-
Granular surface flows confined between flat, frictional walls. Part 1. Kinematics
Authors:
Patrick Richard,
Alexandre Valance,
Renaud Delannay,
Philippe Boltenhagen
Abstract:
We report and analyse the results of extensive discrete element method simulations of three-dimensional gravity driven flows of cohesionless granular media over an erodible bed, the whole being confined between two flat and frictional sidewalls. We focus on the role of sidewalls by performing simulations for different gap widths ($W$) between the two confining sidewalls: from $5$ to $30$ grain siz…
▽ More
We report and analyse the results of extensive discrete element method simulations of three-dimensional gravity driven flows of cohesionless granular media over an erodible bed, the whole being confined between two flat and frictional sidewalls. We focus on the role of sidewalls by performing simulations for different gap widths ($W$) between the two confining sidewalls: from $5$ to $30$ grain sizes ($d$). Our results indicate the existence of two distinct regimes: regime I for flow angles smaller than the critical angle $θ_c\approx 40^\circ$ and regime II at flow angles larger than $θ_c$ . Regime I corresponds to dense flows whereas flows belonging to regime II exhibit a strong variation of the volume fraction through the depth. Three relevant lengths are identified in the system: $W$ the gap between sidewalls, $l$ the length characterizing the vertical variation of the volume fraction and $h$ a characteristic length associated with the vertical variation of the streamwise velocity. Using these lengths we can rescale the profiles of various flow properties (e.g. streamwise velocity, granular temperature, particle rotation...). In regime II, in contrast to regime I, $l$ and $h$ have a similar behaviour. As a consequence, the rescaled profiles in regime II only involve $h$ (or equivalently $l$) and $W$ . Other dissimilarities exist between regimes I and II. In particular, the scaling of the flow rate with $h$ (at fixed $W$ ) differs in the two regimes, although they display a similar scaling with $W$ (at fixed flow angle).
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2022; v1 submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Experimental assessment of the effective friction at the base of granular chute flows on smooth incline
Authors:
Olivier Roche,
Siet van den Wildenberg,
Alexandre Valance,
Renaud Delannay,
Anne Mangeney,
Lucas Corna,
Thierry Latchimy
Abstract:
We report on direct measurements of the basal force components for granular material flowing down a smooth incline. We investigate granular flows for a large range of inclination angles from teta=13.4° to 83.6° and various gate opening of the chute. We find that the effective basal friction coefficient, muB, obtained from the ratio of the longitudinal force to the normal one exhibits a systematic…
▽ More
We report on direct measurements of the basal force components for granular material flowing down a smooth incline. We investigate granular flows for a large range of inclination angles from teta=13.4° to 83.6° and various gate opening of the chute. We find that the effective basal friction coefficient, muB, obtained from the ratio of the longitudinal force to the normal one exhibits a systematic increase with increasing slope angle and a significant weakening with increasing particle hold-up H (the depth-integrated particle volume fraction). At low angles, the basal friction is slightly less than or equal to tan(teta). The deviation from tan(teta) can be interpreted as a contribution from the side-wall to the overall friction. At larger angles, the basal friction muB saturates at an asymptotic value that is dependent on the gate opening of the chute. Importantly, our data confirm the outcomes of recent discrete numerical simulations. First, for steady and fully developed flows as well as for moderately accelerated ones, the variation of the basal friction can be captured through a unique dimensionless number, the Froude number Fr, defined as Fr=U/(gHcos(teta))^1/2, where U is the mean flow velocity. Second, the mean velocity scales with the particle hold-up H with a power exponent close to 1/4, contrasting with the Bagnold scaling (U~H^3/2).
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Influence of lateral confinement on granular flows: comparison between shear-driven and gravity-driven flows
Authors:
Patrick Richard,
Riccardo Artoni,
Alexandre Valance,
Renaud Delannay
Abstract:
The properties of confined granular flows are studied through discrete numerical simulations. Two types of flows with different boundaries are compared: (i) gravity-driven flows topped with a free surface and over a base where erosion balances accretion (ii) shear-driven flows with a constant pressure applied at their top and a bumpy bottom moving at constant velocity. In both cases we observe she…
▽ More
The properties of confined granular flows are studied through discrete numerical simulations. Two types of flows with different boundaries are compared: (i) gravity-driven flows topped with a free surface and over a base where erosion balances accretion (ii) shear-driven flows with a constant pressure applied at their top and a bumpy bottom moving at constant velocity. In both cases we observe shear localization over or/and under a creep zone. We show that, although the different boundaries induce different flow properties (e.g. shear localization of transverse velocity profiles), the two types of flow share common properties like (i) a power law relation between the granular temperature and the shear rate (whose exponent varies from 1 for dense flows to 2 for dilute flows) and (ii) a weakening of friction at the sidewalls which gradually decreases with the depth within the flow.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
High-speed confined granular flows down inclines revisited
Authors:
Y. Zhu,
R. Delannay,
A. Valance
Abstract:
Recent numerical work has shown that high-speed confined granular flows down inclines exhibit a rich variety of flow patterns, including dense unidirectional flows, flows with longitudinal vortices and supported flows characterized by a dense core surrounded by a dilute hot granular gas (Brodu et al, JFM 2015). Here, we revisit the results obtained by Brodu et al. (JFM, 2015) and present new featu…
▽ More
Recent numerical work has shown that high-speed confined granular flows down inclines exhibit a rich variety of flow patterns, including dense unidirectional flows, flows with longitudinal vortices and supported flows characterized by a dense core surrounded by a dilute hot granular gas (Brodu et al, JFM 2015). Here, we revisit the results obtained by Brodu et al. (JFM, 2015) and present new features characterizing these flows. In particular, we provide vertical and transverse profiles for the packing fraction, velocity and granular temperature.We also characterize carefully the transition between the different flow regimes and show that the packing fraction and the vorticity can be successfully used to describe these transitions. Additionally, we emphasize that the effective friction at the basal and side walls can be described by a unique function of a dimensionless number which is the analog of a Froude number: $Fr=V/\sqrt{gH\cos θ}$ where $V$ is the particle velocity at the walls, $θ$ is the inclination angle and $H$ the particle holdup (defined as the depth-integrated particle volume fraction). This universal function bears some similarities with the $μ(I)$ rheological curve derived for dense granular flows.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Grain-scale Modeling and Splash Parametrization for Aeolian Sand Transport
Authors:
Marc Lämmel,
Kamil Dzikowski,
Luc Oger,
Alexandre Valance,
Klaus Kroy
Abstract:
The collision of a spherical grain with a granular bed is commonly parametrized by the splash function, which provides the velocity of the rebounding grain and the velocity distribution and number of ejected grains. Starting from elementary geometric considerations and physical principles, like momentum conservation and energy dissipation in inelastic pair collisions, we derive a rebound parametri…
▽ More
The collision of a spherical grain with a granular bed is commonly parametrized by the splash function, which provides the velocity of the rebounding grain and the velocity distribution and number of ejected grains. Starting from elementary geometric considerations and physical principles, like momentum conservation and energy dissipation in inelastic pair collisions, we derive a rebound parametrization for the collision of a spherical grain with a granular bed. Combined with a recently proposed energy-splitting model [Ho ${\it et\ al.}$, Phys. Rev. E 85, 052301 (2012)] that predicts how the impact energy is distributed among the bed grains, this yields a coarse-grained but complete characterization of the splash as a function of the impact velocity and the impactor-bed grain-size ratio. The predicted mean values of the rebound angle, total and vertical restitution, ejection speed, and number of ejected grains are in excellent agreement with experimental literature data and with our own discrete-element computer simulations. We extract a set of analytical asymptotic relations for shallow impact geometries, which can readily be used in coarse-grained analytical modeling or computer simulations of geophysical particle-laden flows.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2016; v1 submitted 20 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Compressibility regularizes the "$μ(I)$" rheology for granular flows
Authors:
J. Heyman,
R. Delannay,
H. Tabuteau,
A. Valance
Abstract:
The $μ(I)$-rheology has been recently proposed as a potential candidate to model the flow of frictional grains in a dense inertial regime. However, this rheology was shown to be ill-posed in the mathematical sense for a large range of parameters, notably in the slow and fast flow limits \citep{Barker2015}. In this rapid communication, we extend the stability analysis to compressible flows. We show…
▽ More
The $μ(I)$-rheology has been recently proposed as a potential candidate to model the flow of frictional grains in a dense inertial regime. However, this rheology was shown to be ill-posed in the mathematical sense for a large range of parameters, notably in the slow and fast flow limits \citep{Barker2015}. In this rapid communication, we extend the stability analysis to compressible flows. We show that compressibility regularizes mostly the equations, making them well-posed for all parameters, at the condition that sufficient dissipation is associated with volume changes. In addition to the usual Coulomb shear friction coefficient $μ$, we introduce a bulk friction coefficient $μ_b$, associated to volume changes and show that the equations are well-posed in two dimensions if $μ_b>2-2μ$ ($μ_b>3-7μ/2$ in three dimensions). Moreover, we show that the ill-posed domain defined in \citep{Barker2015} transforms into a domain where the equations are unstable but stay well-posed when compressibility is taken into account. These results suggest thus the importance of compressibility in dense granular flows.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2017; v1 submitted 6 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
The fluctuation energy balance in non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport
Authors:
Thomas Pähtz,
Orencio Durán,
Tuan-Duc Ho,
Alexandre Valance,
Jasper F. Kok
Abstract:
Here we compare two extreme regimes of non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport, transport in light and heavy fluids ("saltation" and "bedload", respectively), regarding their particle fluctuation energy balance. From direct numerical simulations, we surprisingly find that the ratio between collisional and fluid drag dissipation of fluctuation energy is significantly larger in saltation tha…
▽ More
Here we compare two extreme regimes of non-suspended fluid-mediated particle transport, transport in light and heavy fluids ("saltation" and "bedload", respectively), regarding their particle fluctuation energy balance. From direct numerical simulations, we surprisingly find that the ratio between collisional and fluid drag dissipation of fluctuation energy is significantly larger in saltation than in bedload, even though the contribution of interparticle collisions to transport of momentum and energy is much smaller in saltation due to the low concentration of particles in the transport layer. We conclude that the much higher frequency of high-energy particle-bed impacts ("splash") in saltation is the cause for this counter-intuitive behavior. Moreover, from a comparison of these simulations to Particle Tracking Velocimetry measurements which we performed in a wind tunnel under steady transport of fine and coarse sand, we find that turbulent fluctuations of the flow produce particle fluctuation energy at an unexpectedly high rate in saltation even under conditions for which the effects of turbulence are usually believed to be small.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
New patterns in high-speed granular flows
Authors:
Nicolas Brodu,
Renaud Delannay,
Alexandre Valance,
Patrick Richard
Abstract:
We report on new patterns in high-speed flows of granular materials obtained by means of extensive numerical simulations. These patterns emerge from the destabilization of unidirectional flows upon increase of mass holdup and inclination angle, and are characterized by complex internal structures including secondary flows, heterogeneous particle volume fraction, symmetry breaking and dynamically m…
▽ More
We report on new patterns in high-speed flows of granular materials obtained by means of extensive numerical simulations. These patterns emerge from the destabilization of unidirectional flows upon increase of mass holdup and inclination angle, and are characterized by complex internal structures including secondary flows, heterogeneous particle volume fraction, symmetry breaking and dynamically maintained order. In particular, we evidenced steady and fully developed "supported" flows, which consist of a dense core surrounded by a highly energetic granular gas. Interestingly, despite their overall diversity, these regimes are shown to obey a scaling law for the mass flow rate as a function of the mass holdup. This unique set of 3D flow regimes raises new challenges for extending the scope of current granular rheological models.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2015; v1 submitted 28 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Dynamics of aeolian sand ripples
Authors:
Z. Csahok,
C. Misbah,
F. Rioual,
A. Valance
Abstract:
We analyze theoretically the dynamics of aeolian sand ripples. In order to put the study in the context we first review existing models. We argue on the local character of sand ripple formation. Using a hydrodynamical model we derive a nonlinear equation for the sand profile. We show how the hydrodynamical model may be modified to recover the missing terms that are dictated by symmetries. The sy…
▽ More
We analyze theoretically the dynamics of aeolian sand ripples. In order to put the study in the context we first review existing models. We argue on the local character of sand ripple formation. Using a hydrodynamical model we derive a nonlinear equation for the sand profile. We show how the hydrodynamical model may be modified to recover the missing terms that are dictated by symmetries. The symmetry and conservation arguments are powerful in that the form of the equation is model-independent. We then present an extensive numerical and analytical analysis of the generic sand ripple equation. We find that at the initial stage the wavelength of the ripple is that corresponding to the linearly most dangerous mode. At later stages the profile undergoes a coarsening process leading to a significant increase of the wavelength. We find that including the next higher order nonlinear term in the equation, leads naturally to a saturation of the local slope. We analyze both analytically and numerically the coarsening stage, in terms of a dynamical exponent for the mean wavelength increase. We discuss some future lines of investigations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
A nonlinear evolution equation for sand ripples based on geometry and conservation
Authors:
Zoltan Csahok,
Chaouqi Misbah,
Alexandre Valance
Abstract:
From geometry and conservation we derive two nonlinear evolution equations for sand ripples. In the case of a strong wind leading to a net erosion of the sand bed, ripples obey the Benney equation. This leads either to order or disorder depending on whether dispersion is strong or weak. In the most frequent case where erosion is counterbalanced by deposition, we derive a new one-parameter nonlin…
▽ More
From geometry and conservation we derive two nonlinear evolution equations for sand ripples. In the case of a strong wind leading to a net erosion of the sand bed, ripples obey the Benney equation. This leads either to order or disorder depending on whether dispersion is strong or weak. In the most frequent case where erosion is counterbalanced by deposition, we derive a new one-parameter nonlinear equation. It reveals ripple structures which then undergo a coarsening process at long times, a process which then slows down dramatically with the growth of the ripple wavelength.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 1998;
originally announced November 1998.
