-
Testing the accuracy of SED modeling techniques using the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog
Authors:
Nicholas Faucher,
Michael R. Blanton
Abstract:
We use simulated galaxy observations from the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog to test the accuracy of Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) modeling techniques. SED modeling is an essential tool for inferring star-formation histories from nearby galaxy observations, but is fraught with difficulty due to our incomplete understanding of stellar populations, chemical enrichment processes, and the nonlinear, geometr…
▽ More
We use simulated galaxy observations from the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog to test the accuracy of Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) modeling techniques. SED modeling is an essential tool for inferring star-formation histories from nearby galaxy observations, but is fraught with difficulty due to our incomplete understanding of stellar populations, chemical enrichment processes, and the nonlinear, geometry-dependent effects of dust on our observations. The NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog uses hydrodynamic simulations and radiative transfer to produce SEDs from the ultraviolet (UV) through the infrared (IR), accounting for the effects of dust. We use the commonly used Prospector software to perform inference on these SEDs, and compare the inferred stellar masses and star-formation rates (SFRs) to the known values in the simulation. We match the stellar population models to isolate the effects of differences in the star-formation history, the chemical evolution history, and the dust. We find that the combined effect of model mismatches for high mass ($> 10^{9.5} M_{\odot}$) galaxies leads to inferred SFRs that are on average underestimated by a factor of 2 when fit to UV through IR photometry, and a factor of 3 when fit to UV through optical photometry. These biases lead to significant inaccuracies in the resulting sSFR-mass relations, with UV through optical fits showing particularly strong deviations from the true relation of the simulated galaxies. In the context of massive existing and upcoming photometric surveys, these results highlight that star-formation history inference from photometry remains imprecise and inaccurate, and that there is a pressing need for more realistic testing of existing techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Quantitatively rating galaxy simulations against real observations with anomaly detection
Authors:
Zehao Jin,
Andrea V. Macciò,
Nicholas Faucher,
Mario Pasquato,
Tobias Buck,
Keri L. Dixon,
Nikhil Arora,
Marvin Blank,
Pavle Vulanović
Abstract:
Cosmological galaxy formation simulations are powerful tools to understand the complex processes that govern the formation and evolution of galaxies. However, evaluating the realism of these simulations remains a challenge. The two common approaches for evaluating galaxy simulations is either through scaling relations based on a few key physical galaxy properties, or through a set of pre-defined m…
▽ More
Cosmological galaxy formation simulations are powerful tools to understand the complex processes that govern the formation and evolution of galaxies. However, evaluating the realism of these simulations remains a challenge. The two common approaches for evaluating galaxy simulations is either through scaling relations based on a few key physical galaxy properties, or through a set of pre-defined morphological parameters based on galaxy images. This paper proposes a novel image-based method for evaluating the quality of galaxy simulations using unsupervised deep learning anomaly detection techniques. By comparing full galaxy images, our approach can identify and quantify discrepancies between simulated and observed galaxies. As a demonstration, we apply this method to SDSS imaging and NIHAO simulations with different physics models, parameters, and resolution. We further compare the metric of our method to scaling relations as well as morphological parameters. We show that anomaly detection is able to capture similarities and differences between real and simulated objects that scaling relations and morphological parameters are unable to cover, thus indeed providing a new point of view to validate and calibrate cosmological simulations against observed data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
A dust attenuation model inspired by the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog
Authors:
Nicholas Faucher,
Michael R. Blanton
Abstract:
We use simulated attenuation curves from the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog to test the flexibility of commonly used dust attenuation models in the face of the variations expected from realistic star-dust geometries. Motivated by lack of flexibility in these existing models, we propose a novel dust attenuation model with three free parameters that can accurately recover the simulated attenuation curves as we…
▽ More
We use simulated attenuation curves from the NIHAO-SKIRT-Catalog to test the flexibility of commonly used dust attenuation models in the face of the variations expected from realistic star-dust geometries. Motivated by lack of flexibility in these existing models, we propose a novel dust attenuation model with three free parameters that can accurately recover the simulated attenuation curves as well as the best-fitting curves from the commonly used models. This new model is fully analytic and treats all starlight equally, in contrast to two-component dust attenuation models. We use the parametrization to investigate the relationship between the overall attenuation law shape and the strength of the 2175 Å bump. Our results indicate variation in star-dust geometry leads these features to correlate tightly, with grayer attenuation curves having weaker bumps.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Panchromatic simulated galaxy observations from the NIHAO project
Authors:
Nicholas Faucher,
Michael R. Blanton,
Andrea V. Macciò
Abstract:
We present simulated galaxy spectral energy distributions (SEDs) from the far ultraviolet through the far infrared, created using hydrodynamic simulations and radiative transfer calculations, suitable for the validation of SED modeling techniques. SED modeling is an essential tool for inferring star formation histories from nearby galaxy observations, but is fraught with difficulty due to our inco…
▽ More
We present simulated galaxy spectral energy distributions (SEDs) from the far ultraviolet through the far infrared, created using hydrodynamic simulations and radiative transfer calculations, suitable for the validation of SED modeling techniques. SED modeling is an essential tool for inferring star formation histories from nearby galaxy observations, but is fraught with difficulty due to our incomplete understanding of stellar populations, chemical enrichment processes, and the non-linear, geometry dependent effects of dust on our observations. Our simulated SEDs will allow us to assess the accuracy of these inferences against galaxies with known ground truth. To create the SEDs, we use simulated galaxies from the NIHAO suite and the radiative transfer code SKIRT. We explore different sub-grid post-processing recipes, using color distributions and their dependence on axis ratio of galaxies in the nearby universe to tune and validate them. We find that sub-grid post-processing recipes that mitigate limitations in the temporal and spatial resolution of the simulations are required for producing FUV to FIR photometry that statistically reproduce the colors of galaxies in the nearby universe. With this paper we release resolved photometry and spatially integrated spectra for our sample galaxies, each from a range of different viewing angles. Our simulations predict that there is a large variation in attenuation laws among galaxies, and that from any particular viewing angle that energy balance between dust attenuation and reemission can be violated by up to a factor of 3. These features are likely to affect SED modeling accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
