-
On Nash-Williams' Theorem regarding sequences with finite range
Authors:
Fedor Pakhomov,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
The famous theorem of Higman states that for any well-quasi-order (wqo) $Q$ the embeddability order on finite sequences over $Q$ is also wqo. In his celebrated 1965 paper, Nash-Williams established that the same conclusion holds even for all the transfinite sequences with finite range, thus proving a far reaching generalization of Higman's theorem.
In the present paper we show that Nash-Williams…
▽ More
The famous theorem of Higman states that for any well-quasi-order (wqo) $Q$ the embeddability order on finite sequences over $Q$ is also wqo. In his celebrated 1965 paper, Nash-Williams established that the same conclusion holds even for all the transfinite sequences with finite range, thus proving a far reaching generalization of Higman's theorem.
In the present paper we show that Nash-Williams' Theorem is provable in the system $\mathsf{ATR}_0$ of second-order arithmetic, thus solving an open problem by Antonio Montalbán and proving the reverse-mathematical equivalence of Nash-Williams' Theorem and $\mathsf{ATR}_0$. In order to accomplish this, we establish equivalent characterization of transfinite Higman's order and an order on the cumulative hierarchy with urelements from the starting wqo $Q$, and find some new connection that can be of purely order-theoretic interest. Moreover, in this paper we present a new setup that allows us to develop the theory of $α$-wqo's in a way that is formalizable within primitive-recursive set theory with urelements, in a smooth and code-free fashion.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Sequential discontinuity and first-order problems
Authors:
Arno Pauly,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
We explore the low levels of the structure of the continuous Weihrauch degrees of first-order problems. In particular, we show that there exists a minimal discontinuous first-order degree, namely that of $\accn$, without any determinacy assumptions. The same degree is also revealed as the least sequentially discontinuous one, i.e. the least degree with a representative whose restriction to some se…
▽ More
We explore the low levels of the structure of the continuous Weihrauch degrees of first-order problems. In particular, we show that there exists a minimal discontinuous first-order degree, namely that of $\accn$, without any determinacy assumptions. The same degree is also revealed as the least sequentially discontinuous one, i.e. the least degree with a representative whose restriction to some sequence converging to a limit point is still discontinuous.
The study of games related to continuous Weihrauch reducibility constitutes an important ingredient in the proof of the main theorem. We present some initial additional results about the degrees of first-order problems that can be obtained using this approach.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Provable better quasi orders
Authors:
Anton Freund,
Alberto Marcone,
Fedor Pakhomov,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
It has recently been shown that fairly strong axiom systems such as $\mathsf{ACA}_0$ cannot prove that the antichain with three elements is a better quasi order ($\mathsf{bqo}$). In the present paper, we give a complete characterization of the finite partial orders that are provably $\mathsf{bqo}$ in such axiom systems. The result will also be extended to infinite orders. As an application, we der…
▽ More
It has recently been shown that fairly strong axiom systems such as $\mathsf{ACA}_0$ cannot prove that the antichain with three elements is a better quasi order ($\mathsf{bqo}$). In the present paper, we give a complete characterization of the finite partial orders that are provably $\mathsf{bqo}$ in such axiom systems. The result will also be extended to infinite orders. As an application, we derive that a version of the minimal bad array lemma is weak over $\mathsf{ACA_0}$. In sharp contrast, a recent result shows that the same version is equivalent to $Π^1_2$-comprehension over the stronger base theory $\mathsf{ATR}_0$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
The logical strength of minimal bad arrays
Authors:
Anton Freund,
Fedor Pakhomov,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
This paper studies logical aspects of the notion of better quasi order, which has been introduced by C. Nash-Williams (Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1965 & 1968). A central tool in the theory of better quasi orders is the minimal bad array lemma. We show that this lemma is exceptionally strong from the viewpoint of reverse mathematics, a framework from mathematica…
▽ More
This paper studies logical aspects of the notion of better quasi order, which has been introduced by C. Nash-Williams (Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1965 & 1968). A central tool in the theory of better quasi orders is the minimal bad array lemma. We show that this lemma is exceptionally strong from the viewpoint of reverse mathematics, a framework from mathematical logic. Specifically, it is equivalent to the set existence principle of $Π^1_2$-comprehension, over the base theory $\mathsf{ATR_0}$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
On the Weihrauch degree of the additive Ramsey theorem
Authors:
Arno Pauly,
Cécilia Pradic,
Giovanni Solda
Abstract:
We characterize the strength, in terms of Weihrauch degrees, of certain problems related to Ramsey-like theorems concerning colourings of the rationals and of the natural numbers. The theorems we are chiefly interested in assert the existence of almost-homogeneous sets for colourings of pairs of rationals respectively natural numbers satisfying properties determined by some additional algebraic st…
▽ More
We characterize the strength, in terms of Weihrauch degrees, of certain problems related to Ramsey-like theorems concerning colourings of the rationals and of the natural numbers. The theorems we are chiefly interested in assert the existence of almost-homogeneous sets for colourings of pairs of rationals respectively natural numbers satisfying properties determined by some additional algebraic structure on the set of colours.
In the context of reverse mathematics, most of the principles we study are equivalent to $Σ^0_2$-induction over $\mathrm{RCA}_0$. The associated problems in the Weihrauch lattice are related to $\mathrm{TC}_\mathbb{N}^*$, $(\mathrm{LPO}')^*$ or their product, depending on their precise formalizations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023; v1 submitted 7 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Algebraic properties of the first-order part of a problem
Authors:
Giovanni Solda,
Manlio Valenti
Abstract:
In this paper we study the notion of first-order part of a computational problem, first introduced by Dzhafarov, Solomon, and Yokoyama, which captures the "strongest computational problem with codomain $\mathbb{N}$ that is Weihrauch reducible to $f$". This operator is very useful to prove separation results, especially at the higher levels of the Weihrauch lattice. We explore the first-order part…
▽ More
In this paper we study the notion of first-order part of a computational problem, first introduced by Dzhafarov, Solomon, and Yokoyama, which captures the "strongest computational problem with codomain $\mathbb{N}$ that is Weihrauch reducible to $f$". This operator is very useful to prove separation results, especially at the higher levels of the Weihrauch lattice. We explore the first-order part in relation with several other operators already known in the literature. We also introduce a new operator, called unbounded finite parallelization, which plays an important role in characterizing the first-order part of parallelizable problems. We show how the obtained results can be used to explicitly characterize the first-order part of several known problems.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
(Extra)ordinary equivalences with the ascending/descending sequence principle
Authors:
Marta Fiori-Carones,
Alberto Marcone,
Paul Shafer,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
We analyze the axiomatic strength of the following theorem due to Rival and Sands in the style of reverse mathematics. "Every infinite partial order $P$ of finite width contains an infinite chain $C$ such that every element of $P$ is either comparable with no element of $C$ or with infinitely many elements of $C$." Our main results are the following. The Rival-Sands theorem for infinite partial or…
▽ More
We analyze the axiomatic strength of the following theorem due to Rival and Sands in the style of reverse mathematics. "Every infinite partial order $P$ of finite width contains an infinite chain $C$ such that every element of $P$ is either comparable with no element of $C$ or with infinitely many elements of $C$." Our main results are the following. The Rival-Sands theorem for infinite partial orders of arbitrary finite width is equivalent to $\mathsf{I}Σ^0_2 + \mathsf{ADS}$ over $\mathsf{RCA}_0$. For each fixed $k \geq 3$, the Rival-Sands theorem for infinite partial orders of width $\leq\! k$ is equivalent to $\mathsf{ADS}$ over $\mathsf{RCA}_0$. The Rival-Sands theorem for infinite partial orders that are decomposable into the union of two chains is equivalent to $\mathsf{SADS}$ over $\mathsf{RCA}_0$. Here $\mathsf{RCA}_0$ denotes the recursive comprehension axiomatic system, $\mathsf{I}Σ^0_2$ denotes the $Σ^0_2$ induction scheme, $\mathsf{ADS}$ denotes the ascending/descending sequence principle, and $\mathsf{SADS}$ denotes the stable ascending/descending sequence principle. To our knowledge, these versions of the Rival-Sands theorem for partial orders are the first examples of theorems from the general mathematics literature whose strength is exactly characterized by $\mathsf{I}Σ^0_2 + \mathsf{ADS}$, by $\mathsf{ADS}$, and by $\mathsf{SADS}$. Furthermore, we give a new purely combinatorial result by extending the Rival-Sands theorem to infinite partial orders that do not have infinite antichains, and we show that this extension is equivalent to arithmetical comprehension over $\mathsf{RCA}_0$.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
An inside/outside Ramsey theorem and recursion theory
Authors:
Marta Fiori-Carones,
Paul Shafer,
Giovanni Soldà
Abstract:
Inspired by Ramsey's theorem for pairs, Rival and Sands proved what we refer to as an inside/outside Ramsey theorem: every infinite graph $G$ contains an infinite subset $H$ such that every vertex of $G$ is adjacent to precisely none, one, or infinitely many vertices of $H$. We analyze the Rival-Sands theorem from the perspective of reverse mathematics and the Weihrauch degrees. In reverse mathema…
▽ More
Inspired by Ramsey's theorem for pairs, Rival and Sands proved what we refer to as an inside/outside Ramsey theorem: every infinite graph $G$ contains an infinite subset $H$ such that every vertex of $G$ is adjacent to precisely none, one, or infinitely many vertices of $H$. We analyze the Rival-Sands theorem from the perspective of reverse mathematics and the Weihrauch degrees. In reverse mathematics, we find that the Rival-Sands theorem is equivalent to arithmetical comprehension and hence is stronger than Ramsey's theorem for pairs. We also identify a weak form of the Rival-Sands theorem that is equivalent to Ramsey's theorem for pairs. We turn to the Weihrauch degrees to give a finer analysis of the Rival-Sands theorem's computational strength. We find that the Rival-Sands theorem is Weihrauch equivalent to the double jump of weak König's lemma. We believe that the Rival-Sands theorem is the first natural theorem shown to exhibit exactly this strength. Furthermore, by combining our result with a result of Brattka and Rakotoniaina, we obtain that solving one instance of the Rival-Sands theorem exactly corresponds to simultaneously solving countably many instances of Ramsey's theorem for pairs. Finally, we show that the uniform computational strength of the weak Rival-Sands theorem is weaker than that of Ramsey's theorem for pairs by showing that a number of well-known consequences of Ramsey's theorem for pairs do not Weihrauch reduce to the weak Rival-Sands theorem. We also address an apparent gap in the literature concerning the relationship between Weihrauch degrees corresponding to the ascending/descending sequence principle and the infinite pigeonhole principle.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2021; v1 submitted 30 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
