-
Benefits and limitations of a new hydraulic performance model
Authors:
Fabian C. Weigend,
Edward Gray,
Oliver Obst,
Jason Siegler
Abstract:
Purpose: Performance models are important tools for coaches and athletes to optimise competition outcomes or training schedules. A recently published hydraulic performance model has been reported to outperform established work-balance models in predicting recovery during intermittent exercise. The new hydraulic model was optimised to predict exercise recovery dynamics. In this work, we hypothesise…
▽ More
Purpose: Performance models are important tools for coaches and athletes to optimise competition outcomes or training schedules. A recently published hydraulic performance model has been reported to outperform established work-balance models in predicting recovery during intermittent exercise. The new hydraulic model was optimised to predict exercise recovery dynamics. In this work, we hypothesised that the benefits of the model come at the cost of inaccurate predictions of metabolic responses to exercise such as $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$.
Methods: Hydraulic model predictions were compared to breath-by-breath $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$ data from 25 constant high-intensity exercise tests of 5 participants (age $32\pm7.8$ years, weight $73.6 \pm 5.81$ kg, $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2\mathrm{max}} \; 3.59 \pm 0.62$ L/min). Each test was performed to volitional exhaustion on a cycle ergometer with a duration between 2 and 12 min. The comparison focuses on the onset of $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$ kinetics.
Results: On average, the hydraulic model predicted peak $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$ during exercise $216\pm113$~s earlier than observed in the data. The new hydraulic model also did not predict the so-called $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$ slow component and made the unrealistic assumption that there is no $\dot{V}_{\mathrm{O}_2}$ at the onset of exercise.
Conclusion: While the new hydraulic model may be a powerful tool for predicting energy recovery, it should not be used to predict metabolic responses during high-intensity exercise. The present study contributes towards a more holistic picture of the benefits and limitations of the new hydraulic model. Data and code are published as open source.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A hydraulic model outperforms work-balance models for predicting recovery kinetics from intermittent exercise
Authors:
Fabian C. Weigend,
David C. Clarke,
Oliver Obst,
Jason Siegler
Abstract:
Data Science advances in sports commonly involve "big data", i.e., large sport-related data sets. However, such big data sets are not always available, necessitating specialized models that apply to relatively few observations. One important area of sport-science research that features small data sets is the study of recovery from exercise. In this area, models are typically fitted to data collect…
▽ More
Data Science advances in sports commonly involve "big data", i.e., large sport-related data sets. However, such big data sets are not always available, necessitating specialized models that apply to relatively few observations. One important area of sport-science research that features small data sets is the study of recovery from exercise. In this area, models are typically fitted to data collected from exhaustive exercise test protocols, which athletes can perform only a few times. Recent findings highlight that established recovery such as the so-called work-balance models are too simple to adequately fit observed trends in the data. Therefore, we investigated a hydraulic model that requires the same few data points as work-balance models to be applied, but promises to predict recovery dynamics more accurately.
To compare the hydraulic model to established work-balance models, we retrospectively applied them to data compiled from published studies. In total, one hydraulic model and three work-balance models were compared on data extracted from five studies. The hydraulic model outperformed established work-balance models on all defined metrics, even those that penalize models featuring higher numbers of parameters. These results incentivize further investigation of the hydraulic model as a new alternative to established performance models of energy recovery.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2022; v1 submitted 10 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
A New Pathway to Approximate Energy Expenditure and Recovery of an Athlete
Authors:
Fabian Clemens Weigend,
Jason Siegler,
Oliver Obst
Abstract:
This work proposes to use evolutionary computation as a pathway to allow a new perspective on the modeling of energy expenditure and recovery of an individual athlete during exercise. We revisit a theoretical concept called the "three component hydraulic model" which is designed to simulate metabolic systems during exercise and which is able to address recently highlighted shortcomings of currentl…
▽ More
This work proposes to use evolutionary computation as a pathway to allow a new perspective on the modeling of energy expenditure and recovery of an individual athlete during exercise. We revisit a theoretical concept called the "three component hydraulic model" which is designed to simulate metabolic systems during exercise and which is able to address recently highlighted shortcomings of currently applied performance models. This hydraulic model has not been entirely validated on individual athletes because it depends on physiological measures that cannot be acquired in the required precision or quantity. This paper introduces a generalized interpretation and formalization of the three component hydraulic model that removes its ties to concrete metabolic measures and allows to use evolutionary computation to fit its parameters to an athlete.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2023; v1 submitted 16 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Techniques for Efficiently Handling Power Surges in Fuel Cell Powered Data Centers: Modeling, Analysis, Results
Authors:
Yang Li,
Di Wang,
Saugata Ghose,
Jie Liu,
Sriram Govindan,
Sean James,
Eric Peterson,
John Siegler,
Rachata Ausavarungnirun,
Onur Mutlu
Abstract:
Fuel cells are a promising power source for future data centers, offering high energy efficiency, low greenhouse gas emissions, and high reliability. However, due to mechanical limitations related to fuel delivery, fuel cells are slow to adjust to sudden increases in data center power demands, which can result in temporary power shortfalls. To mitigate the impact of power shortfalls, prior work ha…
▽ More
Fuel cells are a promising power source for future data centers, offering high energy efficiency, low greenhouse gas emissions, and high reliability. However, due to mechanical limitations related to fuel delivery, fuel cells are slow to adjust to sudden increases in data center power demands, which can result in temporary power shortfalls. To mitigate the impact of power shortfalls, prior work has proposed to either perform power capping by throttling the servers, or to leverage energy storage devices (ESDs) that can temporarily provide enough power to make up for the shortfall while the fuel cells ramp up power generation. Both approaches have disadvantages: power capping conservatively limits server performance and can lead to service level agreement (SLA) violations, while ESD-only solutions must significantly overprovision the energy storage device capacity to tolerate the shortfalls caused by the worst-case (i.e., largest) power surges, which greatly increases the total cost of ownership (TCO).
We propose SizeCap, the first ESD sizing framework for fuel cell powered data centers, which coordinates ESD sizing with power capping to enable a cost-effective solution to power shortfalls in data centers. SizeCap sizes the ESD just large enough to cover the majority of power surges, but not the worst-case surges that occur infrequently, to greatly reduce TCO. It then uses the smaller capacity ESD in conjunction with power capping to cover the power shortfalls caused by the worst-case power surges. As part of our new flexible framework, we propose multiple power capping policies with different degrees of awareness of fuel cell and workload behavior, and evaluate their impact on workload performance and ESD size. Using traces from Microsoft's production data center systems, we demonstrate that SizeCap significantly reduces the ESD size without violating any SLAs.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
A Microscopic Energy- and Density-Dependent Effective Interaction and its Test by Nucleus-Nucleus Scattering
Authors:
G. Bartnitzky,
H. Clement,
P. Czerski,
H. Müther,
F. Nuoffer,
J. Siegler
Abstract:
An effective nucleon-nucleon interaction calculated in nuclear matter from the Bonn potential has been parametrized in terms of a local density- and energy-dependent two-body interaction. This allows to calculate the real part of the nucleus-nucleus scattering potential and to test this effective interaction over a wide region of densities ($ρ\leq 3ρ_0$) produced dynamically in scattering experi…
▽ More
An effective nucleon-nucleon interaction calculated in nuclear matter from the Bonn potential has been parametrized in terms of a local density- and energy-dependent two-body interaction. This allows to calculate the real part of the nucleus-nucleus scattering potential and to test this effective interaction over a wide region of densities ($ρ\leq 3ρ_0$) produced dynamically in scattering experiments. Comparing our calculations with empirical potentials extracted from data on light and heavy ion scattering by model-unrestricted analysis methods, we find quantitative agreement with the exception of proton scattering. The failure in this case may be traced back to the properties of the effective interaction at low densities, for which the nuclear matter results are not reliable. The success of the interaction at high overlap densities confirms the empirical evidence for a soft equation of state for cold nuclear matter.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 1996;
originally announced July 1996.
