-
Propulsive performance of a windsurf-inspired pitching foil
Authors:
Gauthier Bertrand,
Tristan Aurégan,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana,
Marc Fermigier
Abstract:
We study experimentally a symmetrical rigid foil performing pitching oscillations around a mean incidence angle ($α_{m}$) with respect to an incoming flow in a hydrodynamic channel at a constant velocity where the Reynolds number according to the chord of the foil is, $Re_{c} = ρU_{\infty} c / μ= 14400$. The problem is inspired from the pumping maneuver used by athletes on the new hydrofoil-based…
▽ More
We study experimentally a symmetrical rigid foil performing pitching oscillations around a mean incidence angle ($α_{m}$) with respect to an incoming flow in a hydrodynamic channel at a constant velocity where the Reynolds number according to the chord of the foil is, $Re_{c} = ρU_{\infty} c / μ= 14400$. The problem is inspired from the pumping maneuver used by athletes on the new hydrofoil-based windsurf boards. The goal of the study is to quantify the forces on this configuration by varying the pitching kinematics characterized by the Strouhal number ($St_{A} = fA/U_{\infty}$), from 0 to 0.27, and the mean incidence angle $α_{m}$, from 0 to 30$^{\circ}$, of the foil. The force measurements show a high lift production and the delay of the stall angle according to $St_A$ which can be linked to previous studies about the generation of vortices at the trailing edge. A general trend of decrease is observed for the drag force coefficient in pitching compare to the static case. For the highest Strouhal numbers tested, drag coefficient can become negative (thrust) in a range of $α_{m}$ up to 15$^{\circ}$ in specific case. We present the various impacts of the amplitude of beating and the frequency of pitching on the aerodynamic forces for small mean incidence angle and high mean incidence angle (above the static stall angle). By using a sport-mimetic approach, we transform the measured lift $\&$ drag forces into a propulsive and drifting force. Doing so allows us to investigate race strategies. We investigate the generation of propulsion in upwind conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Water wave interactions with a horizontal submerged elastic plate
Authors:
Gatien Polly,
Alexis Mérigaud,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
This article explores how a submerged elastic plate, clamped at one edge, interacts with water waves. Submerged elastic plates have been considered as potentially effective design elements in the development of wave energy harvesters but their behavior in a wave field remains largely unexplored, especially experimentally. Positioned at a fixed depth in a wave tank, the flexible plate demonstrates…
▽ More
This article explores how a submerged elastic plate, clamped at one edge, interacts with water waves. Submerged elastic plates have been considered as potentially effective design elements in the development of wave energy harvesters but their behavior in a wave field remains largely unexplored, especially experimentally. Positioned at a fixed depth in a wave tank, the flexible plate demonstrates significant wave reflection capabilities, a characteristic absent in rigid plates of identical dimensions. The experiments thus reveal that plate motion is crucial for wave reflection. Sufficiently steep waves are shown to induce a change in the mean position of the plate, with the trailing edge reaching the free surface in some cases. This configuration change is found to be particularly efficient to break water waves. These findings contribute to understanding the potential of elastic plates for wave energy harvesting and wave attenuation scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Improving propulsive efficiency using bio-inspired intermittent locomotion
Authors:
Tristan Aurégan,
Mathilde Lemoine,
Benjamin Thiria,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont
Abstract:
Many swimmers, especially small to medium-sized animals, use intermittent locomotion that differs from continuous swimming of large species. This type of locomotion, called burst-and-coast, is often associated with an energetic advantage. In this work, we investigate the intermittent locomotion inspired by fish locomotion but applied to a propeller. The energy consumption of burst-and-coast cycles…
▽ More
Many swimmers, especially small to medium-sized animals, use intermittent locomotion that differs from continuous swimming of large species. This type of locomotion, called burst-and-coast, is often associated with an energetic advantage. In this work, we investigate the intermittent locomotion inspired by fish locomotion but applied to a propeller. The energy consumption of burst-and-coast cycles is measured and compared to the continuous rotation regime. We show that a substantial drag ratio between the active and passive phases of the motion, as observed in fish, is critical for energy savings. Such a contrast can be obtained using a folding propeller that passively opens and closes as the propeller starts and stops rotating. For this reconfigurable propeller, intermittent propulsion is found to be energetically advantageous, saving up to 24% of the energy required to cruise at a given speed. Using an analytical model, we show that intermittent motion is more efficient than continuous motion when the drag reduction in the coast phase exceeds 65%. For fish-like locomotion, this threshold seems to be closer to 30%. A formal analogy allows us to explain the difference between propeller propulsion and fish locomotion.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2024; v1 submitted 26 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Confinement-driven state transition and bistability in schooling fish
Authors:
Baptiste Lafoux,
Paul Bernard,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
We investigate the impact of confinement density (i.e the number of individuals in a group per unit area of available space) on transitions from polarized to milling state, using groups of rummy-nose tetra fish (\textit{Hemigrammus rhodostomus}) under controlled experimental conditions. We demonstrate a continuous state transition controlled by confinement density in a group of live animals. Durin…
▽ More
We investigate the impact of confinement density (i.e the number of individuals in a group per unit area of available space) on transitions from polarized to milling state, using groups of rummy-nose tetra fish (\textit{Hemigrammus rhodostomus}) under controlled experimental conditions. We demonstrate a continuous state transition controlled by confinement density in a group of live animals. During this transition, the school exhibits a bistable state, wherein both polarization and milling states coexist, with the group randomly alternating between them. A simple two-state Markov process describes the observed transition remarkably well. The confinement density influences the statistics of this bistability, shaping the distribution of transition times between states. Our findings suggest that confinement plays a crucial role in state transitions for moving animal groups. More generally, they provide an experimental benchmark for active matter models of macroscopic, self-propelled, confined agents.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2024; v1 submitted 3 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Thrust force is tuned by the rigidity distribution in insect-inspired flapping wings
Authors:
Roméo Antier,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
We study the aerodynamics of a flapping flexible wing with a two-vein pattern that mimics the elastic response of insect wings in a simplified manner. The experiments reveal a non-monotonic variation of the thrust force produced by the wings when the angle between the two veins is varied. An optimal configuration is consistently reached when the two veins are spaced at an angle of about 20 degrees…
▽ More
We study the aerodynamics of a flapping flexible wing with a two-vein pattern that mimics the elastic response of insect wings in a simplified manner. The experiments reveal a non-monotonic variation of the thrust force produced by the wings when the angle between the two veins is varied. An optimal configuration is consistently reached when the two veins are spaced at an angle of about 20 degrees. This value is in the range of what has been measured in the literature for several insect species. The deformation of the wings is monitored during the experiment using video recordings, which allows to pinpoint the physical mechanism behind the non-monotonic behaviour of the force curve and the optimal distribution of the vein network in terms of propulsive force.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Illuminance-tuned collective motion in fish
Authors:
Baptiste Lafoux,
Jeanne Moscatelli,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
We experimentally investigate the role of illumination on the collective dynamics of a large school (ca. 50 individuals) of Hemigrammus rhodostomus. The structure of the group, defined using two order parameters, is quantified while progressively altering the visual range of the fish through controlled cycles of ambient light intensity. We show that, at low light levels, the individuals within the…
▽ More
We experimentally investigate the role of illumination on the collective dynamics of a large school (ca. 50 individuals) of Hemigrammus rhodostomus. The structure of the group, defined using two order parameters, is quantified while progressively altering the visual range of the fish through controlled cycles of ambient light intensity. We show that, at low light levels, the individuals within the group are unable to form a cohesive group, while at higher illuminance the degree of alignment of the school correlates with the light intensity. When increasing the illuminance, the school structure is successively characterized by a polarized state followed by a highly regular and stable rotational configuration (milling). Our study shows that vision is necessary to achieve cohesive collective motion for free swimming fish schools, while the short-range lateral line sensing is insufficient in this situation. The present experiment therefore provides new insights into the interaction mechanisms that govern the emergence and intensity of collective motion in biological systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Ocean wave transmission, reflection and absorption by rows of vertical structures along the coastline
Authors:
Alexis Mérigaud,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
Large arrays of wave-absorbing structures could serve the double objective of coastal protection against erosion and clean, renewable electrical power production. In this work, the principle of an artificial canopy is explored, which consists of vertical structures, arranged in rows parallel to the coastline. Sea waves, which propagate towards the shore, interact with the obstacle rows. A part of…
▽ More
Large arrays of wave-absorbing structures could serve the double objective of coastal protection against erosion and clean, renewable electrical power production. In this work, the principle of an artificial canopy is explored, which consists of vertical structures, arranged in rows parallel to the coastline. Sea waves, which propagate towards the shore, interact with the obstacle rows. A part of the wave energy is reflected back towards the ocean, another part is transmitted to the shoreline, while the rest of the energy is, in theory, available for energy production (although losses, due to viscous effects within the fluid, or imperfect efficiency of the power conversion mechanism, will unavoidably take place). First, a simple geometric representation of the reflection/transmission properties of individual, fixed rows is presented. In the case of moving rows, relationships are drawn between the internal stiffness and damping parameters of the devices, on the one hand, and their reflection, transmission and absorption characteristics, on the other hand. Array properties are then examined, depending on both individual row design parameters and row-to-row spacing values, using the wide-spacing approximation. A numerical case study illustrates the capabilities of the proposed modelling framework, with arrays of vertical, oscillating rectangular plates. The transmitted, reflected and absorbed wave spectra are examined, along with their dependencies on individual oscillator control tuning and array design parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
On the interaction of surface water waves and fully-submerged elastic plates
Authors:
G. Polly,
A. Mérigaud,
R. Alhage,
B. Thiria,
R. Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
The interaction between fully-submerged elastic plates and surface waves is of high interest to optimize wave energy converters such as the "Wave Carpet". This study focuses on the interaction between an elastic plate and waves from an experimental point of view. To do so, a submerged thin elastic plate is held at a fixed position in a wave field. The wave field is analyzed using a top view video…
▽ More
The interaction between fully-submerged elastic plates and surface waves is of high interest to optimize wave energy converters such as the "Wave Carpet". This study focuses on the interaction between an elastic plate and waves from an experimental point of view. To do so, a submerged thin elastic plate is held at a fixed position in a wave field. The wave field is analyzed using a top view video recording that gives access to the water height field while the deformation of the elastic plate is recorded with a side view camera. Preliminary results presented in this paper show that the elastic plate transmits most of incoming wave energy while reflecting almost no energy. It is also shown that dissipation arises for wavelengths less than two times the length of the plate. Causes of dissipation are investigated emphasizing that viscous dissipation could be responsible for the loss of energy.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Burst-and-coast swimmers optimize gait by adapting unique intrinsic cycle
Authors:
G. Li,
I. Ashraf,
B. François,
D. Kolomenskiy,
F. Lechenault,
R. Godoy-Diana,
B. Thiria
Abstract:
This paper addresses the physical mechanism of intermittent swimming by considering the burst-and-coast regime of fish swimming at different speeds. The burst-and-coast regime consists of a cycle with two successive phases: a phase of active undulation powered by the fish muscles followed by a passive gliding phase. Observations of real fish whose swimming gait is forced in a water flume from low…
▽ More
This paper addresses the physical mechanism of intermittent swimming by considering the burst-and-coast regime of fish swimming at different speeds. The burst-and-coast regime consists of a cycle with two successive phases: a phase of active undulation powered by the fish muscles followed by a passive gliding phase. Observations of real fish whose swimming gait is forced in a water flume from low to high speed regimes are performed, using a full description of the fish kinematics and mechanics. We first show that fish modulate a unique intrinsic cycle to sustain the demanded speed by modifying the bursting to coasting ratio while maintaining the duration of the cycle constant. Secondly, we show using numerical simulations that the chosen kinematics correspond to optimized gaits over the range of swimming speeds tested.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Material optimization of flexible blades for wind turbines
Authors:
Vincent Cognet,
Sylvain Courrech du Pont,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
Bioinspired flexible blades have been recently shown to significantly improve the versatility of horizontal-axis wind turbines, by widening their working range and increasing their efficiency. The aerodynamic and centrifugal forces bend the blade along its chord, varying the pitch angle by means of non-consuming mechanisms. Here we introduce a general method based on a universal scaling, which fin…
▽ More
Bioinspired flexible blades have been recently shown to significantly improve the versatility of horizontal-axis wind turbines, by widening their working range and increasing their efficiency. The aerodynamic and centrifugal forces bend the blade along its chord, varying the pitch angle by means of non-consuming mechanisms. Here we introduce a general method based on a universal scaling, which finds the optimal soft materials for the blades to maximize the overall turbine efficiency or rotational power, for any required geometry of classical horizontal-axis turbines. The optimization problem, which depends on various parameters, such as the wind velocity, the rotation rate, the density, the rigidity and the geometry of the blade, is reduced to only two dimensionless parameters: the Cauchy number and the centrifugal number. The blade-element momentum theory is coupled to a torsion spring-based model for the blade deformation. Taking into account realistic incoming wind-velocity distributions in the North Sea and a large wind-turbine geometry, we found a significant increase of the total harvested power, up to +35%. In addition, the optimal soft material corresponding to the maximal efficiency over the entire working range for a given wind turbine geometry is, within the limits of small blade deformations, scale-independent. Thus experiments on small wind turbines are a possible way to determine the optimal soft materials for larger ones. These flexible blades are found to be between 5% and 20% lighter than the current rigid blades.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Modelling of an actuated elastic swimmer
Authors:
Miguel Piñeirua,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
We study the force production dynamics of undulating elastic plates as a model for fish-like inertial swimmers. Using a beam model coupled with Lighthill's large-amplitude elongated-body theory, we explore different localised actuations at one extremity of the plate (heaving, pitching, and a combination of both) in order to quantify the reactive and resistive contributions to the thrust. The latte…
▽ More
We study the force production dynamics of undulating elastic plates as a model for fish-like inertial swimmers. Using a beam model coupled with Lighthill's large-amplitude elongated-body theory, we explore different localised actuations at one extremity of the plate (heaving, pitching, and a combination of both) in order to quantify the reactive and resistive contributions to the thrust. The latter has the form of a quadratic drag in large Reynolds number swimmers and has recently been pointed out as a crucial element in the thrust force balance. We validate the output of a weakly nonlinear solution to the fluid--structure model using thrust force measurements from an experiment with flexible plates subjected to the three different actuation types. The model is subsequently used in a self-propelled configuration ---with a skin friction model that balances thrust to produce a constant cruising speed--- to map the reactive versus resistive thrust production in a parameter space defined by the aspect ratio and the actuation frequency. We show that this balance is modified as the frequency of excitation changes and the response of the elastic plate shifts between different resonant modes, the pure heaving case being the most sensitive to the modal response with drastic changes in the reactive/resistive contribution ratio along the frequency axis. We analyse also the role of the phase lag between the heaving and pitching components in the case of combined actuation, showing in particular a non-trivial effect on the propulsive efficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Resistive thrust production can be as crucial as added mass mechanisms for inertial undulatory swimmers
Authors:
Miguel Piñeirua,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
In this paper, we address a crucial point regarding the description of moderate to high Reynolds numbers aquatic swimmers. For decades, swimming animals have been classified in two different families of propulsive mechanisms based on the Reynolds number: the "resistive" swimmers, using local friction to produce the necessary thrust force for locomotion at low Reynolds number and the "reactive" swi…
▽ More
In this paper, we address a crucial point regarding the description of moderate to high Reynolds numbers aquatic swimmers. For decades, swimming animals have been classified in two different families of propulsive mechanisms based on the Reynolds number: the "resistive" swimmers, using local friction to produce the necessary thrust force for locomotion at low Reynolds number and the "reactive" swimmers, lying in the high Reynolds range, and using added mass acceleration (described by perfect fluid theory). However, inertial swimmers are also systems that dissipate energy, due to their finite size, therefore involving strong resistive contributions, even for high Reynolds numbers. Using a complete model for the hydrodynamic forces, involving both reactive and resistive contributions, we revisit here the physical mechanisms responsible for the thrust production of such swimmers. We show, for instance, that the resistive part of the force balance is as crucial as added mass effects in the modeling of the thrust force, especially for elongated species. The conclusions brought by this work may have significant contributions to the understanding of complex swimming mechanisms, especially for the future design of artificial swimmers.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
On the relation between linear stability analysis and mean flow properties in wakes
Authors:
Benjamin Thiria,
Gilles Bouchet,
Jose Eduardo Wesfreid
Abstract:
In recent studies on wake stability, it has been observed that a simple linear stability analysis applied to the mean flow instead of the basic flow, could give an accurate prediction of the global mode selected frequency, although these phenomena are strongly non-linear. In this letter, we study the transient regime between the stationary (so called basic state) and unstationary solutions of the…
▽ More
In recent studies on wake stability, it has been observed that a simple linear stability analysis applied to the mean flow instead of the basic flow, could give an accurate prediction of the global mode selected frequency, although these phenomena are strongly non-linear. In this letter, we study the transient regime between the stationary (so called basic state) and unstationary solutions of the wake of a circular cylinder at Re=150. We show that the shift of the global frequency as a function of time due to strong non-linear effects, can be interpreted by a continuous mean flow correction induced by the growth of the instability. We show that during this transient regime, the mean state as a function of time plays the role of an instantaneous basic state on which the global frequency can be determined linearly.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Four-winged flapping flyer in forward flight
Authors:
Ramiro Godoy-Diana,
Prasann Jain,
Mariana Centeno,
Alexis Weinreb,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
We study experimentally a four-winged flapping flyer with chord-wise flexible wings in a self-propelled setup. For a given physical configuration of the flyer (i.e. fixed distance between the forewing and hindwing pairs and fixed wing flexibility), we explore the kinematic parameter space constituted by the flapping frequency and the forewing-hindwing phase lag. Cruising speed and consumed electri…
▽ More
We study experimentally a four-winged flapping flyer with chord-wise flexible wings in a self-propelled setup. For a given physical configuration of the flyer (i.e. fixed distance between the forewing and hindwing pairs and fixed wing flexibility), we explore the kinematic parameter space constituted by the flapping frequency and the forewing-hindwing phase lag. Cruising speed and consumed electric power measurements are performed for each point in the $(f,\varphi)$ parameter space and allow us to discuss the problem of performance and efficiency in four-winged flapping flight. We show that different phase-lags are needed for the system to be optimised for fastest flight or lowest energy consumption. A conjecture of the underlying mechanism is proposed in terms of the coupled dynamics of the forewing-hindwing phase lag and the deformation kinematics of the flexible wings.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2014;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Large-amplitude undulatory swimming near a wall
Authors:
Rafael Fernández-Prats,
Veronica Raspa,
Benjamin Thiria,
Francisco Huera-Huarte,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
The propulsive dynamics of a flexible undulating foil in a self-propelled swimming configuration near a wall is studied experimentally. Measurements of the swimming speed and the propulsive force are presented, together with image acquisition of the kinematics of the foil and particle image velocimetry (PIV) in its wake. The presence of the wall enhances the cruising velocity in some cases up to 2…
▽ More
The propulsive dynamics of a flexible undulating foil in a self-propelled swimming configuration near a wall is studied experimentally. Measurements of the swimming speed and the propulsive force are presented, together with image acquisition of the kinematics of the foil and particle image velocimetry (PIV) in its wake. The presence of the wall enhances the cruising velocity in some cases up to 25% and the thrust by a 45%, for swept angles of 160 and 240 degrees. The physical mechanisms underlying this effect are discussed by studying the vorticity dynamics in the wake of the foil. Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) is applied to the PIV measurements in order to analyse the kinetic energy modal distribution in the flow and to relate it to the propulsion generated by the foil.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
The mechanical response of a creased sheet
Authors:
Frederic Lechenault,
Benjamin Thiria,
Mokhtar Adda-Bedia
Abstract:
We investigate the mechanics of thin sheets decorated by non-interacting creases. The system considered here consists in parallel folds connected by elastic panels. We show that the mechanical response of the creased structure is twofold, depending both on the bending deformation of the panels and the hinge-like intrinsic response of the crease. We show that a characteristic length scale, defined…
▽ More
We investigate the mechanics of thin sheets decorated by non-interacting creases. The system considered here consists in parallel folds connected by elastic panels. We show that the mechanical response of the creased structure is twofold, depending both on the bending deformation of the panels and the hinge-like intrinsic response of the crease. We show that a characteristic length scale, defined by the ratio of bending to hinge energies, governs whether the structure's response consists in angle opening or panel bending when a small load is applied. The existence of this length scale is a building block for future works on origami mechanics
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Elastic swimmer on a free surface
Authors:
Sophie Ramananarivo,
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
We present in this fluid dynamics video a novel experimental setup with self-propelled swimmers on a free surface. The swimmers, modeled as flexible thin filaments, are subjected to external electromagnetic forcing driving a propagating elastic wave that gives rise to self- propulsion. The fluid-structure interaction problem of these passive anguilliform swimmers is analyzed in:
S. Ramananarivo,…
▽ More
We present in this fluid dynamics video a novel experimental setup with self-propelled swimmers on a free surface. The swimmers, modeled as flexible thin filaments, are subjected to external electromagnetic forcing driving a propagating elastic wave that gives rise to self- propulsion. The fluid-structure interaction problem of these passive anguilliform swimmers is analyzed in:
S. Ramananarivo, R. Godoy-Diana, and B. Thiria. Passive elastic mechanism to mimic fish-muscles action in anguilliform swimming. J. R. Soc. Interface, 10, 20130667 (2013). DOI:10.1098/rsif.2013.0667
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Stabilizing effect of flexibility in the wake of a flapping foil
Authors:
Catherine Marais,
Benjamin Thiria,
José Eduardo Wesfreid,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
The wake of a flexible foil undergoing pitching oscillations in a low-speed hydrodynamic tunnel is used to examine the effect of chord-wise foil flexibility in the dynamical features of flapping-based propulsion. We compare the regime transitions in the wake with respect to the case of a rigid foil and show that foil flexibility inhibits the symmetry breaking of the reverse Bénard-von Kármán wake…
▽ More
The wake of a flexible foil undergoing pitching oscillations in a low-speed hydrodynamic tunnel is used to examine the effect of chord-wise foil flexibility in the dynamical features of flapping-based propulsion. We compare the regime transitions in the wake with respect to the case of a rigid foil and show that foil flexibility inhibits the symmetry breaking of the reverse Bénard-von Kármán wake reported in the literature. A momentum balance calculation shows the average thrust to be up to three times greater for the flexible foil than for the rigid foil. We explain both of these observations by analyzing the vortex dynamics in the very near wake.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Rather than resonance, flapping wing flyers may play on aerodynamics to improve performance
Authors:
Sophie Ramananarivo,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana,
Benjamin Thiria
Abstract:
Saving energy and enhancing performance are secular preoccupations shared by both nature and human beings. In animal locomotion, flapping flyers or swimmers rely on the flexibility of their wings or body to passively increase their efficiency using an appropriate cycle of storing and releasing elastic energy. Despite the convergence of many observations pointing out this feature, the underlying me…
▽ More
Saving energy and enhancing performance are secular preoccupations shared by both nature and human beings. In animal locomotion, flapping flyers or swimmers rely on the flexibility of their wings or body to passively increase their efficiency using an appropriate cycle of storing and releasing elastic energy. Despite the convergence of many observations pointing out this feature, the underlying mechanisms explaining how the elastic nature of the wings is related to propulsive efficiency remain unclear. Here we use an experiment with a self-propelled simplified insect model allowing to show how wing compliance governs the performance of flapping flyers. Reducing the description of the flapping wing to a forced oscillator model, we pinpoint different nonlinear effects that can account for the observed behavior ---in particular a set of cubic nonlinearities coming from the clamped-free beam equation used to model the wing and a quadratic damping term representing the fluid drag associated to the fast flapping motion. In contrast to what has been repeatedly suggested in the literature, we show that flapping flyers optimize their performance not by especially looking for resonance to achieve larger flapping amplitudes with less effort, but by tuning the temporal evolution of the wing shape (i.e. the phase dynamics in the oscillator model) to optimize the aerodynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2011; v1 submitted 21 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
How wing compliance drives the efficiency of self-propelled flapping flyers
Authors:
Benjamin Thiria,
Ramiro Godoy-Diana
Abstract:
Wing flexibility governs the flying performance of flapping wing flyers. Here, we use a self-propelled flapping-wing model mounted on a ``merry go round'' to investigate the effect of wing compliance on the propulsive efficiency of the system. Our measurements show that the elastic nature of the wings can lead not only to a substantial reduction in the consumed power, but also to an increment of t…
▽ More
Wing flexibility governs the flying performance of flapping wing flyers. Here, we use a self-propelled flapping-wing model mounted on a ``merry go round'' to investigate the effect of wing compliance on the propulsive efficiency of the system. Our measurements show that the elastic nature of the wings can lead not only to a substantial reduction in the consumed power, but also to an increment of the propulsive force. A scaling analysis using a flexible plate model for the wings points out that, for flapping flyers in air, the time-dependent shape of the elastic bending wing is governed by the wing inertia. Based on this prediction, we define the ratio of the inertial forces deforming the wing to the elastic restoring force that limits the deformation as the \emph{elasto-inertial number} $\mathcal{N}_{ei}$. Our measurements with the self-propelled model confirm that it is the appropriate structural parameter to describe flapping flyers with flexible-wings.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2010; v1 submitted 25 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
