-
Testing the Low-Mass End of X-Ray Scaling Relations with a Sample of Chandra Galaxy Groups
Authors:
H. J. Eckmiller,
D. S. Hudson,
T. H. Reiprich
Abstract:
Well-determined scaling relations between X-ray observables and cluster mass are essential for using large cluster samples for cosmology. Cluster relations such as the Lx-T, M-T, Lx-M relations, have been investigated extensively, however the question remains whether these relations hold true also for groups. Some evidence supports a break at low masses, possibly caused by the influence of non-gra…
▽ More
Well-determined scaling relations between X-ray observables and cluster mass are essential for using large cluster samples for cosmology. Cluster relations such as the Lx-T, M-T, Lx-M relations, have been investigated extensively, however the question remains whether these relations hold true also for groups. Some evidence supports a break at low masses, possibly caused by the influence of non-gravitational physics on low-mass systems. The main goal of this work is to test scaling relations for the low-mass range to check whether there is a systematic difference between clusters and groups, and to extend this method of reliable cluster mass determination for future samples down to the group regime. We compiled a statistically complete sample of 112 X-ray galaxy groups, 26 with Chandra data. Temperature, metallicity, and surface brightness profiles were created, and used to determine the main physical quantities and scaling relations. We then compared the group properties to the HIFLUGCS clusters and other samples. We present profiles and scaling relations of the whole sample. T and Z profiles behave universally, except for the cores. The Lx-T, M-T, Lx-M, Mg-M, M-Yx, and Lx-Yx relations are in good agreement with clusters. The Lx-T relation steepens for T<3keV, which could point to a larger impact of heating mechanisms on cooler systems. We found a strong drop in the gas mass fraction below 1keV, which indicates the ICM is less dominant in groups and the galaxies have a stronger influence on the system. In all relations the intrinsic scatter for groups is larger, which appears not correlated with merger activity but could be due to scatter caused by baryonic physics in the group cores. We also demonstrate the importance of selection effects. We have found evidence for a similarity break between groups and clusters. However this does not have a strong effect on scaling relations.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2011; v1 submitted 29 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
The 400d Galaxy Cluster Survey Weak Lensing Programme: I: MMT/Megacam Analysis of CL0030+2618 at z=0.50
Authors:
Holger Israel,
Thomas Erben,
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Alexey Vikhlinin,
Hendrik Hildebrandt,
Daniel S. Hudson,
Brian A. McLeod,
Craig L. Sarazin,
Peter Schneider,
Yu-Ying Zhang
Abstract:
The mass function of galaxy clusters at high redshifts is a particularly useful probe to learn about the history of structure formation and constrain cosmological parameters. We aim at deriving reliable masses for a high-redshift, high-luminosity sample of clusters of galaxies selected from the 400d survey of X-ray selected clusters. Here, we will focus on a particular object, CL0030+2618 at z=0…
▽ More
The mass function of galaxy clusters at high redshifts is a particularly useful probe to learn about the history of structure formation and constrain cosmological parameters. We aim at deriving reliable masses for a high-redshift, high-luminosity sample of clusters of galaxies selected from the 400d survey of X-ray selected clusters. Here, we will focus on a particular object, CL0030+2618 at z=0.50 Using deep imaging in three passbands with the MEGACAM instrument at MMT, we show that MEGACAM is well-suited for measuring gravitational shear. We detect the weak lensing signal of CL0030+2618 at 5.8 sigma significance, using the aperture mass technique. Furthermore, we find significant tangential alignment of galaxies out to ~10 arcmin or >2r_200 distance from the cluster centre. The weak lensing centre of CL0030+2618 agrees with several X-ray measurements and the position of the brightest cluster galaxy. Finally, we infer a weak lensing virial mass of M_200=7.5 10^{14} M_sun for CL0030+2618. Despite complications by a tentative foreground galaxy group in the line of sight, the X-ray and weak lensing estimates for CL0030+2618 are in remarkable agreement. This study paves the way for the largest weak lensing survey of high-redshift galaxy clusters to date.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2010; v1 submitted 16 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
What is a Cool-Core Cluster? A Detailed Analysis of the Cores of the X-ray Flux-Limited HIFLUGCS Cluster Sample
Authors:
Daniel S. Hudson,
Rupal Mittal,
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Paul E. J. Nulsen,
Heinz Andernach,
Craig L. Sarazin
Abstract:
We use the largest complete sample of 64 galaxy clusters (HIghest X-ray FLUx Galaxy Cluster Sample) with available high-quality X-ray data from Chandra, and apply 16 cool-core diagnostics to them, some of them new. We also correlate optical properties of brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) with X-ray properties. To segregate cool core and non-cool-core clusters, we find that central cooling time,…
▽ More
We use the largest complete sample of 64 galaxy clusters (HIghest X-ray FLUx Galaxy Cluster Sample) with available high-quality X-ray data from Chandra, and apply 16 cool-core diagnostics to them, some of them new. We also correlate optical properties of brightest cluster galaxies (BCGs) with X-ray properties. To segregate cool core and non-cool-core clusters, we find that central cooling time, t_cool, is the best parameter for low redshift clusters with high quality data, and that cuspiness is the best parameter for high redshift clusters. 72% of clusters in our sample have a cool core (t_cool < 7.7 h_{71}^{-1/2} Gyr) and 44% have strong cool cores (t_cool <1.0 h_{71}^{-1/2} Gyr). For the first time we show quantitatively that the discrepancy in classical and spectroscopic mass deposition rates can not be explained with a recent formation of the cool cores, demonstrating the need for a heating mechanism to explain the cooling flow problem. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
X-ray Substructure Studies of Four Galaxy Clusters using XMM-Newton Data
Authors:
Yu-Ying Zhang,
Thomas H Reiprich,
Alexis Finoguenov,
Daniel S. Hudson,
Craig L Sarazin
Abstract:
Mahdavi et al. find that the degree of agreement between weak lensing and X-ray mass measurements is a function of cluster radius. Numerical simulations also point out that X-ray mass proxies do not work equally well at all radii. The origin of the effect is thought to be associated with cluster mergers. Recent work presenting the cluster maps showed an ability of X-ray maps to reveal and study…
▽ More
Mahdavi et al. find that the degree of agreement between weak lensing and X-ray mass measurements is a function of cluster radius. Numerical simulations also point out that X-ray mass proxies do not work equally well at all radii. The origin of the effect is thought to be associated with cluster mergers. Recent work presenting the cluster maps showed an ability of X-ray maps to reveal and study cluster mergers in detail. Here we present a first attempt to use the study of substructure in assessing the systematics of the hydrostatic mass measurements using two-dimensional (2-D) X-ray diagnostics. The temperature map is uniquely able to identify the substructure in an almost relaxed cluster which would be unnoticed in the ICM electron number density and pressure maps. We describe the radial fluctuations in the 2-D maps by a cumulative/differential scatter profile relative to the mean profile within/at a given radius. The amplitude indicates ~10 fluctuations in the temperature, electron number density and entropy maps, and ~15 fluctuations in the pressure map. The amplitude of and the discontinuity in the scatter complement 2-D substructure diagnostics, e.g. indicating the most disturbed radial range. There is a tantalizing link between the substructure identified using the scatter of the entropy and pressure fluctuations and the hydrostatic mass bias relative to the expected mass based on the M-Yx and M-Mgas relations particularly at r500. XMM-Newton observations with ~120,000 source photons from the cluster are sufficient to apply our substructure diagnostics via the spectrally measured 2-D temperature, electron number density, entropy and pressure maps.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2009; v1 submitted 23 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
-
AGN heating and ICM cooling in the HIFLUGCS sample of galaxy clusters
Authors:
Rupal Mittal,
Daniel S. Hudson,
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Tracy Clarke
Abstract:
We have carried out an intensive study of the AGN heating-ICM cooling network by comparing various cluster parameters of the HIFLUGCS sample to the integrated radio luminosity of the central AGN, L_R, defined as the total synchrotron power between 10 MHz and 15 GHz. We adopt the central cooling time, t_cool, as the diagnostic to ascertain cooling properties of the clusters and classify clusters…
▽ More
We have carried out an intensive study of the AGN heating-ICM cooling network by comparing various cluster parameters of the HIFLUGCS sample to the integrated radio luminosity of the central AGN, L_R, defined as the total synchrotron power between 10 MHz and 15 GHz. We adopt the central cooling time, t_cool, as the diagnostic to ascertain cooling properties of the clusters and classify clusters with t_cool < 1 Gyr as strong cooling core (SCC) clusters, with 1 Gyr < t_cool <7.7 Gyr as weak cooling core (WCC) clusters and with t_cool > 7.7 Gyr as non-cooling core (NCC) clusters. We find 48 out of 64 clusters (75%) contain cluster center radio sources (CCRS) cospatial with or within 50 h^{-1}_{71} kpc of the X-ray peak emission. Further, we find that the probability of finding a CCRS increases from 45% to 67% to 100% for NCC, WCC and SCC clusters, respectively, suggesting an AGN-feedback machinery in SCC clusters which regulates the cooling in the central regions.
We find L_R in SCC clusters depends strongly on the cluster scale such that more massive clusters harbor more powerful radio AGN. The same trend is observed between L_R and the classical mass deposition rate, MDR, albeit much stronger, in SCC and partly also in WCC clusters. We also perform correlations of the 2MASS K-band luminosity of the brightest cluster galaxy, L_BCG, with L_R and cluster parameters. We invoke the relation between L_BCG and the black hole mass, M_BH, and find a surprisingly tight correlation between M_BH and L_R for SCC clusters. We find also an excellent correlation of L_BCG with M500 and L_X for the entire sample; however, SCC clusters show a tighter trend in both the cases. We discuss the plausible reasons behind these scaling relations in the context of cooling flows and AGN feedback. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2009; v1 submitted 4 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Suzaku measurement of Abell 2204's intracluster gas temperature profile out to 1800 kpc
Authors:
T. H. Reiprich,
D. S. Hudson,
Y. -Y. Zhang,
K. Sato,
Y. Ishisaki,
A. Hoshino,
T. Ohashi,
N. Ota,
Y. Fujita
Abstract:
Context: Measurements of intracluster gas temperatures out to large radii are important for the use of clusters for precision cosmology and for studies of cluster physics. Previous attempts to measure robust temperatures at cluster virial radii failed. Aims: The goal of this work is to measure the temperature profile of the very relaxed galaxy cluster Abell 2204 out to large radii, possibly reac…
▽ More
Context: Measurements of intracluster gas temperatures out to large radii are important for the use of clusters for precision cosmology and for studies of cluster physics. Previous attempts to measure robust temperatures at cluster virial radii failed. Aims: The goal of this work is to measure the temperature profile of the very relaxed galaxy cluster Abell 2204 out to large radii, possibly reaching the virial radius. Methods: Taking advantage of its low particle background due to its low-Earth orbit, Suzaku data are used to measure the outer temperature profile of Abell 2204. These data are combined with Chandra and XMM-Newton data of the same cluster in order to make the connection to the inner regions, unresolved by Suzaku, and to determine the smearing due to Suzaku's PSF. Results: The temperature profile of Abell 2204 is determined from 10 kpc to 1800 kpc, close to an estimate of r200 (the approximation to the virial radius). The temperature rises steeply from below 4 keV in the very center up to more than 8 keV in the intermediate range and then decreases again to about 4 keV at the largest radii. Varying the measured particle background normalization artificially by +-10 percent does not change the results significantly. Predictions for outer temperature profiles based on hydrodynamic simulations show good agreement. In particular, we find the observed temperature profile to be slightly steeper but consistent with a drop of a factor of 0.6 from 0.3 r200 to r200, as predicted by simulations. Conclusions: Temperature measurements up to the virial radius seem feasible with Suzaku, when a careful analysis of the different background components and the effects of the PSF is performed. The result obtained here indicates that numerical simulations capture the intracluster gas physics well in cluster outskirts.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2009; v1 submitted 18 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
-
Complex Physics in Cluster Cores: Showstopper for the Use of Clusters for Cosmology?
Authors:
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Daniel S. Hudson
Abstract:
The influence of cool galaxy cluster cores on the X-ray luminosity--gravitational mass relation is studied with Chandra observations of 64 clusters in the HIFLUGCS sample. As preliminary results we find (i) a significant offset of cool core (CC) clusters to the high luminosity (or low mass) side compared to non-cool core (NCC) clusters, (ii) a smaller scatter of CC clusters compared to NCC clust…
▽ More
The influence of cool galaxy cluster cores on the X-ray luminosity--gravitational mass relation is studied with Chandra observations of 64 clusters in the HIFLUGCS sample. As preliminary results we find (i) a significant offset of cool core (CC) clusters to the high luminosity (or low mass) side compared to non-cool core (NCC) clusters, (ii) a smaller scatter of CC clusters compared to NCC clusters, (iii) a decreasing fraction of CC clusters with increasing cluster mass, (iv) a reduced scatter in the luminosity--mass relation for the entire sample if the luminosity is scaled properly with the central entropy. The implications of these results on the intrinsic scatter are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2006;
originally announced November 2006.
-
X-ray Detection of the Proto Supermassive Binary Black Hole at the Centre of Abell 400
Authors:
Daniel S. Hudson,
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Tracy E. Clarke,
Craig L. Sarazin
Abstract:
We report the first X-ray detection of a proto-supermassive binary black hole at the centre of Abell 400. Using the Chandra ACIS, we are able to clearly resolve the two active galactic nuclei in 3C 75, the well known double radio source at the centre of Abell 400. Through analysis of the new Chandra observation of Abell 400 along with 4.5 GHz and 330 MHz VLA radio data, we will show new evidence…
▽ More
We report the first X-ray detection of a proto-supermassive binary black hole at the centre of Abell 400. Using the Chandra ACIS, we are able to clearly resolve the two active galactic nuclei in 3C 75, the well known double radio source at the centre of Abell 400. Through analysis of the new Chandra observation of Abell 400 along with 4.5 GHz and 330 MHz VLA radio data, we will show new evidence that the Active Galactic Nuclei in 3C 75 are a bound system. Methods. Using the high quality X-ray data, we map the temperature, pressure, density, and entropy of the inner regions as well as the cluster profile properties out to ~18'. We compare features in the X-ray and radio images to determine the interaction between the intra-cluster medium and extended radio emission. The Chandra image shows an elongation of the cluster gas along the northeast-southwest axis; aligned with the initial bending of 3C 75's jets. Additionally, the temperature profile shows no cooling core, consistent with a merging system. There is an apparent shock to the south of the core consistent with a Mach number of M~1.4 or speed of v~1200 km s^-1. Both Active Galactic Nuclei, at least in projection, are located in the low entropy, high density core just north of the shock region. We find that the projected path of the jets does not follow the intra-cluster medium surface brightness gradient as expected if their path were due to buoyancy. We also find that both central AGN are extended and include a thermal component. Based on this analysis, we conclude that the Active Galactic Nuclei in 3C 75 are a bound system from a previous merger. They are contained in a low entropy core moving through the intra-cluster medium at 1200 km s^-1. The bending of the jets is due to the local intra-cluster medium wind.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
Studying the Nature of Dark Energy with Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Thomas H. Reiprich,
Daniel S. Hudson,
Thomas Erben,
Craig L. Sarazin
Abstract:
We report on the status of our effort to constrain the nature of dark energy through the evolution of the cluster mass function. Chandra temperature profiles for 31 clusters from a local cluster sample are shown. The X-ray appearance of the proto supermassive binary black hole at the center of the cluster Abell 400 is described. Preliminary weak lensing results obtained with Megacam@MMT for a re…
▽ More
We report on the status of our effort to constrain the nature of dark energy through the evolution of the cluster mass function. Chandra temperature profiles for 31 clusters from a local cluster sample are shown. The X-ray appearance of the proto supermassive binary black hole at the center of the cluster Abell 400 is described. Preliminary weak lensing results obtained with Megacam@MMT for a redshift z=0.5 cluster from a distant cluster sample are given.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2006;
originally announced March 2006.
-
Diffuse Non-thermal X-ray Emission: Evidence for Cosmic-ray Acceleration at the Shock Front in IC1262
Authors:
Daniel S. Hudson,
Mark J. Henriksen
Abstract:
We report the first localization of diffuse, non-thermal, X-ray emission from a nearby galaxy cluster. Using Chandra data, we have isolated a diffuse non-thermal X-ray component with a photon index, Gamma_ X = 2.21 +0.14 -0.15 and a flux of 9.5 +1.1 -2.5 x 10^-5 photons cm^-2 s^-1 keV^-1 at 1 keV, that extends from ~1'.5 to ~2'.5 to the south of the X-ray flux peak. Comparison to simulations imp…
▽ More
We report the first localization of diffuse, non-thermal, X-ray emission from a nearby galaxy cluster. Using Chandra data, we have isolated a diffuse non-thermal X-ray component with a photon index, Gamma_ X = 2.21 +0.14 -0.15 and a flux of 9.5 +1.1 -2.5 x 10^-5 photons cm^-2 s^-1 keV^-1 at 1 keV, that extends from ~1'.5 to ~2'.5 to the south of the X-ray flux peak. Comparison to simulations implies that the diffuse non-thermal emission is produced by primary electrons, accelerated at shocks to relativistic velocities. Using these results and the flux and hardness maps produced with data from the Chandra Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer, we conclude that a smaller subclump coming from the north merged with IC1262. The offset of the cD galaxy from the X-ray peak and large peculiar velocity indicate that the subclump's impact parameter was to the west and on the near side of IC1262.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2003;
originally announced August 2003.
-
A Soft X-ray Component in the Abell 754 Cluster
Authors:
Mark J. Henriksen,
Daniel S. Hudson,
Eric Tittley
Abstract:
We have analyzed the Chandra, BeppoSax, and ROSAT observations of Abell 754 and report evidence of a soft, diffuse X-ray component. The emission is peaked in the cluster center and is detected out to 8' from the X-ray center. Fitting a thermal model to the combined BeppoSax and PSPC spectra show excess emission below 1 keV in the PSPC and above 100 keV in the BeppoSax PDS. The source 26W20 is in…
▽ More
We have analyzed the Chandra, BeppoSax, and ROSAT observations of Abell 754 and report evidence of a soft, diffuse X-ray component. The emission is peaked in the cluster center and is detected out to 8' from the X-ray center. Fitting a thermal model to the combined BeppoSax and PSPC spectra show excess emission below 1 keV in the PSPC and above 100 keV in the BeppoSax PDS. The source 26W20 is in the field of view of the PDS. The addition of a powerlaw with the spectral parameters measured by Silverman et al. (1998) for 26W20 successfully models the hard component in the PDS. The remaining excess soft emission can be modeled by either a low temperature, 0.75 - 1.03 keV component, or by a powerlaw with a steep spectral index, 2.3. Addition of a second thermal component model provides a much better fit to the data than does the addition of a non-thermal component. The Chandra temperature map does not show any region cooler than 6.9 keV within the region where the cool component was detected. Simulations of the emission from embedded groups were performed and compared with the Chandra temperature map which show groups are a plausible source of ~1 keV emission. The cool component is centrally peaked in the cluster and the gas density and temperature are relatively high arguing against the WHIM as the source of the X-ray emission. X-ray emission from elliptical galaxies is not high enough to provide the total cool component luminosity, 7.0x10^43 ergs s^-1. The peak of the cool component is located between the low frequency radio halos arguing against a non-thermal interpretation for the emission. We conclude that emission from embedded groups is the most likely origin of the cool component in Abell 754.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2003;
originally announced June 2003.
-
A BeppoSAX Observation of the IC1262 Galaxy Cluster
Authors:
D. S. Hudson,
M. J. Henriksen,
S. Colafrancesco
Abstract:
We present an analysis of BeppoSAX observations of the IC1262 galaxy cluster and report the first temperature and abundance measurements, along with preliminary indications of diffuse, nonthermal emission. By fitting a 6' (~360 h_50^-1 kpc) region with a single Mewe-Kaastra-Liedahl model with photoelectric absorption, we find a temperature of 2.1 - 2.3 keV, and abundance of 0.45 - 0.77 (both 90%…
▽ More
We present an analysis of BeppoSAX observations of the IC1262 galaxy cluster and report the first temperature and abundance measurements, along with preliminary indications of diffuse, nonthermal emission. By fitting a 6' (~360 h_50^-1 kpc) region with a single Mewe-Kaastra-Liedahl model with photoelectric absorption, we find a temperature of 2.1 - 2.3 keV, and abundance of 0.45 - 0.77 (both 90% confidence). We find the addition of a power-law component provides a statistically significant improvement (F-test = 90%) to the fit. The addition of a second thermal component also improves the fit but we argue that it is physically implausible. The power-law component has a photon index (Gamma_X) of 0.4 - 2.8 and a nonthermal flux of (4.1 - 56.7) x 10-5 photons cm^-2 s^-1 over the 1.5 - 10.5 keV range in the Medium Energy Concentrator spectrometer detector. An unidentified X-ray source found in the ROSAT High Resolution Imager observation (~0'.9 from the center of the cluster) is a possible explanation for the nonthermal flux; however, additional evidence of diffuse, nonthermal emission comes from the NRAO VLA Sky Survey and the Westerbork Northern Sky Survey radio measurements, in which excess diffuse, radio flux is observed after point-source subtraction. The radio excess can be fitted to a simple power law with a spectral index of ~1.8, which is consistent with the nonthermal X-ray emission spectral index. The steep spectrum is typical of diffuse emission and the size of the radio source implies that it is larger than the cD galaxy and not due to a discreet source.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
