-
The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
Authors:
Eleonora Di Valentino,
Jackson Levi Said,
Adam Riess,
Agnieszka Pollo,
Vivian Poulin,
Adrià Gómez-Valent,
Amanda Weltman,
Antonella Palmese,
Caroline D. Huang,
Carsten van de Bruck,
Chandra Shekhar Saraf,
Cheng-Yu Kuo,
Cora Uhlemann,
Daniela Grandón,
Dante Paz,
Dominique Eckert,
Elsa M. Teixeira,
Emmanuel N. Saridakis,
Eoin Ó Colgáin,
Florian Beutler,
Florian Niedermann,
Francesco Bajardi,
Gabriela Barenboim,
Giulia Gubitosi,
Ilaria Musella
, et al. (513 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The standard model of cosmology has provided a good phenomenological description of a wide range of observations both at astrophysical and cosmological scales for several decades. This concordance model is constructed by a universal cosmological constant and supported by a matter sector described by the standard model of particle physics and a cold dark matter contribution, as well as very early-t…
▽ More
The standard model of cosmology has provided a good phenomenological description of a wide range of observations both at astrophysical and cosmological scales for several decades. This concordance model is constructed by a universal cosmological constant and supported by a matter sector described by the standard model of particle physics and a cold dark matter contribution, as well as very early-time inflationary physics, and underpinned by gravitation through general relativity. There have always been open questions about the soundness of the foundations of the standard model. However, recent years have shown that there may also be questions from the observational sector with the emergence of differences between certain cosmological probes. In this White Paper, we identify the key objectives that need to be addressed over the coming decade together with the core science projects that aim to meet these challenges. These discordances primarily rest on the divergence in the measurement of core cosmological parameters with varying levels of statistical confidence. These possible statistical tensions may be partially accounted for by systematics in various measurements or cosmological probes but there is also a growing indication of potential new physics beyond the standard model. After reviewing the principal probes used in the measurement of cosmological parameters, as well as potential systematics, we discuss the most promising array of potential new physics that may be observable in upcoming surveys. We also discuss the growing set of novel data analysis approaches that go beyond traditional methods to test physical models. [Abridged]
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2025; v1 submitted 2 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Precision cosmology with exact inhomogeneous solutions of General Relativity: the Szekeres models
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
The exact Friedman solution to the field equations of General Relativity (GR) describing a homogeneous and isotropic universe together with its linear and higher-order perturbations are the theoretical roots of the current standard model of cosmology. However, despite its global successes, this standard model currently faces a number of tensions and anomalies, which occur mostly from a mismatch be…
▽ More
The exact Friedman solution to the field equations of General Relativity (GR) describing a homogeneous and isotropic universe together with its linear and higher-order perturbations are the theoretical roots of the current standard model of cosmology. However, despite its global successes, this standard model currently faces a number of tensions and anomalies, which occur mostly from a mismatch between early and late cosmic time region depictions. Actually, in the era of precision cosmology, the late inhomogeneities in the densities of the Universe components can no more be neglected. Moreover, since GR is fundamentally nonlinear, any linear perturbation theory is doomed to fail at reproducing precisely its features, while higher-order perturbed FLRW models cannot either claim the status of exact solution to Einstein's field equations. Fortunately, other GR solutions exist which are best suited for this purpose, e. g., exact inhomogeneous solutions able to represent a matter-cosmological constant dominated universe region. Among these, the Szekeres solution, which is devoid of any symmetry, appears as a proper tool for this purpose. Moreover, since these solutions possess the FLRW model as a homogeneous limit, they can be smoothly matched to the standard representation at the inhomogeneity-homogeneity transition. In this paper, the Szekeres solution and its main interesting properties, as well as the equations needed to use this solution in a cosmological context are presented. Then the prospects for a broader use of its abilities are sketched out. In particular, the use of neural networks is proposed to allow, in the future, the fitting of the huge amount of data becoming available to constrain the arbitrary functions and the constant parameters characterizing the Szekeres model, running for representing our late Universe with an increased precision.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2024; v1 submitted 5 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Redshift and redshift-drift in $Λ= 0$ quasi-spherical Szekeres cosmological models and the effect of averaging
Authors:
Priti Mishra,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Since the advent of the accelerated expanding homogeneous universe model, some other explanations for the supernova Ia dimming have been explored, among which there are inhomogeneous models constructed with exact $Λ= 0$ solutions of Einstein's equations. They have been used either as one patch or to build Swiss-cheese models. The most studied ones have been the Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models.…
▽ More
Since the advent of the accelerated expanding homogeneous universe model, some other explanations for the supernova Ia dimming have been explored, among which there are inhomogeneous models constructed with exact $Λ= 0$ solutions of Einstein's equations. They have been used either as one patch or to build Swiss-cheese models. The most studied ones have been the Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models. However, these models being spatially spherical, they are not well designed to reproduce the large scale structures which exhibit clusters, filaments and non spherical voids. This is the reason why Szekeres models, which are devoid of any symmetry, have recently come into play. In this paper, we give the equations and an algorithm to compute the redshift-drift for the most general quasi-spherical Szekeres (QSS) models with no dark energy. We apply it to a QSS model recently proposed by Bolejko and Sussman (BSQSS model) who averaged their model to reproduce the density distribution of the Alexander and collaborators' LTB model which is able to fit a large set of cosmological data without dark energy. They concluded that their model represents a significant improvement over the observed cosmic structure description by spherical LTB models. We show here that this QSS model is ruled out by a negative cosmological redshift, i.e. a blueshift, which is not observed in the Universe. We also compute a positive redshift and the redshift-drift for the Alexander et al.'s model and compare this redshift-drift to that of the $Λ$CDM model. We conclude that the process of averaging an unphysical QSS model can lead to obtain a physical model able to reproduce our observed local Universe with no dark energy need and that the redshift-drift can discriminate between this model and the $Λ$CDM model. For completeness, we also compute the blueshift-drift of the BSQSS model.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Redshift-drift as a test for discriminating between decelerating inhomogeneous and accelerating universe models
Authors:
Priti Mishra,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Tejinder P. Singh
Abstract:
Exact inhomogeneous solutions of Einstein's equations have been used in the literature to build models reproducing the cosmological data without dark energy. However, owing to the degrees of freedom pertaining to these models, it is necessary to get rid of the degeneracy often exhibited by the problem of distinguishing between them and accelerating universe models. We give an overview of redshift…
▽ More
Exact inhomogeneous solutions of Einstein's equations have been used in the literature to build models reproducing the cosmological data without dark energy. However, owing to the degrees of freedom pertaining to these models, it is necessary to get rid of the degeneracy often exhibited by the problem of distinguishing between them and accelerating universe models. We give an overview of redshift drift in inhomogeneous cosmologies, and explain how it serves to this purpose. One class of models which fits the data is the Szekeres Swiss-cheese class where non-spherically symmetric voids exhibit a typical size of about 400 Mpc. We present our calculation of the redshift drift in this model, and compare it with the results obtained by other authors for alternate scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2013; v1 submitted 18 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Fully Characterizing Axially Symmetric Szekeres Models With Three Data Sets
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Priti Mishra,
Tejinder P. Singh
Abstract:
Inhomogeneous exact solutions of General Relativity with zero cosmological constant have been used in the literature to challenge the ΛCDM model. From one patch Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models to axially symmetric quasi-spherical Szekeres (QSS) Swiss-cheese models, some of them are able to reproduce to a good accuracy the cosmological data. It has been shown in the literature that a zero-Λ-LTB…
▽ More
Inhomogeneous exact solutions of General Relativity with zero cosmological constant have been used in the literature to challenge the ΛCDM model. From one patch Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models to axially symmetric quasi-spherical Szekeres (QSS) Swiss-cheese models, some of them are able to reproduce to a good accuracy the cosmological data. It has been shown in the literature that a zero-Λ-LTB model with a central observer can be fully determined by two data sets. We demonstrate that an axially symmetric zero-Λ-QSS model with an observer located at the origin can be fully reconstructed from three data sets, number counts, luminosity distance and redshift drift. This is a first step towards a future demonstration involving five data sets and the most general Szekeres model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Redshift drift in axially symmetric quasi-spherical Szekeres models
Authors:
Priti Mishra,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Tejinder P. Singh
Abstract:
Models of inhomogeneous universes constructed with exact solutions of Einstein's General Relativity have been proposed in the literature with the aim of reproducing the cosmological data without any need for a dark energy component. Besides large scale inhomogeneity models spherically symmetric around the observer, Swiss-cheese models have also been studied. Among them, Swiss-cheeses where the inh…
▽ More
Models of inhomogeneous universes constructed with exact solutions of Einstein's General Relativity have been proposed in the literature with the aim of reproducing the cosmological data without any need for a dark energy component. Besides large scale inhomogeneity models spherically symmetric around the observer, Swiss-cheese models have also been studied. Among them, Swiss-cheeses where the inhomogeneous patches are modeled by different particular Szekeres solutions have been used for reproducing the apparent dimming of the type Ia supernovae (SNIa). However, the problem of fitting such models to the SNIa data is completely degenerate and we need other constraints to fully characterize them. One of the tests which is known to be able to discriminate between different cosmological models is the redshift-drift. This drift has already been calculated by different authors for Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) models. We compute it here for one particular axially symmetric quasi-spherical Szekeres (QSS) Swiss-cheese which has previously been shown to reproduce to a good accuracy the SNIa data, and we compare the results to the drift in the $Λ$CDM model and in some LTB models that can be found in the literature. We show that it is a good discriminator between them. Then, we discuss our model's remaining degrees of freedom and propose a recipe to fully constrain them.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2012; v1 submitted 26 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Effects of inhomogeneities on the expansion of the Universe: a challenge to dark energy?
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
The current standard model of cosmology, the LambdaCDM model, is based on the homogeneous FLRW solutions of the Einstein equations to which some perturbations are added to account for the CMB features and structure formation at large scales. This model fits rather well the observations provided 95% of the energy density budget of the Universe should be of an unknown physical nature, i.e. dark matt…
▽ More
The current standard model of cosmology, the LambdaCDM model, is based on the homogeneous FLRW solutions of the Einstein equations to which some perturbations are added to account for the CMB features and structure formation at large scales. This model fits rather well the observations provided 95% of the energy density budget of the Universe should be of an unknown physical nature, i.e. dark matter and dark energy. Now, the aim of a cosmological model is not merely to reproduce the observations, but also to give a physical understanding of the Universe we live in. Moreover, even if the assumption of homogeneity seems to be more or less valid at large scales, it appears to be in contradiction with observations at intermediate scales (between the scale of non linear structure formation and that where structures virialize). This is the reason why, during the last decade, a community of researchers formed whose aim was to look for the best way to take into account the influence of the inhomogeneities seen in the Universe and to construct accurate cosmological models which could possibly get rid of the dark components. This task, which is still in its infancy, is currently progressing towards promising results. Two types of methods can be found in the literature: spatial averaging of scalar quantities and use of exact inhomogeneous solutions of General Relativity. We will give here a brief report of the second one.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Some clarifications about Lemaître-Tolman models of the Universe used to deal with the dark energy problem
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
During the past fifteen years, inhomogeneous cosmological models have been put forward to explain the observed dimming of the SNIa luminosity without resorting to dark energy. The simplest models are the spherically symmetric Lemaître-Tolman (LT) solutions with a central observer. Their use must be considered as a mere first step towards more sophisticated models. Spherical symmetry is but a mathe…
▽ More
During the past fifteen years, inhomogeneous cosmological models have been put forward to explain the observed dimming of the SNIa luminosity without resorting to dark energy. The simplest models are the spherically symmetric Lemaître-Tolman (LT) solutions with a central observer. Their use must be considered as a mere first step towards more sophisticated models. Spherical symmetry is but a mathematical simplification and one must consider spherical symmetric models as exhibiting an energy density smoothed out over angles around us. However, they have been taken at face value by some authors who tried to use them for either irrelevant purposes or to put them to the test as if they were robust models of our Universe. We wish to clarify how these models must be used in cosmology. We first use the results obtained by Iguchi and collaborators to derive the density profiles of the pure growing and decaying mode LT models. We then discuss the relevance of the different test proposals in the light of the interpretation given above. We show that decaying-mode (parabolic) LT models always exhibit an overdensity near their centre and growing-mode (elliptic or hyperbolic) LT models, a void. This is at variance with some statements in the literature. We dismiss all previous proposals merely designed to test the spherical symmetry of the LT models, and we agree that the value of $H_0$ and the measurement of the redshift drift are valid tests of the models. However, we suspect that this last test, which is the best in principle, will be more complicated to implement than usually claimed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2012; v1 submitted 5 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Inhomogeneous cosmological models: exact solutions and their applications
Authors:
Krzysztof Bolejko,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Andrzej Krasiński
Abstract:
Recently, inhomogeneous generalisations of the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmological models have gained interest in the astrophysical community and are more often employed to study cosmological phenomena. However, in many papers the inhomogeneous cosmological models are treated as an alternative to the FLRW models. In fact, they are not an alternative, but an exact perturbation of the l…
▽ More
Recently, inhomogeneous generalisations of the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmological models have gained interest in the astrophysical community and are more often employed to study cosmological phenomena. However, in many papers the inhomogeneous cosmological models are treated as an alternative to the FLRW models. In fact, they are not an alternative, but an exact perturbation of the latter, and are gradually becoming a necessity in modern cosmology. The assumption of homogeneity is just a first approximation introduced to simplify equations. So far this assumption is commonly believed to have worked well, but future and more precise observations will not be properly analysed unless inhomogeneities are taken into account. This paper reviews recent developments in the field and shows the importance of an inhomogeneous framework in the analysis of cosmological observations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2011; v1 submitted 7 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Szekeres Swiss-Cheese model and supernova observations
Authors:
Krzysztof Bolejko,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
We use different particular classes of axially symmetric Szekeres Swiss-cheese models for the study of the apparent dimming of the supernovae of type Ia. We compare the results with those obtained in the corresponding Lemaitre-Tolman Swiss-cheese models. Although the quantitative picture is different the qualitative results are comparable, i.e, one cannot fully explain the dimming of the supernova…
▽ More
We use different particular classes of axially symmetric Szekeres Swiss-cheese models for the study of the apparent dimming of the supernovae of type Ia. We compare the results with those obtained in the corresponding Lemaitre-Tolman Swiss-cheese models. Although the quantitative picture is different the qualitative results are comparable, i.e, one cannot fully explain the dimming of the supernovae using small scale ~50 Mpc inhomogeneities. To fit successfully the data we need structures of order of 500 Mpc size or larger. However, this result might be an artifact due to the use of axial light rays in axially symmetric models. Anyhow, this work is a first step in trying to use Szekeres Swiss-cheese models in cosmology and it will be followed by the study of more physical models with still less symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2011; v1 submitted 14 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Inhomogeneities in the Universe with exact solutions of General Relativity
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
It is commonly stated that we have entered the era of precision cosmology in which a number of important observations have reached a degree of precision, and a level of agreement with theory, that is comparable with many Earth-based physics experiments. One of the consequences is the need to examine at what point our usual, well-worn assumption of homogeneity associated to the use of perturbatio…
▽ More
It is commonly stated that we have entered the era of precision cosmology in which a number of important observations have reached a degree of precision, and a level of agreement with theory, that is comparable with many Earth-based physics experiments. One of the consequences is the need to examine at what point our usual, well-worn assumption of homogeneity associated to the use of perturbation theory begins to compromise the accuracy of our models. It is now a widely accepted fact that the effect of the inhomogeneities observed in the Universe cannot be ignored when one wants to construct an accurate cosmological model. Well-established physics can explain several of the observed phenomena without introducing highly speculative elements, like dark matter, dark energy, exponential expansion at densities never attained in any experiment (i.e. inflation), and the like. Two main classes of methods are currently used to deal with these issues. Averaging, sometimes linked to fitting procedures a la Stoegger and Ellis, provide us with one promising way of solving the problem. Another approach is the use of exact inhomogeneous solutions of General Relativity. This will be developed here.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2009;
originally announced November 2009.
-
A (giant) void is not mandatory to explain away dark energy with a Lemaitre - Tolman model
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Krzysztof Bolejko,
Andrzej Krasiński
Abstract:
Lemaître - Tolman (L--T) toy models with a central observer have been used to study the effect of large scale inhomogeneities on the SN Ia dimming. Claims that a giant void is mandatory to explain away dark energy in this framework are currently dominating. Our aim is to show that L-T models exist that reproduce a few features of the $Λ$CDM model, but do not contain the giant cosmic void. We propo…
▽ More
Lemaître - Tolman (L--T) toy models with a central observer have been used to study the effect of large scale inhomogeneities on the SN Ia dimming. Claims that a giant void is mandatory to explain away dark energy in this framework are currently dominating. Our aim is to show that L-T models exist that reproduce a few features of the $Λ$CDM model, but do not contain the giant cosmic void. We propose to use two sets of data - the angular diameter distance together with the redshift-space mass-density and the angular diameter distance together with the expansion rate - both defined on the past null cone as functions of the redshift. We assume that these functions are of the same form as in the $Λ$CDM model. Using the Mustapha-Hellaby-Ellis algorithm, we numerically transform these initial data into the usual two L-T arbitrary functions and solve the evolution equation to calculate the mass distribution in spacetime. For both models, we find that the current density profile does not exhibit a giant void, but rather a giant hump. However, this hump is not directly observable, since it is in a spacelike relation to a present observer. The alleged existence of the giant void was a consequence of the L-T models used earlier because their generality was limited a priori by needless simplifying assumptions, like, for example, the bang-time function being constant. Instead, one can feed any mass distribution or expansion rate history on the past light cone as initial data to the L-T evolution equation. When a fully general L-T metric is used, the giant void is not implied.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2010; v1 submitted 4 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Imitating accelerated expansion of the Universe by matter inhomogeneities - corrections of some misunderstandings
Authors:
Andrzej Krasinski,
Charles Hellaby,
Krzysztof Bolejko,
Marie-Noelle Celerier
Abstract:
A number of misunderstandings about modeling the apparent accelerated expansion of the Universe, and about the `weak singularity' are clarified: 1. Of the five definitions of the deceleration parameter given by Hirata and Seljak (HS), only $q_1$ is a correct invariant measure of acceleration/deceleration of expansion. The $q_3$ and $q_4$ are unrelated to acceleration in an inhomogeneous model. 2.…
▽ More
A number of misunderstandings about modeling the apparent accelerated expansion of the Universe, and about the `weak singularity' are clarified: 1. Of the five definitions of the deceleration parameter given by Hirata and Seljak (HS), only $q_1$ is a correct invariant measure of acceleration/deceleration of expansion. The $q_3$ and $q_4$ are unrelated to acceleration in an inhomogeneous model. 2. The averaging over directions involved in the definition of $q_4$ does not correspond to what is done in observational astronomy. 3. HS's equation (38) connecting $q_4$ to the flow invariants gives self-contradictory results when applied at the centre of symmetry of the Lemaître-Tolman (L-T) model. The intermediate equation (31) that determines $q_{3'}$ is correct, but approximate, so it cannot be used for determining the sign of the deceleration parameter. Even so, at the centre of symmetry of the L-T model, it puts no limitation on the sign of $q_{3'}(0)$. 4. The `weak singularity' of Vanderveld {\it et al.} is a conical profile of mass density at the centre - a perfectly acceptable configuration. 5. The so-called `critical point' in the equations of the `inverse problem' for a central observer in an L-T model is a manifestation of the apparent horizon - a common property of the past light cones in zero-lambda L-T models, perfectly manageable if the equations are correctly integrated.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2010; v1 submitted 24 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Scaling Regimes as obtained from the DR5 Sloan Digital Sky Survey
Authors:
Reuben Thieberger,
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Standard cosmology is based on the assumption that the universe is spatially homogeneous. However the consensus on a homogeneous matter structure, even on very large scales, has never been complete. The advantage of correlation dimension calculations is that they enable one to obtain the transition scale to a homogeneous distribution, whereas other methods, such as those using the two-point corr…
▽ More
Standard cosmology is based on the assumption that the universe is spatially homogeneous. However the consensus on a homogeneous matter structure, even on very large scales, has never been complete. The advantage of correlation dimension calculations is that they enable one to obtain the transition scale to a homogeneous distribution, whereas other methods, such as those using the two-point correlation function, make it hard to exhibit the possible fractal properties of the Universe matter content. Our purpose is to calculate the correlation dimension $D_2$, looking for a possible transition to homogeneity, which would imply $D_2 = 3$. We apply the correlation integral method to the three dimensional sample composed of 332,876 galaxies which we extract from the Fifth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. We analyze the raw data up to the scale $d_{max} = 160$ Mpc, assuming $H_0 = 70$ km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$ and considering three cosmological models in order to test the model dependence of our method. Using volume limited samples for this range leaves us with about 20,000 galaxies. Applying our method to random maps helps us to calibrate our results. We obtain a correlation dimension of the galaxy distribution which seems to increase with scales up to $D_2=3$ reached around 70 Mpc. The results of our analysis, performed on the largest volume limited sample which can be extracted from the SDSS catalog, are compatible with those formerly obtained by other authors. However, to get a more reliable description of the structures at various scales, we think it will be mandatory to use still larger catalogs than those which are currently available.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
Inhomogeneities in the Universe and the Fitting Problem
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Observational cosmology provides us with a large number of high precision data which are used to derive models trying to reproduce ``on the mean'' our observable patch of the Universe. Most of these attempts are achieved in the framework of a Friedmann-Lemaître cosmology where large scale homogeneity is assumed. However, we know, from the observation of structures at increasing scales, that thes…
▽ More
Observational cosmology provides us with a large number of high precision data which are used to derive models trying to reproduce ``on the mean'' our observable patch of the Universe. Most of these attempts are achieved in the framework of a Friedmann-Lemaître cosmology where large scale homogeneity is assumed. However, we know, from the observation of structures at increasing scales, that these models are only approximations of a smoothed or averaged inhomogeneous underlying patern. Anyhow, when modelling the Universe, the usual method is to use continuous functions representing the kinematical scalars of the velocity field, implicitly assuming that they represent volume averages of the corresponding fine-scale inhomogeneous quantities, then put them into the Einstein equations which are solved to give the model and its dependance upon a number of parameters arbitrarily defined. In General Relativity, such a method is very much involved since the equations which determine the metric tensor and the quantities calculated from it are highly nonlinear. The question raised by the method consisting of determining the parameters of an a priori assumed FLRW model from observational data is the ``fitting problem'' brought to general attention by Ellis and Stoeger in the 80's. This problem has recently experienced a reniewed attention due to the amount of available data and the increase of the minimum scale at which homogeneity can be assumed. We propose a discussion of this issue in the light of the latest developments of observational and theoretical cosmology.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2007; v1 submitted 7 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
The Accelerated Expansion of the Universe Challenged by an Effect of the Inhomogeneities. A Review
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Since its decovery during the late 90's, the dimming of distant SN Ia apparent luminosity has been mostly ascribed to the influence of a mysterious dark energy component. Formulated in a Friedmannian cosmological modelling framework based upon the cosmological ``principle'' hypothesis, this interpretation has given rise to the ``concordance'' model. However, a caveat of such a reasoning is that…
▽ More
Since its decovery during the late 90's, the dimming of distant SN Ia apparent luminosity has been mostly ascribed to the influence of a mysterious dark energy component. Formulated in a Friedmannian cosmological modelling framework based upon the cosmological ``principle'' hypothesis, this interpretation has given rise to the ``concordance'' model. However, a caveat of such a reasoning is that the cosmological ``principle'' derives from a philosophical Copernican assumption and has never been tested. Furthermore, a weakness of its conclusion, i. e., the existence of a negative-pressure fluid or a cosmological constant, is that it would have profound implications for the current theories of physics. This is why we have proposed a more conservative explanation, ascribing the departure of the observed universe from an Einstein-de Sitter model to the influence of inhomogeneities. This idea has been independently developed by other authors and further enlarged to the reproduction of different cosmological data. We review here the main proposals which have been put forward to deal with this purpose and present some prospects for future developments.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2007; v1 submitted 15 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
Is the apparent acceleration of the Universe expansion driven by a dark energy-like component or by inhomogeneities?
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Since its decovery during the late 90's, the dimming of distant SN Ia apparent luminosity has been mostly ascribed to the influence of a mysterious dark energy component. Based upon the cosmological "principle" hypothesis, this interpretation has given rise to the "concordance" model, developed in the context of a Friedmann-Lemaitre cosmology. However, a caveat of this reasoning is that the cosm…
▽ More
Since its decovery during the late 90's, the dimming of distant SN Ia apparent luminosity has been mostly ascribed to the influence of a mysterious dark energy component. Based upon the cosmological "principle" hypothesis, this interpretation has given rise to the "concordance" model, developed in the context of a Friedmann-Lemaitre cosmology. However, a caveat of this reasoning is that the cosmological "principle" derives from a philosophical Copernican assumption and has never been tested. Furthermore, a weakness of its conclusion, i. e., the existence of a negative-pressure fluid or a cosmological constant, is that it would have profound implications for the current theories of physics. This is why we have proposed a more conservative explanation, ascribing the departure of the observed universe from an Einstein-de Sitter model to the influence of inhomogeneities. This idea has been independently developed by other authors and further enlarged to the reproduction of different cosmological data. We review here the main proposals which has been made along these lines of though and present some prospects for future developments.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2006; v1 submitted 8 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
-
Accelerated-like expansion: inhomogeneities versus dark energy
Authors:
Marie-Noelle Celerier
Abstract:
The currently available cosmological data yield, as a most striking result, that the expansion rate of the universe seems to be increasing at late times, contrary to the standard (zero cosmological constant) FLRW prediction. The usual explanation for this discrepancy is that a new component of the energy density of the universe, known as dark energy, dominates this recent evolution. Since the ex…
▽ More
The currently available cosmological data yield, as a most striking result, that the expansion rate of the universe seems to be increasing at late times, contrary to the standard (zero cosmological constant) FLRW prediction. The usual explanation for this discrepancy is that a new component of the energy density of the universe, known as dark energy, dominates this recent evolution. Since the existence of such a new component would have a revolutionary impact on our understanding of the fundamental laws of physics, we think important to check other interpretations. We have therefore shown that the SNIa observations could be reproduced by the effect of inhomogeneities. This idea has been further developed by different teams, and enlarged to other cosmological data. We will give here a review of the results of these works and the prospects for future developments.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Testing the Friedmannian magnitude-redshift relation with SNIa data
Authors:
Marie-Noelle Celerier
Abstract:
Standard cosmology is constructed upon the (generally implicit) assumption of the ``large scale'' homogeneity of our Universe. Now, structures are observed at scales which become larger and larger as the observational distances increase. However, the homogeneous Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker model remains a cosmological paradigm, and Friedmannian relations are usually used to work out the…
▽ More
Standard cosmology is constructed upon the (generally implicit) assumption of the ``large scale'' homogeneity of our Universe. Now, structures are observed at scales which become larger and larger as the observational distances increase. However, the homogeneous Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker model remains a cosmological paradigm, and Friedmannian relations are usually used to work out the model, implicitly assuming that the homogeneity assumption is valid at the studied scales. This has been the way the concordance (Lambda-CDM) model came out from the analyses of the SNIa data. Since this model implies the validity of the Friedmannian magnitude-redshift relation at the range of redshifts spaned by the supernovae surveys, it has been proposed some years ago a very simple test of this possible validity, provided the SNIa should be confirmed as standard candles. Since we can hope that the redshifts of the supernovae which will be observed in the years to come will allow such a test to be performed, it would be interesting to find inside the SNIa community some collaborators ready to perform the test.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2005;
originally announced April 2005.
-
Fractal dimensions of the galaxy distribution varying by steps?
Authors:
Marie-Noelle Celerier,
Reuben Thieberger
Abstract:
The structure of the large scale distribution of the galaxies have been widely studied since the publication of the first catalogs. Since large redshift samples are available, their analyses seem to show fractal correlations up to the observational limits. The value of the fractal dimension(s) calculated by different authors have become the object of a large debate, as have been the value of the…
▽ More
The structure of the large scale distribution of the galaxies have been widely studied since the publication of the first catalogs. Since large redshift samples are available, their analyses seem to show fractal correlations up to the observational limits. The value of the fractal dimension(s) calculated by different authors have become the object of a large debate, as have been the value of the expected transition from fractality to a possible large scale homogeneity. Moreover, some authors have proposed that different scaling regimes might be discerned at different lenght scales. To go further on into this issue, we have applied the correlation integral method to the wider sample currently available. We therefore obtain a fractal dimension of the galaxy distribution which seems to vary by steps whose width might be related to the organization hierarchy observed for the galaxies. This result could explain some of the previous results obtained by other authors from the analyses of less complete catalogs and maybe reconcile their apparent discrepancy. However, the method applied here needs to be further checked, since it produces odd fluctuations at each transition scale, which need to be thoroughly explained.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2005;
originally announced April 2005.
-
Relativistic corrections to fractal analyses of the galaxy distribution
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier,
Reuben Thieberger
Abstract:
The effect of curvature on the results of fractal analyses of the galaxy distribution is investigated. We show that, if the universe satisfies the criteria of a wide class of parabolic homogeneous models, the observers measuring the fractal index with the integrated conditional density procedure may use the Hubble formula, without having to allow for curvature, out to distances of 600 Mpc, and p…
▽ More
The effect of curvature on the results of fractal analyses of the galaxy distribution is investigated. We show that, if the universe satisfies the criteria of a wide class of parabolic homogeneous models, the observers measuring the fractal index with the integrated conditional density procedure may use the Hubble formula, without having to allow for curvature, out to distances of 600 Mpc, and possibly far beyond. This contradicts a previous claim by Ribeiro (1995) that, in the Einstein-de Sitter case, relativistic corrections should be taken into account at much smaller scales. We state for the class of cosmological models under study, and give grounds for conjecture for others, that the averaging procedure has a smoothing effect and that, therefore, the redshift-distance relation provides an upper limit to the relativistic corrections involved in such analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2000;
originally announced December 2000.
-
Models of Universe with a Delayed Big-Bang singularity. III. Solving the horizon problem for an off-center observer
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
This paper is the third of a series dedicated to the study of the Delayed Big-Bang (DBB) class of inhomogeneous cosmological models of Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi type. In the first work, it was shown that the geometrical properties of the DBB model are such that the horizon problem can be solved, without need for any inflationary phase, for an observer situated sufficiently near the symmetry center o…
▽ More
This paper is the third of a series dedicated to the study of the Delayed Big-Bang (DBB) class of inhomogeneous cosmological models of Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi type. In the first work, it was shown that the geometrical properties of the DBB model are such that the horizon problem can be solved, without need for any inflationary phase, for an observer situated sufficiently near the symmetry center of the model to justify the ``centered earth'' approximation. In the second work, we studied, in a peculiar subclass of the DBB models, the extent to which the values of the dipole and quadrupole moments measured in the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) temperature anisotropies can support a cosmological origin. This implies a relation between the location of the observer in the universe and the model parameter value: the farther the observer from the symmetry center, the closer our current universe to a local homogeneous pattern. However, in this case, the centered earth approximation is no longer valid and the results of the first work do not apply. We show here that the horizon problem can be solved, in the DBB model, also for an off-center observer, which improves the consistency of this model regarding the assumption of a CMBR large scale anisotropy cosmological origin.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2000; v1 submitted 11 September, 2000;
originally announced September 2000.
-
SNIa data to probe the Cosmological Principle
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Recently collected SNIa data have been used to address the problem of measuring the cosmological parameters of the universe. Analysed in the framework of homogeneous models, they have yielded, as a primary result, a strictly positive cosmological constant. However, a straight reading of the published measurements, conducted with no a priori idea of which model would best describe our universe, a…
▽ More
Recently collected SNIa data have been used to address the problem of measuring the cosmological parameters of the universe. Analysed in the framework of homogeneous models, they have yielded, as a primary result, a strictly positive cosmological constant. However, a straight reading of the published measurements, conducted with no a priori idea of which model would best describe our universe, at least up to redshifts z=1, does not exclude the possibility of ruling out the Cosmological Principle - and cosmological constant - hypotheses. It is here shown how the large scale (in)homogeneity of this part of the universe can be tested on our past light cone, using the magnitude-redshift relation, provided sufficiently accurate data from sources at redshifts approaching z=1 would be available.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2000;
originally announced June 2000.
-
Supernovae data: Cosmological Constant or ruling out the Cosmological Principle ?
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
Analysed in the framework of homogeneous FLRW models, the magnitude-redshift data from high redshift supernovae yield, as a primary result, a strictly positive cosmological constant. Another reading of the currently published measurements does not exclude a possible ruling out of the Cosmological Principle and, thus, also, of the cosmological constant hypothesis. It is shown how shortly coming d…
▽ More
Analysed in the framework of homogeneous FLRW models, the magnitude-redshift data from high redshift supernovae yield, as a primary result, a strictly positive cosmological constant. Another reading of the currently published measurements does not exclude a possible ruling out of the Cosmological Principle and, thus, also, of the cosmological constant hypothesis. It is shown how shortly coming data can be used to settle this fondamental issue, pertaining to both cosmology and particle physics.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2000;
originally announced May 2000.
-
Solving the horizon problem with a Delayed Big-Bang singularity
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
The hot Big-Bang standard model for the evolution of the universe, despite strong successes, lets unresolved a number of problems. One of its main drawbacks, known as the horizon problem, was until now thought to be only solvable by an inflationary scenario. Here is proposed a class of inhomogeneous models of universe, getting rid of some of the worst drawbacks of standard cosmology. The horizon…
▽ More
The hot Big-Bang standard model for the evolution of the universe, despite strong successes, lets unresolved a number of problems. One of its main drawbacks, known as the horizon problem, was until now thought to be only solvable by an inflationary scenario. Here is proposed a class of inhomogeneous models of universe, getting rid of some of the worst drawbacks of standard cosmology. The horizon problem is solved by means of an initial singularity of "delayed" type and without need for any inflationary phase. The flatness and cosmological constant problems disappear.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 1999;
originally announced November 1999.
-
Do we really see a cosmological constant in the supernovae data ?
Authors:
Marie-Noëlle Célérier
Abstract:
The magnitude-redshift relation is one of the tools for a direct observational approach to cosmology. The discovery of high redshift Type Ia supernovae (SNIa) and their use as ``standard candles'' has resurrected interest in this approach. Recently collected data have been used to address the problem of measuring the cosmological parameters of the universe. Analysed in the framework of homogeneo…
▽ More
The magnitude-redshift relation is one of the tools for a direct observational approach to cosmology. The discovery of high redshift Type Ia supernovae (SNIa) and their use as ``standard candles'' has resurrected interest in this approach. Recently collected data have been used to address the problem of measuring the cosmological parameters of the universe. Analysed in the framework of homogeneous models, they have yielded, as a primary result, a strictly positive cosmological constant. However, a straight reading of the published measurements, conducted with no a priori idea of which model would best describe our universe at least up to redshifts $z\sim 1$, does not exclude the possibility of ruling out the Cosmological Principle - and cosmological constant - hypotheses. It is therefore shown here how the large scale homogeneity of this part of the universe can be tested on our past light cone, using the magnitude-redshift relation, provided sufficiently accurate data from sources at redshifts approaching $z=1$ would be available. An exemple of an inhomogeneous model with zero cosmological constant reproducing the current observations is given. The presently published SNIa data can thus be interpreted as implying either a strictly positive cosmological constant in a homogeneous universe or large scale inhomogeneity with no constraint on $Λ$. An increase in the number and measurement accuracy of the candidate ``standard candles'' at very high redshift is therefore urgently needed, for progress in both fundamental issues of the Cosmological Principle and cosmological constant.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2007; v1 submitted 15 July, 1999;
originally announced July 1999.
-
Models of Universe with an inhomogeneous Big Bang singularity. II. CMBR dipole anisotropy as a byproduct of a conic Big Bang singularity
Authors:
J. Schneider,
M. N. Celerier
Abstract:
The existence of stars and galaxies reqires cosmological models with an inhomogeneous matter and radiation distribution. But in these models the initial singularity surface t_0(r) is in general homogeneous (independent of r). In this second paper of a series devoted to an inhomogeneous Big Bang singularity, we investigate the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) dipole. A special Tolman-…
▽ More
The existence of stars and galaxies reqires cosmological models with an inhomogeneous matter and radiation distribution. But in these models the initial singularity surface t_0(r) is in general homogeneous (independent of r). In this second paper of a series devoted to an inhomogeneous Big Bang singularity, we investigate the cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) dipole. A special Tolman-Bondi Universe is used to study the effect of a Big-Bang singularity, depending linearly on r, on the CMBR anisotropy. It is shown that, for an observer located off the ``center'' of this Universe (r=0), the parameters of the model can be tuned so as to reproduce, with a good approximation, the dipole and the quadrupole moments of the CMBR anisotropy observed in recent experiments. If the dipole should prove cosmological, a slight delaying of the Big-Bang over spatial coordinates would thus be a good candidate for its interpretation.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 1999;
originally announced May 1999.
-
A Solution to the Horizon Problem: A Delayed Big-Bang Singularity
Authors:
M. N. Celerier,
J. Schneider
Abstract:
One of the main drawbacks of standard cosmology, known as the horizon problem, was until now thought to be only solvable in an inflationary scenario. A delayed Big-Bang in an inhomogeneous universe is shown to solve this problem while leaving unimpaired the main successful features of the standard model.
One of the main drawbacks of standard cosmology, known as the horizon problem, was until now thought to be only solvable in an inflationary scenario. A delayed Big-Bang in an inhomogeneous universe is shown to solve this problem while leaving unimpaired the main successful features of the standard model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
