Thermochemical models of outer core convection with heterogeneous core-mantle boundary heat flux
Authors:
Souvik Naskar,
Jonathan E. Mound,
Christopher J. Davies,
Andrew T. Clarke
Abstract:
Thermochemical convection in Earth's outer core is driven by the crystallisation of the inner core that releases latent heat and light elements. A key question in core dynamics is whether a stable layer exists just below the core-mantle boundary. Recent core convection simulations, accounting for CMB heterogeneities, propose locally stable regions (or regional inversion lenses, RILs) rather than a…
▽ More
Thermochemical convection in Earth's outer core is driven by the crystallisation of the inner core that releases latent heat and light elements. A key question in core dynamics is whether a stable layer exists just below the core-mantle boundary. Recent core convection simulations, accounting for CMB heterogeneities, propose locally stable regions (or regional inversion lenses, RILs) rather than a global layer, allowing both stable and unstable regions to coexist. In this study, we consider a suite of numerical simulations of thermal, chemical, and thermochemical convection models focussed on Ekman number ($E=10^{-5}$) with thermal and chemical flux Rayleigh numbers $\widetilde{Ra}_T=30-4000$ and $\widetilde{Ra}_C=30-100000$, and thermal and chemical Prandtl numbers $Pr_T=1$ and $Pr_ΞΎ=10$. Analysis of purely chemical models reveals light element accumulation (LEA) below the CMB, resulting in either locally stable regions near the poles or global layers, depending on the strength of chemical forcing. These chemically stratified regions persist in our thermochemical models even if the thermal field is fully destabilising. The addition of a heterogeneous CMB heat flux leads to the formation of RILs driven by thermal stratification. Stable regions in these thermochemical models have varying locations, properties, and morphologies depending on whether thermal or chemical convection dominates. In the investigated parameter range, these RILs are O(100 km) thick, and their strength and thickness generally increase with the strength of thermal driving; they are comparatively less sensitive to the strength of chemical driving. Our simulations reveal a diverse range of possible stable regions and/or a global layer at the top of Earth's core, with a seismically plausible range of thickness and strength, which may also have a signature in geomagnetic observations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
Accessing the dipole-multipole transition in rapidly rotating spherical shell dynamos
Authors:
Andrew T. Clarke,
Christopher J. Davies,
Souvik Naskar,
Stephen J. Mason
Abstract:
Polarity reversals are a key feature of Earth's magnetic field, yet the processes governing them are still poorly understood. Dipole reversals have been found in many numerical dynamo simulations and often occur close to the transition between dipolar and multipolar regimes. Simulated conditions are far from those in Earth's liquid iron core because of the long runtimes needed to capture polarity…
▽ More
Polarity reversals are a key feature of Earth's magnetic field, yet the processes governing them are still poorly understood. Dipole reversals have been found in many numerical dynamo simulations and often occur close to the transition between dipolar and multipolar regimes. Simulated conditions are far from those in Earth's liquid iron core because of the long runtimes needed to capture polarity transitions. We develop a unidimensional path theory in an attempt to simplify the search for the dipole-multipole transition at increasingly realistic physical conditions. We build 3 paths, all based on a constant magnetic Reynolds number $Rm$; one aiming for Magnetic, Coriolis, and Archimedean (MAC), and 2 aiming for inertia-MAC force balance. We add inertia due to its role in simulated reversals. Results show reasonable agreement with predictions within the accessible parameter space, but deviate from predicted behaviour for certain quantities, e.g. magnetic field strength and magnetic/kinetic energy ratio. Further, simulations move into the dipolar non-reversing regime as they are advanced along the path. By increasing the buoyancy driving (via higher Rayleigh number) above the values predicted by the path theory, we are able to access the dipole-multipole transition down to an Ekman number $E\sim 10^{-6}$, comparable to the most extreme conditions reported to date. Results demonstrate that our approach is an efficient method for seeking the dipole-multipole transition at low $E$. However, the conditions under which we access the dipole-multipole transition become increasingly hard to access numerically and also increasingly unrealistic because $Rm$ rises beyond plausible bounds inferred from geophysical observations. Future work combining path theory with variations in the core buoyancy distribution, appears a promising approach to accessing the transition at extreme physical conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
