-
Real-World Deployment and Assessment of a Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning-Based Variable Speed Limit Control System
Authors:
Yuhang Zhang,
Zhiyao Zhang,
Junyi Ji,
Marcos Quiñones-Grueiro,
William Barbour,
Derek Gloudemans,
Gergely Zachár,
Clay Weston,
Gautam Biswas,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This article presents the first field deployment of a multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) based variable speed limit (VSL) control system on Interstate 24 (I-24) near Nashville, Tennessee. We design and demonstrate a full pipeline from training MARL agents in a traffic simulator to a field deployment on a 17-mile segment of I-24 encompassing 67 VSL controllers. The system was launched on Mar…
▽ More
This article presents the first field deployment of a multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) based variable speed limit (VSL) control system on Interstate 24 (I-24) near Nashville, Tennessee. We design and demonstrate a full pipeline from training MARL agents in a traffic simulator to a field deployment on a 17-mile segment of I-24 encompassing 67 VSL controllers. The system was launched on March 8th, 2024, and has made approximately 35 million decisions on 28 million trips in six months of operation. We apply an invalid action masking mechanism and several safety guards to ensure real-world constraints. The MARL-based implementation operates up to 98% of the time, with the safety guards overriding the MARL decisions for the remaining time. We evaluate the performance of the MARL-based algorithm in comparison to a previously deployed non-RL VSL benchmark algorithm on I-24. Results show that the MARL-based VSL control system achieves a superior performance. The accuracy of correctly warning drivers about slowing traffic ahead is improved by 14% and the response delay to non-recurrent congestion is reduced by 75%. The preliminary data shows that the VSL control system has reduced the crash rate by 26% and the secondary crash rate by 50%. We open-sourced the deployed MARL-based VSL algorithm at https://github.com/Lab-Work/marl-vsl-controller.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Scalable analysis of stop-and-go waves
Authors:
Junyi Ji,
Derek Gloudemans,
Yanbing Wang,
Gergely Zachár,
William Barbour,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Analyzing stop-and-go waves at the scale of miles and hours of data is an emerging challenge in traffic research. In the past, datasets were of limited scale and could be easily analyzed by hand or with rudimentary methods to identify a very limited set of traffic waves present within the data. This paper introduces an automatic and scalable stop-and-go wave identification method capable of captur…
▽ More
Analyzing stop-and-go waves at the scale of miles and hours of data is an emerging challenge in traffic research. In the past, datasets were of limited scale and could be easily analyzed by hand or with rudimentary methods to identify a very limited set of traffic waves present within the data. This paper introduces an automatic and scalable stop-and-go wave identification method capable of capturing wave generation, propagation, dissipation, as well as bifurcation and merging, which have previously been observed only very rarely. Using a concise and simple critical-speed based definition of a stop-and-go wave, the proposed method identifies all wave boundaries that encompass spatio-temporal points where vehicle speed is below a chosen critical speed. The method is built upon a graph-based representation of the spatio-temporal points associated with stop-and-go waves, specifically wave front (start) points and wave tail (end) points, and approaches the solution as a graph component identification problem. The method is implemented in Python and demonstrated on a large-scale dataset, I-24 MOTION INCEPTION. New insights revealed from this demonstration with emerging phenomena include: (a) we demonstrate that waves do generate, propagate, and dissipate at a scale (miles and hours) and ubiquity never observed before; (b) wave fronts and tails travels at a consistent speed for a critical speed between 10-20 mph, with propagation variation across lanes, where wave speed on the outer lane are less consistent compared to those on the inner lane; (c) wave fronts and tails propagate at different speeds; (d) wave boundaries capture rich and non-trivial wave topologies, highlighting the complexity of waves.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Stop-and-go wave super-resolution reconstruction via iterative refinement
Authors:
Junyi Ji,
Alex Richardson,
Derek Gloudemans,
Gergely Zachár,
Matthew Nice,
William Barbour,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Stop-and-go waves are a fundamental phenomenon in freeway traffic flow, contributing to inefficiencies, crashes, and emissions. Recent advancements in high-fidelity sensor technologies have improved the ability to capture detailed traffic dynamics, yet such systems remain scarce and costly. In contrast, conventional traffic sensors are widely deployed but suffer from relatively coarse-grain data r…
▽ More
Stop-and-go waves are a fundamental phenomenon in freeway traffic flow, contributing to inefficiencies, crashes, and emissions. Recent advancements in high-fidelity sensor technologies have improved the ability to capture detailed traffic dynamics, yet such systems remain scarce and costly. In contrast, conventional traffic sensors are widely deployed but suffer from relatively coarse-grain data resolution, potentially impeding accurate analysis of stop-and-go waves. This article explores whether generative AI models can enhance the resolution of conventional traffic sensor to approximate the quality of high-fidelity observations. We present a novel approach using a conditional diffusion denoising model, designed to reconstruct fine-grained traffic speed field from radar-based conventional sensors via iterative refinement. We introduce a new dataset, I24-WaveX, comprising 132 hours of data from both low and high-fidelity sensor systems, totaling over 2 million vehicle miles traveled. Our approach leverages this dataset to formulate the traffic measurement enhancement problem as a spatio-temporal super-resolution task. We demonstrate that our model can effectively reproduce the patterns of stop-and-go waves, achieving high accuracy in capturing these critical traffic dynamics. Our results show promising advancements in traffic data enhancement, offering a cost-effective way to leverage existing low spatio-temporal resolution sensor networks for improved traffic analysis and management. We also open-sourced our trained model and code to facilitate further research and applications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2025; v1 submitted 1 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Phase Re-service in Reinforcement Learning Traffic Signal Control
Authors:
Zhiyao Zhang,
George Gunter,
Marcos Quinones-Grueiro,
Yuhang Zhang,
William Barbour,
Gautam Biswas,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
This article proposes a novel approach to traffic signal control that combines phase re-service with reinforcement learning (RL). The RL agent directly determines the duration of the next phase in a pre-defined sequence. Before the RL agent's decision is executed, we use the shock wave theory to estimate queue expansion at the designated movement allowed for re-service and decide if phase re-servi…
▽ More
This article proposes a novel approach to traffic signal control that combines phase re-service with reinforcement learning (RL). The RL agent directly determines the duration of the next phase in a pre-defined sequence. Before the RL agent's decision is executed, we use the shock wave theory to estimate queue expansion at the designated movement allowed for re-service and decide if phase re-service is necessary. If necessary, a temporary phase re-service is inserted before the next regular phase. We formulate the RL problem as a semi-Markov decision process (SMDP) and solve it with proximal policy optimization (PPO). We conducted a series of experiments that showed significant improvements thanks to the introduction of phase re-service. Vehicle delays are reduced by up to 29.95% of the average and up to 59.21% of the standard deviation. The number of stops is reduced by 26.05% on average with 45.77% less standard deviation.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2024; v1 submitted 20 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Field Deployment of Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Based Variable Speed Limit Controllers
Authors:
Yuhang Zhang,
Zhiyao Zhang,
Marcos Quiñones-Grueiro,
William Barbour,
Clay Weston,
Gautam Biswas,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
This article presents the first field deployment of a multi-agent reinforcement-learning (MARL) based variable speed limit (VSL) control system on the I-24 freeway near Nashville, Tennessee. We describe how we train MARL agents in a traffic simulator and directly deploy the simulation-based policy on a 17-mile stretch of Interstate 24 with 67 VSL controllers. We use invalid action masking and seve…
▽ More
This article presents the first field deployment of a multi-agent reinforcement-learning (MARL) based variable speed limit (VSL) control system on the I-24 freeway near Nashville, Tennessee. We describe how we train MARL agents in a traffic simulator and directly deploy the simulation-based policy on a 17-mile stretch of Interstate 24 with 67 VSL controllers. We use invalid action masking and several safety guards to ensure the posted speed limits satisfy the real-world constraints from the traffic management center and the Tennessee Department of Transportation. Since the time of launch of the system through April, 2024, the system has made approximately 10,000,000 decisions on 8,000,000 trips. The analysis of the controller shows that the MARL policy takes control for up to 98% of the time without intervention from safety guards. The time-space diagrams of traffic speed and control commands illustrate how the algorithm behaves during rush hour. Finally, we quantify the domain mismatch between the simulation and real-world data and demonstrate the robustness of the MARL policy to this mismatch.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
FT-AED: Benchmark Dataset for Early Freeway Traffic Anomalous Event Detection
Authors:
Austin Coursey,
Junyi Ji,
Marcos Quinones-Grueiro,
William Barbour,
Yuhang Zhang,
Tyler Derr,
Gautam Biswas,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Early and accurate detection of anomalous events on the freeway, such as accidents, can improve emergency response and clearance. However, existing delays and errors in event identification and reporting make it a difficult problem to solve. Current large-scale freeway traffic datasets are not designed for anomaly detection and ignore these challenges. In this paper, we introduce the first large-s…
▽ More
Early and accurate detection of anomalous events on the freeway, such as accidents, can improve emergency response and clearance. However, existing delays and errors in event identification and reporting make it a difficult problem to solve. Current large-scale freeway traffic datasets are not designed for anomaly detection and ignore these challenges. In this paper, we introduce the first large-scale lane-level freeway traffic dataset for anomaly detection. Our dataset consists of a month of weekday radar detection sensor data collected in 4 lanes along an 18-mile stretch of Interstate 24 heading toward Nashville, TN, comprising over 3.7 million sensor measurements. We also collect official crash reports from the Nashville Traffic Management Center and manually label all other potential anomalies in the dataset. To show the potential for our dataset to be used in future machine learning and traffic research, we benchmark numerous deep learning anomaly detection models on our dataset. We find that unsupervised graph neural network autoencoders are a promising solution for this problem and that ignoring spatial relationships leads to decreased performance. We demonstrate that our methods can reduce reporting delays by over 10 minutes on average while detecting 75% of crashes. Our dataset and all preprocessing code needed to get started are publicly released at https://vu.edu/ft-aed/ to facilitate future research.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024; v1 submitted 21 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Designing, simulating, and performing the 100-AV field test for the CIRCLES consortium: Methodology and Implementation of the Largest mobile traffic control experiment to date
Authors:
Mostafa Ameli,
Sean Mcquade,
Jonathan W. Lee,
Matthew Bunting,
Matthew Nice,
Han Wang,
William Barbour,
Ryan Weightman,
Chris Denaro,
Ryan Delorenzo,
Sharon Hornstein,
Jon F. Davis,
Dan Timsit,
Riley Wagner,
Rita Xu,
Malaika Mahmood,
Mikail Mahmood,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Benjamin Seibold,
Daniel B. Work,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Alexandre M. Bayen
Abstract:
Previous controlled experiments on single-lane ring roads have shown that a single partially autonomous vehicle (AV) can effectively mitigate traffic waves. This naturally prompts the question of how these findings can be generalized to field operational, high-density traffic conditions. To address this question, the Congestion Impacts Reduction via CAV-in-the-loop Lagrangian Energy Smoothing (CIR…
▽ More
Previous controlled experiments on single-lane ring roads have shown that a single partially autonomous vehicle (AV) can effectively mitigate traffic waves. This naturally prompts the question of how these findings can be generalized to field operational, high-density traffic conditions. To address this question, the Congestion Impacts Reduction via CAV-in-the-loop Lagrangian Energy Smoothing (CIRCLES) Consortium conducted MegaVanderTest (MVT), a live traffic control experiment involving 100 vehicles near Nashville, TN, USA. This article is a tutorial for developing analytical and simulation-based tools essential for designing and executing a live traffic control experiment like the MVT. It presents an overview of the proposed roadmap and various procedures used in designing, monitoring, and conducting the MVT, which is the largest mobile traffic control experiment at the time. The design process is aimed at evaluating the impact of the CIRCLES AVs on surrounding traffic. The article discusses the agent-based traffic simulation framework created for this evaluation. A novel methodological framework is introduced to calibrate this microsimulation, aiming to accurately capture traffic dynamics and assess the impact of adding 100 vehicles to existing traffic. The calibration model's effectiveness is verified using data from a six-mile section of Nashville's I-24 highway. The results indicate that the proposed model establishes an effective feedback loop between the optimizer and the simulator, thereby calibrating flow and speed with different spatiotemporal characteristics to minimize the error between simulated and real-world data. Finally, We simulate AVs in multiple scenarios to assess their effect on traffic congestion. This evaluation validates the AV routes, thereby contributing to the execution of a safe and successful live traffic control experiment via AVs.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Reinforcement Learning Based Oscillation Dampening: Scaling up Single-Agent RL algorithms to a 100 AV highway field operational test
Authors:
Kathy Jang,
Nathan Lichtlé,
Eugene Vinitsky,
Adit Shah,
Matthew Bunting,
Matthew Nice,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Benjamin Seibold,
Daniel B. Work,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Jonathan W. Lee,
Alexandre M. Bayen
Abstract:
In this article, we explore the technical details of the reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms that were deployed in the largest field test of automated vehicles designed to smooth traffic flow in history as of 2023, uncovering the challenges and breakthroughs that come with developing RL controllers for automated vehicles. We delve into the fundamental concepts behind RL algorithms and their app…
▽ More
In this article, we explore the technical details of the reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms that were deployed in the largest field test of automated vehicles designed to smooth traffic flow in history as of 2023, uncovering the challenges and breakthroughs that come with developing RL controllers for automated vehicles. We delve into the fundamental concepts behind RL algorithms and their application in the context of self-driving cars, discussing the developmental process from simulation to deployment in detail, from designing simulators to reward function shaping. We present the results in both simulation and deployment, discussing the flow-smoothing benefits of the RL controller. From understanding the basics of Markov decision processes to exploring advanced techniques such as deep RL, our article offers a comprehensive overview and deep dive of the theoretical foundations and practical implementations driving this rapidly evolving field. We also showcase real-world case studies and alternative research projects that highlight the impact of RL controllers in revolutionizing autonomous driving. From tackling complex urban environments to dealing with unpredictable traffic scenarios, these intelligent controllers are pushing the boundaries of what automated vehicles can achieve. Furthermore, we examine the safety considerations and hardware-focused technical details surrounding deployment of RL controllers into automated vehicles. As these algorithms learn and evolve through interactions with the environment, ensuring their behavior aligns with safety standards becomes crucial. We explore the methodologies and frameworks being developed to address these challenges, emphasizing the importance of building reliable control systems for automated vehicles.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 26 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Traffic Control via Connected and Automated Vehicles: An Open-Road Field Experiment with 100 CAVs
Authors:
Jonathan W. Lee,
Han Wang,
Kathy Jang,
Amaury Hayat,
Matthew Bunting,
Arwa Alanqary,
William Barbour,
Zhe Fu,
Xiaoqian Gong,
George Gunter,
Sharon Hornstein,
Abdul Rahman Kreidieh,
Nathan Lichtlé,
Matthew W. Nice,
William A. Richardson,
Adit Shah,
Eugene Vinitsky,
Fangyu Wu,
Shengquan Xiang,
Sulaiman Almatrudi,
Fahd Althukair,
Rahul Bhadani,
Joy Carpio,
Raphael Chekroun,
Eric Cheng
, et al. (39 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The CIRCLES project aims to reduce instabilities in traffic flow, which are naturally occurring phenomena due to human driving behavior. These "phantom jams" or "stop-and-go waves,"are a significant source of wasted energy. Toward this goal, the CIRCLES project designed a control system referred to as the MegaController by the CIRCLES team, that could be deployed in real traffic. Our field experim…
▽ More
The CIRCLES project aims to reduce instabilities in traffic flow, which are naturally occurring phenomena due to human driving behavior. These "phantom jams" or "stop-and-go waves,"are a significant source of wasted energy. Toward this goal, the CIRCLES project designed a control system referred to as the MegaController by the CIRCLES team, that could be deployed in real traffic. Our field experiment leveraged a heterogeneous fleet of 100 longitudinally-controlled vehicles as Lagrangian traffic actuators, each of which ran a controller with the architecture described in this paper. The MegaController is a hierarchical control architecture, which consists of two main layers. The upper layer is called Speed Planner, and is a centralized optimal control algorithm. It assigns speed targets to the vehicles, conveyed through the LTE cellular network. The lower layer is a control layer, running on each vehicle. It performs local actuation by overriding the stock adaptive cruise controller, using the stock on-board sensors. The Speed Planner ingests live data feeds provided by third parties, as well as data from our own control vehicles, and uses both to perform the speed assignment. The architecture of the speed planner allows for modular use of standard control techniques, such as optimal control, model predictive control, kernel methods and others, including Deep RL, model predictive control and explicit controllers. Depending on the vehicle architecture, all onboard sensing data can be accessed by the local controllers, or only some. Control inputs vary across different automakers, with inputs ranging from torque or acceleration requests for some cars, and electronic selection of ACC set points in others. The proposed architecture allows for the combination of all possible settings proposed above. Most configurations were tested throughout the ramp up to the MegaVandertest.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Hierarchical Speed Planner for Automated Vehicles: A Framework for Lagrangian Variable Speed Limit in Mixed Autonomy Traffic
Authors:
Han Wang,
Zhe Fu,
Jonathan Lee,
Hossein Nick Zinat Matin,
Arwa Alanqary,
Daniel Urieli,
Sharon Hornstein,
Abdul Rahman Kreidieh,
Raphael Chekroun,
William Barbour,
William A. Richardson,
Dan Work,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Benjamin Seibold,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Alexandre M. Bayen,
Maria Laura Delle Monache
Abstract:
This paper introduces a novel control framework for Lagrangian variable speed limits in hybrid traffic flow environments utilizing automated vehicles (AVs). The framework was validated using a fleet of 100 connected automated vehicles as part of the largest coordinated open-road test designed to smooth traffic flow. The framework includes two main components: a high-level controller deployed on th…
▽ More
This paper introduces a novel control framework for Lagrangian variable speed limits in hybrid traffic flow environments utilizing automated vehicles (AVs). The framework was validated using a fleet of 100 connected automated vehicles as part of the largest coordinated open-road test designed to smooth traffic flow. The framework includes two main components: a high-level controller deployed on the server side, named Speed Planner, and low-level controllers called vehicle controllers deployed on the vehicle side. The Speed Planner designs and updates target speeds for the vehicle controllers based on real-time Traffic State Estimation (TSE) [1]. The Speed Planner comprises two modules: a TSE enhancement module and a target speed design module. The TSE enhancement module is designed to minimize the effects of inherent latency in the received traffic information and to improve the spatial and temporal resolution of the input traffic data. The target speed design module generates target speed profiles with the goal of improving traffic flow. The vehicle controllers are designed to track the target speed meanwhile responding to the surrounding situation. The numerical simulation indicates the performance of the proposed method: the bottleneck throughput has increased by 5.01%, and the speed standard deviation has been reduced by a significant 34.36%. We further showcase an operational study with a description of how the controller was implemented on a field-test with 100 AVs and its comprehensive effects on the traffic flow.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
A Middle Way to Traffic Enlightenment
Authors:
Matthew W. Nice,
George Gunter,
Junyi Ji,
Yuhang Zhang,
Matthew Bunting,
Will Barbour,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Dan Work
Abstract:
This paper introduces a novel approach that seeks a middle ground for traffic control in multi-lane congestion, where prevailing traffic speeds are too fast, and speed recommendations designed to dampen traffic waves are too slow. Advanced controllers that modify the speed of an automated car for wave-dampening, eco-driving, or other goals, typically are designed with forward collision safety in m…
▽ More
This paper introduces a novel approach that seeks a middle ground for traffic control in multi-lane congestion, where prevailing traffic speeds are too fast, and speed recommendations designed to dampen traffic waves are too slow. Advanced controllers that modify the speed of an automated car for wave-dampening, eco-driving, or other goals, typically are designed with forward collision safety in mind. Our approach goes further, by considering how dangerous it can be for a controller to drive so slowly relative to prevailing traffic that it creates a significant issue for safety and comfort. This paper explores open-road scenarios where large gaps between prevailing speeds and desired speeds can exist, specifically when infrastructure-based variable speed limit systems are not strictly followed at all times by other drivers. Our designed, implemented, and deployed algorithm is able to follow variable speed limits when others also follow it, avoid collisions with vehicles ahead, and adapt to prevailing traffic when other motorists are traveling well above the posted speeds. The key is to reject unsafe speed recommendations from infrastructure-based traffic smoothing systems, based on real-time local traffic conditions observed by the vehicle under control. This solution is implemented and deployed on two control vehicles in heavy multi-lane highway congestion. The results include analysis from system design, and field tests that validate the system's performance using an existing Variable Speed Limit system as the external source for speed recommendations, and the on-board sensors of a stock Toyota Rav4 for inputs that estimate the prevailing speed of traffic around the vehicle under control.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
On the Constrained CAV Platoon Control Problem
Authors:
MirSaleh Bahavarnia,
Junyi Ji,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
The main objective of the connected and automated vehicle (CAV) platoon control problem is to regulate CAVs' position while ensuring stability and accounting for vehicle dynamics. Although this problem has been studied in the literature, existing research has some limitations. This paper presents two new theoretical results that address these limitations: (i) the synthesis of unrealistic high-gain…
▽ More
The main objective of the connected and automated vehicle (CAV) platoon control problem is to regulate CAVs' position while ensuring stability and accounting for vehicle dynamics. Although this problem has been studied in the literature, existing research has some limitations. This paper presents two new theoretical results that address these limitations: (i) the synthesis of unrealistic high-gain control parameters due to the lack of a systematic way to incorporate the lower and upper bounds on the control parameters, and (ii) the performance sensitivity to the communication delay due to inaccurate Taylor series approximation. To be more precise, taking advantage of the wellknown Pade approximation, this paper proposes a constrained CAV platoon controller synthesis that (i) systematically incorporates the lower and upper bounds on the control parameters, and (ii) significantly improves the performance sensitivity to the communication delay. The effectiveness of the presented results is verified through conducting extensive numerical simulations. The proposed controller effectively attenuates the stop-and-go disturbance -- a single cycle of deceleration followed by acceleration -- amplification throughout the mixed platoon (consisting of CAVs and human-driven vehicles). Modern transportation systems will benefit from the proposed CAV controls in terms of effective disturbance attenuation as it will potentially reduce collisions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2024; v1 submitted 24 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Virtual trajectories for I-24 MOTION: data and tools
Authors:
Junyi Ji,
Yanbing Wang,
Derek Gloudemans,
Gergely Zachár,
William Barbour,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This article introduces a new virtual trajectory dataset derived from the I-24 MOTION INCEPTION v1.0.0 dataset to address challenges in analyzing large but noisy trajectory datasets. Building on the concept of virtual trajectories, we provide a Python implementation to generate virtual trajectories from large raw datasets that are typically challenging to process due to their size. We demonstrate…
▽ More
This article introduces a new virtual trajectory dataset derived from the I-24 MOTION INCEPTION v1.0.0 dataset to address challenges in analyzing large but noisy trajectory datasets. Building on the concept of virtual trajectories, we provide a Python implementation to generate virtual trajectories from large raw datasets that are typically challenging to process due to their size. We demonstrate the practical utility of these trajectories in assessing speed variability and travel times across different lanes within the INCEPTION dataset. The virtual trajectory dataset opens future research on traffic waves and their impact on energy.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Online Min Cost Circulation for Multi-Object Tracking on Fragments
Authors:
Yanbing Wang,
Junyi Ji,
William Barbour,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Multi-object tracking (MOT) or global data association problem is commonly approached as a minimum-cost-flow or minimum-cost-circulation problem on a graph. While there have been numerous studies aimed at enhancing algorithm efficiency, most of them focus on the batch problem, where all the data must be available simultaneously to construct a static graph. However, with the growing number of appli…
▽ More
Multi-object tracking (MOT) or global data association problem is commonly approached as a minimum-cost-flow or minimum-cost-circulation problem on a graph. While there have been numerous studies aimed at enhancing algorithm efficiency, most of them focus on the batch problem, where all the data must be available simultaneously to construct a static graph. However, with the growing number of applications that generate streaming data, an efficient online algorithm is required to handle the streaming nature of the input. In this paper, we present an online extension of the well-known negative cycle canceling algorithm for solving the multi-object tracking problem with streaming fragmented data. We provide a proof of correctness for the proposed algorithm and demonstrate its efficiency through numerical experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Enabling Mixed Autonomy Traffic Control
Authors:
Matthew Nice,
Matt Bunting,
Alex Richardson,
Gergely Zachar,
Jonathan W. Lee,
Alexandre Bayen,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Benjamin Seibold,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Dan Work
Abstract:
We demonstrate a new capability of automated vehicles: mixed autonomy traffic control. With this new capability, automated vehicles can shape the traffic flows composed of other non-automated vehicles, which has the promise to improve safety, efficiency, and energy outcomes in transportation systems at a societal scale. Investigating mixed autonomy mobile traffic control must be done in situ given…
▽ More
We demonstrate a new capability of automated vehicles: mixed autonomy traffic control. With this new capability, automated vehicles can shape the traffic flows composed of other non-automated vehicles, which has the promise to improve safety, efficiency, and energy outcomes in transportation systems at a societal scale. Investigating mixed autonomy mobile traffic control must be done in situ given that the complex dynamics of other drivers and their response to a team of automated vehicles cannot be effectively modeled. This capability has been blocked because there is no existing scalable and affordable platform for experimental control. This paper introduces an extensible open-source hardware and software platform, enabling a team of 100 vehicles to execute several different vehicular control algorithms as a collaborative fleet, composed of three different makes and models, which drove 22752 miles in a combined 1022 hours, over 5 days in Nashville, TN in November 2022.
△ Less
Submitted 28 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Traffic smoothing using explicit local controllers
Authors:
Amaury Hayat,
Arwa Alanqary,
Rahul Bhadani,
Christopher Denaro,
Ryan J. Weightman,
Shengquan Xiang,
Jonathan W. Lee,
Matthew Bunting,
Anish Gollakota,
Matthew W. Nice,
Derek Gloudemans,
Gergely Zachar,
Jon F. Davis,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Benjamin Seibold,
Alexandre M. Bayen,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Daniel B. Work,
Benedetto Piccoli
Abstract:
The dissipation of stop-and-go waves attracted recent attention as a traffic management problem, which can be efficiently addressed by automated driving. As part of the 100 automated vehicles experiment named MegaVanderTest, feedback controls were used to induce strong dissipation via velocity smoothing. More precisely, a single vehicle driving differently in one of the four lanes of I-24 in the N…
▽ More
The dissipation of stop-and-go waves attracted recent attention as a traffic management problem, which can be efficiently addressed by automated driving. As part of the 100 automated vehicles experiment named MegaVanderTest, feedback controls were used to induce strong dissipation via velocity smoothing. More precisely, a single vehicle driving differently in one of the four lanes of I-24 in the Nashville area was able to regularize the velocity profile by reducing oscillations in time and velocity differences among vehicles. Quantitative measures of this effect were possible due to the innovative I-24 MOTION system capable of monitoring the traffic conditions for all vehicles on the roadway. This paper presents the control design, the technological aspects involved in its deployment, and, finally, the results achieved by the experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
MARVEL: Multi-Agent Reinforcement-Learning for Large-Scale Variable Speed Limits
Authors:
Yuhang Zhang,
Marcos Quinones-Grueiro,
Zhiyao Zhang,
Yanbing Wang,
William Barbour,
Gautam Biswas,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
Variable Speed Limit (VSL) control acts as a promising highway traffic management strategy with worldwide deployment, which can enhance traffic safety by dynamically adjusting speed limits according to real-time traffic conditions. Most of the deployed VSL control algorithms so far are rule-based, lacking generalizability under varying and complex traffic scenarios. In this work, we propose MARVEL…
▽ More
Variable Speed Limit (VSL) control acts as a promising highway traffic management strategy with worldwide deployment, which can enhance traffic safety by dynamically adjusting speed limits according to real-time traffic conditions. Most of the deployed VSL control algorithms so far are rule-based, lacking generalizability under varying and complex traffic scenarios. In this work, we propose MARVEL (Multi-Agent Reinforcement-learning for large-scale Variable spEed Limits), a novel framework for large-scale VSL control on highway corridors with real-world deployment settings. MARVEL utilizes only sensing information observable in the real world as state input and learns through a reward structure that incorporates adaptability to traffic conditions, safety, and mobility, thereby enabling multi-agent coordination. With parameter sharing among all VSL agents, the proposed framework scales to cover corridors with many agents. The policies are trained in a microscopic traffic simulation environment, focusing on a short freeway stretch with 8 VSL agents spanning 7 miles. For testing, these policies are applied to a more extensive network with 34 VSL agents spanning 17 miles of I-24 near Nashville, TN, USA. MARVEL-based method improves traffic safety by 63.4% compared to the no control scenario and enhances traffic mobility by 58.6% compared to a state-of-the-practice algorithm that has been deployed on I-24. Besides, we conduct an explainability analysis to examine the decision-making process of the agents and explore the learned policy under different traffic conditions. Finally, we test the response of the policy learned from the simulation-based experiments with real-world data collected from I-24 and illustrate its deployment capability.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2024; v1 submitted 18 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
SAILing CAVs: Speed-Adaptive Infrastructure-Linked Connected and Automated Vehicles
Authors:
Matthew Nice,
Matthew Bunting,
George Gunter,
William Barbour,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Dan Work
Abstract:
This work demonstrates a new capability in roadway control: Speed-adaptive, infrastructure-linked connected and automated vehicles. We develop and deploy a lightly modified vehicle that is able to dynamically adjust the vehicle speed in response to posted variable speed limit messages generated by the infrastructure using LTE connectivity. This work describes the open source hardware and software…
▽ More
This work demonstrates a new capability in roadway control: Speed-adaptive, infrastructure-linked connected and automated vehicles. We develop and deploy a lightly modified vehicle that is able to dynamically adjust the vehicle speed in response to posted variable speed limit messages generated by the infrastructure using LTE connectivity. This work describes the open source hardware and software platform that enables integration between infrastructure-based variable posted speed limits, and existing vehicle platforms for automated control. The vehicle is deployed in heavy morning traffic on I-24 in Nashville, TN. The control vehicle follows the posted variable speed limits, resulting in as much as a 25% reduction in speed variability compared to a human-piloted vehicle in the same traffic stream.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
So you think you can track?
Authors:
Derek Gloudemans,
Gergely Zachár,
Yanbing Wang,
Junyi Ji,
Matt Nice,
Matt Bunting,
William Barbour,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Alexandre Bayen,
Benjamin Seibold,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work introduces a multi-camera tracking dataset consisting of 234 hours of video data recorded concurrently from 234 overlapping HD cameras covering a 4.2 mile stretch of 8-10 lane interstate highway near Nashville, TN. The video is recorded during a period of high traffic density with 500+ objects typically visible within the scene and typical object longevities of 3-15 minutes. GPS trajecto…
▽ More
This work introduces a multi-camera tracking dataset consisting of 234 hours of video data recorded concurrently from 234 overlapping HD cameras covering a 4.2 mile stretch of 8-10 lane interstate highway near Nashville, TN. The video is recorded during a period of high traffic density with 500+ objects typically visible within the scene and typical object longevities of 3-15 minutes. GPS trajectories from 270 vehicle passes through the scene are manually corrected in the video data to provide a set of ground-truth trajectories for recall-oriented tracking metrics, and object detections are provided for each camera in the scene (159 million total before cross-camera fusion). Initial benchmarking of tracking-by-detection algorithms is performed against the GPS trajectories, and a best HOTA of only 9.5% is obtained (best recall 75.9% at IOU 0.1, 47.9 average IDs per ground truth object), indicating the benchmarked trackers do not perform sufficiently well at the long temporal and spatial durations required for traffic scene understanding.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Polygon Intersection-over-Union Loss for Viewpoint-Agnostic Monocular 3D Vehicle Detection
Authors:
Derek Gloudemans,
Xinxuan Lu,
Shepard Xia,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Monocular 3D object detection is a challenging task because depth information is difficult to obtain from 2D images. A subset of viewpoint-agnostic monocular 3D detection methods also do not explicitly leverage scene homography or geometry during training, meaning that a model trained thusly can detect objects in images from arbitrary viewpoints. Such works predict the projections of the 3D boundi…
▽ More
Monocular 3D object detection is a challenging task because depth information is difficult to obtain from 2D images. A subset of viewpoint-agnostic monocular 3D detection methods also do not explicitly leverage scene homography or geometry during training, meaning that a model trained thusly can detect objects in images from arbitrary viewpoints. Such works predict the projections of the 3D bounding boxes on the image plane to estimate the location of the 3D boxes, but these projections are not rectangular so the calculation of IoU between these projected polygons is not straightforward. This work proposes an efficient, fully differentiable algorithm for the calculation of IoU between two convex polygons, which can be utilized to compute the IoU between two 3D bounding box footprints viewed from an arbitrary angle. We test the performance of the proposed polygon IoU loss (PIoU loss) on three state-of-the-art viewpoint-agnostic 3D detection models. Experiments demonstrate that the proposed PIoU loss converges faster than L1 loss and that in 3D detection models, a combination of PIoU loss and L1 loss gives better results than L1 loss alone (+1.64% AP70 for MonoCon on cars, +0.18% AP70 for RTM3D on cars, and +0.83%/+2.46% AP50/AP25 for MonoRCNN on cyclists).
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
The Interstate-24 3D Dataset: a new benchmark for 3D multi-camera vehicle tracking
Authors:
Derek Gloudemans,
Yanbing Wang,
Gracie Gumm,
William Barbour,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work presents a novel video dataset recorded from overlapping highway traffic cameras along an urban interstate, enabling multi-camera 3D object tracking in a traffic monitoring context. Data is released from 3 scenes containing video from at least 16 cameras each, totaling 57 minutes in length. 877,000 3D bounding boxes and corresponding object tracklets are fully and accurately annotated fo…
▽ More
This work presents a novel video dataset recorded from overlapping highway traffic cameras along an urban interstate, enabling multi-camera 3D object tracking in a traffic monitoring context. Data is released from 3 scenes containing video from at least 16 cameras each, totaling 57 minutes in length. 877,000 3D bounding boxes and corresponding object tracklets are fully and accurately annotated for each camera field of view and are combined into a spatially and temporally continuous set of vehicle trajectories for each scene. Lastly, existing algorithms are combined to benchmark a number of 3D multi-camera tracking pipelines on the dataset, with results indicating that the dataset is challenging due to the difficulty of matching objects traveling at high speeds across cameras and heavy object occlusion, potentially for hundreds of frames, during congested traffic. This work aims to enable the development of accurate and automatic vehicle trajectory extraction algorithms, which will play a vital role in understanding impacts of autonomous vehicle technologies on the safety and efficiency of traffic.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
CAV Traffic Control to Mitigate the Impact of Congestion from Bottlenecks: A Linear Quadratic Regulator Approach and Microsimulation Study
Authors:
Suyash C. Vishnoi,
Junyi Ji,
MirSaleh Bahavarnia,
Yuhang Zhang,
Ahmad F. Taha,
Christian G. Claudel,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work investigates traffic control via controlled connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) using novel controllers derived from the linear-quadratic regulator (LQR) theory. CAV-platoons are modeled as moving bottlenecks impacting the surrounding traffic with their speeds as control inputs. An iterative controller algorithm based on the LQR theory is proposed along with a variant that allows for…
▽ More
This work investigates traffic control via controlled connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) using novel controllers derived from the linear-quadratic regulator (LQR) theory. CAV-platoons are modeled as moving bottlenecks impacting the surrounding traffic with their speeds as control inputs. An iterative controller algorithm based on the LQR theory is proposed along with a variant that allows for penalizing abrupt changes in platoons speeds. The controllers use the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model implemented using an extended cell transmission model (CTM) which considers the capacity drop phenomenon for a realistic representation of traffic in congestion. The impact of various parameters of the proposed controller on the control performance is analyzed. The effectiveness of the proposed traffic control algorithms is tested using a traffic control example and compared with existing proportional-integral (PI)- and model predictive control (MPC)- based controllers from the literature. A case study using the TransModeler traffic microsimulation software is conducted to test the usability of the proposed controller as well as existing controllers in a realistic setting and derive qualitative insights. It is observed that the proposed controller works well in both settings to mitigate the impact of the jam caused by a fixed bottleneck. The computation time required by the controller is also small making it suitable for real-time control.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2023; v1 submitted 17 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Detecting Socially Abnormal Highway Driving Behaviors via Recurrent Graph Attention Networks
Authors:
Yue Hu,
Yuhang Zhang,
Yanbing Wang,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
With the rapid development of Internet of Things technologies, the next generation traffic monitoring infrastructures are connected via the web, to aid traffic data collection and intelligent traffic management. One of the most important tasks in traffic is anomaly detection, since abnormal drivers can reduce traffic efficiency and cause safety issues. This work focuses on detecting abnormal drivi…
▽ More
With the rapid development of Internet of Things technologies, the next generation traffic monitoring infrastructures are connected via the web, to aid traffic data collection and intelligent traffic management. One of the most important tasks in traffic is anomaly detection, since abnormal drivers can reduce traffic efficiency and cause safety issues. This work focuses on detecting abnormal driving behaviors from trajectories produced by highway video surveillance systems. Most of the current abnormal driving behavior detection methods focus on a limited category of abnormal behaviors that deal with a single vehicle without considering vehicular interactions. In this work, we consider the problem of detecting a variety of socially abnormal driving behaviors, i.e., behaviors that do not conform to the behavior of other nearby drivers. This task is complicated by the variety of vehicular interactions and the spatial-temporal varying nature of highway traffic. To solve this problem, we propose an autoencoder with a Recurrent Graph Attention Network that can capture the highway driving behaviors contextualized on the surrounding cars, and detect anomalies that deviate from learned patterns. Our model is scalable to large freeways with thousands of cars. Experiments on data generated from traffic simulation software show that our model is the only one that can spot the exact vehicle conducting socially abnormal behaviors, among the state-of-the-art anomaly detection models. We further show the performance on real world HighD traffic dataset, where our model detects vehicles that violate the local driving norms.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
I-24 MOTION: An instrument for freeway traffic science
Authors:
Derek Gloudemans,
Yanbing Wang,
Junyi Ji,
Gergely Zachar,
Will Barbour,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
The Interstate-24 MObility Technology Interstate Observation Network (I-24 MOTION) is a new instrument for traffic science located near Nashville, Tennessee. I-24 MOTION consists of 276 pole-mounted high-resolution traffic cameras that provide seamless coverage of approximately 4.2 miles I-24, a 4-5 lane (each direction) freeway with frequently observed congestion. The cameras are connected via fi…
▽ More
The Interstate-24 MObility Technology Interstate Observation Network (I-24 MOTION) is a new instrument for traffic science located near Nashville, Tennessee. I-24 MOTION consists of 276 pole-mounted high-resolution traffic cameras that provide seamless coverage of approximately 4.2 miles I-24, a 4-5 lane (each direction) freeway with frequently observed congestion. The cameras are connected via fiber optic network to a compute facility where vehicle trajectories are extracted from the video imagery using computer vision techniques. Approximately 230 million vehicle miles of travel occur within I-24 MOTION annually. The main output of the instrument are vehicle trajectory datasets that contain the position of each vehicle on the freeway, as well as other supplementary information vehicle dimensions and class. This article describes the design and creation of the instrument, and provides the first publicly available datasets generated from the instrument. The datasets published with this article contains at least 4 hours of vehicle trajectory data for each of 10 days. As the system continues to mature, all trajectory data will be made publicly available at i24motion.org/data.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023; v1 submitted 26 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Automatic vehicle trajectory data reconstruction at scale
Authors:
Yanbing Wang,
Derek Gloudemans,
Junyi Ji,
Zi Nean Teoh,
Lisa Liu,
Gergely Zachár,
William Barbour,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
In this paper we propose an automatic trajectory data reconciliation to correct common errors in vision-based vehicle trajectory data. Given "raw" vehicle detection and tracking information from automatic video processing algorithms, we propose a pipeline including (a) an online data association algorithm to match fragments that describe the same object (vehicle), which is formulated as a min-cost…
▽ More
In this paper we propose an automatic trajectory data reconciliation to correct common errors in vision-based vehicle trajectory data. Given "raw" vehicle detection and tracking information from automatic video processing algorithms, we propose a pipeline including (a) an online data association algorithm to match fragments that describe the same object (vehicle), which is formulated as a min-cost network circulation problem of a graph, and (b) a one-step trajectory rectification procedure formulated as a quadratic program to enhance raw detection data. The pipeline leverages vehicle dynamics and physical constraints to associate tracked objects when they become fragmented, remove measurement noises and outliers and impute missing data due to fragmentations. We assess the capability of the proposed two-step pipeline to reconstruct three benchmarking datasets: (1) a microsimulation dataset that is artificially downgraded to replicate upstream errors, (2) a 15-min NGSIM data that is manually perturbed, and (3) tracking data consists of 3 scenes from collections of video data recorded from 16-17 cameras on a section of the I-24 MOTION system, and compare with the corresponding manually-labeled ground truth vehicle bounding boxes. All of the experiments show that the reconciled trajectories improve the accuracy on all the tested input data for a wide range of measures. Lastly, we show the design of a software architecture that is currently deployed on the full-scale I-24 MOTION system consisting of 276 cameras that covers 4.2 miles of I-24. We demonstrate the scalability of the proposed reconciliation pipeline to process high-volume data on a daily basis.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2023; v1 submitted 15 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Optimization of vaccination for COVID-19 in the midst of a pandemic
Authors:
Qi Luo,
Ryan Weightman,
Sean T. McQuade,
Mateo Diaz,
Emmanuel Trélat,
William Barbour,
Dan Work,
Samitha Samaranayake,
Benedetto Piccoli
Abstract:
During the Covid-19 pandemic a key role is played by vaccination to combat the virus. There are many possible policies for prioritizing vaccines, and different criteria for optimization: minimize death, time to herd immunity, functioning of the health system. Using an age-structured population compartmental finite-dimensional optimal control model, our results suggest that the eldest to youngest v…
▽ More
During the Covid-19 pandemic a key role is played by vaccination to combat the virus. There are many possible policies for prioritizing vaccines, and different criteria for optimization: minimize death, time to herd immunity, functioning of the health system. Using an age-structured population compartmental finite-dimensional optimal control model, our results suggest that the eldest to youngest vaccination policy is optimal to minimize deaths. Our model includes the possible infection of vaccinated populations. We apply our model to real-life data from the US Census for New Jersey and Florida, which have a significantly different population structure. We also provide various estimates of the number of lives saved by optimizing the vaccine schedule and compared to no vaccination.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Compromised ACC vehicles can degrade current mixed-autonomy traffic performance while remaining stealthy against detection
Authors:
George Gunter,
Huichen Li,
Avesta Hojjati,
Matthew Nice,
Matthew Bunting,
Carl A. Gunter,
Bo Li,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Daniel Work
Abstract:
We demonstrate that a supply-chain level compromise of the adaptive cruise control (ACC) capability on equipped vehicles can be used to significantly degrade system level performance of current day mixed-autonomy freeway networks. Via a simple threat model which causes random deceleration attacks (RDAs), compromised vehicles create congestion waves in the traffic that decrease average speed and ne…
▽ More
We demonstrate that a supply-chain level compromise of the adaptive cruise control (ACC) capability on equipped vehicles can be used to significantly degrade system level performance of current day mixed-autonomy freeway networks. Via a simple threat model which causes random deceleration attacks (RDAs), compromised vehicles create congestion waves in the traffic that decrease average speed and network throughput. We use a detailed and realistic traffic simulation environment to quantify the impacts of the attack on a model of a real high-volume freeway in the United States. We find that the effect of the attack depends both on the level of underlying traffic congestion, and what percentage of ACC vehicles can be compromised. In moderate congestion regimes the attack can degrade mean commuter speed by over 7%. In high density regimes overall network throughput can be reduced by up to 3%. And, in moderate to high congestion regimes, it can cost commuters on the network over 300 USD/km hr. All of these results motivate that the proposed attack is able to significantly degrade performance of the traffic network.
We also develop an anomaly detection technique that uses GPS traces on vehicles to identify malicious/compromised vehicles. We employ this technique on data from the simulation experiments and find that it is unable to identify compromised ACCs compared to benign/normal drivers. That is, these attacks are stealthy to detection. Stronger attacks can be accurately labeled as malicious, motivating that there is a limit to how impactful attacks can be before they are no longer stealthy.
Finally, we experimentally execute the attack on a real and commercially available ACC vehicle, demonstrating the possible real world feasibility of an RDA.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Streaming data preprocessing via online tensor recovery for large environmental sensor networks
Authors:
Yue Hu,
Ao Qu,
Yanbing Wang,
Dan Work
Abstract:
Measuring the built and natural environment at a fine-grained scale is now possible with low-cost urban environmental sensor networks. However, fine-grained city-scale data analysis is complicated by tedious data cleaning including removing outliers and imputing missing data. While many methods exist to automatically correct anomalies and impute missing entries, challenges still exist on data with…
▽ More
Measuring the built and natural environment at a fine-grained scale is now possible with low-cost urban environmental sensor networks. However, fine-grained city-scale data analysis is complicated by tedious data cleaning including removing outliers and imputing missing data. While many methods exist to automatically correct anomalies and impute missing entries, challenges still exist on data with large spatial-temporal scales and shifting patterns. To address these challenges, we propose an online robust tensor recovery (OLRTR) method to preprocess streaming high-dimensional urban environmental datasets. A small-sized dictionary that captures the underlying patterns of the data is computed and constantly updated with new data. OLRTR enables online recovery for large-scale sensor networks that provide continuous data streams, with a lower computational memory usage compared to offline batch counterparts. In addition, we formulate the objective function so that OLRTR can detect structured outliers, such as faulty readings over a long period of time. We validate OLRTR on a synthetically degraded National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration temperature dataset, with a recovery error of 0.05, and apply it to the Array of Things city-scale sensor network in Chicago, IL, showing superior results compared with several established online and batch-based low rank decomposition methods.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Integrated Framework of Vehicle Dynamics, Instabilities, Energy Models, and Sparse Flow Smoothing Controllers
Authors:
Jonathan W. Lee,
George Gunter,
Rabie Ramadan,
Sulaiman Almatrudi,
Paige Arnold,
John Aquino,
William Barbour,
Rahul Bhadani,
Joy Carpio,
Fang-Chieh Chou,
Marsalis Gibson,
Xiaoqian Gong,
Amaury Hayat,
Nour Khoudari,
Abdul Rahman Kreidieh,
Maya Kumar,
Nathan Lichtlé,
Sean McQuade,
Brian Nguyen,
Megan Ross,
Sydney Truong,
Eugene Vinitsky,
Yibo Zhao,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli
, et al. (3 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This work presents an integrated framework of: vehicle dynamics models, with a particular attention to instabilities and traffic waves; vehicle energy models, with particular attention to accurate energy values for strongly unsteady driving profiles; and sparse Lagrangian controls via automated vehicles, with a focus on controls that can be executed via existing technology such as adaptive cruise…
▽ More
This work presents an integrated framework of: vehicle dynamics models, with a particular attention to instabilities and traffic waves; vehicle energy models, with particular attention to accurate energy values for strongly unsteady driving profiles; and sparse Lagrangian controls via automated vehicles, with a focus on controls that can be executed via existing technology such as adaptive cruise control systems. This framework serves as a key building block in developing control strategies for human-in-the-loop traffic flow smoothing on real highways. In this contribution, we outline the fundamental merits of integrating vehicle dynamics and energy modeling into a single framework, and we demonstrate the energy impact of sparse flow smoothing controllers via simulation results.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
CAN Coach: Vehicular Control through Human Cyber-Physical Systems
Authors:
M. Nice,
S. Elmadani,
R. Bhadani,
M. Bunting,
J. Sprinkle,
D. Work
Abstract:
This work addresses whether a human-in-the-loop cyber-physical system (HCPS) can be effective in improving the longitudinal control of an individual vehicle in a traffic flow. We introduce the CAN Coach, which is a system that gives feedback to the human-in-the-loop using radar data (relative speed and position information to objects ahead) that is available on the controller area network (CAN). U…
▽ More
This work addresses whether a human-in-the-loop cyber-physical system (HCPS) can be effective in improving the longitudinal control of an individual vehicle in a traffic flow. We introduce the CAN Coach, which is a system that gives feedback to the human-in-the-loop using radar data (relative speed and position information to objects ahead) that is available on the controller area network (CAN). Using a cohort of six human subjects driving an instrumented vehicle, we compare the ability of the human-in-the-loop driver to achieve a constant time-gap control policy using only human-based visual perception to the car ahead, and by augmenting human perception with audible feedback from CAN sensor data. The addition of CAN-based feedback reduces the mean time-gap error by an average of 73%, and also improves the consistency of the human by reducing the standard deviation of the time-gap error by 53%. We remove human perception from the loop using a ghost mode in which the human-in-the-loop is coached to track a virtual vehicle on the road, rather than a physical one. The loss of visual perception of the vehicle ahead degrades the performance for most drivers, but by varying amounts. We show that human subjects can match the velocity of the lead vehicle ahead with and without CAN-based feedback, but velocity matching does not offer regulation of vehicle spacing. The viability of dynamic time-gap control is also demonstrated. We conclude that (1) it is possible to coach drivers to improve performance on driving tasks using CAN data, and (2) it is a true HCPS, since removing human perception from the control loop reduces performance at the given control objective.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Localization-Based Tracking
Authors:
Derek Gloudemans,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
End-to-end production of object tracklets from high resolution video in real-time and with high accuracy remains a challenging problem due to the cost of object detection on each frame. In this work we present Localization-based Tracking (LBT), an extension to any tracker that follows the tracking by detection or joint detection and tracking paradigms. Localization-based Tracking focuses only on r…
▽ More
End-to-end production of object tracklets from high resolution video in real-time and with high accuracy remains a challenging problem due to the cost of object detection on each frame. In this work we present Localization-based Tracking (LBT), an extension to any tracker that follows the tracking by detection or joint detection and tracking paradigms. Localization-based Tracking focuses only on regions likely to contain objects to boost detection speed and avoid matching errors. We evaluate LBT as an extension to two example trackers (KIOU and SORT) on the UA-DETRAC and MOT20 datasets. LBT-extended trackers outperform all other reported algorithms in terms of PR-MOTA, PR-MOTP, and mostly tracked objects on the UA-DETRAC benchmark, establishing a new state-of-the art. relative to tracking by detection with KIOU, LBT-extended KIOU achieves a 25% higher frame-rate and is 1.1% more accurate in terms of PR-MOTA on the UA-DETRAC dataset. LBT-extended SORT achieves a 62% speedup and a 3.2% increase in PR-MOTA on the UA-DETRAC dataset. On MOT20, LBT-extended KIOU has a 50% higher frame-rate than tracking by detection and is 0.4% more accurate in terms of MOTA. As of submission time, our LBT-extended KIOU tracker places 10th overall on the MOT20 benchmark.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Identifiability of car-following dynamic
Authors:
Yanbing Wang,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
The advancement of in-vehicle sensors provides abundant datasets to estimate parameters of car-following models that describe driver behaviors. The question of parameter identifiability of such models (i.e., whether it is possible to infer its unknown parameters from the experimental data) is a central system analysis question, and yet still remains open. This article presents both structural and…
▽ More
The advancement of in-vehicle sensors provides abundant datasets to estimate parameters of car-following models that describe driver behaviors. The question of parameter identifiability of such models (i.e., whether it is possible to infer its unknown parameters from the experimental data) is a central system analysis question, and yet still remains open. This article presents both structural and practical parameter identifiability analysis on four common car-following models: (i) the constant-time headway relative-velocity (CTH-RV) model, (ii) the optimal velocity model (OV), (iii) the follow-the-leader model (FTL) and (iv) the intelligent driver model (IDM). The structural identifiability analysis is carried out using a differential geometry approach, which confirms that, in theory, all of the tested car-following systems are structurally locally identifiable, i.e., the parameters can be uniquely inferred under almost all initial condition and admissible inputs by observing the space gap alone. In a practical setting, we propose an optimization-based numerical direct test to determine parameter identifiability given a specific experimental setup (the specific initial conditions and input are known). The direct test conclusively finds distinct parameters under which the CTH-RV and FTL are not identifiable under the given initial condition and input trajectory.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2022; v1 submitted 15 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Graph Convolutional Networks for traffic anomaly
Authors:
Yue Hu,
Ao Qu,
Dan Work
Abstract:
Event detection has been an important task in transportation, whose task is to detect points in time when large events disrupts a large portion of the urban traffic network. Travel information {Origin-Destination} (OD) matrix data by map service vendors has large potential to give us insights to discover historic patterns and distinguish anomalies. However, to fully capture the spatial and tempora…
▽ More
Event detection has been an important task in transportation, whose task is to detect points in time when large events disrupts a large portion of the urban traffic network. Travel information {Origin-Destination} (OD) matrix data by map service vendors has large potential to give us insights to discover historic patterns and distinguish anomalies. However, to fully capture the spatial and temporal traffic patterns remains a challenge, yet serves a crucial role for effective anomaly detection. Meanwhile, existing anomaly detection methods have not well-addressed the extreme data sparsity and high-dimension challenges, which are common in OD matrix datasets. To tackle these challenges, we formulate the problem in a novel way, as detecting anomalies in a set of directed weighted graphs representing the traffic conditions at each time interval. We further propose \textit{Context augmented Graph Autoencoder} (\textbf{Con-GAE }), that leverages graph embedding and context embedding techniques to capture the spatial traffic network patterns while working around the data sparsity and high-dimensionality issue. Con-GAE adopts an autoencoder framework and detect anomalies via semi-supervised learning. Extensive experiments show that our method can achieve up can achieve a 0.1-0.4 improvements of the area under the curve (AUC) score over state-of-art anomaly detection baselines, when applied on several real-world large scale OD matrix datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Impacts of Covid-19 mode shift on road traffic
Authors:
Yue Hu,
William Barbour,
Kun Qian,
Christian Claudel,
Samitha Samaranayake,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work considers the sensitivity of commute travel times in US metro areas due to potential changes in commute patterns, for example caused by events such as pandemics. Permanent shifts away from transit and carpooling can add vehicles to congested road networks, increasing travel times. Growth in the number of workers who avoid commuting and work from home instead can offset travel time increa…
▽ More
This work considers the sensitivity of commute travel times in US metro areas due to potential changes in commute patterns, for example caused by events such as pandemics. Permanent shifts away from transit and carpooling can add vehicles to congested road networks, increasing travel times. Growth in the number of workers who avoid commuting and work from home instead can offset travel time increases. To estimate these potential impacts, 6-9 years of American Community Survey commute data for 118 metropolitan statistical areas are investigated. For 74 of the metro areas, the average commute travel time is shown to be explainable using only the number of passenger vehicles used for commuting. A universal Bureau of Public Roads model characterizes the sensitivity of each metro area with respect to additional vehicles. The resulting models are then used to determine the change in average travel time for each metro area in scenarios when 25\% or 50\% of transit and carpool users switch to single occupancy vehicles. Under a 25\% mode shift, areas such as San Francisco and New York that are already congested and have high transit ridership may experience round trip travel time increases of 12 minutes (New York) to 20 minutes (San Francisco), costing individual commuters \$1065 and \$1601 annually in lost time. The travel time increases and corresponding costs can be avoided with an increase in working from home. The main contribution of this work is to provide a model to quantify the potential increase in commute travel times under various behavior changes, that can aid policy making for more efficient commuting.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2023; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Estimating adaptive cruise control model parameters from on-board radar units
Authors:
Yanbing Wang,
George Gunter,
Matthew Nice,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Two new methods are presented for estimating car-following model parameters using data collected from the Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) enabled vehicles. The vehicle is assumed to follow a constant time headway relative velocity model in which the parameters are unknown and to be determined. The first technique is a batch method that uses a least-squares approach to estimate the parameters from ti…
▽ More
Two new methods are presented for estimating car-following model parameters using data collected from the Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) enabled vehicles. The vehicle is assumed to follow a constant time headway relative velocity model in which the parameters are unknown and to be determined. The first technique is a batch method that uses a least-squares approach to estimate the parameters from time series data of the vehicle speed, space gap, and relative velocity of a lead vehicle. The second method is an online approach that uses a particle filter to simultaneously estimate both the state of the system and the model parameters. Numerical experiments demonstrate the accuracy and computational performance of the methods relative to a commonly used simulation-based optimization approach. The methods are also assessed on empirical data collected from a 2019 model year ACC vehicle driven in a highway environment. Speed, space gap, and relative velocity data are recorded directly from the factory-installed radar unit via the vehicle's CAN bus. All three methods return similar mean absolute error values in speed and spacing compared to the recorded data. The least-squares method has the fastest run-time performance, and is up to 3 orders of magnitude faster than other methods. The particle filter is faster than real-time, and therefore is suitable in streaming applications in which the datasets can grow arbitrarily large.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Robust Tensor Recovery with Fiber Outliers for Traffic Events
Authors:
Yue Hu,
Dan Work
Abstract:
Event detection is gaining increasing attention in smart cities research. Large-scale mobility data serves as an important tool to uncover the dynamics of urban transportation systems, and more often than not the dataset is incomplete. In this article, we develop a method to detect extreme events in large traffic datasets, and to impute missing data during regular conditions. Specifically, we prop…
▽ More
Event detection is gaining increasing attention in smart cities research. Large-scale mobility data serves as an important tool to uncover the dynamics of urban transportation systems, and more often than not the dataset is incomplete. In this article, we develop a method to detect extreme events in large traffic datasets, and to impute missing data during regular conditions. Specifically, we propose a robust tensor recovery problem to recover low rank tensors under fiber-sparse corruptions with partial observations, and use it to identify events, and impute missing data under typical conditions. Our approach is scalable to large urban areas, taking full advantage of the spatio-temporal correlations in traffic patterns. We develop an efficient algorithm to solve the tensor recovery problem based on the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM) framework. Compared with existing $l_1$ norm regularized tensor decomposition methods, our algorithm can exactly recover the values of uncorrupted fibers of a low rank tensor and find the positions of corrupted fibers under mild conditions. Numerical experiments illustrate that our algorithm can exactly detect outliers even with missing data rates as high as 40%, conditioned on the outlier corruption rate and the Tucker rank of the low rank tensor. Finally, we apply our method on a real traffic dataset corresponding to downtown Nashville, TN, USA and successfully detect the events like severe car crashes, construction lane closures, and other large events that cause significant traffic disruptions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Are commercially implemented adaptive cruise control systems string stable?
Authors:
George Gunter,
Derek Gloudemans,
Raphael E. Stern,
Sean McQuade,
Rahul Bhadani,
Matt Bunting,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Roman Lysecky,
Benjamin Seibold,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
In this article, we assess the string stability of seven 2018 model year adaptive cruise control (ACC) equipped vehicles that are widely available in the US market. Seven distinct vehicle models from two different vehicle makes are analyzed using data collected from more than 1,200 miles of driving in car-following experiments with ACC engaged by the follower vehicle. The resulting dataset is used…
▽ More
In this article, we assess the string stability of seven 2018 model year adaptive cruise control (ACC) equipped vehicles that are widely available in the US market. Seven distinct vehicle models from two different vehicle makes are analyzed using data collected from more than 1,200 miles of driving in car-following experiments with ACC engaged by the follower vehicle. The resulting dataset is used to identify the parameters of a linear second order delay differential equation model that approximates the behavior of the black box ACC systems. The string stability of the data-fitted model associated with each vehicle is assessed, and the main finding is that all seven vehicle models have string unstable ACC systems. For one commonly available vehicle model that offers ACC as a standard feature on all trim levels, we validate the string stability finding with a multi-vehicle platoon experiment in which all vehicles are the same year, make, and model. In this test, an initial disturbance of 6 mph is amplified to a 25 mph disturbance, at which point the last vehicle in the platoon is observed to disengage the ACC. The data collected in the driving experiments is made available, representing the largest publicly available comparative driving dataset on ACC equipped vehicles.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Model based string stability of adaptive cruise control systems using field data
Authors:
George Gunter,
Caroline Janssen,
William Barbour,
Raphael E. Stern,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This article is motivated by the lack of empirical data on the performance of commercially available Society of Automotive Engineers level one automated driving systems. To address this, a set of car following experiments are conducted to collect data from a 2015 luxury electric vehicle equipped with a commercial adaptive cruise control (ACC) system. Velocity, relative velocity, and spacing data c…
▽ More
This article is motivated by the lack of empirical data on the performance of commercially available Society of Automotive Engineers level one automated driving systems. To address this, a set of car following experiments are conducted to collect data from a 2015 luxury electric vehicle equipped with a commercial adaptive cruise control (ACC) system. Velocity, relative velocity, and spacing data collected during the experiments are used to calibrate an optimal velocity relative velocity car following model for both the minimum and maximum following settings. The string stability of both calibrated models is assessed, and it is determined that the best-fit models are string unstable, indicating they are not able to prevent all traffic disturbances from amplifying into phantom jams. Based on the calibrated models, we identify the consequences of the string unstable ACC system on synthetic and empirical lead vehicle disturbances, highlighting that some disturbances can be dampened even with string unstable commercial ACC platoons of moderate size.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Congestion Barcodes: Exploring the Topology of Urban Congestion Using Persistent Homology
Authors:
Yu Wu,
Gabriel Shindnes,
Vaibhav Karve,
Derrek Yager,
Daniel B. Work,
Arnab Chakraborty,
Richard B. Sowers
Abstract:
This work presents a new method to quantify connectivity in transportation networks. Inspired by the field of topological data analysis, we propose a novel approach to explore the robustness of road network connectivity in the presence of congestion on the roadway. The robustness of the pattern is summarized in a congestion barcode, which can be constructed directly from traffic datasets commonly…
▽ More
This work presents a new method to quantify connectivity in transportation networks. Inspired by the field of topological data analysis, we propose a novel approach to explore the robustness of road network connectivity in the presence of congestion on the roadway. The robustness of the pattern is summarized in a congestion barcode, which can be constructed directly from traffic datasets commonly used for navigation. As an initial demonstration, we illustrate the main technique on a publicly available traffic dataset in a neighborhood in New York City.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Dissipation of stop-and-go waves via control of autonomous vehicles: Field experiments
Authors:
Raphael E. Stern,
Shumo Cui,
Maria Laura Delle Monache,
Rahul Bhadani,
Matt Bunting,
Miles Churchill,
Nathaniel Hamilton,
R'mani Haulcy,
Hannah Pohlmann,
Fangyu Wu,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Benjamin Seibold,
Jonathan Sprinkle,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
Traffic waves are phenomena that emerge when the vehicular density exceeds a critical threshold. Considering the presence of increasingly automated vehicles in the traffic stream, a number of research activities have focused on the influence of automated vehicles on the bulk traffic flow. In the present article, we demonstrate experimentally that intelligent control of an autonomous vehicle is abl…
▽ More
Traffic waves are phenomena that emerge when the vehicular density exceeds a critical threshold. Considering the presence of increasingly automated vehicles in the traffic stream, a number of research activities have focused on the influence of automated vehicles on the bulk traffic flow. In the present article, we demonstrate experimentally that intelligent control of an autonomous vehicle is able to dampen stop-and-go waves that can arise even in the absence of geometric or lane changing triggers. Precisely, our experiments on a circular track with more than 20 vehicles show that traffic waves emerge consistently, and that they can be dampened by controlling the velocity of a single vehicle in the flow. We compare metrics for velocity, braking events, and fuel economy across experiments. These experimental findings suggest a paradigm shift in traffic management: flow control will be possible via a few mobile actuators (less than 5%) long before a majority of vehicles have autonomous capabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
A convex formulation of traffic dynamics on transportation networks
Authors:
Yanning Li,
Christian G. Claudel,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This article proposes a numerical scheme for computing the evolution of vehicular traffic on a road network over a finite time horizon. The traffic dynamics on each link is modeled by the Hamilton-Jacobi (HJ) partial differential equation (PDE), which is an equivalent form of the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards PDE. The main contribution of this article is the construction of a single convex optimizati…
▽ More
This article proposes a numerical scheme for computing the evolution of vehicular traffic on a road network over a finite time horizon. The traffic dynamics on each link is modeled by the Hamilton-Jacobi (HJ) partial differential equation (PDE), which is an equivalent form of the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards PDE. The main contribution of this article is the construction of a single convex optimization program which computes the traffic flow at a junction over a finite time horizon and decouples the PDEs on connecting links. Compared to discretization schemes which require the computation of all traffic states on a time-space grid, the proposed convex optimization approach computes the boundary flows at the junction using only the initial condition on links and the boundary conditions of the network. The computed boundary flows at the junction specify the boundary condition for the HJ PDE on connecting links, which then can be separately solved using an existing semi-explicit scheme for single link HJ PDE. As demonstrated in a numerical example of ramp metering control, the proposed convex optimization approach also provides a natural framework for optimal traffic control applications.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
A Collapsed Generalized Aw-Rascle-Zhang Model and Its Model Accuracy
Authors:
Shimao Fan,
Ye Sun,
Benedetto Piccoli,
Benjamin Seibold,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work presents a collapsed generalized Aw-Rascle-Zhang (CGARZ) model, which fits into a generic second order model (GSOM) framework. GSOMs augment the evolution of the traffic density by a second state variable characterizing a property of vehicles or drivers. A cell transmission model for the numerical solution of GSOMs is derived, which is based on analyzing the sending and receiving functio…
▽ More
This work presents a collapsed generalized Aw-Rascle-Zhang (CGARZ) model, which fits into a generic second order model (GSOM) framework. GSOMs augment the evolution of the traffic density by a second state variable characterizing a property of vehicles or drivers. A cell transmission model for the numerical solution of GSOMs is derived, which is based on analyzing the sending and receiving functions of the traffic density and total property. The predictive accuracy of the CGARZ model is then compared to the classical first-order LWR and four second-order models. To that end, a systematic approach to calibrate model parameters from sensor flow-density data is introduced and applied to all models studied. The comparative model validation is conducted using two types of field data: vehicle trajectory data, and loop detector data. It is shown that the CGARZ model provides an intriguing combination of simple model dynamics in the free-flow regime and a representation of the spread of flow-density data in the congested regime, while possessing a competitive prediction accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Scaling the Kalman filter for large-scale traffic estimation
Authors:
Ye Sun,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This work introduces a scalable filtering algorithm for multi-agent traffic estimation. Large-scale networks are spatially partitioned into overlapping road sections. The traffic dynamics of each section is given by the switching mode model (SMM) using a conservation principle, and the traffic state in each section is estimated by a local agent. In the proposed filter, a consensus term is applied…
▽ More
This work introduces a scalable filtering algorithm for multi-agent traffic estimation. Large-scale networks are spatially partitioned into overlapping road sections. The traffic dynamics of each section is given by the switching mode model (SMM) using a conservation principle, and the traffic state in each section is estimated by a local agent. In the proposed filter, a consensus term is applied to promote inter-agent agreement on overlapping sections. The new filter, termed a (spatially) distributed local Kalman consensus filter (DLKCF), is shown to maintain globally asymptotically stable (GAS) mean error dynamics when all sections switch among observable modes. When a section is unobservable, we show that the mean estimate of each state variable in the section is ultimately bounded, which is achieved by exploring the interaction between the properties of the traffic model and the measurement feedback of the filter. Based on the above results, the boundedness of the mean estimation error of the DLKCF under switching sequences with observable and unobservable modes is established to address the overall performance of the filter. Numerical experiments show the ability of the DLKCF to promote consensus, increase estimation accuracy compared to a local filter, and reduce the computational load compared to a centralized approach.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2017; v1 submitted 2 August, 2016;
originally announced August 2016.
-
Using coarse GPS data to quantify city-scale transportation system resilience to extreme events
Authors:
Brian Donovan,
Daniel B. Work
Abstract:
This article proposes a method to quantitatively measure the resilience of transportation systems using GPS data from taxis. The granularity of the GPS data necessary for this analysis is relatively coarse; it only requires coordinates for the beginning and end of trips, the metered distance, and the total travel time. The method works by computing the historical distribution of pace (normalized t…
▽ More
This article proposes a method to quantitatively measure the resilience of transportation systems using GPS data from taxis. The granularity of the GPS data necessary for this analysis is relatively coarse; it only requires coordinates for the beginning and end of trips, the metered distance, and the total travel time. The method works by computing the historical distribution of pace (normalized travel times) between various regions of a city and measuring the pace deviations during an unusual event. This method is applied to a dataset of nearly 700 million taxi trips in New York City, which is used to analyze the transportation infrastructure resilience to Hurricane Sandy. The analysis indicates that Hurricane Sandy impacted traffic conditions for more than five days, and caused a peak delay of two minutes per mile. Practically, it identifies that the evacuation caused only minor disruptions, but significant delays were encountered during the post-disaster reentry process. Since the implementation of this method is very efficient, it could potentially be used as an online monitoring tool, representing a first step toward quantifying city scale resilience with coarse GPS data.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.