-
Cumulative effect of orbital resonances in extreme-mass-ratio inspirals
Authors:
Edoardo Levati,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Kyriakos Destounis,
Paolo Pani
Abstract:
Orbital resonances in extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) have been proven to be a key feature for accurate gravitational-wave template modeling. Decades of research have led to schemes that can not only model the adiabatic inspiral of such a binary system, but also account for the effects of resonances on their evolution. In this work, we use an effective resonance model that includes analytical…
▽ More
Orbital resonances in extreme-mass-ratio inspirals (EMRIs) have been proven to be a key feature for accurate gravitational-wave template modeling. Decades of research have led to schemes that can not only model the adiabatic inspiral of such a binary system, but also account for the effects of resonances on their evolution. In this work, we use an effective resonance model that includes analytically derived corrections to the radiation reaction fluxes, to study the combined effects of both dominant (low-order) and subdominant (high-order) orbital resonances in EMRIs. We show that using single, universal shifts for all fluxes overestimates the resonance impact, and therefore individualized shifts for each resonance crossing are needed for accurate modeling. Our analysis reveals that the cumulative effects from multiple resonance crossings can significantly impact the orbital evolution of EMRIs, especially for highly eccentric orbits. Our results provide further evidence that resonance effects have to be included in template production to extract detailed astrophysical parameters from EMRI signals.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2025; v1 submitted 27 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Inferring Black Hole Spin from Interferometric Measurements of the First Photon Ring: A Geometric Approach
Authors:
Lennox S. Keeble,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Daniel C. M. Palumbo
Abstract:
Accurately inferring black hole spin is crucial for understanding black hole dynamics and their astrophysical environments. In this work, we outline a geometric method for spin estimation by using the interferometric shape of the first photon ring ($n=1$) as an approximation to the critical curve, which, given an assumed value of the black hole inclination, is then mapped to a spin value. While fu…
▽ More
Accurately inferring black hole spin is crucial for understanding black hole dynamics and their astrophysical environments. In this work, we outline a geometric method for spin estimation by using the interferometric shape of the first photon ring ($n=1$) as an approximation to the critical curve, which, given an assumed value of the black hole inclination, is then mapped to a spin value. While future space-based missions will capture a wealth of data on the first photon ring--including the full angle-dependent diameter, angular brightness profile, and astrometric offset from the $n=0$ ring--our analysis is restricted to using only two angle-dependent diameters to compute its shape asymmetry and infer spin. Focusing on low inclinations and moderate-to-high spins, we test the method across various emission models, baselines, and noise sources, including a mock space-based observation. Although the size of the $n=1$ ring depends on the emission model, its interferometric shape remains a robust spin probe at low inclinations. We find that the inferred asymmetry of the $n=1$ image may be biased by the critical curve morphology, and it can be heavily skewed by the presence of noise, whether astrophysical or instrumental. In low-noise limits at low viewing inclination, significant contributions from the $n=0$ image at short baselines may lead to a downward bias in asymmetry estimates. While our method can estimate high spins in noise-free time-averaged images, increasing the noise and astrophysical variability degrades the resulting constraints, providing only lower bounds on the spin when applied to synthetic observed data. Remarkably, even using only the ring's asymmetry, we can establish lower bounds on the spin, underscoring the promise of photon ring-based spin inference in future space-based very long baseline interferometry missions, such as the proposed Black Hole Explorer.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2025; v1 submitted 27 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Perturbative and non-linear analyses of gravitational turbulence in spacetimes with stable light rings
Authors:
Jaime Redondo-Yuste,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño
Abstract:
Some black hole mimickers, as well as black strings and other higher-dimensional spacetimes, exhibit stable light rings-regions where light or high-frequency gravitational waves can be trapped. In these regions, linear perturbations decay slowly, raising the possibility of nonlinear instability mechanisms. In this work, we study the cubic nonlinear wave equation as a proxy for Einstein's equations…
▽ More
Some black hole mimickers, as well as black strings and other higher-dimensional spacetimes, exhibit stable light rings-regions where light or high-frequency gravitational waves can be trapped. In these regions, linear perturbations decay slowly, raising the possibility of nonlinear instability mechanisms. In this work, we study the cubic nonlinear wave equation as a proxy for Einstein's equations, using a four-dimensional model geometry that allows stable trapping. By employing a perturbative approach, we show that the nonlinear wave equation on the sphere with dissipative terms captures several features of the full nonlinear problem. This framework allows us to confirm a previous conjecture: all higher-order energy norms grow for arbitrarily small initial fluctuation amplitudes. Additionally, we analyze the system's mode spectrum at late times, revealing an inertial range dominated by a direct energy cascade. These findings further support the notion that spacetimes with stable light rings develop weak, high-frequency radiation hair, which will not generically lead to instabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Multidisciplinary Science in the Multimessenger Era
Authors:
Eric Burns,
Christopher L. Fryer,
Ivan Agullo,
Jennifer Andrews,
Elias Aydi,
Matthew G. Baring,
Eddie Baron,
Peter G. Boorman,
Mohammad Ali Boroumand,
Eric Borowski,
Floor S. Broekgaarden,
Poonam Chandra,
Emmanouil Chatzopoulos,
Hsin-Yu Chen,
Kelly A. Chipps,
Francesca Civano,
Luca Comisso,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Phong Dang,
Catherine M. Deibel,
Tarraneh Eftekhari,
Courey Elliott,
Ryan J. Foley,
Christopher J. Fontes,
Amy Gall
, et al. (60 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Astrophysical observations of the cosmos allow us to probe extreme physics and answer foundational questions on our universe. Modern astronomy is increasingly operating under a holistic approach, probing the same question with multiple diagnostics including how sources vary over time, how they appear across the electromagnetic spectrum, and through their other signatures, including gravitational w…
▽ More
Astrophysical observations of the cosmos allow us to probe extreme physics and answer foundational questions on our universe. Modern astronomy is increasingly operating under a holistic approach, probing the same question with multiple diagnostics including how sources vary over time, how they appear across the electromagnetic spectrum, and through their other signatures, including gravitational waves, neutrinos, cosmic rays, and dust on Earth. Astrophysical observations are now reaching the point where approximate physics models are insufficient. Key sources of interest are explosive transients, whose understanding requires multidisciplinary studies at the intersection of astrophysics, gravity, nuclear science, plasma physics, fluid dynamics and turbulence, computation, particle physics, atomic, molecular, and optical science, condensed matter and materials science, radiation transport, and high energy density physics. This white paper provides an overview of the major scientific advances that lay at the intersection of physics and astronomy and are best probed through time-domain and multimessenger astrophysics, an exploration of how multidisciplinary science can be fostered, and introductory descriptions of the relevant scientific disciplines and key astrophysical sources of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2025; v1 submitted 5 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Multi-Frequency Models of Black Hole Photon Rings from Low-Luminosity Accretion Disks
Authors:
Tejahni Desire,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Andrew Chael
Abstract:
Images of black holes encode both astrophysical and gravitational properties. Detecting highly-lensed features in images can differentiate between these two effects. We present an accretion disk emission model coupled to the Adaptive Analytical Ray Tracing (AART) code that allows a fast parameter space exploration of black hole photon ring images produced from synchrotron emission from 10 to 670 G…
▽ More
Images of black holes encode both astrophysical and gravitational properties. Detecting highly-lensed features in images can differentiate between these two effects. We present an accretion disk emission model coupled to the Adaptive Analytical Ray Tracing (AART) code that allows a fast parameter space exploration of black hole photon ring images produced from synchrotron emission from 10 to 670 GHz. As an application, we systematically study several disk models and compute their total flux density, average radii, and optical depth. The model parameters are chosen around fiducial values calibrated to general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations and observations of M87*. For the parameter space studied, we characterize the transition between optically thin and thick regimes and the frequency at which the first photon ring is observable. Our results highlight the need for careful definitions of photon ring radius in the image domain, as in certain models, the highly lensed photon ring is dimmer than the direct emission at certain angles. We find that at low frequencies, the ring radii are set by the electron temperature, while at higher frequencies, the magnetic field strength plays a more significant role, demonstrating how multi-frequency analysis can also be used to infer plasma parameters. Lastly, we show how our implementation can qualitatively reproduce multifrequency black hole images from GRMHD simulations when adding time-variability to our disk model through Gaussian random fields. This approach provides a new method for simulating observations from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) and the proposed Black Hole Explorer (BHEX) space mission.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2025; v1 submitted 26 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
On the Morphology of Relativistically Broadened Line Emission from Axisymmetric Equatorial Accretion Disks
Authors:
Delilah E. A. Gates,
Chau Truong,
Amrita Sahu,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño
Abstract:
Single-frequency emission from an accretion disk around a black hole is broadened into a line profile due to gravitational redshift and the motion of the disk's particles relative to the observer. The ensemble of relativistically broadened emission frequencies from the disk elements forms the spectrum viewed by an observer. Over the past decades, the broadened spectra of accreting systems have bee…
▽ More
Single-frequency emission from an accretion disk around a black hole is broadened into a line profile due to gravitational redshift and the motion of the disk's particles relative to the observer. The ensemble of relativistically broadened emission frequencies from the disk elements forms the spectrum viewed by an observer. Over the past decades, the broadened spectra of accreting systems have been used to constrain the spin of the black hole, the observer's inclination, and the astrophysical model parameters of the system. These inferences are usually made under the assumption that the accretion disk consists of particles orbiting around the black hole on stable circular orbits in the equatorial plane. Under this Standard disk model, in this work, we revisit line profile morphology, i.e., its extent, kinks, and fall-off. We provide a unified analytical explanation for these line profile morphological features, which encode the black hole spin, viewing inclination, and locations of the disk's inner and outer edges. We then show that these features, however, are model-dependent, by parametrically relaxing some of the astrophysical assumptions. In particular, we explore how allowing the disk particles to deviate from stable circular orbits rapidly degenerates the characteristic features of the line profile under the Standard disk model. Our results further demonstrate how sensitive our understanding of black hole and system properties can be to assumptions we make when interpreting these types of measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Measuring Black Hole Light Echoes with Very Long Baseline Interferometry
Authors:
George N. Wong,
Lia Medeiros,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
James M Stone
Abstract:
Light passing near a black hole can follow multiple paths from an emission source to an observer due to strong gravitational lensing. Photons following different paths take different amounts of time to reach the observer, which produces an echo signature in the image. The characteristic echo delay is determined primarily by the mass of the black hole, but it is also influenced by the black hole sp…
▽ More
Light passing near a black hole can follow multiple paths from an emission source to an observer due to strong gravitational lensing. Photons following different paths take different amounts of time to reach the observer, which produces an echo signature in the image. The characteristic echo delay is determined primarily by the mass of the black hole, but it is also influenced by the black hole spin and inclination to the observer. In the Kerr geometry, echo images are demagnified, rotated, and sheared copies of the direct image and lie within a restricted region of the image. Echo images have exponentially suppressed flux, and temporal correlations within the flow make it challenging to directly detect light echoes from the total light curve. In this paper, we propose a novel method to search for light echoes by correlating the total light curve with the interferometric signal at high spatial frequencies, which is a proxy for indirect emission. We explore the viability of our method using numerical general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a near-face-on accretion system scaled to M87-like parameters. We demonstrate that our method can be used to directly infer the echo delay period in simulated data. An echo detection would be clear evidence that we have captured photons that have circled the black hole, and a high-fidelity echo measurement would provide an independent measure of fundamental black hole parameters. Our results suggest that detecting echoes may be achievable through interferometric observations with a modest space-based very long baseline interferometry mission.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
The Black Hole Explorer: Motivation and Vision
Authors:
Michael D. Johnson,
Kazunori Akiyama,
Rebecca Baturin,
Bryan Bilyeu,
Lindy Blackburn,
Don Boroson,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Andrew Chael,
Chi-kwan Chan,
Dominic Chang,
Peter Cheimets,
Cathy Chou,
Sheperd S. Doeleman,
Joseph Farah,
Peter Galison,
Ronald Gamble,
Charles F. Gammie,
Zachary Gelles,
Jose L. Gomez,
Samuel E. Gralla,
Paul Grimes,
Leonid I. Gurvits,
Shahar Hadar,
Kari Haworth,
Kazuhiro Hada
, et al. (43 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present the Black Hole Explorer (BHEX), a mission that will produce the sharpest images in the history of astronomy by extending submillimeter Very-Long-Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) to space. BHEX will discover and measure the bright and narrow "photon ring" that is predicted to exist in images of black holes, produced from light that has orbited the black hole before escaping. This discovery…
▽ More
We present the Black Hole Explorer (BHEX), a mission that will produce the sharpest images in the history of astronomy by extending submillimeter Very-Long-Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) to space. BHEX will discover and measure the bright and narrow "photon ring" that is predicted to exist in images of black holes, produced from light that has orbited the black hole before escaping. This discovery will expose universal features of a black hole's spacetime that are distinct from the complex astrophysics of the emitting plasma, allowing the first direct measurements of a supermassive black hole's spin. In addition to studying the properties of the nearby supermassive black holes M87* and Sgr A*, BHEX will measure the properties of dozens of additional supermassive black holes, providing crucial insights into the processes that drive their creation and growth. BHEX will also connect these supermassive black holes to their relativistic jets, elucidating the power source for the brightest and most efficient engines in the universe. BHEX will address fundamental open questions in the physics and astrophysics of black holes that cannot be answered without submillimeter space VLBI. The mission is enabled by recent technological breakthroughs, including the development of ultra-high-speed downlink using laser communications, and it leverages billions of dollars of existing ground infrastructure. We present the motivation for BHEX, its science goals and associated requirements, and the pathway to launch within the next decade.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The Black Hole Explorer: Photon Ring Science, Detection and Shape Measurement
Authors:
Alexandru Lupsasca,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Daniel C. M. Palumbo,
Michael D. Johnson,
Samuel E. Gralla,
Daniel P. Marrone,
Peter Galison,
Paul Tiede,
Lennox Keeble
Abstract:
General relativity predicts that black hole images ought to display a bright, thin (and as-of-yet-unresolved) ring. This "photon ring" is produced by photons that explore the strong gravity of the black hole, flowing along trajectories that experience extreme light bending within a few Schwarzschild radii of the horizon before escaping. The shape of the photon ring is largely insensitive to the pr…
▽ More
General relativity predicts that black hole images ought to display a bright, thin (and as-of-yet-unresolved) ring. This "photon ring" is produced by photons that explore the strong gravity of the black hole, flowing along trajectories that experience extreme light bending within a few Schwarzschild radii of the horizon before escaping. The shape of the photon ring is largely insensitive to the precise details of the emission from the astronomical source surrounding the black hole and therefore provides a direct probe of the Kerr geometry and its parameters. The Black Hole Explorer (BHEX) is a proposed space-based experiment targeting the supermassive black holes M87* and Sgr A* with radio-interferometric observations at frequencies of 100 GHz through 300 GHz and from an orbital distance of ~30,000 km. This design will enable measurements of the photon rings around both M87* and Sgr A*, confirming the Kerr nature of these sources and delivering sharp estimates of their masses and spins.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Explanation for the absence of secondary peaks in black hole light curve autocorrelations
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Charles Gammie,
Alexandru Lupsasca
Abstract:
The observed radiation from hot gas accreting onto a black hole depends on both the details of the flow and the spacetime geometry. The lensing behavior of a black hole produces a distinctive pattern of autocorrelations within its photon ring that encodes its mass, spin, and inclination. In particular, the time autocorrelation of the light curve is expected to display a series of peaks produced by…
▽ More
The observed radiation from hot gas accreting onto a black hole depends on both the details of the flow and the spacetime geometry. The lensing behavior of a black hole produces a distinctive pattern of autocorrelations within its photon ring that encodes its mass, spin, and inclination. In particular, the time autocorrelation of the light curve is expected to display a series of peaks produced by light echoes of the source, with each peak delayed by the characteristic time lapse $τ$ between light echoes. However, such peaks are absent from the light curves of observed black holes. Here, we develop an analytical model for such light curves that demonstrates how, even though light echoes always exist in the signal, they do not produce autocorrelation peaks if the characteristic correlation timescale $λ_0$ of the source is greater than $τ$. We validate our model against simulated light curves of a stochastic accretion model ray traced with a general-relativistic code, and then fit the model to an observed light curve for Sgr A*. We infer that $λ_0>τ$, providing an explanation for the absence of light echoes in the time autocorrelations of Sgr A* light curves. Our results highlight the importance for black hole parameter inference of spatially resolving the photon ring via future space-based interferometry.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2024; v1 submitted 6 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Assessing the impact of instrument noise and astrophysical fluctuations on measurements of the first black hole photon ring
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Lennox Keeble,
Alexandru Lupsasca
Abstract:
Currently envisioned extensions of the Event Horizon Telescope to space will soon target the black hole photon ring: a narrow ring-shaped imprint of a black hole's strong gravity produced in its images by highly bent photon trajectories. In principle, the shape of the photon ring encodes information about the geometry of the underlying black hole spacetime. In practice, however, whether or not thi…
▽ More
Currently envisioned extensions of the Event Horizon Telescope to space will soon target the black hole photon ring: a narrow ring-shaped imprint of a black hole's strong gravity produced in its images by highly bent photon trajectories. In principle, the shape of the photon ring encodes information about the geometry of the underlying black hole spacetime. In practice, however, whether or not this information can be extracted from the ring shape depends on several factors, ranging from the astrophysical details of the emitting source (such as the magnitude of its plasma fluctuations) to the specific configuration of the interferometric array (such as the separation between its telescopes, or the level of noise in its instruments). Here, we employ a phenomenological model to assess the impact of astrophysical fluctuations and instrument noise on the inferred shape of the photon ring. Our systematic study of several astrophysical profiles suggests that this shape can be measured even in the presence of instrument noise across a wide range of baselines. The measurement accuracy and precision appear relatively insensitive to the noise level, up to a sharp threshold beyond which any measurement becomes incredibly challenging (at least without recourse to more sophisticated data analysis methods). Encouragingly, we find that only a few snapshot images are generally needed to overcome the impact of astrophysical fluctuations and correctly infer the ring diameter. Inference becomes more challenging when analyzing the visibility amplitude in a baseline window that is not entirely dominated by a single photon ring. Nevertheless, in most cases, it is still possible to fit a ring shape with the correct fractional asymmetry. These results provide excellent prospects for future precision measurements of black hole spin and fundamental astrophysics via black hole imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024; v1 submitted 1 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Testing gravity with Extreme-Mass-Ratio Inspirals
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Carlos F. Sopuerta
Abstract:
Extreme-mass-ratio inspirals consist of binary systems of compact objects, with orders of magnitude differences in their masses, in the regime where the dynamics are driven by gravitational wave emission. The unique nature of extreme-mass-ratio inspirals facilitates the exploration of diverse and stimulating tests related to various aspects of black holes and General Relativity. These tests encomp…
▽ More
Extreme-mass-ratio inspirals consist of binary systems of compact objects, with orders of magnitude differences in their masses, in the regime where the dynamics are driven by gravitational wave emission. The unique nature of extreme-mass-ratio inspirals facilitates the exploration of diverse and stimulating tests related to various aspects of black holes and General Relativity. These tests encompass investigations into the spacetime geometry, the dissipation of the binary system energy and angular momentum, and the impact of the intrinsic non-linear effects of the gravitational interaction. This review accounts for the manifold opportunities for testing General Relativity, ranging from examinations of black hole properties to cosmological and multimessenger tests.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024; v1 submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
A Lensing-Band Approach to Spacetime Constraints
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Aaron Held
Abstract:
General relativity's prediction that all black holes are described by the Kerr metric, irrespective of their size, can now be empirically tested using electromagnetic observations of supermassive black holes and gravitational waves from mergers of stellar-mass black holes. In this work, we focus on the electromagnetic side of this test and quantify the constraining power of very-long-baseline-inte…
▽ More
General relativity's prediction that all black holes are described by the Kerr metric, irrespective of their size, can now be empirically tested using electromagnetic observations of supermassive black holes and gravitational waves from mergers of stellar-mass black holes. In this work, we focus on the electromagnetic side of this test and quantify the constraining power of very-long-baseline-interferometry (VLBI) observations of emission generated by hot gas surrounding supermassive black holes. We demonstrate how to use lensing bands--annular regions on the observer's screen surrounding the critical curve--to constrain the underlying spacetime geometry. Contingent upon a detection of a lensed VLBI feature, the resulting lensing-band framework allows us to exclude spacetimes for which said feature cannot arise from geodesics that traversed the equatorial plane more than once. Focusing on the first indirect image and tests of black-hole uniqueness, we employ a parametrized spacetime as a case study. We find that resolving geometric information that goes beyond the apparent size of the critical curve has the potential to lift degeneracies between different spacetime parameters. Our work thereby quantifies a conservative estimate of the constraining power of VLBI measurements and contributes to a larger effort to simultaneously constrain geometry and astrophysics.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024; v1 submitted 11 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Waveform Modelling for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
Authors:
LISA Consortium Waveform Working Group,
Niayesh Afshordi,
Sarp Akçay,
Pau Amaro Seoane,
Andrea Antonelli,
Josu C. Aurrekoetxea,
Leor Barack,
Enrico Barausse,
Robert Benkel,
Laura Bernard,
Sebastiano Bernuzzi,
Emanuele Berti,
Matteo Bonetti,
Béatrice Bonga,
Gabriele Bozzola,
Richard Brito,
Alessandra Buonanno,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Marc Casals,
David F. Chernoff,
Alvin J. K. Chua,
Katy Clough,
Marta Colleoni,
Mekhi Dhesi,
Adrien Druart
, et al. (121 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
LISA, the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, will usher in a new era in gravitational-wave astronomy. As the first anticipated space-based gravitational-wave detector, it will expand our view to the millihertz gravitational-wave sky, where a spectacular variety of interesting new sources abound: from millions of ultra-compact binaries in our Galaxy, to mergers of massive black holes at cosmologic…
▽ More
LISA, the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, will usher in a new era in gravitational-wave astronomy. As the first anticipated space-based gravitational-wave detector, it will expand our view to the millihertz gravitational-wave sky, where a spectacular variety of interesting new sources abound: from millions of ultra-compact binaries in our Galaxy, to mergers of massive black holes at cosmological distances; from the beginnings of inspirals that will venture into the ground-based detectors' view to the death spiral of compact objects into massive black holes, and many sources in between. Central to realising LISA's discovery potential are waveform models, the theoretical and phenomenological predictions of the pattern of gravitational waves that these sources emit. This white paper is presented on behalf of the Waveform Working Group for the LISA Consortium. It provides a review of the current state of waveform models for LISA sources, and describes the significant challenges that must yet be overcome.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Prediction for the interferometric shape of the first black hole photon ring
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Alexandru Lupsasca
Abstract:
Black hole images are theoretically predicted (under mild astrophysical assumptions) to display a stack of lensed "photon rings" that carry information about the underlying spacetime geometry. Despite vigorous efforts, no such ring has been observationally resolved thus far. However, planning is now actively under way for space missions targeting the first (and possibly the second) photon rings of…
▽ More
Black hole images are theoretically predicted (under mild astrophysical assumptions) to display a stack of lensed "photon rings" that carry information about the underlying spacetime geometry. Despite vigorous efforts, no such ring has been observationally resolved thus far. However, planning is now actively under way for space missions targeting the first (and possibly the second) photon rings of the supermassive black holes M87* and Sgr A*. In this work, we study interferometric photon ring signatures in time-averaged images of Kerr black holes surrounded by different astrophysical profiles. We focus on the first, most easily accessible photon ring, which has a larger width-to-diameter ratio than subsequent rings and whose image consequently lacks a sharply defined diameter. Nonetheless, we show that it does admit a precise angle-dependent diameter in visibility space, for which the Kerr metric predicts a specific functional form that tracks the critical curve. We find that a measurement of this interferometric ring diameter is possible for most astrophysical profiles, paving the way for precision tests of strong-field general relativity via near-future observations of the first photon ring.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2023; v1 submitted 22 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Adaptive Analytical Ray Tracing of Black Hole Photon Rings
Authors:
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Alexandru Lupsasca,
Hengrui Zhu
Abstract:
Recent interferometric observations by the Event Horizon Telescope have resolved the horizon-scale emission from sources in the vicinity of nearby supermassive black holes. Future space-based interferometers promise to measure the "photon ring"--a narrow, ring-shaped, lensed feature predicted by general relativity, but not yet observed--and thereby open a new window into strong gravity. Here we pr…
▽ More
Recent interferometric observations by the Event Horizon Telescope have resolved the horizon-scale emission from sources in the vicinity of nearby supermassive black holes. Future space-based interferometers promise to measure the "photon ring"--a narrow, ring-shaped, lensed feature predicted by general relativity, but not yet observed--and thereby open a new window into strong gravity. Here we present AART: an Adaptive Analytical Ray-Tracing code that exploits the integrability of light propagation in the Kerr spacetime to rapidly compute high-resolution simulated black hole images, together with the corresponding radio visibility accessible on very long space-ground baselines. The code samples images on a nonuniform adaptive grid that is specially tailored to the lensing behavior of the Kerr geometry and is therefore particularly well-suited to studying photon rings. This numerical approach guarantees that interferometric signatures are correctly computed on long baselines, and the modularity of the code allows for detailed studies of equatorial sources with complex emission profiles and time variability. To demonstrate its capabilities, we use AART to simulate a black hole movie of a stochastic, non-stationary, non-axisymmetric equatorial source; by time-averaging the visibility amplitude of each snapshot, we are able to extract the projected diameter of the photon ring and recover the shape predicted by general relativity.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Tidally-induced nonlinear resonances in EMRIs with an analogue model
Authors:
David Bronicki,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Leo C. Stein
Abstract:
One of the important targets for the future space-based gravitational wave observatory LISA is extreme mass ratio inspirals (EMRIs), where long and accurate waveform modeling is necessary for detection and characterization. Modeling EMRI dynamics requires accounting for effects such as the ones induced by an external tidal field, which can break integrability at resonances and cause significant de…
▽ More
One of the important targets for the future space-based gravitational wave observatory LISA is extreme mass ratio inspirals (EMRIs), where long and accurate waveform modeling is necessary for detection and characterization. Modeling EMRI dynamics requires accounting for effects such as the ones induced by an external tidal field, which can break integrability at resonances and cause significant dephasing. In this paper, we use a Newtonian analogue of a Kerr black hole to study the effect of an external tidal field on the dynamics and the gravitational waveform. We have developed a numerical framework that takes advantage of the integrability of the background system to evolve it with a symplectic splitting integrator, and compute approximate gravitational waveforms to estimate the timescale over which the perturbation affects the dynamics. Comparing this timescale with the characteristic time under radiation reaction at resonance, we introduce a tool for quantifying the regime in which tidal effects might be included when modeling EMRI gravitational waves. As an application of this framework, we perform a detailed analysis of the dynamics at one resonance to show how different entry points into the resonance in phase-space can produce substantially different dynamics, and how one can estimate bounds for the parameter space where tidal effects may become dominant. Such bounds will scale as $\varepsilon \gtrsim C \, q$, where $\varepsilon$ measures the strength of the external tidal field, $q$ is the mass ratio, and $C$ is a number which depends on the resonance and the shape of the tide. We demonstrate how to estimate $C$ using our framework for the 2:3 radial to polar frequency resonance in our model system. This framework can serve as a proxy for proper modeling of the tidal perturbation in the fully relativistic case.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023; v1 submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Spherical accretion in alternative theories of gravity
Authors:
Adam Bauer,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Charles F. Gammie,
Nicolás Yunes
Abstract:
The groundbreaking image of the black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy has raised questions at the intersection of observational astronomy and black hole physics. How well can the radius of a black hole shadow can be measured, and can this measurement be used to distinguish general relativity from other theories of gravity? We explore these questions using a simple spherical flow model in gene…
▽ More
The groundbreaking image of the black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy has raised questions at the intersection of observational astronomy and black hole physics. How well can the radius of a black hole shadow can be measured, and can this measurement be used to distinguish general relativity from other theories of gravity? We explore these questions using a simple spherical flow model in general relativity, scalar Gauss--Bonnet gravity, and the Rezzolla and Zhidenko parameterized metric. We assume an optically thin plasma with power-law emissivity in radius. Along the way we present a generalized Bondi flow as well as a piecewise-analytic model for the brightness profile of a cold inflow. We use the second moment of a synthetic image as a proxy for EHT observables and compute the ratio of the second moment to the radius of the black hole shadow. We show that corrections to this ratio from modifications to general relativity are subdominant compared to corrections to the critical impact parameter, and argue that this is generally true. We find that astrophysical model parameters are the dominant source of uncertainty in this calculation, emphasizing the importance of understanding the astrophysical model. Given a sufficiently accurate astrophysical model, however, it is possible using measurements of the black hole shadow to distinguish between general relativity and other theories of gravity.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021; v1 submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Modeling uncertainties in X-ray reflection spectroscopy measurements II: Impact of the radiation from the plunging region
Authors:
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Menglei Zhou,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful tool to probe the strong gravity region around black holes, but the available relativistic reflection models have a number of simplifications that lead to systematic uncertainties (not fully under control) in the measurement of the properties of a source. In Paper I, we considered the case of an optically thin plunging region and we studied the impact of…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful tool to probe the strong gravity region around black holes, but the available relativistic reflection models have a number of simplifications that lead to systematic uncertainties (not fully under control) in the measurement of the properties of a source. In Paper I, we considered the case of an optically thin plunging region and we studied the impact of the radiation produced by the other side of the disk or circling the black hole one or more times. In the present paper, we discuss the case of an optically thick plunging region and we study the impact of the reflection spectrum of the plunging gas. We show that the contribution of such radiation is more important for low values of the black hole spin parameter and large values of the viewing angle, and it decreases significantly as the spin parameter increases and the inclination angle decreases. While the estimate of some parameters may be affected by the reflection spectrum of the plunging gas if this is not included in the theoretical model, we find that such radiation does not appreciably limit our capability of testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2020; v1 submitted 14 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Astrophysical and theoretical physics implications from multimessenger neutron star observations
Authors:
Hector O. Silva,
A. Miguel Holgado,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Nicolás Yunes
Abstract:
The Neutron Star Interior Composition Explorer (NICER) recently measured the mass and equatorial radius of the isolated neutron star PSR J0030+0451. We use these measurements to infer the moment of inertia, the quadrupole moment, and the surface eccentricity of an isolated neutron star for the first time, using relations between these quantities that are insensitive to the unknown equation of stat…
▽ More
The Neutron Star Interior Composition Explorer (NICER) recently measured the mass and equatorial radius of the isolated neutron star PSR J0030+0451. We use these measurements to infer the moment of inertia, the quadrupole moment, and the surface eccentricity of an isolated neutron star for the first time, using relations between these quantities that are insensitive to the unknown equation of state of supranuclear matter. We also use these results to forecast the moment of inertia of neutron star A in the double pulsar binary J0737-3039, a quantity anticipated to be directly measured in the coming decade with radio observations. Combining this information with the measurement of the tidal Love number with LIGO/Virgo observations, we propose and implement the first theory-agnostic and equation-of-state-insensitive test of general relativity. Specializing these constraints to a particular modified theory, we find that consistency with general relativity places the most stringent constraint on gravitational parity violation to date, surpassing all other previously reported bounds by seven orders of magnitude and opens the path for future a test of general relativity with multimessenger neutron star observations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021; v1 submitted 2 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Astrobites as a Community-led Model for Education, Science Communication, and Accessibility in Astrophysics
Authors:
Gourav Khullar,
Susanna Kohler,
Tarini Konchady,
Mike Foley,
Amber L. Hornsby,
Mithi A. de los Reyes,
Nora Elisa Chisari,
V. Ashley Villar,
Kaitlyn Shin,
Caitlin Doughty,
Nora Shipp,
Joanna Ramasawmy,
Zephyr Penoyre,
Tim Lichtenberg,
Kate Storey-Fisher,
Oliver Hall,
Briley Lewis,
Aaron B. Pearlman,
Alejandro Cárdenas-Avendaño,
Joanna S. Bridge,
Elena González-Egea,
Vatsal Panwar,
Zachary Slepian,
Mara Zimmerman
Abstract:
Support for early career astronomers who are just beginning to explore astronomy research is imperative to increase retention of diverse practitioners in the field. Since 2010, Astrobites has played an instrumental role in engaging members of the community -- particularly undergraduate and graduate students -- in research. In this white paper, the Astrobites collaboration outlines our multi-facete…
▽ More
Support for early career astronomers who are just beginning to explore astronomy research is imperative to increase retention of diverse practitioners in the field. Since 2010, Astrobites has played an instrumental role in engaging members of the community -- particularly undergraduate and graduate students -- in research. In this white paper, the Astrobites collaboration outlines our multi-faceted online education platform that both eases the transition into astronomy research and promotes inclusive professional development opportunities. We additionally offer recommendations for how the astronomy community can reduce barriers to entry to astronomy research in the coming decade.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Experimental Relativity with Accretion Disk Observations
Authors:
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Jaxen Godfrey,
Nicolas Yunes,
Anne Lohfink
Abstract:
Electromagnetic observations have been used over the past decades to understand the nature of black holes and the material around them. Our ability to learn about the fundamental physics relies on our understanding of two key ingredients in the modeling of these electromagnetic observations: the gravity theory that describes the black hole, and the astrophysics that produces the observed radiation…
▽ More
Electromagnetic observations have been used over the past decades to understand the nature of black holes and the material around them. Our ability to learn about the fundamental physics relies on our understanding of two key ingredients in the modeling of these electromagnetic observations: the gravity theory that describes the black hole, and the astrophysics that produces the observed radiation. In this work we study our current ability to constrain and detect deviations from General Relativity using the accretion disk spectrum of stellar-mass black holes in binary systems. Our analysis combines relativistic ray-tracing and Markov-Chain Monte-Carlo sampling techniques to determine how well such tests of General Relativity can be carried out in practice. We show that even when a very simple astrophysical model for the accretion disk is assumed a priori, the uncertainties and covariances between the parameters of the model and the parameters that control the deformation from General Relativity make any test of General Relativity very challenging with accretion disk spectrum observations. We also discuss the implications of assuming that General Relativity is correct a priori on the estimation of parameters of the astrophysical model when the data is not described by Einstein's theory, which can lead to a fundamental systematic bias.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2019; v1 submitted 7 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Iron K$α$ line of boson stars
Authors:
Zheng Cao,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Menglei Zhou,
Cosimo Bambi,
Carlos A. R. Herdeiro,
Eugen Radu
Abstract:
The present paper is a sequel to our previous work [Y. Ni et al., JCAP 1607, 049 (2016)] in which we studied the iron K$α$ line expected in the reflection spectrum of Kerr black holes with scalar hair. These metrics are solutions of Einstein's gravity minimally coupled to a massive, complex scalar field. They form a continuous bridge between a subset of Kerr black holes and a family of rotating bo…
▽ More
The present paper is a sequel to our previous work [Y. Ni et al., JCAP 1607, 049 (2016)] in which we studied the iron K$α$ line expected in the reflection spectrum of Kerr black holes with scalar hair. These metrics are solutions of Einstein's gravity minimally coupled to a massive, complex scalar field. They form a continuous bridge between a subset of Kerr black holes and a family of rotating boson stars depending on one extra parameter, the dimensionless scalar hair parameter $q$, ranging from 0 (Kerr black holes) to 1 (boson stars). Here we study the limiting case $q=1$, corresponding to rotating boson stars. For comparison, spherical boson stars are also considered. We simulate observations with XIS/Suzaku. Using the fact that current observations are well fit by the Kerr solution and thus requiring that acceptable alternative compact objects must be compatible with a Kerr fit, we find that some boson star solutions are relatively easy to rule out as potential candidates to explain astrophysical black holes, while other solutions, which are neither too dilute nor too compact are more elusive and we argue that they cannot be distinguished from Kerr black holes by the analysis of the iron line with current X-ray facilities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2016; v1 submitted 4 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Cosimo Bambi,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We present the first X-ray reflection model for testing the assumption that the metric of astrophysical black holes is described by the Kerr solution. We employ the formalism of the transfer function proposed by Cunningham. The calculations of the reflection spectrum of a thin accretion disk are split into two parts: the calculation of the transfer function and the calculation of the local spectru…
▽ More
We present the first X-ray reflection model for testing the assumption that the metric of astrophysical black holes is described by the Kerr solution. We employ the formalism of the transfer function proposed by Cunningham. The calculations of the reflection spectrum of a thin accretion disk are split into two parts: the calculation of the transfer function and the calculation of the local spectrum at any emission point in the disk. The transfer function only depends on the background metric and takes into account all the relativistic effects (gravitational redshift, Doppler boosting, and light bending). Our code computes the transfer function for a spacetime described by the Johannsen metric and can easily be extended to any stationary, axisymmetric, and asymptotically flat spacetime. Transfer functions and single line shapes in the Kerr metric are compared with those calculated from existing codes to check that we reach the necessary accuracy. We also simulate some observations with NuSTAR and LAD/eXTP and fit the data with our new model to show the potential capabilities of current and future observations to constrain possible deviations from the Kerr metric.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2017; v1 submitted 3 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Iron K$α$ line of Kerr black holes with scalar hair
Authors:
Yueying Ni,
Menglei Zhou,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Cosimo Bambi,
Carlos A. R. Herdeiro,
Eugen Radu
Abstract:
Recently, a family of hairy black holes in 4-dimensional Einstein gravity minimally coupled to a complex, massive scalar field was discovered~\cite{hbh}. Besides the mass $M$ and spin angular momentum $J$, these objects are characterized by a Noether charge $Q$, measuring the amount of scalar hair, which is not associated to a Gauss law and cannot be measured at spatial infinity. Introducing a dim…
▽ More
Recently, a family of hairy black holes in 4-dimensional Einstein gravity minimally coupled to a complex, massive scalar field was discovered~\cite{hbh}. Besides the mass $M$ and spin angular momentum $J$, these objects are characterized by a Noether charge $Q$, measuring the amount of scalar hair, which is not associated to a Gauss law and cannot be measured at spatial infinity. Introducing a dimensionless scalar hair parameter $q$, ranging from 0 to 1, we recover (a subset of) Kerr black holes for $q=0$ and a family of rotating boson stars for $q=1$. In the present paper, we explore the possibility of measuring $q$ for astrophysical black holes with current and future X-ray missions. We study the iron K$α$ line expected in the reflection spectrum of such hairy black holes and we simulate observations with Suzaku and eXTP. As a proof of concept, we point out, by analyzing a sample of hairy black holes, that current observations can already constrain the scalar hair parameter $q$, because black holes with $q$ close to 1 would have iron lines definitively different from those we observe in the available data. We conclude that a detailed scanning of the full space of solutions, together with data from the future X-ray missions, like eXTP, will be able to put relevant constraints on the astrophysical realization of Kerr black holes with scalar hair.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2016; v1 submitted 15 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Search for astrophysical rotating Ellis wormholes with X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Menglei Zhou,
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Cosimo Bambi,
Burkhard Kleihaus,
Jutta Kunz
Abstract:
Recently, two of us have found numerically rotating Ellis wormholes as solutions of 4-dimensional Einstein gravity coupled to a phantom field. In this paper, we investigate possible observational signatures to identify similar objects in the Universe. These symmetric wormholes have a mass and are compact, so they may look like black holes. We study the iron line profile in the X-ray reflection spe…
▽ More
Recently, two of us have found numerically rotating Ellis wormholes as solutions of 4-dimensional Einstein gravity coupled to a phantom field. In this paper, we investigate possible observational signatures to identify similar objects in the Universe. These symmetric wormholes have a mass and are compact, so they may look like black holes. We study the iron line profile in the X-ray reflection spectrum of a thin accretion disk around rotating Ellis wormholes and we find some specific observational signatures that can be used to distinguish these objects from Kerr black holes. We simulate some observations with XIS/Suzaku assuming typical parameters for a bright AGN and we conclude that current X-ray missions cannot apply strong constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2016; v1 submitted 24 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis: comparison between the gravitational wave and the iron line approaches
Authors:
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Jiachen Jiang,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
The recent announcement of the detection of gravitational waves by the LIGO/Virgo collaboration has opened a new window to test the nature of astrophysical black holes. Konoplya & Zhidenko have shown how the LIGO data of GW 150914 can constrain possible deviations from the Kerr metric. In this letter, we compare their constraints with those that can be obtained from accreting black holes by fittin…
▽ More
The recent announcement of the detection of gravitational waves by the LIGO/Virgo collaboration has opened a new window to test the nature of astrophysical black holes. Konoplya & Zhidenko have shown how the LIGO data of GW 150914 can constrain possible deviations from the Kerr metric. In this letter, we compare their constraints with those that can be obtained from accreting black holes by fitting their reflected X-ray spectrum, the so-called iron line method. We simulate observations with eXTP, a next generation X-ray mission, finding constraints much stronger than those obtained by Konoplya & Zhidenko. Our results can at least show that, contrary to what is quite commonly believed, it is not obvious that gravitational waves are the most powerful approach to test strong gravity. In the presence of high quality data and with the systematics under control, the iron line method may provide competitive constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2016; v1 submitted 15 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A study for testing the Kerr metric with AGN iron line eclipses
Authors:
Alejandro Cardenas-Avendano,
Jiachen Jiang,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
Recently, two of us have studied iron line reverberation mapping to test black hole candidates, showing that the time information in reverberation mapping can better constrain the Kerr metric than the time-integrated approach. Motivated by this finding, here we explore the constraining power of another time-dependent measurement: an AGN iron line eclipse. An obscuring cloud passes between the AGN…
▽ More
Recently, two of us have studied iron line reverberation mapping to test black hole candidates, showing that the time information in reverberation mapping can better constrain the Kerr metric than the time-integrated approach. Motivated by this finding, here we explore the constraining power of another time-dependent measurement: an AGN iron line eclipse. An obscuring cloud passes between the AGN and the distant observer, covering different parts of the accretion disk at different times. Similar to the reverberation measurement, an eclipse might help to better identify the relativistic effects affecting the X-ray photons. However, this is not what we find. In our study, we employ the Johannsen-Psaltis parametrisation, but we argue that our conclusions hold in a large class of non-Kerr metrics. We explain our results pointing out an important difference between reverberation and eclipse measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2016; v1 submitted 13 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A Survey of Astronomical Research: An Astronomy for Development Baseline
Authors:
V. A. R. M. Ribeiro,
P. Russo,
A. Cardenas-Avendano
Abstract:
Measuring scientific development is a difficult task. Different metrics have been put forward to evaluate scientific development; in this paper we explore a metric that uses the number of peer-reviewed, and when available non-peer-reviewed articles, research research articles as an indicator of development in the field of astronomy. We analyzed the available publication record, using the SAO/NASA…
▽ More
Measuring scientific development is a difficult task. Different metrics have been put forward to evaluate scientific development; in this paper we explore a metric that uses the number of peer-reviewed, and when available non-peer-reviewed articles, research research articles as an indicator of development in the field of astronomy. We analyzed the available publication record, using the SAO/NASA Astrophysics Database System, by country affiliation in the time span between 1950 and 2011 for countries with a Gross National Income of less than 14,365 USD in 2010. This represents 149 countries. We propose that this metric identifies countries in `astronomy development' with a culture of research publishing. We also propose that for a country to develop astronomy it should invest in outside expert visits, send their staff abroad to study and establish a culture of scientific publishing. Furthermore, we propose that this paper may be used as a baseline to measure the success of major international projects, such as the International Year of Astronomy 2009.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2013; v1 submitted 2 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
