-
Ambiguity in the use of SIR models to fit epidemic incidence data
Authors:
B Shayak,
Sana Jahedi,
James A Yorke
Abstract:
When fitting a multi-parameter model to a data set, computer algorithms may suggest that a range of parameters provide equally reasonable fits, making the parameter estimation difficult. Here, we prove this fact for an SIR model. We say a set of parameter values is a good fit to outbreak data if the solution has the data's three most significant characteristics: the standard deviation, the mean ti…
▽ More
When fitting a multi-parameter model to a data set, computer algorithms may suggest that a range of parameters provide equally reasonable fits, making the parameter estimation difficult. Here, we prove this fact for an SIR model. We say a set of parameter values is a good fit to outbreak data if the solution has the data's three most significant characteristics: the standard deviation, the mean time, and the total number of cases. In our model, in addition to the "basic reproduction number" $R_0$, three other parameters need to be estimated to fit a solution to outbreak data. We will show that those parameters can be chosen so that each gives a linear transformation of a solution's incidence data. As a result, we show that for every choice of $R_0>1$, there is a good fit for each outbreak. We also illustrate our results by providing the least square best fits of the New York City and London data sets of the Omicron variant of COVID-19. Furthermore, we show how versions of the SIR model with $N$ compartments have far more good fits- - indeed a high dimensional set of good fits -- for each target -- showing that more complicated models may have an even greater problem in overparametrizing outbreak characteristics.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Unbounded sequences of stable limit cycles in the delayed Duffing equation: an exact analysis
Authors:
Si Mohamed Sah,
Bernold Fiedler,
B. Shayak,
Richard H. Rand
Abstract:
The delayed Duffing equation $\ddot{x}(t)+x(t-T)+x^3(t)=0$ is shown to possess an infinite and unbounded sequence of rapidly oscillating, asymptotically stable periodic solutions, for fixed delays such that $T^2<\tfrac{3}{2}π^2$. In contrast to several previous works which involved approximate solutions, the treatment here is exact.
The delayed Duffing equation $\ddot{x}(t)+x(t-T)+x^3(t)=0$ is shown to possess an infinite and unbounded sequence of rapidly oscillating, asymptotically stable periodic solutions, for fixed delays such that $T^2<\tfrac{3}{2}π^2$. In contrast to several previous works which involved approximate solutions, the treatment here is exact.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Simplified model and analysis of a pair of coupled thermo-optical MEMS oscillators
Authors:
Richard H. Rand,
Alan T. Zehnder,
B. Shayak,
Aditya Bhaskar
Abstract:
Motivated by the dynamics of micro-scale oscillators with thermo-optical feedback, a simplified third order model, capturing the key features of these oscillators is developed, where each oscillator consists of a displacement variable coupled to a temperature variable. Further, the dynamics of a pair of such oscillators coupled via a linear spring is analyzed. The analytical procedures used are th…
▽ More
Motivated by the dynamics of micro-scale oscillators with thermo-optical feedback, a simplified third order model, capturing the key features of these oscillators is developed, where each oscillator consists of a displacement variable coupled to a temperature variable. Further, the dynamics of a pair of such oscillators coupled via a linear spring is analyzed. The analytical procedures used are the variational equation method and the two-variable expansion method. It is shown that the analytical results are in agreement with the results of numerical integration. The bifurcation structure of the system is revealed through a bifurcation diagram.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
A New self-propelled magnetic bearing with helical windings
Authors:
B Shayak
Abstract:
In this work a design is proposed for an active, permanent magnet based, self-propelled magnetic bearing i.e. levitating motor having the following features : (a) simple winding structure, (b) high load supporting capacity, (c) no eccentricity sensors, (d) stable confinement in all translational dimensions, (e) stable confinement in all rotational dimensions and (f) high efficiency. This design us…
▽ More
In this work a design is proposed for an active, permanent magnet based, self-propelled magnetic bearing i.e. levitating motor having the following features : (a) simple winding structure, (b) high load supporting capacity, (c) no eccentricity sensors, (d) stable confinement in all translational dimensions, (e) stable confinement in all rotational dimensions and (f) high efficiency. This design uses an architecture consisting of a helically wound three-phase stator, and a rotor with the magnets also arranged in a helical manner. Active control is used to excite the rotor at a torque angle lying in the second quadrant. This torque angle is independent of the rotor's position inside the stator cavity hence the control algorithm is similar to that of a conventional permanent magnet synchronous motor. It is motivated through a physical argument that the bearing rotor develops a lift force proportional to the output torque and that it remains stably confined in space. These assertions are then proved rigorously through a calculation of the magnetic fields, forces and torques. The stiffness matrix of the system is presented and a discussion of stable and unstable operating regions is given.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Analysis of a remarkable singularity in a nonlinear DDE
Authors:
Matthew Davidow,
B. Shayak,
Richard H. Rand
Abstract:
In this work we investigate the dynamics of the nonlinear DDE (delay-differential equation)
x''(t)+x(t-T)+x(t)^3=0
where T is the delay. For T=0 this system is conservative and exhibits no limit cycles. For T>0, no matter how small, an infinite number of limit cycles exist, their amplitudes going to infinity in the limit as T approaches zero.
We investigate this situation in three ways: 1) H…
▽ More
In this work we investigate the dynamics of the nonlinear DDE (delay-differential equation)
x''(t)+x(t-T)+x(t)^3=0
where T is the delay. For T=0 this system is conservative and exhibits no limit cycles. For T>0, no matter how small, an infinite number of limit cycles exist, their amplitudes going to infinity in the limit as T approaches zero.
We investigate this situation in three ways: 1) Harmonic Balance, 2) Melnikov's integral, and 3) Adding damping to regularize the singularity.
△ Less
Submitted 1 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
The Physics of Motorcycles and Fast Bicycles : Lean, Stability and Counter-steering
Authors:
B Shayak
Abstract:
In this work I will obtain the system of nonlinear equations that correctly describes the motion of motorcycles and fast bicycles (above 30 km/hr) for the first time in literature. I will use it to calculate the lean angle during a turn and prove that the motion of the vehicle is unconditionally stable at all operating speeds under consideration. I will then employ it to give a quantitative model…
▽ More
In this work I will obtain the system of nonlinear equations that correctly describes the motion of motorcycles and fast bicycles (above 30 km/hr) for the first time in literature. I will use it to calculate the lean angle during a turn and prove that the motion of the vehicle is unconditionally stable at all operating speeds under consideration. I will then employ it to give a quantitative model of counter-steering - the phenomenon by which a turning mobike first goes the wrong way and then starts going the right way.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
A Method for stability analysis of magnetic bearings : Basic stability criteria
Authors:
B Shayak
Abstract:
In this work I outline a general procedure for dynamic modeling and stability analysis of a magnetic bearing, which is a rotating shaft confined inside a chamber through electromagnetic forces alone. I consider the simplest type of self-propelled bearing, namely a permanent magnet synchronous motor and an induction motor rotor freely suspended inside the corresponding stator, and having no eccentr…
▽ More
In this work I outline a general procedure for dynamic modeling and stability analysis of a magnetic bearing, which is a rotating shaft confined inside a chamber through electromagnetic forces alone. I consider the simplest type of self-propelled bearing, namely a permanent magnet synchronous motor and an induction motor rotor freely suspended inside the corresponding stator, and having no eccentricity-fedback control algorithm. Writing Euler's equations for the rotor mechanics and Maxwell's equations for the electromagnetic field leads to a systematic technique for analysing the dynamics of the complete system. Physical arguments indicate that that two essential components for rotor confinement are a spatial gradient in the stator magnetic field and a torque angle lying in the second quadrant. These predictions are confirmed through the linear stability analysis. The direct practical utility of the results is mitigated by the presence of a repeated eigenvalue in the linearized equations. Despite this limitation, the analysis presented can act as a good starting point for more accurate treatments of other magnetic bearing configurations.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
