Showing 1–20 of 20 results for author: Buckner, A S M

FEAST: JWST uncovers the emerging timescales of young star clusters in M83

Authors: Alice Knutas, Angela Adamo, Alex Pedrini, Sean T. Linden, Varun Bajaj, Jenna E. Ryon, Benjamin Gregg, Ahmad A. Ali, Eric P. Andersson, Arjan Bik, Giacomo Bortolini, Anne S. M. Buckner, Daniela Calzetti, Ana Duarte-Cabral, Bruce G. Elmegreen, Helena Faustino Vieira, John S. Gallagher, Kathryn Grasha, Kelsey Johnson, Thomas S. -Y. Lai, Drew Lapeer, Matteo Messa, Göran Östlin, Elena Sabbi, Linda J. Smith , et al. (1 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present JWST NIRCam observations of the emerging young star clusters (eYSCs) detected in the nearby spiral galaxy M83. The NIRcam mosaic encompasses the nuclear starburst, the bar, and the inner spiral arms. The eYSCs, detected in Pa$α$ and Br$α$ maps, have been largely missed in previous optical campaigns of young star clusters (YSCs). We distinguish between eYSCI, if they also have compact 3.… ▽ More We present JWST NIRCam observations of the emerging young star clusters (eYSCs) detected in the nearby spiral galaxy M83. The NIRcam mosaic encompasses the nuclear starburst, the bar, and the inner spiral arms. The eYSCs, detected in Pa$α$ and Br$α$ maps, have been largely missed in previous optical campaigns of young star clusters (YSCs). We distinguish between eYSCI, if they also have compact 3.3~$μ$m PAH emission associated to them, and eYSCII, if they only appear as compact Pa$α$ emitters. We find that the variations in the 3.3~$μ$m PAH feature are consistent with an evolutionary sequence where eYSCI evolve into eYSCII and then optical YSCs. This sequence is clear in the F300M-F335M (tracing the excess in the \PAHlambda\ feature) and the F115W-F187N (tracing the excess in Pa$α$) colors which become increasingly bluer as clusters emerge. The central starburst stands out as the region where the most massive eYSCs are currently forming in the galaxy. We estimate that only about 20~\% of the eYSCs will remain detectable as compact YSCs. Combining eYSCs and YSCs ($\leq$10 Myr) we recover an average clearing timescale of 6~Myr in which clusters transition from embedded to fully exposed. We see evidence of shorter emergence timescales ($\sim$5~Myr) for more massive ($>5\times10^3$ \msun) clusters, while star clusters of $\sim 10^3$ \msun\ about 7~Myr. We estimate that eYSCs remain associated to the \PAHlambda\ emission 3--4~Myr. Larger samples of eYSC and YSC populations will provide stronger statistics to further test environmental and cluster mass dependencies on the emergence timescale. △ Less

Submitted 13 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: Submitted to ApJ. Comments welcome

Observational Bias and Young Massive Cluster Characterisation II. Can Gaia accurately observe young clusters and associations?

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Tim Naylor, Clare L. Dobbs, Steven Rieder, Thomas J. R. Bending

Abstract: Observations of clusters suffer from issues such as completeness, projection effects, resolving individual stars and extinction. As such, how accurate are measurements and conclusions are likely to be? Here, we take cluster simulations (Westerlund2- and Orion- type), synthetically observe them to obtain luminosities, accounting for extinction and the inherent limits of Gaia, then place them within… ▽ More Observations of clusters suffer from issues such as completeness, projection effects, resolving individual stars and extinction. As such, how accurate are measurements and conclusions are likely to be? Here, we take cluster simulations (Westerlund2- and Orion- type), synthetically observe them to obtain luminosities, accounting for extinction and the inherent limits of Gaia, then place them within the real Gaia DR3 catalogue. We then attempt to rediscover the clusters at distances of between 500pc and 4300pc. We show the spatial and kinematic criteria which are best able to pick out the simulated clusters, maximising completeness and minimising contamination. We then compare the properties of the 'observed' clusters with the original simulations. We looked at the degree of clustering, the identification of clusters and subclusters within the datasets, and whether the clusters are expanding or contracting. Even with a high level of incompleteness (e.g. $<2\%$ stellar members identified), similar qualitative conclusions tend to be reached compared to the original dataset, but most quantitative conclusions are likely to be inaccurate. Accurate determination of the number, stellar membership and kinematic properties of subclusters, are the most problematic to correctly determine, particularly at larger distances due to the disappearance of cluster substructure as the data become more incomplete, but also at smaller distances where the misidentification of asterisms as true structure can be problematic. Unsurprisingly, we tend to obtain better quantitative agreement of properties for our more massive Westerlund2-type cluster. We also make optical style images of the clusters over our range of distances. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2023; v1 submitted 31 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 19 pages, 10 figures, 6 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Star cluster formation and feedback in different environments of a Milky Way-like galaxy

Authors: Ahmad A. Ali, Clare L. Dobbs, Thomas J. R. Bending, Anne S. M. Buckner, Alex R. Pettitt

Abstract: It remains unclear how galactic environment affects star formation and stellar cluster properties. This is difficult to address in Milky Way-mass galaxy simulations because of limited resolution and less accurate feedback compared to cloud-scale models. We carry out zoom-in simulations to re-simulate 100-300 pc regions of a Milky Way-like galaxy using smoothed particle hydrodynamics, including fin… ▽ More It remains unclear how galactic environment affects star formation and stellar cluster properties. This is difficult to address in Milky Way-mass galaxy simulations because of limited resolution and less accurate feedback compared to cloud-scale models. We carry out zoom-in simulations to re-simulate 100-300 pc regions of a Milky Way-like galaxy using smoothed particle hydrodynamics, including finer resolution (0.4 Msun per particle), cluster-sink particles, ray-traced photoionization from O stars, H$_2$/CO chemistry, and ISM heating/cooling. We select $10^6$ Msun cloud complexes from a galactic bar, inner spiral arm, outer arm, and inter-arm region (in order of galactocentric radius), retaining the original galactic potentials. The surface densities of star formation rate and neutral gas follow $Σ_{SFR} \propto Σ_{gas}^{1.3}$, with the bar lying higher up the relation than the other regions. However, the inter-arm region forms stars 2-3x less efficiently than the arm models at the same $Σ_{gas}$. The bar produces the most massive cluster, the inner arm the second, and the inter-arm the third. Almost all clusters in the bar and inner arm are small (radii < 5 pc), while 30-50 per cent of clusters in the outer arm and inter-arm have larger radii more like associations. Bar and inner arm clusters rotate at least twice as fast, on average, than clusters in the outer arm and inter-arm regions. The degree of spatial clustering also decreases from bar to inter-arm. Our results indicate that young massive clusters, potentially progenitors of globular clusters, may preferentially form near the bar/inner arm compared to outer arm/inter-arm regions. △ Less

Submitted 22 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 14 pages, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Using Molecular Gas Observations to Guide Initial Conditions for Star Cluster Simulations

Authors: Alison Sills, Steven Rieder, Anne S. M. Buckner, Alvaro Hacar, Simon Portegies Zwart, Paula S. Teixeira

Abstract: The earliest evolution of star clusters involves a phase of co-existence of both newly-formed stars, and the gas from which they are forming. Observations of the gas in such regions provide a wealth of data that can inform the simulations which are needed to follow the evolution of such objects forward in time. We present a method for transforming the observed gas properties into initial condition… ▽ More The earliest evolution of star clusters involves a phase of co-existence of both newly-formed stars, and the gas from which they are forming. Observations of the gas in such regions provide a wealth of data that can inform the simulations which are needed to follow the evolution of such objects forward in time. We present a method for transforming the observed gas properties into initial conditions for simulations that include gas, stars, and ongoing star formation. We demonstrate our technique using the Orion Nebula Cluster. Since the observations cannot provide all the necessary information for our simulations, we make choices for the missing data and assess the impact of those choices. We find that the results are insensitive to the adopted choices of the gas velocity in the plane of the sky. The properties of the surrounding gas cloud (e.g. overall density and size), however, have an effect on the star formation rate and pace of assembly of the resultant star cluster. We also analyze the stellar properties of the cluster and find that the stars become more tightly clustered and in a stronger radial distribution even as new stars form in the filament. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 11 pages, 12 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

The formation of clusters and OB associations in different density spiral arm environments

Authors: C. L. Dobbs, T. J. R. Bending, A. R. Pettitt, A. S. M. Buckner, M. R. Bate

Abstract: We present simulations of the formation and evolution of clusters in spiral arms. The simulations follow two different spiral arm regions, and the total gas mass is varied to produce a range of different mass clusters. We find that including photoionizing feedback produces the observed cluster mass radius relation, increasing the radii of clusters compared to without feedback. Supernovae have litt… ▽ More We present simulations of the formation and evolution of clusters in spiral arms. The simulations follow two different spiral arm regions, and the total gas mass is varied to produce a range of different mass clusters. We find that including photoionizing feedback produces the observed cluster mass radius relation, increasing the radii of clusters compared to without feedback. Supernovae have little impact on cluster properties. We find that in our high density, high gas mass simulations, star formation is less affected by feedback, as star formation occurs rapidly before feedback has much impact. In our lowest gas density simulation, the resulting clusters are completely different (e.g. the number of clusters and their masses) to the case with no feedback. The star formation rate is also significantly suppressed. The fraction of stars in clusters in this model decreases with time flattening at about 20\%. In our lowest gas simulation model, we see the formation of a star forming group with properties similar to an OB association, in particular similar to Orion Ia. We suggest that low densities, and stronger initial dynamics are conducive to forming associations rather than clusters. In all models cluster formation is complex with clusters merging and splitting. The most massive clusters which form have tended to undergo more mergers. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 23 pages, 19 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS, movies available at https://icybob.co.uk/movies.html (lowest 2 panels)

Observational Bias and Young Massive Cluster Characterisation I. 2D Perspective Effects

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Kong You Liow, Clare L. Dobbs, Tim Naylor, Steven Rieder

Abstract: Understanding the formation and evolution of high mass star clusters requires comparisons between theoretical and observational data to be made. Unfortunately, while the full phase space of simulated regions is available, often only partial 2D spatial and kinematic data is available for observed regions. This raises the question as to whether cluster parameters determined from 2D data alone are re… ▽ More Understanding the formation and evolution of high mass star clusters requires comparisons between theoretical and observational data to be made. Unfortunately, while the full phase space of simulated regions is available, often only partial 2D spatial and kinematic data is available for observed regions. This raises the question as to whether cluster parameters determined from 2D data alone are reliable and representative of clusters real parameters and the impact of line-of-sight orientation. In this paper we derive parameters for a simulated cluster formed from a cloud-cloud collision with the full 6D phase space, and compare them with those derived from three different 2D line-of-sight orientations for the cluster. We show the same qualitative conclusions can be reached when viewing clusters in 2D versus 3D, but that drawing quantitative conclusions when viewing in 2D is likely to be inaccurate. The greatest divergence occurs in the perceived kinematics of the cluster, which in some orientations appears to be expanding when the cluster is actually contracting. Increases in the cluster density compounds pre-existing perspective issues, reducing the relative accuracy and consistency of properties derived from different orientations. This is particularly problematic for determination of the number, and membership, of subclusters present in the cluster. We find the fraction of subclusters correctly identified in 2D decreases as the cluster evolves, reaching less than 3.4% at the evolutionary end point for our cluster. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 16 pages, 10 figures, 1 table. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Investigating the structure of star-forming regions using INDICATE

Authors: George A. Blaylock-Squibbs, Richard J. Parker, Anne S. M. Buckner, Manuel Guedel

Abstract: The ability to make meaningful comparisons between theoretical and observational data of star-forming regions is key to understanding the star formation process. In this paper we test the performance of INDICATE, a new method to quantify the clustering tendencies of individual stars in a region, on synthetic star-forming regions with sub-structured, and smooth, centrally concentrated distributions… ▽ More The ability to make meaningful comparisons between theoretical and observational data of star-forming regions is key to understanding the star formation process. In this paper we test the performance of INDICATE, a new method to quantify the clustering tendencies of individual stars in a region, on synthetic star-forming regions with sub-structured, and smooth, centrally concentrated distributions. INDICATE quantifies the amount of stellar affiliation of each individual star, and also determines whether this affiliation is above random expectation for the star-forming region in question. We show that INDICATE cannot be used to quantify the overall structure of a region due to a degeneracy when applied to regions with different geometries. We test the ability of INDICATE to detect differences in the local stellar surface density and its ability to detect and quantify mass segregation. We then compare it to other methods such as the mass segregation ratio $Λ_{\rm{MSR}}$, the local stellar surface density ratio $Σ_{\rm{LDR}}$ and the cumulative distribution of stellar positions. INDICATE detects significant differences in the clustering tendencies of the most massive stars when they are at the centre of a smooth, centrally concentrated distribution, corresponding to areas of greater stellar surface density. When applied to a subset of the 50 most massive stars we show INDICATE can detect signals of mass segregation. We apply INDICATE to the following nearby star-forming regions: Taurus, ONC, NGC 1333, IC 348 and $ρ$ Ophiuchi and find a diverse range of clustering tendencies in these regions. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 16 pages + appendices, 10 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

The Spatial Evolution of Young Massive Clusters III. Effect of the Gaia Filter on 2D Spatial Distribution Studies

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Zeinab Khorrami, Marta González, Stuart L. Lumsden, Paul Clark, Estelle Moraux

Abstract: [Context.] Gaia is limited in the optical down to G~21 mag so it is essential to understand the biases introduced by a magnitude-limited sample on spatial distribution studies. [Aims.] We ascertain how sample incompleteness in Gaia observations of young clusters affects the local spatial analysis tool INDICATE and subsequently the perceived spatial properties of these clusters. [Methods.] We creat… ▽ More [Context.] Gaia is limited in the optical down to G~21 mag so it is essential to understand the biases introduced by a magnitude-limited sample on spatial distribution studies. [Aims.] We ascertain how sample incompleteness in Gaia observations of young clusters affects the local spatial analysis tool INDICATE and subsequently the perceived spatial properties of these clusters. [Methods.] We created a mock Gaia cluster catalogue from a synthetic dataset using the observation generating tool MYOSOTIS. The effect of cluster distance, uniform and variable extinction, binary fraction, population masking by the point spread function wings of high-mass members, and contrast sensitivity limits on the trends identified by INDICATE are explored. A comparison of the typical index values derived by INDICATE for members of the synthetic dataset and their corresponding mock Gaia catalogue observations is made to identify any significant changes. [Results.] We typically find only small variations in the pre- and post-observation index values of cluster populations, which can increase as a function of incompleteness percentage and binarity. No significant strengthening, or false signatures, of stellar concentrations are found but real signatures may be diluted. Conclusions drawn about the spatial behaviour of Gaia-observed cluster populations that are, and are not, associated with their natal nebulosity are reliable for most clusters but the perceived behaviours of individual members can change so INDICATE should be used as a measure of spatial behaviours between members as a function of their intrinsic properties (e.g. mass, age, object type), rather than to draw conclusions about any specific observed member. [Conclusions.] INDICATE is a robust spatial analysis tool to reliably study Gaia-observed young cluster populations within 1 kpc, up to a sample incompleteness of 83.3% and binarity of 50%. △ Less

Submitted 15 December, 2021; v1 submitted 23 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A. 20 pages, 4 figures, 2 manuscript tables, appendix with 9 reader reference tables

Journal ref: A&A 659, A72 (2022)

Extreme adaptive optics astrometry of R136. Searching for high proper motion stars

Authors: Zeinab Khorrami, M. Langlois, F. Vakili, P. C. Clark, A. S. M. Buckner, M. Gonzalez, P. Crowther, R. Wunsch, J. Palous, A. Boccaletti, S. Lumsden, E. Moraux

Abstract: We compared high-contrast near-infrared images of the core of R136 taken by VLT/SPHERE, in two epochs separated by 3.06 years. For the first time we monitored the dynamics of the detected sources in the core of R136 from a ground-based telescope with adaptive optics. The aim of these observations was to search for High prOper Motion cAndidates (HOMAs) in the central region of R136 (r<6") where it… ▽ More We compared high-contrast near-infrared images of the core of R136 taken by VLT/SPHERE, in two epochs separated by 3.06 years. For the first time we monitored the dynamics of the detected sources in the core of R136 from a ground-based telescope with adaptive optics. The aim of these observations was to search for High prOper Motion cAndidates (HOMAs) in the central region of R136 (r<6") where it has been challenging for other instruments. Two bright sources (K<15mag and V<16mag) are located near R136a1 and R136c (massive WR stars) and have been identified as potential HOMAs. These sources have significantly shifted in the images with respect to the mean shift of all reliable detected sources and their neighbours, and six times their own astrometric errors. We calculate their proper motions to be 1.36\pm0.22 mas/yr (321\pm52 km/s) and 1.15\pm0.11 mas/yr (273\pm26 km/s). We discuss different possible scenarios to explain the magnitude of such extreme proper motions, and argue for the necessity to conduct future observations to conclude on the nature of HOMAs in the core of R136. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: Accepted to be published in A&A/Letter. catalogue of the reliable-consistent sources are available online via CDS

Journal ref: A&A 649, L8 (2021)

High contrast and resolution near infrared photometry of the core of R136

Authors: Zeinab Khorrami, Maud Langlois, Paul C. Clark, Farrokh Vakili, Anne S. M. Buckner, Marta Gonzalez, Paul Crowther, Richard Wunsch, Jan Palous, Stuart Lumsden, Estelle Moraux

Abstract: We present the sharpest and deepest near infrared photometric analysis of the core of R136, a newly formed massive star cluster at the centre of the 30 Doradus star forming region in the Large Magellanic Cloud. We used the extreme adaptive optics of the SPHERE focal instrument implemented on the ESO Very Large Telescope and operated in its IRDIS imaging mode, for the second time with longer exposu… ▽ More We present the sharpest and deepest near infrared photometric analysis of the core of R136, a newly formed massive star cluster at the centre of the 30 Doradus star forming region in the Large Magellanic Cloud. We used the extreme adaptive optics of the SPHERE focal instrument implemented on the ESO Very Large Telescope and operated in its IRDIS imaging mode, for the second time with longer exposure time in the H- and K filters. Our aim was to (i) increase the number of resolved sources in the core of R136, and (ii) to compare with the first epoch to classify the properties of the detected common sources between the two epochs. Within the field of view (FOV) of 10.8"x12.1" (2.7pc x3.0pc), we detected 1499 sources in both H and K filters, for which 76% of these sources have visual companions closer than 0.2". The larger number of detected sources, enabled us to better sample the mass function (MF). The MF slopes are estimated at ages of 1, 1.5 and 2 Myr, at different radii, and for different mass ranges. The MF slopes for the mass range of 10-300 solar-mass are about 0.3 dex steeper than the mass range of 3-300 solar-mass, for the whole FOV and different radii. Comparing the JHK colours of 790 sources common in between the two epochs, 67% of detected sources in the outer region (r >3") are not consistent with evolutionary models at 1-2 Myr and with extinctions similar to the average cluster value, suggesting an origin from ongoing star formation within 30 Doradus, unrelated to R136. △ Less

Submitted 11 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 24 pages, 20 figures, 6 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

S2D2: Small-scale Significant substructure DBSCAN Detection I. NESTs detection in 2D star-forming regions

Authors: Marta González, Isabelle Joncour, Anne S. M. Buckner, Zeinhab Khorrami, Estelle Moraux, Stuart L. Lumsden, Paul Clark, René D. Oudmaijer, José Manuel Blanco, Ignacio de la Calle, José María Herrera-Fernandez, Jesús J. Salgado, Luis Valero-Martín, Zoe Torres, Álvaro Hacar, Ana Ulla

Abstract: The spatial and dynamical structure of star-forming regions can help provide insights on stellar formation patterns. The amount of data from current and upcoming surveys calls for robust and objective procedures to detect structure, so the results can be statistically analysed and different regions compared. We provide the community with a tool able to detect the small scale significant structure,… ▽ More The spatial and dynamical structure of star-forming regions can help provide insights on stellar formation patterns. The amount of data from current and upcoming surveys calls for robust and objective procedures to detect structure, so the results can be statistically analysed and different regions compared. We provide the community with a tool able to detect the small scale significant structure, above random expectation, in star-forming regions, which could be the imprint of the stellar formation process. The tool makes use of the one point correlation function and of nearest neighbour statistics to determine the parameters for the DBSCAN algorithm. The procedure successfully detects significant small scale substructures in heterogeneous regions, fulfilling the goals it was designed for, and providing very reliable structures. The analysis of regions close to complete spatial randomness ($Q \in [0.7,0.87]$) shows that, even when some structure is present and recovered, it is hardly distinguishable from spurious detection in homogeneous regions due to projection effects. Interpretation should thus be done with care. For concentrated regions, we detect a main structure surrounded by smaller ones, corresponding to the core plus some Poisson fluctuations around it. We argue that these structures do not correspond to the small compact regions we are looking for. In some realistic cases, a more complete hierarchical, multi-scale analysis would be needed to capture the complexity of the region. We have developed implementations of our procedure, and a catalogue of the NESTs (Nested Elementary STructures) detected by it in four star-forming regions (Taurus, IC 348, Upper Scorpius, and Carina), which are publicly available to the community. Implementations of the 3D, and up to 6D versions of the procedure including proper movements are in progress, and will be provided as future work. △ Less

Submitted 20 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 24 pages, 21 figures. Accepted for publication in A&A. Abstract abridged

Journal ref: A&A 647, A14 (2021)

Mass segregation and sequential star formation in NGC 2264 revealed by Herschel

Authors: T. Nony, J. -F. Robitaille, F. Motte, M. Gonzalez, I. Joncour, E. Moraux, A. Men'shchikov, P. Didelon, F. Louvet, A. S. M. Buckner, N. Schneider, S. L. Lumsden, S. Bontemps, Y. Pouteau, N. Cunningham, E. Fiorellino, R. Oudmaijer, P. André, B. Thomasson

Abstract: The mass segregation of stellar clusters could be primordial rather than dynamical. Despite the abundance of studies of mass segregation for stellar clusters, those for stellar progenitors are still scarce, so the question on the origin and evolution of mass segregation is still open. Our goal is to characterize the structure of the NGC 2264 molecular cloud and compare the populations of clumps an… ▽ More The mass segregation of stellar clusters could be primordial rather than dynamical. Despite the abundance of studies of mass segregation for stellar clusters, those for stellar progenitors are still scarce, so the question on the origin and evolution of mass segregation is still open. Our goal is to characterize the structure of the NGC 2264 molecular cloud and compare the populations of clumps and young stellar objects (YSOs) in this region whose rich YSO population has shown evidence of sequential star formation. We separated the Herschel column density map of NGC 2264 in three subregions and compared their cloud power spectra using a multiscale segmentation technique. We identified in the whole NGC 2264 cloud a population of 256 clumps with typical sizes of ~0.1 pc and masses ranging from 0.08 Msun to 53 Msun. Although clumps have been detected all over the cloud, the central subregion of NGC 2264 concentrates most of the massive, bound clumps. The local surface density and the mass segregation ratio indeed indicate a strong degree of mass segregation for the 15 most massive clumps, with a median $Σ_6$ three time that of the whole clumps population and $Λ_{MSR}$ about 8. We showed that this cluster of massive clumps is forming within a high-density cloud ridge, itself formed and probably still fed by the high concentration of gas observed on larger scales in the central subregion. The time sequence obtained from the combined study of the clump and YSO populations in NGC 2264 suggests that the star formation started in the northern subregion, that it is now actively developing at the center and will soon start in the southern subregion. Taken together, the cloud structure and the clump and YSO populations in NGC 2264 argue for a dynamical scenario of star formation. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 26 pages, 19 figures. Accepted for publication in A&A, abstract abridged for arXiv

Journal ref: A&A 645, A94 (2021)

The Spatial Evolution of Young Massive Clusters II. Looking for Imprints of Star Formation in NGC 2264 with Gaia DR2

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Zeinab Khorrami, Marta Gonzalez, Stuart L. Lumsden, Estelle Moraux, Rene D. Oudmaijer, Paul Clark, Isabelle Joncour, Jose Manuel Blanco, Ignacio de la Calle, Alvaro Hacar, Jose M. Herrera-Fernandez, Frederique Motte, Jesus Salgado, Luis Valero-Martin

Abstract: Aims. To demonstrate that `INDICATE' is a powerful spatial analysis tool which when combined with kinematic data from Gaia DR2 can be used to robustly probe star formation history. Methods. We compared the dynamic & spatial distributions of young stellar objects (YSOs) at various evolutionary stages in NGC 2264 using Gaia DR2 proper motion data and INDICATE. Results. The dynamic & spatial beha… ▽ More Aims. To demonstrate that `INDICATE' is a powerful spatial analysis tool which when combined with kinematic data from Gaia DR2 can be used to robustly probe star formation history. Methods. We compared the dynamic & spatial distributions of young stellar objects (YSOs) at various evolutionary stages in NGC 2264 using Gaia DR2 proper motion data and INDICATE. Results. The dynamic & spatial behaviours of YSOs at different evolutionary stages are distinct. Dynamically, Class II YSOs predominately have non-random trajectories that are consistent with known substructures, whereas Class III YSOs have random trajectories with no clear expansion or contraction patterns. Spatially, there is a correlation between the evolutionary stage and source concentration: 69.4% of Class 0/I, 27.9% of Class II, and 7.7% of Class III objects are found to be clustered. The proportion of YSOs clustered with objects of the same class also follows this trend. Class 0/I objects are both found to be more tightly clustered with the general populous/objects of the same class than Class IIs and IIIs by a factor of 1.2/4.1 and 1.9/6.6, respectively. An exception to these findings is within 0.05deg of S Mon where Class III objects mimic the behaviours of Class II sources across the wider cluster region. Our results suggest (i) current YSOs distributions are a result of dynamical evolution, (ii) prolonged star formation has been occurring sequentially, and (iii) stellar feedback from S Mon is causing YSOs to appear as more evolved sources. Conclusions. Designed to provide a quantitative measure of clustering behaviours, INDICATE is a powerful tool with which to perform rigorous spatial analyses. Our findings are consistent with what is known about NGC 2264, effectively demonstrating that when combined with kinematic data from Gaia DR2 INDICATE can be used to robustly study the star formation history of a cluster. △ Less

Submitted 18 March, 2020; v1 submitted 28 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 13 pages, 4 figures, 5 tables, Accepted for publication in A&A

Journal ref: A&A 636, A80 (2020)

A Code to Make Your Own Synthetic ObservaTIonS (MYOSOTIS)

Authors: Zeinab Khorrami, Pouria Khalaj, Anne S. M. Buckner, Paul C. Clark, Estelle Moraux, Stuart Lumsden, Isabelle Joncour, Rene D. Oudmaijer, Ignacio de la Calle, Jose M. Herrera-Fernandez, Frederique Motte, Jose Manuel Blanco, Luis Valero-Martin

Abstract: We introduce our new code MYOSOTIS (Make Your Own Synthetic ObservaTIonS) which is designed to produce synthetic observations from simulated clusters. The code can synthesise observations from both ground- and spaced-based observatories, for a range of different filters, observational conditions and angular/spectral resolution. In this paper, we highlight some of the features of MYOSOTIS, creating… ▽ More We introduce our new code MYOSOTIS (Make Your Own Synthetic ObservaTIonS) which is designed to produce synthetic observations from simulated clusters. The code can synthesise observations from both ground- and spaced-based observatories, for a range of different filters, observational conditions and angular/spectral resolution. In this paper, we highlight some of the features of MYOSOTIS, creating synthetic observations from young massive star clusters. Our model clusters are simulated using nbody6 code and have different total masses, half-mass radii, and binary fractions. The synthetic observations are made at the age of 2 Myr with Solar metallicity and under different extinction conditions. For each cluster, we create synthetic images of the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) in the visible (WFPC2/F555W) as well as Very Large Telescopes (VLT) in the nearIR (SPHERE/IRDIS/Ks). We show how MYOSOTIS can be used to look at mass function (MF) determinations. For this aim we re-estimate stellar masses using a photometric analysis on the synthetic images. The synthetic MF slopes are compared to their actual values. Our photometric analysis demonstrate that depending on the adopted filter, extinction, angular resolution and pixel sampling of the instruments, the power-law index of the underlying MFs can be shallower than the observed ones by at least 0.25 dex which is in agreement with the observed discrepancies reported in the literature, specially for young star clusters. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures, Accepted to be published in MNRAS

The Spatial Evolution of Young Massive Clusters I. A New Tool to Quantitatively Trace Stellar Clustering

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Zeinab Khorrami, Pouria Khalaj, Stuart L. Lumsden, Isabelle Joncour, Estelle Moraux, Paul Clark, Rene D. Oudmaijer, Jose Manuel Blanco, Ignacio de la Calle, Jose M. Herrera-Fernandez, Frederique Motte, Jesus J. Salgado, Luis Valero-Martin

Abstract: Aims. To present the new novel statistical clustering tool 'INDICATE' which assesses and quantifies the degree of spatial clustering of each object in a dataset, discuss its applications as a tracer of morphological stellar features in star forming regions, and to look for these features in the Carina Nebula (NGC 3372). Results. We successfully recover known stellar structure of the Carina Nebul… ▽ More Aims. To present the new novel statistical clustering tool 'INDICATE' which assesses and quantifies the degree of spatial clustering of each object in a dataset, discuss its applications as a tracer of morphological stellar features in star forming regions, and to look for these features in the Carina Nebula (NGC 3372). Results. We successfully recover known stellar structure of the Carina Nebula, including the 5 young star clusters in this region. Four sub-clusters contain no, or very few, stars with a degree of association above random which suggests they may be fluctuations in the field rather than real clusters. In addition we find: (1) Stars in the NW and SE regions have significantly different clustering tendencies, which is reflective of differences in the apparent star formation activity in these regions. Further study is required to ascertain the physical origin of the difference; (2) The different clustering properties between these two regions are even more pronounced for OB stars; (3) There are no signatures of classical mass segregation present in the SE region - massive stars here are not spatially concentrated together above random; (4) Stellar concentrations are more frequent around massive stars than typical for the general population, particularly in the Tr14 cluster; (5) There is a relation between the concentration of OB stars and the concentration of (lower mass) stars around OB stars in the centrally concentrated Tr14 and Tr15, but no such relation exists in Tr16. We conclude this is due to the highly sub-structured nature of Tr16. Conclusions. INDICATE is a powerful new tool employing a novel approach to quantify the clustering tendencies of individual objects in a dataset within a user-defined parameter space. As such it can be used in a wide array of data analysis applications. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2019; v1 submitted 7 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: Accepted for publication in A&A; 15 pages, 10 figures, 3 appendices

Journal ref: A&A 622, A184 (2019)

FSR 1716: A new Milky Way Globular Cluster confirmed using VVV RR Lyrae stars

Authors: Dante Minniti, Tali Palma, Istvan Dékány, Maren Hempel, Marina Rejkuba, Joyce Pullen, Javier Alonso-García, Rodolfo Barbá, Beatriz Barbuy, Eduardo Bica, Charles Bonatto, Jura Borissova, Marcio Catelan, Julio A. Carballo-Bello, Andre Nicolas Chene, Juan J. Clariá, Roger E. Cohen, Rodrigo Contreras-Ramos, Bruno Dias, Jim Emerson, Dirk Froebrich, Anne S. M. Buckner, Douglas Geisler, Oscar A. Gonzalez, Felipe Gran , et al. (13 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We use deep multi-epoch near-IR images of the VISTA Variables in the Vía Láctea (VVV) Survey to search for RR Lyrae stars towards the Southern Galactic plane. Here we report the discovery of a group of RR Lyrae stars close together in VVV tile d025. Inspection of the VVV images and PSF photometry reveals that most of these stars are likely to belong to a globular cluster, that matches the position… ▽ More We use deep multi-epoch near-IR images of the VISTA Variables in the Vía Láctea (VVV) Survey to search for RR Lyrae stars towards the Southern Galactic plane. Here we report the discovery of a group of RR Lyrae stars close together in VVV tile d025. Inspection of the VVV images and PSF photometry reveals that most of these stars are likely to belong to a globular cluster, that matches the position of the previously known star cluster FSR\,1716. The stellar density map of the field yields a $>100$ sigma detection for this candidate globular cluster, that is centered at equatorial coordinates $RA_{J2000}=$16:10:30.0, $DEC_{J2000}=-$53:44:56; and galactic coordinates $l=$329.77812, $b=-$1.59227. The color-magnitude diagram of this object reveals a well populated red giant branch, with a prominent red clump at $K_s=13.35 \pm 0.05$, and $J-K_s=1.30 \pm 0.05$. We present the cluster RR Lyrae positions, magnitudes, colors, periods and amplitudes. The presence of RR Lyrae indicates an old globular cluster, with age $>10$ Gyr. We classify this object as an Oosterhoff type I globular cluster, based on the mean period of its RR Lyrae type ab, $<P>=0.540$ days, and argue that this is a relatively metal-poor cluster with $[Fe/H] = -1.5 \pm 0.4$ dex. The mean extinction and reddening for this cluster are $A_{K_s}=0.38 \pm 0.02$, and $E(J-K_s)=0.72 \pm 0.02$ mag, respectively, as measured from the RR Lyrae colors and the near-IR color-magnitude diagram. We also measure the cluster distance using the RR Lyrae type ab stars. The cluster mean distance modulus is $(m-M)_0 = 14.38 \pm 0.03$ mag, implying a distance $D = 7.5 \pm 0.2$ kpc, and a Galactocentric distance $R_G=4.3$ kpc. △ Less

Submitted 5 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures. ApJL, in press

Properties of Star Clusters -- III: Analysis of 13 FSR Clusters using UKIDSS-GPS and VISTA-VVV

Authors: A. S. M. Buckner, D. Froebrich

Abstract: Discerning the nature of open cluster candidates is essential for both individual and statistical analyses of cluster properties. Here we establish the nature of thirteen cluster candidates from the FSR cluster list using photometry from the 2MASS and deeper, higher resolution UKIDSS-GPS and VISTA-VVV surveys. These clusters were selected because they were flagged in our previous studies as expect… ▽ More Discerning the nature of open cluster candidates is essential for both individual and statistical analyses of cluster properties. Here we establish the nature of thirteen cluster candidates from the FSR cluster list using photometry from the 2MASS and deeper, higher resolution UKIDSS-GPS and VISTA-VVV surveys. These clusters were selected because they were flagged in our previous studies as expected to contain a large proportion of pre-main sequence members or are at unusually small/large Galactocentric distances. We employ a decontamination procedure of JHK photometry to identify cluster members. Cluster properties are homogeneously determined and we conduct a cross comparative study of our results with the literature (where available). Seven of the here studied clusters were confirmed to contain PMS stars, one of which is a newly confirmed cluster. Our study of FSR1716 is the deepest to date and is in notable disagreement with previous studies, finding that it has a distance of about 7.3kpc and age of 10-12Gyr. As such, we argue that this cluster is a potential globular cluster candidate. △ Less

Submitted 11 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Comments: 14 figures, 1 table

The UWISH2 extended H2 source catalogue

Authors: D. Froebrich, S. V. Makin, C. J. Davis, T. M. Gledhill, Y. Kim, B. -C. Koo, J. Rowles, J. Eislöffel, J. Nicholas, J. J. Lee, J. Williamson, A. S. M. Buckner

Abstract: We present the extended source catalogue for the UKIRT Widefield Infrared Survey for H2 (UWISH2). The survey is unbiased along the inner Galactic Plane from l \approx 357deg to l \approx 65deg and |b| < 1.5deg and covers 209 square degrees. A further 42.0 and 35.5 square degrees of high dust column density regions have been targeted in Cygnus and Auriga. We have identified 33200 individual extende… ▽ More We present the extended source catalogue for the UKIRT Widefield Infrared Survey for H2 (UWISH2). The survey is unbiased along the inner Galactic Plane from l \approx 357deg to l \approx 65deg and |b| < 1.5deg and covers 209 square degrees. A further 42.0 and 35.5 square degrees of high dust column density regions have been targeted in Cygnus and Auriga. We have identified 33200 individual extended H2 features. They have been classified to be associated with about 700 groups of jets and outflows, 284 individual (candidate) Planetary Nebulae, 30 Supernova Remnants and about 1300 Photo-Dissociation Regions. We find a clear decline of star formation activity (traced by H2 emission from jets and photo-dissociation regions) with increasing distance from the Galactic Centre. About 60% of the detected candidate Planetary Nebulae have no known counterpart and 25% of all Supernova Remnants have detectable H2 emission associated with them. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2015; v1 submitted 27 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 25 pages, 10 figures, 6 tables, Full paper with higher resolution figures and entire Appendix can be found at http://astro.kent.ac.uk/~df/

Properties of Star Clusters - II: Scale Height Evolution of Clusters

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Dirk Froebrich

Abstract: Until now it has been impossible to observationally measure how star cluster scale height evolves beyond 1Gyr as only small samples have been available. Here we establish a novel method to determine the scale height of a cluster sample using modelled distributions and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests. This allows us to determine the scale height with a 25% accuracy for samples of 38 clusters or more. We a… ▽ More Until now it has been impossible to observationally measure how star cluster scale height evolves beyond 1Gyr as only small samples have been available. Here we establish a novel method to determine the scale height of a cluster sample using modelled distributions and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests. This allows us to determine the scale height with a 25% accuracy for samples of 38 clusters or more. We apply our method to investigate the temporal evolution of cluster scale height, using homogeneously selected sub-samples of Kharchenko et al. (MWSC), Dias et al. (DAML02), WEBDA, and Froebrich et al. (FSR). We identify a linear relationship between scale height and log(age/yr) of clusters, considerably different from field stars. The scale height increases from about 40pc at 1Myr to 75pc at 1Gyr, most likely due to internal evolution and external scattering events. After 1Gyr, there is a marked change of the behaviour, with the scale height linearly increasing with log(age/yr) to about 550pc at 3.5Gyr. The most likely interpretation is that the surviving clusters are only observable because they have been scattered away from the mid-plane in their past. A detailed understanding of this observational evidence can only be achieved with numerical simulations of the evolution of cluster samples in the Galactic Disk. Furthermore, we find a weak trend of an age-independent increase in scale height with galactocentric distance. There are no significant temporal or spatial variations of the cluster distribution zero point. We determine the Sun's vertical displacement from the Galactic Plane as $Z_\odot=18.5\pm1.2$pc. △ Less

Submitted 17 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 20 pages, 3 tables, 7 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS, Version with high resolution figures and complete appendix can be found at http://astro.kent.ac.uk/~df/

Properties of Star Clusters - I: Automatic Distance and Extinction Estimates

Authors: Anne S. M. Buckner, Dirk Froebrich

Abstract: Determining star cluster distances is essential to analyse their properties and distribution in the Galaxy. In particular it is desirable to have a reliable, purely photometric distance estimation method for large samples of newly discovered cluster candidates e.g. from 2MASS, UKIDSS-GPS and VISTA-VVV. Here, we establish an automatic method to estimate distances and reddening from NIR photometry a… ▽ More Determining star cluster distances is essential to analyse their properties and distribution in the Galaxy. In particular it is desirable to have a reliable, purely photometric distance estimation method for large samples of newly discovered cluster candidates e.g. from 2MASS, UKIDSS-GPS and VISTA-VVV. Here, we establish an automatic method to estimate distances and reddening from NIR photometry alone, without the use of isochrone fitting. We employ a decontamination procedure of JHK photometry to determine the density of stars foreground to clusters and a galactic model to estimate distances. We then calibrate the method using clusters with known properties. This allows us to establish distance estimates with better than 40% accuracy. We apply our method to determine the extinction and distance values to 378 known open clusters and 397 cluster candidates from the list of Froebrich, Scholz and Raftery (2003). We find that the sample is biased towards clusters of a distance of approximately 3kpc, with typical distances between 2 and 6kpc. Using the cluster distances and extinction values, we investigate how the average extinction per kiloparsec distance changes as a function of Galactic longitude. We find a systematic dependence that can be approximated by A_H(l)[mag/kpc]=0.10+0.001*|l-180deg|/deg for regions more than 60deg from the Galactic Centre. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2013; originally announced September 2013.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 tables, 9 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS, Version with high resolution figures and complete appendix can be found at http://astro.kent.ac.uk/~df/