-
Solenoidal force balances in numerical dynamos
Authors:
Robert J. Teed,
Emmanuel Dormy
Abstract:
Numerical simulations of the geodynamo (and other planetary dynamos) have made significant progress in recent years. As computing power has advanced, some new models claim to be ever more appropriate for understanding Earth's core dynamics. One measure of the success of such models is the ability to replicate the expected balance between forces operating within the core; Coriolis and Lorentz force…
▽ More
Numerical simulations of the geodynamo (and other planetary dynamos) have made significant progress in recent years. As computing power has advanced, some new models claim to be ever more appropriate for understanding Earth's core dynamics. One measure of the success of such models is the ability to replicate the expected balance between forces operating within the core; Coriolis and Lorentz forces are predicted to be most important. The picture is complicated for an incompressible flow by the existence of the pressure gradient force which renders the gradient parts of all other forces dynamically unimportant. This can confuse the situation, especially when the scale dependence of forces are considered. In this work we investigate force balances through the alternative approach of eliminating gradient parts of each force to form `solenoidal force balances'. We perform a lengthscale dependent analysis for several spherical simulations and find that removal of gradient parts offers an alternative picture of the force balance compared to looking at traditional forces alone. Solenoidal force balances provide some agreement with the results of previous studies but also significant differences. They offer a cleaner overall picture of the dynamics and introduce differences at smaller scales. This has implications for geodynamo models purporting to have reached Earth-like regimes: in order to achieve a meaningful comparison of forces, only the solenoidal part of forces should be considered.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2023; v1 submitted 27 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Axisymmetric simulations of the convective overstability in protoplanetary discs
Authors:
Robert J. Teed,
Henrik H. Latter
Abstract:
Protoplanetary discs at certain radii exhibit adverse radial entropy gradients that can drive oscillatory convection (`convective overstability'; COS). The ensuing hydrodynamical activity may reshape the radial thermal structure of the disc while mixing solid material radially and vertically or, alternatively, concentrating it in vortical structures. We perform local axisymmetric simulations of th…
▽ More
Protoplanetary discs at certain radii exhibit adverse radial entropy gradients that can drive oscillatory convection (`convective overstability'; COS). The ensuing hydrodynamical activity may reshape the radial thermal structure of the disc while mixing solid material radially and vertically or, alternatively, concentrating it in vortical structures. We perform local axisymmetric simulations of the COS using the code SNOOPY, showing first how parasites halt the instability's exponential growth, and second, the different saturation routes it takes subsequently. As the Reynolds and (pseudo-) Richardson numbers increase, the system moves successively from (a) a weakly nonlinear state characterised by relatively ordered nonlinear waves, to (b) wave turbulence, and finally to (c) the formation of intermittent and then persistent zonal flows. In three-dimensions, we expect the latter flows to spawn vortices in the orbital plane. Given the very high Reynolds numbers in protoplanetary discs, the third regime should be the most prevalent. As a consequence, we argue that the COS is an important dynamical process in planet formation, especially near features such as dead zone edges, ice lines, gaps, and dust rings.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Dynamic mode decomposition to retrieve torsional Alfvén waves
Authors:
Kumiko Hori,
Steven M. Tobias,
Robert J. Teed
Abstract:
Dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) is utilised to identify the intrinsic signals arising from planetary interiors. Focusing on an axisymmetric quasi-geostrophic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave -called torsional Alfvén waves (TW) - we examine the utility of DMD in two types of MHD direct numerical simulations: Boussinesq magnetoconvection and anelastic convection-driven dynamos in rapidly rotating sph…
▽ More
Dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) is utilised to identify the intrinsic signals arising from planetary interiors. Focusing on an axisymmetric quasi-geostrophic magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wave -called torsional Alfvén waves (TW) - we examine the utility of DMD in two types of MHD direct numerical simulations: Boussinesq magnetoconvection and anelastic convection-driven dynamos in rapidly rotating spherical shells, which model the dynamics in Earth's core and in Jupiter, respectively. We demonstrate that DMD is capable of distinguishing internal modes and boundary/interface-related modes from the timeseries of the internal velocity. Those internal modes may be realised as free TW, in terms of eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of their normal mode solutions. Meanwhile it turns out that, in order to account for the details, the global TW eigenvalue problems in spherical shells need to be further addressed.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Anelastic torsional oscillations in Jupiter's metallic hydrogen region
Authors:
Kumiko Hori,
Robert J. Teed,
Chris A Jones
Abstract:
We consider torsional Alfvén waves which may be excited in Jupiter's metallic hydrogen region. These axisymmetric zonal flow fluctuations have previously been examined for incompressible fluids in the context of Earth's liquid iron core. Theoretical models of the deep-seated Jovian dynamo, implementing radial changes of density and electrical conductivity in the equilibrium model, have reproduced…
▽ More
We consider torsional Alfvén waves which may be excited in Jupiter's metallic hydrogen region. These axisymmetric zonal flow fluctuations have previously been examined for incompressible fluids in the context of Earth's liquid iron core. Theoretical models of the deep-seated Jovian dynamo, implementing radial changes of density and electrical conductivity in the equilibrium model, have reproduced its strong, dipolar magnetic field. Analysing such models, we find anelastic torsional waves travelling perpendicular to the rotation axis in the metallic region on timescales of at least several years. Being excited by the more vigorous convection in the outer part of the dynamo region, they can propagate both inwards and outwards. When being reflected at a magnetic tangent cylinder at the transition to the molecular region, they can form standing waves. Identifying such reflections in observational data could determine the depth at which the metallic region effectively begins. Also, this may distinguish Jovian torsional waves from those in Earth's core, where observational evidence has suggested waves mainly travelling outwards from the rotation axis. These waves can transport angular momentum and possibly give rise to variations in Jupiter's rotation period of magnitude no greater than tens of milliseconds. In addition these internal disturbances could give rise to a 10% change over time in the zonal flows at a depth of 3000 km below the surface.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019; v1 submitted 29 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
On the necessary conditions for bursts of convection within the rapidly rotating cylindrical annulus
Authors:
Robert J. Teed,
Chris A. Jones,
Rainer Hollerbach
Abstract:
Zonal flows are often found in rotating convective systems. Not only are these jet-flows driven by the convection, they can also have a profound effect on the nature of the convection. In this work the cylindrical annulus geometry is exploited in order to perform nonlinear simulations seeking to produce strong zonal flows and multiple jets. The parameter regime is extended to Prandtl numbers that…
▽ More
Zonal flows are often found in rotating convective systems. Not only are these jet-flows driven by the convection, they can also have a profound effect on the nature of the convection. In this work the cylindrical annulus geometry is exploited in order to perform nonlinear simulations seeking to produce strong zonal flows and multiple jets. The parameter regime is extended to Prandtl numbers that are not unity. Multiple jets are found to be spaced according to a Rhines scaling based on the zonal flow speed, not the convective velocity speed. Under certain conditions the nonlinear convection appears in quasi-periodic bursts. A mean field stability analysis is performed around a basic state containing both the zonal flow and the mean temperature gradient found from the nonlinear simulations. The convective growth rates are found to fluctuate with both of these mean quantities suggesting that both are necessary in order for the bursting phenomenon to occur.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
The dynamics and excitation of torsional waves in geodynamo simulations
Authors:
Robert J. Teed,
Chris A. Jones,
Steven M. Tobias
Abstract:
The predominant force balance in rapidly rotating planetary cores is between Coriolis, pressure, buoyancy and Lorentz forces. This magnetostrophic balance leads to a Taylor state where the spatially averaged azimuthal Lorentz force is compelled to vanish on cylinders aligned with the rotation axis. Any deviation from this state leads to a torsional oscillation, signatures of which have been observ…
▽ More
The predominant force balance in rapidly rotating planetary cores is between Coriolis, pressure, buoyancy and Lorentz forces. This magnetostrophic balance leads to a Taylor state where the spatially averaged azimuthal Lorentz force is compelled to vanish on cylinders aligned with the rotation axis. Any deviation from this state leads to a torsional oscillation, signatures of which have been observed in the Earth's secular variation and are thought to influence length of day variations via angular momentum conservation. In order to investigate the dynamics of torsional oscillations, we perform several three-dimensional dynamo simulations in a spherical shell. We find torsional oscillations, identified by their propagation at the correct Alfvén speed, in many of our simulations. We find that the frequency, location and direction of propagation of the waves are influenced by the choice of parameters. Torsional waves are observed within the tangent cylinder and also have the ability to pass through it. Several of our simulations display waves with core travel times of 4 to 6 years. We calculate the driving terms for these waves and find that both the Reynolds force and ageostrophic convection acting through the Lorentz force are important in driving torsional oscillations.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Rapidly rotating plane layer convection with zonal flow
Authors:
Robert J. Teed,
Chris A. Jones,
Rainer Hollerbach
Abstract:
The onset of convection in a rapidly rotating layer in which a thermal wind is present is studied. Diffusive effects are included. The main motivation is from convection in planetary interiors, where thermal winds are expected due to temperature variations on the core-mantle boundary. The system admits both convective instability and baroclinic instability. We find a smooth transition between the…
▽ More
The onset of convection in a rapidly rotating layer in which a thermal wind is present is studied. Diffusive effects are included. The main motivation is from convection in planetary interiors, where thermal winds are expected due to temperature variations on the core-mantle boundary. The system admits both convective instability and baroclinic instability. We find a smooth transition between the two types of modes, and investigate where the transition region between the two types of instability occurs in parameter space. The thermal wind helps to destabilise the convective modes. Baroclinic instability can occur when the applied vertical temperature gradient is stable, and the critical Rayleigh number is then negative. Long wavelength modes are the first to become unstable. Asymptotic analysis is possible for the transition region and also for long wavelength instabilities, and the results agree well with our numerical solutions. We also investigate how the instabilities in this system relate to the classical baroclinic instability in the Eady problem. We conclude by noting that baroclinic instabilities in the Earth's core arising from heterogeneity in the lower mantle could possibly drive a dynamo even if the Earth's core were stably stratified and so not convecting.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
