-
Interlaboratory comparison of particle filtration efficiency testing equipment
Authors:
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Ruth Perez Calderon,
Richard G. Green,
Andrew Oldershaw,
Gregory J. Smallwood
Abstract:
This work presents the results of two interlaboratory comparisons of particle filtration efficiency measurements performed by a network of laboratories across Canada and Australia. Testing across multiple layers of a common verification material demonstrates a constant size-resolved quality factor when layering uncharged materials. Size-resolved filtration curves also match expectations, with incr…
▽ More
This work presents the results of two interlaboratory comparisons of particle filtration efficiency measurements performed by a network of laboratories across Canada and Australia. Testing across multiple layers of a common verification material demonstrates a constant size-resolved quality factor when layering uncharged materials. Size-resolved filtration curves also match expectations, with increasingly size-dependent curves and a predictable increase in the PFE. Candidate reference materials with controlled material properties were also tested across multiple laboratories. Each set of materials sharing a common charge level show specific trends with the material basis weight. Respirators showed more consistency between the laboratories than the other filters. However, across a majority of the tests, dark uncertainties, which are otherwise unexplained variability between laboratories, are significant. This leaves room to improve the test method by developing improved verification procedures and additional reference materials.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Estimating density, velocity, and pressure fields in supersonic flow using physics-informed BOS
Authors:
Joseph P. Molnar,
Lakshmi Venkatakrishnan,
Bryan E. Schmidt,
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Samuel J. Grauer
Abstract:
We report a new workflow for background-oriented schlieren (BOS), termed "physics-informed BOS," to extract density, velocity, and pressure fields from a pair of reference and distorted images. Our method uses a physics-informed neural network (PINN) to produce flow fields that simultaneously satisfy the measurement data and governing equations. For the high-speed flows of interest in this work, w…
▽ More
We report a new workflow for background-oriented schlieren (BOS), termed "physics-informed BOS," to extract density, velocity, and pressure fields from a pair of reference and distorted images. Our method uses a physics-informed neural network (PINN) to produce flow fields that simultaneously satisfy the measurement data and governing equations. For the high-speed flows of interest in this work, we specify a physics loss based on the Euler and irrotationality equations. BOS is a quantitative fluid visualization technique that is used to characterize high-speed flows. Images of a background pattern, positioned behind the target flow, are processed using computer vision and tomography algorithms to determine the density field. Crucially, BOS features a series of ill-posed inverse problems that require supplemental information (i.e., in addition to the images) to accurately reconstruct the flow. Current BOS workflows rely upon interpolation of the images or a penalty term to promote a globally- or piecewise-smooth solution. However, these algorithms are invariably incompatible with the flow physics, leading to errors in the density field. Physics-informed BOS directly reconstructs all the flow fields using a PINN that includes the BOS measurement model and governing equations. This procedure improves the accuracy of density estimates and also yields velocity and pressure data, which was not previously available. We demonstrate our approach by reconstructing synthetic data that corresponds to analytical and numerical phantoms as well as experimental measurements. Our physics-informed reconstructions are significantly more accurate than conventional BOS estimates. Further, to the best of our knowledge, this work represents the first use of a PINN to reconstruct a supersonic flow from experimental data of any kind.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2023; v1 submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Size-dependent mass absorption cross-section of soot particles from various sources
Authors:
Joel C. Corbin,
Tyler J. Johnson,
Fengshan Liu,
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Mark P. Johnson,
Prem Lobo,
Greg J. Smallwood
Abstract:
The mass absorption cross-section (MAC) of combustion-generated soot is used in pollution and emissions measurements to quantify the mass concentration of soot and in atmospheric modelling to predict the radiative effects of soot on climate. Previous work has suggested that the MAC of soot particles may change with their size, due to (1) internal scattering among monomers in the soot aggregate, (2…
▽ More
The mass absorption cross-section (MAC) of combustion-generated soot is used in pollution and emissions measurements to quantify the mass concentration of soot and in atmospheric modelling to predict the radiative effects of soot on climate. Previous work has suggested that the MAC of soot particles may change with their size, due to (1) internal scattering among monomers in the soot aggregate, (2) the correlation of soot primary-particle diameter with aggregate size, (3) quantum confinement effects, or (4) a size-dependent degree of soot graphitization. Here, we report a size-dependent MAC for ex-situ soot sampled from two commercially available diffusion-flame soot generators, one aviation turbine engine, and one diesel generator. We also incorporate literature data. We show that the MAC increases with aggregate size until a plateau is reached at single particle masses between 4 and 30 fg (approximately 300-650 nm soot mobility diameter). The smallest particles may have MACs 50% to 80% smaller than the largest, depending on the source, while the largest particles have MACs within the range reported by previous measurements on polydisperse samples. Moreover, we show that models of hypotheses (1), (2), and (3) do not describe our measurement results, leaving hypothesis (4) as the only remaining candidate.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Filtration and breathability of nonwoven fabrics used in washable masks
Authors:
Thomas W. Bement,
Ania Mitros,
Rebecca Lau,
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Jocelyn Songer,
Heidi Alexander,
Devon Ostrom,
Hamed Nikookar,
Steven. N. Rogak
Abstract:
This study explores nonwoven and woven fabrics to improve upon the performance of the widespread all-cotton mask, and examines the effect of layering, machine washing and drying on their filtration and breathability for submicron and supermicron particles. Individual materials were evaluated for their quality factor, Q, which combines filtration efficiency and breathability. Filtration was tested…
▽ More
This study explores nonwoven and woven fabrics to improve upon the performance of the widespread all-cotton mask, and examines the effect of layering, machine washing and drying on their filtration and breathability for submicron and supermicron particles. Individual materials were evaluated for their quality factor, Q, which combines filtration efficiency and breathability. Filtration was tested against particles 0.5 to 5 micron aerodynamic diameter. Nonwoven polyester and nonwoven polypropylene (craft fabrics, medical masks, and medical wraps) showed higher quality factors than woven materials (flannel cotton, Kona cotton, sateen cotton). Materials with meltblown nonwoven polypropylene filtered best, especially against submicron particles. Subsequently, we combined high performing fabrics into multi-layer sets, evaluating the sets quality factors before and after our washing protocol, which included machine washing, machine drying, and isopropanol soak. Sets incorporating meltblown nonwoven polypropylene designed for filtration (Filti and surgical mask) degraded significantly post-wash in the submicron range where they excelled prior to washing (Q = 57 and 79 at 1 micron, respectively, degraded to Q = 10 and 15 post-wash). Washing caused lesser quality degradation in sets incorporating spunbond non-woven polypropylene or medical wraps (Q = 12 to 24 pre-wash, Q = 8 to 10 post-wash). Post-wash quality factors are similar for all multi-layer sets in this study, and higher than Kona quilting cotton (Q = 6). Washed multi-layer sets filtered 12-42 percent of 0.5 micron, 27-76 percent of 1 micron, 58-96 percent of 2.8 micron, and 72-100 percent of 4.2 micron particles. The measured filtration and pressure drop of both the homogeneous and heterogeneous multi-layer fabric combinations agreed with the estimations from the layering model.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Comparison of measurement systems for assessing number- and mass-based particle filtration efficiency
Authors:
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Joel C. Corbin,
Triantafillos Koukoulas,
Andrew Oldershaw,
Thierry Lavoie,
Jalal Norooz Oliaee,
Fengshan Liu,
Ian D. Leroux,
Gregory J. Smallwood,
Prem Lobo,
Richard G. Green
Abstract:
The particle filtration efficiency (PFE) of a respirator or face mask is one of its key properties. While the physics of particle filtration results in the PFE being size-dependent, measurement standards are specified using a single, integrated PFE, for simplicity. This integrated PFE is commonly defined with respect to either the number (NBFE) or mass (MBFE) distribution of particles as a functio…
▽ More
The particle filtration efficiency (PFE) of a respirator or face mask is one of its key properties. While the physics of particle filtration results in the PFE being size-dependent, measurement standards are specified using a single, integrated PFE, for simplicity. This integrated PFE is commonly defined with respect to either the number (NBFE) or mass (MBFE) distribution of particles as a function of size. This relationship is non-trivial; it is influenced by both the shape of the particle distribution and the fact that multiple practical definitions of particle size are used. This manuscript discusses the relationship between NBFE and MBFE in detail, providing a guide to practitioners. Our discussion begins with a theoretical discussion of the underlying principles. We then present experimental results for a database of size-resolved PFE (SPFE) measurements for over 900 candidate respirators and filter media, including filter media with systematically varied properties and commercial samples that span the 20%-99.8% MBFE. The observed relationships between NBFE and MBFE are discussed in terms of the most-penetrating particle size (MPPS) and charge state of the media. For the NaCl particles used here, we observed that MBFEs were greater than NBFEs for charged materials and vice versa for uncharged materials. This relationship is observed because a shift from NBFE to MBFE weights the distribution towards larger sizes, while charged materials shift the MPPS to smaller sizes. Results are validated by comparing the output of a pair of TSI 8130As, a common instrument used in gauging standards compliance, to that of MBFEs computed from a system capable of measuring SPFE.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Systematic experimental comparison of particle filtration efficiency test methods for commercial respirators and face masks
Authors:
Joel C. Corbin,
Greg J. Smallwood,
Ian Leroux,
Jalal Norooz Oliaee,
Fengshan Liu,
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Richard G. Green,
Nathan F. Murnaghan,
Triantafillos Koukoulas,
Prem Lobo
Abstract:
Respirators, medical masks, and barrier face coverings all filter airborne particles using similar physical principles. However, they are tested for certification using a variety of standardized test methods, creating challenges for the comparison of differently certified products. We have performed systematic experiments to quantify and understand the differences between standardized test methods…
▽ More
Respirators, medical masks, and barrier face coverings all filter airborne particles using similar physical principles. However, they are tested for certification using a variety of standardized test methods, creating challenges for the comparison of differently certified products. We have performed systematic experiments to quantify and understand the differences between standardized test methods for N95 respirators (NIOSH TEB-APR-STP-0059 under US 42 CFR 84), medical face masks (ASTM F2299/F2100), and COVID-19-related barrier face coverings (ASTM F3502-21). Our experiments demonstrate the role of face velocity, particle properties (mean size, size variability, electric charge, density, and shape), measurement techniques, and environmental preconditioning. The measured filtration efficiency was most sensitive to changes in face velocity and particle charge. Relative to the NIOSH method, users of the ASTM F2299/F2100 method have commonly used non-neutralized (highly charged) aerosols as well as smaller face velocities, each of which may result in approximately 10% higher measured filtration efficiencies. In the NIOSH method, environmental conditioning at elevated humidity increased filtration efficiency in some commercial samples while decreasing it in others, indicating that measurement should be performed both with and without conditioning. More generally, our results provide an experimental basis for the comparison of respirators certified under various international methods, including FFP2, KN95, P2, Korea 1st Class, and DS2.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2021; v1 submitted 7 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Characterizing soot in TEM images using a convolutional neural network
Authors:
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Max Frei,
Alberto Baldelli,
P. Kirchen,
Frank E. Kruis,
Steven N. Rogak
Abstract:
Soot is an important material with impacts that depend on particle morphology. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) represents one of the most direct routes to qualitatively assess particle characteristics. However, producing quantitative information requires robust image processing tools, which is complicated by the low image contrast and complex aggregated morphologies characteristic of soot.…
▽ More
Soot is an important material with impacts that depend on particle morphology. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) represents one of the most direct routes to qualitatively assess particle characteristics. However, producing quantitative information requires robust image processing tools, which is complicated by the low image contrast and complex aggregated morphologies characteristic of soot. The current work presents a new convolutional neural network explicitly trained to characterize soot, using pre-classified images of particles from a natural gas engine; a laboratory gas flare; and a marine engine. The results are compared against other existing classifiers before considering the effect that the classifiers have on automated primary particle size methods. Estimates of the overall uncertainties between fully automated approaches of aggregate characterization range from 25% in d_{p,100} to 85% in D_{TEM}. A consistent correlation is observed between projected-area equivalent diameter and primary particle size across all of the techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Properties of materials considered for improvised masks
Authors:
Steven. N. Rogak,
Timothy A. Sipkens,
Mang Guan,
Hamed Nikookar,
Daniela Vargas Figueroa,
Jing Wang
Abstract:
During a pandemic in which aerosol and droplet transmission is possible, the demand for masks that meet medical or workplace standards can prevent most individuals or organizations from obtaining suitable protection. Cloth masks are widely believed to impede droplet and aerosol transmission but most are constructed from materials with unknown filtration efficiency, airflow resistance and water res…
▽ More
During a pandemic in which aerosol and droplet transmission is possible, the demand for masks that meet medical or workplace standards can prevent most individuals or organizations from obtaining suitable protection. Cloth masks are widely believed to impede droplet and aerosol transmission but most are constructed from materials with unknown filtration efficiency, airflow resistance and water resistance. Further, there has been no clear guidance on the most important performance metrics for the materials used by the general public (as opposed to high-risk healthcare settings). Here we provide data on a range of common fabrics that might be used to construct masks. None of the materials were suitable for masks meeting the N95 NIOSH standard, but many could provide useful filtration (>90%) of 3 micron particles (a plausible challenge size for human generated aerosols), with low pressure drop. These were: nonwoven sterile wraps, dried baby wipes and some double-knit cotton materials. Decontamination of N95 masks using isopropyl alcohol produces the expected increase in particle penetration, but for 3 micron particles, filtration efficiency is still well above 95%. Tightly woven thin fabrics, despite having the visual appearance of a good particle barrier, had remarkably low filtration efficiency and high pressure drop. These differences in filtration performance can be partly explained by the material structure; the better structures expose individual fibers to the flow while the poor materials may have small fundamental fibers but these are in tightly bundled yarns. The fit and use of the whole mask are critical factors not addressed in this work. Despite the complexity of the design of a very good mask, it is clear that for the larger aerosol particles, any mask will provide substantial protection to the wearer and those around them.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
