-
Magnetically driven outflows in 3D common-envelope evolution of massive stars
Authors:
Marco Vetter,
Friedrich K. Roepke,
Fabian R. N. Schneider,
Rüdiger Pakmor,
Sebastian Ohlmann,
Javier Morán-Fraile,
Mike Y. M. Lau,
Giovanni Leidi,
Damien Gagnier,
Robert Andrassy
Abstract:
Recent three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical simulations of the common-envelope interaction revealed the self-consistent formation of bipolar magnetically driven outflows launched from a toroidal structure resembling a circumbinary disk. So far, the dynamical impact of bipolar outflows on the common-envelope phase remains uncertain and we aim to quantify its importance. We illustrate the impact…
▽ More
Recent three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical simulations of the common-envelope interaction revealed the self-consistent formation of bipolar magnetically driven outflows launched from a toroidal structure resembling a circumbinary disk. So far, the dynamical impact of bipolar outflows on the common-envelope phase remains uncertain and we aim to quantify its importance. We illustrate the impact on common-envelope evolution by comparing two simulations -- one with magnetic fields and one without -- using the three-dimensional moving-mesh hydrodynamics code AREPO. We focus on the specific case of a $10 M_\odot$ red supergiant star with a $5 M_\odot$ black hole companion. By the end of the magnetohydrodynamic simulations (after $\sim 1220$ orbits of the core binary system), about $6.4 \%$ of the envelope mass is ejected via the bipolar outflow, contributing to angular momentum extraction from the disk structure and core binary. The resulting enhanced torques reduce the final orbital separation by about $24 \%$ compared to the hydrodynamical scenario, while the overall envelope ejection remains dominated by recombination-driven equatorial winds. We analyze field amplification and outflow launching mechanisms, confirming consistency with earlier studies: magnetic fields are amplified by shear flows, and outflows are launched by a magneto-centrifugal process, supported by local shocks and magnetic pressure gradients. These outflows originate from $\sim 1.1$ times the orbital separation. We conclude that the magnetically driven outflows and their role in the dynamical interaction are a universal aspect, and we further propose an adaptation of the $α_\mathrm{CE}$-formalism by adjusting the final orbital energy with a factor of $1+ M_\mathrm{out}/μ$, where $M_\mathrm{out}$ is the mass ejected through the outflows and $μ$ the reduced mass of the core binary. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Journey to the center of the common envelope evolution. Inner dynamics of the post-dynamical inspiral
Authors:
Damien Gagnier,
Ondrej Pejcha
Abstract:
Three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of common envelope evolution are often terminated soon after the initial dynamical plunge of the companion transitions into a long-lasting post-dynamical inspiral with slowly varying semi-major axis, $a_\text{b}$. This premature termination is often due to insufficient numerical resolution and challenges associated with the softening of the gravitationa…
▽ More
Three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of common envelope evolution are often terminated soon after the initial dynamical plunge of the companion transitions into a long-lasting post-dynamical inspiral with slowly varying semi-major axis, $a_\text{b}$. This premature termination is often due to insufficient numerical resolution and challenges associated with the softening of the gravitational potential of the two cores. In this work, we use statically-refined 3D hydrodynamical simulations to study binaries orbiting inside a common envelope, exploring the effects of varying numerical resolution, $δ$, gravitational potential softening prescriptions, and the associated softening lengthscale, $ε$. We find that quantities such as the binary inspiral timescale or the volume-averaged shearing rate typically converge to asymptotic values only for $ε\le 0.1 a_\text{b}$ and $δ\le 6 \times 10^{-3}a_\text{b}$ with smaller $ε$ requiring correspondingly smaller $δ$. After a few tens of binary orbits, the two cores become surrounded by a corotating, nearly hydrostatic gas structure, resembling the shared envelope of a contact binary. We propose that this structure is responsible for the slowing down of the dynamical inspiral, leading to an asymptotic inspiral timescale of approximately $10^5$ orbital periods for a binary mass ratio $q=1/3$, and approximately $10^6$ orbital periods for a binary mass ratio $q=1$. By investigating kinetic helicity, we argue that the magnetic field is unlikely to organize into large-scale structures via the usual $α$--effect during the post-dynamical phase. Even in the absence of magnetic fields, we observe intermittent polar outflows collimated by partially centrifugally evacuated polar funnels. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Post-dynamical inspiral phase of common envelope evolution. The role of magnetic fields
Authors:
Damien Gagnier,
Ondrej Pejcha
Abstract:
During common envelope evolution, an initially weak magnetic field may undergo amplification by interacting with spiral density waves and turbulence generated in the stellar envelope by the inspiralling companion. Using 3D magnetohydrodynamical simulations on adaptively refined spherical grids with excised central regions, we studied the amplification of magnetic fields and their effect on the env…
▽ More
During common envelope evolution, an initially weak magnetic field may undergo amplification by interacting with spiral density waves and turbulence generated in the stellar envelope by the inspiralling companion. Using 3D magnetohydrodynamical simulations on adaptively refined spherical grids with excised central regions, we studied the amplification of magnetic fields and their effect on the envelope structure, dynamics, and the orbital evolution of the binary during the post-dynamical inspiral phase. About $95\%$ of magnetic energy amplification arises from magnetic field stretching, folding, and winding due to differential rotation and turbulence while compression against magnetic pressure accounts for the remaining $\sim 5\%$. Magnetic energy production peaks at a scale of $3a_\text{b}$, where $a_\text{b}$ is the semimajor axis of the central binary's orbit. Because the magnetic energy production declines at large radial scales, the conditions are not favorable for the formation of magnetically collimated bipolar jet-like outflows unless they are generated on small scales near the individual cores, which we did not resolve. Magnetic fields have a negligible impact on binary orbit evolution, mean kinetic energy, and the disk-like morphology of angular momentum transport, but turbulent Maxwell stress can dominate Reynolds stress when accretion onto the central binary is allowed, leading to an $α$-disk parameter of $\simeq 0.034$. Finally, we discovered accretion streams arising from the stabilizing effect of the magnetic tension from the toroidal field about the orbital plane, which prevents overdensities from being destroyed by turbulence and enables them to accumulate mass and eventually migrate toward the binary.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023; v1 submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Post-dynamical inspiral phase of common envelope evolution: Binary orbit evolution and angular momentum transport
Authors:
Damien Gagnier,
Ondřej Pejcha
Abstract:
After the companion dynamically plunges through the primary's envelope, the two cores remain surrounded by a common envelope and the decrease of the orbital period $P_\text{orb}$ stalls. The subsequent evolution has never been systematically explored with multidimensional simulations. For this study, we performed 3D hydrodynamical simulations of an envelope evolving under the influence of a centra…
▽ More
After the companion dynamically plunges through the primary's envelope, the two cores remain surrounded by a common envelope and the decrease of the orbital period $P_\text{orb}$ stalls. The subsequent evolution has never been systematically explored with multidimensional simulations. For this study, we performed 3D hydrodynamical simulations of an envelope evolving under the influence of a central binary star using an adaptively refined spherical grid. We followed the evolution over hundreds of orbits of the central binary to characterize the transport of angular momentum by advection, gravitational torques, turbulence, and viscosity. We find that local advective torques from the mean flow and Reynolds stresses associated with the turbulent flow dominate the angular momentum transport, which occurs outward in a disk-like structure about the orbital plane and inward along the polar axis. Turbulent transport is less efficient, but can locally significantly damp or enhance the net angular momentum radial transport and may even reverse its direction. Short-term variability in the envelope is remarkably similar to circumbinary disks, including the formation and destruction of lump-like overdensities, which enhance mass accretion and contribute to the outward transport of eccentricity generated in the vicinity of the binary. If the accretion onto the binary is allowed, the orbital decay timescale settles to a nearly constant value $τ_\text{b} \sim 10^3$ to $10^4\,P_\text{orb}$, while preventing accretion leads to a slowly increasing $τ_\text{b} \sim 10^5\,P_\text{orb}$ at the end of our simulations. Our results suggest that the post-dynamical orbital contraction and envelope ejection will slowly continue while the binary is surrounded by gas and that $τ_\text{b}$ is often much shorter than the thermal timescale of the envelope.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2023; v1 submitted 1 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Stress-driven spin-down of a viscous fluid within a spherical shell
Authors:
Damien Gagnier,
Michel Rieutord
Abstract:
We investigate the linear properties of the steady and axisymmetric stress-driven spin-down flow of a viscous fluid inside a spherical shell, both within the incompressible and anelastic approximations, and in the asymptotic limit of small viscosities. From boundary layer analysis, we derive an analytical geostrophic solution for the 3D incompressible steady flow, inside and outside the cylinder…
▽ More
We investigate the linear properties of the steady and axisymmetric stress-driven spin-down flow of a viscous fluid inside a spherical shell, both within the incompressible and anelastic approximations, and in the asymptotic limit of small viscosities. From boundary layer analysis, we derive an analytical geostrophic solution for the 3D incompressible steady flow, inside and outside the cylinder $\mathcal{C}$ that is tangent to the inner shell. The Stewartson layer that lies on $\mathcal{C}$ is composed of two nested shear layers of thickness $O(E^{2/7})$ and $O(E^{1/3})$. We derive the lowest order solution for the $E^{2/7}$-layer. A simple analysis of the $E^{1/3}$-layer laying along the tangent cylinder, reveals it to be the site of an upwelling flow of amplitude $O(E^{1/3})$. Despite its narrowness, this shear layer concentrates most of the global meridional kinetic energy of the spin-down flow. Furthermore, a stable stratification does not perturb the spin-down flow provided the Prandtl number is small enough. If this is not the case, the Stewartson layer disappears and meridional circulation is confined within the thermal layers. The scalings for the amplitude of the anelastic secondary flow have been found to be the same as for the incompressible flow in all three regions, at the lowest order. However, because the velocity no longer conforms the Taylor-Proudman theorem, its shape differs outside the tangent cylinder $\mathcal{C}$, that is, where differential rotation takes place. Finally, we find the settling of the steady-state to be reached on a viscous time for the weakly, strongly and thermally unstratified incompressible flows. Large density variations relevant to astro- and geophysical systems, tend to slightly shorten the transient.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2020; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Evolution of rotation in rapidly rotating early-type stars during the main sequence with 2D models
Authors:
D. Gagnier,
M. Rieutord,
C. Charbonnel,
B. Putigny,
F. Espinosa Lara
Abstract:
The understanding of the rotational evolution of early-type stars is deeply related to that of anisotropic mass and angular momentum loss. In this paper, we aim to clarify the rotational evolution of rapidly rotating early-type stars along the main sequence (MS). We have used the 2D ESTER code to compute and evolve isolated rapidly rotating early-type stellar models along the MS, with and without…
▽ More
The understanding of the rotational evolution of early-type stars is deeply related to that of anisotropic mass and angular momentum loss. In this paper, we aim to clarify the rotational evolution of rapidly rotating early-type stars along the main sequence (MS). We have used the 2D ESTER code to compute and evolve isolated rapidly rotating early-type stellar models along the MS, with and without anisotropic mass loss. We show that stars with $Z=0.02$ and masses between $5$ and $7~M_\odot$ reach criticality during the main sequence provided their initial angular velocity is larger than 50% of the Keplerian one. More massive stars are subject to radiation-driven winds and to an associated loss of mass and angular momentum. We find that this angular momentum extraction from the outer layers can prevent massive stars from reaching critical rotation and greatly reduce the degree of criticality at the end of the MS. Our model includes the so-called bi-stability jump of the $\dot{M}-T_{\rm eff}$ relation of 1D-models. This discontinuity now shows up in the latitude variations of the mass-flux surface density, endowing rotating massive stars with either a single-wind regime (no discontinuity) or a two-wind regime (a discontinuity). In the two-winds-regime, mass loss and angular momentum loss are strongly increased at low latitudes inducing a faster slow-down of the rotation. However, predicting the rotational fate of a massive star is difficult, mainly because of the non-linearity of the phenomena involved and their strong dependence on uncertain prescriptions. Moreover, the very existence of the bi-stability jump in mass-loss rate remains to be substantiated by observations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Critical angular velocity and anisotropic mass loss of rotating stars with radiation-driven winds
Authors:
D. Gagnier,
M. Rieutord,
C. Charbonnel,
G. Putigny,
F. Espinosa Lara
Abstract:
The understanding of the evolution of early-type stars is tightly related to that of the effects of rapid rotation. For massive stars, rapid rotation combines with their strong radiation-driven wind. The aim of this paper is to investigate two questions that are prerequisite to the study of the evolution of massive rapidly rotating stars: (i) What is the critical angular velocity of a star when ra…
▽ More
The understanding of the evolution of early-type stars is tightly related to that of the effects of rapid rotation. For massive stars, rapid rotation combines with their strong radiation-driven wind. The aim of this paper is to investigate two questions that are prerequisite to the study of the evolution of massive rapidly rotating stars: (i) What is the critical angular velocity of a star when radiative acceleration is significant in its atmosphere? (ii) How do mass and angular momentum loss depend on the rotation rate? To investigate fast rotation, which makes stars oblate, we used the 2D ESTER models and a simplified approach, the $ω$-model, which gives the latitudinal dependence of the radiative flux in a centrifugally flattened radiative envelope. We find that radiative acceleration only mildly influences the critical angular velocity, at least for stars with masses lower than 40 Msun. We explain this mild reduction of the critical angular velocity compared to the classical Keplerian angular velocity by the combined effects of gravity darkening and a reduced equatorial opacity that is due to the centrifugal acceleration. To answer the second question, we first devised a model of the local surface mass flux, which we calibrated with previously developed 1D models. The discontinuity (the so-called bi-stability jump) included in the $\dot{M}-T_{\rm eff}$ relation of 1D models means that the mass flux of a fast-rotating star is controlled by either a single wind or a two-wind regime. Mass and angular momentum losses are strong around the equator if the star is in the two-wind regime. We also show that the difficulty of selecting massive stars that are viewed pole-on makes detecting the discontinuity in the relation between mass loss and effective temperature also quite challenging.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Turbulent transport by diffusive stratified shear flows: from local to global models. Part II: Limitations of local models
Authors:
D. Gagnier,
P. Garaud
Abstract:
This paper continues the systematic investigation of diffusive shear instabilities initiated in Part I of this series. In this work, we primarily focus on quantifying the impact of non-local mixing, which is not taken into account in Zahn's mixing model \citep{Zahn92}. We present the results of direct numerical simulations in a new model setup designed to contain coexisting laminar and turbulent s…
▽ More
This paper continues the systematic investigation of diffusive shear instabilities initiated in Part I of this series. In this work, we primarily focus on quantifying the impact of non-local mixing, which is not taken into account in Zahn's mixing model \citep{Zahn92}. We present the results of direct numerical simulations in a new model setup designed to contain coexisting laminar and turbulent shear layers. As in Part I, we use the Low Péclet Number approximation of \citet{Lign1999} to model the evolution of the perturbations. Our main findings are twofold. First, turbulence is not necessarily generated whenever Zahn's nonlinear criterion \citep{Zahn1974} $J{\rm Pr} < (J{\rm Pr})_c$ is satisfied, where $J=N^2/S^2$ is the local gradient Richardson number, ${\rm Pr} = ν/ κ_T$ is the Prandtl number, and $(J{\rm Pr})_c \simeq 0.007$. We have demonstrated that the presence or absence of turbulent mixing in this limit hysteretically depends on the history of the shear layer. Second, Zahn's nonlinear instability criterion only approximately locates the edge of the turbulent layer, and mixing beyond the region where $J{\rm Pr} < (J{\rm Pr})_c$ can also take place in a manner analogous to convective overshoot. We found that the turbulent kinetic energy decays roughly exponentially beyond the edge of the shear-unstable region, on a lengthscale $δ$ that is directly proportional to the scale of the turbulent eddies, which are themselves of the order of the Zahn scale (see Part I). Our results suggest that mixing by diffusive shear instabilities should be modeled with more care than is currently standard in stellar evolution codes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2018; v1 submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Turbulent transport by diffusive stratified shear flows: from local to global models. Part I: Numerical simulations of a stratified plane Couette flow
Authors:
P. Garaud,
D. Gagnier,
J. Verhoeven
Abstract:
Shear-induced turbulence could play a significant role in mixing momentum and chemical species in stellar radiation zones, as discussed by Zahn (1974). In this paper we analyze the results of direct numerical simulations of stratified plane Couette flows, in the limit of rapid thermal diffusion, to measure the turbulent diffusivity and turbulent viscosity as a function of the local shear and the l…
▽ More
Shear-induced turbulence could play a significant role in mixing momentum and chemical species in stellar radiation zones, as discussed by Zahn (1974). In this paper we analyze the results of direct numerical simulations of stratified plane Couette flows, in the limit of rapid thermal diffusion, to measure the turbulent diffusivity and turbulent viscosity as a function of the local shear and the local stratification. We find that the stability criterion proposed by Zahn (1974), namely that the product of the gradient Richardson number and the Prandtl number must be smaller than a critical values $(J\Pr)_c$ for instability, adequately accounts for the transition to turbulence in the flow, with $(J\Pr)_c \simeq 0.007$. This result recovers and confirms the prior findings of Prat et al. (2016). Zahn's model for the turbulent diffusivity and viscosity (Zahn 1992), namely that the mixing coefficient should be proportional to the ratio of the thermal diffusivity to the gradient Richardson number, does not satisfactorily match our numerical data when applied as is. It fails (as expected) in the limit of large stratification where the Richardson number exceeds the aforementioned threshold for instability, but it also fails in the limit of low stratification where the turbulent eddy scale becomes limited by the computational domain size. We propose a revised model for turbulent mixing by diffusive stratified shear instabilities, that now properly accounts for both limits, fits our data satisfactorily, and recovers Zahn's 1992 model in the limit of large Reynolds numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
