined by randomly constructed statistical ensembles numbering $7.24\times 10^5$ of massless asteroids that are set to migrate radially from the outer to the inner boundaries of the coorbital region of a Jupiter-mass planet. Orbital states include coorbital capture, ejection, collisions with the Sun and the planet and free-crossing of the coorbital region. The relative efficiency of retrograde capture with respect to prograde capture is confirmed as an intrinsic property of the coorbital resonance. Half the asteroids cross the coorbital region regardless of eccentricity and for any inclination less than $120^\circ$. We also find that the recently discovered retrograde coorbital of Jupiter, asteroid 2015 BZ509, lies almost exactly at the capture efficiency peak associated with its orbital parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Resonance capture at arbitrary inclination: II. Effect of the radial drift rate
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
The effect of radial drift rate on mean motion resonance capture is studied for prograde, polar and retrograde orbits. We employ the numerical framework of our earlier exploration of resonance capture at arbitrary inclination. Randomly constructed samples of massless particles are set to migrate radially from outside the orbit of a Jupiter-mass planet at different drift rates totalling more than…
▽ More
The effect of radial drift rate on mean motion resonance capture is studied for prograde, polar and retrograde orbits. We employ the numerical framework of our earlier exploration of resonance capture at arbitrary inclination. Randomly constructed samples of massless particles are set to migrate radially from outside the orbit of a Jupiter-mass planet at different drift rates totalling more than $1.6\times 10^6$ numerical simulations. Slower drift rates reduce overall capture probability especially for prograde orbits and enhance capture at specific initial inclinations of high order resonances such as the outer 1:5, 1:4, 1:3, 2:5, 3:7 and 5:7. Global capture is reduced with increasing eccentricity at all inclinations as high order resonances capture more particles that are subsequently lost by disruptive close encounters with the planet. The relative efficiency of retrograde resonances at long-lived capture with respect to prograde resonances is explained by the reduced effect of planet encounters as such events occur with a shorter duration and a higher relative velocity for retrograde motion. Capture in the coorbital 1:1 resonance is marginally affected by the radial drift rate except for nearly coplanar retrograde eccentric orbits whose capture likelihood is increased significantly with slower drift rates. An unexpected finding is the presence of a dynamical corridor for capture in high order inner prograde resonances with initial inclinations in the range [50$^\circ$,80$^\circ$] especially at the inner 5:2 resonance whose capture likelihood peaks at 80% to 90% depending on initial eccentricity.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
A numerical investigation of coorbital stability and libration in three dimensions
Authors:
Maria Helena M. Morais,
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Motivated by the dynamics of resonance capture, we study numerically the coorbital resonance for inclination180 >=I>=0 in the circular restricted three-body problem. We examine the similarities and differences between planar and three dimensional coorbital resonance capture and seek their origin in the stability of coorbital motion at arbitrary inclination. After we present stability maps of the p…
▽ More
Motivated by the dynamics of resonance capture, we study numerically the coorbital resonance for inclination180 >=I>=0 in the circular restricted three-body problem. We examine the similarities and differences between planar and three dimensional coorbital resonance capture and seek their origin in the stability of coorbital motion at arbitrary inclination. After we present stability maps of the planar prograde and retrograde coorbital resonances, we characterize the new coorbital modes in three dimensions. We see that retrograde mode I (R1) and mode II (R2) persist as we change the relative inclination, while retrograde mode III (R3) seems to exist only in the planar problem. A new coorbital mode (R4) appears in 3D which is a retrograde analogue to an horseshoe-orbit. The Kozai-Lidov resonance is active for retrograde orbits as well as prograde orbits and plays a key role in coorbital resonance capture. Stable coorbital modes exist at all inclinations, including retrograde and polar obits. This result confirms the robustness the coorbital resonance at large inclination and encourages the search for retrograde coorbital companions of the solar system's planets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Towards an interpretation of MOND as a modification of inertia
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
We explore the possibility that Milgrom's Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is a manifestation of the modification of inertia at small accelerations. Consistent with the Tully-Fisher relation, dynamics in the small acceleration domain may originate from a quartic (cubic) velocity-dependence of energy (momentum) whereas gravitational potentials remain linear with respect to mass. The natural frame…
▽ More
We explore the possibility that Milgrom's Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) is a manifestation of the modification of inertia at small accelerations. Consistent with the Tully-Fisher relation, dynamics in the small acceleration domain may originate from a quartic (cubic) velocity-dependence of energy (momentum) whereas gravitational potentials remain linear with respect to mass. The natural framework for this interpretation is Finsler geometry. The simplest static isotropic Finsler metric of a gravitating mass that incorporates the Tully-Fisher relation at small acceleration is associated with a spacetime interval that is either a homogeneous quartic root of polynomials of local displacements or a simple root of a rational fraction thereof. We determine the low energy gravitational equation and find that Finsler spacetimes that produce a Tully-Fisher relation require that the gravitational potential be modified. For an isolated mass, Newton's potential $Mr^{-1}$ is replaced by $Ma_0\log (r/r_0)$ where $a_0$ is MOND's acceleration scale and $r_0$ is a yet undetermined distance scale. Orbital energy is linear with respect to mass but angular momentum is proportional to $ M^{3/4}$. Asymptotic light deflection resulting from time curvature is similar to that of a singular isothermal sphere implying that space curvature must be the main source of deflection in static Finsler spacetimes possibly through the presence of the distance scale $r_0$ that appears in the asymptotic form of the gravitational potential. The quartic nature of the Finsler metric hints at the existence of an underlying area-metric that describes the effective structure of spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015; v1 submitted 2 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Michel Henon's first research article: An improved calculation of the perturbation of stellar velocities
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Fifteen years after the discovery of dynamical friction by Chandrasekhar, Michel Henon attempts to solve the longstanding problem of the divergence of the friction suffered by the perturber and caused by the most distant cluster stars. His solution laid the foundation to the current understanding of dynamical friction as a non-local transitory force.
Fifteen years after the discovery of dynamical friction by Chandrasekhar, Michel Henon attempts to solve the longstanding problem of the divergence of the friction suffered by the perturber and caused by the most distant cluster stars. His solution laid the foundation to the current understanding of dynamical friction as a non-local transitory force.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Resonance capture at arbitrary inclination
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Maria Helena Moreira Morais
Abstract:
Resonance capture is studied numerically in the three-body problem for arbitrary inclinations. Massless particles are set to drift from outside the 1:5 resonance with a Jupiter-mass planet thereby encountering the web of the planet's diverse mean motion resonances. Randomly constructed samples explore parameter space for inclinations from 0 to 180 deg with 5deg increments totalling nearly 6x10^5 n…
▽ More
Resonance capture is studied numerically in the three-body problem for arbitrary inclinations. Massless particles are set to drift from outside the 1:5 resonance with a Jupiter-mass planet thereby encountering the web of the planet's diverse mean motion resonances. Randomly constructed samples explore parameter space for inclinations from 0 to 180 deg with 5deg increments totalling nearly 6x10^5 numerical simulations. Thirty resonances internal and external to the planet's location are monitored. We find that retrograde resonances are unexpectedly more efficient at capture than prograde resonances and that resonance order is not necessarily a good indicator of capture efficiency at arbitrary inclination. Capture probability drops significantly at moderate sample eccentricity for initial inclinations in the range [10deg,110deg]. Orbit inversion is possible for initially circular orbits with inclinations in the range [60deg,130deg]. Capture in the 1:1 coorbital resonance occurs with great likelihood at large retrograde inclinations. The planet's orbital eccentricity, if larger than 0.1, reduces the capture probabilities through the action of the eccentric Kozai-Lidov mechanism. A capture asymmetry appears between inner and outer resonances as prograde orbits are preferentially trapped in inner resonances. The relative capture efficiency of retrograde resonance suggests that the dynamical lifetimes of Damocloids and Centaurs on retrograde orbits must be significantly larger than those on prograde orbits implying that the recently identified asteroids in retrograde resonance, 2006 BZ8, 2008 SO218, 2009 QY6 and 1999 LE31(Morais and Namouni, 2013, MNRAS 436, L30) may be among the oldest small bodies that wander between the outer giant planets.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Asteroids in retrograde resonance with Jupiter and Saturn
Authors:
M. H. M. Morais,
F. Namouni
Abstract:
We identify a set of asteroids among Centaurs and Damocloids, that orbit contrary to the common direction of motion in the Solar System and that enter into resonance with Jupiter and Saturn. Their orbits have inclinations I >= 140 deg and semi-major axes a < 15 AU. Two objects are currently in retrograde resonance with Jupiter: 2006 BZ8 in the 2/-5 resonance and 2008 SO218 in the 1/-2 resonance. O…
▽ More
We identify a set of asteroids among Centaurs and Damocloids, that orbit contrary to the common direction of motion in the Solar System and that enter into resonance with Jupiter and Saturn. Their orbits have inclinations I >= 140 deg and semi-major axes a < 15 AU. Two objects are currently in retrograde resonance with Jupiter: 2006 BZ8 in the 2/-5 resonance and 2008 SO218 in the 1/-2 resonance. One object, 2009 QY6, is currently in the 2/-3 retrograde resonance with Saturn. These are the first examples of Solar System objects in retrograde resonance. The present resonant configurations last for several thousand years. Brief captures in retrograde resonance with Saturn are also possible during the 20,000 years integration timespan, particularly in the 1/-1 resonance (2006 BZ8) and the 9/-7 resonance (1999 LE31).
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
-
Retrograde resonance in the planar three-body problem
Authors:
M. H. M. Morais,
F. Namouni
Abstract:
We continue the investigation of the dynamics of retrograde resonances initiated in Morais & Giuppone (2012). After deriving a procedure to deduce the retrograde resonance terms from the standard expansion of the three-dimensional disturbing function, we concentrate on the planar problem and construct surfaces of section that explore phase-space in the vicinity of the main retrograde resonances (2…
▽ More
We continue the investigation of the dynamics of retrograde resonances initiated in Morais & Giuppone (2012). After deriving a procedure to deduce the retrograde resonance terms from the standard expansion of the three-dimensional disturbing function, we concentrate on the planar problem and construct surfaces of section that explore phase-space in the vicinity of the main retrograde resonances (2/-1, 1/-1 and 1/-2). In the case of the 1/-1 resonance for which the standard expansion is not adequate to describe the dynamics, we develop a semi-analytic model based on numerical averaging of the unexpanded disturbing function, and show that the predicted libration modes are in agreement with the behavior seen in the surfaces of section.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2013; v1 submitted 30 April, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
The excitation of planetary orbits by stellar jet variability and polarity reversal
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Planets form in active protoplanetary disks that sustain stellar jets. Momentum loss from the jet system may excite the planets' orbital eccentricity and inclination (Namouni 2005, AJ 130, 280). Evaluating quantitatively the effects of such excitation requires a realistic modeling of the momentum loss profiles associated with stellar jets. In this work, we model linear momentum loss as a time-vari…
▽ More
Planets form in active protoplanetary disks that sustain stellar jets. Momentum loss from the jet system may excite the planets' orbital eccentricity and inclination (Namouni 2005, AJ 130, 280). Evaluating quantitatively the effects of such excitation requires a realistic modeling of the momentum loss profiles associated with stellar jets. In this work, we model linear momentum loss as a time-variable stochastic process that results in a zero mean stellar acceleration. Momentum loss may involve periodic or random polarity reversals. We characterize orbital excitation as a function of the variability timescale and identify a novel excitation resonance between a planet's orbital period and the jet's variability timescale where the former equals twice the latter. For constant variability timescales, resonance is efficient for both periodic and random polarity reversals, the latter being stronger than the former. For a time variable variability timescale, resonance crossing is a more efficient excitation mechanism when polarity reversals are periodic. Each polarity reversal type has distinct features that may help constrain the magnetic history of the star through the observation of its planetary companions. For instance, outward planet migration to large distances from parent stars is one of the natural outcomes of periodic polarity reversal excitation if resonance crossing is sufficiently slow. Applying the excitation mechanism to the solar system, we find that the planet-jet variability resonance with periodic polarity reversal momentum loss is a possible origin for the hitherto unexplained inclination of Jupiter's orbit by 6 deg. with respect to the Sun's equator.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2012; v1 submitted 7 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
The fate of moons of close-in giant exoplanets
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
We show that the fate of moons of a close-in giant planet is mainly determined by the migration history of the planet in the protoplanetary disk. As the planet migrates in the disk from beyond the snow line towards a multi-day period orbit, the formed and forming moons become unstable as the planet's sphere of influence shrinks. Disk-driven migration is faster than the moons' tidal orbital evoluti…
▽ More
We show that the fate of moons of a close-in giant planet is mainly determined by the migration history of the planet in the protoplanetary disk. As the planet migrates in the disk from beyond the snow line towards a multi-day period orbit, the formed and forming moons become unstable as the planet's sphere of influence shrinks. Disk-driven migration is faster than the moons' tidal orbital evolution. Moons are eventually ejected from around close-in exoplanets or forced into collision with them before tides from the star affect their orbits. If moons are detected around close-in exoplanets, they are unlikely to have been formed in situ, instead they were captured from the protoplanetary disk on retrograde orbits around the planets.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
On dynamical friction in a gaseous medium with a boundary
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Dynamical friction arises from the interaction of a perturber and the gravitational wake it excites in the ambient medium. We study the effects of the presence of a boundary on dynamical friction by studying analytically the interaction of perturber with uniform rectilinear motion in a uniform homogeneous medium with a reflecting planar boundary. Wake reflection at a medium's boundary may occur at…
▽ More
Dynamical friction arises from the interaction of a perturber and the gravitational wake it excites in the ambient medium. We study the effects of the presence of a boundary on dynamical friction by studying analytically the interaction of perturber with uniform rectilinear motion in a uniform homogeneous medium with a reflecting planar boundary. Wake reflection at a medium's boundary may occur at the edges of truncated disks perturbed by planetary or stellar companions as well as in numerical simulations of planet-disk interaction with no-outflow boundary conditions. In this paper, we show that the presence of the boundary modifies the behaviour of dynamical friction significantly. We find that perturbers are invariably pushed away from the boundary and reach a terminal subsonic velocity near Mach 0.37 regardless of initial velocity. Dynamical friction may even be reversed for Mach numbers less than 0.37 thereby accelerating instead of decelerating the perturber. Perturbers moving parallel to the boundary feel additional friction orthogonal to the direction of motion that is much stronger than the standard friction along the direction of motion. These results indicate that the common use of the standard Chandrasekhar formula as a short hand estimate of dynamical friction may be inadequate as observed in various numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2010; v1 submitted 25 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
Dynamical friction for accelerated motion in a gaseous medium
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Dynamical friction arises from the interaction of a perturber and the gravitational wake it excites in the ambient medium. This interaction is usually derived assuming that the perturber has a constant velocity. In realistic situations, motion is accelerated as for instance by dynamical friction itself. Here, we study the effect of acceleration on the dynamical friction force. We characterize th…
▽ More
Dynamical friction arises from the interaction of a perturber and the gravitational wake it excites in the ambient medium. This interaction is usually derived assuming that the perturber has a constant velocity. In realistic situations, motion is accelerated as for instance by dynamical friction itself. Here, we study the effect of acceleration on the dynamical friction force. We characterize the density enhancement associated with a constantly accelerating perturber with rectilinear motion in an infinite homogeneous gaseous medium and show that dynamical friction is not a local force and that its amplitude may depend on the perturber's initial velocity. The force on an accelerating perturber is maximal between Mach 1 and Mach 2, where it is smaller than the corresponding uniform motion friction. In the limit where the perturber's size is much smaller than the distance needed to change the Mach number by unity through acceleration, a subsonic perturber feels a force similar to uniform motion friction only if its past history does not include supersonic episodes. Once an accelerating perturber reaches large supersonic speeds, accelerated motion friction is marginally stronger than uniform motion friction. The force on a decelerating supersonic perturber is weaker than uniform motion friction as the velocity decreases to a few times the sound speed. Dynamical friction on a decelerating subsonic perturber with an initial Mach number larger than 2 is much larger than uniform motion friction and tends to a finite value as the velocity vanishes in contrast to uniform motion friction.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2009; v1 submitted 3 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Satellite dynamics on the Laplace surface
Authors:
Scott Tremaine,
Jihad Touma,
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
The orbital dynamics of most planetary satellites is governed by the quadrupole moment from the equatorial bulge of the host planet and the tidal field from the Sun. On the Laplace surface, the long-term orbital evolution driven by the combined effects of these forces is zero, so that orbits have a fixed orientation and shape. The "classical" Laplace surface is defined for circular orbits, and c…
▽ More
The orbital dynamics of most planetary satellites is governed by the quadrupole moment from the equatorial bulge of the host planet and the tidal field from the Sun. On the Laplace surface, the long-term orbital evolution driven by the combined effects of these forces is zero, so that orbits have a fixed orientation and shape. The "classical" Laplace surface is defined for circular orbits, and coincides with the planet's equator at small planetocentric distances and with its orbital plane at large distances. A dissipative circumplanetary disk should settle to this surface, and hence satellites formed from such a disk are likely to orbit in or near the classical Laplace surface. This paper studies the properties of Laplace surfaces. Our principal results are: (i) if the planetary obliquity exceeds 68.875 deg there is a range of semimajor axes in which the classical Laplace surface is unstable; (ii) at some obliquities and planetocentric distances there is a distinct Laplace surface consisting of nested eccentric orbits, which bifurcates from the classical Laplace surface at the point where instability sets in; (iii) there is also a "polar" Laplace surface perpendicular to the line of nodes of the planetary equator on the planetary orbit; (iv) for circular orbits, the polar Laplace surface is stable at small planetocentric distances and unstable at large distances; (v) at the onset of instability this polar Laplace surface bifurcates into two polar Laplace surfaces composed of nested eccentric orbits.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
On the integrability of stellar motion in an accelerated logarithmic potential
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Massimiliano Guzzo,
Elena Lega
Abstract:
An accelerated logarithmic potential models the mean motion of stars in a flat rotation curve galaxy that sustains a wind system. For stars outside the galactic wind launching region, the asymmetric removal of linear momentum by the wind is seen as a perturbing acceleration superimposed onto the galactic potential. We study the integrability of stellar motion in an accelerated logarithmic potent…
▽ More
An accelerated logarithmic potential models the mean motion of stars in a flat rotation curve galaxy that sustains a wind system. For stars outside the galactic wind launching region, the asymmetric removal of linear momentum by the wind is seen as a perturbing acceleration superimposed onto the galactic potential. We study the integrability of stellar motion in an accelerated logarithmic potential. We use surfaces of section of the dynamical system to probe the integrability of motion. We provide numerical evidence that motion in an accelerated logarithmic potential is non-integrable. Large scale chaotic diffusion occurs for lower values of the projected angular momentum along the direction of acceleration and persists at all values of the angular momentum in the outer part of the galaxy inside the truncation radius where the galactic acceleration balances the wind-induced acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2008; v1 submitted 14 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
The Accelerated Kepler Problem
Authors:
Fathi Namouni,
Massimiliano Guzzo
Abstract:
The accelerated Kepler problem is obtained by adding a constant acceleration to the classical two-body Kepler problem. This setting models the dynamics of a jet-sustaining accretion disk and its content of forming planets as the disk loses linear momentum through the asymmetric jet-counterjet system it powers. The dynamics of the accelerated Kepler problem is analyzed using physical as well as p…
▽ More
The accelerated Kepler problem is obtained by adding a constant acceleration to the classical two-body Kepler problem. This setting models the dynamics of a jet-sustaining accretion disk and its content of forming planets as the disk loses linear momentum through the asymmetric jet-counterjet system it powers. The dynamics of the accelerated Kepler problem is analyzed using physical as well as parabolic coordinates. The latter naturally separate the problem's Hamiltonian into two unidimensional Hamiltonians. In particular, we identify the origin of the secular resonance in the accelerated Kepler problem and determine analytically the radius of stability boundary of initially circular orbits that are of particular interest to the problem of radial migration in binary systems as well as to the truncation of accretion disks through stellar jet acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Origin theories for the eccentricities of extrasolar planets
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Half the known extrasolar planets have orbital eccentricities in excess of 0.3. Such large eccentricities are surprising as it is thought that planets form in a protoplanetary disk on nearly circular orbits much like the current states of the solar system planets. Possible explanations for the large planetary eccentricities include the perturbations that accompany planet-planet scattering, the t…
▽ More
Half the known extrasolar planets have orbital eccentricities in excess of 0.3. Such large eccentricities are surprising as it is thought that planets form in a protoplanetary disk on nearly circular orbits much like the current states of the solar system planets. Possible explanations for the large planetary eccentricities include the perturbations that accompany planet-planet scattering, the tidal interaction between the gas disk and the planets, Kozai's secular eccentricity cycles, the eccentricity excitation during planetary pair migration in mean motion resonance, the perturbations by stellar encounters, stellar-like relaxation that occurs if planets formed through gravitational instability, and the relative acceleration by the stellar jet system of the host star with respect to the companion. In this chapter, we comment on the relevance and characteristics of the various eccentricity origin theories.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
On the Flaring of Jet-sustaining Accretion Disks
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
Jet systems with two unequal components interact with their parent accretion disks through the asymmetric removal of linear momentum from the star-disk system. We show that as a result of this interaction, the disk's state of least energy is not made up of orbits that lie in a plane containing the star's equator as in a disk without a jet. The disk's profile has the shape of a sombrero curved in…
▽ More
Jet systems with two unequal components interact with their parent accretion disks through the asymmetric removal of linear momentum from the star-disk system. We show that as a result of this interaction, the disk's state of least energy is not made up of orbits that lie in a plane containing the star's equator as in a disk without a jet. The disk's profile has the shape of a sombrero curved in the direction of acceleration. For this novel state of minimum energy, we derive the temperature profile of thin disks. The flaring geometry caused by the sombrero profile increases the disk temperature especially in its outer regions. The jet-induced acceleration disturbs the vertical equilibrium of the disk leading to mass loss in the form of a secondary wind emanating from the upper face of the disk. Jet time variability causes the disk to radially expand or contract depending on whether the induced acceleration increases or decreases. Jet time variability also excites vertical motion and eccentric distortions in the disk and affects the sombrero profile's curvature. These perturbations lead to the heating of the disk through its viscous stresses as it tries to settle into the varying state of minimum energy. The jet-disk interaction studied here will help estimate the duration of the jet episode in star-disk systems and may explain the origin of the recently observed one-sided molecular outflow of the HH 30 disk-jet system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2007;
originally announced January 2007.
-
On the Origin of the Eccentricities of Extrasolar Planets
Authors:
Fathi Namouni
Abstract:
We develop a phenomenological theory that aims to account for the origin of the large eccentricities of extrasolar planets and that of the small eccentricities in the solar system, the preference for apsidal alignment in non-resonant multiplanet systems, and the origin of the similarities in the eccentricity distribution of extra-solar planets and that of spectroscopic binary stars. We show that…
▽ More
We develop a phenomenological theory that aims to account for the origin of the large eccentricities of extrasolar planets and that of the small eccentricities in the solar system, the preference for apsidal alignment in non-resonant multiplanet systems, and the origin of the similarities in the eccentricity distribution of extra-solar planets and that of spectroscopic binary stars. We show that if a physical process is weakly dependent on the local dynamics of the companion and imparts a small relative acceleration to the star-companion system, the eccentricity of the companion's orbit is excited to large values depending on the direction and duration of acceleration. A natural candidate for such processes are asymmetric stellar jets and star-disk winds. When the acceleration originates from a precessing jet, large eccentricities can be excited by the resonance of the jet's precession frequency with the induced acceleration's excitation frequency even for nearly perpendicular jets. Precession also reduces the eccentricity amplitude far inside the resonance radius. The acceleration's strength is best constrained in multiplanet systems because of the companions' mutual gravitational perturbations, while the acceleration's duration is bounded by the condition that the residual velocity imparted to the star is smaller than the stellar velocity dispersion in the Galaxy. In the outer parts of the star-companion system where the acceleration excitation time is comparable to or smaller than the orbital period, significant radial migration takes place which may have important consequences for the dynamics of the minor body populations in the solar system. The theory is illustrated with the $\upsilon$ Andromedae binary system.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
-
New coorbital dynamics in the solar system
Authors:
F. Namouni,
A. A. Christou,
C. D. Murray
Abstract:
Following the discovery that asteroid (3753) Cruithne was a coorbital companion of the Earth, a new theory of coorbital motion has been developed whereby planets or satellites can maintain companion objects in the same orbit as themselves. This has led to the prediction of hitherto unknown types of stable motion, all of which are seen in the evolution of specific near-Earth asteroids. The slow d…
▽ More
Following the discovery that asteroid (3753) Cruithne was a coorbital companion of the Earth, a new theory of coorbital motion has been developed whereby planets or satellites can maintain companion objects in the same orbit as themselves. This has led to the prediction of hitherto unknown types of stable motion, all of which are seen in the evolution of specific near-Earth asteroids. The slow diffusion of such objects through the Earth's coorbital region is shown to lead to temporary capture, suggesting the existence of undiscovered retrograde moons of the Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
