-
Dark Matter Substructure or Source Model Systematics? A Case Study of Cluster Lens Abell S1063
Authors:
Nino Ephremidze,
Chandrika Chandrashekar,
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Cora Dvorkin
Abstract:
Mapping the small-scale structure of the universe through gravitational lensing is a promising tool for probing the particle nature of dark matter. Curved Arc Basis (CAB) has been proposed as a local lensing formalism in galaxy clusters, with the potential to detect low-mass dark matter substructure. In this work, we analyze the cluster lens Abell S1063 in search of dark matter substructure with t…
▽ More
Mapping the small-scale structure of the universe through gravitational lensing is a promising tool for probing the particle nature of dark matter. Curved Arc Basis (CAB) has been proposed as a local lensing formalism in galaxy clusters, with the potential to detect low-mass dark matter substructure. In this work, we analyze the cluster lens Abell S1063 in search of dark matter substructure with the CAB formalism, using multi-band imaging data from JWST. We use two different source modeling methods: shapelets and pixel-based source reconstruction based on Delaunay triangulation. We find that source modeling systematics from shapelets result in a disagreement between Curved Arc Basis parameters measured from different filters. Source modeling with Delaunay significantly alleviates this systematic, as seen in the improvement in agreement across filters. We also find that inadequate complexity in source modeling can result in convincing spurious detections of dark matter substructure from strong gravitational lenses, as seen by our $Δ\text{BIC} > 20$ measurement of a $M \sim 10^{10}$ $M_{\odot}$ subhalo with shapelets, a spurious detection that is not reproduced with Delaunay source modeling. We demonstrate that multi-band analysis with different JWST filters is key for disentangling source and lens model systematics from dark matter substructure detections.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Along the Primary Curve: Simultaneous Source and Lens Reconstruction of Bright Arcs in Cluster Lenses
Authors:
Atınç Çağan Şengül
Abstract:
Gravitational lensing is the phenomenon arising when light rays are deflected by the mass between the source and the observer. Largely magnified and highly distorted images of background galaxies are formed by these angular deflections if the deflecting mass distribution and the background sources align. As the most massive gravitationally bound objects in the universe, galaxy clusters are places…
▽ More
Gravitational lensing is the phenomenon arising when light rays are deflected by the mass between the source and the observer. Largely magnified and highly distorted images of background galaxies are formed by these angular deflections if the deflecting mass distribution and the background sources align. As the most massive gravitationally bound objects in the universe, galaxy clusters are places where such alignments are usually found. By carefully analyzing the images of lensed galaxies, one can measure the mass, both visible and invisible, along the line-of-sight. These measurements are crucial in investigating the nature of dark matter, which constitutes most of the mass within clusters. Existing lensing analysis methods typically forward model the multiple images of dozens of background galaxies lensed by the cluster. To make this forward modeling computationally tractable, these multiple images are reduced to a much smaller summary data vector, which includes the locations, magnifications, and distortions. Our work avoids this loss of information by forward modeling the data at pixel-level. We develop a parametric model for the angular deflections near the bright arcs that allows us to control the shape of the curve that gives the directions of the eigenvectors of the Jacobian of the lensing matrix. The bright and extended images often follow such curves. We apply our analysis method to the bright arcs in gravitational lenses SDSS J1110+6459 and SDSS J0004-0103. We present our lens and source reconstructions for each system. With the application of our new method to many other lensing systems, we anticipate significant improvement in lens modeling near the critical curve, which will provide higher precision mass reconstructions for the deflectors. High-precision lens models allow for more robust de-lensing, which aids the studies of various highly magnified sources.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Substructure Detection in Realistic Strong Lensing Systems with Machine Learning
Authors:
Arthur Tsang,
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Cora Dvorkin
Abstract:
Tens of thousands of galaxy-galaxy strong lensing systems are expected to be discovered by the end of the decade. These will form a vast new dataset that can be used to probe subgalactic dark matter structures through its gravitational effects, which will in turn allow us to study the nature of dark matter at small length scales. This work shows how we can leverage machine learning to search throu…
▽ More
Tens of thousands of galaxy-galaxy strong lensing systems are expected to be discovered by the end of the decade. These will form a vast new dataset that can be used to probe subgalactic dark matter structures through its gravitational effects, which will in turn allow us to study the nature of dark matter at small length scales. This work shows how we can leverage machine learning to search through the data and identify which systems are most likely to contain dark matter substructure and thus can be studied in greater depth. We use a UNet, an image segmentation architecture, on a simulated strongly-lensed dataset with realistic sources (COSMOS galaxies), lenses (power-law elliptical profiles with multipoles and external shear), and noise. Our machine learning algorithm is able to quickly detect most substructure at high image resolution and subhalo concentration. At a false positive rate of $10\%$, we are able to identify systems with substructure at a true positive rate of $71\%$ for a subhalo mass range of $10^{9}\text{-}10^{9.5}\,M_\odot$. While recent detections are consistent with higher concentrations, we find that our algorithm fails at detecting subhalos with lower concentrations (expected from $Λ$CDM simulations).
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Subhalo effective density slope measurements from HST strong lensing data with neural likelihood-ratio estimation
Authors:
Gemma Zhang,
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Cora Dvorkin
Abstract:
Examining the properties of subhalos with strong gravitational lensing images can shed light on the nature of dark matter. From upcoming large-scale surveys, we expect to discover orders of magnitude more strong lens systems that can be used for subhalo studies. To optimally extract information from a large number of strong lensing images, machine learning provides promising avenues for efficient…
▽ More
Examining the properties of subhalos with strong gravitational lensing images can shed light on the nature of dark matter. From upcoming large-scale surveys, we expect to discover orders of magnitude more strong lens systems that can be used for subhalo studies. To optimally extract information from a large number of strong lensing images, machine learning provides promising avenues for efficient analysis that is unachievable with traditional analysis methods, but application of machine learning techniques to real observations is still limited. We build upon previous work, which uses a neural likelihood-ratio estimator, to constrain the effective density slopes of subhalos and demonstrate the feasibility of this method on real strong lensing observations. To do this, we implement significant improvements to the forward simulation pipeline and undertake careful model evaluation using simulated images. Ultimately, we use our trained model to predict the effective subhalo density slope from combining a set of strong lensing images taken by the \textit{Hubble Space Telescope}. We found the subhalo slope measurement of this set of observations to be steeper than the slope predictions of cold dark matter subhalos. Our result adds to several previous works that also measured high subhalo slopes in observations. Although a possible explanation for this is that subhalos with steeper slopes are easier to detect due to selection effects and thus contribute to statistical bias, our result nevertheless points to the need for careful analysis of more strong lensing observations from future surveys.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024; v1 submitted 18 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Detecting Low-Mass Perturbers in Cluster Lenses using Curved Arc Bases
Authors:
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Simon Birrer,
Priyamvada Natarajan,
Cora Dvorkin
Abstract:
Strong gravitationally lensed arcs produced by galaxy clusters have been observationally detected for several decades now. These strong lensing constraints provided high-fidelity mass models for cluster lenses that include substructure down to $10^{9-10}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. Optimizing lens models, where the cluster mass distribution is modeled by a smooth component and subhalos associated with the…
▽ More
Strong gravitationally lensed arcs produced by galaxy clusters have been observationally detected for several decades now. These strong lensing constraints provided high-fidelity mass models for cluster lenses that include substructure down to $10^{9-10}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. Optimizing lens models, where the cluster mass distribution is modeled by a smooth component and subhalos associated with the locations of individual cluster galaxies, has enabled deriving the subhalo mass function, providing important constraints on the nature and granularity of dark matter. In this work, we explore and present a novel method to detect and measure individual perturbers (subhalos, line-of-sight halos, and wandering supermassive black holes) by exploiting their proximity to highly distorted lensed arcs in galaxy clusters, and by modeling the local lensing distortions with curved arc bases. This method offers the possibility of detecting individual low-mass perturber subhalos in clusters and halos along the line-of-sight down to a mass resolution of $10^8\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. We quantify our sensitivity to low-mass perturbers ($M\sim 10^{7-9}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$) in clusters ($M\sim 10^{14-15}\mathrm{M}_\odot$), by creating realistic mock data. Using three lensed images of a background galaxy in the cluster SMACS J0723, taken by the $\textit{James Webb Space Telescope}$, we study the retrieval of the properties of potential perturbers with masses $M=10^{7-9}\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$. From the derived posterior probability distributions for the perturber, we constrain its concentration, redshift, and ellipticity. By allowing us to probe lower-mass substructures, the use of curved arc bases can lead to powerful constraints on the nature of dark matter as discrimination between dark matter models appears on smaller scales.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023; v1 submitted 26 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Probing Dark Matter with Strong Gravitational Lensing through an Effective Density Slope
Authors:
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Cora Dvorkin
Abstract:
Many dark matter (DM) models that are consistent with current cosmological data show differences in the predicted (sub)halo mass function, especially at sub-galactic scales, where observations are challenging due to the inefficiency of star formation. Strong gravitational lensing has been shown to be a useful tool for detecting dark low-mass (sub)halos through perturbations in lensing arcs, theref…
▽ More
Many dark matter (DM) models that are consistent with current cosmological data show differences in the predicted (sub)halo mass function, especially at sub-galactic scales, where observations are challenging due to the inefficiency of star formation. Strong gravitational lensing has been shown to be a useful tool for detecting dark low-mass (sub)halos through perturbations in lensing arcs, therefore allowing the testing of different DM scenarios. However, measuring the total mass of a perturber from strong lensing data is challenging. Over or underestimating perturber masses can lead to incorrect inferences about the nature of DM. In this paper, we argue that inferring an effective slope of the dark matter density profile, which is the power-law slope of perturbers at intermediate radii, where we expect the perturber to have the largest observable effect, is a promising way to circumvent these challenges. Using N-body simulations, we show that (sub)halo populations under different DM scenarios differ in their effective density slope distributions. Using realistic mocks of Hubble Space Telescope observations of strong lensing images, we show that the effective density slope of perturbers can be robustly measured with high enough accuracy to discern between different models. We also present our measurement of the effective density slope $γ=1.96\substack{+0.12 \\ -0.12}$ for the perturber in JVAS B1938+666, which we find to be a $2σ$ outlier of the cold dark matter scenario. More measurements of this kind are needed to be able to draw robust conclusions about the nature of dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022; v1 submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Substructure Detection Reanalyzed: Dark Perturber shown to be a Line-of-Sight Halo
Authors:
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Cora Dvorkin,
Bryan Ostdiek,
Arthur Tsang
Abstract:
Observations of structure at sub-galactic scales are crucial for probing the properties of dark matter, which is the dominant source of gravity in the universe. It will become increasingly important for future surveys to distinguish between line-of-sight halos and subhalos to avoid wrong inferences on the nature of dark matter. We reanalyze a sub-galactic structure (in lens JVAS B1938+666) that ha…
▽ More
Observations of structure at sub-galactic scales are crucial for probing the properties of dark matter, which is the dominant source of gravity in the universe. It will become increasingly important for future surveys to distinguish between line-of-sight halos and subhalos to avoid wrong inferences on the nature of dark matter. We reanalyze a sub-galactic structure (in lens JVAS B1938+666) that has been previously found using the gravitational imaging technique in galaxy-galaxy lensing systems. This structure has been assumed to be a satellite in the halo of the main lens galaxy. We fit the redshift of the perturber of the system as a free parameter, using the multi-plane thin-lens approximation, and find that the redshift of the perturber is $z_\mathrm{int} = 1.42\substack{+0.10 \\ -0.15}$ (with a main lens redshift of $z=0.881$). Our analysis indicates that this structure is more massive than the previous result by an order of magnitude. This constitutes the first dark perturber shown to be a line-of-sight halo with a gravitational lensing method.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2022; v1 submitted 1 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Quantifying the Line-of-Sight Halo Contribution to the Dark Matter Convergence Power Spectrum from Strong Gravitational Lenses
Authors:
Atınç Çağan Şengül,
Arthur Tsang,
Ana Diaz Rivero,
Cora Dvorkin,
Hong-Ming Zhu,
Uroš Seljak
Abstract:
Galaxy-galaxy strong gravitational lenses have become a popular probe of dark matter (DM) by providing a window into structure formation on the smallest scales. In particular, the convergence power spectrum of subhalos within lensing galaxies has been suggested as a promising observable to study DM. However, the distances involved in strong-lensing systems are vast, and we expect the relevant volu…
▽ More
Galaxy-galaxy strong gravitational lenses have become a popular probe of dark matter (DM) by providing a window into structure formation on the smallest scales. In particular, the convergence power spectrum of subhalos within lensing galaxies has been suggested as a promising observable to study DM. However, the distances involved in strong-lensing systems are vast, and we expect the relevant volume to contain line-of-sight (LOS) halos that are not associated with the main lens. We develop a formalism to calculate the effect of LOS halos as an effective convergence power spectrum. The multi-lens plane equation couples the angular deflections of consecutive lens planes, but by assuming that the perturbations due to the LOS halos are small, we show that they can be projected onto the main-lens plane as effective subhalos. We test our formalism by simulating lensing systems using the full multi-plane lens equation and find excellent agreement. We show how the relative contribution of LOS halos and subhalos depends on the source and lens redshift, as well as the assumed halo and subhalo mass functions. For a fiducial system with fraction of DM halo mass in substructure $f_{\rm sub}=0.4\%$ for subhalo masses $[10^5-10^8]\rm{M}_{\odot}$, the interloper contribution to the power spectrum is at least several times greater than that of subhalos for source redshifts $z_s\gtrsim0.5$. Furthermore, it is likely that for the SLACS and BELLS lenses the interloper contribution dominates: $f_{\rm sub}\gtrsim2\%$ ($4\%$) is needed for subhalos to dominate in SLACS (BELLS), which is higher than current upper bounds on $f_{\rm sub}$ for our mass range. Since the halo mass function is better understood from first principles, the dominance of interlopers in galaxy-galaxy lenses with high-quality imaging can be seen as a significant advantage when translating this observable into a constraint on DM.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
