-
Second Response to the critique of "Cotton Gravity''
Authors:
R. A. Sussman,
C. A. Mantica,
L. G. Molinari,
S. Nájera
Abstract:
Clement and Noiucer submitted a note {\tt arXiv:2401.16008 [gr-qc]} replying to our criticism {\tt arXiv:2401.10479 [gr-qc]} of their previous submission. We reply to the contents of this note and remark that these authors have not addressed our arguments. This will be our last response to them. Readers are advised to look at all material and judge by themselves
Clement and Noiucer submitted a note {\tt arXiv:2401.16008 [gr-qc]} replying to our criticism {\tt arXiv:2401.10479 [gr-qc]} of their previous submission. We reply to the contents of this note and remark that these authors have not addressed our arguments. This will be our last response to them. Readers are advised to look at all material and judge by themselves
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Response to a critique of "Cotton Gravity"
Authors:
Roberto A Sussman,
Carlo Alberto Mantica,
Luca Guido Molinari,
Sebastián Nájera
Abstract:
We address in this article the criticism in a recently submitted article by Clement and Noiucer (arXiv:2312.17662 [gr-qc]) on "Cotton Gravity" (CG), a gravity theory alternative to General Relativity. These authors claim that CG is "not predictive" for producing "too many" spherically symmetric vacuum solutions, while taking the Bianchi I vacuum as test case they argue that geometric constraint on…
▽ More
We address in this article the criticism in a recently submitted article by Clement and Noiucer (arXiv:2312.17662 [gr-qc]) on "Cotton Gravity" (CG), a gravity theory alternative to General Relativity. These authors claim that CG is "not predictive" for producing "too many" spherically symmetric vacuum solutions, while taking the Bianchi I vacuum as test case they argue that geometric constraint on the Cotton tensor lead to an undetermined problem, concluding in the end that CG "is not a physical theory". We provide arguments showing that this critique is incorrect and misrepresents the theory.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024; v1 submitted 18 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Exact solutions of Cotton Gravity in its Codazzi formulation
Authors:
Roberto A Sussman,
Sebastian Najera
Abstract:
The "Codazzi formulation", based on a Codazzi tensor, provides a more robust and straightforward theoretical framework for "Cotton Gravity" (CG) than its original formulation in terms of the Cotton tensor. Using this formulation we provide a self-consistent procedure to generate non-trivial exact solutions in CG that generalize well known General Relativity (GR) solutions. We re-derive a known CG…
▽ More
The "Codazzi formulation", based on a Codazzi tensor, provides a more robust and straightforward theoretical framework for "Cotton Gravity" (CG) than its original formulation in terms of the Cotton tensor. Using this formulation we provide a self-consistent procedure to generate non-trivial exact solutions in CG that generalize well known General Relativity (GR) solutions. We re-derive a known CG solution that generalizes the Schwarzschild solution of GR, showing that it is the unique vacuum solution of static spherical symmetry in CG, extending this result to a CG generalization of the Reissner-Nordstrom solution of GR, all of which places a strong case supporting the fulfillment of Birkhoff's theorem. When applied to Friedman-Lema\^ıtre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models CG naturally identifies the $Λ$CDM model as the unique FLRW dust model with constant negative spatial curvature. We also obtain CG generalizations of the Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) and Szekeres dust solutions of GR, allowing for time and space dependent changes from decelerated to accelerated evolution, without necessarily assuming a dark energy source. The CG generalization of static perfect fluid spheres allows in the weak field regime to model the flattening of rotation velocities in spherical galactic systems without assuming dark matter. We also generalize non-static spherically symmetric perfect fluid solutions with a shear-free 4 velocity. Our results suggest the need for further research using the Codazzi formulation to explore the potential for applications of CG to current open problems in gravitational systems.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2024; v1 submitted 4 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Fab-Four cosmography to tackle the Hubble tension
Authors:
Celia Escamilla-Rivera,
José María de Albornoz-Caratozzolo,
Sebastián Nájera
Abstract:
In the context of the Fab-Four theory of gravity in a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker background, in this work we use the cosmography approach to study a particular self-tuning filter solution focused on a zero-curvature fixed point to study the $H_0$ tension. In this scheme, the equations restrict the universe's evolution to certain scenarios, including radiation-like expansion, matter-like e…
▽ More
In the context of the Fab-Four theory of gravity in a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker background, in this work we use the cosmography approach to study a particular self-tuning filter solution focused on a zero-curvature fixed point to study the $H_0$ tension. In this scheme, the equations restrict the universe's evolution to certain scenarios, including radiation-like expansion, matter-like expansion, and late-time acceleration. Furthermore, we build the cosmographic series of the Fab-Four theory to obtain the kinematic parameters as the Hubble constant $H_0$ and the deceleration parameter $q_0$ for all the scenarios mentioned. Finally, we compare our results to find that it is possible to alleviate the current discrepancy on $H_0$ by considering specific requirements on the free parameters of the Fab-Four theory through a self-tuning filter.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Inhomogeneous solutions in $f(T,B)$ gravity
Authors:
Sebastián Nájera,
Aram Aguilar,
Geovanny A. Rave-Franco,
Celia Escamilla-Rivera,
Roberto A. Sussman
Abstract:
In this paper we explore the possibility to find exact solutions for Teleparallel Gravity (TG) of the type of spherically symmetric Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) dust models. We apply to the LTB metric the formalism of Teleparallel Gravity in its extension to $f(T,B)$ models, which can be seen it as the analagous from the Schwarzschild solution in General Relativity. An exact LTB solution is obtai…
▽ More
In this paper we explore the possibility to find exact solutions for Teleparallel Gravity (TG) of the type of spherically symmetric Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) dust models. We apply to the LTB metric the formalism of Teleparallel Gravity in its extension to $f(T,B)$ models, which can be seen it as the analagous from the Schwarzschild solution in General Relativity. An exact LTB solution is obtained which is compatible with a specific $f(T,B)$ model whose observational constraints are cosmological viable in a standard spatially flat Robertson-Walker geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The first non-static inhomogeneous exact solution in $f(T,B)$ gravity
Authors:
Sebastián Nájera,
Aram Aguilar,
Celia Escamilla-Rivera,
Roberto A. Sussman
Abstract:
We examine in this paper the possibility of finding exact solutions for Teleparallel Gravity (TG) of the type of spherically symmetric Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) dust models. We apply to the LTB metric, as obtained from the Schwarzschild solution in General Relativity, the formalism of Teleparallel Gravity in its extension to $f(T,B)$ models. An exact LTB solution is obtained that is compatible…
▽ More
We examine in this paper the possibility of finding exact solutions for Teleparallel Gravity (TG) of the type of spherically symmetric Lema\^ıtre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) dust models. We apply to the LTB metric, as obtained from the Schwarzschild solution in General Relativity, the formalism of Teleparallel Gravity in its extension to $f(T,B)$ models. An exact LTB solution is obtained that is compatible with a specific $f(T,B)$ model that seems to be appropriate to fit observations when applied to standard spatially flat Robertson-Walker geometry.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
On Negative Mass Cosmology in General Relativity
Authors:
Sebastián Nájera,
Aldo Gamboa,
Alejandro Aguilar-Nieto,
Celia Escamilla-Rivera
Abstract:
In this Letter we present strong arguments in favour of thoroughly revising the negative mass cosmology (NMC), which has been proposed as a simple alternative explanation of dark energy and dark matter effects, within the framework of General Relativity. We show that there are various physical predictions in this model which require fine-tuning in order to make them compatible with current cosmolo…
▽ More
In this Letter we present strong arguments in favour of thoroughly revising the negative mass cosmology (NMC), which has been proposed as a simple alternative explanation of dark energy and dark matter effects, within the framework of General Relativity. We show that there are various physical predictions in this model which require fine-tuning in order to make them compatible with current cosmological surveys. In this way, the original motivation of the NMC model becomes obscured due to the imposition of fine-tuned unknown variables. We conclude that a more rigorous theoretical treatment is needed in order to make the NMC a viable cosmological model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2021; v1 submitted 23 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Non-comoving Cold Dark Matter in a $Λ$CDM background
Authors:
Sebastián Nájera,
Roberto A. Sussman
Abstract:
We examine the evolution of peculiar velocities of cold dark matter (CDM) in localized arrays of inhomogeneous cosmic structures in a $Λ$CDM background that can be identified as a frame comoving with the Cosmic Microwave (CMB). These arrays are constructed by smoothly matching to this cosmological background regions of Szekeres-II models whose source is an imperfect fluid reinterpreted as non-como…
▽ More
We examine the evolution of peculiar velocities of cold dark matter (CDM) in localized arrays of inhomogeneous cosmic structures in a $Λ$CDM background that can be identified as a frame comoving with the Cosmic Microwave (CMB). These arrays are constructed by smoothly matching to this cosmological background regions of Szekeres-II models whose source is an imperfect fluid reinterpreted as non-comoving dust, keeping only first order terms in $v/c$. Considering a single Szekeres-II region matched along two comoving interfaces to a $Λ$CDM background, the magnitudes of peculiar velocities within this region are compatible with values reported in the literature, while the present day Hubble expansion scalar differs from that of the $Λ$CDM background value by a 10\% factor, a result that might provide useful information to the ongoing debate on the $H_0$ tension. While the models cannot describe the virialization process, we show through a representative example that structures of galactic cluster mass reach the onset of this process at redshifts around $z\sim 3$.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021; v1 submitted 22 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Pancakes as opposed to Swiss Cheese
Authors:
Sebastián Nájera,
Roberto A. Sussman
Abstract:
We examine a novel class of toy models of cosmological inhomogeneities by smoothly matching along a suitable hypersurface an arbitrary number of sections of "quasi flat" inhomogeous and anisotropic Szekeres-II models to sections of any spatially flat cosmology that can be described by the Robertson-Waker metric (including de Sitter, anti de Sitter and Minkowski spacetimes). The resulting "pancake"…
▽ More
We examine a novel class of toy models of cosmological inhomogeneities by smoothly matching along a suitable hypersurface an arbitrary number of sections of "quasi flat" inhomogeous and anisotropic Szekeres-II models to sections of any spatially flat cosmology that can be described by the Robertson-Waker metric (including de Sitter, anti de Sitter and Minkowski spacetimes). The resulting "pancake" models are quasi-flat analogues to the well known spherical "Swiss-cheese" models found in the literature. Since Szekeres-II models can be, in general, compatible with a wide range of sources (dissipative fluids, mixtures of non-comoving fluids, mixtures of fluids with scalar or magnetic fields or gravitational waves), the pancake configurations we present allow for a description of a wide collection of localized sources embedded in a Robertson-Waker geometry. We provide various simple examples of arbitrary numbers of Szekeres-II regions (whose sources are comoving dust and energy flux interpreted as a field of peculiar velocities) matched with Einstein de Sitter, $Λ$CDM and de Sitter backgrounds. We also prove that the Szekeres-II regions can be rigorously regarded as "exact" perturbations on a background defined by the matching discussed above. We believe that these models can be useful to test ideas on averaging and backreaction and on the effect of inhomogeneities on cosmic evolution and observations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2020; v1 submitted 8 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
