-
Magnetic Webs in Stellar Radiative Zones
Authors:
Valentin A. Skoutnev,
Andrei M. Beloborodov
Abstract:
Rotational evolution of stellar radiative zones is an old puzzle. We argue that angular momentum (AM) transport by turbulent processes induced by differential rotation is insufficient, and propose that a key role is played by ``magnetic webs." We define magnetic webs as stable magnetic configurations that enforce corotation of their coupled mass shells. Stable magnetic configurations naturally for…
▽ More
Rotational evolution of stellar radiative zones is an old puzzle. We argue that angular momentum (AM) transport by turbulent processes induced by differential rotation is insufficient, and propose that a key role is played by ``magnetic webs." We define magnetic webs as stable magnetic configurations that enforce corotation of their coupled mass shells. Stable magnetic configurations naturally form through relaxation of helical magnetic fields deposited in parts of radiative zones. We discuss the conditions for a magnetic configuration to be sufficiently sturdy to prevent the build up of differential rotation, and conclude that these conditions are easily met in stellar interiors. Low mass stars on the red giant branch (RGB) likely have their compact cores coupled to the lower part of their extended radiative mantle by a magnetic web that was deposited by the receding zone of core convection on the main sequence. This results in moderate core rotation that is broadly consistent with asteroseismic observations, as we illustrate with a stellar evolution model with mass $1.6M_\odot$. Evolving massive stars host more complicated patterns of convective zones that may leave behind many webs, transporting AM towards the surface. Efficient web formation likely results in most massive stars dying with magnetized and slowly rotating cores.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Zones of Tayler Instability in Stars
Authors:
Valentin A. Skoutnev,
Andrei M. Beloborodov
Abstract:
The Tayler instability (TI) of toroidal magnetic fields is a candidate mechanism for driving turbulence, angular momentum transport, and dynamo action in stellar radiative zones. Recently Skoutnev & Beloborodov (2024) revisited the linear stability analysis of a toroidal magnetic field in a rotating and stably stratified fluid. In this paper, we extend the analysis to include both thermal and comp…
▽ More
The Tayler instability (TI) of toroidal magnetic fields is a candidate mechanism for driving turbulence, angular momentum transport, and dynamo action in stellar radiative zones. Recently Skoutnev & Beloborodov (2024) revisited the linear stability analysis of a toroidal magnetic field in a rotating and stably stratified fluid. In this paper, we extend the analysis to include both thermal and compositional stratification, allowing for general application to stars. We formulate an analytical instability criterion for use as a ``toggle switch" in stellar evolution codes. It determines when and where in a star the Tayler-Spruit dynamo may be responsible for angular momentum transport. We implement such a ``toggle switch" in the MESA stellar evolution code and map out the stability of each mode of the TI on a grid of stellar evolution models. In evolved lower mass stars, the TI becomes suppressed in compositionally stratified regions, undermining the Tayler-Spruit dynamo as an explanation of the core-envelope coupling. In higher mass stars, the TI is active throughout the radiative zones, but at different wavenumbers than previously expected.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
Tayler Instability Revisited
Authors:
Valentin A. Skoutnev,
Andrei M. Beloborodov
Abstract:
Tayler instability of toroidal magnetic fields $B_φ$ is broadly invoked as a trigger for turbulence and angular momentum transport in stars. This paper presents a systematic revision of the linear stability analysis for a rotating, magnetized, and stably stratified star. For plausible configurations of $B_φ$, instability requires diffusive processes: viscosity, magnetic diffusivity, or thermal/com…
▽ More
Tayler instability of toroidal magnetic fields $B_φ$ is broadly invoked as a trigger for turbulence and angular momentum transport in stars. This paper presents a systematic revision of the linear stability analysis for a rotating, magnetized, and stably stratified star. For plausible configurations of $B_φ$, instability requires diffusive processes: viscosity, magnetic diffusivity, or thermal/compositional diffusion. Our results reveal a new physical picture, demonstrating how different diffusive effects independently trigger instability of two types of waves in the rotating star: magnetostrophic waves and inertial waves. It develops via overstability of the waves, whose growth rate sharply peaks at some characteristic wavenumbers. We determine instability conditions for each wave branch and find the characteristic wavenumbers. The results are qualitatively different for stars with magnetic Prandtl number $Pm\ll 1$ (e.g. the Sun) and $Pm\gg 1$ (e.g. protoneutron stars). The parameter dependence of unstable modes suggests a non-universal scaling of the possible Tayler-Spruit dynamo.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2024; v1 submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Critical Balance and Scaling of Strongly Stratified Turbulence at Low Prandtl Number
Authors:
Valentin A. Skoutnev
Abstract:
We extend the scaling relations of stably stratified turbulence from the geophysical regime of unity Prandtl number to the astrophysical regime of extremely small Prandtl number applicable to stably stratified regions of stars and gas giants. A transition to a new turbulent regime is found to occur when the Prandtl number drops below the inverse of the buoyancy Reynolds number, i.e. $PrRb<1$, whic…
▽ More
We extend the scaling relations of stably stratified turbulence from the geophysical regime of unity Prandtl number to the astrophysical regime of extremely small Prandtl number applicable to stably stratified regions of stars and gas giants. A transition to a new turbulent regime is found to occur when the Prandtl number drops below the inverse of the buoyancy Reynolds number, i.e. $PrRb<1$, which signals a shift of the dominant balance in the buoyancy equation. Application of critical balance arguments then derives new predictions for the anisotropic energy spectrum and dominant balance of the Boussinesq equations in the $PrRb\ll1$ regime. We find that all the standard scaling relations from the unity $Pr$ limit of stably stratified turbulence simply carry over if the Froude number, $Fr$, is replaced by a modified Froude number, $Fr_M\equiv Fr/(PrRb)^{1/4}$. The geophysical and astrophysical regimes are thus smoothly connected across the $PrRb=1$ transition. Applications to vertical transport in stellar radiative zones and modification to the instability criterion for the small-scale dynamo are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2022; v1 submitted 3 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
On large-scale dynamos with stable stratification and the application to stellar radiative zones
Authors:
Valentin Skoutnev,
Jonathan Squire,
Amitava Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
Our understanding of large-scale magnetic fields in stellar radiative zones remains fragmented and incomplete. Such magnetic fields, which must be produced by some form of dynamo mechanism, are thought to dominate angular-momentum transport, making them crucial to stellar evolution. A major difficulty is the effect of stable stratification, which generally suppresses dynamo action. We explore the…
▽ More
Our understanding of large-scale magnetic fields in stellar radiative zones remains fragmented and incomplete. Such magnetic fields, which must be produced by some form of dynamo mechanism, are thought to dominate angular-momentum transport, making them crucial to stellar evolution. A major difficulty is the effect of stable stratification, which generally suppresses dynamo action. We explore the effects of stable stratification on mean-field dynamo theory with a particular focus on a non-helical large-scale dynamo (LSD) mechanism known as the magnetic shear-current effect. We find that the mechanism is robust to increasing stable stratification as long as the original requirements for its operation are met: a source of shear and non-helical magnetic fluctuations (e.g. from a small-scale dynamo). Both are plausibly sourced in the presence of differential rotation. Our idealized direct numerical simulations, supported by mean-field theory, demonstrate the generation of near equipartition large-scale toroidal fields. Additionally, a scan over magnetic Reynolds number shows no change in the growth or saturation of the LSD, providing good numerical evidence of a dynamo mechanism resilient to catastrophic quenching, which has been an issue for helical dynamos. These properties -- the absence of catastrophic quenching and robustness to stable stratification -- make the mechanism a plausible candidate for generating in-situ large-scale magnetic fields in stellar radiative zones.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2022; v1 submitted 3 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Scaling of Small-Scale Dynamo Properties in the Rayleigh-Taylor Instability
Authors:
Valentin Skoutnev,
Elias R. Most,
Amitava Bhattacharjee,
Alexander A. Philippov
Abstract:
We derive scaling relations based on free-fall and isotropy assumptions for the kinematic small-scale dynamo growth rate and amplification factor over the course of the mixing, saturation, and decay phases of the Rayleigh-Taylor instability (RTI) in a fully-ionized plasma. The scaling relations are tested using sets of three dimensional, visco-resistive MHD simulations of the RTI and found to hold…
▽ More
We derive scaling relations based on free-fall and isotropy assumptions for the kinematic small-scale dynamo growth rate and amplification factor over the course of the mixing, saturation, and decay phases of the Rayleigh-Taylor instability (RTI) in a fully-ionized plasma. The scaling relations are tested using sets of three dimensional, visco-resistive MHD simulations of the RTI and found to hold in the saturation phase, but exhibit discrepancies during the mixing and decays phases, suggesting a need to relax either the free-fall or isotropy assumptions. Application of the scaling relations allows for quantitative prediction of the net amplification of magnetic energy in the kinematic dynamo phase and therefore a determination of whether the magnetic energy either remains sub-equipartition at all velocity scales or reaches equipartition with at least some scales of the turbulent kinetic energy in laboratory and astrophysical scenarios. As an example, we consider the dynamo in RTI-unstable regions of the outer envelope of a binary neutron star merger and predict that the kinematic regime of the small-scale dynamo ends on the time scale of nanoseconds and then reaches saturation on a timescale of microseconds, which are both fast compared to the millisecond relaxation time of the post-merger.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021; v1 submitted 8 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Small-Scale Dynamo in Stably Stratified Turbulence
Authors:
Valentin Skoutnev,
Jonathan Squire,
Amitava Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
We present numerical investigations into three principal properties of the small-scale dynamo in stably stratified turbulence: the onset criterion, the growth rate, and the nature of the magnetic field anisotropy in the kinematic regime. The results suggest that all three dynamo properties are controlled by the scale separation between the Ozmidov scale and the viscous or resistive scale. In addit…
▽ More
We present numerical investigations into three principal properties of the small-scale dynamo in stably stratified turbulence: the onset criterion, the growth rate, and the nature of the magnetic field anisotropy in the kinematic regime. The results suggest that all three dynamo properties are controlled by the scale separation between the Ozmidov scale and the viscous or resistive scale. In addition to the critical magnetic Reynolds number, this allows for the definition of critical buoyancy and magnetic buoyancy Reynolds numbers for stratified small-scale dynamo onset in the high and low magnetic Prandtl number regimes, respectively. The presence of a small-scale dynamo in stellar radiative zones could affect dynamics through resulting Maxwell stresses and/or influence large-scale dynamo mechanisms in regions of differential rotation. Taking the solar radiative zone as a representative example and applying the onset criterion, we find that the stratification is strong enough to make the small-scale dynamo marginally active in the stably stratified turbulence of the solar tachocline.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2021; v1 submitted 3 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Noise-Induced Magnetic Field Saturation in Kinetic Simulations
Authors:
J. Juno,
M. Swisdak,
J. M. TenBarge,
V. Skoutnev,
A. Hakim
Abstract:
Monte Carlo methods are often employed to numerically integrate kinetic equations, such as the particle-in-cell method for the plasma kinetic equation, but these methods suffer from the introduction of counting noise to the solution. We report on a cautionary tale of counting noise modifying the nonlinear saturation of kinetic instabilities driven by unstable beams of plasma. We find a saturated m…
▽ More
Monte Carlo methods are often employed to numerically integrate kinetic equations, such as the particle-in-cell method for the plasma kinetic equation, but these methods suffer from the introduction of counting noise to the solution. We report on a cautionary tale of counting noise modifying the nonlinear saturation of kinetic instabilities driven by unstable beams of plasma. We find a saturated magnetic field in under-resolved particle-in-cell simulations due to the sampling error in the current density. The noise-induced magnetic field is anomalous, as the magnetic field damps away in continuum kinetic and increased particle count particle-in-cell simulations. This modification of the saturated state has implications for a broad array of astrophysical phenomena beyond the simple plasma system considered here, and it stresses the care that must be taken when using particle methods for kinetic equations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2020; v1 submitted 15 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Boundary-induced effect on the spoke-like activity in ExB plasma
Authors:
Eduardo Rodriguez,
Valentin Skoutnev,
Yevgeny Raitses,
Andrew Powis,
Igor Kaganovich,
Andrei Smolyakov
Abstract:
The spoke instability in an $E\times B$ Penning discharge is shown to be strongly affected by the boundary that is perpendicular to $B$ field lines. The instability is the strongest when bounded by dielectric walls. With a conducting wall, biased to collect electron current from the plasma, the spoke becomes faster, less coherent and localised closer to the axis. The corresponding anomalous cross-…
▽ More
The spoke instability in an $E\times B$ Penning discharge is shown to be strongly affected by the boundary that is perpendicular to $B$ field lines. The instability is the strongest when bounded by dielectric walls. With a conducting wall, biased to collect electron current from the plasma, the spoke becomes faster, less coherent and localised closer to the axis. The corresponding anomalous cross-field transport is assessed via simultaneous time-resolved measurements of plasma potential and density. This shows a dominant large-scale $E\times B$ anomalous character of the electron cross-field current for dielectric walls reaching $40-100$% of the discharge current, with an effective Hall parameter $β_\mathrm{eff}\sim10$. The anomalous current is greatly reduced with the conducting boundary (characterised by $β_\mathrm{eff}\sim10^2$). These experimental measurements are shown to be qualitatively consistent with the decrease of the $E$ field that triggers the collisionless Simon-Hoh instability.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Temperature-dependent Saturation of Weibel-type Instabilities in Counter-streaming Plasmas
Authors:
V. Skoutnev,
A. Hakim,
J. Juno,
J. M. TenBarge
Abstract:
We present the first 2X2V continuum Vlasov-Maxwell simulations of interpenetrating, unmagnetized plasmas to study the competition between two-stream, Oblique, and filamentation modes in the weakly relativistic regime. We find that after nonlinear saturation of the fastest-growing two-stream and Oblique modes, the effective temperature anisotropy, which drives current filament formation via the sec…
▽ More
We present the first 2X2V continuum Vlasov-Maxwell simulations of interpenetrating, unmagnetized plasmas to study the competition between two-stream, Oblique, and filamentation modes in the weakly relativistic regime. We find that after nonlinear saturation of the fastest-growing two-stream and Oblique modes, the effective temperature anisotropy, which drives current filament formation via the secular Weibel instability, has a strong dependence on the internal temperature of the counter-streaming plasmas. The effective temperature anisotropy is significantly more reduced in colder than in hotter plasmas, leading to orders of magnitude lower magnetization for colder plasmas. A strong dependence of the energy conversion efficiency of Weibel-type instabilities on internal beam temperature has implications for determining their contribution to the observed magnetization of many astrophysical and laboratory plasmas.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
