Statistical search for angular non-stationarities of long gamma-ray burst jets using Swift data
Authors:
Andor Budai,
Peter Raffai,
Balint Borgulya,
Brian Albert Dawes,
Gabor Szeifert
Abstract:
In Budai et al. (2020) we argued that angular non-stationarities of gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets can result in a statistical connection between the angle values deduced from jet break times and the variabilities of prompt light curves. The connection should be an anti-correlation if luminosity densities of jets follow a power-law or a uniform profile, and a correlation if they have a Gaussian profil…
▽ More
In Budai et al. (2020) we argued that angular non-stationarities of gamma-ray burst (GRB) jets can result in a statistical connection between the angle values deduced from jet break times and the variabilities of prompt light curves. The connection should be an anti-correlation if luminosity densities of jets follow a power-law or a uniform profile, and a correlation if they have a Gaussian profile. In this follow-up paper, we search for the connection by measuring Spearman's rank correlation coefficient in a sample of 19 long GRBs observed by the Swift satellite. Using 16 of the GRBs with well-defined angle measurements, we find $ρ= -0.20_{-0.09}^{+0.09}$ and $p = 0.46_{-0.19}^{+0.23}$. Adding three more GRBs to the sample, each with a pair of equally possible angle values, can strengthen the anti-correlation to $ρ=-0.31_{-0.08}^{+0.07}$ and $p=0.19_{-0.09}^{+0.14}$. We show that these results are incompatible with non-stationary jets having Gaussian profiles, and that $\gtrsim\!100$ GRBs with observed afterglows would be needed to confirm the potential existence of the angle-variability anti-correlation with $3σ$ significance. If the connection is real, GRB jet angles would be constrainable from prompt gamma light curves, without the need of afterglow observations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2021; v1 submitted 30 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
A statistical method to detect non-stationarities of gamma-ray burst jets
Authors:
Andor Budai,
Peter Raffai,
Balint Borgulya,
Brian Albert Dawes,
Gabor Szeifert,
Vince Varga
Abstract:
We propose a method to detect possible non-stationarities of gamma-ray burst jets. Assuming that the dominant source of variability in the prompt gamma light curve is the non-stationarity of the jet, we show that there should be a connection between the variability measure and the characteristic angle of the jet derived from the jet break time of the afterglow. We carried out Monte Carlo simulatio…
▽ More
We propose a method to detect possible non-stationarities of gamma-ray burst jets. Assuming that the dominant source of variability in the prompt gamma light curve is the non-stationarity of the jet, we show that there should be a connection between the variability measure and the characteristic angle of the jet derived from the jet break time of the afterglow. We carried out Monte Carlo simulations of long gamma-ray burst observations assuming three radial luminosity density profiles for jets and randomizing all burst parameters, and created samples of gamma light curves by simulating jets undergoing Brownian motions with linear restoring forces. We were able to demonstrate that the connection between the variability and the characteristic angle is an anti-correlation in case of uniform and power-law jet profiles, and a correlation in case of a Gaussian profile. We have found that as low as $50$ $(144)$ gamma-ray burst observations with jet angle measurements can be sufficient for a $3σ (5σ) $ detection of the connection. The number of observations required for the detection depends on the underlying jet beam profile, ranging from 50 (144) to 237 (659) for the four specific profile models we tested.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2019; v1 submitted 20 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
