-
Violation of $γ$ in Brans-Dicke gravity
Authors:
Hoang Ky Nguyen,
Bertrand Chauvineau
Abstract:
The Brans Class I solution in Brans-Dicke gravity is a staple in the study of gravitational theories beyond General Relativity. Discovered in 1961, it describes the exterior vacuum of a spherical Brans-Dicke star and is characterized by two adjustable parameters. Surprisingly, the relationship between these parameters and the properties of the star has not been rigorously established. In this Proc…
▽ More
The Brans Class I solution in Brans-Dicke gravity is a staple in the study of gravitational theories beyond General Relativity. Discovered in 1961, it describes the exterior vacuum of a spherical Brans-Dicke star and is characterized by two adjustable parameters. Surprisingly, the relationship between these parameters and the properties of the star has not been rigorously established. In this Proceeding, we bridge this gap by deriving $\textit{the}$ complete exterior solution of Brans Class I, expressed in terms of the total energy and total pressure of the spherisymmetric gravity source. The solution allows for the $\textit{exact}$ derivation of $\textit{all}$ post-Newtonian parameters in Brans-Dicke gravity for far field regions of a spherical source. Particularly for the $γ$ parameter, instead of the conventional result $γ_{\,\text{PPN}}=\frac{ω+1}{ω+2}$, we obtain the analytical expression $γ_{\,\text{exact}}=\frac{ω+1+(ω+2)\,Θ}{ω+2+(ω+1)\,Θ}$ where $Θ$ is the ratio of the total pressure $P_{\parallel}^{*}+2P_{\perp}^{*}$ and total energy $E^{*}$ contained within the mass source. Our $\textit{non-perturbative}$ $γ$ formula is valid for all field strengths and types of matter comprising the mass source. Consequently, observational constraints on $γ$ thus set $\textit{joint}$ bounds on $ω$ and $\varTheta$, with the latter representing a global characteristic of the mass source. More broadly, our formula highlights the importance of pressure (when $\varTheta\neq0$) in spherical Brans-Dicke stars, and potentially in stars within other modified theories of gravitation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2024; v1 submitted 25 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The complete exterior spacetime of spherical Brans-Dicke stars
Authors:
Bertrand Chauvineau,
Hoang Ky Nguyen
Abstract:
We derive the complete expression for the Brans Class I exterior spacetime explicitly in terms of the energy and pressures profiles of a stationary spherisymmetric gravity source. This novel and generic expression is achieved in a parsimonious manner, requiring only a subset of the Brans-Dicke field equation and the scalar equation. For distant orbiting test particles, this expression promptly pro…
▽ More
We derive the complete expression for the Brans Class I exterior spacetime explicitly in terms of the energy and pressures profiles of a stationary spherisymmetric gravity source. This novel and generic expression is achieved in a parsimonious manner, requiring only a subset of the Brans-Dicke field equation and the scalar equation. For distant orbiting test particles, this expression promptly provides a simple, closed and exact formula of the [textgreek]<LaTeX>\textgreek{g}</LaTeX> Eddington parameter, which reads γ_{exact}=((ω+1+(ω+2)Θ)/(ω+2+(ω+1)Θ)), where Θ is the ratio of the star's "total pressure" integral over its energy integral. This non-perturbative result reproduces the usual Post-Newtonian ((ω+1)/(ω+2)) expression in the case of a "Newtonian star", in which the pressure is negligible with respect to the energy density. Furthermore, it converges to the General Relativity value (γ_{GR}=1) as the star's equation of state approaches that of ultra-relativistic matter (in which case Θ approaches 1), a behavior consistent with broader studies on scalar-tensor gravity. Our derivation underscores the essence of these results involving (1) the key relevant portion of the Brans-Dicke field equations, (2) the uniqueness of the Brans Class I vacuum solution for the non-phantom action, viz. ω>-3/2, and (3) the involvement of only two free parameters in this solution, hence requiring two quantities (energy and pressure integrals) of the mass source to fully characterize the solution. From a practical standpoint, it elucidates how a given stellar interior structure model determines the star's exterior gravitational field and impacts the motions of light objects (such as planets and accretion disks) orbiting it.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2024; v1 submitted 22 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Impact of Star Pressure on $γ$ in Modified Gravity beyond Post-Newtonian Approach
Authors:
Hoang Ky Nguyen,
Bertrand Chauvineau
Abstract:
We provide a concrete example exhibiting marked deviation from the PPN approximation in a modified theory of gravity. Specifically, we derive the exact formula for the Robertson parameter $γ$ in Brans-Dicke gravity for compact mass sources, explicitly incorporating the pressure content of these sources. We achieve this by exploiting the $\textit integrability$ of the 00-component of the Brans-Dick…
▽ More
We provide a concrete example exhibiting marked deviation from the PPN approximation in a modified theory of gravity. Specifically, we derive the exact formula for the Robertson parameter $γ$ in Brans-Dicke gravity for compact mass sources, explicitly incorporating the pressure content of these sources. We achieve this by exploiting the $\textit integrability$ of the 00-component of the Brans-Dicke field equation. In place of the conventional PPN result $γ_{PPN}=\frac{ω+1}{ω+2}$, we obtain the analytical expression $γ_{\,exact}=\frac{ω+1+(ω+2)\varTheta}{ω+2+(ω+1)\varTheta}$ where $\varTheta$ is the ratio of the total pressure $P_\parallel^*+2P_\perp^*$ and total energy $E^*$ contained within the mass source. Our $\textit non\text{-}perturbative$ formula is valid for all field strengths and types of matter comprising the mass source. We draw four key conclusions: (1) The usual $γ_{PPN}$ formula is violated in the presence of pressure, viz. when $\varTheta\neq0$, revealing a limitation of the PPN approximation in Brans-Dicke gravity. (2) The PPN result mainly stems from the assumption of pressureless matter. Even in the weak-field star case, non-zero pressure leads to a violation of the PPN $γ$ formula. Conversely, the PPN result is a good approximation for low-pressure matter, i.e. when $\varTheta\approx0$, for all field strengths. (3) Observational constraints on $γ$ set $\textit joint$ bounds on $ω$ and $\varTheta$, with the latter representing a global characteristic of a mass source. If the equation of state of matter in the mass source approaches the ultra-relativistic form, entailing $\varTheta\simeq1$, $γ_{\,exact}$ converges to 1 $\textit irrespective$ of $ω$. (4) In a broader context, our findings indicate the latent significance of considering the interior structure of stars in observational astronomy.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024; v1 submitted 29 March, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
New views on classical and quantum Brans-Dicke theory
Authors:
Júlio C. Fabris,
Bertrand Chauvineau,
Davi C. Rodrigues,
Carla R. Almeida,
Oliver F. Piattella
Abstract:
The Brans-Dicke action is one of the most natural extensions of the Einstein-Hilbert action. It is based on the introduction of a fundamental scalar field that effectively incorporates a dynamics to the gravitational coupling $G$. In spite of the diverse motivations and the rich phenomenology that comes from its solutions, Solar System tests impose strong constraints on the Brans-Dicke theory, ren…
▽ More
The Brans-Dicke action is one of the most natural extensions of the Einstein-Hilbert action. It is based on the introduction of a fundamental scalar field that effectively incorporates a dynamics to the gravitational coupling $G$. In spite of the diverse motivations and the rich phenomenology that comes from its solutions, Solar System tests impose strong constraints on the Brans-Dicke theory, rendering it indistinguishable from General Relativity. In the present text, new perspectives for the Brans-Dicke theory are presented, based on the possibility that the scalar field presented in the BD theory can be external, as well as on the applications to black hole physics and the primordial universe.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Introducing quantum effects in classical theories
Authors:
J. C. Fabris,
O. F. Piattella,
D. C. Rodrigues,
B. Chauvineau,
M. H. Daouda
Abstract:
In this paper, we explore two different ways of implementing quantum effects in a classical structure. The first one is through an external field. The other one is modifying the classical conservation laws. In both cases, the consequences for the description of the evolution of the universe are discussed.
In this paper, we explore two different ways of implementing quantum effects in a classical structure. The first one is through an external field. The other one is modifying the classical conservation laws. In both cases, the consequences for the description of the evolution of the universe are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2015; v1 submitted 22 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Scalar-tensor theories with an external scalar
Authors:
Bertrand Chauvineau,
Davi C. Rodrigues,
Júlio C. Fabris
Abstract:
Scalar-tensor (ST) gravity is considered in the case where the scalar is an external field. We show that General Relativity (GR) and usual ST gravity are particular cases of the External Scalar-Tensor (EST) gravity. It is shown with a particular cosmological example that it is possible to join a part of a GR solution to a part of a ST one such that the complete solution neither belongs to GR nor t…
▽ More
Scalar-tensor (ST) gravity is considered in the case where the scalar is an external field. We show that General Relativity (GR) and usual ST gravity are particular cases of the External Scalar-Tensor (EST) gravity. It is shown with a particular cosmological example that it is possible to join a part of a GR solution to a part of a ST one such that the complete solution neither belongs to GR nor to ST, but fully satisfies the EST field equations. We argue that external fields may effectively work as a type of screening mechanism for ST theories.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2016; v1 submitted 25 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Visser's Massive Gravity Bimetric Theory Revisited
Authors:
Alain de Roany,
Bertrand Chauvineau,
J. A. de Freitas Pacheco
Abstract:
A massive gravity theory was proposed by Visser in the late nineties. This theory, based on a backgroung metric $b_{αβ}$ and on an usual dynamical metric $g_{αβ}$ has the advantage of being free of ghosts as well as discontinuities present in other massive theories proposed in the past. In the present investigation, the equations of Visser's theory are revisited with a particular care on the relat…
▽ More
A massive gravity theory was proposed by Visser in the late nineties. This theory, based on a backgroung metric $b_{αβ}$ and on an usual dynamical metric $g_{αβ}$ has the advantage of being free of ghosts as well as discontinuities present in other massive theories proposed in the past. In the present investigation, the equations of Visser's theory are revisited with a particular care on the related conservation laws.\ It will be shown that a multiplicative factor is missing in the graviton tensor originally derived by Visser, which has no incidence on the weak field approach but becomes important in the strong field regime when, for instance, cosmological applications are considered. In this case, contrary to some previous claims found in the literature, we conclude that a non-static background metric is required in order to obtain a solution able to mimic the $Λ$CDM cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Explicit formulae for the two way time-transfer in the T2L2 experiment including the J2 contribution to the Earth potential in a relativistic framework
Authors:
Olivier Minazzoli,
Bertrand Chauvineau,
Etienne Samain,
Pierre Exertier,
Patrick Vrancken,
Philippe Guillemot
Abstract:
The topic of this paper is to study the two way time-transfer problem between a ground based station and a low orbit Earth's satellite, in the aim of an application to the T2L2 experiment. The sudy is driven in a fully relativistic framework. Because of the rapid increase in clock's precision/measurements, the first term beyond the Earth's potential monopolar term is explicitly taken into accoun…
▽ More
The topic of this paper is to study the two way time-transfer problem between a ground based station and a low orbit Earth's satellite, in the aim of an application to the T2L2 experiment. The sudy is driven in a fully relativistic framework. Because of the rapid increase in clock's precision/measurements, the first term beyond the Earth's potential monopolar term is explicitly taken into account. Explicit formulae, for both the distance and offset problems (definitions in the text) are proposed for the relevant applications.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Relativistic versus Newtonian orbit model: the Relativistic Motion Integrator (RMI) software. Illustration with the LISA mission
Authors:
S. Pireaux,
B. Chauvineau,
A. Hees
Abstract:
The Relativistic Motion Integrator (RMI) consists in integrating numerically the EXACT relativistic equations of motion, for a given metric (corresponding to a gravitational field at first post-Newtonian order or higher), instead of Newtonian equations plus relativistic corrections. The aim of the present paper is to validate the method, and to illustrate how RMI can be used for space missions t…
▽ More
The Relativistic Motion Integrator (RMI) consists in integrating numerically the EXACT relativistic equations of motion, for a given metric (corresponding to a gravitational field at first post-Newtonian order or higher), instead of Newtonian equations plus relativistic corrections. The aim of the present paper is to validate the method, and to illustrate how RMI can be used for space missions to produce relativistic ephemerides of test-bodies (or satellites). Indeed, nowadays, relativistic effects have to be taken into account, and comparing a RMI model with a classical keplerian one helps to quantify such effects.
LISA is a relevant example to use RMI. A precise orbit model for the LISA spacecraft is needed not only for the sake of satellite ephemerides but also to compute the photon flight time in laser links between spacecraft, required in LISA data pre-processing in order to reach the gravitational wave detection level.
Relativistic effects in LISA orbit model needed to be considered and quantified. Using RMI, we show that the numerical classical model for LISA orbits in the gravitational field of a non-rotating spherical Sun without planets can be wrong, with respect to the numerical relativisitic version of the same model, by as much as about ten kilometers in radial distance during a year and up to about 60 kilometers in along track distance after a year... with consequences on estimated photon flight times.
We validated RMI numerical results with a 1PN analytical developpement.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2009; v1 submitted 23 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Stochastic background from extra-galactic double neutron stars
Authors:
T. Regimbau,
B. Chauvineau
Abstract:
We present Monte Carlo simulations of the extra galactic population of inspiralling double neutron stars, and estimate its contribution to the astrophysical gravitational wave background, in the frequency range of ground based interferometers, corresponding to the last thousand seconds before the last stable orbit when more than 96 percent of the signal is released. We show that sources at redsh…
▽ More
We present Monte Carlo simulations of the extra galactic population of inspiralling double neutron stars, and estimate its contribution to the astrophysical gravitational wave background, in the frequency range of ground based interferometers, corresponding to the last thousand seconds before the last stable orbit when more than 96 percent of the signal is released. We show that sources at redshift z>0.5 contribute to a truly continuous background which may be detected by correlating third generation interferometers.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2007;
originally announced July 2007.
