-
Strontium I, III, IV and V: Electron Impact Excitation Data for Kilonovae and White Dwarf Diagnostic Applications
Authors:
David J. Dougan,
Niall E. McElroy,
Connor P. Ballance,
Catherine A. Ramsbottom
Abstract:
Strontium (Sr) emissions have been observed across a wide range of astrophysical phenomena, from kilonovae (KNe) events to white dwarf (WD) stars. Precise and extensive atomic data for low ionisation stages of Sr is required for accurate theoretical modelling and to improve our understanding of evolutionary pathways. We calculated energy levels, Einstein A coefficients and electron-impact excitati…
▽ More
Strontium (Sr) emissions have been observed across a wide range of astrophysical phenomena, from kilonovae (KNe) events to white dwarf (WD) stars. Precise and extensive atomic data for low ionisation stages of Sr is required for accurate theoretical modelling and to improve our understanding of evolutionary pathways. We calculated energy levels, Einstein A coefficients and electron-impact excitation collision strengths for Sr I, Sr III, Sr IV and Sr V at the temperature and density ranges of interest in KNe and WD research. We developed new target structures using the GRASP0 and AUTOSTRUCTURE packages. The energies and A-values arising from the new structures were found to be in good agreement with experimental and theoretical equivalents reported in the literature. Maxwellian averaged electron impact collision strengths were calculated using the R-matrix approach, as applied through the DARC and RMBP coding packages. These are presented in adf04 file format. The new data sets allowed us to construct synthetic spectra for the first five ionisation stages of Sr and probe possible density and temperature diagnostic lines. The synthetic spectra within the KNe regime revealed possible Sr IV and Sr V candidate lines at 1027.69nm and 1203.35nm respectively. These may provide useful benchmarks for determining the extent of Sr ionisation that can be reached in an evolving KNe event. Additional diagnostic lines were found to be poor across the Sr ion stages for both KNe and WD regimes due to most levels being in either coronal or Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE) conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Searching for new physics using high precision absorption spectroscopy; continuum placement uncertainties and the fine structure constant in strong gravity
Authors:
Chung-Chi Lee,
John K. Webb,
Darren Dougan,
Vladimir A. Dzuba,
Victor V. Flambaum,
Dinko Milaković
Abstract:
Searches for variations of fundamental constants require a comprehensive understanding of measurement errors. This paper examines a source of error that is usually overlooked: the impact of continuum placement error. We investigate the problem using a high resolution, high signal to noise spectrum of the white dwarf G191$-$B2B. Narrow photospheric absorption lines allow us to search for new physic…
▽ More
Searches for variations of fundamental constants require a comprehensive understanding of measurement errors. This paper examines a source of error that is usually overlooked: the impact of continuum placement error. We investigate the problem using a high resolution, high signal to noise spectrum of the white dwarf G191$-$B2B. Narrow photospheric absorption lines allow us to search for new physics in the presence of a gravitational field approximately $10^4$ times that on Earth. Modelling photospheric lines requires knowing the underlying spectral continuum level. We describe the development of a fully automated, objective, and reproducible continuum estimation method. Measurements of the fine structure constant are produced using several continuum models. The results show that continuum placement variations result in small systematic shifts in the centroids of narrow photospheric absorption lines which impact significantly on fine structure constant measurements. This effect should therefore be included in the error budgets of future measurements. Our results suggest that continuum placement variations should be investigated in other contexts, including fine structure constant measurements in stars other than white dwarfs. The analysis presented here is based on NiV absorption lines in the photosphere of G191$-$B2B. Curiously, the inferred measurement of the fine structure constant obtained in this paper using NiV (the least negative of our measurements is $Δα/α= -1.462 \pm 1.121 \times 10^{-5}$) is inconsistent with the most recent previous G191$-$B2B photospheric measurement using FeV ($Δα/α= 6.36 \pm 0.35_{stat} \pm 1.84_{sys} \times 10^{-5}$). Given both measurements are derived from the same spectrum, we presume (but in this work are unable to check) that this 3.2$σ$ difference results from unknown laboratory wavelength systematics.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2025; v1 submitted 1 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Searching for new physics using high precision absorption spectroscopy; continuum placement uncertainties and $Δα/α$ towards the quasar PHL957
Authors:
John K. Webb,
Chung-Chi Lee,
Dinko Milaković,
Darren Dougan,
Vladimir A. Dzuba,
Victor V. Flambaum
Abstract:
Detecting or placing upper limits on spacetime variations of fundamental constants requires quantifying every potential source of uncertainty. We continue our previous study into the impact of continuum variations on measurements of the fine structure constant, here in the context of quasar absorption systems. An automated (hence objective and reproducible) continuum modelling method is reported i…
▽ More
Detecting or placing upper limits on spacetime variations of fundamental constants requires quantifying every potential source of uncertainty. We continue our previous study into the impact of continuum variations on measurements of the fine structure constant, here in the context of quasar absorption systems. An automated (hence objective and reproducible) continuum modelling method is reported in an accompanying paper. We apply the method to the $z_{abs}=1.7975$ absorption system towards the quasar PHL957. Multiple continuum fits are generated, and for each, we derive independent models of the system, each giving its own measurement of the fine structure constant $α$. This process isolates and quantifies the error contribution associated with continuum placement uncertainty. This source of uncertainty, ignored in many previous measurements, arises in two ways: (i) slight local continuum tilt uncertainty generates small line shifts, and (ii) different continuum estimates produce slightly different kinematic structures in the absorption system model. Taking continuum placement uncertainty into account, the new PHL957 measurement we obtain is $Δα/α= -0.53^{+5.45}_{-5.51} \times 10^{-6}$. This measurement assumes terrestrial magnesium isotopic abundances. Recommendations are provided for future $α$ measurements. Finally, we also note the potential importance of the effects identified here for future redshift drift experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Measuring the fine structure constant on white dwarf surfaces; uncertainties from continuum placement variations
Authors:
Chung-Chi Lee,
John K. Webb,
Darren Dougan,
Vladimir A. Dzuba,
Victor V. Flambaum
Abstract:
Searches for variations of fundamental constants require accurate measurement errors. There are several potential sources of errors and quantifying each one accurately is essential. This paper addresses one source of uncertainty relating to measuring the fine structure constant on white dwarf surfaces. Detailed modelling of photospheric absorption lines requires knowing the underlying spectral con…
▽ More
Searches for variations of fundamental constants require accurate measurement errors. There are several potential sources of errors and quantifying each one accurately is essential. This paper addresses one source of uncertainty relating to measuring the fine structure constant on white dwarf surfaces. Detailed modelling of photospheric absorption lines requires knowing the underlying spectral continuum level. Here we describe the development of a fully automated, objective, and reproducible continuum estimation method, based on fitting cubic splines to carefully selected data regions. Example fits to the Hubble Space Telescope spectrum of the white dwarf G191-B2B are given. We carry out measurements of the fine structure constant using two continuum models. The results show that continuum placement variations result in small systematic shifts in the centroids of narrow photospheric absorption lines which impact significantly on fine structure constant measurements. This effect must therefore be included in the overall error budget of future measurements. Our results also suggest that continuum placement variations should be investigated in other contexts, including fine structure constant measurements in stars other than white dwarfs, quasar absorption line measurements of the fine structure constant, and quasar measurements of cosmological redshift drift.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Do the constants of nature couple to strong gravitational fields?
Authors:
S. P. Preval,
M. A. Barstow,
J. B. Holberg,
J. D. Barrow,
J. C. Berengut,
J. K. Webb,
D. Dougan,
J. Hu
Abstract:
Recently, white dwarf stars have found a new use in the fundamental physics community. Many prospective theories of the fundamental interactions of Nature allow traditional constants, like the fine structure constant $α$, to vary in some way. A study by Berengut et al. (2013) used the Fe/Ni V line measurements made by Preval et al. (2013) from the hot DA white dwarf G191-B2B, in an attempt to dete…
▽ More
Recently, white dwarf stars have found a new use in the fundamental physics community. Many prospective theories of the fundamental interactions of Nature allow traditional constants, like the fine structure constant $α$, to vary in some way. A study by Berengut et al. (2013) used the Fe/Ni V line measurements made by Preval et al. (2013) from the hot DA white dwarf G191-B2B, in an attempt to detect any variation in $α$. It was found that the Fe V lines indicated an increasing alpha, whereas the Ni V lines indicated a decreasing alpha. Possible explanations for this could be misidentification of the lines, inaccurate atomic data, or wavelength dependent distortion in the spectrum. We examine the first two cases by using a high S/N reference spectrum from the hot sdO BD+28$^{\circ}$4211 to calibrate the Fe/Ni V atomic data. With this new data, we re-evaluate the work of Berengut et al. (2013) to derive a new constraint on the variation of alpha in a gravitational field.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2014; v1 submitted 3 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
