-
A simple multistage theory for multimorbidity
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster
Abstract:
It is shown how observational data of disease incidence can be used to determine whether two diseases can have a ``shared stage'' or ``step'', before either disease can occur, and how the unobserved rate of this step can be determined. The approach is in principle quite general, and illustrated with specific examples using simplified multistage models of disease. It offers a simple approach for st…
▽ More
It is shown how observational data of disease incidence can be used to determine whether two diseases can have a ``shared stage'' or ``step'', before either disease can occur, and how the unobserved rate of this step can be determined. The approach is in principle quite general, and illustrated with specific examples using simplified multistage models of disease. It offers a simple approach for studying multiple diseases in an individual, and for identifying the underlying causes of multiple conditions. This includes studies for two or more cancer types. The fundamental mathematical model is analysed to compare key statistical properties such as the expectation and variance with those of independent diseases, and its properties are illustrated with specific examples. Despite the complex nature of models that study multiple conditions, the most important general results do not need an understanding of the underlying mathematics and can be appreciated by a non-expert.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
When can relative risks provide causal estimates?
Authors:
A. J. Webster
Abstract:
It is emphasised that for epidemiological studies where disease incidence is rare, results from conventional proportional hazards models can often correctly estimate causal associations. The well-known "backdoor criteria" from causal-inference is applied to the common epidemiological study of rare diseases with a proportional hazards model, providing an example of when and how estimates from conve…
▽ More
It is emphasised that for epidemiological studies where disease incidence is rare, results from conventional proportional hazards models can often correctly estimate causal associations. The well-known "backdoor criteria" from causal-inference is applied to the common epidemiological study of rare diseases with a proportional hazards model, providing an example of when and how estimates from conventional proportional hazards studies can be used. A similar study with the "frontdoor criteria", that allows studies with unmeasured confounders, finds similar results to conventional mediation analysis with measured confounders. Reasons for this are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Bayesian information criteria for clustering normally distributed data
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster
Abstract:
Maximum likelihood estimates (MLEs) are asymptotically normally distributed, and this property is used in meta-analyses to test the heterogeneity of estimates, either for a single cluster or for several sub-groups. More recently, MLEs for associations between risk factors and diseases have been hierarchically clustered to search for diseases with shared underlying causes, but an objective statisti…
▽ More
Maximum likelihood estimates (MLEs) are asymptotically normally distributed, and this property is used in meta-analyses to test the heterogeneity of estimates, either for a single cluster or for several sub-groups. More recently, MLEs for associations between risk factors and diseases have been hierarchically clustered to search for diseases with shared underlying causes, but an objective statistical criterion is needed to determine the number and composition of clusters. To tackle this problem, conventional statistical tests are briefly reviewed, before considering the posterior distribution for a partition of data into clusters. The posterior distribution is calculated by marginalising out the unknown cluster centres, and is different to the likelihood associated with mixture models. The calculation is equivalent to that used to obtain the Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC), but is exact, without a Laplace approximation. The result includes a sum of squares term, and terms that depend on the number and composition of clusters, that penalise the number of free parameters in the model. The usual BIC is shown to be unsuitable for clustering applications unless the number of items in each individual cluster is sufficiently large.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2022; v1 submitted 10 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Multi-stage models for the failure of complex systems, cascading disasters, and the onset of disease
Authors:
A. J. Webster
Abstract:
Complex systems can fail through different routes, often progressing through a series of (rate-limiting) steps and modified by environmental exposures. The onset of disease, cancer in particular, is no different. Multi-stage models provide a simple but very general mathematical framework for studying the failure of complex systems, or equivalently, the onset of disease. They include the Armitage D…
▽ More
Complex systems can fail through different routes, often progressing through a series of (rate-limiting) steps and modified by environmental exposures. The onset of disease, cancer in particular, is no different. Multi-stage models provide a simple but very general mathematical framework for studying the failure of complex systems, or equivalently, the onset of disease. They include the Armitage Doll multi-stage cancer model as a particular case, and have potential to provide new insights into how failures and disease, arise and progress. A method described by E.T. Jaynes is developed to provide an analytical solution for a large class of these models, and highlights connections between the convolution of Laplace transforms, sums of random variables, and Schwinger/Feynman parameterisations. Examples include: exact solutions to the Armitage-Doll model, the sum of Gamma-distributed variables with integer-valued shape parameters, a clonal-growth cancer model, and a model for cascading disasters. Applications and limitations of the approach are discussed in the context of recent cancer research. The model is sufficiently general to be used in many contexts, such as engineering, project management, disease progression, and disaster risk for example, allowing the estimation of failure rates in complex systems and projects. The intended result is a mathematical toolkit for applying multi-stage models to the study of failure rates in complex systems and to the onset of disease, cancer in particular.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2019; v1 submitted 22 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
A global consumer-led strategy to tackle climate change
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster
Abstract:
A successful response to climate change needs vast investments in low-carbon research, energy, and sustainable development. Governments can drive research, provide environmental regulation, and accelerate global development, but the necessary low-carbon investments of 2-3% GDP have yet to materialise. A new strategy to tackle climate change through consumer and government action is outlined. It re…
▽ More
A successful response to climate change needs vast investments in low-carbon research, energy, and sustainable development. Governments can drive research, provide environmental regulation, and accelerate global development, but the necessary low-carbon investments of 2-3% GDP have yet to materialise. A new strategy to tackle climate change through consumer and government action is outlined. It relies on ethical investments for sustainable development and low-carbon energy, and a voluntarily financed low-carbon fund for adaptation to climate change. Together these enable a global response through individual actions and investments. With OECD savings exceeding 5% of disposable household income, ethical savings alone have considerable potential.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2018; v1 submitted 9 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Lightning Strikes and Attribution of Climatic Change
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster
Abstract:
Using lightning strikes as an example, two possible schemes are discussed for the attribution of changes in event frequency to climate change, and estimating the cost associated with them. The schemes determine the fraction of events that should be attributed to climatic change, and the fraction that should be attributed to natural chance. They both allow for the expected increase in claims and th…
▽ More
Using lightning strikes as an example, two possible schemes are discussed for the attribution of changes in event frequency to climate change, and estimating the cost associated with them. The schemes determine the fraction of events that should be attributed to climatic change, and the fraction that should be attributed to natural chance. They both allow for the expected increase in claims and the fluctuations about this expected value. Importantly, the attribution fraction proposed in the second of these schemes is necessarily different to that found in epidemiological studies. This ensures that the statistically expected fraction of attributed claims is correctly equal to the expected increase in claims. The analysis of lightning data highlights two particular difficulties with data-driven, as opposed to modeled, attribution studies. The first is the possibility of unknown "confounding" variables that can influence the strike frequency. This is partly accounted for here by considering the influence of temperature changes within a given month, so as to standardise the data to allow for cyclical climatic influences. The second is the possibility suggested by the data presented here, that climate change may lead to qualitatively different climate patterns, with a different relationship between e.g. strike frequency and temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
An Insurance-Led Response to Climate Change
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster,
Richard H. Clarke
Abstract:
Climate change is widely expected to increase weather related damage and the insurance claims that result from it. This will increase insurance premiums, in a way that is independent of a customer's contribution to the causes of climate change. Insurance provides a financial mechanism that mitigates some of the consequences of climate change, allowing damage from increasingly frequent events to be…
▽ More
Climate change is widely expected to increase weather related damage and the insurance claims that result from it. This will increase insurance premiums, in a way that is independent of a customer's contribution to the causes of climate change. Insurance provides a financial mechanism that mitigates some of the consequences of climate change, allowing damage from increasingly frequent events to be repaired. We observe that the insurance industry could reclaim any increase in claims due to climate change, by increasing the insurance premiums on energy producers for example, without needing government intervention or a new tax. We argue that this insurance-led levy must acknowledge both present carbon emissions and a modern industry's carbon inheritance, that is, to recognise that fossil-fuel driven industrial growth has provided the innovations and conditions needed for modern civilisation to exist and develop. A tax or levy on energy production is one mechanism that would recognise carbon inheritance through the increased (energy) costs for manufacturing and using modern technology, and can also provide an incentive to minimise carbon emissions, through higher costs for the most polluting industries. The necessary increases in insurance premiums would initially be small, and will require an event attribution (EA) methodology to determine their size. We propose that the levies can be phased in as the science of event attribution becomes sufficiently robust for each claim type, to ultimately provide a global insurance-led response to climate change.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2017; v1 submitted 3 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
The unintended influence of control systems on edge-plasma transport and stability in the Joint European Torus
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
J. Morris,
T. N. Todd,
S. Brezinsek,
JET EFDA Contributors
Abstract:
A unique experiment in the Joint European Torus (JET) consecutively produced 120 almost identical plasma pulses, providing two orders of magnitude more data than is usually available. This allows the statistical detection of previously unobservable phenomena such as a sequence of resonant-like waiting times between edge-localised instabilities (ELMs). Here we investigate the causes of this phenome…
▽ More
A unique experiment in the Joint European Torus (JET) consecutively produced 120 almost identical plasma pulses, providing two orders of magnitude more data than is usually available. This allows the statistical detection of previously unobservable phenomena such as a sequence of resonant-like waiting times between edge-localised instabilities (ELMs). Here we investigate the causes of this phenomenon. By synchronising data to the 1000s of ELM times and averaging the results, random errors are reduced by a factor of 50, allowing unprecedentedly detailed behaviour to be described. A clear link can then be observed between plasma confinement, ELM occurrence, vertical plasma oscillations, and an otherwise unobservable oscillation in a control coil current that is not usually associated with ELM occurrence. The results suggest a strong and unanticipated edge-plasma dependence on control system behaviour.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.
-
Distinguishing Cause from Correlation in Tokamak Experiments to Trigger Edge Localised Plasma Instabilities
Authors:
A. J. Webster
Abstract:
The generic question is considered: How can we determine the probability of an otherwise quasirandom event, having been triggered by an external influence? A specific problem is the quantification of the success of techniques to trigger, and hence control, edge-localised plasma instabilities (ELMs) in magnetically confined fusion (MCF) experiments. The development of such techniques is essential t…
▽ More
The generic question is considered: How can we determine the probability of an otherwise quasirandom event, having been triggered by an external influence? A specific problem is the quantification of the success of techniques to trigger, and hence control, edge-localised plasma instabilities (ELMs) in magnetically confined fusion (MCF) experiments. The development of such techniques is essential to ensure tolerable heat loads on components in large MCF fusion devices, and is necessary for their development into economically successful power plants. Bayesian probability theory is used to rigorously formulate the problem and to provide a formal solution. Accurate but pragmatic methods are developed to estimate triggering probabilities, and are illustrated with experimental data. These allow results from experiments to be quantitatively assessed, and rigorously quantified conclusions to be formed. Example applications include assessing whether triggering of ELMs is a statistical or deterministic process, and the establishment of thresholds to ensure that ELMs are reliably triggered.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2014; v1 submitted 10 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
ELM Processes and Properties in 2T 2MA JET Plasmas
Authors:
Anthony J. Webster,
Stephen J. Webster,
EFDA JET Contributors
Abstract:
During July 2012, 150 almost identical H-mode plasmas were consecutively created in the Joint European Torus (JET), providing a combined total of approximately 8 minutes of steady-state plasma with 15,000 Edge Localised Modes (ELMs). In principle, each of those 15,000 ELMs are statistically equivalent. Here the changes in edge density and plasma energy associated with those ELMs are explored, usin…
▽ More
During July 2012, 150 almost identical H-mode plasmas were consecutively created in the Joint European Torus (JET), providing a combined total of approximately 8 minutes of steady-state plasma with 15,000 Edge Localised Modes (ELMs). In principle, each of those 15,000 ELMs are statistically equivalent. Here the changes in edge density and plasma energy associated with those ELMs are explored, using the spikes in Beryllium II (527 nm) radiation as an indicator for the onset of an ELM. Two timescales are found during the ELM process. The first timescale is associated with the density drop, and the second (longer) timescale is associated with a reduction in MHD energy that is consistent with a resistive relaxation of the plasma's edge. The statistical properties of the energy and density losses due to the ELMs are explored. Surprisingly the commonly reported link between ELM energy (E) and ELM frequency (f), of E proportional to 1/f, is not found. Instead beyond the first 0.02 seconds of waiting time between ELMs, the energy losses due to the ELMs are found to be statistically the same. Surprisingly no correlation is found between the energies of consecutive ELMs either. A weak link is found between the density drop and the ELM waiting time. Consequences of these results for ELM control and modelling are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2014; v1 submitted 8 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Time-Resonant Tokamak Plasma Edge Instabilities?
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
R. O. Dendy,
F. A. Calderon,
S. C. Chapman,
E. Delabie,
D. Dodt,
R. Felton,
T. N. Todd,
F. Maviglia,
J. Morris,
V. Riccardo,
B. Alper,
S Brezinsek,
P. Coad,
J. Likonen,
M. Rubel,
JET EFDA Contributors
Abstract:
For a two week period during the Joint European Torus (JET) 2012 experimental campaign, the same high confinement plasma was repeated 151 times. The dataset was analysed to produce a probability density function (pdf) for the waiting times between edge-localised plasma instabilities ("ELMS"). The result was entirely unexpected. Instead of a smooth single peaked pdf, a succession of 4-5 sharp maxim…
▽ More
For a two week period during the Joint European Torus (JET) 2012 experimental campaign, the same high confinement plasma was repeated 151 times. The dataset was analysed to produce a probability density function (pdf) for the waiting times between edge-localised plasma instabilities ("ELMS"). The result was entirely unexpected. Instead of a smooth single peaked pdf, a succession of 4-5 sharp maxima and minima uniformly separated by 7-8 millisecond intervals was found. Here we explore the causes of this newly observed phenomenon, and conclude that it is either due to a self-organised plasma phenomenon or an interaction between the plasma and a real-time control system. If the maxima are a result of "resonant" frequencies at which ELMs can be triggered more easily, then future ELM control techniques can, and probably will, use them. Either way, these results demand a deeper understanding of the ELMing process.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Calculation of Exact Estimators by Integration Over the Surface of an n-Dimensional Sphere
Authors:
Anthony J Webster
Abstract:
This paper reconsiders the problem of calculating the expected set of probabilities <p_i>, given the observed set of items {m_i}, that are distributed among n bins with an (unknown) set of probabilities {p_i} for being placed in the ith bin. The problem is often formulated using Bayes theorem and the multinomial distribution, along with a constant prior for the values of the p_i, leading to a Diri…
▽ More
This paper reconsiders the problem of calculating the expected set of probabilities <p_i>, given the observed set of items {m_i}, that are distributed among n bins with an (unknown) set of probabilities {p_i} for being placed in the ith bin. The problem is often formulated using Bayes theorem and the multinomial distribution, along with a constant prior for the values of the p_i, leading to a Dirichlet distribution for the {p_i}. The moments of the p_i can then be calculated exactly. Here a new approach is suggested for the calculation of the moments, that uses a change of variables that reduces the problem to an integration over a portion of the surface of an n-dimensional sphere. This greatly simplifies the calculation by allowing a straightforward integration over (n-1) independent variables, with the constraints on the set of p_i being automatically satisfied. For the Dirichlet and similar distributions the problem simplifies even further, with the resulting integrals subsequently factorising, allowing their easy evaluation in terms of Beta functions. A proof by induction confirms existing calculations for the moments. The advantage of the approach presented here is that the methods and results apply with minimum or no modifications to numerical calculations that involve more complicated distributions or non-constant prior distributions, for which cases the numerical calculations will be greatly simplified.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Identifying low-dimensional dynamics in Type-I edge-localised-mode processes in JET plasmas
Authors:
F. A. Calderon,
R. O. Dendy,
S. C. Chapman,
A. J. Webster,
B. Alper,
R. M. Nicol,
JET EFDA Contributors
Abstract:
Edge localised mode (ELM) measurements from reproducibly similar plasmas in the Joint European Torus (JET) tokamak, which differ only in their gas puffing rate, are analysed in terms of the pattern in the sequence of inter-ELM time intervals. It is found that the category of ELM defined empirically as Type I - typically more regular, less frequent, and having larger amplitude than other ELM types…
▽ More
Edge localised mode (ELM) measurements from reproducibly similar plasmas in the Joint European Torus (JET) tokamak, which differ only in their gas puffing rate, are analysed in terms of the pattern in the sequence of inter-ELM time intervals. It is found that the category of ELM defined empirically as Type I - typically more regular, less frequent, and having larger amplitude than other ELM types - embraces substantially different ELMing processes. By quantifying the structure in the sequence of inter-ELM time intervals using delay time plots, we reveal transitions between distinct phase space dynamics, implying transitions between distinct underlying physical processes. The control parameter for these transitions between these different ELMing processes is the gas puffing rate.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2013;
originally announced April 2013.
-
Statistical Characterisation and Classification of Edge Localised Plasma Instabilities
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
R. O. Dendy
Abstract:
The statistics of edge-localised plasma instabilities (ELMs) in toroidal magnetically confined fusion plasmas are considered. From first principles, standard experimentally motivated assumptions are shown to determine a specific probability distribution for the waiting times between ELMs: the Weibull distribution. This is confirmed empirically by a statistically rigorous comparison with a large da…
▽ More
The statistics of edge-localised plasma instabilities (ELMs) in toroidal magnetically confined fusion plasmas are considered. From first principles, standard experimentally motivated assumptions are shown to determine a specific probability distribution for the waiting times between ELMs: the Weibull distribution. This is confirmed empirically by a statistically rigorous comparison with a large data set from the Joint European Torus (JET). The successful characterisation of ELM waiting times enables future work to progress in various ways. Here we present a quantitative classification of ELM types, complementary to phenomenological approaches. It also informs us about the nature of ELMing processes, such as whether they are random or deterministic.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Estimating Omissions from Searches
Authors:
Anthony J Webster,
Richard Kemp
Abstract:
The mark-recapture method was devised by Petersen in 1896 to estimate the number of fish migrating into the Limfjord, and independently by Lincoln in 1930 to estimate waterfowl abundance. The technique applies to any search for a finite number of items by two or more people or agents, allowing the number of searched-for items to be estimated. This ubiquitous problem appears in fields from ecology…
▽ More
The mark-recapture method was devised by Petersen in 1896 to estimate the number of fish migrating into the Limfjord, and independently by Lincoln in 1930 to estimate waterfowl abundance. The technique applies to any search for a finite number of items by two or more people or agents, allowing the number of searched-for items to be estimated. This ubiquitous problem appears in fields from ecology and epidemiology, through to mathematics, social sciences, and computing. Here we exactly calculate the moments of the hypergeometric distribution associated with this long-standing problem, confirming that widely used estimates conjectured in 1951 are often too small. Our Bayesian approach highlights how different search strategies will modify the estimates. As an example, we assess the accuracy of a systematic literature review, an application we recommend.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2013; v1 submitted 5 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
-
Magnetohydrodynamic Stability at a Separatrix: Part II
Authors:
A. J. Webster
Abstract:
In the first part to this paper\cite{part1} it was shown how a simple Magnetohydrodynamic model could be used to determine the stability of a Tokamak plasma's edge to a Peeling (External Kink) mode. Stability was found to be determined by the value of $Δ'$, a normalised measure of the discontinuity in the radial derivative of the radial perturbation to the magnetic field at the plasma-vacuum int…
▽ More
In the first part to this paper\cite{part1} it was shown how a simple Magnetohydrodynamic model could be used to determine the stability of a Tokamak plasma's edge to a Peeling (External Kink) mode. Stability was found to be determined by the value of $Δ'$, a normalised measure of the discontinuity in the radial derivative of the radial perturbation to the magnetic field at the plasma-vacuum interface. Here we calculate $Δ'$, but in a way that avoids the numerical divergences that can arise near a separatrice's X-point. This is accomplished by showing how the method of conformal transformations may be generalised to allow their application to systems with a non-zero boundary condition, and using the technique to obtain analytic expressions for both the vacuum energy and $Δ'$. A conformal transformation is used again to obtain an equilibrium vacuum field surrounding a plasma with a separatrix. This allows the subsequent evaluation of the vacuum energy and $Δ'$. For a plasma-vacuum boundary that approximates a separatrix, the growth rate $γ$ normalised by the Aflven frequency $γ_A$ is then found to have $\ln(γ/γ_A)=-{1/2} \ln (q'/q)$. Consequences for Peeling mode stability are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Magnetohydrodynamic Stability at a Separatrix: Part I
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
C. G. Gimblett
Abstract:
The rapid deposition of energy by Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) onto plasma facing components, is a potentially serious issue for large Tokamaks such as ITER and DEMO. The trigger for ELMs is believed to be the ideal Magnetohydrodynamic Peeling-Ballooning instability, but recent numerical calculations have suggested that a plasma equilibrium with an X-point - as is found in all ITER-like Tokamaks,…
▽ More
The rapid deposition of energy by Edge Localised Modes (ELMs) onto plasma facing components, is a potentially serious issue for large Tokamaks such as ITER and DEMO. The trigger for ELMs is believed to be the ideal Magnetohydrodynamic Peeling-Ballooning instability, but recent numerical calculations have suggested that a plasma equilibrium with an X-point - as is found in all ITER-like Tokamaks, is stable to the Peeling mode. This contrasts with analytical calculations (G. Laval, R. Pellat, J. S. Soule, Phys Fluids, {\bf 17}, 835, (1974)), that found the Peeling mode to be unstable in cylindrical plasmas with arbitrary cross-sectional shape. However the analytical calculation only applies to a Tokamak plasma in a cylindrical approximation. Here, we re-examine the assumptions made in cylindrical geometry calculations, and generalise the calculation to an arbitrary Tokamak geometry at marginal stability. The resulting equations solely describe the Peeling mode, and are not complicated by coupling to the ballooning mode, for example. We find that stability is determined by the value of a single parameter $Δ'$ that is the poloidal average of the normalised jump in the radial derivative of the perturbed magnetic field's normal component. We also find that near a separatrix it is possible for the energy principle's $δW$ to be negative (that is usually taken to indicate that the mode is unstable, as in the cylindrical theory), but the growth rate to be arbitrarily small.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Osmotic Stabilisation of Concentrated Emulsions and Foams
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
M. E. Cates
Abstract:
In the absence of coalescence, coarsening of emulsions (and foams) is controlled by molecular diffusion of dispersed phase between droplets/bubbles. Studies of dilute emulsions have shown how the osmotic pressure of a trapped species within droplets can ``osmotically stabilise'' the emulsion. Webster and Cates (Langmuir, 1998, 14, 2068-2079) gave rigorous criteria for osmotic stabilisation of mo…
▽ More
In the absence of coalescence, coarsening of emulsions (and foams) is controlled by molecular diffusion of dispersed phase between droplets/bubbles. Studies of dilute emulsions have shown how the osmotic pressure of a trapped species within droplets can ``osmotically stabilise'' the emulsion. Webster and Cates (Langmuir, 1998, 14, 2068-2079) gave rigorous criteria for osmotic stabilisation of mono- and polydisperse emulsions, in the dilute regime. We consider here whether analogous criteria exist for the osmotic stabilisation of mono- and polydisperse concentrated emulsions and foams, and suggest that the pressure differences driving coarsening are small compared to the mean Laplace pressure. An exact calculation confirms this for a monodisperse 2D model, finding a bubble's pressure as P_i = P + Pi + P_i^G, with P, Pi the atmospheric and osmotic pressures, and P_i^G a ``geometric pressure'' that reduces to the Laplace pressure only for a spherical bubble. For Princen's 2D emulsion model, P_i^G is only 5% larger in the dry limit than the dilute limit. We conclude that osmotic stabilisation of dense systems typically requires a pressure of trapped molecules in each droplet that is comparable to the Laplace pressures the same droplets would have if spherical, as opposed to the much larger Laplace pressures present in the system. We study coarsening of foams and concentrated emulsions when there is insufficient of the trapped species present. Rate-limiting mechanisms are considered, their applicability and associated droplet growth rates discussed. In a concentrated foam or emulsion, a finite yield threshold for droplet rearrangement may be enough to prevent coarsening of the remainder.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
-
Stabilisation of Emulsions by Trapped Species
Authors:
A. J. Webster,
M. E. Cates
Abstract:
We consider an emulsion whose droplets contain a trapped species (insoluble in the continuous phase), and study the emulsion's stability against coarsening via Lifshitz-Slyozov dynamics (Ostwald Ripening). Extending an earlier treatment by Kabalnov et al(Colloids and Surfaces, 24,(1987), 19-32), we derive a general condition on the mean initial droplet volume which ensures stability, even when a…
▽ More
We consider an emulsion whose droplets contain a trapped species (insoluble in the continuous phase), and study the emulsion's stability against coarsening via Lifshitz-Slyozov dynamics (Ostwald Ripening). Extending an earlier treatment by Kabalnov et al(Colloids and Surfaces, 24,(1987), 19-32), we derive a general condition on the mean initial droplet volume which ensures stability, even when arbitrary polydispersity is present in both size and composition of the initial droplets. We distinguish "nucleated" coarsening, which requires either fluctuations about the mean field equations or a tail in the initial droplet size distribution, from "spinodal" coarsening in which a typical droplet is locally unstable. A weaker condition for stability, previously suggested by Kabalnov et al., is sufficient only to prevent "spinodal" coarsening and is best viewed as a condition for metastability. The coarsening of unstable emulsions is considered, and shown at long times to resemble that of ordinary emulsions (with no trapped species), but with a reduced value of the initial volume fraction of dispersed phase. We discuss the physical principles relevant to the stability of emulsions with trapped species, describing how these may be exploited to restabilise partially coarsened emulsions and to "shrink" previously formed emulsion droplets to form "miniemulsions".
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 1998; v1 submitted 13 January, 1998;
originally announced January 1998.
