Showing 1–50 of 82 results for author: Balbus, S

The plunging region of a thin accretion disc around a Schwarzschild black hole

Authors: Jake Rule, Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, James Stone, Lizhong Zhang

Abstract: A set of analytic solutions for the plunging region thermodynamics have been developed recently under the assumption that the fluid undergoes a gravity-dominated geodesic plunge into the black hole. We test this model against a dedicated 3D global GRMHD simulation of a thin accretion disc around a Schwarzschild black hole using the code AthenaK. Provided that we account for non-adiabatic heating i… ▽ More A set of analytic solutions for the plunging region thermodynamics have been developed recently under the assumption that the fluid undergoes a gravity-dominated geodesic plunge into the black hole. We test this model against a dedicated 3D global GRMHD simulation of a thin accretion disc around a Schwarzschild black hole using the code AthenaK. Provided that we account for non-adiabatic heating in the energetics, plausibly from grid-scale magnetic dissipation, we find an excellent agreement between the analytic model and the simulated quantities. These results are particularly important for existing and future electromagnetic black hole spin measurements, many of which do not to include the plunging fluid in their emission modelling. This exclusion typically stems from the assumption of a zero-stress boundary condition at the ISCO, forcing all thermodynamic quantities to vanish. Instead, we find a non-zero $δ_\mathcal{J}\approx 5.3 \%$ drop in the angular momentum over the plunging region, which is consistent with both prior simulations and observations. We demonstrate that this stress is small enough for the dynamics of the fluid in the plunging region to be well-described by geodesic trajectories, yet large enough to cause measurable dissipation near to the ISCO - keeping thermodynamic quantities from vanishing. In the plunging region, constant $α$-disc models are a physically inappropriate framework. △ Less

Submitted 19 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures, submitted to MNRAS, comments welcome

The dynamics of accretion flows near to the innermost stable circular orbit

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Francesco Mori, Steven Balbus

Abstract: Accretion flows are fundamentally turbulent systems, yet are classically modelled with viscous theories only valid on length scales significantly greater than the typical size of turbulent eddies in the flow. We demonstrate that, while this will be a reasonable bulk description of the flow at large radii, this must break down as the flow approaches absorbing boundaries, such as the innermost stabl… ▽ More Accretion flows are fundamentally turbulent systems, yet are classically modelled with viscous theories only valid on length scales significantly greater than the typical size of turbulent eddies in the flow. We demonstrate that, while this will be a reasonable bulk description of the flow at large radii, this must break down as the flow approaches absorbing boundaries, such as the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a black hole disc. This is because in a turbulent flow large velocity fluctuations can carry a fluid element over the ISCO from a finite distance away, from which it will not return, a process without analogy in conventional models. This introduces a non-zero directional bias into the velocity fluctuations in the near-ISCO disc. By studying reduced random walk problems, we derive a number of implications of the presence of an absorbing boundary in an accretion context. In particular, we show that the average velocity with which a typical fluid element crosses the ISCO is much larger than is assumed in traditional theories. This enhanced velocity modifies the thermodynamic properties of black hole accretion flows on both sides of the ISCO. In particular, thermodynamic quantities for larger ISCO stresses no longer display pronounced cusps at the ISCO in this new formalism, a result with relevance for a number of observational probes of the intra-ISCO region. Finally, we demonstrate that these extended models reproduce the trans-ISCO behaviour observed in GRMHD simulations of thin discs. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 14 pages + appendices. 10 figures. Resubmitted to MNRAS

Testing theories of accretion and gravity with super-extremal Kerr discs

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus, Adam Ingram

Abstract: Fitting the thermal continuum emission of accreting black holes observed across X-ray bands represents one of the principle means of constraining the properties (mass and spin) of astrophysical black holes. Recent ''continuum fitting'' studies of Galactic X-ray binaries in the soft state have found best fitting dimensionless spin values which run into the prior bounds placed on traditional models… ▽ More Fitting the thermal continuum emission of accreting black holes observed across X-ray bands represents one of the principle means of constraining the properties (mass and spin) of astrophysical black holes. Recent ''continuum fitting'' studies of Galactic X-ray binaries in the soft state have found best fitting dimensionless spin values which run into the prior bounds placed on traditional models ($a_\star = 0.9999$). It is of critical importance that these results are robust, and not a result solely of the presence of these prior bounds and deficiencies in conventional models of accretion. Motivated by these results we derive and present superkerr, an XSPEC model comprising of a thin accretion disc solution valid in the Kerr geometry for arbitrary spin parameter $a_\star$, extending previous models valid only for black holes ($|a_\star| < 1$). This extension into ''superextremal'' spacetimes with $|a_\star| > 1$ includes solutions which describe discs evolving around naked singularities, not black holes. While being valid solutions of Einstein's field equations these naked singularities are not expected to be present in nature. We discuss how the ''measurement'' of a Kerr spin parameter $1 < a_\star < 5/3$ would present compelling evidence for the requirement of a rethink in either standard accretion theory, or our theories of gravity. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 16 pages + appendices, 16 figures. Accepted MNRAS version. superkerr XSPEC model available at: https://github.com/andymummeryastro/superkerr

Fundamental scaling relationships revealed in the optical light curves of tidal disruption events

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Sjoert van Velzen, Edward Nathan, Adam Ingram, Erica Hammerstein, Ludovic Fraser-Taliente, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We present fundamental scaling relationships between properties of the optical/UV light curves of tidal disruption events (TDEs) and the mass of the black hole that disrupted the star. We have uncovered these relations from the late-time emission of TDEs. Using a sample of 63 optically-selected TDEs, the latest catalog to date, we observed flattening of the early-time emission into a near-constant… ▽ More We present fundamental scaling relationships between properties of the optical/UV light curves of tidal disruption events (TDEs) and the mass of the black hole that disrupted the star. We have uncovered these relations from the late-time emission of TDEs. Using a sample of 63 optically-selected TDEs, the latest catalog to date, we observed flattening of the early-time emission into a near-constant late-time plateau for at least two-thirds of our sources. Compared to other properties of the TDE lightcurves (e.g., peak luminosity or decay rate) the plateau luminosity shows the tightest correlation with the total mass of host galaxy ($p$-value of $2 \times 10^{-6}$, with a residual scatter of 0.3 dex). Physically this plateau stems from the presence of an accretion flow. We demonstrate theoretically and numerically that the amplitude of this plateau emission is strongly correlated with black hole mass. By simulating a large population of TDEs, we determine a plateau luminosity-black hole mass scaling relationship well described by $ \log_{10} \left(M_{\bullet}/M_{\odot} \right) = 1.50 \log_{10} \left( L_{\rm plat}/10^{43} {\rm erg \, s^{-1}} \right) + 9.0 $. The observed plateau luminosities of TDEs and black hole masses in our large sample are in excellent agreement with this simulation. Using the black hole mass predicted from the observed TDE plateau luminosity, we reproduce the well-known scaling relations between black hole mass and galaxy velocity dispersion. The large black hole masses of 10 of the TDEs in our sample allow us to provide constraints on their black hole spins, favouring rapidly rotating black holes. We add 49 (34) black hole masses to the galaxy mass (velocity dispersion) scaling relationships, updating and extending these correlations into the low black hole mass regime. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2023; v1 submitted 16 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: Version 2: Data and analysis scripts now available at https://github.com/sjoertvv/manyTDE. 25 pages + appendices, 20 figures. Accepted version in MNRAS

Accretion within the innermost stable circular orbit: analytical thermodynamic solutions in the adiabatic limit

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We present analytical solutions for the thermodynamic (temperature, pressure, density, etc.) properties of thin accretion flows in the region within the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole, the first analytical solutions of their kind. These solutions are constructed in the adiabatic limit and neglect radiative losses, an idealisation valid for a restricted region of parame… ▽ More We present analytical solutions for the thermodynamic (temperature, pressure, density, etc.) properties of thin accretion flows in the region within the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole, the first analytical solutions of their kind. These solutions are constructed in the adiabatic limit and neglect radiative losses, an idealisation valid for a restricted region of parameter space. We highlight a number of remarkable properties of these solutions, including that these solutions cool for radii $r_I/2 < r < r_I$, before increasing in temperature for $0 < r < r_I/2$, independent of black hole spin and assumptions regarding the equation of state of the accretion flow. The radiative temperature of these solutions can, for some values of the free parameters of the theory, peak within the ISCO and not in the main body of the disc. These solutions represent a fundamentally new class of analytical accretion solutions, which are both non-circular and non-radial in character. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: 17 pages, with 5 appendices. 12 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

The high energy probability distribution of accretion disc luminosity fluctuations

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: The probability density function of accretion disc luminosity fluctuations at high observed energies (i.e., energies larger than the peak temperature scale of the disc) is derived, under the assumption that the temperature fluctuations are log-normally distributed. Thin disc theory is used throughout. While log-normal temperature fluctuations would imply that the disc's bolometric luminosity is al… ▽ More The probability density function of accretion disc luminosity fluctuations at high observed energies (i.e., energies larger than the peak temperature scale of the disc) is derived, under the assumption that the temperature fluctuations are log-normally distributed. Thin disc theory is used throughout. While log-normal temperature fluctuations would imply that the disc's bolometric luminosity is also log-normal, the observed Wien-like luminosity behaves very differently. For example, in contrast to a log-normal distribution, the standard deviation of the derived distribution is not linearly proportional to its mean. This means that these systems do not follow a linear rms-flux relationship. Instead they exhibit very high intrinsic variance, and undergo what amounts to a phase transition, in which the mode of the distribution (in the statistical sense) ceases to exist, even for physically reasonable values of the underlying temperature variance. The moments of this distribution are derived using asymptotic expansion techniques. A result that is important for interpreting observations is that the theory predicts that the fractional variability of these disc systems should increase as the observed frequency is increased. The derived distribution will be of practical utility in quantitatively understanding the variability of disc systems observed at energies above their peak temperature scale, including X-ray observations of tidal disruption events. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 13 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS

Inspirals from the innermost stable circular orbit of Kerr black holes: Exact solutions and universal radial flow

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We present exact solutions of test particle orbits spiralling inward from the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole. Our results are valid for any allowed value of the angular momentum $a$-parameter of the Kerr metric. These solutions are of considerable physical interest. In particular, the radial 4-velocity of these orbits is both remarkably simple and, with the radial coor… ▽ More We present exact solutions of test particle orbits spiralling inward from the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) of a Kerr black hole. Our results are valid for any allowed value of the angular momentum $a$-parameter of the Kerr metric. These solutions are of considerable physical interest. In particular, the radial 4-velocity of these orbits is both remarkably simple and, with the radial coordinate scaled by its ISCO value, universal in form, otherwise completely independent of the black hole spin. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters. 5 pages 3 figures

Energy partition between Alfvénic and compressive fluctuations in magnetorotational turbulence with near-azimuthal mean magnetic field

Authors: Y. Kawazura, A. A. Schekochihin, M. Barnes, W. Dorland, S. A. Balbus

Abstract: The theory of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence predicts that Alfvénic and slow-mode-like compressive fluctuations are energetically decoupled at small scales in the inertial range. The partition of energy between these fluctuations determines the nature of dissipation, which, in many astrophysical systems, happens on scales where plasma is collisionless. However, when the magnetorotational ins… ▽ More The theory of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence predicts that Alfvénic and slow-mode-like compressive fluctuations are energetically decoupled at small scales in the inertial range. The partition of energy between these fluctuations determines the nature of dissipation, which, in many astrophysical systems, happens on scales where plasma is collisionless. However, when the magnetorotational instability (MRI) drives the turbulence, it is difficult to resolve numerically the scale at which both types of fluctuations start to be decoupled because the MRI energy injection occurs in a broad range of wavenumbers, and both types of fluctuations are usually expected to be coupled even at relatively small scales. In this study, we focus on collisional MRI turbulence threaded by a near-azimuthal mean magnetic field, which is naturally produced by the differential rotation of a disc. We show that, in such a case, the decoupling scales are reachable using a reduced MHD model that includes differential-rotation effects. In our reduced MHD model, the Alfvénic and compressive fluctuations are coupled only through the linear terms that are proportional to the angular velocity of the accretion disc. We numerically solve for the turbulence in this model and show that the Alfvénic and compressive fluctuations are decoupled at the small scales of our simulations as the nonlinear energy transfer dominates the linear coupling below the MRI-injection scale. In the decoupling scales, the energy flux of compressive fluctuations contained in the small scales is almost double that of Alfvénic fluctuations. Finally, we discuss the application of this result to prescriptions of ion-to-electron heating ratio in hot accretion flows. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2022; v1 submitted 24 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Journal of Plasma Physics

Journal ref: Journal of Plasma Physics 88, 905880311 (2022)

Hard X-ray emission from a Compton scattering corona in large black hole mass tidal disruption events

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We extend the relativistic time-dependent thin-disc TDE model to describe nonthermal ($2-10$ keV) X-ray emission produced by the Compton up-scattering of thermal disc photons by a compact electron corona, developing analytical and numerical models of the evolving nonthermal X-ray light curves. In the simplest cases, these X-ray light curves follow power-law profiles in time. We suggest that TDE di… ▽ More We extend the relativistic time-dependent thin-disc TDE model to describe nonthermal ($2-10$ keV) X-ray emission produced by the Compton up-scattering of thermal disc photons by a compact electron corona, developing analytical and numerical models of the evolving nonthermal X-ray light curves. In the simplest cases, these X-ray light curves follow power-law profiles in time. We suggest that TDE discs act in many respects as scaled-up versions of XRB discs, and that such discs should undergo state transitions into harder accretion states. XRB state transitions typically occur when the disc luminosity becomes roughly one percent of its Eddington value. We show that if the same is true for TDE discs then this, in turn, implies that TDEs with nonthermal X-ray spectra should come preferentially from large-mass black holes. The characteristic hard-state transition mass is $M_{\rm HS} \simeq 2\times10^7 M_\odot$. Hence, subpopulations of thermal and nonthermal X-ray TDEs should come from systematically different black hole masses. We demonstrate that the known populations of thermal and nonthermal X-ray TDEs do indeed come from different distributions of black hole masses. The null-hypothesis of identical black hole mass distributions is rejected by a two-sample Anderson-Darling test with a $p$-value $< 0.01$. Finally, we present a model for the X-ray rebrightening of TDEs at late times as they transition into the hard state. These models of evolving TDE light curves are the first to join both thermal and nonthermal X-ray components in a unified scenario. △ Less

Submitted 15 June, 2021; v1 submitted 13 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: v2: Small modifications to match accepted journal version, some references added. v1: 13 pages, 11 figures, 4 tables. Re-submitted after review to MNRAS, comments welcome

An upper observable black hole mass scale for tidal disruption events with thermal X-ray spectra

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We comprehensively model the X-ray luminosity emergent from time dependent relativistic accretion discs, developing analytical models of the X-ray luminosity of thermal disc systems as a function of black hole mass $M$, disc mass $M_d$, and disc $α$-parameter. The X-ray properties of these solutions will be directly relevant for understanding TDE observations. We demonstrate an extremely strong su… ▽ More We comprehensively model the X-ray luminosity emergent from time dependent relativistic accretion discs, developing analytical models of the X-ray luminosity of thermal disc systems as a function of black hole mass $M$, disc mass $M_d$, and disc $α$-parameter. The X-ray properties of these solutions will be directly relevant for understanding TDE observations. We demonstrate an extremely strong suppression of thermal X-ray luminosity from large mass black holes, $L_X \sim \exp(-m^{7/6})$, where $m$ is a dimensionless mass, roughly the the black hole mass in unity of $10^6$M$_\odot$. This strong suppression results in upper-observable black hole mass limits, which we demonstrate to be of order $M_{\rm lim} \simeq 3 \times 10^7 M_\odot$, above which thermal X-ray emission will not be observable. This upper observable black hole mass limit is a function of the remaining disc parameters, and the full dependence can be described analytically (eq. 82). We demonstrate that the current population of observed X-ray TDEs is indeed consistent with an upper black hole mass limit of order $M \sim 10^7M_\odot$, consistent with our analysis. △ Less

Submitted 27 July, 2021; v1 submitted 13 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: v2: Updated with more sources added to Table 2, now matches journal version. v1: 15 pages, 10 figures, 2 tables. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Elasticity of tangled magnetic fields

Authors: D. N. Hosking, A. A. Schekochihin, S. A. Balbus

Abstract: The fundamental difference between incompressible ideal magnetohydrodynamics and the dynamics of a non-conducting fluid is that magnetic fields exert a tension force that opposes their bending; magnetic fields behave like elastic strings threading the fluid. It is natural, therefore, to expect that a magnetic field tangled at small length scales should resist a large-scale shear in an elastic way,… ▽ More The fundamental difference between incompressible ideal magnetohydrodynamics and the dynamics of a non-conducting fluid is that magnetic fields exert a tension force that opposes their bending; magnetic fields behave like elastic strings threading the fluid. It is natural, therefore, to expect that a magnetic field tangled at small length scales should resist a large-scale shear in an elastic way, much as a ball of tangled elastic strings responds elastically to an impulse. Furthermore, a tangled field should support the propagation of `magnetoelastic waves', the isotropic analogue of Alfvén waves on a straight magnetic field. Here, we study magnetoelasticity in the idealised context of an equilibrium tangled field configuration. In contrast to previous treatments, we explicitly account for intermittency of the Maxwell stress, and show that this intermittency necessarily decreases the frequency of magnetoelastic waves in a stable field configuration. We develop a mean-field formalism to describe magnetoelastic behaviour, retaining leading-order corrections due to the coupling of large- and small-scale motions, and solve the initial-value problem for viscous fluids subjected to a large-scale shear, showing that the development of small-scale motions results in anomalous viscous damping of large-scale waves. Finally, we test these analytic predictions using numerical simulations of standing waves on tangled, linear force-free magnetic-field equilibria. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 26 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: J. Plasma Phys. 86 (2020) 905860511

ASASSN-15lh: a TDE about a maximally rotating $10^9 M_{\odot}$ black hole

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven Balbus

Abstract: We model the light curves of the novel and extremely luminous transient ASASSN-15lh at nine different frequencies, from infrared to ultra-violet photon energies, as an evolving relativistic disc produced in the aftermath of a tidal disruption event. Good fits to all nine light curves are simultaneously obtained when $M_{\rm acc} \simeq 0.07 M_{\odot}$ is accreted onto a black hole of mass… ▽ More We model the light curves of the novel and extremely luminous transient ASASSN-15lh at nine different frequencies, from infrared to ultra-violet photon energies, as an evolving relativistic disc produced in the aftermath of a tidal disruption event. Good fits to all nine light curves are simultaneously obtained when $M_{\rm acc} \simeq 0.07 M_{\odot}$ is accreted onto a black hole of mass $M \simeq 10^9 M_{\odot}$, and near maximal rotation $a/r_g = 0.99$. The best fit black hole mass is consistent with a number of existing estimates from galactic scaling relationships. If confirmed, our results represent the detection of one of the most massive rapidly spinning black holes to date, and are strong evidence for a TDE origin for ASASSN-15lh. This would be the first TDE to be observed in the disc dominated state at optical and infrared frequencies. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS Letters. Comments welcome

Long-term evolution of a magnetic massive merger product

Authors: F. R. N. Schneider, S. T. Ohlmann, Ph. Podsiadlowski, F. K. Roepke, S. A. Balbus, R. Pakmor

Abstract: About 10% of stars more massive than ${\approx}\,1.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ have strong, large-scale surface magnetic fields and are being discussed as progenitors of highly-magnetic white dwarfs and magnetars. The origin of these fields remains uncertain. Recent 3D magnetohydrodynamical simulations have shown that strong magnetic fields can be generated in the merger of two massive stars. Here, we fo… ▽ More About 10% of stars more massive than ${\approx}\,1.5\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ have strong, large-scale surface magnetic fields and are being discussed as progenitors of highly-magnetic white dwarfs and magnetars. The origin of these fields remains uncertain. Recent 3D magnetohydrodynamical simulations have shown that strong magnetic fields can be generated in the merger of two massive stars. Here, we follow the long-term evolution of such a 3D merger product in a 1D stellar evolution code. During a thermal relaxation phase after the coalescence, the merger product reaches critical surface rotation, sheds mass and then spins down primarily because of internal mass readjustments. The spin of the merger product after thermal relaxation is mainly set by the co-evolution of the star-torus structure left after coalescence. This evolution is still uncertain, so we also consider magnetic braking and other angular-momentum-gain and -loss mechanisms that may influence the final spin of the merged star. Because of core compression and mixing of carbon and nitrogen in the merger, enhanced nuclear burning drives a transient convective core that greatly contributes to the rejuvenation of the star. Once the merger product relaxed back to the main sequence, it continues its evolution similar to that of a genuine single star of comparable mass. It is a slow rotator that matches the magnetic blue straggler $τ$ Sco. Our results show that merging is a promising mechanism to explain some magnetic massive stars and it may also be key to understand the origin of the strong magnetic fields of highly-magnetic white dwarfs and magnetars. △ Less

Submitted 11 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 17 pages (incl. appendix), 14 figures, 2 tables; accepted for publication in MNRAS

The spectral evolution of disc dominated tidal disruption events

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We perform a detailed numerical and analytical study of the properties of observed light curves from relativistic thin discs, focussing on observational bands most appropriate for comparison with tidal disruption events (TDEs). We make use of asymptotic expansion techniques applied to the spectral emission integral, using time dependent disc temperature profiles appropriate for solutions of the re… ▽ More We perform a detailed numerical and analytical study of the properties of observed light curves from relativistic thin discs, focussing on observational bands most appropriate for comparison with tidal disruption events (TDEs). We make use of asymptotic expansion techniques applied to the spectral emission integral, using time dependent disc temperature profiles appropriate for solutions of the relativistic thin disc equation. Rather than a power law associated with bolometric disc emission $L \sim t^{-n}$, the observed X-ray flux from disc-dominated TDEs will typically have the form of a power law multiplied by an exponential (see eq. 91). While precise details are somewhat dependent on the nature of the ISCO stress and disc-observer orientational angle, the general form of the time-dependent flux is robust and insensitive to the exact disc temperature profile. We present numerical fits to the UV and X-ray light curves of ASASSN-14li, a particularly well observed TDE. This modelling incorporates strong gravity optics. The full 900 days of ASASSN-14li X-ray observations are very well fit by a simple relativistic disc model, significantly improving upon previous work. The same underlying model also fits the final 1000 days of ASASSN-14li observations in three different UV bandpasses. Finally, we demonstrate that the analytic formulae reproduce the properties of full numerical modelling at both UV and X-ray wavelengths with great fidelity. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2020; v1 submitted 13 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 20 pages, 19 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Comments welcome

How mergers magnetise massive stars

Authors: Fabian R. N. Schneider, Sebastian T. Ohlmann, Philipp Podsiadlowski, Friedrich K. Röpke, Steven A. Balbus, Rüdiger Pakmor, Volker Springel

Abstract: Magnetic fields are ubiquitous in the Universe. The Sun's magnetic field drives the solar wind and causes solar flares and other energetic surface phenomena that profoundly affect space weather here on Earth. The first magnetic field in a star other than the Sun was detected in 1947 in the peculiar A-type star 78 Vir. It is now known that the magnetic fields of the Sun and other low-mass stars (<1… ▽ More Magnetic fields are ubiquitous in the Universe. The Sun's magnetic field drives the solar wind and causes solar flares and other energetic surface phenomena that profoundly affect space weather here on Earth. The first magnetic field in a star other than the Sun was detected in 1947 in the peculiar A-type star 78 Vir. It is now known that the magnetic fields of the Sun and other low-mass stars (<1.5 solar masses) are generated in-situ by a dynamo process in their turbulent, convective envelopes. Unlike such stars, intermediate-mass and high-mass stars (>1.5 solar masses; referred to as "massive" stars here) have relatively quiet, radiative envelopes where a solar-like dynamo cannot operate. However, about 10% of them, including 78 Vir, have strong, large-scale surface magnetic fields whose origin has remained a major mystery. The massive star $τ$ Sco is a prominent member of this group and appears to be surprisingly young compared to other presumably coeval members of the Upper Scorpius association. Here, we present the first 3D magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of the coalescence of two massive main-sequence stars and 1D stellar evolution computations of the subsequent evolution of the merger product that can explain $τ$ Sco's magnetic field, apparent youth and other observed characteristics. We argue that field amplification in stellar mergers is a general mechanism to form strongly-magnetised massive stars. These stars are promising progenitors of those neutron stars that host the strongest magnetic fields in the Universe, so-called magnetars, and that may give rise to some of the enigmatic fast radio bursts. Strong magnetic fields affect the explosions of core-collapse supernovae and, moreover, those magnetic stars that have rapidly-rotating cores at the end of their lives might provide the right conditions to power long-duration gamma-ray bursts and super-luminous supernovae. △ Less

Submitted 30 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: This is the authors' initially submitted version of a paper that is published in the October 10th 2019 issue of Nature at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1621-5

Journal ref: Nature 574, 211-214 (2019)

Evolution of relativistic thin discs with a finite ISCO stress: II. Late time behaviour

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We present solutions to the relativistic thin disc evolutionary equation using a modified description of the mean fluid flow within the disc. The model takes into account the effects of sub-circular velocities in the innermost disc regions, and resolves otherwise unsustainable behaviour present in simple finite ISCO stress disc models. We show that the behaviour of a relativistic thin disc evolvin… ▽ More We present solutions to the relativistic thin disc evolutionary equation using a modified description of the mean fluid flow within the disc. The model takes into account the effects of sub-circular velocities in the innermost disc regions, and resolves otherwise unsustainable behaviour present in simple finite ISCO stress disc models. We show that the behaviour of a relativistic thin disc evolving with a finite ISCO stress is comprised of three distinct stages which join the ordinarily distinct finite and vanishing ISCO stress solutions into a fully continuous model parameterisation. The most important prediction of our model is the existence of an intermediate stage of "stalled accretion", controlled by a single dimensionless parameter. The hallmarks of this evolutionary phase appear to have been seen in GRMHD simulations as well as in the late time X-ray observations of tidal disruption events, but dedicated simulations and extended observations are needed for a deeper understanding. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 8 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Evolution of relativistic thin discs with a finite ISCO stress: I. Stalled accretion

Authors: Andrew Mummery, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We present solutions to the relativistic thin disc evolutionary equation using an $α$-model for the turbulent stress tensor. Solutions with a finite stress at the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) give rise to bolometric light curves with a shallow power law time dependence, in good agreement with those observed in tidal disruption events. A self-similar model based on electron scattering opa… ▽ More We present solutions to the relativistic thin disc evolutionary equation using an $α$-model for the turbulent stress tensor. Solutions with a finite stress at the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) give rise to bolometric light curves with a shallow power law time dependence, in good agreement with those observed in tidal disruption events. A self-similar model based on electron scattering opacity, for example, yields a power law index of $-11/14$, as opposed to $-19/16$ for the case of zero ISCO stress. These solutions correspond to an extended period of relaxation of the evolving disc which, like the light curves they produce, is not sustainable indefinitely. Cumulative departures from the approximation of exact circular orbits cause the power law index to evolve slowly with time, leading eventually to the steeper fall-off associated with traditional zero ISCO stress models. These modified solutions are discussed in detail in a companion paper. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Comments: 11 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

[Plasma 2020 Decadal] The Material Properties of Weakly Collisional, High-Beta Plasmas

Authors: M. W. Kunz, J. Squire, S. A. Balbus, S. D. Bale, C. H. K. Chen, E. Churazov, S. C. Cowley, C. B. Forest, C. F. Gammie, E. Quataert, C. S. Reynolds, A. A. Schekochihin, L. Sironi, A. Spitkovsky, J. M. Stone, I. Zhuravleva, E. G. Zweibel

Abstract: This white paper, submitted for the Plasma 2020 Decadal Survey, concerns the physics of weakly collisional, high-beta plasmas -- plasmas in which the thermal pressure dominates over the magnetic pressure and in which the inter-particle collision time is comparable to the characteristic timescales of bulk motions. This state of matter, although widespread in the Universe, remains poorly understood:… ▽ More This white paper, submitted for the Plasma 2020 Decadal Survey, concerns the physics of weakly collisional, high-beta plasmas -- plasmas in which the thermal pressure dominates over the magnetic pressure and in which the inter-particle collision time is comparable to the characteristic timescales of bulk motions. This state of matter, although widespread in the Universe, remains poorly understood: we lack a predictive theory for how it responds to perturbations, how it transports momentum and energy, and how it generates and amplifies magnetic fields. Such topics are foundational to the scientific study of plasmas, and are of intrinsic interest to those who regard plasma physics as a fundamental physics discipline. But these topics are also of extrinsic interest: addressing them directly informs upon our understanding of a wide variety of space and astrophysical systems, including accretion flows around supermassive black holes, the intracluster medium (ICM) between galaxies in clusters, and regions of the near-Earth solar wind. Specific recommendations to advance this field of study are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 6 pages, submitted for the Plasma 2020 Decadal Survey

The evolution of Kerr discs and late-time tidal disruption event light curves

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Andrew Mummery

Abstract: An encounter between a passing star and a massive black hole at the centre of a galaxy, a so-called tidal disruption event or TDE, may leave a debris disc that subsequently accretes onto the hole. We solve for the time evolution of such a TDE disc, making use of an evolutionary equation valid for both the Newtonian and Kerr regimes. The late time luminosity emergent from such a disc is of interest… ▽ More An encounter between a passing star and a massive black hole at the centre of a galaxy, a so-called tidal disruption event or TDE, may leave a debris disc that subsequently accretes onto the hole. We solve for the time evolution of such a TDE disc, making use of an evolutionary equation valid for both the Newtonian and Kerr regimes. The late time luminosity emergent from such a disc is of interest as a model diagnostic, as it tends to follow a power law decline. The original simple ballistic fallback model, with equal mass in equal energy intervals, produces a -5/3 power law, while standard viscous disc descriptions yield a somewhat more shallow decline, with an index closer to -1.2. Of four recent, well-observed tidal disruption event candidates however, all had fall-off power law indices smaller than 1 in magnitude. In this work, we revisit the problem of thin disc evolution, solving this reduced problem in full general relativity. Our solutions produce power law indices that are in much better accord with observations. The late time observational data from many TDEs are generally supportive, not only of disc accretion models, but of finite stress persisting down to the innermost stable circular orbit. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

The general relativistic thin disc evolution equation

Authors: Steven A Balbus

Abstract: In the classical theory of thin disc accretion discs, the constraints of mass and angular momentum conservation lead to a diffusion-like equation for the turbulent evolution of the surface density. Here, we revisit this problem, extending the Newtonian analysis to the regime of Kerr geometry relevant to black holes. A diffusion-like equation once again emerges, but now with a singularity at the ra… ▽ More In the classical theory of thin disc accretion discs, the constraints of mass and angular momentum conservation lead to a diffusion-like equation for the turbulent evolution of the surface density. Here, we revisit this problem, extending the Newtonian analysis to the regime of Kerr geometry relevant to black holes. A diffusion-like equation once again emerges, but now with a singularity at the radius at which the effective angular momentum gradient passes through zero. The equation may be analysed using a combination of WKB, local techniques, and matched asymptotic expansions. It is shown that imposing the boundary condition of a vanishing stress tensor (more precisely the radial-azimuthal component thereof) allows smooth stable modes to exist external to the angular momentum singularity, the innermost stable circular orbit, while smoothly vanishing inside this location. The extension of the disc diffusion equation to the domain of general relativity introduces a new tool for numerical and phenomenolgical studies of accretion discs, and may prove to be a useful technique for understanding black hole X-ray transients. △ Less

Submitted 11 August, 2017; v1 submitted 27 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 7 Pages, 1 figure. Accepted for publication in MNRAS. Revised version corrects minor typos in equations (64) and (66) of original, otherwise unaltered

Demonstration of a magnetic Prandtl number disc instability from first principles

Authors: William J. Potter, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: Understanding what determines the strength of MHD turbulence in accretion discs is a question of fundamental theoretical and observational importance. In this work we investigate whether the dependence of the turbulent accretion disc stress ($α$) on the magnetic Prandtl number (Pm) is sufficiently sensitive to induce thermal-viscous instability using 3D MHD simulations. We first investigate whethe… ▽ More Understanding what determines the strength of MHD turbulence in accretion discs is a question of fundamental theoretical and observational importance. In this work we investigate whether the dependence of the turbulent accretion disc stress ($α$) on the magnetic Prandtl number (Pm) is sufficiently sensitive to induce thermal-viscous instability using 3D MHD simulations. We first investigate whether the $α$-Pm dependence, found by many previous authors, has a physical or numerical origin by conducting a suite of local shearing-box simulations. We find that a definite $α$-Pm dependence persists when simultaneously increasing numerical resolution and decreasing the absolute values of both the viscous and resistive dissipation coefficients. This points to a physical origin of the $α$-Pm dependence. Using a further set of simulations which include realistic turbulent heating and radiative cooling, and by giving Pm a realistic physical dependence on the plasma temperature and density, we demonstrate that the $α$-Pm dependence is sufficiently strong to lead to a local instability. We confirm that the instability manifests itself as an unstable limit cycle by mapping the local thermal-equilibrium curve of the disc. This is the first self-consistent MHD simulation demonstrating the Pm instability from first principles. This result is important because a physical Pm instability would lead to the global propagation of heating and cooling fronts and a transition between disc states on timescales compatible with the observed hard/soft state transitions in black hole binaries. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Comments: 7 pages, 6 figures, submitted to MNRAS

The Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke instability in stellar radiative zones

Authors: Andrea Caleo, Steven A. Balbus, Emanuele Tognelli

Abstract: The Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability is a rotational instability that is thought to contribute to the transfer of angular momentum in differentially rotating stars. It has been included in recent codes of stellar evolution in a diffusion-like approximation, under the assumption that the kinematic viscosity $ν$ is unimportant for the development of the instability. As noted previously by… ▽ More The Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability is a rotational instability that is thought to contribute to the transfer of angular momentum in differentially rotating stars. It has been included in recent codes of stellar evolution in a diffusion-like approximation, under the assumption that the kinematic viscosity $ν$ is unimportant for the development of the instability. As noted previously by other authors, for most stellar applications this may not be a valid approximation. We discuss this issue in detail, solving the dispersion relation of the perturbed modes for realistic values of $ν$ in the bulk of the radiative zone of the Sun and of three red giant stars at various evolutionary stages. We find that the GSF instability is triggered only in layers of extremely strong shear. In a simple case study, we also investigate the effect of a small deviation from axisymmetry or a small background magnetic field. We find that, like the viscosity, these have a stabilising effect. We conclude that this instability is probably far less efficient in transporting angular momentum than is often assumed, and may not even be present. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Simplified derivation of the gravitational wave stress tensor from the linearized Einstein field equations

Authors: Steven A Balbus

Abstract: A conserved stress energy tensor for weak field gravitational waves propagating in vacuum is derived directly from the linearized wave equation alone, for an arbitrary gauge using standard general relativity. In any harmonic gauge, the form of the tensor leads directly to the classical expression for the outgoing wave energy. The method described here, however, is a much simpler, shorter, and more… ▽ More A conserved stress energy tensor for weak field gravitational waves propagating in vacuum is derived directly from the linearized wave equation alone, for an arbitrary gauge using standard general relativity. In any harmonic gauge, the form of the tensor leads directly to the classical expression for the outgoing wave energy. The method described here, however, is a much simpler, shorter, and more physically motivated approach than is the customary procedure, which involves a lengthy and cumbersome second-order (in wave-amplitude) calculation starting with the Einstein tensor. Our method has the added advantage of exhibiting the direct coupling between the outgoing energy flux in gravitational waves and the work done by the gravitational field on the sources. For nonharmonic gauges, the directly derived wave stress tensor has an apparent index asymmetry. This coordinate artefact may be removed, and the symmetrized (still gauge-invariant) tensor then takes on its widely-used form. Angular momentum conservation follows immediately. For any harmonic gauge, however, the stress tensor is manifestly symmetric from the start and its derivation depends, in its entirety, on the structure of the linearized wave equation. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2016; v1 submitted 20 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 11 pages, no figures. Published in PNAS

Journal ref: PNAS, 113, 42, 11662--11666 (2016)

Surprises in astrophysical gasdynamics

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, WIlliam J. Potter

Abstract: Much of astrophysics consists of the study of ionised gas under the influence of gravitational and magnetic fields. Thus, it is not possible to understand the astrophysical universe without a detailed knowledge of the dynamics of magnetised fluids. Fluid dynamics is, however, a notoriously tricky subject, in which it is all too easy for one's a priori intuition to go astray. In this review, we see… ▽ More Much of astrophysics consists of the study of ionised gas under the influence of gravitational and magnetic fields. Thus, it is not possible to understand the astrophysical universe without a detailed knowledge of the dynamics of magnetised fluids. Fluid dynamics is, however, a notoriously tricky subject, in which it is all too easy for one's a priori intuition to go astray. In this review, we seek to guide the reader through a series of illuminating yet deceptive problems, all with an enlightening twist. We cover a broad range of topics including the instabilities acting in accretion discs, the hydrodynamics governing the convective zone of the Sun, the magnetic shielding of a cooling galaxy cluster, and the behaviour of thermal instabilities and evaporating clouds. The aim of this review is to surprise and intrigue even veteran astrophysical theorists with an idiosynchratic choice of problems and counterintuitive results. At the same time, we endeavour to bring forth the fundamental ideas, to set out important assumptions, and to describe carefully whatever novel techniques may be appropriate to the problem at hand. By beginning at the beginning, and analysing a wide variety of astrophysical settings, we seek not only to make this review suitable for fluid dynamic veterans, but to engage novice recruits as well with what we hope will be an unusual and instructive introduction to the subject. △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 68 pages, 8 figures, to appear in Rep. Prog. Phys

The radiative zone of the Sun and the tachocline: stability of baroclinic patterns of differential rotation

Authors: Andrea Caleo, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: Barotropic rotation and radiative equilibrium are mutually incompatible in stars. The issue is often addressed by allowing for a meridional circulation, but this is not devoid of theoretical complications. Models of rotation in the Sun which maintain strict radiative equilibrium, making use of the observation that the Sun is not in a state of barotropic rotation, have recently been suggested. To i… ▽ More Barotropic rotation and radiative equilibrium are mutually incompatible in stars. The issue is often addressed by allowing for a meridional circulation, but this is not devoid of theoretical complications. Models of rotation in the Sun which maintain strict radiative equilibrium, making use of the observation that the Sun is not in a state of barotropic rotation, have recently been suggested. To investigate the dynamical behaviour of these solutions, we study the local stability of stratified, weakly magnetized, differentially rotating fluids to non-axisymmetric perturbations. Finite heat conductivity, kinematic viscosity, and resistivity are present. The evolution of local embedded perturbations is governed by a set of coupled, ordinary differential equations with time-dependent coefficients. Two baroclinic models of rotation for the upper radiative zone and tachocline are studied: (i) an interpolation based on helioseismology data, (ii) a theoretical solution directly compatible with radiative equilibrium. The growth of the local Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke instability appears to be suppressed, largely because of the viscosity. An extensive exploration of wavenumber space is carried out, with and without a magnetic field. Although we easily find classical local instabilities when they ought formally to be present, for the Sun the analysis reveals neither unstable solutions, nor even solutions featuring a large transient growth. We have not ruled out larger scale or nonlinear instabilities, nor have we rigorously proven local stability. But rotational configurations in close agreement with observations, generally thought to be vulnerable to the classic local Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke instability, do appear to be locally stable under rather general circumstances. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Inefficient Driving of Bulk Turbulence by Active Galactic Nuclei in a Hydrodynamic Model of the Intracluster Medium

Authors: Christopher S. Reynolds, Steven A. Balbus, Alexander A. Schekochihin

Abstract: Central jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) appear to heat the core regions of the intracluster medium (ICM) in cooling-core galaxy clusters and groups, thereby preventing a cooling catastrophe. However, the physical mechanism(s) by which the directed flow of kinetic energy is thermalized throughout the ICM core remains unclear. We examine one widely discussed mechanism whereby the AGN induces sub… ▽ More Central jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) appear to heat the core regions of the intracluster medium (ICM) in cooling-core galaxy clusters and groups, thereby preventing a cooling catastrophe. However, the physical mechanism(s) by which the directed flow of kinetic energy is thermalized throughout the ICM core remains unclear. We examine one widely discussed mechanism whereby the AGN induces subsonic turbulence in the ambient medium, the dissipation of which provides the ICM heat source. Through controlled inviscid 3-d hydrodynamic simulations, we verify that explosive AGN-like events can launch gravity waves (g-modes) into the ambient ICM which in turn decay to volume-filling turbulence. In our model, however, this process is found to be inefficient, with less than 1% of the energy injected by the AGN activity actually ending up in the turbulence of the ambient ICM. This efficiency is an order of magnitude or more too small to explain the observations of AGN-feedback in galaxy clusters and groups with short central cooling times. Atmospheres in which the g-modes are strongly trapped/confined have an even lower efficiency since, in these models, excitation of turbulence relies on the g-modes' ability to escape from the center of the cluster into the bulk ICM. Our results suggest that, if AGN-induced turbulence is indeed the mechanism by which the AGN heats the ICM core, its driving may rely on physics beyond that captured in our ideal hydrodynamic model. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: 11 pages. Accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal

Differential rotation and radiative equilibrium in the Sun: is the tachocline spreading?

Authors: Andrea Caleo, Steven Balbus, William Potter

Abstract: It is well known that the combination of barotropic rotation and radiative equilibrium are mutually incompatible in stars. The Sun's internal rotation is far from barotropic, however, which allows at least the theoretical possibility that the Sun's thermal balance is one of radiative equilibrium in the region of the tachocline near the outer boundary of the radiative zone. We show here that (i) th… ▽ More It is well known that the combination of barotropic rotation and radiative equilibrium are mutually incompatible in stars. The Sun's internal rotation is far from barotropic, however, which allows at least the theoretical possibility that the Sun's thermal balance is one of radiative equilibrium in the region of the tachocline near the outer boundary of the radiative zone. We show here that (i) the constraint of radiative equilibrium leads to a straightforward ordinary differential equation for the Sun's rotation profile, and (ii) solutions of this equation can be found that, to within current levels of accuracy, closely resemble the rotation profile deduced from helioseismology. More generally, we calculate how large a baroclinic deviation from uniform rotation is required to maintain radiative equilibrium without meridional circulation throughout the bulk of the radiative zone. Very little deviation is required, well below detectability. The feasibility of radiative equilibrium for the tachocline suggests that the issue of a spreading boundary layer may be less severe than previously thought. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

On the high frequency spectrum of a classical accretion disc

Authors: Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We derive simple and explicit expressions for the high frequency spectrum of a classical accretion disc. Both stress-free and finite stress inner boundaries are considered. A classical accretion disc spectrum with a stress-free inner boundary departs from a Wien spectrum at large $ν$, scaling as $ν^{2.5}$ (as opposed to $ν^3$) times the usual exponential cut-off. If there is finite stress at the i… ▽ More We derive simple and explicit expressions for the high frequency spectrum of a classical accretion disc. Both stress-free and finite stress inner boundaries are considered. A classical accretion disc spectrum with a stress-free inner boundary departs from a Wien spectrum at large $ν$, scaling as $ν^{2.5}$ (as opposed to $ν^3$) times the usual exponential cut-off. If there is finite stress at the inner disc boundary, the maximum disc temperature generally occurs at this edge, even at relatively modest values of the stress. In this case, the high frequency spectrum is proportional to $ν^2$ times the exponential cut-off. If the temperature maximum is a local hot spot, instead of an axisymmetric ring, then an interior maximum produces a $ν^2$ prefactor while an edge maximum yields $ν^{1.5}$. Because of beaming effects, these latter findings should pertain to a classical relativistic disc. The asymptotics are in general robust and independent of the detailed temperature profile, provided only that the liberated free energy of differential rotation is dissipated locally, and may prove useful beyond the strict domain of classical disc theory. As observations continue to improve with time, our findings suggest the possibility of using the high energy spectral component of black hole candidates as a signature prediction of classical theory, as well as an diagnostic of the stress at the inner regions of an accretion disc. △ Less

Submitted 8 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures. To appear in MNRAS Letters

Dynamical, biological, and anthropic consequences of equal lunar and solar angular radii

Authors: Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: The nearly equal lunar and solar angular sizes as subtended at the Earth is generally regarded as a coincidence. This is, however, an incidental consequence of the tidal forces from these bodies being comparable. Comparable magnitudes implies strong temporal modulation, as the forcing frequencies are nearly but not precisely equal. We suggest that on the basis of paleogeographic reconstructions, i… ▽ More The nearly equal lunar and solar angular sizes as subtended at the Earth is generally regarded as a coincidence. This is, however, an incidental consequence of the tidal forces from these bodies being comparable. Comparable magnitudes implies strong temporal modulation, as the forcing frequencies are nearly but not precisely equal. We suggest that on the basis of paleogeographic reconstructions, in the Devonian period, when the first tetrapods appeared on land, a large tidal range would accompany these modulated tides. This would have been conducive to the formation of a network of isolated tidal pools, lending support to A.S. Romer's classic idea that the evaporation of shallow pools was an evolutionary impetus for the development of chiridian limbs in aquatic tetrapodomorphs. Romer saw this as the reason for the existence of limbs, but strong selection pressure for terrestrial navigation would have been present even if the limbs were aquatic in origin. Since even a modest difference in the Moon's angular size relative to the Sun's would lead to a qualitatively different tidal modulation, the fact that we live on a planet with a Sun and Moon of close apparent size is not entirely coincidental: it may have an anthropic basis. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2014; originally announced June 2014.

Comments: 12 Pages, 4 figures, To appear Proc Roy Soc (A)

An accretion disc instability induced by a temperature sensitive $α$ parameter

Authors: William J. Potter, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: In the standard thin disc formalism the dimensionless $α$ parameter is usually assumed to be constant. However, there are good theoretical reasons for believing, as well as evidence from simulations, that $α$ is dependent on intrinsic disc properties. In this paper we analyse the conditions for the stability of a thin accretion disc in which $α$ is a function of the magnetic Prandtl number, the ra… ▽ More In the standard thin disc formalism the dimensionless $α$ parameter is usually assumed to be constant. However, there are good theoretical reasons for believing, as well as evidence from simulations, that $α$ is dependent on intrinsic disc properties. In this paper we analyse the conditions for the stability of a thin accretion disc in which $α$ is a function of the magnetic Prandtl number, the ratio of collisional viscosity to resistivity. In the inner disc, where the free electron opacity and radiation viscosity dominate, the disc is unstable if $α$ is proportional to the magnetic Prandtl number with an exponent, $n$, and $6/13<n<10/3$. This is within the range of values for the power-law index found in MHD simulations with simple energetics. We calculate the evolution of the unstable disc within the $α$ formalism and show that the physically accessible solutions form a limit cycle, analogous to the behaviour seen in recurrent dwarf novae. It is noteworthy that the time-dependent global behaviour of the instability results in cyclic heating of the inner section of the disc, when parameters appropriate for an X-ray binary system are used. We calculate a model spectrum of the disc in the flaring and quiescent states and show that the behaviour is compatible with X-ray observations of the thermal accretion disc in flaring X-ray binary systems. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2017; v1 submitted 31 March, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Comments: 10 pages, 3 figures, MNRAS published version with a few typos corrected

The stability of stratified, rotating systems and the generation of vorticity in the Sun

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Emmanuel Schaan

Abstract: We examine the linear behavior of three-dimensional Lagrangian displacements in a stratified, shearing background. The isentropic and iso-rotation surfaces of the equilibrium flow are assumed to be axisymmetric, but otherwise fully two-dimensional. Three-dimensional magnetic fields are included in the perturbation equations; however the equilibrium is assumed to be well-described by purely hydrody… ▽ More We examine the linear behavior of three-dimensional Lagrangian displacements in a stratified, shearing background. The isentropic and iso-rotation surfaces of the equilibrium flow are assumed to be axisymmetric, but otherwise fully two-dimensional. Three-dimensional magnetic fields are included in the perturbation equations; however the equilibrium is assumed to be well-described by purely hydrodynamic forces. The model, in principle very general, is used to study the behavior of fluid displacements in an environment resembling the solar convection zone. Some very suggestive results emerge. All but high-latitude displacements align themselves with the observed surfaces of constant angular velocity. The tendency for the angular velocity to remain constant with depth in the bulk of the convective zone, together with other critical features of the rotation profile, emerge from little more than a visual inspection of the governing equation. In the absence of a background axial angular velocity gradient, displacements exhibit no poleward bias, suggesting that solar convection "plays-off" of prexisting shear rather than creates it. We argue that baroclinic vorticity of precisely the right order is generated at the radiative/convective zone boundary due to centrifugal distortion of equipotential surfaces that is not precisely followed by isothermal surfaces. If so, many features of the Sun's internal rotation become more clear, including: i) the general appearance of the tachocline; ii) the extension of differential rotation well into the radiative zone; iii) the abrupt change of morphology of convective zone isorotation surfaces; and iv) the inability of current numerical simulations to reproduce the solar rotation profile without imposed entropy boundary conditions. △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: 30 pages, 2 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

The dynamics of inner dead-zone boundaries in protoplanetary disks

Authors: Henrik N. Latter, Steven Balbus

Abstract: In protoplanetary disks, the inner radial boundary between the MRI turbulent (`active') and MRI quiescent (`dead') zones plays an important role in models of the disk evolution and in some planet formation scenarios. In reality, this boundary is not well-defined: thermal heating from the star in a passive disk yields a transition radius close to the star (<0.1 au), whereas if the disk is already M… ▽ More In protoplanetary disks, the inner radial boundary between the MRI turbulent (`active') and MRI quiescent (`dead') zones plays an important role in models of the disk evolution and in some planet formation scenarios. In reality, this boundary is not well-defined: thermal heating from the star in a passive disk yields a transition radius close to the star (<0.1 au), whereas if the disk is already MRI active, it can self-consistently maintain the requisite temperatures out to a transition radius of roughly 1 au. Moreover, the interface may not be static; it may be highly fluctuating or else unstable. In this paper, we study a reduced model of the dynamics of the active/dead zone interface that mimics several important aspects of a real disk system. We find that MRI-transition fronts propagate inward (a `dead front' suppressing the MRI) if they are initially at the larger transition radius, or propagate outward (an `active front' igniting the MRI) if starting from the smaller transition radius. In both cases, the front stalls at a well-defined intermediate radius, where it remains in a quasi-static equilibrium. We propose that it is this new, intermediate stalling radius that functions as the true boundary between the active and dead zones in protoplanetary disks. These dynamics are likely implicated in observations of variable accretion, such as FU Ori outbursts, as well as in those planet formation theories that require the accumulation of solid material at the dead/active interface. △ Less

Submitted 21 August, 2012; v1 submitted 29 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 16 pages, 10 figures; MNRAS accepted; v3 final corrections

A Self-Consistent Reduced Model for Dusty Magnetorotationally Unstable Discs

Authors: Emmanuel Jacquet, Steven Balbus

Abstract: The interaction between settling of dust grains and magnetorotational instability (MRI) turbulence in protoplanetary disks is analyzed. We use a reduced system of coupled ordinary differential equations to represent the interaction between the diffusion of grains and the inhibition of the MRI. The coupled equations are styled on a Landau equation for the turbulence and a Fokker-Planck equation for… ▽ More The interaction between settling of dust grains and magnetorotational instability (MRI) turbulence in protoplanetary disks is analyzed. We use a reduced system of coupled ordinary differential equations to represent the interaction between the diffusion of grains and the inhibition of the MRI. The coupled equations are styled on a Landau equation for the turbulence and a Fokker-Planck equation for the diffusion. The turbulence-grain interaction is probably most relevant near the outer edge of the disk's quiescent, or "dead" zone. Settling is most pronounced near the midplane, where a high dust concentration can self-consistently suppress the MRI. Under certain conditions, however, grains can reach high altitudes, a result of some observational interest. Finally, we show that the equilibrium solutions are linearly stable. △ Less

Submitted 8 March, 2012; originally announced March 2012.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures, accepted to MNRAS

Global model of differential rotation in the Sun

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Henrik Latter, Nigel Weiss

Abstract: The isorotation contours of the solar convective zone (SCZ) show three distinct morphologies, corresponding to two boundary layers (inner and outer), and the bulk of the interior. Previous work has shown that the thermal wind equation together with informal arguments on the nature of convection in a rotating fluid could be used to deduce the shape of the isorotation surfaces in the bulk of the SCZ… ▽ More The isorotation contours of the solar convective zone (SCZ) show three distinct morphologies, corresponding to two boundary layers (inner and outer), and the bulk of the interior. Previous work has shown that the thermal wind equation together with informal arguments on the nature of convection in a rotating fluid could be used to deduce the shape of the isorotation surfaces in the bulk of the SCZ with great fidelity, and that the tachocline contours could also be described by relatively simple phenomenology. In this paper, we show that the form of these surfaces can be understood more broadly as a mathematical consequence of the thermal wind equation and a narrow convective shell. The analysis does not yield the angular velocity function directly, an additional surface boundary condition is required. But much can already be deduced without constructing the entire rotation profile. The mathematics may be combined with dynamical arguments put forth in previous works to the mutual benefit of each. An important element of our approach is to regard the constant angular velocity surfaces as an independent coordinate variable for what is termed the "residual entropy," a quantity that plays a key role in the equation of thermal wind balance. The difference between the dynamics of the bulk of the SCZ and the tachocline is due to a different functional form of the residual entropy in each region. We develop a unified theory for the rotational behavior of both the SCZ and the tachocline, using the solutions for the characteristics of the thermal wind equation. These characteristics are identical to the isorotation contours in the bulk of the SCZ, but the two deviate in the tachocline. The outer layer may be treated, at least descriptively, by similar mathematical techniques, but this region probably does not obey thermal wind balance. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2011; originally announced November 2011.

Comments: 26 pages, 7 figures, accepted to MNRAS

On linear dust-gas streaming instabilities in protoplanetary discs

Authors: Emmanuel Jacquet, Steven A. Balbus, Henrik N. Latter

Abstract: We revisit, via a very simplified set of equations, a linear streaming instability (technically an overstability), which is present in, and potentially important for, dusty protoplanetary disks (Youdin & Goodman 2005). The goal is a better understanding of the physical origin of such instabilities, which are notoriously subtle. Rotational dynamics seem to be essential to this type of instability,… ▽ More We revisit, via a very simplified set of equations, a linear streaming instability (technically an overstability), which is present in, and potentially important for, dusty protoplanetary disks (Youdin & Goodman 2005). The goal is a better understanding of the physical origin of such instabilities, which are notoriously subtle. Rotational dynamics seem to be essential to this type of instability, which cannot be captured by one-dimensional Cartesian models. Dust `pileups' in moving pressure maxima are an important triggering mechanism of the instability, and drag feedback of dust upon the gas allows these maxima to be strengthened. Coriolis forces and the background drift counteract the effects of the pressure force. △ Less

Submitted 28 April, 2011; originally announced April 2011.

Comments: 9 pages, 1 figure. Accepted to MNRAS

Radiative and dynamic stability of a dilute plasma

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Christopher S. Reynolds

Abstract: We analyze the linear stability of a dilute, hot plasma, taking into account the effects of stratification and anisotropic thermal conduction. The work is motivated by attempts to understand the dynamics of the intracluster medium in galaxy clusters. We show that magnetic field configurations that nominally stabilize either the heat-flux driven buoyancy instability (associated with a positive ther… ▽ More We analyze the linear stability of a dilute, hot plasma, taking into account the effects of stratification and anisotropic thermal conduction. The work is motivated by attempts to understand the dynamics of the intracluster medium in galaxy clusters. We show that magnetic field configurations that nominally stabilize either the heat-flux driven buoyancy instability (associated with a positive thermal gradient) or the magnetothermal instability (negative thermal gradient) can lead to previously unrecognized g-mode overstabilities. The driving source of the overstability is either radiative cooling (positive temperature gradient) or the heat flux itself (negative temperature gradient). While the implications of these overstabilities have yet to be explored, we speculate that the cold fronts observed in many relaxed galaxy clusters may be related to their non-linear evolution. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2010; v1 submitted 26 July, 2010; originally announced July 2010.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters. Revised version corrects typo in figure

The effect of the tachocline on differential rotation in the Sun

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Henrik N. Latter

Abstract: In this paper, we present a model for the effects of the tachocline on the differential rotation in the solar convection zone. The mathematical technique relies on the assumption that entropy is nearly constant ("well-mixed") in isorotation surfaces both outside and within the tachocline. The resulting solutions exhibit nontrivial features that strikingly resemble the true tachocline isorotation c… ▽ More In this paper, we present a model for the effects of the tachocline on the differential rotation in the solar convection zone. The mathematical technique relies on the assumption that entropy is nearly constant ("well-mixed") in isorotation surfaces both outside and within the tachocline. The resulting solutions exhibit nontrivial features that strikingly resemble the true tachocline isorotation contours in unexpected detail. This strengthens the mathematical premises of the theory. The observed rotation pattern in the tachocline shows strong quadrupolar structure, an important feature that is explicitly used in constructing our solutions. The tachocline is treated locally as an interior boundary layer of small but finite thickness, and an explicit global solution is then constructed. A dynamical link can thus be established between the internal jump in the angular velocity at the tachocline and the spread of angular velocities observed near the solar surface. In general, our results suggest that the bulk of the solar convection zone is in thermal wind balance, and that simple quadrupolar stresses, local in radius, mediate the tachocline transition from differential rotation to uniform rotation in the radiative interior. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2010; originally announced May 2010.

Comments: 20 Pages, 4 figures, to appear in MNRAS

Resistive double-diffusive instability in the dead-zones of protostellar disks

Authors: Henrik N. Latter, Julius F. Bonart, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We outline a novel linear instability that may arise in the dead-zones of protostellar disks, and possibly the fluid interiors of planets and protoplanets. In essence it is an axisymmetric buoyancy instability, but one that would not be present in a purely hydrodynamical gas. The necessary ingredients for growth include a negative radial entropy gradient (of any magnitude), weak magnetic fields,… ▽ More We outline a novel linear instability that may arise in the dead-zones of protostellar disks, and possibly the fluid interiors of planets and protoplanets. In essence it is an axisymmetric buoyancy instability, but one that would not be present in a purely hydrodynamical gas. The necessary ingredients for growth include a negative radial entropy gradient (of any magnitude), weak magnetic fields, and efficient resistive diffusion (in comparison with thermal diffusion). The character of the instability is local, axisymmetric, and double-diffusive, and it attacks lengths much shorter than the resistive scale. Like the axisymmetric convective instability, it draws its energy from the negative radial entropy gradient; but by utilising the diffusing magnetic field, it can negate the stabilising influence of rotation. Its nonlinear saturated state, while not transporting appreciable angular momentum, could drive radial and vertical mixing, which may influence the temperature structure of the disk, dust dynamics and, potentially, planet formation. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2010; v1 submitted 19 February, 2010; originally announced February 2010.

Comments: 16 pages, 5 figures. MNRAS Accepted. V2: cosmetic changes to bring in line with MNRAS version

Journal ref: MNRAS (2010), 405, 1831

Differential rotation in fully convective stars

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Nigel O. Weiss

Abstract: Under the assumption of thermal wind balance and effective entropy mixing in constant rotation surfaces, the isorotational contours of the solar convective zone may be reproduced with great fidelity. Even at this early stage of development, this helioseismology fit may be used to put a lower bound on the midlatitude {\em radial} solar entropy gradient, which in good accord with standard mixing l… ▽ More Under the assumption of thermal wind balance and effective entropy mixing in constant rotation surfaces, the isorotational contours of the solar convective zone may be reproduced with great fidelity. Even at this early stage of development, this helioseismology fit may be used to put a lower bound on the midlatitude {\em radial} solar entropy gradient, which in good accord with standard mixing length theory. In this paper, we generalize this solar calculation to fully convective stars (and potentially planets), retaining the assumptions of thermal wind balance and effective entropy mixing in isorotational surfaces. It is found that each isorotation contour is of the form $R^2 = A+BΦ(r)$, where $R$ is the radius from the rotation axis, $Φ(r)$ is the (assumed spherical) gravitational potential, and $A$ and $B$ are constant along the contour. This result is applied to simple models of fully convective stars. Both solar-like surface rotation profiles (angular velocity decreasing toward the poles) as well as "antisolar" profiles (angular velocity increasing toward the poles) are modeled; the latter bear some suggestive resemblance to numerical simulations. We also perform exploratory studies of zonal surface flows similar to those seen in Jupiter and Saturn. In addition to providing a practical framework for understanding the results of large scale numerical simulations, our findings may also prove useful in dynamical calculations for which a simple but viable model for the background rotation profile in a convecting fluid is needed. Finally, our work bears directly on an important goal of the CoRoT program: to elucidate the internal structure of rotating, convecting stars. △ Less

Submitted 20 January, 2010; originally announced January 2010.

Comments: 21 pages, 20 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

On Differential Rotation and Convection in the Sun

Authors: S. A. Balbus, J. Bonart, H. N. Latter, N. O. Weiss

Abstract: We show that the differential rotation profile of the solar convection zone, apart from inner and outer boundary layers, can be reproduced with great accu- racy if the isorotation contours correspond to characteristics of the thermal wind equation. This requires that there be a formal quantitative relationship involving the entropy and the angular velocity. Earlier work has suggested that this c… ▽ More We show that the differential rotation profile of the solar convection zone, apart from inner and outer boundary layers, can be reproduced with great accu- racy if the isorotation contours correspond to characteristics of the thermal wind equation. This requires that there be a formal quantitative relationship involving the entropy and the angular velocity. Earlier work has suggested that this could arise from magnetohydrodynamic stability constraints; here we argue that purely hydrodynamical processes could also lead to such a result. Of special importance to the hydrodynamical solution is the fact that the thermal wind equation is insensitive to radial entropy gradients. This allows a much more general class of solutions to fit the solar isorotation contours, beyond just those in which the entropy itself must be a function of the angular velocity. In particular, for this expanded class, the thermal wind solution of the solar rotation profile remains valid even when large radial entropy gradients are present. A clear and explicit example of this class of solution appears to be present in published numerical simulations of the solar convective zone. Though hydrodynamical in character, the theory is not sensitive to the presence of weak magnetic fields. Thus, the identification of solar isorotation contours with the characteristics of the thermal wind equation appears to be robust, accommodating, but by no means requiring, magnetic field dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 29 July, 2009; originally announced July 2009.

Comments: 16 pages, 2 figures. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

Inertial waves near corotation in 3D hydrodynamical disks

Authors: Henrik Latter, Steven Balbus

Abstract: This paper concerns the interaction between non-axisymmetric inertial waves and their corotation resonances in a hydrodynamical disk. Inertial waves are of interest because they can localise in resonant cavities circumscribed by Lindblad radii, and as a consequence exhibit discrete oscillation frequencies that may be observed. It is often hypothesised that these trapped eigenmodes are affiliated… ▽ More This paper concerns the interaction between non-axisymmetric inertial waves and their corotation resonances in a hydrodynamical disk. Inertial waves are of interest because they can localise in resonant cavities circumscribed by Lindblad radii, and as a consequence exhibit discrete oscillation frequencies that may be observed. It is often hypothesised that these trapped eigenmodes are affiliated with the poorly understood QPO phenomenon. We demonstrate that a large class of non-axisymmetric 3D inertial waves cannot manifest as trapped normal modes. This class includes any inertial wave whose resonant cavity contains a corotation singularity. Instead, these `singular' modes constitute a continuous spectrum and, as an ensemble, are convected with the flow, giving rise to shearing waves. Lastly, we present a simple demonstration of how the corotation singularity stabilizes three-dimensional perturbations in a slender torus. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2009; v1 submitted 3 July, 2009; originally announced July 2009.

Comments: 17 pages, 5 figures. MNRAS accepted. V2 - Section 5.2 moved to appendix and errors removed

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.399:1058-1073,2009

Magnetohydrodynamics of Protostellar Disks

Authors: Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: The magnetohydrodynamical behavior (MHD) of accretion disks is reviewed. A detailed presentation of the fundamental MHD equations appropriate for protostellar disks is given. The combination of a weak (subthermal) magnetic field and Keplerian rotation is unstable to the magnetorotational instability (MRI), if the degree of ionization in the disk is sufficiently high. The MRI produces enhanced an… ▽ More The magnetohydrodynamical behavior (MHD) of accretion disks is reviewed. A detailed presentation of the fundamental MHD equations appropriate for protostellar disks is given. The combination of a weak (subthermal) magnetic field and Keplerian rotation is unstable to the magnetorotational instability (MRI), if the degree of ionization in the disk is sufficiently high. The MRI produces enhanced angular momentum and leads to a breakdown of laminar flow into turbulence. If the turbulent energy is dissipated locally, standard "$α$" modeling should give a reasonable estimate for the disk structure. Because away from the central star the ionization fraction of protostellar disks is small, they are generally not in the regime of near perfect conductivity. Nonideal MHD effects are important. Of these, Ohmic dissipation and Hall electromotive forces are the most important. The presence of dust is also critical, as small interstellar scale grains absorb free charges that are needed for good magnetic coupling. On scales of AU's there may be a region near the disk midplane that is magnetically decoupled, a so-called {\em dead zone.} But the growth and settling of the grains as time evolves reduces their efficiency to absorb charge. With ionization provided by coronal X-rays from the central star (and possibly also cosmic rays), protostellar disks may be sufficiently magnetized throughout most of their lives to be MRI active, especially away from the disk midplane. △ Less

Submitted 4 June, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 45 pages. To be published in Physical Processes in Circumstellar Disks Around Young Stars, ed. P. Garcia, (University of Chicago Press: Chicago)

Simulations of MHD Instabilities in Intracluster Medium Including Anisotropic Thermal Conduction

Authors: Tamara Bogdanovic, Christopher S. Reynolds, Steven A. Balbus, Ian J. Parrish

Abstract: We perform a suite of simulations of cooling cores in clusters of galaxies in order to investigate the effect of the recently discovered heat flux buoyancy instability (HBI) on the evolution of cores. Our models follow the 3-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) of cooling cluster cores and capture the effects of anisotropic heat conduction along the lines of magnetic field, but do not account… ▽ More We perform a suite of simulations of cooling cores in clusters of galaxies in order to investigate the effect of the recently discovered heat flux buoyancy instability (HBI) on the evolution of cores. Our models follow the 3-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) of cooling cluster cores and capture the effects of anisotropic heat conduction along the lines of magnetic field, but do not account for the cosmological setting of clusters or the presence of AGN. Our model clusters can be divided into three groups according to their final thermodynamical state: catastrophically collapsing cores, isothermal cores, and an intermediate group whose final state is determined by the initial configuration of magnetic field. Modeled cores that are reminiscent of real cluster cores show evolution towards thermal collapse on a time scale which is prolonged by a factor of ~2-10 compared with the zero-conduction cases. The principal effect of the HBI is to re-orient field lines to be perpendicular to the temperature gradient. Once the field has been wrapped up onto spherical surfaces surrounding the core, the core is insulated from further conductive heating (with the effective thermal conduction suppressed to less than 1/100th of the Spitzer value) and proceeds to collapse. We speculate that, in real clusters, the central AGN and possibly mergers play the role of "stirrers," periodically disrupting the azimuthal field structure and allowing thermal conduction to sporadically heat the core. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2009; v1 submitted 27 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 16 pages, 3 tables, 17 figures, accepted to ApJ with minor revisions, to appear in Volume 704, Oct 20, 2009 issue

Journal ref: Astrophys.J.704:211-225,2009

A comparison of local simulations and reduced models of MRI-induced turbulence

Authors: Pierre Lesaffre, Steven A. Balbus, Henrik Latter

Abstract: We run mean-field shearing-box numerical simulations with a temperature-dependent resistivity and compare them to a reduced dynamical model. Our simulations reveal the co-existence of two quasi-steady states, a `quiet' state and an `active' turbulent state, confirming the predictions of the reduced model. The initial conditions determine on which state the simulation ultimately settles. The acti… ▽ More We run mean-field shearing-box numerical simulations with a temperature-dependent resistivity and compare them to a reduced dynamical model. Our simulations reveal the co-existence of two quasi-steady states, a `quiet' state and an `active' turbulent state, confirming the predictions of the reduced model. The initial conditions determine on which state the simulation ultimately settles. The active state is strongly influenced by the geometry of the computational box and the thermal properties of the gas. Cubic domains support permanent channel flows, bar-shaped domains exhibit eruptive behaviour, and horizontal slabs give rise to infrequent channels. Meanwhile, longer cooling time-scales lead to higher saturation amplitudes. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: MNRAS accepted, 9 pages, 11 figures

Life Cycles of Magnetic Fields in Stellar Evolution

Authors: D. Uzdensky, J. Arons, S. Balbus, E. Blackman, J. Goodman, M. Medvedev, A. Spitkovsky, J. Stone

Abstract: This is a white paper submitted to the Stars and Stellar Evolution (SSE) Science Frontier Panel (SFP) of the NRC's Astronomy and Astrophysics 2010 Decadal Survey. The white paper is endorsed by the American Physical Society's (APS) Topical Group on Plasma Astrophysics (GPAP). This is a white paper submitted to the Stars and Stellar Evolution (SSE) Science Frontier Panel (SFP) of the NRC's Astronomy and Astrophysics 2010 Decadal Survey. The white paper is endorsed by the American Physical Society's (APS) Topical Group on Plasma Astrophysics (GPAP). △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2009; originally announced February 2009.

Comments: 8 pages; a white paper submitted to the SSE Panel of the Astro2010 Decadal Survey on behalf of the APS Topical Group on Plasma Astrophysics

MRI channel flows and their parasites

Authors: Henrik N. Latter, Pierre Lesaffre, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: Local simulations of the magnetorotational instability (MRI) in accretion disks can exhibit recurrent coherent structures called channel flows. The formation and destruction of these structures may play a role in the development and saturation of MRI-induced turbulence, and consequently help us understand the time-dependent accretion behaviour of certain astrophysical objects. Previous investiga… ▽ More Local simulations of the magnetorotational instability (MRI) in accretion disks can exhibit recurrent coherent structures called channel flows. The formation and destruction of these structures may play a role in the development and saturation of MRI-induced turbulence, and consequently help us understand the time-dependent accretion behaviour of certain astrophysical objects. Previous investigations have revealed that channel solutions are attacked by various parasitic modes, foremost of which is an analogue of the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. We revisit these instabilities and show how they relate to the classical instabilities of plasma physics, the kink and pinch modes. However, we argue that in most cases channels emerge from developed turbulence and are eventually destroyed by turbulent mixing, not by the parasites. The exceptions are the clean isolated channels which appear in systems near criticality or which emerge from low amplitude initial conditions. These structures inevitably achieve large amplitudes and are only then destroyed, giving rise to eruptive behaviour. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Comments: 17 pages, 17 figures, accepted by MNRAS

Journal ref: Mon.Not.Roy.Astron.Soc.394:715,2009

Magnetostrophic MRI in the Earth's Outer Core

Authors: Ludovic Petitdemange, Emmanuel Dormy, Steven A. Balbus

Abstract: We show that a simple, modified version of the Magnetorotational Instability (MRI) can develop in the outer liquid core of the Earth, in the presence of a background shear. It requires either thermal wind, or a primary instability, such as convection, to drive a weak differential rotation within the core. The force balance in the Earth's core is very unlike classical astrophysical applications o… ▽ More We show that a simple, modified version of the Magnetorotational Instability (MRI) can develop in the outer liquid core of the Earth, in the presence of a background shear. It requires either thermal wind, or a primary instability, such as convection, to drive a weak differential rotation within the core. The force balance in the Earth's core is very unlike classical astrophysical applications of the MRI (such as gaseous disks around stars). Here, the weak differential rotation in the Earth core yields an instability by its constructive interaction with the planet's much larger rotation rate. The resulting destabilising mechanism is just strong enough to counteract stabilizing resistive effects, and produce growth on geophysically interesting timescales. We give a simple physical explanation of the instability, and show that it relies on a force balance appropriate to the Earth's core, known as magnetostrophic balance. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2009; originally announced January 2009.

Journal ref: GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 35, L15305, 2008

A Simple Model for Solar Isorotational Contours

Authors: Steven Balbus

Abstract: The solar convective zone, or SCZ, is nearly adiabatic and marginally convectively unstable. But the SCZ is also in a state of differential rotation, and its dynamical stability properties are those of a weakly magnetized gas. This renders it far more prone to rapidly growing rotational baroclinic instabilities than a hydrodynamical system would be. These instabilities should be treated on the s… ▽ More The solar convective zone, or SCZ, is nearly adiabatic and marginally convectively unstable. But the SCZ is also in a state of differential rotation, and its dynamical stability properties are those of a weakly magnetized gas. This renders it far more prone to rapidly growing rotational baroclinic instabilities than a hydrodynamical system would be. These instabilities should be treated on the same footing as convective instabilites. If isentropic and isorotational surfaces coincide in the SCZ, the gas is marginally (un)stable to {\em both} convective and rotational disturbances. This is a plausible resolution for the instabilities associated with these more general rotating convective systems. This motivates an analysis of the thermal wind equation in which isentropes and isorotational surfaces are identical. The characteristics of this partial differential equation correspond to isorotation contours, and their form may be deduced even without precise knowledge of how the entropy and rotation are functionally related. Although the exact solution of the global SCZ problem in principle requires this knowledge, even the simplest models produce striking results in broad agreement with helioseismology data. This includes horizontal (i.e. quasi-spherical) isorotational contours at the poles, axial contours at the equator, and approximately radial contours at midlatitudes. The theory does not apply directly to the tachocline, where a simple thermal wind balance is not expected to be valid. The work presented here is subject to tests of self-consistency, among them the prediction that there should be good agreement between isentropes and isorotational contours in sufficiently well-resolved large scale numerical MHD simulations. △ Less

Submitted 7 January, 2009; v1 submitted 17 September, 2008; originally announced September 2008.

Comments: Final version: 21 pages, 4 figures, to appear in MNRAS; thorough revision, typos and minor errors corrected, expanded development and reordering of the material. Conclusions unchanged from original

Regulation of thermal conductivity in hot galaxy clusters by MHD turbulence

Authors: Steven A. Balbus, Christopher S. Reynolds

Abstract: The role of thermal conduction in regulating the thermal behavior of cooling flows in galaxy clusters is reexamined. Recent investigations have shown that the anisotropic Coulomb heat flux caused by a magnetic field in a dilute plasma drives a dynamical instability. A long standing problem of cooling flow theory has been to understand how thermal conduction can offset radiative core losses witho… ▽ More The role of thermal conduction in regulating the thermal behavior of cooling flows in galaxy clusters is reexamined. Recent investigations have shown that the anisotropic Coulomb heat flux caused by a magnetic field in a dilute plasma drives a dynamical instability. A long standing problem of cooling flow theory has been to understand how thermal conduction can offset radiative core losses without completely preventing them. In this Letter we propose that magnetohydrodynamic turbulence driven by the heat flux instability regulates field-line insulation and drives a reverse convective thermal flux, both of which may mediate the stabilization of the cooling cores of hot clusters. This model suggests that turbulent mixing should accompany strong thermal gradients in cooling flows. This prediction seems to be supported by the spatial distribution of metals in the central galaxies of clusters, which shows a much stronger correlation with the ambient hot gas temperature gradient than with the parent stellar population. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2008; originally announced June 2008.

Comments: 4 Pages. Accepted for publication in Astrophysical Journal Letters

Exact shering box solutions of MHD flows with resistivity, viscosity and cooling

Authors: P. Lesaffre, S. A. Balbus

Abstract: Axisymmetric incompressible modes of the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) with a vertical wavenumber are exact solutions of the non-linear local equations of motion for a disk (shearing box). They are referred to as "channel solutions". Here, we generalize a class of these solutions to include energy losses, viscous, and resistive effects. In the limit of zero shear, we recover the result th… ▽ More Axisymmetric incompressible modes of the magneto-rotational instability (MRI) with a vertical wavenumber are exact solutions of the non-linear local equations of motion for a disk (shearing box). They are referred to as "channel solutions". Here, we generalize a class of these solutions to include energy losses, viscous, and resistive effects. In the limit of zero shear, we recover the result that torsional Alfvén waves are exact solutions of the non-linear equations. Our method allows the extension of these solutions into the dissipative regime. These new solutions serve as benchmarks for simulations including dissipation and energy loss, and to calibrate numerical viscosity and resistivity in the Zeus3D code. We quantify the anisotropy of numerical dissipation and compute its scaling with time and space resolution. We find a strong dependence of the dissipation on the mean magnetic field that may affect the saturation state of the MRI as computed with Zeus3D. It is also shown that elongated grid cells generally preclude isotropic dissipation and that a Courant time step smaller than that which is commonly used should be taken to avoid spurious anti-diffusion of magnetic field. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2007; originally announced September 2007.

Comments: 17 pages, 18 figures, MNRAS in press