-
Simulating High-Velocity Clouds in the Observational Plane: An Initial Study with the Smith Cloud
Authors:
Lori E. Porter,
Matthew Abruzzo,
Greg L. Bryan,
Mary Putman,
Yong Zheng,
Drummond Fielding
Abstract:
High-velocity clouds (HVCs) may fuel future star formation in the Milky Way, but they must first survive their passage through the hot halo. While recent work has improved our understanding of the survival criterion for cloud-wind interactions, few observational comparisons exist that test this criterion. We therefore present an initial comparison of simulations with the Smith Cloud (SC; $d=$ 12.4…
▽ More
High-velocity clouds (HVCs) may fuel future star formation in the Milky Way, but they must first survive their passage through the hot halo. While recent work has improved our understanding of the survival criterion for cloud-wind interactions, few observational comparisons exist that test this criterion. We therefore present an initial comparison of simulations with the Smith Cloud (SC; $d=$ 12.4 kpc, $l, b = 40^{\circ}, -13^{\circ}$) as mapped with the GALFA-HI survey. We use the Smith Cloud's observed properties to motivate simulations of comparable clouds in wind tunnel simulations with Enzo-E, an MHD code. For both observations and simulations, we generate moment maps, characterize turbulence through a projected first-order velocity structure function (VSF), and do the same for HI column density with a normalized autocovariance function. We explore how initial cloud conditions (such as radius, metallicity, thermal pressure, viewing angle, and distance) affect these statistics, demonstrating that the small-scale VSF is sensitive to cloud turbulence while large scales depend on cloud bulk velocity and viewing angle. We find that some simulations reproduce key observational features (particularly the correlation between column density and velocity dispersion) but none match all observational probes at the same time (the large scales of the column density autocovariance is particularly challenging). We find that the simulated cloud (cloud C) showing growth via a turbulent radiative mixing layer (TRML) is the best match, implying the importance of TRML-mediated cooling for Milky Way HVCs. We conclude by suggesting improvements for simulations to better match observed HVCs.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
Cloud properties in simulated galactic winds
Authors:
Orlando Warren,
Evan E. Schneider,
S. Alwin Mao,
Matthew W. Abruzzo
Abstract:
In this work, we investigate the properties of a population of cool clouds in simulated galaxy outflows. Using data from the CGOLS isolated galaxy simulations, we generate catalogues of $\sim 10^5$ clouds. We describe the impact of two different supernova feedback models -- a centrally concentrated starburst and disk-wide distributed star formation -- on the resulting cloud population. In both cas…
▽ More
In this work, we investigate the properties of a population of cool clouds in simulated galaxy outflows. Using data from the CGOLS isolated galaxy simulations, we generate catalogues of $\sim 10^5$ clouds. We describe the impact of two different supernova feedback models -- a centrally concentrated starburst and disk-wide distributed star formation -- on the resulting cloud population. In both cases we find that the mass distribution function $dN/dM \propto M^{-2}$, in good agreement with model predictions of turbulent fragmentation. We explore how cloud properties change with distance from the galaxy and find no qualitative distinction between the two feedback modes, although significant quantitative differences exist in attributes such as the total number of clouds, their densities, etc. We further show that both internal cloud velocities and cloud-cloud relative velocities are described well by properties of turbulent motion, despite significant bulk radial velocities. Finally, we investigate the distribution of cloud sizes in the context of recent theoretical arguments about cloud survival in winds. We find that proposed cloud survival criteria are a good predictor of cloud survival, in both the case where clouds are primarily destroyed and the case where cloud growth occurs in the outflow.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Dust Survival in Galactic Winds
Authors:
Helena M. Richie,
Evan E. Schneider,
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Paul Torrey
Abstract:
We present a suite of high-resolution numerical simulations to study the evolution and survival of dust in hot galactic winds. We implement a novel dust framework in the Cholla hydrodynamics code and use wind tunnel simulations of cool, dusty clouds to understand how thermal sputtering affects the dust content of galactic winds. Our simulations illustrate how various regimes of cloud evolution imp…
▽ More
We present a suite of high-resolution numerical simulations to study the evolution and survival of dust in hot galactic winds. We implement a novel dust framework in the Cholla hydrodynamics code and use wind tunnel simulations of cool, dusty clouds to understand how thermal sputtering affects the dust content of galactic winds. Our simulations illustrate how various regimes of cloud evolution impact dust survival, dependent on cloud size, wind properties, and dust grain size. We find that significant amounts of dust can survive in winds in all scenarios, even without shielding from the cool phase of outflows. We present an analytic framework that explains this result, along with an analysis of the impact of cloud evolution on the total fraction of dust survival. Using these results, we estimate that 60 percent of 0.1 micron dust that enters a starburst-driven wind could survive to populate both the hot and cool phases of the halo, based on a simulated distribution of cloud properties. We also investigate how these conclusions depend on grain size, exploring grains from 0.1 micron to 10 Angstrom. Under most circumstances, grains smaller than 0.01 micron cannot withstand hot-phase exposure, suggesting that the small grains observed in the CGM are either formed in situ due to the shattering of larger grains, or must be carried there in the cool phase of outflows. Finally, we show that the dust-to-gas ratio of clouds declines as a function of distance from the galaxy due to cloud-wind mixing and condensation. These results provide an explanation for the vast amounts of dust observed in the CGMs of galaxies and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2024; v1 submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Korg: fitting, model atmosphere interpolation, and Brackett lines
Authors:
Adam J Wheeler,
Andrew R Casey,
Matthew W Abruzzo
Abstract:
We describe several updates to Korg, a package for 1D LTE spectral synthesis of FGKM stars. Built-in functions to fit observed spectra via synthesis or equivalent widths make it easy to take advantage of Korg's automatic differentiation. Comparison to a past analysis of 18 Sco shows that we obtain significantly reduced line-to-line abundance scatter with Korg. Fitting and synthesis are facilitated…
▽ More
We describe several updates to Korg, a package for 1D LTE spectral synthesis of FGKM stars. Built-in functions to fit observed spectra via synthesis or equivalent widths make it easy to take advantage of Korg's automatic differentiation. Comparison to a past analysis of 18 Sco shows that we obtain significantly reduced line-to-line abundance scatter with Korg. Fitting and synthesis are facilitated by a rigorously-tested model atmosphere interpolation method, which introduces negligible error to synthesized spectra for stars with $T_\mathrm{eff} \gtrsim 4000\,\mathrm{K}$. For cooler stars, atmosphere interpolation is complicated by the presence of molecules, though we demonstrate an adequate method for cool dwarfs. The chemical equilibrium solver has been extended to include polyatomic and charged molecules, extending Korg's regime of applicability to M stars. We also discuss a common oversight regarding the synthesis of hydrogen lines in the infrared, and show that Korg's Brackett line profiles are a much closer match to observations than others available. Documentation, installation instructions, and tutorials are available at https://github.com/ajwheeler/Korg.jl.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2024; v1 submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
TuRMoiL of Survival: A Unified Survival Criterion for Cloud-Wind Interactions
Authors:
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Drummond B. Fielding,
Greg L. Bryan
Abstract:
Cloud-wind interactions play an important role in long-lived multiphase flows in many astrophysical contexts. When this interaction is primarily mediated by hydrodynamics and radiative cooling, the survival of clouds can be phrased in terms of the comparison between a timescale that dictates the evolution of the cloud-wind interaction, (the dynamical time-scale $τ_{\rm dyn}$) and the relevant cool…
▽ More
Cloud-wind interactions play an important role in long-lived multiphase flows in many astrophysical contexts. When this interaction is primarily mediated by hydrodynamics and radiative cooling, the survival of clouds can be phrased in terms of the comparison between a timescale that dictates the evolution of the cloud-wind interaction, (the dynamical time-scale $τ_{\rm dyn}$) and the relevant cooling timescale $τ_{\rm cool}$. Previously proposed survival criteria, which can disagree by large factors about the size of the smallest surviving clouds, differ in both their choice of $τ_{\rm cool}$ and (to a lesser extent) $τ_{\rm dyn}$. Here we present a new criterion which agrees with a previously proposed empirical formulae but is based on simple physical principles. The key insight is that clouds can grow if they are able to mix and cool gas from the hot wind faster than it advects by the cloud. Whereas prior criteria associate $τ_{\rm dyn}$ with the cloud crushing timescale, our new criterion links it to the characteristic cloud-crossing timescale of a hot-phase fluid element, making it more physically consistent with shear-layer studies. We develop this insight into a predictive expression and validate it with hydrodynamic ENZO-E simulations of ${\sim}10^4\, {\rm K}$, pressure-confined clouds in hot supersonic winds, exploring, in particular, high wind/cloud density contrasts, where disagreements are most pronounced. Finally, we illustrate how discrepancies among previous criteria primarily emerged due to different choices of simulation conditions and cooling properties, and discuss how they can be reconciled.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Korg: a modern 1D LTE spectral synthesis package
Authors:
Adam J. Wheeler,
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Andrew R. Casey,
Melissa K. Ness
Abstract:
We present Korg, a new package for 1D LTE (local thermodynamic equilibrium) spectral synthesis of FGK stars, which computes theoretical spectra from the near-ultraviolet to the near-infrared, and implements both plane-parallel and spherical radiative transfer. We outline the inputs and internals of Korg, and compare synthetic spectra from Korg, MOOG, Turbospectrum, and SME. The disagreements betwe…
▽ More
We present Korg, a new package for 1D LTE (local thermodynamic equilibrium) spectral synthesis of FGK stars, which computes theoretical spectra from the near-ultraviolet to the near-infrared, and implements both plane-parallel and spherical radiative transfer. We outline the inputs and internals of Korg, and compare synthetic spectra from Korg, MOOG, Turbospectrum, and SME. The disagreements between Korg and the other codes are no larger than those between the other codes, although disagreement between codes is substantial. We examine the case of a C$_2$ band in detail, finding that uncertainties on physical inputs to spectral synthesis account for a significant fraction of the disagreement. Korg is 1-100 times faster than other codes in typical use, compatible with automatic differentiation libraries, and easily extensible, making it ideal for statistical inference and parameter estimation applied to large data sets. Documentation and installation instructions are available at https://ajwheeler.github.io/Korg.jl/stable/.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Taming the TuRMoiL: The Temperature Dependence of Turbulence in Cloud-Wind Interactions
Authors:
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Drummond B. Fielding,
Greg L. Bryan
Abstract:
Turbulent radiative mixing layers (TRMLs) play an important role in many astrophysical contexts where cool ($\lesssim 10^4$ K) clouds interact with hot flows (e.g., galactic winds, high velocity clouds, infalling satellites in halos and clusters). The fate of these clouds (as well as many of their observable properties) is dictated by the competition between turbulence and radiative cooling; howev…
▽ More
Turbulent radiative mixing layers (TRMLs) play an important role in many astrophysical contexts where cool ($\lesssim 10^4$ K) clouds interact with hot flows (e.g., galactic winds, high velocity clouds, infalling satellites in halos and clusters). The fate of these clouds (as well as many of their observable properties) is dictated by the competition between turbulence and radiative cooling; however, turbulence in these multiphase flows remains poorly understood. We have investigated the emergent turbulence arising in the interaction between clouds and supersonic winds in hydrodynamic ENZO-E simulations. In order to obtain robust results, we employed multiple metrics to characterize the turbulent velocity, $v_{\rm turb}$. We find four primary results, when cooling is sufficient for cloud survival. First, $v_{\rm turb}$ manifests clear temperature dependence. Initially, $v_{\rm turb}$ roughly matches the scaling of sound speed on temperature. In gas hotter than the temperature where cooling peaks, this dependence weakens with time until $v_{\rm turb}$ is constant. Second, the relative velocity between the cloud and wind initially drives rapid growth of $v_{\rm turb}$. As it drops (from entrainment), $v_{\rm turb}$ starts to decay before it stabilizes at roughly half its maximum. At late times cooling flows appear to support turbulence. Third, the magnitude of $v_{\rm turb}$ scales with the ratio between the hot phase sound crossing time and the minimum cooling time. Finally, we find tentative evidence for a length-scale associated with resolving turbulence. Under-resolving this scale may cause violent shattering and affect the cloud's large-scale morphological properties.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2023; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
A simple model for mixing and cooling in cloud-wind interactions
Authors:
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Greg L. Bryan,
Drummond B. Fielding
Abstract:
We introduce a simple entropy-based formalism to characterize the role of mixing in pressure-balanced multiphase clouds, and demonstrate example applications using Enzo-E (magneto)hydrodynamic simulations. Under this formalism, the high-dimensional description of the system's state at a given time is simplified to the joint distribution of mass over pressure ($P$) and entropy ($K=P/ρ^γ$). As a res…
▽ More
We introduce a simple entropy-based formalism to characterize the role of mixing in pressure-balanced multiphase clouds, and demonstrate example applications using Enzo-E (magneto)hydrodynamic simulations. Under this formalism, the high-dimensional description of the system's state at a given time is simplified to the joint distribution of mass over pressure ($P$) and entropy ($K=P/ρ^γ$). As a result, this approach provides a way for (empirically and analytically) quantifying the impact of different initial conditions and sets of physics on the system evolution. We find that mixing predominantly alters the distribution along the $K$ direction and illustrate how the formalism can be used to model mixing and cooling for fluid elements originating in the cloud. We further confirm and generalize a previously suggested criterion for cloud growth in the presence of radiative cooling, and demonstrate that the shape of the cooling curve, particularly at the low temperature end, can play an important role in controlling condensation. Moreover, we discuss the capacity of our approach to generalize such a criterion to apply to additional sets of physics, and to build intuition for the impact of subtle higher order effects not directly addressed by the criterion.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Powderday: Dust Radiative Transfer for Galaxy Simulations
Authors:
Desika Narayanan,
Matthew J. Turk,
Thomas Robitaille,
Ashley J. Kelly,
B. Connor McClellan,
Ray S. Sharma,
Prerak Garg,
Matthew Abruzzo,
Ena Choi,
Charlie Conroy,
Benjamin D. Johnson,
Benjamin Kimock,
Qi Li,
Christopher C. Lovell,
Sidney Lower,
George C. Privon,
Jonathan Roberts,
Snigdaa Sethuram,
Gregory F. Snyder,
Robert Thompson,
John H. Wise
Abstract:
We present Powderday, a flexible, fast, open-source dust radiative transfer package designed to interface with galaxy formation simulations. Powderday builds on FSPS population synthesis models, Hyperion dust radiative transfer, and employs yt to interface between different software packages. We include our stellar population synthesis modeling on the fly, which allows for significant run-time fle…
▽ More
We present Powderday, a flexible, fast, open-source dust radiative transfer package designed to interface with galaxy formation simulations. Powderday builds on FSPS population synthesis models, Hyperion dust radiative transfer, and employs yt to interface between different software packages. We include our stellar population synthesis modeling on the fly, which allows for significant run-time flexibility in the assumed stellar physics. We include a model for nebular line emission that can employ either precomputed Cloudy lookup tables (for efficiency), or direct photoionization calculations for all young stars (for flexibility). The dust content follows either observationally-motivated prescriptions, direct modeling from galaxy formation simulations, or a novel approach that includes the dust content via learning-based algorithms from the SIMBA cosmological galaxy formation simulation. AGN can additionally be included via a range of prescriptions. The output of these models are broadband SEDs, as well as filter-convolved images. Powderday is designed to eliminate last-mile efforts by researchers that employ different hydrodynamic galaxy formation models, and seamlessly interfaces with GIZMO, AREPO, GASOLINE, CHANGA, and ENZO. We demonstrate the capabilities of the code via three applications: a model for the star formation rate (SFR) - infrared luminosity relation in galaxies (including the impact of AGN); the impact of circumstellar dust around AGB stars on the mid-infrared emission from galaxy SEDs; and the impact of galaxy inclination angle on dust attenuation laws.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
The Impact of Photometric Redshift Errors on Lensing Statistics in Ray-Tracing Simulations
Authors:
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Zoltán Haiman
Abstract:
Weak lensing surveys are reaching sensitivities at which uncertainties in the galaxy redshift distributions n(z) from photo-z errors degrade cosmological constraints. We use ray-tracing simulations and a simple treatment of photo-z errors to assess cosmological parameter biases from uncertainties in n(z) in an LSST-like survey. We use the power spectrum and the abundance of lensing peaks to infer…
▽ More
Weak lensing surveys are reaching sensitivities at which uncertainties in the galaxy redshift distributions n(z) from photo-z errors degrade cosmological constraints. We use ray-tracing simulations and a simple treatment of photo-z errors to assess cosmological parameter biases from uncertainties in n(z) in an LSST-like survey. We use the power spectrum and the abundance of lensing peaks to infer cosmological parameters, and find that the former is somewhat more resilient to photo-z errors. We place conservative lower limits on the survey size at which different types of photo-z errors degrade LCDM (wCDM) parameter constraints by 50%. A residual constant photo-z bias of |dz| < 0.003(1+z), satisfying the current LSST requirement, does not significantly degrade constraints for surveys smaller than ~1300 (~490) square degrees using lensing peaks and ~6500 (~4900) square degrees using the power spectrum. Adopting a recent prediction for LSST's full photo-z probability distribution function (PDF), we find that simply approximating n(z) with the photo-z galaxy distribution directly computed from this PDF would degrade surveys as small as ~60 (~65) square degrees using lensing peaks or the power spectrum. Assuming that the centroid bias in each tomographic redshift bin can be removed from the photo-z galaxy distribution, using lensing peaks or the power spectrum still degrades surveys larger than ~200 (~255) or ~248 (~315) square degrees. These results imply that the expected broad photo-z PDF significantly biases parameters, which needs to be further mitigated using more sophisticated photo-z treatments.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Identifying Mergers Using Quantitative Morphologies in Zoom Simulations of High-Redshift Galaxies
Authors:
Matthew W. Abruzzo,
Desika Narayanan,
Romeel Davé,
Robert Thompson
Abstract:
Non-parametric morphology measures are a powerful tool for identifying galaxy mergers at low redshifts. We employ cosmological zoom simulations using Gizmo with the Mufasa feedback scheme, post-processed using 3D dust radiative transfer into mock observations, to study whether common morphological measures Gini G, M20, concentration C, and asymmetry A are effective at identifying major galaxy merg…
▽ More
Non-parametric morphology measures are a powerful tool for identifying galaxy mergers at low redshifts. We employ cosmological zoom simulations using Gizmo with the Mufasa feedback scheme, post-processed using 3D dust radiative transfer into mock observations, to study whether common morphological measures Gini G, M20, concentration C, and asymmetry A are effective at identifying major galaxy mergers at z ~ 2 - 4, i.e. "Cosmic Noon". Our zoom suite covers galaxies with 10^8.6 < M_* < 10^11 M_sun at z ~ 2, and broadly reproduces key global galaxy observations. Our primary result is that these morphological measures are unable to robustly pick out galaxies currently undergoing mergers during Cosmic Noon, typically performing no better than a random guess. This improves only marginally if we consider whether galaxies have undergone a merger within the last Gyr. When also considering minor mergers, galaxies display no trend of moving towards the merger regime with increasing merger ratio. From z = 4 -> 2, galaxies move from the non-merger towards the merger regime in all statistics, but this is primarily an effect of mass: Above a given noise level, higher mass galaxies display a more complex outer morphology induced by their clustered environment. We conclude that during Cosmic Noon, these morphological statistics are of limited value in identifying galaxy mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A Multi-telescope Campaign on FRB 121102: Implications for the FRB Population
Authors:
C. J. Law,
M. W. Abruzzo,
C. G. Bassa,
G. C. Bower,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
B. J. Butler,
T. Cantwell,
S. H. Carey,
S. Chatterjee,
J. M. Cordes,
P. Demorest,
J. Dowell,
R. Fender,
K. Gourdji,
K. Grainge,
J. W. T. Hessels,
J. Hickish,
V. M. Kaspi,
T. J. W. Lazio,
M. A. McLaughlin,
D. Michilli,
K. Mooley,
Y. C. Perrott,
S. M. Ransom,
N. Razavi-Ghods
, et al. (11 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present results of the coordinated observing campaign that made the first subarcsecond localization of a Fast Radio Burst, FRB 121102. During this campaign, we made the first simultaneous detection of an FRB burst by multiple telescopes: the VLA at 3 GHz and the Arecibo Observatory at 1.4 GHz. Of the nine bursts detected by the Very Large Array at 3 GHz, four had simultaneous observing coverage…
▽ More
We present results of the coordinated observing campaign that made the first subarcsecond localization of a Fast Radio Burst, FRB 121102. During this campaign, we made the first simultaneous detection of an FRB burst by multiple telescopes: the VLA at 3 GHz and the Arecibo Observatory at 1.4 GHz. Of the nine bursts detected by the Very Large Array at 3 GHz, four had simultaneous observing coverage at other observatories. We use multi-observatory constraints and modeling of bursts seen only at 3 GHz to confirm earlier results showing that burst spectra are not well modeled by a power law. We find that burst spectra are characterized by a ~500 MHz envelope and apparent radio energy as high as $10^{40}$ erg. We measure significant changes in the apparent dispersion between bursts that can be attributed to frequency-dependent profiles or some other intrinsic burst structure that adds a systematic error to the estimate of DM by up to 1%. We use FRB 121102 as a prototype of the FRB class to estimate a volumetric birth rate of FRB sources $R_{FRB} \approx 5x10^{-5}/N_r$ Mpc$^{-3}$ yr$^{-1}$, where $N_r$ is the number of bursts per source over its lifetime. This rate is broadly consistent with models of FRBs from young pulsars or magnetars born in superluminous supernovae or long gamma-ray bursts, if the typical FRB repeats on the order of thousands of times during its lifetime.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
The direct localization of a fast radio burst and its host
Authors:
S. Chatterjee,
C. J. Law,
R. S. Wharton,
S. Burke-Spolaor,
J. W. T. Hessels,
G. C. Bower,
J. M. Cordes,
S. P. Tendulkar,
C. G. Bassa,
P. Demorest,
B. J. Butler,
A. Seymour,
P. Scholz,
M. W. Abruzzo,
S. Bogdanov,
V. M. Kaspi,
A. Keimpema,
T. J. W. Lazio,
B. Marcote,
M. A. McLaughlin,
Z. Paragi,
S. M. Ransom,
M. Rupen,
L. G. Spitler,
H. J. van Langevelde
Abstract:
Fast radio bursts are astronomical radio flashes of unknown physical nature with durations of milliseconds. Their dispersive arrival times suggest an extragalactic origin and imply radio luminosities orders of magnitude larger than any other kind of known short-duration radio transient. Thus far, all FRBs have been detected with large single-dish telescopes with arcminute localizations, and attemp…
▽ More
Fast radio bursts are astronomical radio flashes of unknown physical nature with durations of milliseconds. Their dispersive arrival times suggest an extragalactic origin and imply radio luminosities orders of magnitude larger than any other kind of known short-duration radio transient. Thus far, all FRBs have been detected with large single-dish telescopes with arcminute localizations, and attempts to identify their counterparts (source or host galaxy) have relied on contemporaneous variability of field sources or the presence of peculiar field stars or galaxies. These attempts have not resulted in an unambiguous association with a host or multi-wavelength counterpart. Here we report the sub-arcsecond localization of FRB 121102, the only known repeating burst source, using high-time-resolution radio interferometric observations that directly image the bursts themselves. Our precise localization reveals that FRB 121102 originates within 100 mas of a faint 180 uJy persistent radio source with a continuum spectrum that is consistent with non-thermal emission, and a faint (25th magnitude) optical counterpart. The flux density of the persistent radio source varies by tens of percent on day timescales, and very long baseline radio interferometry yields an angular size less than 1.7 mas. Our observations are inconsistent with the fast radio burst having a Galactic origin or its source being located within a prominent star-forming galaxy. Instead, the source appears to be co-located with a low-luminosity active galactic nucleus or a previously unknown type of extragalactic source. [Truncated] If other fast radio bursts have similarly faint radio and optical counterparts, our findings imply that direct sub-arcsecond localizations of FRBs may be the only way to provide reliable associations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
