Subthreshold Jitter in VR Can Induce Visual Discomfort
Authors:
Samuel J. Levulis,
Kevin W. Rio,
Pablo Ramon Soria,
James Wilmott,
Charlie S. Burlingham,
Phillip Guan
Abstract:
Visual-vestibular conflicts (VVCs) are a primary contributor to visually induced motion sickness (VIMS) in head-mounted displays (HMDs). However, virtual reality (VR) comfort studies often rely on exposing seated or standing users to experiences with high intensity visual motion (such as roller coasters). These drastic VVCs tend to induce pronounced VIMS symptoms that can be reliably detected acro…
▽ More
Visual-vestibular conflicts (VVCs) are a primary contributor to visually induced motion sickness (VIMS) in head-mounted displays (HMDs). However, virtual reality (VR) comfort studies often rely on exposing seated or standing users to experiences with high intensity visual motion (such as roller coasters). These drastic VVCs tend to induce pronounced VIMS symptoms that can be reliably detected across individuals using common survey measures. The conclusions from studies using these extreme motion-based conflicts may not accurately generalize to naturalistic use cases in VR where efforts are made to minimize, rather than maximize, VIMS symptoms. In this work, we show that a subthreshold visual-vestibular conflict can induce measurable discomfort during naturalistic, long duration use. We first present a psychophysical study, conducted outside of an HMD, to rigorously identify the perceptual thresholds for sinusoidal noise in render pose (i.e., jitter) resulting in erroneous 3D motion of rendered content. We next introduce subthreshold levels of jitter to a Meta Quest 3 VR HMD and demonstrate that this can induce visual discomfort in participants playing the commercially-available game Cubism across a three-session, repeated-measures study. Importantly, we did not identify statistically significant comfort differences between control and jitter conditions with traditional pre- and post-test comparison of Simulator Sickness Questionnaire (SSQ) scores. Significant differences were only identified using the Motion Illness Symptoms Classification (MISC) survey administered every 10 minutes across each 90 minute session. This highlights the benefits of incorporating time-resolved data points and suggests that lightweight, more frequent surveys may be important tools for measuring visual discomfort in more ecologically-valid scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2025; v1 submitted 22 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
VR.net: A Real-world Dataset for Virtual Reality Motion Sickness Research
Authors:
Elliott Wen,
Chitralekha Gupta,
Prasanth Sasikumar,
Mark Billinghurst,
James Wilmott,
Emily Skow,
Arindam Dey,
Suranga Nanayakkara
Abstract:
Researchers have used machine learning approaches to identify motion sickness in VR experience. These approaches demand an accurately-labeled, real-world, and diverse dataset for high accuracy and generalizability. As a starting point to address this need, we introduce `VR.net', a dataset offering approximately 12-hour gameplay videos from ten real-world games in 10 diverse genres. For each video…
▽ More
Researchers have used machine learning approaches to identify motion sickness in VR experience. These approaches demand an accurately-labeled, real-world, and diverse dataset for high accuracy and generalizability. As a starting point to address this need, we introduce `VR.net', a dataset offering approximately 12-hour gameplay videos from ten real-world games in 10 diverse genres. For each video frame, a rich set of motion sickness-related labels, such as camera/object movement, depth field, and motion flow, are accurately assigned. Building such a dataset is challenging since manual labeling would require an infeasible amount of time. Instead, we utilize a tool to automatically and precisely extract ground truth data from 3D engines' rendering pipelines without accessing VR games' source code. We illustrate the utility of VR.net through several applications, such as risk factor detection and sickness level prediction. We continuously expand VR.net and envision its next version offering 10X more data than the current form. We believe that the scale, accuracy, and diversity of VR.net can offer unparalleled opportunities for VR motion sickness research and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
