-
Impact of extended long-range electrostatics on the correlation of liquid-liquid equilibria in aqueous ionic liquid systems
Authors:
Hugo Marques,
Andrés González de Castilla,
Simon Müller,
Irina Smirnova
Abstract:
Recently an improved long-range model for electrolyte solutions was developed that is applicable from infinite dilution to pure salt. This paper tests this claim for the first time applying it to the calculation of liquid-liquid equilibria for mixtures of different ionic liquids (ILs) and water. The conventional Pitzer-Debye-Hückel (PDH) equation is compared to two of its new, thermodynamically co…
▽ More
Recently an improved long-range model for electrolyte solutions was developed that is applicable from infinite dilution to pure salt. This paper tests this claim for the first time applying it to the calculation of liquid-liquid equilibria for mixtures of different ionic liquids (ILs) and water. The conventional Pitzer-Debye-Hückel (PDH) equation is compared to two of its new, thermodynamically consistent extensions. Both development stages, the extended PDH term and the modified-extended PDH, account for concentration dependent mixture properties instead of using solvent properties. The latter one additionally introduces a modified parameter of closest approach which improves the overall performance of the model for high electrolyte concentrations in systems with variable or low permittivities. To account for the short-range interactions, these long-range models are coupled with the UNIversal QUAsi-Chemical (UNIQUAC) model. Three modeling strategies were tested for the short-range contribution. First, the UNIQUAC parameters were adjusted to each system individually, then the binary interaction parameters were the same for each binary interaction type for all the systems and lastly a linear function of the carbon number was used where possible. For all systems and all modeling strategies tested, the predictive performance increased from PDH to E-PDH and then to ME-PDH. Overall, an introduction of concentration dependent properties and the modification added to ME-PDH enhanced modeling performance when describing these systems, showing the general applicability of this novel long-range term.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 31 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
On the analogy between the restricted primitive model and capacitor circuits. Part II: A generalized Gibbs-Duhem consistent extension of the Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term with corrections for low and variable relative permittivity
Authors:
Andrés González de Castilla,
Simon Müller,
Irina Smirnova
Abstract:
We present a novel, thermodynamically consistent modification of the Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term and its extension for concentration dependent density, molar mass and relative permittivity. This extension is validated for ionic liquids by comparison with a reference model from the literature and, in contrast to similar extensions, also applied to conventional salts with small spherical ions in aqueou…
▽ More
We present a novel, thermodynamically consistent modification of the Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term and its extension for concentration dependent density, molar mass and relative permittivity. This extension is validated for ionic liquids by comparison with a reference model from the literature and, in contrast to similar extensions, also applied to conventional salts with small spherical ions in aqueous, mixed and non-aqueous solvents. The central novelty is the inclusion of a modified parameter of closest approach, which improves the overall qualitative performance of the Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term over the complete relative permittivity range. Gibbs-Duhem consistency is retained in the modified extension and sample calculations for aqueous [BMIM][BF4] and aqueous NaCl are provided. The novel, modified and extended term with concentration dependent properties is combined with the predictive COSMO-RS-ES model for the calculation of phase equilibria and activity coefficients in electrolytes with conventional salts. The performance of the COSMO-RS-ES model for predictions of salt solubility in fully non-aqueous media improves significantly upon introduction of concentration dependent properties within the long-range electrostatics. Modelling performance with the modified extended Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term outperforms modelling with the unmodified extension as well as with the conventional term with no extension. The correlated relative permittivity of the mixture is overestimated with respect to experimental values and kinetic depolarization effects provide a plausible explanation for this observation. Overall, our results support the consistent introduction of concentration dependent properties within the electrostatic theory in order to improve the modelling of electrolytes with particular emphasis on non-aqueous electrolytes.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
On the analogy between the restricted primitive model and capacitor circuits: Semi-empirical alternatives for over- and underscreening in the calculation of mean ionic activity coefficients
Authors:
Andrés González de Castilla,
Simon Müller,
Irina Smirnova
Abstract:
The analogy between the restricted primitive model and capacitor circuits, originally described decades ago for the Mean Spherical Approximation, is explored to demonstrate its transferability in linearized electrolyte theories. On this basis, we offer an explanation of why treating the salt diameter as a free adjustable parameter blurs differences between electrolyte theories in the calculation o…
▽ More
The analogy between the restricted primitive model and capacitor circuits, originally described decades ago for the Mean Spherical Approximation, is explored to demonstrate its transferability in linearized electrolyte theories. On this basis, we offer an explanation of why treating the salt diameter as a free adjustable parameter blurs differences between electrolyte theories in the calculation of mean ionic activity coefficients. Furthermore, a capacitor circuit analogy with an approximation of the Dressed Ion Theory is applied to develop a modified closest approach parameter "b" for the Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term. This modification is able to account for the qualitative effects of over- and underscreening in the calculation of mean ionic activity coefficients. This is achieved by defining "b" as a semi-empirical function that allows close resemblance with the multiple decay-length extension of the Debye-Hückel theory for high dielectric constant values and that lies close to recommended literature values of "b" for low dielectric constant values. Finally, as proof of principle, this modified semi-empirical Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term is implemented in the predictive COSMO-RS-ES model, an own reimplementation of the COSMO-RS theory developed for thermodynamic property calculations of electrolyte systems. It is shown that the modified semi-empirical Pitzer-Debye-Hückel term is an effective replacement for the recently published version of COSMO-RS-ES with explicit considerations for ion pairing. This reduces the modelling complexity by implicitly considering ion pairing and improves overall qualitative performance for the prediction of salt solubilities in mixed-solvent systems and even mean ionic activity coefficients in non-aqueous media.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Thermodynamic and Transport Properties Modeling of Deep Eutectic Solvents: A review on gE-models, equations of state and molecular dynamics
Authors:
Andrés González de Castilla,
Jan Philipp Bittner,
Simon Müller,
Sven Jakobtorweihen,
Irina Smirnova
Abstract:
Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have gained attention in recent years as attractive alternatives to traditional solvents. There is a growing number of publications dealing with the thermodynamic modeling of DESs highlighting the importance of modeling the solutions' properties. In this review, we summarize the state-of-the-art in DES modeling as well as its current challenges. We also summarize the…
▽ More
Deep eutectic solvents (DESs) have gained attention in recent years as attractive alternatives to traditional solvents. There is a growing number of publications dealing with the thermodynamic modeling of DESs highlighting the importance of modeling the solutions' properties. In this review, we summarize the state-of-the-art in DES modeling as well as its current challenges. We also summarize the various modeling approaches to phase equilibria and properties of DESs with gE-models, EOS and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. The current gE-model and EOS-based approaches handle DESs as pseudo-components in order to simplify the parameterizations and calculation strategies. However, for the models to become more transferable and predictive, it would be preferable to model the individual DES constituents instead of using the pseudo-components. This implies that validation with more detailed experimental data that includes the distribution of the DES components is also required. MD simulations, in contrast to gE-models and EOS, are capable of providing information about the liquid structure and can predict dynamic properties although, the latter quantities still show some imprecisions. Therefore, insights into the liquid structure of DES systems from MD could also aid in improving present modeling strategies in addition to a better understanding. Finally, the latest developments for DES force fields are discussed as the quality of the applied force fields determine the results of MD simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Calculation of Thermodynamic Equilibria with the Predictive Electrolyte Model COSMO-RS-ES: Improvements for Low Permittivity Systems
Authors:
Simon Müller,
Andrés González de Castilla,
Christoph Taeschler,
Andreas Klein,
Irina Smirnova
Abstract:
The predictive electrolyte model COSMO-RS-ES is refined to improve the description of systems at 25°C in which strong ion pairing is expected due to a low static permittivity of the liquid phase. Furthermore, the short-range ion energy interaction equations have been modified to better describe the misfit and energy interaction terms between ions and solvent molecules. In addition, the salt solubi…
▽ More
The predictive electrolyte model COSMO-RS-ES is refined to improve the description of systems at 25°C in which strong ion pairing is expected due to a low static permittivity of the liquid phase. Furthermore, the short-range ion energy interaction equations have been modified to better describe the misfit and energy interaction terms between ions and solvent molecules. In addition, the salt solubility database is extended with additional non-aqueous systems containing solvents that have a low (ε_s<15) dielectric constant and promote near to full ion association. Throughout this work it is demonstrated that liquid-liquid equilibrium calculations and solid-liquid equilibrium predictions for electrolyte systems can be markedly improved with the inclusion of Bjerrum treatment based phenomenological considerations while introducing only one general additional parameter. Our modified approach reinforces the capabilities of COSMO-RS ES as a powerful predictive tool for the calculation of phase equilibria in systems with scarce experimental data.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 29 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
