-
Combined Annual Modulation Dark Matter Search with COSINE-100 and ANAIS-112
Authors:
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. França,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
S. B. Hong,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim,
Y. J. Ko,
D. H. Lee
, et al. (49 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The annual modulation signal, claimed to be consistent with dark matter as observed by DAMA/LIBRA in a sodium-iodide based detector, has persisted for over two decades. COSINE-100 and ANAIS-112 were designed to test the claim directly using the same target material. COSINE-100, located at Yangyang Underground Laboratory in South Korea, and ANAIS-112, located at Canfranc Underground Laboratory in S…
▽ More
The annual modulation signal, claimed to be consistent with dark matter as observed by DAMA/LIBRA in a sodium-iodide based detector, has persisted for over two decades. COSINE-100 and ANAIS-112 were designed to test the claim directly using the same target material. COSINE-100, located at Yangyang Underground Laboratory in South Korea, and ANAIS-112, located at Canfranc Underground Laboratory in Spain, have been taking data since 2016 and 2017, respectively. Each experiment published its respective results independently. In this paper, we present the results of an annual modulation search as a test of the signal observed by DAMA/LIBRA with the first three respective years of data from COSINE-100 and ANAIS-112. Using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo method, we find best fit values for modulation amplitude of $-0.0002 {\pm} 0.0026$ cpd/kg/keV in the 1-6 keV and $0.0021 {\pm} 0.0028$ cpd/kg/keV in the 2-6 keV energy regions. These results are not compatible with DAMA/LIBRA's assertion for their observation of annual modulation at $3.7σ$ and $2.6σ$, respectively. Performing a simple combination of the newly released 6-years datasets from both experiments find values consistent with no modulation at $0.0005 {\pm} 0.0019$ cpd/kg/keV in the 1-6 keV and $0.0027 {\pm} 0.0021$ cpd/kg/keV in the 2-6 keV energy regions with $4.68σ$ and $3.53σ$ respective exclusions of the DAMA/LIBRA signal.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Limits on WIMP dark matter with NaI(Tl) crystals in three years of COSINE-100 data
Authors:
G. H. Yu,
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. Franca,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim,
Y. J. Ko,
D. H. Lee
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report limits on WIMP dark matter derived from three years of data collected by the COSINE-100 experiment with NaI(Tl) crystals, achieving an improved energy threshold of 0.7 keV. This lowered threshold enhances sensitivity in the sub-GeV mass range, extending the reach for direct detection of low-mass dark matter. Although no excess of WIMP-like events was observed, the increased sensitivity e…
▽ More
We report limits on WIMP dark matter derived from three years of data collected by the COSINE-100 experiment with NaI(Tl) crystals, achieving an improved energy threshold of 0.7 keV. This lowered threshold enhances sensitivity in the sub-GeV mass range, extending the reach for direct detection of low-mass dark matter. Although no excess of WIMP-like events was observed, the increased sensitivity enabled a model-independent comparison between the expected WIMP signal rate-based on mass limits from our data-and DAMA's reported modulation amplitude. Our findings strongly disfavor the DAMA signal as originating from WIMP interactions, fully excluding DAMA/LIBRA 3$σ$ allowed regions and providing enhanced WIMP mass limits by an order of magnitude in the spin-independent model compared to previous results. In the spin-dependent model, cross-section upper limits were obtained in the mass range [0.1-5.0] GeV/c$^2$, with additional sensitivity to sub-GeV WIMPs through the inclusion of the Migdal effect. These results represent substantial progress in low-mass dark matter exploration and reinforce constraints on the longstanding DAMA claim.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
COSINE-100 Full Dataset Challenges the Annual Modulation Signal of DAMA/LIBRA
Authors:
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. Franca,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim,
Y. J. Ko,
D. H. Lee,
E. K. Lee
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
For over 25 years, the DAMA/LIBRA collaboration has claimed to observe an annual modulation signal, suggesting the existence of dark matter interactions. However, no other experiments have replicated their result using different detector materials. To address this puzzle, the COSINE-100 collaboration conducted a model-independent test using 106 kg of sodium iodide as detectors, the same target mat…
▽ More
For over 25 years, the DAMA/LIBRA collaboration has claimed to observe an annual modulation signal, suggesting the existence of dark matter interactions. However, no other experiments have replicated their result using different detector materials. To address this puzzle, the COSINE-100 collaboration conducted a model-independent test using 106 kg of sodium iodide as detectors, the same target material as DAMA/LIBRA. Analyzing data collected over 6.4 years, with improved energy calibration and time-dependent background description, we found no evidence of an annual modulation signal, challenging the DAMA/LIBRA result with a confidence level greater than 3$σ$. This finding represents a significant step toward resolving the long-standing debate surrounding DAMA/LIBRA's dark matter claim, indicating that the observed modulation is unlikely to be caused by dark matter interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Lowering threshold of NaI(Tl) scintillator to 0.7 keV in the COSINE-100 experiment
Authors:
G. H. Yu,
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. França,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim,
Y. J. Ko,
D. H. Lee
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
COSINE-100 is a direct dark matter search experiment, with the primary goal of testing the annual modulation signal observed by DAMA/LIBRA, using the same target material, NaI(Tl). In previous analyses, we achieved the same 1 keV energy threshold used in the DAMA/LIBRA's analysis that reported an annual modulation signal with 11.6$σ$ significance. In this article, we report an improved analysis th…
▽ More
COSINE-100 is a direct dark matter search experiment, with the primary goal of testing the annual modulation signal observed by DAMA/LIBRA, using the same target material, NaI(Tl). In previous analyses, we achieved the same 1 keV energy threshold used in the DAMA/LIBRA's analysis that reported an annual modulation signal with 11.6$σ$ significance. In this article, we report an improved analysis that lowered the threshold to 0.7 keV, thanks to the application of Multi-Layer Perception network and a new likelihood parameter with waveforms in the frequency domain. The lower threshold would enable a better comparison of COSINE-100 with new DAMA results with a 0.75 keV threshold and account for differences in quenching factors. Furthermore the lower threshold can enhance COSINE-100's sensitivity to sub-GeV dark matter searches.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2024; v1 submitted 26 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Improved background modeling for dark matter search with COSINE-100
Authors:
G. H. Yu,
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. Franca,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim,
Y. J. Ko,
D. H. Lee
, et al. (33 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
COSINE-100 aims to conclusively test the claimed dark matter annual modulation signal detected by DAMA/LIBRA collaboration. DAMA/LIBRA has released updated analysis results by lowering the energy threshold to 0.75 keV through various upgrades. They have consistently claimed to have observed the annual modulation. In COSINE-100, it is crucial to lower the energy threshold for a direct comparison wi…
▽ More
COSINE-100 aims to conclusively test the claimed dark matter annual modulation signal detected by DAMA/LIBRA collaboration. DAMA/LIBRA has released updated analysis results by lowering the energy threshold to 0.75 keV through various upgrades. They have consistently claimed to have observed the annual modulation. In COSINE-100, it is crucial to lower the energy threshold for a direct comparison with DAMA/LIBRA, which also enhances the sensitivity of the search for low-mass dark matter, enabling COSINE-100 to explore this area. Therefore, it is essential to have a precise and quantitative understanding of the background spectrum across all energy ranges. This study expands the background modeling from 0.7 to 4000 keV using 2.82 years of COSINE-100 data. The modeling has been improved to describe the background spectrum across all energy ranges accurately. Assessments of the background spectrum are presented, considering the nonproportionality of NaI(Tl) crystals at both low and high energies and the characteristic X-rays produced by the interaction of external backgrounds with materials such as copper. Additionally, constraints on the fit parameters obtained from the alpha spectrum modeling fit are integrated into this model. These improvements are detailed in the paper.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Absolute light yield measurement of NaI:Tl crystals for dark matter search
Authors:
Nguyen Thanh Luan,
Kim Hong Joo,
Lee Hyun Su,
Jin Jegal,
Lam Tan Truc,
Khan Arshad,
Nguyen Duc Ton
Abstract:
The NaI:Tl crystals were early investigated and used for wide application fields due to high light yield and crystal growth advantages. So far, the absolute light yields of NaI:Tl crystal have typically been known to be 40 ph/keV. However, it varies widely, far from the theoretical estimation. Since the high light yield and better sensitivity of NaI:Tl crystal is important for low mass dark matter…
▽ More
The NaI:Tl crystals were early investigated and used for wide application fields due to high light yield and crystal growth advantages. So far, the absolute light yields of NaI:Tl crystal have typically been known to be 40 ph/keV. However, it varies widely, far from the theoretical estimation. Since the high light yield and better sensitivity of NaI:Tl crystal is important for low mass dark matter search. Therefore, it is necessary to use high light NaI:Tl crystal, and absolute light yield should be measured with accuracy. In this work, we use the single photoelectron technique for measuring the absolute light yield of 35 NaI:Tl crystals with various sizes from different vendors. There are several high-quality crystals from the COSINE-100 experiment and commercial companies in these crystals. The theoretical estimation and GEANT4 optical simulation have been studied to investigate the PMT optics. Results show the essential role of this correction in avoiding overrated light yield values. The SPE technique using different PMT was compared to the photodiode and avalanche photodiode methods. A 10% systematic error was obtained. Our results show the excellent absolute light yield of NaI:Tl, at 59.4 +- 5.9 ph/keV, while the theoretical predicted light yield is around 70 ph/keV. The evaluation with NaI:Tl crystals in the COSINE-100 experiment has been performed. The six crystals in the COSINE-100 experiment have a high light yield. Based on our results, the light loss of encapsulation needs to be improved, especially for the big-size crystals.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Nonproportionality of NaI(Tl) Scintillation Detector for Dark Matter Search Experiments
Authors:
S. M. Lee,
G. Adhikari,
N. Carlin,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. Fran. a,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
S. W. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim
, et al. (37 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a comprehensive study of the nonproportionality of NaI(Tl) scintillation detectors within the context of dark matter search experiments. Our investigation, which integrates COSINE-100 data with supplementary $γ$ spectroscopy, measures light yields across diverse energy levels from full-energy $γ$ peaks produced by the decays of various isotopes. These $γ$ peaks of interest were produced…
▽ More
We present a comprehensive study of the nonproportionality of NaI(Tl) scintillation detectors within the context of dark matter search experiments. Our investigation, which integrates COSINE-100 data with supplementary $γ$ spectroscopy, measures light yields across diverse energy levels from full-energy $γ$ peaks produced by the decays of various isotopes. These $γ$ peaks of interest were produced by decays supported by both long and short-lived isotopes. Analyzing peaks from decays supported only by short-lived isotopes presented a unique challenge due to their limited statistics and overlapping energies, which was overcome by long-term data collection and a time-dependent analysis. A key achievement is the direct measurement of the 0.87 keV light yield, resulting from the cascade following electron capture decay of $^{22}$Na from internal contamination. This measurement, previously accessible only indirectly, deepens our understanding of NaI(Tl) scintillator behavior in the region of interest for dark matter searches. This study holds substantial implications for background modeling and the interpretation of dark matter signals in NaI(Tl) experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2024; v1 submitted 14 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Alpha backgrounds in NaI(Tl) crystals of COSINE-100
Authors:
G. Adhikari,
N. Carlin,
D. F. F. S. Cavalcante,
J. Y. Cho,
J. J. Choi,
S. Choi,
A. C. Ezeribe,
L. E. Franca,
C. Ha,
I. S. Hahn,
S. J. Hollick,
E. J. Jeon,
H. W. Joo,
W. G. Kang,
M. Kauer,
B. H. Kim,
H. J. Kim,
J. Kim,
K. W. Kim,
S. H. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
S. W. Kim,
W. K. Kim,
Y. D. Kim,
Y. H. Kim
, et al. (38 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
COSINE-100 is a dark matter direct detection experiment with 106 kg NaI(Tl) as the target material. 210Pb and daughter isotopes are a dominant background in the WIMP region of interest and are detected via beta decay and alpha decay. Analysis of the alpha channel complements the background model as observed in the beta/gamma channel. We present the measurement of the quenching factors and Monte Ca…
▽ More
COSINE-100 is a dark matter direct detection experiment with 106 kg NaI(Tl) as the target material. 210Pb and daughter isotopes are a dominant background in the WIMP region of interest and are detected via beta decay and alpha decay. Analysis of the alpha channel complements the background model as observed in the beta/gamma channel. We present the measurement of the quenching factors and Monte Carlo simulation results and activity quantification of the alpha decay components of the COSINE-100 NaI(Tl) crystals. The data strongly indicate that the alpha decays probabilistically undergo two possible quenching factors but require further investigation. The fitted results are consistent with independent measurements and improve the overall understanding of the COSINE-100 backgrounds. Furthermore, the half-life of 216Po has been measured to be 143.4 +/- 1.2 ms, which is consistent with and more precise than recent measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
