-
Three-Minute Oscillations in Sunspot's Penumbrae and Superpenumbrae. Alfvénic or Sound?
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov
Abstract:
In the immediate sunspots' vicinity -- their superpenumbra -- 3-minute line-of-sight (LOS) velocity oscillations dominate in the photosphere and chromosphere. Oscillations of similar periods are also registered in the transition region and lower corona above active regions. The goal of the work is to clarify whether these LOS velocity oscillations are manifestations of Alfvénic waves in the lower…
▽ More
In the immediate sunspots' vicinity -- their superpenumbra -- 3-minute line-of-sight (LOS) velocity oscillations dominate in the photosphere and chromosphere. Oscillations of similar periods are also registered in the transition region and lower corona above active regions. The goal of the work is to clarify whether these LOS velocity oscillations are manifestations of Alfvénic waves in the lower solar atmosphere. The study is based on three sunspots with the use of the Solar Dynamics Observatory data. Additional observations of a sunspot were carried out at ground-based Automated Solar Telescope. We use narrow-band frequency filtration (5.6--5.8 mHz) of the LOS velocity, magnetic field, and intensity signals of the Fe i 6173 A spectral line. For the analysis, we used 90-minute long series. We come to the conclusion that the 3-minute oscillations in the LOS velocity signals result from magnetoacoustic waves rather than from Alfvénic waves. However, oscillations registered in magnetic field signals indicate that Alfvénic waves may be present already in the photosphere. Further research requires simultaneous observations of LOS velocity, magnetic field strength, spectral line width, and intensity carried out at two heights of the solar atmosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Problems in Observation and Identification of Torsional Waves in the Lower Solar Atmosphere
Authors:
A. A. Chelpanov,
N. I. Kobanov
Abstract:
Registering periodic variations of spectral line widths serves as the main method for observing torsional Alfvén waves. Theoretically, the method seems valid, yet it entails a number of caveats when applied to data. For instance, the amplitudes of these observations should vary with changes of the location on the disk, and they should be associated with no intensity oscillations. We analyze extens…
▽ More
Registering periodic variations of spectral line widths serves as the main method for observing torsional Alfvén waves. Theoretically, the method seems valid, yet it entails a number of caveats when applied to data. For instance, the amplitudes of these observations should vary with changes of the location on the disk, and they should be associated with no intensity oscillations. We analyze extensive observational material of periodic non-thermal variations of line widths in coronal holes and facular regions in a number of spectral lines: Hα, He I 10830 Å, Ca II 8542 Å, Ba II 4554 Å. In most cases, we detected associated intensity oscillations at similar frequencies. Besides, we observed no centre-to-limb dependency. This calls for a discussion on the practical validity of the method and on the alternative explanations for the nature of non-thermal variations of spectral line widths. Based on our observations, we consider registering line profile broadening a necessary but not sufficient means for unambiguous identification of torsional Alfvén waves in the lower solar atmosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Oscillation Dynamics in Short-Lived Facula Regions during Their Lifetime
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov
Abstract:
We performed a multi-wave study of the oscillation dynamic in short-lived facula regions during their lifetime. We studied oscillations in five regions, three of which belonged to the beginning of the current solar activity cycle, and two of them existed at the end of the previous cycle. We found that in the facula regions of the current cycle, low-frequency 1-2 mHz oscillation dominated at the ea…
▽ More
We performed a multi-wave study of the oscillation dynamic in short-lived facula regions during their lifetime. We studied oscillations in five regions, three of which belonged to the beginning of the current solar activity cycle, and two of them existed at the end of the previous cycle. We found that in the facula regions of the current cycle, low-frequency 1-2 mHz oscillation dominated at the early stages of the faculae formation, while in the regions of the previous cycle, five-minute oscillations dominated at this stage. At the maximal development phase of all the facula regions, the locations of observed low frequencies are closely related to those of the coronal loops. These results support the version that the sources of the low-frequency oscillations in loops lie loops' foot points.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Using Flare-Induced Modulation of Three- and Five-Minute Oscillations for Studying Wave Propagation in the Solar Atmosphere
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov
Abstract:
We propose a method for diagnosing the physical conditions in the solar atmosphere using an increase in oscillation amplitudes resulting from minuscule solar flares. As an example, we consider a B2 flare, which caused a sharp short-lived increase in the amplitude of three- and five-minute oscillations in the lower layers of the solar atmosphere. Enhanced three- and five-minute oscillations propaga…
▽ More
We propose a method for diagnosing the physical conditions in the solar atmosphere using an increase in oscillation amplitudes resulting from minuscule solar flares. As an example, we consider a B2 flare, which caused a sharp short-lived increase in the amplitude of three- and five-minute oscillations in the lower layers of the solar atmosphere. Enhanced three- and five-minute oscillations propagated from the lower layers of the atmosphere into the corona. Such short oscillation trains made it possible to remove the uncertainties arising in the measurements of the phase and group lags between the layers. In addition, the amplification of the oscillations that reach the corona may add to the likelihood of a repeated flare. Studying oscillations in small flare events has the advantage of exploring the atmosphere in its quasi-quiet condition as opposed to powerful flares, which cause substantial and prolonged disturbance of the environment. In addition, small flares are much more common than powerful flares, which allows one to choose from a larger sample of observational material.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021; v1 submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Propagating Oscillations in the Lower Atmosphere under Coronal Holes
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov,
Maksim Chelpanov,
Aleksandr Kiselev
Abstract:
The subject of this study is oscillations in the lower atmosphere in coronal-hole regions, where the conditions are favorable for propagation between the atmospheric layers. Based on spectroscopic observations in photospheric and chromospheric lines, we analysed the features of the oscillations that show signs of propagation between layers of the solar atmosphere. Using the cross-spectrum wavelet…
▽ More
The subject of this study is oscillations in the lower atmosphere in coronal-hole regions, where the conditions are favorable for propagation between the atmospheric layers. Based on spectroscopic observations in photospheric and chromospheric lines, we analysed the features of the oscillations that show signs of propagation between layers of the solar atmosphere. Using the cross-spectrum wavelet algorithm, we found that both chromospheric and photospheric signals under coronal holes share a range of significant oscillations of periods around five minutes, while the signals outside of coronal holes show no mutual oscillations in the photosphere and chromosphere. The phase shift between the layers indicates a predominantly upward propagation with partial presence of standing waves. We also tested the assumption that torsional Alfvén waves propagating in the corona originate in the lower atmosphere. However, the observed line-width oscillations, although similar in period to the Alfvén waves observed earlier in the corona of open-field regions, seem to be associated with other MHD modes. If we assume that the oscillations that we observed are related to Alfvén waves, then perhaps this is only through the mechanisms of the slow MHD wave transformation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Multilevel Observations of the Oscillations in the First Active Region of the New Cycle
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov
Abstract:
For the first time, a multi-wave research of oscillation dynamics in a solar facula from its birth to decay was carried out. We performed spectral observations of active region NOAA 12744 at Horizontal Solar Telescope of the Sayan Solar Observatory in the H$α$, He I 10830 A, and Si I 10827 A lines. We used Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) line-of-sight magnetic field data and the 1600 A, 304 A, an…
▽ More
For the first time, a multi-wave research of oscillation dynamics in a solar facula from its birth to decay was carried out. We performed spectral observations of active region NOAA 12744 at Horizontal Solar Telescope of the Sayan Solar Observatory in the H$α$, He I 10830 A, and Si I 10827 A lines. We used Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) line-of-sight magnetic field data and the 1600 A, 304 A, and 171 A UV channels. At the early stages of the facula evolution, we observed low-frequency (1-2 mHz) oscillations concentrate in the central part of the facula. In the lower solar atmosphere, this is registered in the intensity, line-of-sight velocity, and magnetic field signals. These frequencies were also observed in the transition region and corona (304 A and 171 A channels). At the maximal development phase of the facula evolution, the low frequency oscillations closely reproduce the coronal loop structures forming above the active region. At the decay phase, the spatial distributions of the observed frequencies resemble those found in and above the undisturbed chromosphere network. Our results indicate a direct relation of the low frequency oscillations observed in the lower solar atmosphere with the oscillations in the coronal loops, which is probably implemented through the loop footpoints.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Oscillations Accompanying a He I 10830 Å Negative Flare in a Solar Facula II. Response of the Transition Region and Corona
Authors:
Nikolai Kobanov,
Andrei Chelpanov
Abstract:
We studied oscillations related to flare SOL2012-09-21T02:19 in the transition region and chromosphere based on Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager (RHESSI) and Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) data, as well as data from a ground-based observatory. We found that 2-minute oscillations triggered by the flare first appeared in the RHESSI channels then subsequently showed up in the SD…
▽ More
We studied oscillations related to flare SOL2012-09-21T02:19 in the transition region and chromosphere based on Reuven Ramaty High Energy Solar Spectroscopic Imager (RHESSI) and Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) data, as well as data from a ground-based observatory. We found that 2-minute oscillations triggered by the flare first appeared in the RHESSI channels then subsequently showed up in the SDO 171 Å and 304 Å channels and after that in the chromospheric He I 10830 Å line. The delay of the chromospheric signal compared to the RHESSI signal is 7 minutes, which indicates that the wave perturbation propagated from the corona to the chromosphere. We used the sharp increase in 3- and 5-minute oscillations during the flare in the lower atmosphere to trace the propagation of the oscillation trains to the transition region and corona. The results show that the 171 Å channel signals lagged behind the photospheric and chromospheric signals by 200 s on average. We suggest that we observed slow magnetoacoustic waves both in the case of 2-minute oscillations propagating downwards from the corona and in the case of 3- and 5-minute oscillations leaking to the corona from beneath.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Oscillations accompanying a He I 10830 Å negative flare in a solar facula
Authors:
Andrei Chelpanov,
Nikolai Kobanov
Abstract:
On September 21, 2012, we carried out spectral observations of a solar facula in the Si I 10827 Å, He I 10830 Å, and Hα spectral lines. Later, in the process of analyzing the data, we found a small-scale flare in the middle of the time series. Due to an anomalous increase in the absorption of the He I 10830 Å line, we identified this flare as a negative flare. The aim of this paper is to study the…
▽ More
On September 21, 2012, we carried out spectral observations of a solar facula in the Si I 10827 Å, He I 10830 Å, and Hα spectral lines. Later, in the process of analyzing the data, we found a small-scale flare in the middle of the time series. Due to an anomalous increase in the absorption of the He I 10830 Å line, we identified this flare as a negative flare. The aim of this paper is to study the influence of the negative flare on the oscillation characteristics in the facular photosphere and chromosphere. We measured line-of-sight (LOS) velocity and intensity of all the three lines as well as half-width of the chromospheric lines. We also used SDO/HMI magnetic field data. The flare caused modulation of all the studied parameters. In the location of the negative flare, the amplitude of the oscillations increased four times on average. In the adjacent magnetic field local maxima, the chromospheric LOS velocity oscillations appreciably decreased during the flare. The facula region oscillated as a whole with a 5-minute period before the flare, and this synchronicity was disrupted after the flare. The flare changed the spectral composition of the line-of-sight magnetic field oscillations, causing an increase in the low-frequency oscillation power.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2018; v1 submitted 23 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Negative flare in the He I 10830 Å line in facula
Authors:
Nikolai Kobanov,
Andrei Chelpanov,
Vasiliy Pulyaev
Abstract:
A small-scale flare SOL2012-09-21T02:19 (B2) occurred in a spotless active region that we observed at a ground-based telescope equipped with a spectrograph. During the flare, we registered an increase in absorption in the He I 10830 Å line by 25%, while other chromospheric and coronal spectral lines demonstrated increase in brightness at the same location. This phenomenon called negative flare had…
▽ More
A small-scale flare SOL2012-09-21T02:19 (B2) occurred in a spotless active region that we observed at a ground-based telescope equipped with a spectrograph. During the flare, we registered an increase in absorption in the He I 10830 Å line by 25%, while other chromospheric and coronal spectral lines demonstrated increase in brightness at the same location. This phenomenon called negative flare had rarely been observed at the Sun before. In this paper, we describe the morphology of this flare and investigate its dynamics based on our spectral observations and space imaging data. The H$α$ and He I 10830 Å lines reach their extreme intensities 5 and 6 minutes after the 171 Å line. The brightening first occurred in the 171 Å and 193 Å Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) channels followed by the 94 Å, 304 Å, and 1600 Å signals $\sim$2 minutes after (for the maximum phases). However, the abrupt changes in line-of-sight (LOS) velocities in the chromospheric lines occur simultaneously with the intensity changes in the 304 Å and 1600 Å lines: we observed a downward motion that was followed by two upward motions. The measured horizontal speed of the perturbation propagation was close to 70 km s$^{-1}$ both in the chromospheric and coronal lines. We assume that we observed the photoionization-recombination process caused by UV radiation from the transition region during the coronal flare. With this, we point out the difficulties in interpreting the time lag between the emission maximum in the SDO UV channels and the second absorption maximum in the He I 10830 Å line.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Peculiarity of the oscillation stratification in sunspot penumbrae
Authors:
D. Y. Kolobov,
A. A. Chelpanov,
N. I. Kobanov
Abstract:
Spatial distributions of the dominant oscillation frequency obtained for four sunspots show a feature shared by all the analysed levels of the solar atmosphere in these sunspots. This feature located in the inner penumbrae indicates that this region has favourable conditions for 2.5-4 mHz oscillation propagation. This agrees with the fact that the spectral composition of the oscillations at three…
▽ More
Spatial distributions of the dominant oscillation frequency obtained for four sunspots show a feature shared by all the analysed levels of the solar atmosphere in these sunspots. This feature located in the inner penumbrae indicates that this region has favourable conditions for 2.5-4 mHz oscillation propagation. This agrees with the fact that the spectral composition of the oscillations at three atmospheric heights (FeI 6173Å, 1700Å, and He II 304Å) in this region are similar. There have been previous evidence of particular similarities along height of photospheric magnetic field strength, line-of-sight velocity, and temperature profile in the inner penumbra, where the internal boundary of the Evershed flow is located. The finding of the same dominant oscillation frequency at a range of altitudes from the chromosphere up to the transition region extends the height range, suggesting similarities in physical conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Influence of the Magnetic Field on Oscillation Spectra in Solar Faculae
Authors:
Andrei A. Chelpanov,
Nikolai I. Kobanov,
Dmitry Y. Kolobov
Abstract:
In this work, we studied oscillation parameters in faculae above magnetic knots and in the adjacent to them areas. Using SDO data we analysed oscillations in magnetic strength, Doppler velocity, and intensity signals for the lower photosphere, and in intensity for the higher levels. We found that in the magnetic field strength oscillation spectra in magnetic knots, peaks at a frequency of about 4.…
▽ More
In this work, we studied oscillation parameters in faculae above magnetic knots and in the adjacent to them areas. Using SDO data we analysed oscillations in magnetic strength, Doppler velocity, and intensity signals for the lower photosphere, and in intensity for the higher levels. We found that in the magnetic field strength oscillation spectra in magnetic knots, peaks at a frequency of about 4.8 mHz appear, while there are no such frequencies in the adjacent facular patches of a moderate field strength. On the contrary, Doppler velocity photospheric oscillation spectra are similar for these types of regions: in both cases, the significant peaks are in the 2.5--4.5 mHz range, though the oscillations in magnetic knots are 2--3 times weaker than those at the facular periphery. At the upper photosphere, the dominant frequencies in magnetic knots are 0.5--1 mHz higher than in the medium-field regions. The transition region oscillations above magnetic knots mainly concentrate in the 3--6 mHz range, and those above moderate-field patches concentrate below 3 mHz.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2016; v1 submitted 7 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Behaviour of oscillations in loop structures above active regions
Authors:
D. Y. Kolobov,
N. I. Kobanov,
A. A. Chelpanov,
A. A. Kochanov,
S. A. Anfinogentov,
S. A. Chupin,
I. I. Myshyakov,
V. E. Tomin
Abstract:
In this study we combine the multiwavelength ultraviolet -- optical (Solar Dynamics Observatory, SDO) and radio (Nobeyama Radioheliograph, NoRH) observations to get further insight into space-frequency distribution of oscillations at different atmospheric levels of the Sun. We processed the observational data on NOAA 11711 active region and found oscillations propagating from the photospheric leve…
▽ More
In this study we combine the multiwavelength ultraviolet -- optical (Solar Dynamics Observatory, SDO) and radio (Nobeyama Radioheliograph, NoRH) observations to get further insight into space-frequency distribution of oscillations at different atmospheric levels of the Sun. We processed the observational data on NOAA 11711 active region and found oscillations propagating from the photospheric level through the transition region upward into the corona. The power maps of low-frequency (1--2 mHz) oscillations reproduce well the fan-like coronal structures visible in the Fe ix 171A line. High frequency oscillations (5--7 mHz) propagate along the vertical magnetic field lines and concentrate inside small-scale elements in the umbra and at the umbra-penumbra boundary. We investigated the dependence of the dominant oscillation frequency upon the distance from the sunspot barycentre to estimate inclination of magnetic tubes in higher levels of sunspots where it cannot be measured directly, and found that this angle is close to 40 degrees above the umbra boundaries in the transition region.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Oscillations Above Sunspots and Faculae: Height Stratification and Relation to Coronal Fan Structure
Authors:
N. I. Kobanov,
D. Y. Kolobov,
A. A. Chelpanov
Abstract:
Oscillation properties in two sunspots and two facular regions are studied using Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) data and ground-based observations in the SiI 10827 and HeI 10830 lines. The aim is to study different-frequency spatial distribution characteristics above sunspots and faculae and their dependence on magnetic-field features and to detect the oscillations that reach the corona from the…
▽ More
Oscillation properties in two sunspots and two facular regions are studied using Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) data and ground-based observations in the SiI 10827 and HeI 10830 lines. The aim is to study different-frequency spatial distribution characteristics above sunspots and faculae and their dependence on magnetic-field features and to detect the oscillations that reach the corona from the deep photosphere most effectively. We used Fast-Fourier-Transform and frequency filtration of the intensity and Doppler-velocity variations with Morlet wavelet to trace the wave propagating from the photosphere to the chromosphere and corona. Spatial distribution of low-frequency (1-2 mHz) oscillations outlines well the fan-loop structures in the corona (the Fe IX 171 line) above sunspots and faculae. High-frequency oscillations (5-7 mHz) are concentrated in fragments inside the photospheric umbra boundaries and close to facular-region centers. This implies that the upper parts of most coronal loops, which transfer low-frequency oscillations from the photosphere, sit in the Fe IX 171 line-formation layer. We used dominant frequency vs. distance from barycenter relations to estimate magnetic-tube inclination angle in the higher layers, which poses difficulties for direct magnetic-field measurements. According to our calculations, this angle is about 40 degrees in the transition region around umbra borders. Phase velocities measured in the coronal loops' upper parts in the Fe IX 171 line-formation layer reach 100-150 km/s for sunspots and 50-100 km/s for faculae.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Oscillations above sunspots from the temperature minimum to the corona
Authors:
N. I. Kobanov,
A. A. Chelpanov,
D. Y. Kolobov
Abstract:
Context. An analysis of the oscillations above sunspots was carried out using simultaneous ground-based and Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) observations (SiI 10827A, HeI 10830A, FeI 6173A, 1700A, HeII 304A, FeIX 171A).
Aims. Investigation of the spatial distribution of oscillation power in the frequency range 1-8 mHz for the different height levels of the solar atmosphere. Measuring the time la…
▽ More
Context. An analysis of the oscillations above sunspots was carried out using simultaneous ground-based and Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) observations (SiI 10827A, HeI 10830A, FeI 6173A, 1700A, HeII 304A, FeIX 171A).
Aims. Investigation of the spatial distribution of oscillation power in the frequency range 1-8 mHz for the different height levels of the solar atmosphere. Measuring the time lags between the oscillations at the different layers.
Methods. We used frequency filtration of the intensity and Doppler velocity variations with Morlet wavelet to trace the wave propagation from the photosphere to the chromosphere and the corona.
Results. The 15 min oscillations are concentrated near the outer penumbra in the upper photosphere (1700 A), forming a ring, that expands in the transition zone. These oscillations propagate upward and reach the corona level, where their spatial distribution resembles a fan structure. The spatial distribution of the 5 min oscillation power looks like a circle-shape structure matching the sunspot umbra border at the photospheric level. The circle expands at the higher levels (HeII 304A and FeIX 171A). This indicates that the low-frequency oscillations propagate along the inclined magnetic tubes in the spot. We found that the inclination of the tubes reaches 50--60 degrees in the upper chromosphere and the transition zone. The main oscillation power in the 5-8 mHz range concentrates within the umbra boundaries at all the levels. The highest frequency oscillations (8 mHz) are located in the peculiar points inside the umbra. These points probably coincide with umbral dots. We deduced the propagation velocities to be 28+-15 km/s, 26+-15 km/s, and 55+-10 km/s for the SiI 10827A-HeI 10830A, 1700A-HeII 304A, and HeII 304A-FeIX 171A height levels, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Direct measurement results of the time lag of LOS-velocity oscillations between two heights in solar faculae and sunspots
Authors:
Nikolai Kobanov,
Dmitri Kolobov,
Arseniy Kustov,
Sergey Chupin,
Andrey Chelpanov
Abstract:
We present an investigation of line-of-sight (LOS) velocity oscillations in solar faculae and sunspots. To study the phase relations between chromosphere and photosphere oscillations of the LOS velocity, we measured the time lag of the chromospheric signal relative to the photospheric one for several faculae and sunspots in a set of spectral line pairs. The measured time lags are different for dif…
▽ More
We present an investigation of line-of-sight (LOS) velocity oscillations in solar faculae and sunspots. To study the phase relations between chromosphere and photosphere oscillations of the LOS velocity, we measured the time lag of the chromospheric signal relative to the photospheric one for several faculae and sunspots in a set of spectral line pairs. The measured time lags are different for different objects. The mean measured delay between the oscillations in the five-minute band in faculae is 50s for the SiI 10827Å-HeI 10830Å pair; for the pair FeI 6569Å-H-alpha 6563Å the mean delay is 20s; for the pair FeI 4551Å-BaII 4554Å the mean delay is 7s; for the pair SiI 8536Å-CaII 8542Å the mean delay is 20s. For the oscillations in the three-minute band in sunspot umbrae the mean delay is 55s for the SiI 10827Å-HeI 10830Å pair; for the Fe I 6569Å-H-alpha 6563Å pair it was not possible to determine the delay; for the FeI 4551Å-BaII 4554Å pair the mean delay is 6s; for the SiI 8536Å-CaII 8542Å pair the mean delay is 21s. Measured delays correspond to the wave propagation speed which significantly exceeds the generally adopted speed of sound in the photosphere. This raises the question of the origin of these oscillations. The possibility that we deal with slow MHD waves is not ruled out.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.