-
Extracting the X-ray reverberation response functions from the AGN light curves using an autoencoder
Authors:
Sanhanat Deesamutara,
Poemwai Chainakun,
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon,
Kamonwan Khanthasombat,
Wasutep Luangtip,
Jiachen Jiang,
Francisco Pozo Nuñez,
Andrew J. Young
Abstract:
We study the X-ray reverberation in active galactic nuclei (AGN) using the variational autoencoder (VAE), which is a machine-learning algorithm widely used for signal processing and feature reconstruction. While the X-ray reverberation signatures that contain the information of the accretion disk and the X-ray emitting corona are commonly analyzed in the Fourier domain, this work aims to extract t…
▽ More
We study the X-ray reverberation in active galactic nuclei (AGN) using the variational autoencoder (VAE), which is a machine-learning algorithm widely used for signal processing and feature reconstruction. While the X-ray reverberation signatures that contain the information of the accretion disk and the X-ray emitting corona are commonly analyzed in the Fourier domain, this work aims to extract the reverberation response functions directly from the AGN light curves. The VAE is trained using the simulated light curves that contain the primary X-rays from the lamp-post corona varying its height and the corresponding reflection X-rays from the disk. We use progressively more realistic light-curve models, such as those that include the effects of disk-propagating fluctuations and random noises, to assess the ability of the VAE to reconstruct the response profiles. Interestingly, the VAE can recognize the reverberation patterns on the light curves, hence the coronal height can be predicted. We then deploy the VAE model to the XMM-Newton data of IRAS 13224-3809 and directly estimate, for the first time, the response functions of this source in various observations. The result reveals the corona changing its height between $3~r_{\rm g}$ and $20~r_{\rm g}$, which is correlated with the source luminosity and in line with previous literature. Finally, we discuss the advantages and limitations of this method.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Bar instability and formation timescale across Toomre's $Q$ parameter and central mass concentration: slow bar formation or true stability
Authors:
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We investigate the bar formation process using $N$-body simulations across the Toomre's parameter $Q_{min}$ and central mass concentration (CMC), focusing principally on the formation timescale. Of importance is that, as suggested by cosmological simulations, disk galaxies have limited time of $\sim 8$ Gyr in the Universe timeline to evolve secularly, starting when they became physically and kinem…
▽ More
We investigate the bar formation process using $N$-body simulations across the Toomre's parameter $Q_{min}$ and central mass concentration (CMC), focusing principally on the formation timescale. Of importance is that, as suggested by cosmological simulations, disk galaxies have limited time of $\sim 8$ Gyr in the Universe timeline to evolve secularly, starting when they became physically and kinematically steady to prompt the bar instability. By incorporating this time limit, bar-unstable disks are further sub-divided into those that establish a bar before and after that time, namely the normal and the slowly bar-forming disks. Simulations demonstrate that evolutions of bar strengths and configurations of the slowly bar-forming and the bar-stable cases are nearly indistinguishable prior to $8$ Gyr, albeit dynamically distinct, while differences can be noticed afterwards. Differentiating them before $8$ Gyr is possible by identifying the proto-bar, a signature of bar development visible in kinematical maps such as the Fourier spectrogram and the angular velocity field, which emerges in the former group $1-2$ Gyr before the fully developed bar, whereas it is absent in the latter group until $8$ Gyr and such bar-stable disk remains unbarred until at least $10$ Gyr. In addition, we find complicated interplays between $Q_{min}$ and CMC in regulating the bar formation. Firstly, disk stabilization requires both high $Q_{min}$ and CMC. Either high $Q_{min}$ or high CMC only results in slow bar formation. Secondly, some hot disks can form a bar more rapidly than the colder ones in a specific range of $Q_{min}$ and CMC.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Violent relaxation in one-dimensional self-gravitating system: deviation from the Vlasov limit due to finite-$N$ effect
Authors:
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of a finite particle number $N$ on the violent relaxation leading to the Quasi-Stationary State (QSS) in a one-dimensional self-gravitating system. From the theoretical point of view, we demonstrate that the local Poissonian fluctuations embedded in the initial state give rise to an additional term proportional to $1/N$ in the Vlasov equation. This term designates the str…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of a finite particle number $N$ on the violent relaxation leading to the Quasi-Stationary State (QSS) in a one-dimensional self-gravitating system. From the theoretical point of view, we demonstrate that the local Poissonian fluctuations embedded in the initial state give rise to an additional term proportional to $1/N$ in the Vlasov equation. This term designates the strength of the local mean-field variations by fluctuations. Because it is of the mean-field origin, we interpret it differently from the known collision term in the way that it effects the violent relaxation stage. Its role is to deviate the distribution function from the Vlasov limit, in the collisionless manner, at a rate proportional to $1/N$ while the violent relaxation is progressing. This hypothesis is tested by inspecting the QSSs in simulations of various $N$. We observe that the core phase-space density can exceed the limiting density deduced from the Vlasov equation and its deviation degree is in accordance with the $1/N$ estimate. This indicates the deviation from the standard mean-field approximation of the violent relaxation process by that $1/N$ term. In conclusion, the finite-$N$ effect has a significant contribution to the QSS apart from that it plays a role in the collisional stage that takes place long after. The conventional collisionless Vlasov equation might not be able to describe the violent relaxation of a system of particles properly without the correction term of the local finite-$N$ fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Morphological evolution of disk galaxies and their concentration, asymmetry and clumpiness (CAS) properties in simulations across Toomre's $Q$ parameter
Authors:
Teeraparb Chantavat,
Suraphong Yuma,
Punnapha Malelohit,
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We investigate the morphological and structural evolutions of disk galaxies in simulations for a wide range of Toomre's $Q$ parameter. In addition to the inspection of conventional bar modes, we compute the concentration, asymmetry and clumpiness (CAS) parameters to enlarge the understanding of the galaxy evolution. These parameters are widely employed to analyze the light distribution of the obse…
▽ More
We investigate the morphological and structural evolutions of disk galaxies in simulations for a wide range of Toomre's $Q$ parameter. In addition to the inspection of conventional bar modes, we compute the concentration, asymmetry and clumpiness (CAS) parameters to enlarge the understanding of the galaxy evolution. These parameters are widely employed to analyze the light distribution of the observed galaxies, but the adaptation to numerical simulations is not much considered. While the bar formation takes place in a considerable range of $Q$ around $1$, barred galaxies originating from $Q>1$ and $Q<1$ disks yield the CAS values that differ significantly. Disks starting with $Q<1$ develop clumps due to local gravitational instabilities along with the bar and these clumps play a central role in enhancing the CAS values. That process is absent in $Q>1$ counterparts in which the evolution is dominated by linearly unstable two-armed modes that lead to lower CAS values. Likewise, unbarred galaxies that are obtainable from disks with $Q$ far below and far above $1$ exhibit greatly different CAS magnitudes. It turns out that the CAS parameters can serve as indicators of the initial kinematical state and the evolution history of a disk of any morphology. In addition, we find an alternative mechanism of the formation of the lopsided barred galaxy when $Q\lesssim 1$. Bars that evolve in the midst of the clumps can spontaneously become lopsided at the end.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Investigating scaling relations in X-ray reverberating AGN using symbolic regression
Authors:
P. Thongkonsing,
P. Chainakun,
T. Worrakitpoonpon,
A. J. Young
Abstract:
Symbolic regression (SR) is a regression analysis based on genetic algorithms to search for mathematical expressions that best fit a given data set, by allowing the expressions themselves to mutate. We use the SR to analyze the parameter relations of the X-ray reverberating Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) where the soft Fe-L lags were observed by XMM-Newton. Firstly, we revisit the lag-mass scaling r…
▽ More
Symbolic regression (SR) is a regression analysis based on genetic algorithms to search for mathematical expressions that best fit a given data set, by allowing the expressions themselves to mutate. We use the SR to analyze the parameter relations of the X-ray reverberating Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) where the soft Fe-L lags were observed by XMM-Newton. Firstly, we revisit the lag-mass scaling relations by using the SR to derive all possible mathematical expressions and test them in terms of accuracy, simplicity and robustness. We find that the correlation between the lags, $τ$, and the black hole mass, $M_{\rm BH}$, is certain, but the relation should be written in the form of $\log (τ) = α+ β(\log{(M_{\rm BH}/M_{\odot})})^γ$, where $1 \lesssim γ\lesssim 2$. Moreover, incorporating more parameters such as the reflection fraction ($RF$) and the Eddington ratio ($λ_{\rm Edd}$) to the lag-mass scaling relation is made possible by the SR. It reveals that $α$, rather than being a constant, can be $-2.15 + 0.02RF$ or $0.03(RF + λ_{\rm Edd})$, with the fine-tuned different $β$ and $γ$. These further support the relativistic disc-reflection framework in which such functional dependencies can be straightforwardly explained. Furthermore, we derive their host-galaxy mass, $M_{\ast}$, by fitting the spectral energy distribution (SED). We find that the SR model supports a non-linear $M_{\rm BH}$--$M_{\ast}$ relationship, while $\log (M_{\rm BH}/M_{\ast})$ varies between $-5.4$ and $-1.5$, with an average value of $\sim -3.7$. No significant correlation between $M_{\ast}$ and $λ_{\rm Edd}$ is confirmed in these samples.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Dynamical analysis of Maclaurin disk with velocity dispersion and its influence on bar formation
Authors:
T. Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We investigate the influence of Toomre's $Q$ parameter on the bar-forming dynamics of Maclaurin disk using $N$-body simulations. According to the Toomre's criterion, local velocity dispersion parametrized by $Q\geq 1$ is required to suppress the local axisymmetric instability but, in turn, it deviates particle orbits from nearly circular limit in which particle natural frequencies are calculated.…
▽ More
We investigate the influence of Toomre's $Q$ parameter on the bar-forming dynamics of Maclaurin disk using $N$-body simulations. According to the Toomre's criterion, local velocity dispersion parametrized by $Q\geq 1$ is required to suppress the local axisymmetric instability but, in turn, it deviates particle orbits from nearly circular limit in which particle natural frequencies are calculated. We resolve this by including the effect of velocity dispersion, as the pressure potential, into the effective potential with the gravitational potential. With this formulation, circular orbit approximation is retrieved. The effective potential hypothesis can describe the $Q$-dependences of angular and epicyclic motions of the bar-forming processes and the established bars reasonably well provided that $Q\geq 1$. This indicates the influence of initial $Q$ that is imprinted in the entire disk dynamics, not only that $Q$ serves as the stability indicator. In addition, we perform the stability test for the disk-in-halo systems. With the presence of halo, disks are more susceptible to the bar formation as seen by the elevated critical $Q$ than that for the isolated disk. This is attributed to the differential rotation that builds the unstable non-axisymmetric spiral modes more efficiently which are the ingredients of bar instability.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Formation of spiral structure from the violent relaxation of self-gravitating disks
Authors:
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We present the numerical study of the formation of spiral structure in the context of violent relaxation. Initial conditions are the out-of-equilibrium disks of self-gravitating particles in rigid rotation. By that mechanism, robust and non-stationary spiral arms can be formed within a few free-fall times by the shearing of the mass ejection following the collapse. With a closer look, we find diff…
▽ More
We present the numerical study of the formation of spiral structure in the context of violent relaxation. Initial conditions are the out-of-equilibrium disks of self-gravitating particles in rigid rotation. By that mechanism, robust and non-stationary spiral arms can be formed within a few free-fall times by the shearing of the mass ejection following the collapse. With a closer look, we find different properties of the arms in connection with the initial configuration. The winding degree tends to increase with initial angular speed provided that a disk is thin. If disk surface is circular, both number and position of arms are governed by the Poissonian density fluctuations that produce more arms as more particles are introduced. On the contrary, if the surface ellipticity is imposed, the number of arms and their placement are effectively controlled. Otherwise, the increase of thickness leads to a complicated outcome since the number of arms and winding degree are less effectively controlled. We speculate that this complexity is caused by a strong non-axisymmetric field during the violent relaxation that disorganizes the pre-collapse motion and the concentration of particles.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Limitation of symmetry breaking by gravitational collapse: the revisit of Lin-Mestel-Shu instability
Authors:
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We revisit the topic of shape evolution during the spherical collapse of an $N$-body system. Our main objective is to investigate the critical particle number below which, during a gravitational collapse, the amplification of triaxiality from initial fluctuations is effective, and above which it is ineffective. To this aim, we develop the Lin-Mestel-Shu theory for a system of particles initially w…
▽ More
We revisit the topic of shape evolution during the spherical collapse of an $N$-body system. Our main objective is to investigate the critical particle number below which, during a gravitational collapse, the amplification of triaxiality from initial fluctuations is effective, and above which it is ineffective. To this aim, we develop the Lin-Mestel-Shu theory for a system of particles initially with isotropic velocity dispersion and with a simple power-law density profile. We first determine, for an unstable cloud, two radii corresponding to the balance of two opposing forces and their fluctuations: such radii fix the sizes of the non-collapsing region and the triaxial seed from density fluctuations. We hypothesize that the triaxial degree of the final state depends on which radius is dominant prior to the collapse phase leading to a different scheme of the self-consistent shape evolution of the core and the rest of the system. The condition where the two radii are equal therefore identifies the critical particle number, which can be expressed as the function of the parameters of initial state. In numerical work, we can pinpoint such a critical number by comparing the virialized flattening with the initial flattening. The difference between these two quantities agrees with the theoretical predictions only for the power-law density profiles with an exponent in the range $[0,0.25]$. For higher exponents, results suggest that the critical number is above the range of simulated $N$. We speculate that there is an additional mechanism, related to strong density gradients that increases further the flattening, requiring higher $N$ to further weaken the initial fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Particle number dependence in the non-linear evolution of N-body self-gravitating systems
Authors:
David Benhaiem,
Michael Joyce,
Francesco Sylos Labini,
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
Simulations of purely self-gravitating N-body systems are often used in astrophysics and cosmology to study the collisionless limit of such systems. Their results for macroscopic quantities should then converge well for sufficiently large N. Using a study of the evolution from a simple space of spherical initial conditions - including a region characterised by so-called "radial orbit instability"…
▽ More
Simulations of purely self-gravitating N-body systems are often used in astrophysics and cosmology to study the collisionless limit of such systems. Their results for macroscopic quantities should then converge well for sufficiently large N. Using a study of the evolution from a simple space of spherical initial conditions - including a region characterised by so-called "radial orbit instability" - we illustrate that the values of N at which such convergence is obtained can vary enormously. In the family of initial conditions we study, good convergence can be obtained up to a few dynamical times with N $ \sim 10^3$ - just large enough to suppress two body relaxation - for certain initial conditions, while in other cases such convergence is not attained at this time even in our largest simulations with N $\sim 10^5$. The qualitative difference is due to the stability properties of fluctuations introduced by the N-body discretisation, of which the initial amplitude depends on N. We discuss briefly why the crucial role which such fluctuations can potentially play in the evolution of the N-body system could, in particular, constitute a serious problem in cosmological simulations of dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Angular momentum generation in cold gravitational collapse
Authors:
D. Benhaiem,
M. Joyce,
F. Sylos Labini,
T. Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
During the violent relaxation of a self-gravitating system a significant fraction of its mass may be ejected. If the time varying gravitational field also breaks spherical symmetry this mass can potentially carry angular momentum. Thus starting initial configurations with zero angular momentum can in principle lead to a bound virialized system with non-zero angular momentum. We explore here, using…
▽ More
During the violent relaxation of a self-gravitating system a significant fraction of its mass may be ejected. If the time varying gravitational field also breaks spherical symmetry this mass can potentially carry angular momentum. Thus starting initial configurations with zero angular momentum can in principle lead to a bound virialized system with non-zero angular momentum. We explore here, using numerical simulations, how much angular momentum can be generated in a virialized structure in this way, starting from configurations of cold particles which are very close to spherically symmetric. For initial configurations in which spherical symmetry is broken only by the Poissonian fluctuations associated with the finite particle number $N$, with $N$ in range $10^3$ to $10^5$, we find that the relaxed structures have standard "spin" parameters $λ\sim 10^{-3}$, and decreasing slowly with $N$. For slightly ellipsoidal initial conditions, in which the finite-$N$ fluctuations break the residual reflection symmetries, we observe values $λ\sim 10^{-2}$, of the same order of magnitude as those reported for elliptical galaxies. The net angular momentum vector is typically aligned close to normal to the major semi-axis of the triaxial relaxed structure, and also with that of the ejected mass. This simple mechanism may provide an alternative, or complement, to "tidal torque theory" for understanding the origin of angular momentum in astrophysical structures.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2015; v1 submitted 13 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Spherical symmetry breaking in cold gravitational collapse of isolated systems
Authors:
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We study, using $N$-body simulation, the shape evolution in gravitational collapse of cold uniform spherical system. The central interest is on how the deviation from spherical symmetry depends on particle number $N$. By revisit of the spherical collapse model, we hypothesize that the departure from spherical symmetry is regulated by the finite-$N$ density fluctuation. Following this assumption, t…
▽ More
We study, using $N$-body simulation, the shape evolution in gravitational collapse of cold uniform spherical system. The central interest is on how the deviation from spherical symmetry depends on particle number $N$. By revisit of the spherical collapse model, we hypothesize that the departure from spherical symmetry is regulated by the finite-$N$ density fluctuation. Following this assumption, the estimate of the flattening of relaxed structures is derived to be $N^{-1/3}$. In numerical part, we find that the virialized states can be characterized by the core-halo structures and the flattenings of the cores fit reasonably well with the prediction. Moreover the results from large $N$ systems suggest the divergence of relaxation time to the final shapes with $N$.We also find that the intrinsic shapes of the cores are considerably diverse as they vary from nearly spherical, prolate, oblate or completely triaxial in each realization. When $N$ increases, this variation is suppressed as the final shapes do not differ much from initial symmetry. In addition, we observe the stable rotation of the virialized states. Further investigation reveals that the origin of this rotation is related in some way to the initial density fluctuation.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2014; v1 submitted 15 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Quasi-stationary states in the self-gravitating sheet model
Authors:
Michael Joyce,
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We study quasi-stationary states (QSS) resulting from violent relaxation in the one-dimensional self-gravitating "sheet model", revisiting in particular the question of the adequacy of the theory of Lynden-Bell (LB) to describe them. For "waterbag" initial conditions characterized by a single phase space density, the prediction of this theory is, in this model, a function of only one parameter, wh…
▽ More
We study quasi-stationary states (QSS) resulting from violent relaxation in the one-dimensional self-gravitating "sheet model", revisiting in particular the question of the adequacy of the theory of Lynden-Bell (LB) to describe them. For "waterbag" initial conditions characterized by a single phase space density, the prediction of this theory is, in this model, a function of only one parameter, which can conveniently be chosen to be the ratio of the energy to that in the degenerate limit. Studying a class of such initial conditions in which the shape of the initial waterbag is varied, we find that the LB predictions are reasonably good always in the low energy region, while at higher energies (i.e. in the non-degenerate limit) they are generally not even qualitatively correct, although certain initial conditions can still be found where they are as good as at low energy. We find notably that, in line with what has been observed by Levin et al. in some other models, when LB theory does not work the QSS are always characterized by the presence of a {\it degenerate} core, which these authors explain as the result of dynamical resonances. In short LB theory appears to be a good approximation only when violent relaxation is sufficiently "gentle", and otherwise a degenerate core-halo structure results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2011; v1 submitted 22 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
Relaxation to thermal equilibrium in the self-gravitating sheet model
Authors:
Michael Joyce,
Tirawut Worrakitpoonpon
Abstract:
We revisit the issue of relaxation to thermal equilibrium in the so-called "sheet model", i.e., particles in one dimension interacting by attractive forces independent of their separation. We show that this relaxation may be very clearly detected and characterized by following the evolution of order parameters defined by appropriately normalized moments of the phase space distribution which probe…
▽ More
We revisit the issue of relaxation to thermal equilibrium in the so-called "sheet model", i.e., particles in one dimension interacting by attractive forces independent of their separation. We show that this relaxation may be very clearly detected and characterized by following the evolution of order parameters defined by appropriately normalized moments of the phase space distribution which probe its entanglement in space and velocity coordinates. For a class of quasi-stationary states which result from the violent relaxation of rectangular waterbag initial conditions, characterized by their virial ratio R_0, we show that relaxation occurs on a time scale which (i) scales approximately linearly in the particle number N, and (ii) shows also a strong dependence on R_0, with quasi-stationary states from colder initial conditions relaxing much more rapidly. The temporal evolution of the order parameter may be well described by a stretched exponential function. We study finally the correlation of the relaxation times with the amplitude of fluctuations in the relaxing quasi-stationary states, as well as the relation between temporal and ensemble averages.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2010; v1 submitted 13 April, 2010;
originally announced April 2010.
