-
Competition in the nutrient-driven self-cycling fermentation process
Authors:
Stacey R. Smith?,
Tyler Meadows,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
Self-cycling fermentation is an automated process used for culturing microorganisms. We consider a model of $n$ distinct species competing for a single non-reproducing nutrient in a self-cycling fermentor in which the nutrient level is used as the decanting condition. The model is formulated in terms of impulsive ordinary differential equations. We prove that two species are able to coexist in the…
▽ More
Self-cycling fermentation is an automated process used for culturing microorganisms. We consider a model of $n$ distinct species competing for a single non-reproducing nutrient in a self-cycling fermentor in which the nutrient level is used as the decanting condition. The model is formulated in terms of impulsive ordinary differential equations. We prove that two species are able to coexist in the fermentor under certain conditions. We also provide numerical simulations that suggest coexistence of three species is possible and that competitor-mediated coexistence can occur in this case. These results are in contrast to the chemostat, the continuous analogue, where multiple species cannot coexist on a single nonreproducing nutrient.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
An augmented phase plane approach for discrete planar maps: Introducing next-iterate operators
Authors:
Sabrina H. Streipert,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
The next-iterate operators and corresponding next-iterate root-sets and root-curves associated with the nullclines of a planar discrete map are introduced. How to augment standard phase portraits that include the nullclines and the direction field, by including the signs of the root-operators associated with their nullclines, thus producing an augmented phase portrait, is described. The sign of a…
▽ More
The next-iterate operators and corresponding next-iterate root-sets and root-curves associated with the nullclines of a planar discrete map are introduced. How to augment standard phase portraits that include the nullclines and the direction field, by including the signs of the root-operators associated with their nullclines, thus producing an augmented phase portrait, is described. The sign of a next-iterate operator associated with a nullcline determines whether a point is mapped above or below the corresponding nullcline and can, for example, identify positively invariant regions. Using a Lotka-Volterra type competition model, we demonstrate how to construct the augmented phase portrait. We show that the augmented phase portrait provides an elementary, alternative approach for determining the complete global dynamics of this model. We further explore the limitations and potential of the augmented phase portrait by considering a Ricker competition model, a model involving mutualism, and a predator-prey model.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Population Growth and Competition Models with Decay and Competition Consistent Delay
Authors:
Chiu-Ju Lin,
Ting-Hao Hsu,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
We derive an alternative expression for a delayed logistic equation in which the rate of change in the population involves a growth rate that depends on the population density during an earlier time period. In our formulation, the delay in the growth term is consistent with the rate of instantaneous decline in the population given by the model. Our formulation is a modification of [Arino et al., J…
▽ More
We derive an alternative expression for a delayed logistic equation in which the rate of change in the population involves a growth rate that depends on the population density during an earlier time period. In our formulation, the delay in the growth term is consistent with the rate of instantaneous decline in the population given by the model. Our formulation is a modification of [Arino et al., J.~Theoret.~Biol.~241(1):109--119, 2006] by taking the intraspecific competition between the adults and juveniles into account. We provide a complete global analysis showing that no sustained oscillations are possible. A threshold giving the interface between extinction and survival is determined in terms of the parameters in the model. The theory of chain transitive sets and the comparison theorem for cooperative delay differential equations are used to determine the global dynamics of the model.
We extend our delayed logistic equation to a system modeling the competition of two species. For the competition model, we provide results on local stability, bifurcation diagrams, and adaptive dynamics. Assuming that the species with shorter delay produces fewer offspring at a time than the species with longer delay, we show that there is a critical value, $τ^*$, such that the evolutionary trend is for the delay to approach $τ^*$.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
An alternative delayed population growth difference equation model
Authors:
Sabrina H. Streipert,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
We propose an alternative delayed population growth difference equation model based on a modification of the Beverton-Holt recurrence, assuming a delay only in the growth contribution that takes into account that those individuals that die during the delay, do not contribute to growth. The model introduced differs from existing delay difference equations in population dynamics, such as the delayed…
▽ More
We propose an alternative delayed population growth difference equation model based on a modification of the Beverton-Holt recurrence, assuming a delay only in the growth contribution that takes into account that those individuals that die during the delay, do not contribute to growth. The model introduced differs from existing delay difference equations in population dynamics, such as the delayed logistic difference equation, which was formulated as a discretization of the Hutchinson model. The analysis of our delayed difference equation model identifies an important critical delay threshold. If the time delay exceeds this threshold, the model predicts that the population will go extinct for all non-negative initial conditions and if it is below this threshold, the population survives and its size converges to a positive globally asymptotically stable equilibrium that is decreasing in size as the delay increases. Firstly, we obtain the local stability results by exploiting the special structure of powers of the Jacobian matrix. Secondly, we show that local stability implies global stability using two different techniques. For one set of parameter values, a contraction mapping result is applied, while for the remaining set of parameter values, we show that the result follows by first proving that the recurrence structure is eventually monotonic in each of its arguments.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Chaotic dynamics in a simple predator-prey model with discrete delay
Authors:
Guihong Fan,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
A discrete delay is included to model the time between the capture of the prey and its conversion to viable biomass in the simplest classical Gause type predator-prey model that has equilibrium dynamics without delay. As the delay increases from zero, the coexistence equilibrium undergoes a supercritical Hopf bifurcation, two saddle-node bifurcations of limit cycles, and a cascade of period doubli…
▽ More
A discrete delay is included to model the time between the capture of the prey and its conversion to viable biomass in the simplest classical Gause type predator-prey model that has equilibrium dynamics without delay. As the delay increases from zero, the coexistence equilibrium undergoes a supercritical Hopf bifurcation, two saddle-node bifurcations of limit cycles, and a cascade of period doublings, eventu1ally leading to chaos. The resulting periodic orbits and the strange attractor resemble their counterparts for the Mackey-Glass equation. Due to the global stability of the system without delay, these complicated dynamics can be solely attributed to the introduction of the delay. Since many models include predator-prey like interactions as submodels, this study emphasizes the importance of understanding the implications of overlooking delay in such models on the reliability of the model-based predictions, especially since the temperature is known to have an effect on the length of certain delays.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Growth on multiple interactive-essential resources in a self-cycling fermentor: An impulsive differential equations approach
Authors:
Tyler Meadows,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
We introduce a model of the growth of a single microorganism in a self-cycling fermentor in which an arbitrary number of resources are limiting, and impulses are triggered when the concentration of one specific substrate reaches a predetermined level. The model is in the form of a system of impulsive differential equations. We consider the operation of the reactor to be successful if it cycles ind…
▽ More
We introduce a model of the growth of a single microorganism in a self-cycling fermentor in which an arbitrary number of resources are limiting, and impulses are triggered when the concentration of one specific substrate reaches a predetermined level. The model is in the form of a system of impulsive differential equations. We consider the operation of the reactor to be successful if it cycles indefinitely without human intervention and derive conditions for this to occur. In this case, the system of impulsive differential equations has a periodic solution. We show that success is equivalent to the convergence of solutions to this periodic solution. We provide conditions that ensure that a periodic solution exists. When it exists, it is unique and attracting. However, we also show that whether a solution converges to this periodic solution, and hence whether the model predicts that the reactor operates successfully, is initial condition dependent. The analysis is illustrated with numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
A qualitative study of an anaerobic food-web reveals the importance of hydrogen for microbial stability
Authors:
Szymon Sobieszek,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz,
Matthew J. Wade
Abstract:
The mathematical analysis of a three-tiered food-web describing anaerobic chlorophenol mineralisation has suggested the emergence of interesting dynamical behaviour through its specific ecological interactions, which include competition, syntrophy and product inhibition. Previous numerical analyses have revealed the possibility for a Hopf bifurcation occurring through the interior equilibrium and…
▽ More
The mathematical analysis of a three-tiered food-web describing anaerobic chlorophenol mineralisation has suggested the emergence of interesting dynamical behaviour through its specific ecological interactions, which include competition, syntrophy and product inhibition. Previous numerical analyses have revealed the possibility for a Hopf bifurcation occurring through the interior equilibrium and the role of extraneous substrate inputs in both mitigating the emergence of periodic solutions and expanding the desired stable positive steady-state, where full mineralisation occurs. Here we show that, for a generalised model, the inflow of multiple substrates results in greater dynamical complexity and prove the occurrence of a supercritical Hopf bifurcation resulting from variations in these operating parameters. Further, using numerical estimation, we also show that variations in the dilution rate can lead to Bogdanov-Takens and Bautin bifurcations. Finally, we are able to show apply persistence theory for a range of parameter sets to demonstrate unique persistence in the cases where chlorophenol and hydrogen are extraneously added to the system, mirroring recent applied studies highlighting the role of hydrogen in maintaining stable anaerobic microbial communities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Global analysis of a simplified model of anaerobic digestion and a new result for the chemostat
Authors:
Tyler Meadows,
Marion Weedermann,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
A. Bornhöft, R. Hanke-Rauschenbach, and K. Sundmacher, [Nonlinear Dyn., 73 (2013), pp. 535-549] introduced a qualitative simplification to the ADM1 model for anaerobic digestion. We obtain global results for this model by first analyzing the limiting system, a model of single species growth in the chemostat in which the response function is non-monotone and the species decay rate is included. Usin…
▽ More
A. Bornhöft, R. Hanke-Rauschenbach, and K. Sundmacher, [Nonlinear Dyn., 73 (2013), pp. 535-549] introduced a qualitative simplification to the ADM1 model for anaerobic digestion. We obtain global results for this model by first analyzing the limiting system, a model of single species growth in the chemostat in which the response function is non-monotone and the species decay rate is included. Using a Lyapunov function argument and the theory of asymptotically autonomous systems, we prove that even in the parameter regime where there is bistability, no periodic orbits exist and every solution converges to one of the equilibrium points. We then describe two algorithms for stochastically perturbing the parameters of the model. Simulations done with these two algorithms are compared with simulations done using the Gillespie and tau-leaping algorithms. They illustrate the severe impact environmental factors may have on anaerobic digestion in the transient phase.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
A Criterion for the Existence of Relaxation Oscillations with Applications to Predator-Prey Systems and an Epidemic Model
Authors:
Ting-Hao Hsu,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
We derive characteristic functions to determine the number and stability of relaxation oscillations for a class of planar systems. Applying our criterion, we give conditions under which the chemostat predator-prey system has a globally orbitally asymptotically stable limit cycle. Also we demonstrate that a prescribed number of relaxation oscillations can be constructed by varying the perturbation…
▽ More
We derive characteristic functions to determine the number and stability of relaxation oscillations for a class of planar systems. Applying our criterion, we give conditions under which the chemostat predator-prey system has a globally orbitally asymptotically stable limit cycle. Also we demonstrate that a prescribed number of relaxation oscillations can be constructed by varying the perturbation for an epidemic model studied by Li et al. [SIAM J. Appl. Math, 2016].
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019; v1 submitted 19 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Growth on Two Limiting Essential Resources in a Self-Cycling Fermentor
Authors:
Ting-Hao Hsu,
Tyler Meadows,
Lin Wang,
Gail S. K. Wolkowicz
Abstract:
A system of impulsive differential equations with state-dependent impulses is used to model the growth of a single population on two limiting essential resources in a self-cycling fermentor. Potential applications include water purification and biological waste remediation. The self-cycling fermentation process is a semi-batch process and the model is an example of a hybrid system. In this case, a…
▽ More
A system of impulsive differential equations with state-dependent impulses is used to model the growth of a single population on two limiting essential resources in a self-cycling fermentor. Potential applications include water purification and biological waste remediation. The self-cycling fermentation process is a semi-batch process and the model is an example of a hybrid system. In this case, a well-stirred tank is partially drained, and subsequently refilled using fresh medium when the concentration of both resources (assumed to be pollutants) falls below some acceptable threshold. We consider the process successful if the threshold for emptying/refilling the reactor can be reached indefinitely without the time between successive emptying/refillings becoming unbounded and without interference by the operator. We prove that whenever the process is successful, the model predicts that the concentrations of the population and the resources converge to a positive periodic solution. We derive conditions for the successful operation of the process that are shown to be initial condition dependent and prove that if these conditions are not satisfied, then the reactor fails. We show numerically that there is an optimal fraction of the medium drained from the tank at each impulse that maximizes the output of the process.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
