Showing 1–50 of 67 results for author: Sivak, A

Information thermodynamics of cellular ion pumps

Authors: Julian D. Jiménez-Paz, Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: The framework of bipartite stochastic thermodynamics is a powerful tool to analyze a composite system's internal thermodynamics. It has been used to study the components of different molecular machines such as ATP synthase. However, this approach has not yet been used to describe ion-transporting proteins despite their high-level functional similarity. Here we study the bipartite thermodynamics of… ▽ More The framework of bipartite stochastic thermodynamics is a powerful tool to analyze a composite system's internal thermodynamics. It has been used to study the components of different molecular machines such as ATP synthase. However, this approach has not yet been used to describe ion-transporting proteins despite their high-level functional similarity. Here we study the bipartite thermodynamics of the sodium-potassium pump in the nonequilibrium steady state. Using a physically intuitive partition between the ATP-consuming subsystem and the ion-transporting subsystem, we find considerable information flow comparable to other molecular machines, and Maxwell-demon behavior in the ATP-consuming subsystem. We vary ion concentrations and transmembrane voltage in a range including the neuronal action potential, and find that the information flow inverts during depolarization. △ Less

Submitted 12 June, 2025; originally announced June 2025.

Comments: 9 pages, 5 figures

Efficiently driving F$_1$ molecular motor in experiment by suppressing nonequilibrium variation

Authors: Takahide Mishima, Deepak Gupta, Yohei Nakayama, W. Callum Wareham, Takumi Ohyama, David A. Sivak, Shoichi Toyabe

Abstract: F$_1$-ATPase (F$_1$) is central to cellular energy transduction. Forcibly rotated by another motor F$_\mathrm{o}$, F$_1$ catalyzes ATP synthesis by converting mechanical work into chemical free energy stored in the molecule ATP. The details of how F$_\mathrm{o}$ drives F$_1$ are not fully understood; however, evaluating efficient ways to rotate F$_1$ could provide fruitful insights into this drivi… ▽ More F$_1$-ATPase (F$_1$) is central to cellular energy transduction. Forcibly rotated by another motor F$_\mathrm{o}$, F$_1$ catalyzes ATP synthesis by converting mechanical work into chemical free energy stored in the molecule ATP. The details of how F$_\mathrm{o}$ drives F$_1$ are not fully understood; however, evaluating efficient ways to rotate F$_1$ could provide fruitful insights into this driving since there is a selective pressure to improve efficiency. Here, we show that rotating F$_1$ with an angle clamp is significantly more efficient than a constant torque. Our experiments, combined with theory and simulation, indicate that the angle clamp significantly suppresses the nonequilibrium variation that contributes to the futile dissipation of input work. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures for the main manuscript. 9 pages, 5 figures for the supplemental material

Hunting for Maxwell's Demon in the Wild

Authors: Johan du Buisson, Jannik Ehrich, Matthew P. Leighton, Avijit Kundu, Tushar K. Saha, John Bechhoefer, David A. Sivak

Abstract: The apparent paradox of Maxwell's demon motivated the development of information thermodynamics and, more recently, engineering advances enabling the creation of nanoscale information engines. From these advances, it is now understood that nanoscale machines like the molecular motors within cells can in principle operate as Maxwell demons. This motivates the question: does information help power m… ▽ More The apparent paradox of Maxwell's demon motivated the development of information thermodynamics and, more recently, engineering advances enabling the creation of nanoscale information engines. From these advances, it is now understood that nanoscale machines like the molecular motors within cells can in principle operate as Maxwell demons. This motivates the question: does information help power molecular motors? Answering this would seemingly require simultaneous measurement of all system degrees of freedom, which is generally intractable in single-molecule experiments. To overcome this limitation, we derive a statistical estimator to infer both the direction and magnitude of subsystem heat flows, and thus to determine whether -- and how strongly -- a motor operates as a Maxwell demon. The estimator uses only trajectory measurements for a single degree of freedom. We demonstrate the estimator by applying it to simulations of an experimental realization of an information engine and a kinesin molecular motor. Our results show that kinesin transitions to a Maxwell-demon mechanism in the presence of nonequilibrium noise, with a corresponding increase in velocity consistent with experiments. These findings suggest that molecular motors may have evolved to leverage active fluctuations within cells. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2025; originally announced April 2025.

Comments: 12 pages, 5 figures

Multiparameter optimal control of F1-ATPase

Authors: W. Callum Wareham, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Biological molecular machines convert free energy between different forms in cells, often at high efficiency. Optimal control theory provides a framework to elucidate design principles governing energetically efficient driving. Here, we use linear-response theory to design efficient protocols exercising dynamic control of trap center and stiffness in a model of driven F1-ATPase. We find that the k… ▽ More Biological molecular machines convert free energy between different forms in cells, often at high efficiency. Optimal control theory provides a framework to elucidate design principles governing energetically efficient driving. Here, we use linear-response theory to design efficient protocols exercising dynamic control of trap center and stiffness in a model of driven F1-ATPase. We find that the key design principles of an efficient protocol can be satisfied either by dynamic control of both parameters or by dynamic control of a single parameter and a good static choice for the second. These results illustrate that accessing a new degree of dynamic control provides varying performance improvements in different systems. △ Less

Submitted 10 June, 2025; v1 submitted 31 October, 2024; originally announced October 2024.

Comments: 8 main text pages, 2 appendices

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 111, 064410 (2025)

Global thermodynamic manifold for conservative control of stochastic systems

Authors: Jordan R. Sawchuk, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Optimal control of stochastic systems plays a central role in nonequilibrium physics, with applications in the study of biological molecular motors and the design of single-molecule experiments. While exact analytic solutions to optimization problems are rare, under slow driving conditions, the problem can be reformulated geometrically solely in terms of equilibrium properties. In this framework,… ▽ More Optimal control of stochastic systems plays a central role in nonequilibrium physics, with applications in the study of biological molecular motors and the design of single-molecule experiments. While exact analytic solutions to optimization problems are rare, under slow driving conditions, the problem can be reformulated geometrically solely in terms of equilibrium properties. In this framework, minimum-work protocols are geodesics on a thermodynamic manifold whose metric is a generalized friction tensor. Here, we introduce a new foundation for this friction-tensor formalism for conservatively driven systems. Under complete control of the potential energy, a global thermodynamic manifold (on which points are identified with instantaneous energy landscapes) has as its metric a full-control friction tensor. Arbitrary partial-control friction tensors arise naturally as inherited metrics on submanifolds of this global manifold. Leveraging a simple mathematical relationship between system dynamics and the geometry of the global manifold, we derive new expressions for the friction tensor that offer powerful tools for interpretation and computation of friction tensors and minimum-work protocols. Our results elucidate a connection between relaxation and dissipation in slowly driven systems and suggest optimization heuristics. We demonstrate the utility of these developments in three illustrative examples. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2025; v1 submitted 26 September, 2024; originally announced September 2024.

Comments: 13 pages, 3 page appendices, 8 figures

Flow of Energy and Information in Molecular Machines

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Molecular machines transduce free energy between different forms throughout all living organisms. While truly machines in their own right, unlike their macroscopic counterparts molecular machines are characterized by stochastic fluctuations, overdamped dynamics, and soft components, and operate far from thermodynamic equilibrium. In addition, information is a relevant free-energy resource for mole… ▽ More Molecular machines transduce free energy between different forms throughout all living organisms. While truly machines in their own right, unlike their macroscopic counterparts molecular machines are characterized by stochastic fluctuations, overdamped dynamics, and soft components, and operate far from thermodynamic equilibrium. In addition, information is a relevant free-energy resource for molecular machines, leading to new modes of operation for nanoscale engines. Towards the objective of engineering synthetic nanomachines, an important goal is to understand how molecular machines transduce free energy to perform their functions in biological systems. In this review we discuss the nonequilibrium thermodynamics of free-energy transduction within molecular machines, with a focus on quantifying energy and information flows between their components. We review results from theory, modeling, and inference from experiments that shed light on the internal thermodynamics of molecular machines, and ultimately explore what we can learn from considering these interactions. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2024; originally announced June 2024.

Comments: Review article. 19 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 76, 379-403 (2025)

Multimodal Fusion of Echocardiography and Electronic Health Records for the Detection of Cardiac Amyloidosis

Authors: Zishun Feng, Joseph A. Sivak, Ashok K. Krishnamurthy

Abstract: Cardiac amyloidosis, a rare and highly morbid condition, presents significant challenges for detection through echocardiography. Recently, there has been a surge in proposing machine-learning algorithms to identify cardiac amyloidosis, with the majority being imaging-based deep-learning approaches that require extensive data. In this study, we introduce a novel transformer-based multimodal fusion… ▽ More Cardiac amyloidosis, a rare and highly morbid condition, presents significant challenges for detection through echocardiography. Recently, there has been a surge in proposing machine-learning algorithms to identify cardiac amyloidosis, with the majority being imaging-based deep-learning approaches that require extensive data. In this study, we introduce a novel transformer-based multimodal fusion algorithm that leverages information from both imaging and electronic health records. Specifically, our approach utilizes echocardiography videos from both the parasternal long-axis (PLAX) view and the apical 4-chamber (A4C) view along with patients' demographic data, laboratory tests, and cardiac metrics to predict the probability of cardiac amyloidosis. We evaluated our method using 5-fold cross-validation on a dataset comprising 41 patients and achieved an Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve (AUROC) of 0.94. The experimental results demonstrate that our approach can achieve competitive results with a significantly smaller dataset compared to prior imaging-based methods that required data from thousands of patients. This underscores the potential of leveraging multimodal data to enhance diagnostic accuracy in the identification of complex cardiac conditions such as cardiac amyloidosis. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Performance limits of information engines

Authors: Johan du Buisson, David A. Sivak, John Bechhoefer

Abstract: We review recent studies of a colloidal information engine that consists of a bead in water and held by an optical trap. The bead is ratcheted upward without any apparent external work, by taking advantage of favorable thermal fluctuations. Much of the previous work on such engines aimed to show that accounting for information-processing costs can reconcile the observed motion with the second law… ▽ More We review recent studies of a colloidal information engine that consists of a bead in water and held by an optical trap. The bead is ratcheted upward without any apparent external work, by taking advantage of favorable thermal fluctuations. Much of the previous work on such engines aimed to show that accounting for information-processing costs can reconcile the observed motion with the second law of thermodynamics. By contrast, we focus on the factors that limit the performance of such engines by optimizing variously the upward velocity, rate of gravitational free-energy extraction, or ability to track a trajectory. We then consider measurement noise, which degrades engine performance. A naive use of noisy measurements in the feedback algorithm leads to a phase transition at finite signal-to-noise ratio: below the transition, the engine no longer functions. A more sophisticated, `Bayesian' algorithm eliminates the phase transition and improves performance. Finally, operating the information engine in a nonequilibrium environment with extra force fluctuations can enhance the performance by orders of magnitude, even to the point where the energy extracted exceeds that needed to run the information processing. Autonomous implementations of an information engine in such environments could be powered entirely by the additional energy of the bath. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 25 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Adv. Phys. X 9(1), 2352112 (2024)

Information thermodynamics of transition paths between multiple mesostates

Authors: Miranda D. Louwerse, David A. Sivak

Abstract: A central concern across the natural sciences is a quantitative understanding of the mechanism governing rare transitions between two metastable states. Recent research has uncovered a fundamental equality between the time-reversal asymmetry of the ensemble of such transition paths and the informativeness of system dynamics about the reactivity of a given trajectory, immediately leading to quantit… ▽ More A central concern across the natural sciences is a quantitative understanding of the mechanism governing rare transitions between two metastable states. Recent research has uncovered a fundamental equality between the time-reversal asymmetry of the ensemble of such transition paths and the informativeness of system dynamics about the reactivity of a given trajectory, immediately leading to quantitative criteria for judging the importance of distinct system coordinates for the transition. Here we generalize this framework to multiple mesostates. We find that the main system-wide and coordinate-specific results generalize intuitively, while the combinatorial diversity of pairwise transitions raises new questions and points to new concepts. This work increases the previous framework's generality and applicability and forges connections to enhanced-sampling and coarse-grained dynamical approaches such as milestoning and Markov-state models. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: 9 pages main text, 2 pages Appendices

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 109, 064112 (2024)

Information Arbitrage in Bipartite Heat Engines

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, Jannik Ehrich, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Heat engines and information engines have each historically served as motivating examples for the development of thermodynamics. While these two types of systems are typically thought of as two separate kinds of machines, recent empirical studies of specific systems have hinted at possible connections between the two. Inspired by molecular machines in the cellular environment, which in many cases… ▽ More Heat engines and information engines have each historically served as motivating examples for the development of thermodynamics. While these two types of systems are typically thought of as two separate kinds of machines, recent empirical studies of specific systems have hinted at possible connections between the two. Inspired by molecular machines in the cellular environment, which in many cases have separate components in contact with distinct sources of fluctuations, we study bipartite heat engines. We show that a bipartite heat engine can only produce net output work by acting as an information engine. Conversely, information engines can only extract more work than the work consumed to power them if they have access to different sources of fluctuations, i.e., act as heat engines. We illustrate these findings first through an analogy to economics and a cyclically controlled 2D ideal gas. We then explore two analytically tractable model systems in more detail: a Brownian-gyrator heat engine which we show can be reinterpreted as a feedback-cooling information engine, and a quantum-dot information engine which can be reinterpreted as a thermoelectric heat engine. Our results suggest design principles for both heat engines and information engines at the nanoscale, and ultimately imply constraints on how free-energy transduction is carried out in biological molecular machines. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: 23 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. X 14, 041038 (2024)

Jensen bound for the entropy production rate in stochastic thermodynamics

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Bounding and estimating entropy production has long been an important goal of nonequilibrium thermodynamics. We recently derived a lower bound on the total and subsystem entropy production rates of continuous stochastic systems. This `Jensen bound' has led to fundamental limits on the performance of collective transport systems and permitted thermodynamic inference of free-energy transduction betw… ▽ More Bounding and estimating entropy production has long been an important goal of nonequilibrium thermodynamics. We recently derived a lower bound on the total and subsystem entropy production rates of continuous stochastic systems. This `Jensen bound' has led to fundamental limits on the performance of collective transport systems and permitted thermodynamic inference of free-energy transduction between components of bipartite molecular machines. Our original derivation relied on a number of assumptions, which restricted the bound's regime of applicability. Here we derive the Jensen bound far more generally for multipartite overdamped Langevin dynamics. We then consider several extensions, allowing for position-dependent diffusion coefficients, underdamped dynamics, and non-multipartite overdamped dynamics. Our results extend the Jensen bound to a far broader class of systems. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2023; v1 submitted 18 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 7 pages, 0 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 109, L012101 (2024)

Efficient control protocols for an active Ornstein-Uhlenbeck particle

Authors: Deepak Gupta, Sabine H. L. Klapp, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Designing a protocol to efficiently drive a stochastic system is an active field of research. Here we extend such control theory to an active Ornstein-Uhlenbeck particle (AOUP) in a bistable potential, driven by a harmonic trap. We find that protocols designed to minimize the excess work (up to linear-response) perform better than naive protocols with constant velocity for a wide range of protocol… ▽ More Designing a protocol to efficiently drive a stochastic system is an active field of research. Here we extend such control theory to an active Ornstein-Uhlenbeck particle (AOUP) in a bistable potential, driven by a harmonic trap. We find that protocols designed to minimize the excess work (up to linear-response) perform better than naive protocols with constant velocity for a wide range of protocol durations. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2023; v1 submitted 25 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 8 figures, Minor revision

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 108, 024117 (2023)

Signal in the noise: temporal variation in exponentially growing populations

Authors: Eric W. Jones, Joshua Derrick, Roger M. Nisbet, Will Ludington, David A. Sivak

Abstract: In exponential population growth, variability in the timing of individual division events and environmental factors (including stochastic inoculation) compound to produce variable growth trajectories. In several stochastic models of exponential growth we show power-law relationships that relate variability in the time required to reach a threshold population size to growth rate and inoculum size.… ▽ More In exponential population growth, variability in the timing of individual division events and environmental factors (including stochastic inoculation) compound to produce variable growth trajectories. In several stochastic models of exponential growth we show power-law relationships that relate variability in the time required to reach a threshold population size to growth rate and inoculum size. Population-growth experiments in E. coli and S. aureus with inoculum sizes ranging between 1 and 100 are consistent with these relationships. We quantify how noise accumulates over time, finding that it encodes -- and can be used to deduce -- information about the early growth rate of a population. △ Less

Submitted 7 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 6 page main text with 5 figures, 8 page supplement with 4 figures. Updated with substantially revised manuscript

Journal ref: Sci. Rep. 13, 21340 (2023)

Unlocking the potential of information flow: Maximizing free-energy transduction in a model of an autonomous rotary molecular motor

Authors: Mathis Grelier, David A. Sivak, Jannik Ehrich

Abstract: Molecular motors fulfill critical functions within all living beings. Understanding their underlying working principles is therefore of great interest. Here we develop a simple model inspired by the two-component biomolecular motor Fo-F1 ATP synthase. We analyze its energetics and characterize information flows between the machine's components. At maximum output power we find that information tran… ▽ More Molecular motors fulfill critical functions within all living beings. Understanding their underlying working principles is therefore of great interest. Here we develop a simple model inspired by the two-component biomolecular motor Fo-F1 ATP synthase. We analyze its energetics and characterize information flows between the machine's components. At maximum output power we find that information transduction plays a minor role for free-energy transduction. However, when the two components are coupled to different environments (e.g., when in contact with heat baths at different temperatures), we show that information flow becomes a resource worth exploiting to maximize free-energy transduction. Our findings suggest that real-world powerful and efficient information engines could be found in machines whose components are subjected to fluctuations of different strength, since in this situation the benefit gained from using information for work extraction can outweigh the costs of information generation. △ Less

Submitted 13 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 109, 034115 (2024)

Remembering the work of Phillip L. Geissler: A coda to his scientific trajectory

Authors: Gregory R. Bowman, Stephen J. Cox, Christoph Dellago, Kateri H. DuBay, Joel D. Eaves, Daniel A. Fletcher, Layne B. Frechette, Michael Grünwald, Katherine Klymko, JiYeon Ku, Ahmad K. Omar, Eran Rabani, David R. Reichman, Julia R. Rogers, Andreana M. Rosnik, Grant M. Rotskoff, Anna R. Schneider, Nadine Schwierz, David A. Sivak, Suriyanarayanan Vaikuntanathan, Stephen Whitelam, Asaph Widmer-Cooper

Abstract: Phillip L. Geissler made important contributions to the statistical mechanics of biological polymers, heterogeneous materials, and chemical dynamics in aqueous environments. He devised analytical and computational methods that revealed the underlying organization of complex systems at the frontiers of biology, chemistry, and materials science. In this retrospective, we celebrate his work at these… ▽ More Phillip L. Geissler made important contributions to the statistical mechanics of biological polymers, heterogeneous materials, and chemical dynamics in aqueous environments. He devised analytical and computational methods that revealed the underlying organization of complex systems at the frontiers of biology, chemistry, and materials science. In this retrospective, we celebrate his work at these frontiers. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Journal ref: Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 74, 11.1-11.27 (2023)

Optimal Control in Stochastic Thermodynamics

Authors: Steven Blaber, David A. Sivak

Abstract: We review recent progress in optimal control in stochastic thermodynamics. Theoretical advances provide in-depth insight into minimum-dissipation control with either full or limited (parametric) control, and spanning the limits from slow to fast driving and from weak to strong driving. Known exact solutions give a window into the properties of minimum-dissipation control, which are reproduced by a… ▽ More We review recent progress in optimal control in stochastic thermodynamics. Theoretical advances provide in-depth insight into minimum-dissipation control with either full or limited (parametric) control, and spanning the limits from slow to fast driving and from weak to strong driving. Known exact solutions give a window into the properties of minimum-dissipation control, which are reproduced by approximate methods in the relevant limits. Connections between optimal-transport theory and minimum-dissipation protocols under full control give deep insight into the properties of optimal control and place bounds on the dissipation of thermodynamic processes. Since minimum-dissipation protocols are relatively well understood and advanced approximation methods and numerical techniques for estimating minimum-dissipation protocols have been developed, now is an opportune time for application to chemical and biological systems. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2023; v1 submitted 1 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Journal ref: J. Phys. Commun. 7, 033001 (2023)

Optimal Control of the F${_1}$-ATPase Molecular Motor

Authors: Deepak Gupta, Steven J. Large, Shoichi Toyabe, David A. Sivak

Abstract: F$_{1}$-ATPase is a rotary molecular motor that \emph{in vivo} is subject to strong nonequilibrium driving forces. There is great interest in understanding the operational principles governing its high efficiency of free-energy transduction. Here we use a near-equilibrium framework to design a non-trivial control protocol to minimize dissipation in rotating F$_{1}$ to synthesize ATP. We find that… ▽ More F$_{1}$-ATPase is a rotary molecular motor that \emph{in vivo} is subject to strong nonequilibrium driving forces. There is great interest in understanding the operational principles governing its high efficiency of free-energy transduction. Here we use a near-equilibrium framework to design a non-trivial control protocol to minimize dissipation in rotating F$_{1}$ to synthesize ATP. We find that the designed protocol requires much less work than a naive (constant-velocity) protocol across a wide range of protocol durations. Our analysis points to a possible mechanism for energetically efficient driving of F$_{1}$ \emph{in vivo} and provides insight into free-energy transduction for a broader class of biomolecular and synthetic machines. △ Less

Submitted 28 December, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 7 pages + SI, Minor revision

Journal ref: J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2022, 13, 11844-11849

Inferring Subsystem Efficiencies in Bipartite Molecular Machines

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Molecular machines composed of coupled subsystems transduce free energy between different external reservoirs, in the process internally transducing energy and information. While subsystem efficiencies of these molecular machines have been measured in isolation, less is known about how they behave in their natural setting when coupled together and acting in concert. Here we derive upper and lower… ▽ More Molecular machines composed of coupled subsystems transduce free energy between different external reservoirs, in the process internally transducing energy and information. While subsystem efficiencies of these molecular machines have been measured in isolation, less is known about how they behave in their natural setting when coupled together and acting in concert. Here we derive upper and lower bounds on the subsystem efficiencies of a bipartite molecular machine. We demonstrate their utility by estimating the efficiencies of the $\mathrm{F}_\mathrm{o}$ and $\mathrm{F}_1$ subunits of ATP synthase and that of kinesin pulling a diffusive cargo. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2023; v1 submitted 24 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters, 130(17), 178401 (2023)

Energy and information flows in autonomous systems

Authors: Jannik Ehrich, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Multi-component molecular machines are ubiquitous in biology. We review recent progress on describing their thermodynamic properties using autonomous bipartite Markovian dynamics. The first and second laws can be split into local versions applicable to each subsystem of a two-component system, illustrating that one can not only resolve energy flows between the subsystems but also information flows… ▽ More Multi-component molecular machines are ubiquitous in biology. We review recent progress on describing their thermodynamic properties using autonomous bipartite Markovian dynamics. The first and second laws can be split into local versions applicable to each subsystem of a two-component system, illustrating that one can not only resolve energy flows between the subsystems but also information flows quantifying how each subsystem's dynamics influence the joint system's entropy balance. Applying the framework to molecular-scale sensors allows one to derive tighter bounds on their energy requirement. Two-component strongly coupled machines can be studied from a unifying perspective quantifying to what extent they operate conventionally by transducing power or like an information engine by generating information flow to rectify thermal fluctuations into output power. △ Less

Submitted 6 April, 2023; v1 submitted 21 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: review article, 32 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: Front. Phys. 11, 1108357 (2023)

Connections between efficient control and spontaneous transitions in an Ising model

Authors: Miranda D. Louwerse, David A. Sivak

Abstract: A system can be driven between metastable configurations by a time-dependent driving protocol, which uses external control parameters to change the potential energy of the system. Here we investigate the correspondence between driving protocols that are designed to minimize work and the spontaneous transition paths of the system in the absence of driving. We study the spin-inversion reaction in a… ▽ More A system can be driven between metastable configurations by a time-dependent driving protocol, which uses external control parameters to change the potential energy of the system. Here we investigate the correspondence between driving protocols that are designed to minimize work and the spontaneous transition paths of the system in the absence of driving. We study the spin-inversion reaction in a 2D Ising model, quantifying the timing of each spin flip and heat flow to the system during both a minimum-work protocol and a spontaneous transition. The general order of spin flips during the transition mechanism is preserved between the processes, despite the coarseness of control parameters that are unable to reproduce more detailed features of the spontaneous mechanism. Additionally, external control parameters provide energy to each system component to compensate changes in internal energy, showing how control parameters are tuned during a minimum-work protocol to counteract underlying energetic features. This study supports a correspondence between minimum-work protocols and spontaneous transition mechanisms. △ Less

Submitted 24 December, 2022; v1 submitted 14 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 106, 064124 (2022)

Therapeutic algebra of immunomodulatory drug responses at single-cell resolution

Authors: Jialong Jiang, Sisi Chen, Tiffany Tsou, Christopher S. McGinnis, Tahmineh Khazaei, Qin Zhu, Jong H. Park, Paul Rivaud, Inna-Marie Strazhnik, Eric D. Chow, David A. Sivak, Zev J. Gartner, Matt Thomson

Abstract: Therapeutic modulation of immune states is central to the treatment of human disease. However, how drugs and drug combinations impact the diverse cell types in the human immune system remains poorly understood at the transcriptome scale. Here, we apply single-cell mRNA-seq to profile the response of human immune cells to 502 immunomodulatory drugs alone and in combination. We develop a unified mat… ▽ More Therapeutic modulation of immune states is central to the treatment of human disease. However, how drugs and drug combinations impact the diverse cell types in the human immune system remains poorly understood at the transcriptome scale. Here, we apply single-cell mRNA-seq to profile the response of human immune cells to 502 immunomodulatory drugs alone and in combination. We develop a unified mathematical model that quantitatively describes the transcriptome scale response of myeloid and lymphoid cell types to individual drugs and drug combinations through a single inferred regulatory network. The mathematical model reveals how drug combinations generate novel, macrophage and T-cell states by recruiting combinations of gene expression programs through both additive and non-additive drug interactions. A simplified drug response algebra allows us to predict the continuous modulation of immune cell populations between activated, resting and hyper-inhibited states through combinatorial drug dose titrations. Our results suggest that transcriptome-scale mathematical models could enable the design of therapeutic strategies for programming the human immune system using combinations of therapeutics. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 19 pages, 5 figures

Information engine in a nonequilibrium bath

Authors: Tushar K. Saha, Jannik Ehrich, Momčilo Gavrilov, Susanne Still, David A. Sivak, John Bechhoefer

Abstract: Information engines can convert thermal fluctuations of a bath at temperature $T$ into work at rates of order $k_\mathrm{B}T$ per relaxation time of the system. We show experimentally that such engines, when in contact with a bath that is out of equilibrium, can extract much more work. We place a heavy, micron-scale bead in a harmonic potential that ratchets up to capture favorable fluctuations. A… ▽ More Information engines can convert thermal fluctuations of a bath at temperature $T$ into work at rates of order $k_\mathrm{B}T$ per relaxation time of the system. We show experimentally that such engines, when in contact with a bath that is out of equilibrium, can extract much more work. We place a heavy, micron-scale bead in a harmonic potential that ratchets up to capture favorable fluctuations. Adding a fluctuating electric field increases work extraction up to ten times, limited only by the strength of applied field. Our results connect Maxwell's demon with energy harvesting and an estimate of efficiency shows that information engines in nonequilibrium baths can greatly outperform conventional engines. △ Less

Submitted 30 July, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 9 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 131, 057101 (2023)

Energetic cost of feedback control

Authors: Jannik Ehrich, Susanne Still, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Successful feedback control of small systems allows for the rectification of thermal fluctuations, converting them into useful energy; however, control itself requires work. This paper emphasizes the fact that the controller is a physical entity interacting with the feedback-controlled system. For a specifically designed class of controllers, reciprocal interactions become nonreciprocal due to lar… ▽ More Successful feedback control of small systems allows for the rectification of thermal fluctuations, converting them into useful energy; however, control itself requires work. This paper emphasizes the fact that the controller is a physical entity interacting with the feedback-controlled system. For a specifically designed class of controllers, reciprocal interactions become nonreciprocal due to large timescale separation, which considerably simplifies the situation. We introduce a minimally dissipative controller model, illustrating the findings using a simple example. We find that the work required to run the controller must at least compensate for the decrease in entropy due to the control operation. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2023; v1 submitted 21 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 12 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Res. 5, 023080 (2023)

Optimal control with a strong harmonic trap

Authors: Steven Blaber, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Quadratic trapping potentials are widely used to experimentally probe biopolymers and molecular machines and drive transitions in steered molecular-dynamics simulations. Approximating energy landscapes as locally quadratic, we design multidimensional trapping protocols that minimize dissipation. The designed protocols are easily solvable and applicable to a wide range of systems. The approximation… ▽ More Quadratic trapping potentials are widely used to experimentally probe biopolymers and molecular machines and drive transitions in steered molecular-dynamics simulations. Approximating energy landscapes as locally quadratic, we design multidimensional trapping protocols that minimize dissipation. The designed protocols are easily solvable and applicable to a wide range of systems. The approximation does not rely on either fast or slow limits and is valid for any duration provided the trapping potential is sufficiently strong. We demonstrate the utility of the designed protocols with a simple model of a periodically driven rotary motor. Our results elucidate principles of effective single-molecule manipulation and efficient nonequilibrium free-energy estimation. △ Less

Submitted 9 August, 2022; v1 submitted 26 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 106, L022103 (2022)

Bayesian information engine that optimally exploits noisy measurements

Authors: Tushar K. Saha, Joseph N. E. Lucero, Jannik Ehrich, David A. Sivak, John Bechhoefer

Abstract: We have experimentally realized an information engine consisting of an optically trapped, heavy bead in water. The device raises the trap center after a favorable "up" thermal fluctuation, thereby increasing the bead's average gravitational potential energy. In the presence of measurement noise, poor feedback decisions degrade its performance; below a critical signal-to-noise ratio, the engine sho… ▽ More We have experimentally realized an information engine consisting of an optically trapped, heavy bead in water. The device raises the trap center after a favorable "up" thermal fluctuation, thereby increasing the bead's average gravitational potential energy. In the presence of measurement noise, poor feedback decisions degrade its performance; below a critical signal-to-noise ratio, the engine shows a phase transition and cannot store any gravitational energy. However, using Bayesian estimates of the bead's position to make feedback decisions can extract gravitational energy at all measurement noise strengths and has maximum performance benefit at the critical signal-to-noise ratio. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 14 pages, 10 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 130601 (2022)

Efficient two-dimensional control of barrier crossing

Authors: Steven Blaber, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Driven barrier crossings are pervasive in optical-trapping experiments and steered molecular-dynamics simulations. Despite the high fidelity of control, the freedom in the choice of driving protocol is rarely exploited to improve efficiency. We design protocols that reduce dissipation for rapidly driven barrier crossing under two-dimensional control of a harmonic trapping potential, controlling bo… ▽ More Driven barrier crossings are pervasive in optical-trapping experiments and steered molecular-dynamics simulations. Despite the high fidelity of control, the freedom in the choice of driving protocol is rarely exploited to improve efficiency. We design protocols that reduce dissipation for rapidly driven barrier crossing under two-dimensional control of a harmonic trapping potential, controlling both trap center and stiffness. For fast driving, the minimum-dissipation protocol jumps halfway between the control-parameter endpoints. For slow driving, the minimum-dissipation protocol generically slows down and tightens the trap as it crosses the barrier, resulting in both significant energy savings and increased flux compared to naive and one-dimensional protocols (that only change trap center). Combining fast and slow results, we design protocols that improve performance at all speeds. △ Less

Submitted 4 July, 2022; v1 submitted 6 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Journal ref: EPL 139 17001 (2022)

Dynamic and thermodynamic bounds for collective motor-driven transport

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Molecular motors work collectively to transport cargo within cells, with anywhere from one to several hundred motors towing a single cargo. For a broad class of collective-transport systems, we use tools from stochastic thermodynamics to derive a new lower bound for the entropy production rate which is tighter than the second law. This implies new bounds on the velocity, efficiency, and precision… ▽ More Molecular motors work collectively to transport cargo within cells, with anywhere from one to several hundred motors towing a single cargo. For a broad class of collective-transport systems, we use tools from stochastic thermodynamics to derive a new lower bound for the entropy production rate which is tighter than the second law. This implies new bounds on the velocity, efficiency, and precision of general transport systems and a set of analytic Pareto frontiers for identical motors. In a specific model, we identify conditions for saturation of these Pareto frontiers. △ Less

Submitted 10 September, 2022; v1 submitted 28 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures. Appendices: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 118102 (2022)

Multidimensional minimum-work control of a 2D Ising model

Authors: Miranda D. Louwerse, David A. Sivak

Abstract: A system's configurational state can be manipulated using dynamic variation of control parameters, such as temperature, pressure, or magnetic field; for finite-duration driving, excess work is required above the equilibrium free-energy change. Minimum-work protocols in multidimensional control-parameter space have potential to significantly reduce work relative to one-dimensional control. By numer… ▽ More A system's configurational state can be manipulated using dynamic variation of control parameters, such as temperature, pressure, or magnetic field; for finite-duration driving, excess work is required above the equilibrium free-energy change. Minimum-work protocols in multidimensional control-parameter space have potential to significantly reduce work relative to one-dimensional control. By numerically minimizing a linear-response approximation to the excess work, we design protocols in control-parameter spaces of a 2D Ising model that efficiently drive the system from the all-down to all-up configuration. We find that such designed multidimensional protocols take advantage of more flexible control to avoid control-parameter regions of high system resistance, heterogeneously input and extract work to make use of system relaxation, and flatten the energy landscape, making accessible many configurations that would otherwise have prohibitively high energy and thus decreasing spin correlations. Relative to one-dimensional protocols, this speeds up the rate-limiting spin-inversion reaction, thereby keeping the system significantly closer to equilibrium for a wide range of protocol durations, and significantly reducing resistance and hence work. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2022; v1 submitted 21 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 10 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 156, 194108 (2022)

Internal energy and information flows mediate input and output power in bipartite molecular machines

Authors: Emma Lathouwers, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Microscopic biological systems operate far from equilibrium, are subject to strong fluctuations, and are composed of many coupled components with interactions varying in nature and strength. Researchers are actively investigating the general design principles governing how biomolecular machines achieve effective free-energy transduction in light of these challenges. We use a model of two strongly… ▽ More Microscopic biological systems operate far from equilibrium, are subject to strong fluctuations, and are composed of many coupled components with interactions varying in nature and strength. Researchers are actively investigating the general design principles governing how biomolecular machines achieve effective free-energy transduction in light of these challenges. We use a model of two strongly coupled stochastic rotary motors to explore the effect of coupling strength between components of a molecular machine. We observe prominent thermodynamic characteristics at intermediate coupling strength, near that which maximizes output power: a maximum in power and information transduced from the upstream to the downstream system, and equal subsystem entropy production rates. These observations are unified through a bound on the machine's input and output power, which accounts for both the energy and information transduced between subsystems. △ Less

Submitted 28 February, 2022; v1 submitted 16 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 6 main pages, 4 appendix pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 105, 024136 (2022)

Performance scaling and trade-offs for collective motor-driven transport

Authors: Matthew P. Leighton, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Motor-driven intracellular transport of organelles, vesicles, and other molecular cargo is a highly collective process. An individual cargo is often pulled by a team of transport motors, with numbers ranging from only a few to several hundred. We explore the behavior of these systems using a stochastic model for transport of molecular cargo by an arbitrary number N of motors obeying linear Langevi… ▽ More Motor-driven intracellular transport of organelles, vesicles, and other molecular cargo is a highly collective process. An individual cargo is often pulled by a team of transport motors, with numbers ranging from only a few to several hundred. We explore the behavior of these systems using a stochastic model for transport of molecular cargo by an arbitrary number N of motors obeying linear Langevin dynamics, finding analytic solutions for the N-dependence of the velocity, precision of forward progress, energy flows between different system components, and efficiency. In two opposing regimes, we show that these properties obey simple scaling laws with N. Finally, we explore trade-offs between performance metrics as N is varied, providing insight into how different numbers of motors might be well-matched to distinct contexts where different performance metrics are prioritized. △ Less

Submitted 5 January, 2022; v1 submitted 31 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: New J. Phys. 24 013009 (2022)

Maximal fluctuation exploitation in Gaussian information engines

Authors: Joseph N. E. Lucero, Jannik Ehrich, John Bechhoefer, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Understanding the connections between information and thermodynamics has been among the most visible applications of stochastic thermodynamics. While recent theoretical advances have established that the second law of thermodynamics sets limits on information-to-energy conversion, it is currently unclear to what extent real systems can achieve the predicted theoretical limits. Using a simple model… ▽ More Understanding the connections between information and thermodynamics has been among the most visible applications of stochastic thermodynamics. While recent theoretical advances have established that the second law of thermodynamics sets limits on information-to-energy conversion, it is currently unclear to what extent real systems can achieve the predicted theoretical limits. Using a simple model of an information engine that has recently been experimentally implemented, we explore the limits of information-to-energy conversion when an information engine's benefit is limited to output energy that can be stored. We find that restricting the engine's output in this way can limit its ability to convert information to energy. Nevertheless, a feedback control that inputs work can allow the engine to store energy at the highest achievable rate. These results sharpen our theoretical understanding of the limits of real systems that convert information to energy. △ Less

Submitted 20 October, 2021; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 17 pages, 17 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E, 104, (2021), 044122

Information Thermodynamics of the Transition-Path Ensemble

Authors: Miranda D. Louwerse, David A. Sivak

Abstract: The reaction coordinate describing a transition between reactant and product is a fundamental concept in the theory of chemical reactions. Within transition-path theory, a quantitative definition of the reaction coordinate is found in the committor, which is the probability that a trajectory initiated from a given microstate first reaches the product before the reactant. Here we develop an informa… ▽ More The reaction coordinate describing a transition between reactant and product is a fundamental concept in the theory of chemical reactions. Within transition-path theory, a quantitative definition of the reaction coordinate is found in the committor, which is the probability that a trajectory initiated from a given microstate first reaches the product before the reactant. Here we develop an information-theoretic origin for the committor and show how selecting transition paths from the equilibrium ensemble induces entropy production which exactly equals the information that system dynamics provide about the reactivity of trajectories. This equality of entropy production and dynamical information generation also holds at the level of arbitrary individual coordinates, providing parallel measures of the coordinate's relevance to the reaction, each of which is maximized by the committor. △ Less

Submitted 30 April, 2022; v1 submitted 21 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 10 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 170602 (2022)

Steps minimize dissipation in rapidly driven stochastic systems

Authors: Steven Blaber, Miranda D. Louwerse, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Micro- and nano-scale systems driven by rapid changes in control parameters (control protocols) dissipate significant energy. In the fast-protocol limit, we find that protocols that minimize dissipation at fixed duration are universally given by a two-step process, jumping to and from a point that balances jump size with fast relaxation. Jump protocols could be exploited by molecular machines or t… ▽ More Micro- and nano-scale systems driven by rapid changes in control parameters (control protocols) dissipate significant energy. In the fast-protocol limit, we find that protocols that minimize dissipation at fixed duration are universally given by a two-step process, jumping to and from a point that balances jump size with fast relaxation. Jump protocols could be exploited by molecular machines or thermodynamic computing to improve energetic efficiency, and implemented in nonequilibrium free-energy estimation to improve accuracy. △ Less

Submitted 5 August, 2021; v1 submitted 10 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 022101 (2021)

Heat fluctuations in a harmonic chain of active particles

Authors: Deepak Gupta, David A. Sivak

Abstract: One of the major challenges in stochastic thermodynamics is to compute the distributions of stochastic observables for small-scale systems for which fluctuations play a significant role. Hitherto much theoretical and experimental research has focused on systems composed of passive Brownian particles. In this paper, we study the heat fluctuations in a system of interacting active particles. Specifi… ▽ More One of the major challenges in stochastic thermodynamics is to compute the distributions of stochastic observables for small-scale systems for which fluctuations play a significant role. Hitherto much theoretical and experimental research has focused on systems composed of passive Brownian particles. In this paper, we study the heat fluctuations in a system of interacting active particles. Specifically we consider a one-dimensional harmonic chain of $N$ active Ornstein-Uhlenbeck particles, with the chain ends connected to heat baths of different temperatures. We compute the moment-generating function for the heat flow in the steady state. We employ our general framework to explicitly compute the moment-generating function for two example single-particle systems. Further, we analytically obtain the scaled cumulants for the heat flow for the chain. Numerical Langevin simulations confirm the long-time analytical expressions for first and second cumulants for the heat flow for a two-particle chain. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2021; v1 submitted 16 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 23 pages, 7 figures, Major revision

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 104, 024605 (2021)

Maximizing power and velocity of an information engine

Authors: Tushar K. Saha, Joseph N. E. Lucero, Jannik Ehrich, David A. Sivak, John Bechhoefer

Abstract: Information-driven engines that rectify thermal fluctuations are a modern realization of the Maxwell-demon thought experiment. We introduce a simple design based on a heavy colloidal particle, held by an optical trap and immersed in water. Using a carefully designed feedback loop, our experimental realization of an "information ratchet" takes advantage of favorable "up" fluctuations to lift a weig… ▽ More Information-driven engines that rectify thermal fluctuations are a modern realization of the Maxwell-demon thought experiment. We introduce a simple design based on a heavy colloidal particle, held by an optical trap and immersed in water. Using a carefully designed feedback loop, our experimental realization of an "information ratchet" takes advantage of favorable "up" fluctuations to lift a weight against gravity, storing potential energy without doing external work. By optimizing the ratchet design for performance via a simple theory, we find that the rate of work storage and velocity of directed motion is limited only by the physical parameters of the engine: the size of the particle, stiffness of the ratchet spring, friction produced by the motion, and temperature of the surrounding medium. Notably, because performance saturates with increasing frequency of observations, the measurement process is not a limiting factor. The extracted power and velocity are at least an order of magnitude higher than in previously reported engines. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 16 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: PNAS 118, e2023356118 (2021)

Skewed Thermodynamic Geometry and Optimal Free Energy Estimation

Authors: Steven Blaber, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Free energy differences are a central quantity of interest in physics, chemistry, and biology. We develop design principles that improve the precision and accuracy of free energy estimators, which has potential applications to screening for targeted drug discovery. Specifically, by exploiting the connection between the work statistics of time-reversed protocol pairs, we develop near-equilibrium ap… ▽ More Free energy differences are a central quantity of interest in physics, chemistry, and biology. We develop design principles that improve the precision and accuracy of free energy estimators, which has potential applications to screening for targeted drug discovery. Specifically, by exploiting the connection between the work statistics of time-reversed protocol pairs, we develop near-equilibrium approximations for moments of the excess work and analyze the dominant contributions to the precision and accuracy of standard nonequilibrium free-energy estimators. Within linear response, minimum-dissipation protocols follow geodesics of the Riemannian metric induced by the Stokes' friction tensor. We find the next-order contribution arises from the rank-3 supra-Stokes' tensor that skews the geometric structure such that minimum-dissipation protocols follow geodesics of a generalized cubic Finsler metric. Thus, near equilibrium the supra-Stokes' tensor determines the leading-order contribution to the bias of bidirectional free-energy estimators. △ Less

Submitted 1 January, 2021; v1 submitted 29 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 153, 244119 (2020)

Hidden energy flows in strongly coupled nonequilibrium systems

Authors: Steven J Large, David A Sivak

Abstract: Quantifying the flow of energy within and through fluctuating nanoscale systems poses a significant challenge to understanding microscopic biological machines. A common approach involves coarse-graining, which allows a simplified description of such systems. This has the side effect of inducing so-called hidden contributions (due to sub-resolution dynamics) that complicate the resulting thermodyna… ▽ More Quantifying the flow of energy within and through fluctuating nanoscale systems poses a significant challenge to understanding microscopic biological machines. A common approach involves coarse-graining, which allows a simplified description of such systems. This has the side effect of inducing so-called hidden contributions (due to sub-resolution dynamics) that complicate the resulting thermodynamics. Here we develop a thermodynamically consistent theory describing the nonequilibrium excess power internal to autonomous systems, and introduce a phenomenological framework to quantify the hidden excess power associated with their operation. We confirm our theoretical predictions in numerical simulations of a minimal model for both a molecular transport motor and a rotary motor. △ Less

Submitted 11 March, 2021; v1 submitted 16 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: 14 pages, 3 figures

Journal ref: EPL, 133, 10003 (2021)

Free-energy transduction within autonomous systems

Authors: Steven J Large, Jannik Ehrich, David A Sivak

Abstract: The excess work required to drive a stochastic system out of thermodynamic equilibrium through a time-dependent external perturbation is directly related to the amount of entropy produced during the driving process, allowing excess work and entropy production to be used interchangeably to quantify dissipation. Given the common intuition of biological molecular machines as internally communicating… ▽ More The excess work required to drive a stochastic system out of thermodynamic equilibrium through a time-dependent external perturbation is directly related to the amount of entropy produced during the driving process, allowing excess work and entropy production to be used interchangeably to quantify dissipation. Given the common intuition of biological molecular machines as internally communicating work between components, it is tempting to extend this correspondence to the driving of one component of an autonomous system by another; however, no such relation between the internal excess work and entropy production exists. Here we introduce the `transduced additional free energy rate' between strongly coupled subsystems of an autonomous system, that is analogous to the excess power in systems driven by an external control parameter that receives no feedback from the system. We prove that this is a relevant measure of dissipation -- in that it equals the steady-state entropy production rate due to the downstream subsystem -- and demonstrate its advantages with a simple model system. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2021; v1 submitted 7 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 022140 (2021)

Apparent superballistic dynamics in one-dimensional random walks with biased detachment

Authors: Chapin S. Korosec, David A. Sivak, Nancy R. Forde

Abstract: The mean-squared displacement (MSD) is an averaged quantity widely used to assess anomalous diffusion. In many cases, such as molecular motors with finite processivity, dynamics of the system of interest produce trajectories of varying duration. Here we explore the effects of finite processivity on different measures of the MSD. We do so by investigating a deceptively simple dynamical system: a on… ▽ More The mean-squared displacement (MSD) is an averaged quantity widely used to assess anomalous diffusion. In many cases, such as molecular motors with finite processivity, dynamics of the system of interest produce trajectories of varying duration. Here we explore the effects of finite processivity on different measures of the MSD. We do so by investigating a deceptively simple dynamical system: a one-dimensional random walk (with equidistant jump lengths, symmetric move probabilities, and constant step duration) with an origin-directed detachment bias. By tuning the time dependence of the detachment bias, we find through analytical calculations and trajectory simulations that the system can exhibit a broad range of anomalous diffusion, extending beyond conventional diffusion to superdiffusion and even superballistic motion. We analytically determine that protocols with a time-increasing detachment lead to an ensemble-averaged velocity increasing in time, thereby providing the effective acceleration that is required to push the system above the ballistic threshold. MSD analysis of burnt-bridges ratchets similarly reveals superballistic behavior. Because superdiffusive MSDs are often used to infer biased, motor-like dynamics, these findings provide a cautionary tale for dynamical interpretation. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 033520 (2020)

Nonequilibrium Energy Transduction in Stochastic Strongly Coupled Rotary Motors

Authors: Emma Lathouwers, Joseph N. E. Lucero, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Living systems at the molecular scale are composed of many constituents with strong and heterogeneous interactions, operating far from equilibrium, and subject to strong fluctuations. These conditions pose significant challenges to efficient, precise, and rapid free energy transduction, yet nature has evolved numerous molecular machines that do just this. Using a simple model of the ingenious rota… ▽ More Living systems at the molecular scale are composed of many constituents with strong and heterogeneous interactions, operating far from equilibrium, and subject to strong fluctuations. These conditions pose significant challenges to efficient, precise, and rapid free energy transduction, yet nature has evolved numerous molecular machines that do just this. Using a simple model of the ingenious rotary machine FoF1-ATP synthase, we investigate the interplay between nonequilibrium driving forces, thermal fluctuations, and interactions between strongly coupled subsystems. This model reveals design principles for effective free energy transduction. Most notably, while tight coupling is intuitively appealing, we find that output power is maximized at intermediate-strength coupling, which permits lubrication by stochastic fluctuations with only minimal slippage. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2020; v1 submitted 3 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 17 pages, 12 figures. J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 2020

Journal ref: J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 11, 5273-5278 (2020)

Theory of nonequilibrium free energy transduction by molecular machines

Authors: Aidan I Brown, David A Sivak

Abstract: Biomolecular machines are protein complexes that convert between different forms of free energy. They are utilized in nature to accomplish many cellular tasks. As isothermal nonequilibrium stochastic objects at low Reynolds number, they face a distinct set of challenges compared to more familiar human-engineered macroscopic machines. Here we review central questions in their performance as free en… ▽ More Biomolecular machines are protein complexes that convert between different forms of free energy. They are utilized in nature to accomplish many cellular tasks. As isothermal nonequilibrium stochastic objects at low Reynolds number, they face a distinct set of challenges compared to more familiar human-engineered macroscopic machines. Here we review central questions in their performance as free energy transducers, outline theoretical and modeling approaches to understand these questions, identify both physical limits on their operational characteristics and design principles for improving performance, and discuss emerging areas of research. △ Less

Submitted 19 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 90 pages, 17 figures. Accepted version, with figure attribution and copyright statements corrected. This article is in press in Chemical Reviews, available online at https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00254

Journal ref: Chemical Reviews, 120, 1, 434-459 (2020)

Modeling work-speed-accuracy trade-offs in a stochastic rotary machine

Authors: Alexandra K. S. Kasper, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Molecular machines are stochastic systems that catalyze the energetic processes keeping living cells alive and structured. Inspired by the examples of F1-ATP synthase and the bacterial flagellum, we present a minimal model of an externally driven stochastic rotary machine. We explore the trade-offs of work, driving speed, and driving accuracy when changing driving strength, speed, and the underlyi… ▽ More Molecular machines are stochastic systems that catalyze the energetic processes keeping living cells alive and structured. Inspired by the examples of F1-ATP synthase and the bacterial flagellum, we present a minimal model of an externally driven stochastic rotary machine. We explore the trade-offs of work, driving speed, and driving accuracy when changing driving strength, speed, and the underlying system dynamics. We find an upper bound on accuracy and work for a particular speed. Our results favor slow driving when tasked with minimizing the work-accuracy ratio and maximizing the rate of successful cycles. Finally, in the parameter regime mapping to the dynamics of F1-ATP synthase, we find a significant decay of driving accuracy at physiological rotation rates, raising questions about how ATP synthase achieves reasonable or even remarkable efficiency in vivo. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2020; v1 submitted 25 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 101, 032110 (2020)

Active Learning of Spin Network Models

Authors: Jialong Jiang, David A. Sivak, Matt Thomson

Abstract: The inverse statistical problem of finding direct interactions in complex networks is difficult. In the natural sciences, well-controlled perturbation experiments are widely used to probe the structure of complex networks. However, our understanding of how and why perturbations aid inference remains heuristic, and we lack automated procedures that determine network structure by combining inference… ▽ More The inverse statistical problem of finding direct interactions in complex networks is difficult. In the natural sciences, well-controlled perturbation experiments are widely used to probe the structure of complex networks. However, our understanding of how and why perturbations aid inference remains heuristic, and we lack automated procedures that determine network structure by combining inference and perturbation. Therefore, we propose a general mathematical framework to study inference with iteratively applied perturbations. Using the formulation of information geometry, our framework quantifies the difficulty of inference and the information gain from perturbations through the curvature of the underlying parameter manifold, measured by Fisher information. We apply the framework to the inference of spin network models and find that designed perturbations can reduce the sampling complexity by $10^6$-fold across a variety of network architectures. Physically, our framework reveals that perturbations boost inference by causing a network to explore previously inaccessible states. Optimal perturbations break spin-spin correlations within a network, increasing the information available for inference and thus reducing sampling complexity by orders of magnitude. Our active learning framework could be powerful in the analysis of complex networks as well as in the rational design of experiments. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2019; v1 submitted 25 March, 2019; originally announced March 2019.

Comments: 19 pages, 10 figures

Optimal discrete control: minimizing dissipation in discretely driven nonequilibrium systems

Authors: Steven J. Large, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Microscopic machines utilize free energy to create and maintain out-of-equilibrium organization in virtually all living things. Often this takes the form of converting the free energy stored in nonequilibrium chemical potential differences into useful work, via a series of reactions involving the binding, chemical catalysis, and unbinding of small molecules. Such chemical reactions occur on timesc… ▽ More Microscopic machines utilize free energy to create and maintain out-of-equilibrium organization in virtually all living things. Often this takes the form of converting the free energy stored in nonequilibrium chemical potential differences into useful work, via a series of reactions involving the binding, chemical catalysis, and unbinding of small molecules. Such chemical reactions occur on timescales much faster than the protein conformational rearrangements they induce. Here, we derive the energetic cost for driving a system out of equilibrium via a series of such effectively instantaneous (and hence discrete) perturbations. This analysis significantly generalizes previously established results, and provides insight into qualitative, as well as quantitative, aspects of finite-time, minimum-dissipation discrete control protocols. We compare our theoretical formalism to an exactly solvable model system and also demonstrate the dissipation reduction achievable in a simple multistable model for a discretely driven molecular machine. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2019; v1 submitted 19 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 24 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: J. Stat. Mech. (2019) 083212

Breaking time-reversal symmetry for ratchet models of molecular machines

Authors: Arshia Zarrin, David A. Sivak, Aidan I. Brown

Abstract: Biomolecular machines transduce free energy from one form to another to fulfill many important roles inside cells, with dissipation required to achieve directed progress. We investigate how to break time-reversal symmetry at a given dissipation cost by using deterministic protocols to drive systems over sawtooth potentials, which have frequently been used to model molecular machines as ratchets. T… ▽ More Biomolecular machines transduce free energy from one form to another to fulfill many important roles inside cells, with dissipation required to achieve directed progress. We investigate how to break time-reversal symmetry at a given dissipation cost by using deterministic protocols to drive systems over sawtooth potentials, which have frequently been used to model molecular machines as ratchets. Time asymmetry increases for sawtooth potentials with higher barriers and for driving potentials of intermediate width. For systems driven over a sawtooth potential according to a protocol, we find that symmetric sawtooths maximize time asymmetry, while earlier work examining ratchet models of molecular machines required asymmetric sawtooth potentials to achieve directed behavior. This distinction arises because deterministically driven machines are externally provided with direction, while autonomous machines must generate directed behavior. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2019; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 062127 (2019)

Optimal control of protein copy number

Authors: Steven Blaber, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Cell-cell communication is often achieved by secreted signaling molecules that bind membrane-bound receptors. A common class of such receptors are G-protein coupled receptors, where extracellular binding induces changes on the membrane affinity near the receptor for certain cytosolic proteins, effectively altering their chemical potential. We analyze the minimum-dissipation schedules for dynamical… ▽ More Cell-cell communication is often achieved by secreted signaling molecules that bind membrane-bound receptors. A common class of such receptors are G-protein coupled receptors, where extracellular binding induces changes on the membrane affinity near the receptor for certain cytosolic proteins, effectively altering their chemical potential. We analyze the minimum-dissipation schedules for dynamically changing chemical potential to induce steady-state changes in protein copy-number distributions, and illustrate with analytic solutions for linear chemical reaction networks. Protocols that change chemical potential on biologically relevant timescales are experimentally accessible using optogenetic manipulations, and our framework provides non-trivial predictions about functional dynamical cell-cell interactions. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2020; v1 submitted 3 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 10 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 101, 022118 (2020)

Optimal Control of Rotary Motors

Authors: Joseph N. E. Lucero, Aliakbar Mehdizadeh, David A. Sivak

Abstract: Single-molecule experiments have found near-perfect thermodynamic efficiency in the rotary motor F1-ATP synthase. To help elucidate the principles underlying nonequilibrium energetic efficiency in such stochastic machines, we investigate driving protocols that minimize dissipation near equilibrium in a simple model rotary mechanochemical motor, as determined by a generalized friction coefficient.… ▽ More Single-molecule experiments have found near-perfect thermodynamic efficiency in the rotary motor F1-ATP synthase. To help elucidate the principles underlying nonequilibrium energetic efficiency in such stochastic machines, we investigate driving protocols that minimize dissipation near equilibrium in a simple model rotary mechanochemical motor, as determined by a generalized friction coefficient. Our simple model has a periodic friction coefficient that peaks near system energy barriers. This implies a minimum-dissipation protocol that proceeds rapidly when the system is overwhelmingly in a single macrostate, but slows significantly near energy barriers, thereby harnessing thermal fluctuations to kick the system over energy barriers with minimal work input. This model also manifests a phenomenon not seen in otherwise similar non-periodic systems: sufficiently fast protocols can effectively lap the system. While this leads to a non-trivial tradeoff between accuracy of driving and energetic cost, we find that our designed protocols out-perform naive protocols. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2019; v1 submitted 27 July, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 12 pages, 11 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 99, 012119 (2019)

Energy dissipation and information flow in coupled Markovian systems

Authors: Matthew E. Quenneville, David A. Sivak

Abstract: A stochastic system under the influence of a stochastic environment is correlated with both present and future states of the environment. Such a system can be seen as implicitly implementing a predictive model of future environmental states. The non-predictive model complexity has been shown to lower-bound the thermodynamic dissipation. Here we explore these statistical and physical quantities at… ▽ More A stochastic system under the influence of a stochastic environment is correlated with both present and future states of the environment. Such a system can be seen as implicitly implementing a predictive model of future environmental states. The non-predictive model complexity has been shown to lower-bound the thermodynamic dissipation. Here we explore these statistical and physical quantities at steady state in simple models. We show that under quasi-static driving this model complexity saturates the dissipation. Beyond the quasi-static limit, we demonstrate a lower bound on the ratio of this model complexity to total dissipation, that is realized in the limit of weak driving. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2018; originally announced July 2018.

Comments: 10 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: Entropy 20(9), 707, 2018

Pulling cargo increases the precision of molecular motor progress

Authors: Aidan I Brown, David A Sivak

Abstract: Biomolecular motors use free energy to drive a variety of cellular tasks, including the transport of cargo, such as vesicles and organelles. We find that the widely-used `constant-force' approximation for the effect of cargo on motor dynamics leads to a much larger variance of motor step number compared to explicitly modeling diffusive cargo, suggesting the constant-force approximation may be misa… ▽ More Biomolecular motors use free energy to drive a variety of cellular tasks, including the transport of cargo, such as vesicles and organelles. We find that the widely-used `constant-force' approximation for the effect of cargo on motor dynamics leads to a much larger variance of motor step number compared to explicitly modeling diffusive cargo, suggesting the constant-force approximation may be misapplied in some cases. We also find that, with cargo, motor progress is significantly more precise than suggested by a recent result. For cargo with a low relative diffusivity, the dynamics of continuous cargo motion---rather than discrete motor steps---dominate, leading to a new, more permissive bound on the precision of motor progress which is independent of the number of stages per motor cycle. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2019; v1 submitted 22 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 9 pages, 10 figures. This is the version of the article before peer review or editing, as submitted by an author to Europhysics Letters. IOP Publishing Ltd is not responsible for any errors or omissions in this version of the manuscript or any version derived from it. The Version of Record is available online at https://doi.org/10.1209/0295-5075/126/40004

Journal ref: Europhys. Lett. 126 (4), 40004 (2019)

Physically optimizing inference

Authors: Audrey Huang, Benjamin Sheldan, David A. Sivak, Matt Thomson

Abstract: Data is scaling exponentially in fields ranging from genomics to neuroscience to economics. A central question is: can modern machine learning methods be applied to construct predictive models of natural systems like cells and brains based on large data sets? In this paper, we examine how inference is impacted when training data is generated by the statistical behavior of a physical system, and he… ▽ More Data is scaling exponentially in fields ranging from genomics to neuroscience to economics. A central question is: can modern machine learning methods be applied to construct predictive models of natural systems like cells and brains based on large data sets? In this paper, we examine how inference is impacted when training data is generated by the statistical behavior of a physical system, and hence outside direct control by the experimentalist. We develop an information-theoretic analysis for the canonical problem of spin-network inference. Our analysis reveals the essential role that the physical properties of the spin network and its environment play in determining the difficulty of the underlying machine learning problem. Specifically, stochastic fluctuations drive a system to explore a range of configurations providing `raw' information for a learning algorithm to construct an accurate model; yet they also blur energetic differences between network states and thereby degrade information. This competition leads spin networks to generically have an intrinsic optimal temperature at which stochastic spin fluctuations provide maximal information for discriminating among competing models, maximizing inference efficiency. We demonstrate a simple active learning protocol that optimizes network temperature to boost inference efficiency and dramatically increases the efficiency of inference on a neural circuit reconstruction task. Our results reveal a fundamental link between physics and information and show how the physical environment can be tuned to optimize the efficiency of machine learning. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2018; v1 submitted 19 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.