-
Compressible turbulence in the interstellar medium: New insights from a high-resolution supersonic turbulence simulation
Authors:
Renaud Ferrand,
Sébastien Galtier,
Fouad Sahraoui,
Christoph Federrath
Abstract:
The role of supersonic turbulence in structuring the interstellar medium (ISM) remains an unsettled question. Here, this problem is investigated using a newexact law of compressible isothermal hydrodynamic turbulence, which involves two-point correlations in physical space. The new law is shown to have a compact expression that contains a single flux term reminiscent of the incompressible case and…
▽ More
The role of supersonic turbulence in structuring the interstellar medium (ISM) remains an unsettled question. Here, this problem is investigated using a newexact law of compressible isothermal hydrodynamic turbulence, which involves two-point correlations in physical space. The new law is shown to have a compact expression that contains a single flux term reminiscent of the incompressible case and a source term with a simple expression whose sign is given by the divergence of the velocity. The law is then used to investigate the properties of such a turbulence at integral Mach number $4$ produced by a massive numerical simulation with a grid resolution of $10,048^3$ points. The flux (resp. source) term was found to have positive (resp. negative) contribution to the total energy cascade rate, which is interpreted as a direct cascade amplified by compression, while their sum is constant in the inertial range. Using a local (in space) analysis it is shown that the source is mainly driven by filamentary structures in which the flux is negligible. Taking positive defined correlations reveals the existence of different turbulent regimes separated by the sonic scale, which determines the scale over which the non-negligible source modifies the scaling of the flux. Our study provides new insight into the dynamics and structures of supersonic interstellar turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Energy transfer, discontinuities and heating in the inner solar wind measured with a weak and local formulation of the Politano-Pouquet law
Authors:
Vincent David,
Sébastien Galtier,
Fouad Sahraoui,
Lina Z. Hadid
Abstract:
The solar wind is a highly turbulent plasma for which the mean rate of energy transfer $\varepsilon$ has been measured for a long time using the Politano-Pouquet (PP98) exact law. However, this law assumes statistical homogeneity that can be violated by the presence of discontinuities. Here, we introduce a new method based on the inertial dissipation $\Dis$ whose analytical form is derived from in…
▽ More
The solar wind is a highly turbulent plasma for which the mean rate of energy transfer $\varepsilon$ has been measured for a long time using the Politano-Pouquet (PP98) exact law. However, this law assumes statistical homogeneity that can be violated by the presence of discontinuities. Here, we introduce a new method based on the inertial dissipation $\Dis$ whose analytical form is derived from incompressible magnetohydrodynamics (MHD); it can be considered as a weak and {\it local} (in space) formulation of the PP98 law whose expression is recovered after integration is space. We used $\Dis$ to estimate the local energy transfer rate from the \textit{THEMIS-B} and \textit{Parker Solar Probe} (PSP) data taken in the solar wind at different heliospheric distances. Our study reveals that discontinuities near the Sun lead to a strong energy transfer that affects a wide range of scales $σ$. We also observe that switchbacks seem to be characterized by a singular behavior with an energy transfer varying as $σ^{-3/4}$, which slightly differs from classical discontinuities characterized by a $σ^{-1}$ scaling. A comparison between the measurements of $\varepsilon$ and $\Dis$ shows that in general the latter is significantly larger than the former.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The incompressible energy cascade rate in anisotropic solar wind turbulence
Authors:
N. Andrés,
F. Sahraoui,
Huang,
L. Z. Hadid,
S. Galtier
Abstract:
Context. The presence of a magnetic guide field induces several types of anisotropy in solar wind turbulence. The energy cascade rate between scales in the inertial range depends strongly on the direction of this magnetic guide field, splitting the energy cascade according to the parallel and perpendicular directions with respect to magnetic guide field. Aims. Using more than two years of Parker S…
▽ More
Context. The presence of a magnetic guide field induces several types of anisotropy in solar wind turbulence. The energy cascade rate between scales in the inertial range depends strongly on the direction of this magnetic guide field, splitting the energy cascade according to the parallel and perpendicular directions with respect to magnetic guide field. Aims. Using more than two years of Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observations, the isotropy and anisotropy energy cascade rates are investigated. The variance and normalized fluctuation ratios, the kinetic and magnetic energies, and the normalized cross-helicity and residual energy are studied. The connection between the heliocentric distance, the local temperature of the plasma, and the energy cascade components is made. Methods. Using exact relations for fully developed incompressible magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence, the incompressible energy cascade rate is computed. In particular, using the isotropy and 2D and slab assumptions, the isotropic, perpendicular, and parallel energy cascade rate components are estimated. Results. The variance anisotropy ratios, for both velocity and magnetic fields, do not exhibit a dependence with respect to the heliocentric distance $r$ between 0.2 and 0.8 au. While the velocity normalized fluctuation ratio shows a dependence with $r$, the magnetic normalized fluctuation ratio does not. A strong correlation between the isotropic and anisotropic energy cascade rates and the temperature is found. A clear dominance of the perpendicular cascades over the parallel cascades as PSP approaches the Sun is observed. A dominant 2D cascade and/or geometry over the slab component in slow solar wind turbulence in the largest MHD scales is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2022; v1 submitted 27 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Fluid energy cascade rate and kinetic damping: new insight from 3D Landau-fluid simulations
Authors:
R. Ferrand,
F. Sahraoui,
D. Laveder,
T. Passot,
P. L. Sulem,
S. Galtier
Abstract:
Using an exact law for incompressible Hall magnetohydrodynamics (HMHD) turbulence, the energy cascade rate is computed from three-dimensional HMHD-CGL (bi-adiabatic ions and isothermal electrons) and Landau fluid (LF) numerical simulations that feature different intensities of Landau damping over a broad range of wavenumbers, typically $0.05\lesssim k_\perp d_i \lesssim100$. Using three sets of cr…
▽ More
Using an exact law for incompressible Hall magnetohydrodynamics (HMHD) turbulence, the energy cascade rate is computed from three-dimensional HMHD-CGL (bi-adiabatic ions and isothermal electrons) and Landau fluid (LF) numerical simulations that feature different intensities of Landau damping over a broad range of wavenumbers, typically $0.05\lesssim k_\perp d_i \lesssim100$. Using three sets of cross-scale simulations where turbulence is initiated at large, medium and small scales, the ability of the fluid energy cascade to "sense" the kinetic Landau damping at different scales is tested. The cascade rate estimated from the exact law and the dissipation calculated directly from the simulation are shown to reflect the role of Landau damping in dissipating energy at all scales, with an emphasis on the kinetic ones. This result provides new prospects on using exact laws for simplified fluid models to analyze dissipation in kinetic simulations and spacecraft observations, and new insights into theoretical description of collisionless magnetized plasmas.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021; v1 submitted 7 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
The evolution of compressible solar wind turbulence in the inner heliosphere: PSP, THEMIS and MAVEN observations
Authors:
N. Andrés,
F. Sahraoui,
L. Z. Hadid,
S. Y. Huang,
N. Romanelli,
S. Galtier,
G. DiBraccio,
J. Halekas
Abstract:
The first computation of the compressible energy transfer rate from $\sim$ 0.2 AU up to $\sim$ 1.7 AU is obtained using PSP, THEMIS and MAVEN observations. The compressible energy cascade rate $\varepsilon_C$ is computed for hundred of events at different heliocentric distances, for time intervals when the spacecraft were in the pristine solar wind. The observational results show moderate increase…
▽ More
The first computation of the compressible energy transfer rate from $\sim$ 0.2 AU up to $\sim$ 1.7 AU is obtained using PSP, THEMIS and MAVEN observations. The compressible energy cascade rate $\varepsilon_C$ is computed for hundred of events at different heliocentric distances, for time intervals when the spacecraft were in the pristine solar wind. The observational results show moderate increases of $\varepsilon_C$ with respect to the incompressible cascade rate $\varepsilon_I$. Depending on the level of compressibility in the plasma, which reach up to 25 $\%$ in the PSP perihelion, the different terms in the compressible exact relation are shown to have different impact in the total cascade rate $\varepsilon_C$. Finally, the observational results are connected with the local ion temperature and the solar wind heating problem.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The Ion Transition Range of Solar Wind Turbulence in the Inner Heliosphere: Parker Solar Probe Observations
Authors:
S. Y. Huang,
F. Sahraoui,
N. Andrés,
L. Z. Hadid,
Z. G. Yuan,
J. S. He,
J. S. Zhao,
S. Galtier,
J. Zhang,
X. H. Deng,
K. Jiang,
L. Yu,
S. B. Xu,
Q. Y. Xiong,
Y. Y. Wei,
T. Dudok de Wit,
S. D. Bale,
J. C. Kasper
Abstract:
The scaling of the turbulent spectra provides a key measurement that allows to discriminate between different theoretical predictions of turbulence. In the solar wind, this has driven a large number of studies dedicated to this issue using in-situ data from various orbiting spacecraft. While a semblance of consensus exists regarding the scaling in the MHD and dispersive ranges, the precise scaling…
▽ More
The scaling of the turbulent spectra provides a key measurement that allows to discriminate between different theoretical predictions of turbulence. In the solar wind, this has driven a large number of studies dedicated to this issue using in-situ data from various orbiting spacecraft. While a semblance of consensus exists regarding the scaling in the MHD and dispersive ranges, the precise scaling in the transition range and the actual physical mechanisms that control it remain open questions. Using the high-resolution data in the inner heliosphere from Parker Solar Probe (PSP) mission, we find that the sub-ion scales (i.e., at the frequency f ~ [2, 9] Hz) follow a power-law spectrum f^a with a spectral index a varying between -3 and -5.7. Our results also show that there is a trend toward and anti-correlation between the spectral slopes and the power amplitudes at the MHD scales, in agreement with previous studies: the higher the power amplitude the steeper the spectrum at sub-ion scales. A similar trend toward an anti-correlation between steep spectra and increasing normalized cross helicity is found, in agreement with previous theoretical predictions about the imbalanced solar wind. We discuss the ubiquitous nature of the ion transition range in solar wind turbulence in the inner heliosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Magnetic effects on fields morphologies and reversals in geodynamo simulations
Authors:
Mélissa D. Menu,
Ludovic Petitdemange,
Sébastien Galtier
Abstract:
The dynamo effect is the most popular candidate to explain the non-primordial magnetic fields of astrophysical objects. Although many systematic studies of parameters have already been made to determine the different dynamical regimes explored by direct numerical geodynamo simulations, it is only recently that the regime corresponding to the outer core of the Earth characterized by a balance of fo…
▽ More
The dynamo effect is the most popular candidate to explain the non-primordial magnetic fields of astrophysical objects. Although many systematic studies of parameters have already been made to determine the different dynamical regimes explored by direct numerical geodynamo simulations, it is only recently that the regime corresponding to the outer core of the Earth characterized by a balance of forces between the Coriolis and Lorentz forces is accessible numerically. In most previous studies, the Lorentz force played a relatively minor role. For example, they have shown that a purely hydrodynamic parameter (the local Rossby number $Ro_\ell$ determines the stability domain of dynamos dominated by the axial dipole (dipolar dynamos).
In this study, we show that this result cannot hold when the Lorentz force becomes dominant. We model turbulent geodynamo simulations with a strong Lorentz force by varying the important parameters over several orders of magnitude. This method enables us to question previous results and to argue on the applications of numerical dynamos in order to better understand the geodynamo problem. Strong dipolar fields considerably affect the kinetic energy distribution of convective motions which enables the maintenance of this field configuration. The relative importance of each force depends on the spatial length scale, whereas $Ro_\ell$ is a global output parameter which ignores the spatial dependency. We show that inertia does not induce a dipole collapse as long as the Lorentz and the Coriolis forces remain dominant at large length scales.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Energy cascade rate measured in a collisionless space plasma with MMS data and compressible Hall magnetohydrodynamic turbulence theory
Authors:
Nahuel Andrés,
Fouad Sahraoui,
Sebastien Galtier,
Lina Z. Hadid,
Renaud Ferrand,
Shiyong Y. Huang
Abstract:
The first complete estimation of the compressible energy cascade rate $|\varepsilon_\text{C}|$ at magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) and sub-ion scales is obtained in the Earth's magnetosheath using Magnetospheric MultiScale (MMS) spacecraft data and an exact law derived recently for {\it compressible} Hall MHD turbulence. A multi-spacecraft technique is used to compute the velocity and magnetic gradients,…
▽ More
The first complete estimation of the compressible energy cascade rate $|\varepsilon_\text{C}|$ at magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) and sub-ion scales is obtained in the Earth's magnetosheath using Magnetospheric MultiScale (MMS) spacecraft data and an exact law derived recently for {\it compressible} Hall MHD turbulence. A multi-spacecraft technique is used to compute the velocity and magnetic gradients, and then all the correlation functions involved in the exact relation. It is shown that when the density fluctuations are relatively small, $|\varepsilon_\text{C}|$ identifies well with its incompressible analogue $|\varepsilon_\text{I}|$ at MHD scales but becomes much larger than $|\varepsilon_\text{I}|$ at sub-ion scales. For larger density fluctuations, $|\varepsilon_\text{C}|$ is larger than $|\varepsilon_\text{I}|$ at every scale with a value significantly higher than for smaller density fluctuations. Our study reveals also that for both small and large density fluctuations, the non-flux terms remain always negligible with respect to the flux terms and that the major contribution to $|\varepsilon_\text{C}|$ at sub-ion scales comes from the compressible Hall flux.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
-8/3 spectrum in kinetic Alfvén wave turbulence: implications for the solar wind
Authors:
Vincent David,
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
The nature of solar wind turbulence at large scale is rather well understood in the theoretical framework of magnetohydrodynamics. The situation is quite different at sub-proton scales where the magnetic energy spectrum measured by different spacecrafts does not fit with the classical turbulence predictions: a power law index close to $-8/3$ is generally reported which is far from the predictions…
▽ More
The nature of solar wind turbulence at large scale is rather well understood in the theoretical framework of magnetohydrodynamics. The situation is quite different at sub-proton scales where the magnetic energy spectrum measured by different spacecrafts does not fit with the classical turbulence predictions: a power law index close to $-8/3$ is generally reported which is far from the predictions of strong and wave turbulence, $-7/3$ and $-5/2$ respectively. This discrepancy is considered as a major problem for solar wind turbulence. Here, we show with a nonlinear diffusion model of weak kinetic Alfvén wave turbulence where the cascade is driven by local triadic interactions (Passot and Sulem, 2019), that a magnetic spectrum with a power law index of $-8/3$ can emerge. This scaling corresponds to a self-similar solution of the second kind with a front propagation following the law $k_f \sim (t_*-t)^{-3/4}$, with $t<t_*$. This solution appears when we relax the implicit assumption of stationarity generally made in turbulence. The agreement between the theory and observations can be interpreted as an evidence of the non-stationarity of solar wind turbulence at sub-proton scales.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Inverse cascade of hybrid helicity in $B Ω$-MHD turbulence
Authors:
Mélissa D. Menu,
Sébastien Galtier,
Ludovic Petitdemange
Abstract:
We investigate the impact of a solid-body rotation $Ω_0$ on the large-scale dynamics of an incompressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulent flow in presence of a background magnetic field $\bf B_0$ and at low Rossby number. Three-dimensional direct numerical simulations are performed in a periodic box, at unit magnetic Prandtl number and with a forcing at intermediate wavenumber $k_f=20$. When $Ω_0$ i…
▽ More
We investigate the impact of a solid-body rotation $Ω_0$ on the large-scale dynamics of an incompressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulent flow in presence of a background magnetic field $\bf B_0$ and at low Rossby number. Three-dimensional direct numerical simulations are performed in a periodic box, at unit magnetic Prandtl number and with a forcing at intermediate wavenumber $k_f=20$. When $Ω_0$ is aligned with $\bf B_0$ (i.e. $θ\equiv \widehat{\left(Ω_{0}, \bf B_0 \right)} = 0$), inverse transfer is found for the magnetic spectrum at $k<k_f$. This transfer is stronger when the forcing excites preferentially right-handed (rather than left-handed) fluctuations; it is smaller when $θ>0$ and becomes weak when $θ\ge 35^o$. These properties are understood as the consequence of an inverse cascade of hybrid helicity which is an inviscid/ideal invariant of this system when $θ=0$. Hybrid helicity emerges, therefore, as a key element for understanding rotating dynamos. Implication of these findings on the origin of the alignment of the magnetic dipole with the rotation axis in planets and stars is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Energy cascade rate in isothermal compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Nahuel Andrés,
Fouad Sahraoui,
Sébastien Galtier,
Lina Z. Hadid,
Pablo Dmitruk,
Pablo Mininni
Abstract:
Three-dimensional direct numerical simulations are used to study the energy cascade rate in isothermal compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. Our analysis is guided by a two-point exact law derived recently for this problem in which flux, source, hybrid, and mixed terms are present. The relative importance of each term is studied for different initial subsonic Mach numbers $M_S$ and differen…
▽ More
Three-dimensional direct numerical simulations are used to study the energy cascade rate in isothermal compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. Our analysis is guided by a two-point exact law derived recently for this problem in which flux, source, hybrid, and mixed terms are present. The relative importance of each term is studied for different initial subsonic Mach numbers $M_S$ and different magnetic guide fields ${\bf B}_0$. The dominant contribution to the energy cascade rate comes from the compressible flux, which depends weakly on the magnetic guide field ${\bf B}_0$, unlike the other terms whose modulus increase significantly with $M_S$ and ${\bf B}_0$. In particular, for strong ${\bf B}_0$ the source and hybrid terms are dominant at small scales with almost the same amplitude but with a different sign. A statistical analysis made with an isotropic decomposition based on the SO(3) rotation group is shown to generate spurious results in presence of ${\bf B}_0$, when compared with an axisymmetric decomposition better suited to the geometry of the problem. Our numerical results are compared with previous analyses made with in-situ measurements in the solar wind and the terrestrial magnetosheath.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2018; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence in the Earth's magnetosheath: estimation of the energy cascade rate using in situ spacecraft data
Authors:
Lina Hadid,
Fouad Sahraoui,
Sebastien Galtier,
Shiyong Huang
Abstract:
The first estimation of the energy cascade rate ${|ε_C|}$ of magnetosheath turbulence is obtained using the CLUSTER and THEMIS spacecraft data and an exact law of compressible isothermal magnetohydrodynamics turbulence. ${|ε_C|}$ is found to be of the order of ${10{^{-13}} J.m^{3}.s^{-1}}$, at least two orders of magnitude larger than its value in the solar wind (order of…
▽ More
The first estimation of the energy cascade rate ${|ε_C|}$ of magnetosheath turbulence is obtained using the CLUSTER and THEMIS spacecraft data and an exact law of compressible isothermal magnetohydrodynamics turbulence. ${|ε_C|}$ is found to be of the order of ${10{^{-13}} J.m^{3}.s^{-1}}$, at least two orders of magnitude larger than its value in the solar wind (order of ${10{^{-16}} J.m^{3}.s^{-1}}$ in the fast wind). Two types of turbulence are evidenced and shown to be dominated either by incompressible Alfvénic or magnetosonic-like fluctuations. Density fluctuations are shown to amplify the cascade rate and its spatial anisotropy in comparison with incompressible Alfvénic turbulence. Furthermore, for compressible magnetosonic fluctuations, large cascade rates are found to lie mostly near the linear kinetic instability of the mirror mode. New empirical power-laws are evidenced and relate ${|ε_C|}$ to the turbulent Mach number and the internal energy. These new finding have potential applications in distant astrophysical plasmas that are not accessible to in situ measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2017; v1 submitted 12 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Exact law for homogeneous compressible Hall magnetohydrodynamics turbulence
Authors:
Nahuel Andrés,
Sébastien Galtier,
Fouad Sahraoui
Abstract:
We derive the exact law for three-dimensional (3D) homogeneous compressible isothermal Hall magnetohydrodynamics (CHMHD) turbulence, without the assumption of isotropy. The Hall current is shown to introduce new flux and sources terms that act at the small scales (comparable or smaller than the ion skin depth) to significantly impact the turbulence dynamics. The new law provides an accurate means…
▽ More
We derive the exact law for three-dimensional (3D) homogeneous compressible isothermal Hall magnetohydrodynamics (CHMHD) turbulence, without the assumption of isotropy. The Hall current is shown to introduce new flux and sources terms that act at the small scales (comparable or smaller than the ion skin depth) to significantly impact the turbulence dynamics. The new law provides an accurate means to estimate for the first time the energy cascade rate over a broad range of scales covering the MHD inertial range and the sub-ion dispersive range in 3D numerical simulations and {\it in situ} spacecraft observations of compressible turbulence. This work is particularly relevant to astrophysical flows in which small scale density fluctuations cannot be ignored such as the solar wind, planetary magnetospheres and the interstellar medium (ISM).
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Energy Cascade Rate In Compressible Fast And Slow Solar Wind Turbulence
Authors:
L. Z. Hadid,
F. Sahraoui,
S. Galtier
Abstract:
Estimation of the energy cascade rate in the inertial range of solar wind turbulence has been done so far mostly within the incompressible magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) theory. Here, we go beyond that approximation to include plasma compressibility using a reduced form of a recently derived exact law for compressible, isothermal MHD turbulence. Using in-situ data from the THEMIS/ARTEMIS spacecraft in…
▽ More
Estimation of the energy cascade rate in the inertial range of solar wind turbulence has been done so far mostly within the incompressible magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) theory. Here, we go beyond that approximation to include plasma compressibility using a reduced form of a recently derived exact law for compressible, isothermal MHD turbulence. Using in-situ data from the THEMIS/ARTEMIS spacecraft in the fast and slow solar wind, we investigate in detail the role of the compressible fluctuations in modifying the energy cascade rate with respect to the prediction of the incompressible MHD model. In particular, we found that the energy cascade rate: i) is amplified particularly in the slow solar wind; ii) exhibits weaker fluctuations in spatial scales, which leads to a broader inertial range than the previous reported ones; iii) has a power law scaling with the turbulent Mach number; iv) has a lower level of spatial anisotropy. Other features of solar wind turbulence are discussed along with their comparison with previous studies that used incompressible or heuristic (non exact) compressible MHD models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Exact scaling laws for helical three-dimensional two-fluid turbulent plasmas
Authors:
Nahuel Andrés,
Sebastien Galtier,
Fouad Sahraoui
Abstract:
We derive exact scaling laws for a three-dimensional incompressible helical two-fluid plasma, without the assumption of isotropy. For each ideal invariant of the two-fluid model, i.e. the total energy, the electron helicity and the proton helicity, we derive simple scaling laws in terms of two-point increments correlation functions expressed in terms of the velocity field of each species and the m…
▽ More
We derive exact scaling laws for a three-dimensional incompressible helical two-fluid plasma, without the assumption of isotropy. For each ideal invariant of the two-fluid model, i.e. the total energy, the electron helicity and the proton helicity, we derive simple scaling laws in terms of two-point increments correlation functions expressed in terms of the velocity field of each species and the magnetic field. These variables are appropriate for comparison with \textit{in-situ} measurements in the solar wind at different spatial ranges and data from numerical simulations. Finally, with the exact scaling laws and dimensional analysis we predict the magnetic energy and electron helicity spectra for different ranges of scales.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2017; v1 submitted 30 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Intermittency in Weak Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
Authors:
Romain Meyrand,
Khurom H. Kiyani,
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
Intermittency is investigated using decaying direct numerical simulations of incompressible weak magnetohydrodynamic turbulence with a strong uniform magnetic field ${\bf b_0}$ and zero cross-helicity. At leading order, this regime is achieved via three-wave resonant interactions with the scattering of two of these waves on the third/slow mode for which $k_{\parallel} = 0$. When the interactions w…
▽ More
Intermittency is investigated using decaying direct numerical simulations of incompressible weak magnetohydrodynamic turbulence with a strong uniform magnetic field ${\bf b_0}$ and zero cross-helicity. At leading order, this regime is achieved via three-wave resonant interactions with the scattering of two of these waves on the third/slow mode for which $k_{\parallel} = 0$. When the interactions with the slow mode are artificially reduced the system exhibits an energy spectrum with $k_{\perp}^{-3/2}$, whereas the expected exact solution with $k_{\perp}^{-2}$ is recovered with the full nonlinear system. In the latter case, strong intermittency is found when the vector separation of structure functions is taken transverse to ${\bf b_0}$ - at odds with classical weak turbulence where self-similarity is expected. This surprising result, which is being reported here for the first time, may be explained by the influence of slow modes whose regime belongs to strong turbulence. We derive a new log--Poisson law, $ζ_p = p/8 +1 -(1/4)^{p/2}$, which fits perfectly the data and highlights the dominant role of current sheets.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Entanglement of helicity and energy in kinetic Alfven wave/whistler turbulence
Authors:
S. Galtier,
R. Meyrand
Abstract:
The role of magnetic helicity is investigated in kinetic Alfvén wave and oblique whistler turbulence in presence of a relatively intense external magnetic field $b_0 {\bf e_\parallel}$. In this situation, turbulence is strongly anisotropic and the fluid equations describing both regimes are the reduced electron magnetohydrodynamics (REMHD) whose derivation, originally made from the gyrokinetic the…
▽ More
The role of magnetic helicity is investigated in kinetic Alfvén wave and oblique whistler turbulence in presence of a relatively intense external magnetic field $b_0 {\bf e_\parallel}$. In this situation, turbulence is strongly anisotropic and the fluid equations describing both regimes are the reduced electron magnetohydrodynamics (REMHD) whose derivation, originally made from the gyrokinetic theory, is also obtained here from compressible Hall MHD. We use the asymptotic equations derived by Galtier \& Bhattacharjee (2003) to study the REMHD dynamics in the weak turbulence regime. The analysis is focused on the magnetic helicity equation for which we obtain the exact solutions: they correspond to the entanglement relation, $n+\tilde n = -6$, where $n$ and $\tilde n$ are the power law indices of the perpendicular (to ${\bf b_0}$) wave number magnetic energy and helicity spectra respectively. Therefore, the spectra derived in the past from the energy equation only, namely $n=-2.5$ and $\tilde n = - 3.5$, are not the unique solutions to this problem but rather characterize the direct energy cascade. The solution $\tilde n = -3$ is a limit imposed by the locality condition; it is also the constant helicity flux solution obtained heuristically. The results obtained offer a new paradigm to understand solar wind turbulence at sub-ion scales where it is often observed that $-3 < n < -2.5$.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Exact Relation with Two-point Correlation Functions and Phenomenological Approach for Compressible Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
Authors:
Supratik Banerjee,
Sébastien Galtier
Abstract:
Compressible isothermal magnetohydrodynamic turbulence is analyzed under the assumption of statistical homogeneity and in the asymptotic limit of large kinetic and magnetic Reynolds numbers. Following Kolmogorov we derive an exact relation for some two-point correlation functions which generalizes the expression recently found for hydrodynamics. We show that the magnetic field brings new source an…
▽ More
Compressible isothermal magnetohydrodynamic turbulence is analyzed under the assumption of statistical homogeneity and in the asymptotic limit of large kinetic and magnetic Reynolds numbers. Following Kolmogorov we derive an exact relation for some two-point correlation functions which generalizes the expression recently found for hydrodynamics. We show that the magnetic field brings new source and flux terms into the dynamics which may act on the inertial range similarly as a source or a sink for the mean energy transfer rate. The introduction of a uniform magnetic field simplifies significantly the exact relation for which a simple phenomenology may be given. A prediction for axisymmetric energy spectra is eventually proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Wave turbulence in magnetohydrodynamics
Authors:
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
This chapter reviews the recent progress made mainly during the last two decades on wave turbulence in magnetized plasmas (MHD, Hall MHD and electron MHD) in the incompressible and compressible cases. The emphasis is made on homogeneous and anisotropic turbulence which usually provides the best theoretical framework to investigate space and laboratory plasmas. The interplanetary medium and the sol…
▽ More
This chapter reviews the recent progress made mainly during the last two decades on wave turbulence in magnetized plasmas (MHD, Hall MHD and electron MHD) in the incompressible and compressible cases. The emphasis is made on homogeneous and anisotropic turbulence which usually provides the best theoretical framework to investigate space and laboratory plasmas. The interplanetary medium and the solar atmosphere are presented as two examples of media where anisotropic wave turbulence is relevant. The most important results of wave turbulence are reported and discussed in the context of space and simulated magnetized plasmas. Important issues and possible spurious interpretations are eventually discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Exact relation for correlation functions in compressible isothermal turbulence
Authors:
Sebastien Galtier,
Supratik Banerjee
Abstract:
Compressible isothermal turbulence is analyzed under the assumption of homogeneity and in the asymptotic limit of a high Reynolds number. An exact relation is derived for some two-point correlation functions which reveals a fundamental difference with the incompressible case. The main difference resides in the presence of a new type of term which acts on the inertial range similarly as a source or…
▽ More
Compressible isothermal turbulence is analyzed under the assumption of homogeneity and in the asymptotic limit of a high Reynolds number. An exact relation is derived for some two-point correlation functions which reveals a fundamental difference with the incompressible case. The main difference resides in the presence of a new type of term which acts on the inertial range similarly as a source or a sink for the mean energy transfer rate. When isotropy is assumed, compressible turbulence may be described by the relation, $- {2 \over 3} ε_{\rm{eff}} r = {\cal F}_r(r)$, where ${\cal F}_r$ is the radial component of the two-point correlation functions and $ε_{\rm{eff}}$ is an effective mean total energy injection rate. By dimensional arguments we predict that a spectrum in $k^{-5/3}$ may still be preserved at small scales if the density-weighted fluid velocity, $ρ^{1/3} \uu$, is used.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Third-order Elsässer moments in axisymmetric MHD turbulence
Authors:
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
Incompressible MHD turbulence is investigated under the presence of a uniform magnetic field $\bb0$. Such a situation is described in the correlation space by a divergence relation which expresses the statistical conservation of the Elsässer energy flux through the inertial range. The ansatz is made that the development of anisotropy, observed when $B_0$ is strong enough, implies a foliation of sp…
▽ More
Incompressible MHD turbulence is investigated under the presence of a uniform magnetic field $\bb0$. Such a situation is described in the correlation space by a divergence relation which expresses the statistical conservation of the Elsässer energy flux through the inertial range. The ansatz is made that the development of anisotropy, observed when $B_0$ is strong enough, implies a foliation of space correlation. A direct consequence is the possibility to derive a vectorial law for third-order Elsässer moments which is parametrized by the intensity of anisotropy. We use the so-called critical balance assumption to fix this parameter and find a unique expression.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
-
On the two-dimensional state in driven magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Barbara Bigot,
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
The dynamics of the two-dimensional (2D) state in driven tridimensional (3D) incompressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence is investigated through high-resolution direct numerical simulations and in the presence of an external magnetic field at various intensities. For such a flow the 2D state (or slow mode) and the 3D modes correspond respectively to spectral fluctuations in the plan…
▽ More
The dynamics of the two-dimensional (2D) state in driven tridimensional (3D) incompressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence is investigated through high-resolution direct numerical simulations and in the presence of an external magnetic field at various intensities. For such a flow the 2D state (or slow mode) and the 3D modes correspond respectively to spectral fluctuations in the plan $k_\parallel=0$ and in the area $k_\parallel>0$. It is shown that if initially the 2D state is set to zero it becomes non negligible in few turnover times particularly when the external magnetic field is strong. The maintenance of a large scale driving leads to a break for the energy spectra of 3D modes; when the driving is stopped the previous break is removed and a decay phase emerges with alfvénic fluctuations. For a strong external magnetic field the energy at large perpendicular scales lies mainly in the 2D state and in all situations a pinning effect is observed at small scales.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Nonlinear diffusion equations for anisotropic MHD turbulence with cross-helicity
Authors:
Sebastien Galtier,
Eric Buchlin
Abstract:
Nonlinear diffusion equations of spectral transfer are systematically derived for anisotropic magnetohydrodynamics in the regime of wave turbulence. The background of the analysis is the asymptotic Alfvén wave turbulence equations from which a differential limit is taken. The result is a universal diffusion-type equation in ${\bf k}$-space which describes in a simple way and without free parameter…
▽ More
Nonlinear diffusion equations of spectral transfer are systematically derived for anisotropic magnetohydrodynamics in the regime of wave turbulence. The background of the analysis is the asymptotic Alfvén wave turbulence equations from which a differential limit is taken. The result is a universal diffusion-type equation in ${\bf k}$-space which describes in a simple way and without free parameter the energy transport perpendicular to the external magnetic field ${\bf B_0}$ for transverse and parallel fluctuations. These equations are compatible with both the thermodynamic equilibrium and the finite flux spectra derived by Galtier et al. (2000); it improves therefore the model built heuristically by Litwick \& Goldreich (2003) for which only the second solution was recovered. This new system offers a powerful description of a wide class of astrophysical plasmas with non-zero cross-helicity.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2010; v1 submitted 20 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
A Universal Law for Solar-Wind Turbulence at Electron Scales
Authors:
R. Meyrand,
S. Galtier
Abstract:
The interplanetary magnetic fluctuation spectrum obeys a Kolmogorovian power law at scales above the proton inertial length and gyroradius which is well regarded as an inertial range. Below these scales a power law index around $-2.5$ is often measured and associated to nonlinear dispersive processes. Recent observations reveal a third region at scales below the electron inertial length. This regi…
▽ More
The interplanetary magnetic fluctuation spectrum obeys a Kolmogorovian power law at scales above the proton inertial length and gyroradius which is well regarded as an inertial range. Below these scales a power law index around $-2.5$ is often measured and associated to nonlinear dispersive processes. Recent observations reveal a third region at scales below the electron inertial length. This region is characterized by a steeper spectrum that some refer to it as the dissipation range. We investigate this range of scales in the electron magnetohydrodynamic approximation and derive an exact and universal law for a third-order structure function. This law can predict a magnetic fluctuation spectrum with an index of $-11/3$ which is in agreement with the observed spectrum at the smallest scales. We conclude on the possible existence of a third turbulence regime in the solar wind instead of a dissipation range as recently postulated.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Anisotropic turbulent model for solar coronal heating
Authors:
B. Bigot,
S. Galtier,
H. Politano
Abstract:
Context : We present a self-consistent model of solar coronal heating, originally developed by Heyvaert & Priest (1992), in which we include the dynamical effect of the background magnetic field along a coronal structure by using exact results from wave MHD turbulence (Galtier et al. 2000). Aims : We evaluate the heating rate and the microturbulent velocity for comparison with observations in th…
▽ More
Context : We present a self-consistent model of solar coronal heating, originally developed by Heyvaert & Priest (1992), in which we include the dynamical effect of the background magnetic field along a coronal structure by using exact results from wave MHD turbulence (Galtier et al. 2000). Aims : We evaluate the heating rate and the microturbulent velocity for comparison with observations in the quiet corona, active regions and also coronal holes. Methods :The coronal structures are assumed to be in a turbulent state maintained by the slow erratic motions of the magnetic footpoints. A description for the large-scale and the unresolved small-scale dynamics are given separately. From the latter, we compute exactly (or numerically for coronal holes) turbulent viscosites that are finally used in the former to close self-consistently the system and derive the heating flux expression. Results : We show that the heating rate and the turbulent velocity compare favorably with coronal observations. Conclusions : Although the Alfven wave turbulence regime is strongly anisotropic, and could reduce a priori the heating efficiency, it provides an unexpected satisfactory model of coronal heating for both magnetic loops and open magnetic field lines.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2008; v1 submitted 12 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
On the von Karman-Howarth equations for Hall MHD flows
Authors:
S. Galtier
Abstract:
The von Karman-Howarth equations are derived for three-dimensional (3D) Hall magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) in the case of an homogeneous and isotropic turbulence. From these equations, we derive exact scaling laws for the third-order correlation tensors. We show how these relations are compatible with previous heuristic and numerical results. These multi-scale laws provide a relevant tool to invest…
▽ More
The von Karman-Howarth equations are derived for three-dimensional (3D) Hall magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) in the case of an homogeneous and isotropic turbulence. From these equations, we derive exact scaling laws for the third-order correlation tensors. We show how these relations are compatible with previous heuristic and numerical results. These multi-scale laws provide a relevant tool to investigate the non-linear nature of the high frequency magnetic field fluctuations in the solar wind or, more generally, in any plasma where the Hall effect is important.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
Large-Scale Magnetic Field Re-generation by Resonant MHD Wave Interactions
Authors:
S. Galtier,
S. Nazarenko
Abstract:
We investigate numerically the long-time behavior of balanced Alfven wave turbulence forced at intermediate scales. Whereas the usual constant-flux solution is found at the smallest scales, two new scalings are obtained at the forcing scales and at the largest scales of the system. In the latter case we show, in particular, that the spectrum evolves first to a state determined by Loitsyansky inv…
▽ More
We investigate numerically the long-time behavior of balanced Alfven wave turbulence forced at intermediate scales. Whereas the usual constant-flux solution is found at the smallest scales, two new scalings are obtained at the forcing scales and at the largest scales of the system. In the latter case we show, in particular, that the spectrum evolves first to a state determined by Loitsyansky invariant and later a state close to the thermodynamic equipartition solution predicted by wave turbulence. The astrophysical implications for galactic magnetic field generation are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
-
Multi-scale Hall-MHD turbulence in the solar wind
Authors:
S. Galtier,
E. Buchlin
Abstract:
Solar wind magnetic fluctuation spectra exhibit a significant power law steepening at frequencies f>1Hz. The origin of this multi-scaling is investigated through dispersive Hall magnetohydrodynamics. We perform three-dimensional numerical simulations in the framework of a highly turbulent shell model and show that the large-scale magnetic fluctuations are characterized by a k^-5/3-type spectrum…
▽ More
Solar wind magnetic fluctuation spectra exhibit a significant power law steepening at frequencies f>1Hz. The origin of this multi-scaling is investigated through dispersive Hall magnetohydrodynamics. We perform three-dimensional numerical simulations in the framework of a highly turbulent shell model and show that the large-scale magnetic fluctuations are characterized by a k^-5/3-type spectrum which steepens at scales smaller than the ion inertial length d_i, to k^-7/3 if the magnetic energy overtakes the kinetic energy, or to k^-11/3 in the opposite case. These results are in agreement both with a heuristic description a la Kolmogorov, and with the range of power law indices found in the solar wind.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2007; v1 submitted 25 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Influence of the definition of dissipative events on their statistics
Authors:
Eric Buchlin,
Sebastien Galtier,
Marco Velli
Abstract:
A convenient and widely used way to study the turbulent plasma in the solar corona is to do statistics of properties of events (or structures), associated with flares, that can be found in observations or in numerical simulations. Numerous papers have followed such a methodology, using different definitions of an event, but the reasons behind the choice of a particular definition (and not anothe…
▽ More
A convenient and widely used way to study the turbulent plasma in the solar corona is to do statistics of properties of events (or structures), associated with flares, that can be found in observations or in numerical simulations. Numerous papers have followed such a methodology, using different definitions of an event, but the reasons behind the choice of a particular definition (and not another one) is very rarely discussed. We give here a comprehensive set of possible event definitions starting from a one-dimensional data set such as a time-series of energy dissipation. Each definition is then applied to a time-series of energy dissipation issued from simulations of a shell-model of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence as defined in Giuliani and Carbone (1998), or from a new model of coupled shell-models designed to represent a magnetic loop in the solar corona. We obtain distributions of the peak dissipation power, total energy, duration and waiting-time associated to each definition. These distributions are then investigated and compared, and the influence of the definition of an event on statistics is discussed. In particular, power-law distributions are more likely to appear when using a threshold. The sensitivity of the distributions to the definition of an event seems also to be weaker for events found in a highly intermittent time series. Some implications on statistical results obtained from observations are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2004;
originally announced November 2004.
-
Small-scale turbulent dynamo - a numerical investigation
Authors:
R. J. West,
S. Nazarenko,
J. P. Laval,
S. Galtier
Abstract:
We present the results of a numerical investigation of the turbulent kinematic dynamo problem in a high Prandtl number regime. The scales of the magnetic turbulence we consider are far smaller than the Kolmogorov dissipative scale, so that the magnetic wavepackets evolve in a nearly smooth velocity field. Firstly, we consider the Kraichnan-Kazantsev model (KKM) in which the strain matrix is take…
▽ More
We present the results of a numerical investigation of the turbulent kinematic dynamo problem in a high Prandtl number regime. The scales of the magnetic turbulence we consider are far smaller than the Kolmogorov dissipative scale, so that the magnetic wavepackets evolve in a nearly smooth velocity field. Firstly, we consider the Kraichnan-Kazantsev model (KKM) in which the strain matrix is taken to be independent of coordinate and Gaussian white in time. To simulate the KKM we use a stochastic Euler-Maruyama method. We test the theoretical predictions for the growth of rates of the magnetic energy and higher order moments (Kazantsev, 1968; Kulsrud & Anderson, 1992; Chertkov et al., 1999), the shape of the energy spectrum (Kazantsev, 1968; Kulsrud & Anderson, 1992; Schekochihin et al., 2000a; Nazarenko et al., 2003) and the behaviour of the polarisation and spectral flatness Nazarenko et al., 2003). In general, the results appear to be in good agreement with the theory, with the exception that the predicted decay of the polarisation in time is not reproduced well in the stochastic numerics. Secondly, in order to study the sensitivity of the KKM predictions to the choice of strain statistics, we perform additional simulations for the case of a Gaussian strain with a finite correlation time and also for a strain taken from a DNS data set. These experiments are based on non-stochastic schemes, using a timestep that is much smaller than the correlation time of the strain. We find that the KKM is generally insensitive to the choice of strain statistics and most KKM results, including the decay of the polarisation, are reproduced well. The only exception appears to be the flatness whose spectrum is not reproduced in accordance with the KKM predictions in these simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2003; v1 submitted 21 May, 2003;
originally announced May 2003.
-
A simplified numerical model of coronal energy dissipation based on reduced MHD
Authors:
E. Buchlin,
V. Aletti,
S. Galtier,
M. Velli,
G. Einaudi,
J. -C. Vial
Abstract:
A 3D model intermediate between cellular automata (CA) models and the reduced magnetohydrodynamic (RMHD) equations is presented to simulate solar impulsive events generated along a coronal magnetic loop. The model consists of a set of planes distributed along a magnetic loop between which the information propagates through Alfven waves. Statistical properties in terms of power-laws for energies…
▽ More
A 3D model intermediate between cellular automata (CA) models and the reduced magnetohydrodynamic (RMHD) equations is presented to simulate solar impulsive events generated along a coronal magnetic loop. The model consists of a set of planes distributed along a magnetic loop between which the information propagates through Alfven waves. Statistical properties in terms of power-laws for energies and durations of dissipative events are obtained, and their agreement with X-ray and UV flares observations is discussed. The existence of observational biases is also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2003; v1 submitted 19 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
A weak turbulence theory for incompressible MHD
Authors:
S. Galtier,
S. V. Nazarenko,
A. C. Newell,
A. Pouquet
Abstract:
We derive a weak turbulence formalism for incompressible MHD. Three-wave interactions lead to a system of kinetic equations for the spectral densities of energy and helicity. We find energy spectra solution of the kinetic equations. The constants of the spectra are computed exactly and found to depend on the amount of correlation between the velocity and the magnetic field. Comparison with sever…
▽ More
We derive a weak turbulence formalism for incompressible MHD. Three-wave interactions lead to a system of kinetic equations for the spectral densities of energy and helicity. We find energy spectra solution of the kinetic equations. The constants of the spectra are computed exactly and found to depend on the amount of correlation between the velocity and the magnetic field. Comparison with several numerical simulations and models is also made.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2000;
originally announced August 2000.
-
Statistical Study of Short Quiescent Times Between Flares
Authors:
Sebastien Galtier
Abstract:
The study of the statistical distribution of short quiescent times ($\le$ 30 minutes) between solar flares has been investigated on a 1D MHD model. A power law behaviour is found which indicates the existence of sympathetic flaring. This prediction is supported by recent observations.
The study of the statistical distribution of short quiescent times ($\le$ 30 minutes) between solar flares has been investigated on a 1D MHD model. A power law behaviour is found which indicates the existence of sympathetic flaring. This prediction is supported by recent observations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2000; v1 submitted 28 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
