-
Comparative clustering analysis of Ca II 854.2 nm spectral profiles from simulations and observations
Authors:
Thore E. Moe,
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Luc Rouppe van der Voort,
Mats Carlsson,
Viggo Hansteen,
Flavio Calvo,
Jorrit Leenaarts
Abstract:
We aim to compare and contrast the typical shapes of synthetic Ca II 854.2 nm spectra found in Bifrost simulations having different magnetic activity with the spectral shapes found in a quiet Sun observation from the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST). We use clustering techniques to extract the typical Ca II 854.2 nm profile shapes synthesized from Bifrost simulations with varying amounts of magne…
▽ More
We aim to compare and contrast the typical shapes of synthetic Ca II 854.2 nm spectra found in Bifrost simulations having different magnetic activity with the spectral shapes found in a quiet Sun observation from the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST). We use clustering techniques to extract the typical Ca II 854.2 nm profile shapes synthesized from Bifrost simulations with varying amounts of magnetic activity. We degrade the synthetic profiles to observational conditions and repeat the clustering, and we compare our synthetic results with actual observations. While the mean spectra for our high resolution simulations compare reasonably well with the observations, we find that there are considerable differences between the clusters of observed and synthetic intensity profiles, even after the synthetic profiles have been degraded. The typical absorption profiles from the simulations are both narrower and display a steeper transition from the inner wings to the line core. Furthermore, even in our most quiescent simulation we find a far larger fraction of profiles with local emission around the core, or other exotic profile shapes, than in the observations. Looking into the atmospheric structure for a selected set of synthetic clusters, we find distinct differences in the temperature stratification for the clusters most and least similar to the observations. The narrow and steep profiles are associated with either weak gradients in temperature, or temperatures rising to a local maximum in the line wing forming region before sinking to a minimum in the line core forming region. The profiles that display less steep transitions show extended temperature gradients that are steeper in the range $-3 \lesssim \log τ_{5000} \lesssim -1$.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Shape-based clustering of synthetic Stokes profiles using k-means and k-Shape
Authors:
Thore Espedal Moe,
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Flavio Calvo,
Jorrit Leenaarts
Abstract:
The shapes of Stokes profiles contain much information about the atmospheric conditions that produced them. However, a variety of different atmospheric structures can produce very similar profiles. Thus, it is important for proper interpretation of observations to have a good understanding of how the shapes of Stokes profiles depend on the underlying atmosphere. An excellent tool in this regard is…
▽ More
The shapes of Stokes profiles contain much information about the atmospheric conditions that produced them. However, a variety of different atmospheric structures can produce very similar profiles. Thus, it is important for proper interpretation of observations to have a good understanding of how the shapes of Stokes profiles depend on the underlying atmosphere. An excellent tool in this regard is forward modeling, i.e. computing and studying synthetic spectra from realistic simulations of the solar atmosphere. Modern simulations routinely produce several hundred thousand spectral profiles per snapshot. With such numbers, it becomes necessary to use automated procedures in order to organize the profiles according to their shape. Here we illustrate the use of two complementary methods, k-means and k-Shape, to cluster similarly shaped profiles, and demonstrate how the resulting clusters can be combined with knowledge of the simulation's atmosphere to interpret spectral shapes. We generate synthetic Stokes profiles for the Ca II 854.2 nm line using the Multi3D code from a Bifrost simulation snapshot. We then apply the k-means and k-Shape clustering techniques to group the profiles together according to their shape. We show and compare the classes of profile shapes we retrieve from applying both k-means and k-Shape to our synthetic intensity spectra. We then show the structure of the underlying atmosphere for two particular classes of profile shapes retrieved by the clustering, and demonstrate how this leads to an interpretation for the formation of those profile shapes. Furthermore, we apply both methods to the subset of our profiles containing the strongest Stokes V signals, and demonstrate how k-Shape can be qualitatively better than k-means at retrieving complex profile shapes when using a small number of clusters.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Effects of spatial resolution on inferences of atmospheric quantities from simulations
Authors:
Thore E. Moe,
Tiago M. D. Pereira,
Mats Carlsson
Abstract:
Small scale processes are thought to be important for the dynamics of the solar atmosphere. While numerical resolution fundamentally limits their inclusion in MHD simulations, real observations at the same nominal resolution should still contain imprints of sub-resolution effects. This means that the synthetic observables from a simulation of given resolution might not be directly comparable to re…
▽ More
Small scale processes are thought to be important for the dynamics of the solar atmosphere. While numerical resolution fundamentally limits their inclusion in MHD simulations, real observations at the same nominal resolution should still contain imprints of sub-resolution effects. This means that the synthetic observables from a simulation of given resolution might not be directly comparable to real observables at the same resolution. It is thus of interest to investigate how inferences based on synthetic spectra from simulations with different numerical resolutions compare, and whether these differences persist after the spectra have been spatially degraded to a common resolution. We aim to compare synthetic spectra obtained from realistic 3D radiative magnetohydrodynamic (rMHD) simulations run at three different numerical resolutions from the same initial atmosphere, using very simple methods for inferring line-of-sight velocities and magnetic fields. Additionally we examine how the differing spatial resolution impacts the results retrieved from the STiC inversion code. We find that while the simple inferences for all three simulations reveal the same large-scale tendencies, the higher resolutions yield more fine-grained structures and more extreme line-of-sight velocities/magnetic fields in concentrated spots even after spatial smearing. We also see indications that the imprints of sub-resolution effects on the degraded spectra result in systematic errors in the inversions, and that these errors increase with the amount of sub-resolution effects included. Fortunately, however, we find that including successively more sub-resolution yields smaller additional effects; i.e. there is a clear trend of diminishing importance for progressively finer sub-resolution effects.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
