-
The Occurrence and Impact of Carbon-Oxygen Shell Mergers in Massive Stars
Authors:
L. Roberti,
M. Pignatari,
H. E. Brinkman,
S. K. Jeena,
A. Sieverding,
A. Falla,
M. Limongi,
A. Chieffi,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
In their final stages before undergoing a core-collapse supernova, massive stars may experience mergers between internal shells where carbon (C) and oxygen (O) are consumed as fuels for nuclear burning. This interaction, known as a C-O shell merger, can dramatically alter the internal structure of the star, leading to peculiar nucleosynthesis and potentially influencing the supernova explosion and…
▽ More
In their final stages before undergoing a core-collapse supernova, massive stars may experience mergers between internal shells where carbon (C) and oxygen (O) are consumed as fuels for nuclear burning. This interaction, known as a C-O shell merger, can dramatically alter the internal structure of the star, leading to peculiar nucleosynthesis and potentially influencing the supernova explosion and the propagation of the subsequent supernova shock. Our understanding of the frequency and consequences of C-O shell mergers remains limited. This study aims to identify for the first time early diagnostics in the stellar structure which will lead to C-O shell mergers in more advanced stages. We also assess their role in shaping the chemical abundances in the most metal poor stars of the Galaxy. We analyze a set of 209 of stellar evolution models available in the literature, with different initial progenitor masses and metallicities. We then compare the nucleosynthetic yields from a subset of these models with the abundances of odd-Z elements in metal-poor stars. We find that the occurrence of C-O shell mergers in stellar models can be predicted with good approximation based on the outcomes of the central He burning phase, specifically, from the CO core mass ($\rm M_{CO}$) and the $\rm ^{12}C$ central mass fraction ($\rm X_{C12}$): 90$\%$ of models with a C-O merger have $\rm X_{C12}< 0.277$ and $\rm M_{CO}< 4.90 M_{\odot}$, with average values $\rm M_{CO} = 4.02 M_{\odot}$ and $\rm X_{C12}= 0.176$. Additionally, we confirm that the Sc-rich and K-rich yields from models with C-O mergers would solve the long-standing underproduction of these elements in massive stars. Our results emphasize the crucial role of C-O shell mergers in enriching the interstellar medium, particularly in the production of odd-Z elements.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
The impact of asteroseismically calibrated internal mixing on nucleosynthetic wind yields of massive stars
Authors:
Hannah E. Brinkman,
Lorenzo Roberti,
Alex Kemp,
Mathias Michielsen,
Andrew Tkachenko,
Conny Aerts
Abstract:
Asteroseismology gives us the opportunity to look inside stars and determine their internal properties. Based on these observations, estimations can be made for the amount of the convective boundary mixing and envelope mixing of such stars, and the shape of the mixing profile in the envelope. However, these results are not typically included in stellar evolution models. We aim to investigate the i…
▽ More
Asteroseismology gives us the opportunity to look inside stars and determine their internal properties. Based on these observations, estimations can be made for the amount of the convective boundary mixing and envelope mixing of such stars, and the shape of the mixing profile in the envelope. However, these results are not typically included in stellar evolution models. We aim to investigate the impact of varying convective boundary mixing and envelope mixing in a range based on asteroseismic modelling in stellar models, both for the stellar structure and for the nucleosynthetic yields. In this first study, we focus on the pre-explosive evolution of a 20Msun star and evolve the models to the final phases of carbon burning. We vary the convective boundary mixing, implemented as step-overshoot, with the overshoot parameter in the range 0.05-0.4 and the amount of envelope mixing in the range 1-10$^{6}$ with a mixing profile based on internal gravity waves. We use a large nuclear network of 212 isotopes to study the nucleosynthesis. We find that enhanced mixing according to asteroseismology of main-sequence stars, both at the convective core boundary and in the envelope, has significant effects on the nucleosynthetic wind yields. Our evolutionary models beyond the main sequence diverge in yields from models based on rotational mixing, having longer helium burning lifetimes and lighter helium-depleted cores. We find that the asteroseismic ranges of internal mixing calibrated from core hydrogen burning stars lead to similar wind yields as those resulting from the theory of rotational mixing. Adopting the seismic mixing levels beyond the main sequence, we find earlier transitions to radiative carbon burning compared to models based on rotational mixing. This influences the compactness and the occurrence of shell-mergers, which may affect the supernova properties and explosive nucleosynthesis.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Aluminium-26 from massive binary stars III. Binary stars up to core-collapse and their impact on the early Solar System
Authors:
Hannah E. Brinkman,
C. L. Doherty,
M. Pignatari,
O. R. Pols,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
Many of the short-lived radioactive nuclei that were present in the early Solar System can be produced in massive stars. In the first paper in this series (Brinkman et al. 2019), we focused on the production of $^{26}$Al in massive binaries. In our second paper (Brinkman et al. 2021), we considered rotating single stars, two more short-lived radioactive nuclei, $^{36}$Cl and $^{41}$Ca, and the com…
▽ More
Many of the short-lived radioactive nuclei that were present in the early Solar System can be produced in massive stars. In the first paper in this series (Brinkman et al. 2019), we focused on the production of $^{26}$Al in massive binaries. In our second paper (Brinkman et al. 2021), we considered rotating single stars, two more short-lived radioactive nuclei, $^{36}$Cl and $^{41}$Ca, and the comparison to the early Solar System data. In this work, we update our previous conclusions by further considering the impact of binary interactions. We used the MESA stellar evolution code with an extended nuclear network to compute massive (10-80 M$ _{\odot} $), binary stars at various initial periods and solar metallicity (Z=0.014), up to the onset of core collapse. The early Solar System abundances of $^{26}$Al and $^{41}$Ca can be matched self-consistently by models with initial masses $\geq$25 M$_{\odot}$, while models with initial primary masses $\geq$35 M$_{\odot}$ can also match $^{36}$Cl. Almost none of the models provide positive net yields for $^{19}$F, while for $^{22}$Ne the net yields are positive from 30 M$_{\odot}$ and higher. This leads to an increase by a factor of approximately 4 in the amount of $^{22}$Ne produced by a stellar population of binary stars, relative to single stars. Also, besides the impact on the stellar yields, our 10 M$_{\odot}$ primary star undergoing Case A mass-transfer ends its life as a white dwarf instead of as a core-collapse supernova. This demonstrates that binary interactions can also strongly impact the evolution of stars close to the supernova boundary.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Chemical Evolution of Fluorine in the Milky Way
Authors:
Kate A. Womack,
Fiorenzo Vincenzo,
Brad K. Gibson,
Benoit Côté,
Marco Pignatari,
Hannah E. Brinkman,
Paolo Ventura,
Amanda Karakas
Abstract:
Fluorine has many different potential sites and channels of production, making narrowing down a dominant site of fluorine production particularly challenging. In this work, we investigate which sources are the dominant contributors to the galactic fluorine by comparing chemical evolution models to observations of fluorine abundances in Milky Way stars covering a metallicity range -2$<$[Fe/H]$<$0.4…
▽ More
Fluorine has many different potential sites and channels of production, making narrowing down a dominant site of fluorine production particularly challenging. In this work, we investigate which sources are the dominant contributors to the galactic fluorine by comparing chemical evolution models to observations of fluorine abundances in Milky Way stars covering a metallicity range -2$<$[Fe/H]$<$0.4 and upper limits in the range -3.4$<$[Fe/H]$<$-2.3. In our models, we use a variety of stellar yield sets in order to explore the impact of varying both AGB and massive star yields on the chemical evolution of fluorine. In particular, we investigate different prescriptions for initial rotational velocity in massive stars as well as a metallicity dependent mix of rotational velocities. We find that the observed [F/O] and [F/Fe] abundance ratios at low metallicity and the increasing trend of [F/Ba] at [Fe/H]$\gtrsim$-1 can only be reproduced by chemical evolution models assuming, at all metallicities, a contribution from rapidly rotating massive stars with initial rotational velocities as high as 300km s$^{-1}$. A mix of rotational velocities may provide a more physical solution than the sole use of massive stars with $v_{\text{rot}}$=300$\text{km s}^{-1}$, which are predicted to overestimate the fluorine and average s-process elemental abundances at [Fe/H]$\gtrsim$-1. The contribution from AGB stars is predicted to start at [Fe/H]$\approx$-1 and becomes increasingly important at high metallicity, being strictly coupled to the evolution of the nitrogen abundance. Finally, by using modern yield sets, we investigate the fluorine abundances of Wolf-Rayet winds, ruling them out as dominant contributors to the galactic fluorine.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The RADIOSTAR Project
Authors:
Maria Lugaro,
Benoit Côté,
Marco Pignatari,
Andrés Yagüe López,
Hannah Brinkman,
Borbála Cseh,
Jacqueline Den Hartogh,
Carolyn Louise Doherty,
Amanda Irene Karakas,
Chiaki Kobayashi,
Thomas Lawson,
Mária Pető,
Benjámin Soós,
Thomas Trueman,
Blanka Világos
Abstract:
Radioactive nuclei are the key to understanding the circumstances of the birth of our Sun because meteoritic analysis has proven that many of them were present at that time. Their origin, however, has been so far elusive. The ERC-CoG-2016 RADIOSTAR project is dedicated to investigating the production of radioactive nuclei by nuclear reactions inside stars, their evolution in the Milky Way Galaxy,…
▽ More
Radioactive nuclei are the key to understanding the circumstances of the birth of our Sun because meteoritic analysis has proven that many of them were present at that time. Their origin, however, has been so far elusive. The ERC-CoG-2016 RADIOSTAR project is dedicated to investigating the production of radioactive nuclei by nuclear reactions inside stars, their evolution in the Milky Way Galaxy, and their presence in molecular clouds. So far, we have discovered that: (i) radioactive nuclei produced by slow ($^{107}$Pd and $^{182}$Hf) and rapid ($^{129}$I and $^{247}$Cm) neutron captures originated from stellar sources - asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars and compact binary mergers, respectively - within the galactic environment that predated the formation of the molecular cloud where the Sun was born; (ii) the time that elapsed from the birth of the cloud to the birth of the Sun was of the order of 10$^7$ years, and (iii) the abundances of the very short-lived nuclei $^{26}$Al, $^{36}$Cl, and $^{41}$Ca can be explained by massive star winds in single or binary systems, if these winds directly polluted the early Solar System. Our current and future work, as required to finalise the picture of the origin of radioactive nuclei in the Solar System, involves studying the possible origin of radioactive nuclei in the early Solar System from core-collapse supernovae, investigating the production of $^{107}$Pd in massive star winds, modelling the transport and mixing of radioactive nuclei in the galactic and molecular cloud medium, and calculating the galactic chemical evolution of $^{53}$Mn and $^{60}$Fe and of the p-process isotopes $^{92}$Nb and $^{146}$Sm.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Comparison between core-collapse supernova nucleosynthesis and meteoric stardust grains: investigating magnesium, aluminium, and chromium
Authors:
Jacqueline den Hartogh,
Maria K. Petö,
Thomas Lawson,
Andre Sieverding,
Hannah Brinkman,
Marco Pignatari,
Maria Lugaro
Abstract:
Isotope variations of nucleosynthetic origin among Solar System's solid samples are well documented, yet the origin of these variations is still uncertain. The observed variability of \iso{54}Cr among materials formed in different regions of the proto-planetary disk has been attributed to variable amounts of presolar chromium-rich oxide (chromite) grains, which exist within the meteoritic stardust…
▽ More
Isotope variations of nucleosynthetic origin among Solar System's solid samples are well documented, yet the origin of these variations is still uncertain. The observed variability of \iso{54}Cr among materials formed in different regions of the proto-planetary disk has been attributed to variable amounts of presolar chromium-rich oxide (chromite) grains, which exist within the meteoritic stardust inventory and most likely originated from some type of supernova explosions. To investigate if core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) could be the site of origin of these grains, we analyse yields of CCSN models of stars with initial mass 15, 20 and 25 M$_{\odot}$, and solar metallicity. We present an extensive abundance data set of the Cr, Mg, and Al isotopes as a function of enclosed mass. We find cases in which the explosive C-ashes produce a composition in good agreement with the observed \iso{54}Cr/\iso{52}Cr and \iso{53}Cr/\iso{52}Cr ratios as well as the \iso{50}Cr/\iso{52}Cr ratios. Taking into account that the signal at atomic mass 50 could also originate from \iso{50}Ti, the ashes of explosive He-burning also match the observed ratios. Addition of material from the He ashes (enriched in Al and Cr relative to Mg to simulate the make-up of chromite grains) to the Solar System composition may reproduce the observed correlation between Mg and Cr anomalies, while material from the C-ashes does not present significant Mg anomalies together with Cr isotopic variations. In all cases, non-radiogenic, stable Mg isotope variations dominate over the variations expected from \iso{26}Al.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2022; v1 submitted 12 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
The Radioactive Nuclei $^{\textbf{26}}$Al and $^{\textbf{60}}$Fe in the Cosmos and in the Solar System
Authors:
Roland Diehl,
Maria Lugaro,
Alexander Heger,
Andre Sieverding,
Xiaodong Tang,
KuoAng Li,
Ertao Li,
Carolyn L. Doherty,
Martin G. H. Krause,
Anton Wallner,
Nikos Prantzos,
Hannah E. Brinkman,
Jaqueline W. den Hartogh,
Benjamin Wehmeyer,
Andrés Yagüe López,
Moritz M. M. Pleintinger,
Projjval Banerjee,
Wei Wang
Abstract:
The cosmic evolution of the chemical elements from the Big Bang to the present time is driven by nuclear fusion reactions inside stars and stellar explosions. A cycle of matter recurrently re-processes metal-enriched stellar ejecta into the next generation of stars. The study of cosmic nucleosynthesis and of this matter cycle requires the understanding of the physics of nuclear reactions, of the c…
▽ More
The cosmic evolution of the chemical elements from the Big Bang to the present time is driven by nuclear fusion reactions inside stars and stellar explosions. A cycle of matter recurrently re-processes metal-enriched stellar ejecta into the next generation of stars. The study of cosmic nucleosynthesis and of this matter cycle requires the understanding of the physics of nuclear reactions, of the conditions at which the nuclear reactions are activated inside the stars and stellar explosions, of the stellar ejection mechanisms through winds and explosions, and of the transport of the ejecta towards the next cycle, from hot plasma to cold, star-forming gas. Due to the long timescales of stellar evolution, and because of the infrequent occurrence of stellar explosions, observational studies are challenging. Due to their radioactive lifetime of million years, the 26Al and 60Fe isotopes are suitable to characterise simultaneously the processes of nuclear fusion reactions and of interstellar transport. We describe and discuss the nuclear reactions involved in the production and destruction of 26Al and 60Fe, the key characteristics of the stellar sites of their nucleosynthesis and their interstellar journey after ejection from the nucleosynthesis sites. We connect the theoretical astrophysical aspects to the variety of astronomical messengers, from stardust and cosmic-ray composition measurements, through observation of gamma rays produced by radioactivity, to material deposited in deep-sea ocean crusts and to the inferred composition of the first solids that have formed in the Solar System. We show that considering measurements of the isotopic ratio of 26Al to 60Fe eliminate some of the unknowns when interpreting astronomical results, and discuss the lessons learned from these two isotopes on cosmic chemical evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2021; v1 submitted 17 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Aluminium-26 from massive binary stars II. Rotating single stars up to core-collapse and their impact on the early Solar System
Authors:
Hannah E. Brinkman,
J. W. den Hartogh,
C. L. Doherty,
M. Pignatari,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
Radioactive nuclei were present in the early Solar System, as inferred from analysis of meteorites. Many are produced in massive stars, either during their lives or their final explosions. In the first paper in this series (Brinkman et al. 2019), we focused on the production of $^{26}$Al in massive binaries. Here, we focus on the production of another two short-lived radioactive nuclei, $^{36}$Cl…
▽ More
Radioactive nuclei were present in the early Solar System, as inferred from analysis of meteorites. Many are produced in massive stars, either during their lives or their final explosions. In the first paper in this series (Brinkman et al. 2019), we focused on the production of $^{26}$Al in massive binaries. Here, we focus on the production of another two short-lived radioactive nuclei, $^{36}$Cl and $^{41}$Ca, and the comparison to the early Solar System data. We used the MESA stellar evolution code with an extended nuclear network and computed massive (10-80 M$ _{\odot} $), rotating (with initial velocities of 150 and 300 km/s) and non-rotating single stars at solar metallicity (Z=0.014) up to the onset of core collapse. We present the wind yields for the radioactive isotopes $^{26}$Al, $^{36}$Cl, and $^{41}$Ca, and the stable isotopes $^{19}$F and $^{20}$Ne. In relation to the stable isotopes, we find that only the most massive models, $\geq$ 60M$_{\odot}$ and $\geq$ 40M$_{\odot}$ give positive $^{19}$F and $^{20}$Ne yields, respectively, depending on the initial rotation rate. In relation to the radioactive isotopes, we find that the early Solar System abundances of $^{26}$Al and $^{41}$Ca can be matched with by models with initial masses $\geq$40M$_{\odot}$, while $^{36}$Cl is matched only by our most massive models, $\geq$60M$_{\odot}$. $^{60}$Fe is not significantly produced by any wind model, as required by the observations. Therefore, massive star winds are a favoured candidate for the origin of the very short-lived $^{26}$Al, $^{36}$Cl, and $^{41}$Ca in the early Solar System.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2021; v1 submitted 13 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Aluminium-26 from massive binary stars I: non-rotating models
Authors:
H. E. Brinkman,
C. L. Doherty,
O. R. Pols,
E. T. Li,
B. Côté,
M. Lugaro
Abstract:
Aluminium-26 is a short-lived radionuclide with a half-life of 0.72Myr, which is observed today in the Galaxy via gamma-ray spectroscopy and is inferred to have been present in the early Solar System via analysis of meteorites. Massive stars are considered the main contributors of Al26. Although most massive stars are found in binary systems, the effect, however, of binary interactions on the Al26…
▽ More
Aluminium-26 is a short-lived radionuclide with a half-life of 0.72Myr, which is observed today in the Galaxy via gamma-ray spectroscopy and is inferred to have been present in the early Solar System via analysis of meteorites. Massive stars are considered the main contributors of Al26. Although most massive stars are found in binary systems, the effect, however, of binary interactions on the Al26 yields have not been investigated since Braun & Langer (1995). Here we aim to fill this gap. We have used the MESA stellar evolution code to compute massive (10Msun<=M<=80Msun), non-rotating, single and binary stars of solar metallicity (Z=0.014). We computed the wind yields for the single stars and for the binary systems where mass transfer plays a major role. Depending on the initial mass of the primary star and orbital period, the Al26 yield can either increase or decrease in a binary system. For binary systems with primary masses up to ~35-40Msun, the yield can increase significantly, especially at the lower mass-end, while above ~45Msun the yield becomes similar to the single star yield or even decreases. Our preliminary results show that compared to supernova explosions, the contribution of mass-loss in binary systems to the total Al26 abundance produced by a stellar population is minor. On the other hand, if massive star mass-loss is the origin of Al26 in the early Solar System, our results will have significant implications for the identification of the potential stellar, or stellar population, source.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
