-
Accurate Critical Exponents from the Optimal Truncation of the epsilon- Expansion within the O(N)-symmetric Field Theory for large N
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
The perturbation series for the renormalization group functions of the $O(N)-$symmetric $φ^4$ field theory are divergent but asymptotic. They are usually followed by Resummation calculations to extract reliable results. Although the same features exist for QED series, their partial sums can return accurate results because the perturbation parameter is small. In this work, however, we show that, fo…
▽ More
The perturbation series for the renormalization group functions of the $O(N)-$symmetric $φ^4$ field theory are divergent but asymptotic. They are usually followed by Resummation calculations to extract reliable results. Although the same features exist for QED series, their partial sums can return accurate results because the perturbation parameter is small. In this work, however, we show that, for $N\ge4$, the partial sum ( according to optimal truncation) of the series for the exponents $ν$ and $η$ gives results that are very competitive to the recent Monte Carlo and Conformal field calculations. The series can be written in terms of the perturbation parameter $α=σ\varepsilon=\frac{3}{N+8}\varepsilon$ which is smaller for larger $N$ and thus as $N$ increases one expects accurate perturbative results like the QED case. Such optimal truncation, however, doesn't work for the series of the critical exponent $ω$ ( for intermediate values of $N$) as the truncated series includes only the first order. Nevertheless, for $N\ge4$, the large-order parameter $σ=\frac{3}{N+8}$ is getting smaller which rationalizes for the use of the Pad$\acute{e}$ approximation. For that aim, we first obtain the seven-loop $\varepsilon$-series from the recent available corresponding $g$-expansion. The seven-loop Pad$\acute{e}$ approximation gives accurate results for the three exponents. Besides, for all the seven orders in the series, the large-$N$ limit leads to the exact result predicted by the non-perturbative $1/N$-Expansion.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Toward Exact Critical Exponents from the low-order loop expansion of the Effective Potential in Quantum Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
The asymptotic strong-coupling behavior as well as the exact critical exponents from scalar field theory even in the simplest case of $1+1$ dimensions have not been obtained yet. Hagen Kleinert has linked both critical exponents and strong coupling parameters to each other. He used a clevert variational technique ( back to kleinert and Feynman) to extract accurate values for the strong coupling pa…
▽ More
The asymptotic strong-coupling behavior as well as the exact critical exponents from scalar field theory even in the simplest case of $1+1$ dimensions have not been obtained yet. Hagen Kleinert has linked both critical exponents and strong coupling parameters to each other. He used a clevert variational technique ( back to kleinert and Feynman) to extract accurate values for the strong coupling parameters from which he was able to extract precise critical exponents. In this work, we suggest a simple method of using the effective potential (low-order) to obtain exact values for the strong-coupling parameters for the $φ^{4}$ scalar field theory in $0+1$ and $1+1$ space-time dimensions. For the $0+1$ case, our results coincide with the well-known exact values from literature while for the $1+1$ case we test the results by obtaining the corresponding exact critical exponent. As the effective potential is a well-established tool in quantum field theory, we expect that the results can be easily extended to the most important three dimensional case and then the dream of getting exact critical exponents is made possible.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024; v1 submitted 14 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
High-Order Parametrization of the Hypergeometric-Meijer Approximants
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In previous articles, we showed that, based on large-order asymptotic behavior, one can approximate a divergent series via the parametrization of a specific hypergeometric approximant. The analytical continuation is then carried out through a Mellin-Barnes integral representation of the hypergeometric approximant or equivalently using an equivalent form of the Meijer G-Function. The parametrizatio…
▽ More
In previous articles, we showed that, based on large-order asymptotic behavior, one can approximate a divergent series via the parametrization of a specific hypergeometric approximant. The analytical continuation is then carried out through a Mellin-Barnes integral representation of the hypergeometric approximant or equivalently using an equivalent form of the Meijer G-Function. The parametrization process involves the solution of a non-linear set of coupled equations which is hard to achieve (might be impossible) for high orders using normal PCs. In this work, we extend the approximation algorithm to accommodate any order (high or low) of the given series in a short time. The extension also allows us to employ non-perturbative information like strong-coupling and large-order asymptotic data which are always used to accelerate the convergence. We applied the algorithm for different orders (up to O($29$)) of the ground state energy of the $x^4$ anharmonic oscillator with and without the non-perturbative information. We also considered the available $20$ orders for the ground sate energy of the $\mathcal{PT}-$symmetric $ix^{3}$ anharmonic oscillator as well as the given $20$ orders of its strong-coupling expansion or equivalently the Yang-Lee model. For high order weak-coupling parametrization, accurate results have been obtained for the ground state energy and the non-perturbative parameters describing strong-coupling and large-order asymptotic behaviors. The employment of the non-perturbative data accelerated the convergence very clearly. The High temperature expansion for the susceptibility within the $SQ$ lattice has been also considered and led to accurate prediction for the critical exponent and critical temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
The $λ$-point anomaly in view of the seven-loop Hypergeometric resummation for the critical exponent $ν$ of the $O(2)$ $φ^4$ model
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we use a specific parameterization of the hypergeometric approximants ( the one by Mera et.al in Phys. Rev. Let. 115, 143001 (2015)) to approximate the seven-loop critical exponent $ν$ for the $O(2)$-symmetric $φ^4$ model. Our prediction gives the result $ν=0.6711(7)$ which is compatible with the value $ν=0.6709(1)$ from the famous experiment carried on the space shuttle Columbia. On…
▽ More
In this work, we use a specific parameterization of the hypergeometric approximants ( the one by Mera et.al in Phys. Rev. Let. 115, 143001 (2015)) to approximate the seven-loop critical exponent $ν$ for the $O(2)$-symmetric $φ^4$ model. Our prediction gives the result $ν=0.6711(7)$ which is compatible with the value $ν=0.6709(1)$ from the famous experiment carried on the space shuttle Columbia. On the other hand, our result is also compatible with recent precise theoretical predictions that are excluding the experimental result. These theoretical results include non-perturbative renormalization group calculations ( $ν=0.6716(6)$), the most precise result from Monte Carlo simulations ($ν=0.67169(7)$) as well as the recent conformal bootstrap calculations ($ν=0.67175(10)$). Although our result is compatible with experiment, the plot of renormalization group result versus the number of loops suggests that higher orders are expected to add significantly to accuracy and precision of the $ν$ exponent in a way that may favor the theoretical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Critical Exponents of the O(N)-symmetric $φ^4$ Model from the \boldmath{\large{ $\varepsilon^7$}} Hypergeometric-Meijer Resummation
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We extract the $\varepsilon$-expansion from the recently obtained seven-loop $g$-expansion for the renormalization group functions of the $O(N)$-symmetric model. The different series obtained for the critical exponents $ν,\ ω$ and $η$ have been resummed using our recently introduced hypergeometric-Meijer resummation algorithm. In three dimensions, very precise results have been obtained for all th…
▽ More
We extract the $\varepsilon$-expansion from the recently obtained seven-loop $g$-expansion for the renormalization group functions of the $O(N)$-symmetric model. The different series obtained for the critical exponents $ν,\ ω$ and $η$ have been resummed using our recently introduced hypergeometric-Meijer resummation algorithm. In three dimensions, very precise results have been obtained for all the critical exponents for $N=0,1,2,3$ and $4$. To shed light on the obvious improvement of the predictions at this order, we obtained the divergence of the specific heat critical exponent $α$ for the $XY$ model. We found the result $-0.0123(11)$ which is compatible with the famous experimental result of -0.0127(3) from the specific heat of zero gravity liquid helium superfluid transition while the six-loop Borel with conformal mapping resummation result in literature gives the value -0.007(3). For the challenging case of resummation of the $\varepsilon$-expansion series in two dimensions, we showed that our resummation results reflect a significant improvement to the previous six-loop resummation predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2020; v1 submitted 26 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Precise Critical Exponents of the O(N)-Symmetric Quantum field Model using Hypergeometric-Meijer Resummation
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we show that one can select different types of Hypergeometric approximants for the resummation of divergent series with different large-order growth factors. Being of $n!$ growth factor, the divergent series for the $\varepsilon$-expansion of the critical exponents of the $O(N)$-symmetric model is approximated by the Hypergeometric functions $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$. The divergent…
▽ More
In this work, we show that one can select different types of Hypergeometric approximants for the resummation of divergent series with different large-order growth factors. Being of $n!$ growth factor, the divergent series for the $\varepsilon$-expansion of the critical exponents of the $O(N)$-symmetric model is approximated by the Hypergeometric functions $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$. The divergent $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ functions are then resummed using their equivalent Meijer-G function representation. The convergence of the resummation results for the exponents $ν$,\ $η$ and $ω$ has been shown to improve systematically in going from low order to the highest known six-loops order. Our six-loops resummation results are very competitive to the recent six-loops Borel with conformal mapping predictions and to recent Monte Carlo simulation results. To show that precise results extend for high $N$ values, we listed the five-loops results for $ν$ which are very accurate as well. The recent seven-loops order ($g$-series) for the renormalization group functions $β,γ_{φ^2}$ and $γ_{m^2}$ have been resummed too. Accurate predictions for the critical coupling and the exponents $ν$, $η$ and $ω$ have been extracted from $β$,$γ_{φ^2}$ and $γ_{m^2}$ approximants.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Weak-Coupling, Strong-Coupling and Large-Order Parametrization of the Hypergeometric-Meijer Approximants
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
Without Borel or Pad$\acute{e}$ techniques, we show that for a divergent series with $n!$ large-order growth factor, the set of Hypergeometric series $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ represents suitable approximants for which there exist no free parameters. The divergent $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ series are then resummed via their representation in terms of the Meijer-G function. The choice of $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ accelerates th…
▽ More
Without Borel or Pad$\acute{e}$ techniques, we show that for a divergent series with $n!$ large-order growth factor, the set of Hypergeometric series $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ represents suitable approximants for which there exist no free parameters. The divergent $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ series are then resummed via their representation in terms of the Meijer-G function. The choice of $_{k+1}F_{k-1}$ accelerates the convergence even with only weak-coupling information as input. For more acceleration of the convergence, we employ the strong-coupling and large-order information. We obtained a new constraint that relates the difference of numerator and denominator parameters in the Hypergeometric approximant to one of the large-order parameters. To test the validity of that constraint, we employed it to obtain the exact partition function of the zero-dimensional $φ^4$ scalar field theory. The algorithm is also applied for the resummation of the ground state energies of $φ_{0+1}^{4}$ and $iφ_{0+1}^{3}$ scalar field theories. We get accurate results for the whole coupling space and the precision is improved systematically in using higher orders. Precise results for the critical exponents of the $O(4)$-symmetric field model in three dimensions have been obtained from resummation of the recent six-loops order of the corresponding perturbation series. The recent seven-loops order for the $β$-function of the $φ^{4}_{3+1}$ field theory has been resummed which shows non-existence of fixed points. The first resummation result of the seven-loop series representing the fractal dimension of the two-dimensional self-avoiding polymer is presented here where we get a very accurate value of $d_f=1.3307$ compared to its exact value ($4/3\approx1.3333$).
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2020; v1 submitted 8 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Universal Large-order asymptotic behavior of the Strong-coupling and High-Temperature series expansions
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
For theories that exhibit second order phase transition, we conjecture that the large-order asymptotic behavior of the strong-coupling ( High-Temperature) series expansion takes the form $σ^{n} n^{b}$ where $b$ is a universal parameter. The associated critical exponent is then given by $b+1$. The series itself can be approximated by the hypergeometric approximants $_{p}F_{p-1}$ which can mimic the…
▽ More
For theories that exhibit second order phase transition, we conjecture that the large-order asymptotic behavior of the strong-coupling ( High-Temperature) series expansion takes the form $σ^{n} n^{b}$ where $b$ is a universal parameter. The associated critical exponent is then given by $b+1$. The series itself can be approximated by the hypergeometric approximants $_{p}F_{p-1}$ which can mimic the same large-order behavior of the given series. Near the tip of the branch cut, the hypergeometric function $_{p}F_{p-1}$ has a power-law behavior from which the critical exponent and critical coupling can be extracted. The conjecture has been tested in this work for the perturbation series of the ground state energy of the Yang-Lee model as a strong-coupling form of the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric $iφ^3$ theory and the High-Temperature expansion within the Ising model. From the known $b$ parameter for the Yang-Lee model, we obtained the exact critical exponents which reflects the universality of $b$. Very accurate prediction for $b$ has been obtained from the many orders available for the High-Temperature series expansion of the Ising model which in turn predicts accurate critical exponent. Apart from critical exponents, the hypergeometric approximants for the Yang-Lee model show almost exact predictions for the ground state energy from low orders of perturbation series as input.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2021; v1 submitted 8 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Extrapolating the precision of the Hypergeometric Resummation to Strong couplings with application to the $\mathcal{PT-}$Symmetric $iφ^{3}$ Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In PRL 115, 143001 (2015), H. Mera et al. developed a new simple but precise Hypergeometric Resummation technique. In this work, we suggest to obtain half of the parameters of the Hypergeometric function from the strong coupling expansion of the physical quantity. Since these parameters are taking now their exact values they can improve the precision of the technique for the whole range of the cou…
▽ More
In PRL 115, 143001 (2015), H. Mera et al. developed a new simple but precise Hypergeometric Resummation technique. In this work, we suggest to obtain half of the parameters of the Hypergeometric function from the strong coupling expansion of the physical quantity. Since these parameters are taking now their exact values they can improve the precision of the technique for the whole range of the coupling values. The second order approximant $\,_{2}F_{1}$ of the algorithm is applied to resum the perturbation series of the ground state energy of the $\mathcal{PT-}$symmetric $(iφ^{3})_{0+1}$ field theory. It gives accurate results compared to exact calculations from the literature specially for very large coupling values. The $\mathcal{PT-}$ symmetry breaking of the Yang-Lee model has been investigated where third, fourth and fifth orders were able to get very accurate results when compared to other resummation methods involving $150$ orders. The critical exponent $ν$ of the $O(4)$-symmetric model in three dimensions has been precisely obtained using only first order of perturbation series as input. The algorithm can be extended easily to accommodate any order of perturbation series in using the generalized Hypergeometric function $\,_{k+1}F_{k}$ as it shares the same analytic properties with $\,_{2}F_{1}$.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2019; v1 submitted 14 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Effective Action study of $\mathcal{PT}$-Symmetry Breaking for the non-Hermitian $\left( iφ^{3}\right) _{6-ε}$ Theory and The Yang-Lee Edge Singularity
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We use the effective potential method to study the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry breaking of the non-Hermitian $iφ^{3}$ field theory in $6-ε$ space-time dimensions. The critical exponents so obtained coincide with the exact values listed in the literature. We showed that at the point of $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry breaking, the vacuum-vacuum amplitude is certainly zero and the fugacity is one which mimics a…
▽ More
We use the effective potential method to study the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry breaking of the non-Hermitian $iφ^{3}$ field theory in $6-ε$ space-time dimensions. The critical exponents so obtained coincide with the exact values listed in the literature. We showed that at the point of $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetry breaking, the vacuum-vacuum amplitude is certainly zero and the fugacity is one which mimics a Yang-Lee edge singularity in magnetic systems. What makes this work interesting is that it takes into account problems which are always overlooked in the literature for the Yang-Lee model like stability, unitarity and generation of Stokes wedges at space-time dimensions for which divergences occur in the theory . Besides, here we make direct calculation of critical exponents from the dependance of the order parameter on external magnetic field not from the density of zeros of the partition function.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
The General Solution for the Relativistic and Nonrelativistic Schrödinger Equation for the $δ^{(n)}$-Function Potential in 1-dimension Using Cutoff Regularization, and the Fate of Universality
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
M. Salman,
A. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
A general method has been developed to solve the Schrödinger equation for an arbitrary derivative of the $δ$-function potential in 1-d using cutoff regularization. The work treats both the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases. A distinction in the treatment has been made between the case when the derivative $n$ is an even number from the one when $n$ is an odd number. A general gap equations for…
▽ More
A general method has been developed to solve the Schrödinger equation for an arbitrary derivative of the $δ$-function potential in 1-d using cutoff regularization. The work treats both the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases. A distinction in the treatment has been made between the case when the derivative $n$ is an even number from the one when $n$ is an odd number. A general gap equations for each case has been derived. The case of $δ^{(2)}$-function potential has been used as an example. The results from the relativistic case show that the $δ^{(2)}$-function system behaves exactly like the $δ$-function and the $δ'$-function potentials, which means it also shares the same features with quantum field theories, like being asymptotically free, in the massless limit, it undergoes dimensional transmutation and it possesses an infrared conformal fixed point. As a result the evidence of universality of contact interactions has been extended further to include the $δ^{(2)}$-function potential.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2019; v1 submitted 28 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Majorana Fermions in a Box
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
A. M. Shalaby,
U. -J. Wiese
Abstract:
Majorana fermion dynamics may arise at the edge of Kitaev wires or superconductors. Alternatively, it can be engineered by using trapped ions or ultracold atoms in an optical lattice as quantum simulators. This motivates the theoretical study of Majorana fermions confined to a finite volume, whose boundary conditions are characterized by self-adjoint extension parameters. While the boundary condit…
▽ More
Majorana fermion dynamics may arise at the edge of Kitaev wires or superconductors. Alternatively, it can be engineered by using trapped ions or ultracold atoms in an optical lattice as quantum simulators. This motivates the theoretical study of Majorana fermions confined to a finite volume, whose boundary conditions are characterized by self-adjoint extension parameters. While the boundary conditions for Dirac fermions in $(1+1)$-d are characterized by a 1-parameter family, $λ= - λ^*$, of self-adjoint extensions, for Majorana fermions $λ$ is restricted to $\pm i$. Based on this result, we compute the frequency spectrum of Majorana fermions confined to a 1-d interval. The boundary conditions for Dirac fermions confined to a 3-d region of space are characterized by a 4-parameter family of self-adjoint extensions, which is reduced to two distinct 1-parameter families for Majorana fermions. We also consider the problems related to the quantum mechanical interpretation of the Majorana equation as a single-particle equation. Furthermore, the equation is related to a relativistic Schrödinger equation that does not suffer from these problems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2016; v1 submitted 28 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Fate of Accidental Symmetries of the Relativistic Hydrogen Atom in a Spherical Cavity
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
A. M. Shalaby,
U. -J. Wiese
Abstract:
The non-relativistic hydrogen atom enjoys an accidental $SO(4)$ symmetry, that enlarges the rotational $SO(3)$ symmetry, by extending the angular momentum algebra with the Runge-Lenz vector. In the relativistic hydrogen atom the accidental symmetry is partially lifted. Due to the Johnson-Lippmann operator, which commutes with the Dirac Hamiltonian, some degeneracy remains. When the non-relativisti…
▽ More
The non-relativistic hydrogen atom enjoys an accidental $SO(4)$ symmetry, that enlarges the rotational $SO(3)$ symmetry, by extending the angular momentum algebra with the Runge-Lenz vector. In the relativistic hydrogen atom the accidental symmetry is partially lifted. Due to the Johnson-Lippmann operator, which commutes with the Dirac Hamiltonian, some degeneracy remains. When the non-relativistic hydrogen atom is put in a spherical cavity of radius $R$ with perfectly reflecting Robin boundary conditions, characterized by a self-adjoint extension parameter $γ$, in general the accidental $SO(4)$ symmetry is lifted. However, for $R = (l+1)(l+2) a$ (where $a$ is the Bohr radius and $l$ is the orbital angular momentum) some degeneracy remains when $γ= \infty$ or $γ= \frac{2}{R}$. In the relativistic case, we consider the most general spherically and parity invariant boundary condition, which is characterized by a self-adjoint extension parameter. In this case, the remnant accidental symmetry is always lifted in a finite volume. We also investigate the accidental symmetry in the context of the Pauli equation, which sheds light on the proper non-relativistic treatment including spin. In that case, again some degeneracy remains for specific values of $R$ and $γ$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
The Solution of the Relativistic Schrodinger Equation for the $δ'$-Function Potential in 1-dimension Using Cutoff Regularization
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
A. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We study the relativistic version of Schrödinger equation for a point particle in 1-d with potential of the first derivative of the delta function. The momentum cutoff regularization is used to study the bound state and scattering states. The initial calculations show that the reciprocal of the bare coupling constant is ultra-violet divergent, and the resultant expression cannot be renormalized in…
▽ More
We study the relativistic version of Schrödinger equation for a point particle in 1-d with potential of the first derivative of the delta function. The momentum cutoff regularization is used to study the bound state and scattering states. The initial calculations show that the reciprocal of the bare coupling constant is ultra-violet divergent, and the resultant expression cannot be renormalized in the usual sense. Therefore a general procedure has been developed to derive different physical properties of the system. The procedure is used first on the non-relativistic case for the purpose of clarification and comparisons. The results from the relativistic case show that this system behaves exactly like the delta function potential, which means it also shares the same features with quantum field theories, like being asymptotically free, and in the massless limit, it undergoes dimensional transmutation and it possesses an infrared conformal fixed point.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
A Solution of the Relativistic Schrödinger Equation for the $δ$-Function Potential in 1-dimensiona with Cutoff Regularization
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We study the solution of the relativistic Schrödinger equation for a point particle in 1-d under $δ$-function potential by using cutoff regularization. We show that the problem is renormalizable, and the results are exactly the same as the ones obtained using dimensional regularization.
We study the solution of the relativistic Schrödinger equation for a point particle in 1-d under $δ$-function potential by using cutoff regularization. We show that the problem is renormalizable, and the results are exactly the same as the ones obtained using dimensional regularization.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2014; v1 submitted 12 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Asymptotic Freedom, Dimensional Transmutation, and an Infra-red Conformal Fixed Point for the $δ$-Function Potential in 1-dimensional Relativistic Quantum Mechanics
Authors:
M. H. Al-Hashimi,
A. M. Shalaby,
U. -J. Wiese
Abstract:
We consider the Schrödinger equation for a relativistic point particle in an external 1-dimensional $δ$-function potential. Using dimensional regularization, we investigate both bound and scattering states, and we obtain results that are consistent with the abstract mathematical theory of self-adjoint extensions of the pseudo-differential operator $H = \sqrt{p^2 + m^2}$. Interestingly, this relati…
▽ More
We consider the Schrödinger equation for a relativistic point particle in an external 1-dimensional $δ$-function potential. Using dimensional regularization, we investigate both bound and scattering states, and we obtain results that are consistent with the abstract mathematical theory of self-adjoint extensions of the pseudo-differential operator $H = \sqrt{p^2 + m^2}$. Interestingly, this relatively simple system is asymptotically free. In the massless limit, it undergoes dimensional transmutation and it possesses an infra-red conformal fixed point. Thus it can be used to illustrate non-trivial concepts of quantum field theory in the simpler framework of relativistic quantum mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Comment on "Families of Particles with Different Masses in PT-Symmetric Quantum Field Theory" [arXiv:1002.3253]
Authors:
Abouzeid. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In a recent letter by Carl M. Bender and S. P. Klevansky [arXiv:1002.3253] an elementary field theory is proposed where the authors claimed that it can account for the existence of family of particles without any employment of group structures. In this work, we relied on the fact that the Dyson-Schwinger equations used by the authors stem from a variational principle and tried to reproduce their r…
▽ More
In a recent letter by Carl M. Bender and S. P. Klevansky [arXiv:1002.3253] an elementary field theory is proposed where the authors claimed that it can account for the existence of family of particles without any employment of group structures. In this work, we relied on the fact that the Dyson-Schwinger equations used by the authors stem from a variational principle and tried to reproduce their results by a mere variational algorithm. We were able to reproduce exactly their results by the employment of two different variational calculations of the vacuum energy in the proposed theory. We showed that the two vacuum solutions obtained by the authors of the commented letter correspond to two non-degenerate vacuum energies except for the $d=0$ space-time dimensions where the vacuum states are degenerate. Since any variational calculation of the vacuum energy should be higher than the true (exact) vacuum energy, the most accurate result will correspond to the vacuum that lowers the vacuum energy. We showed that the vacuum with unbroken $Z_{2}$ symmetry has lower energy than the vacuum with broken $Z_{2}$ symmetry. Accordingly, the theory will prefer to live with the vacuum of unbroken $Z_{2}$ symmetry in which the proposed theory is Hermitian. Thus the proposed theory neither has a preferred non-Hermitian representation nor it describes a family of particles as claimed by the authors of the commented work.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2011;
originally announced January 2011.
-
Vacuum Stability of the wrong sign $(-φ^{6})$ Scalar Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We apply the effective potential method to study the vacuum stability of the bounded from above $(-φ^{6})$ (unstable) quantum field potential. The stability ($\partial E/\partial b=0)$ and the mass renormalization ($\partial^{2} E/\partial b^{2}=M^{2})$ conditions force the effective potential of this theory to be bounded from below (stable). Since bounded from below potentials are always associat…
▽ More
We apply the effective potential method to study the vacuum stability of the bounded from above $(-φ^{6})$ (unstable) quantum field potential. The stability ($\partial E/\partial b=0)$ and the mass renormalization ($\partial^{2} E/\partial b^{2}=M^{2})$ conditions force the effective potential of this theory to be bounded from below (stable). Since bounded from below potentials are always associated with localized wave functions, the algorithm we use replaces the boundary condition applied to the wave functions in the complex contour method by two stability conditions on the effective potential obtained. To test the validity of our calculations, we show that our variational predictions can reproduce exactly the results in the literature for the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric $φ^{4}$ theory. We then extend the applications of the algorithm to the unstudied stability problem of the bounded from above $(-φ^{6})$ scalar field theory where classical analysis prohibits the existence of a stable spectrum. Concerning this, we calculated the effective potential up to first order in the couplings in $d$ space-time dimensions. We find that a Hermitian effective theory is instable while a non-Hermitian but $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric effective theory characterized by a pure imaginary vacuum condensate is stable (bounded from below) which is against the classical predictions of the instability of the theory. We assert that the work presented here represents the first calculations that advocates the stability of the $(-φ^{6})$ scalar potential.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2014; v1 submitted 25 December, 2010;
originally announced December 2010.
-
On the $iφ^{3}$ $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric Scalar Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we show that, for the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory, their exists a contradiction between the assumption that the field is real and the fact that the quantized as well as the classical fields have to satisfy the Klein-Gordon equation. In solving the Klein-Gordon equation for the theory under investigation, we realized that the field is a pure imaginary solitary wave which spoils out…
▽ More
In this work, we show that, for the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory, their exists a contradiction between the assumption that the field is real and the fact that the quantized as well as the classical fields have to satisfy the Klein-Gordon equation. In solving the Klein-Gordon equation for the theory under investigation, we realized that the field is a pure imaginary solitary wave which spoils out the non-Hermiticity of the theory. Thus, instead of being non-Hermitian, the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory is a kind of a Hermitian-Lee-Wick theory which suffers from the existence of the famous ghost states and instability problems. We applied a Canonical transformation to obtain a Non-Hermitian and non-$\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric representation which leads to the invalidity of the previous trials in the literature to cure the ghost states problem. Moreover, the solitonic solution is a non-topological one which is a very strange result to appear for a one component field theory. To account for this strange result, we conjecture that the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory has an equivalent Hermitian and non-Lee wick theory that have a conserved Noether current.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2010; v1 submitted 1 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
On the validity of the 'New ansatz for metric operator calculation in pseudo-Hermitian field theory'"
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
This paper has been withdrawn by the author(s), due a mistake of factor 1/2.
This paper has been withdrawn by the author(s), due a mistake of factor 1/2.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2009; v1 submitted 18 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Reply to "Comment on 'New ansatz for metric operator calculation in pseudo-Hermitian field theory '", arXiv:0906.4293
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this report, we reply to a recent comment by Carl M. Bender, Gregorio Benincasa and Hugh F. Jones on our work 'New ansatz for metric operator calculation in pseudo-Hermitian field theory (Phys. Rev. D. 79, 107702 (2009)). In fact, they figured out that there exist sign errors in our work which leaded to the conclusion of the invalidity of the ansatz introduced in our work. Here, we show that,…
▽ More
In this report, we reply to a recent comment by Carl M. Bender, Gregorio Benincasa and Hugh F. Jones on our work 'New ansatz for metric operator calculation in pseudo-Hermitian field theory (Phys. Rev. D. 79, 107702 (2009)). In fact, they figured out that there exist sign errors in our work which leaded to the conclusion of the invalidity of the ansatz introduced in our work. Here, we show that, the ansatz is valid in d+1 space-time dimensions, which by itself is a new and very important result. The importance of the work comes from the fact that it is the first time to have a metric operator for a quantum field theory which is local in the fields as well as valid in 3+1 space-time dimensions. Moreover, it is composed of the operators in the Hamiltonian itself which makes the Feynmann diagram calculations for the physical amplitudes go the same way as in conventional theories.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2009; v1 submitted 12 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Vacuum Stability of the $\mathcal{PT}$-Symmetric $\left( -φ^{4}\right) $ Scalar Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we study the vacuum stability of the classical unstable $\left( -φ^{4}\right) $ scalar field potential. Regarding this, we obtained the effective potential, up to second order in the coupling, for the theory in $1+1$ and $2+1$ space-time dimensions. We found that the obtained effective potential is bounded from below, which proves the vacuum stability of the theory in space-time dime…
▽ More
In this work, we study the vacuum stability of the classical unstable $\left( -φ^{4}\right) $ scalar field potential. Regarding this, we obtained the effective potential, up to second order in the coupling, for the theory in $1+1$ and $2+1$ space-time dimensions. We found that the obtained effective potential is bounded from below, which proves the vacuum stability of the theory in space-time dimensions higher than the previously studied $0+1$ case. In our calculations, we used the canonical quantization regime in which one deals with operators rather than classical functions used in the path integral formulation. Therefore, the non-Hermiticity of the effective field theory is obvious. Moreover, the method we employ implements the canonical equal-time commutation relations and the Heisenberg picture for the operators. Thus, the metric operator is implemented in the calculations of the transition amplitudes. Accordingly, the method avoids the very complicated calculations needed in other methods for the metric operator. To test the accuracy of our results, we obtained the exponential behavior of the vacuum condensate for small coupling values, which has been obtained in the literature using other methods. We assert that this work is interesting, as all the studies in the literature advocate the stability of the $\left( -φ^{4}\right) $ theory at the quantum mechanical level while our work extends the argument to the level of field quantization.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2014; v1 submitted 26 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
New Ansatz for Metric Operator Calculation in Pseudo-Hermitian Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, a new ansatz is introduced to make the calculations of the metric operator in Pseudo-Hermitian field theory simpler. The idea is to assume that the metric operator is not only a functional of the field operators $φ$ and its conjugate field $π$ but also on the field gradient $\nablaφ$. Rather than the locality of the metric operator obtained, the ansatz enables one to calculate the…
▽ More
In this work, a new ansatz is introduced to make the calculations of the metric operator in Pseudo-Hermitian field theory simpler. The idea is to assume that the metric operator is not only a functional of the field operators $φ$ and its conjugate field $π$ but also on the field gradient $\nablaφ$. Rather than the locality of the metric operator obtained, the ansatz enables one to calculate the metric operator just once for all dimensions of the space-time. We calculated the metric operator of the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory up to first order in the coupling. The higher orders can be conjectured from their corresponding operators in the quantum mechanical case available in the literature. We assert that, the calculations existing in literature for the metric operator in field theory are cumbersome and are done case by case concerning the dimension of space-time in which the theory is investigated. Moreover, while the resulted metric operator in this work is local, the existing calculations for the metric operator leads to a non-local one. Indeed, we expect that the new results introduced in this work will greatly lead to the progress of the studies in Pseudo-Hermitian field theories where there exist a lack of such kind of studies in the literature. In fact, with the aid of this work a rigorous study of a $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric Higgs mechanism can be reached.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2009; v1 submitted 13 January, 2009;
originally announced January 2009.
-
Possible treatment of the Ghost states in the Lee-Wick Standard Model
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
Very recently, the Lee-Wick standard model has been introduced as a non-SUSY extension of the Standard model which solves the Hierarchy problem. In this model, each field kinetic term attains a higher derivative term. Like any Lee-Wick theory, this model suffers from existence of Ghost states. In this work, we consider a prototype scalar field theory with its kinetic term has a higher derivative…
▽ More
Very recently, the Lee-Wick standard model has been introduced as a non-SUSY extension of the Standard model which solves the Hierarchy problem. In this model, each field kinetic term attains a higher derivative term. Like any Lee-Wick theory, this model suffers from existence of Ghost states. In this work, we consider a prototype scalar field theory with its kinetic term has a higher derivative term, which mimics the scalar sector in the Lee-Wick Standard model. We introduced an imaginary auxiliary field to have an equivalent non-Hermitian two-field scalar field theory. We were able to calculate the positive definite metric operator $η$ in quantum mechanical and quantum field versions of the theory in a closed form. While the Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian in a Hilbert space with the Dirac sense inner product, it is Hermitian in a Hilbert space endowed by the inner product $<n|η|m>$ as well as having a correct-sign propagator (no Lee-Wick fields). Besides, the obtained metric operator also diagonalizes the Hamiltonian in the two fields (no mixing). Moreover, the Hermiticity of $η$ constrained the two Higgs masses to be related as $M>2m$, which has been obtained in another work using a very different regime and thus supports our calculation. Also, an equivalent Hermitian (in the Dirac sense) Hamiltonian is obtained which has no Ghost states at all, which is a forward step to make the Lee-Wick theories more popular among the Physicists.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2009; v1 submitted 17 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
Effective Field calculations of the Energy Spectrum of the $\mathcal{PT}% $-Symmetric ($-x^{4}$) Potential
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we show that the traditional effective field approach can be applied to the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric wrong sign ($-x^{4}$) quartic potential. The importance of this work lies in the possibility of its extension to the more important $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric quantum field theory while the other approaches which use complex contours are not willing to be applicable. We calculated the…
▽ More
In this work, we show that the traditional effective field approach can be applied to the $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric wrong sign ($-x^{4}$) quartic potential. The importance of this work lies in the possibility of its extension to the more important $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric quantum field theory while the other approaches which use complex contours are not willing to be applicable. We calculated the effective potential of the massless $-x^{4}$ theory as well as the full spectrum of the theory. Although the calculations are carried out up to first order in the coupling, the predicted spectrum is very close to the exact one taken from other works. The most important result of this work is that the effective potential obtained, which is equivalent to the Gaussian effective potential, is bounded from below while the classical potential is bounded from above. This explains the stability of the vacuum of the theory. The obtained quasi-particle Hamiltonian is non-Hermitian but $\mathcal{PT}$-symmetric and we showed that the calculation of the metric operator can go perturbatively. In fact, the calculation of the metric operator can be done even for higher dimensions (quantum field theory) which, up till now, can not be calculated in the other approaches either perturbatively or in a closed form due to the possible appearance of field radicals. Moreover, we argued that the effective theory is perturbative for the whole range of the coupling constant and the perturbation series is expected to converge rapidly (the effective coupling $g_{eff}={1/6}$).
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2009; v1 submitted 20 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
Representation Dependence of Superficial Degree of Divergences in Quantum Field Theory
Authors:
Abouzeid. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In this work, we investigate a very important but unstressed result in the work of Carl M. Bender, Jun-Hua Chen, and Kimball A. Milton ( J.Phys.A39:1657-1668, 2006). In this article, Bender \textit{et.al} have calculated the vacuum energy of the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory and its Hermitian equivalent theory up to $g^{4}$ order of calculations. While all the Feynman diagrams of the $iφ^{3}$ theor…
▽ More
In this work, we investigate a very important but unstressed result in the work of Carl M. Bender, Jun-Hua Chen, and Kimball A. Milton ( J.Phys.A39:1657-1668, 2006). In this article, Bender \textit{et.al} have calculated the vacuum energy of the $iφ^{3}$ scalar field theory and its Hermitian equivalent theory up to $g^{4}$ order of calculations. While all the Feynman diagrams of the $iφ^{3}$ theory are finite in $0+1$ space-time dimensions, some of the corresponding Feynman diagrams in the equivalent Hermitian theory are divergent. In this work, we show that the divergences in the Hermitian theory originate from superrenormalizable, renormalizable and non-renormalizable terms in the interaction Hamiltonian even though the calculations are carried out in the $0+1$ space-time dimensions. Relying on this interesting result, we raise the question, is the superficial degree of divergence of a theory is representation dependent? To answer this question, we introduce and study a class of non-Hermitian quantum field theories characterized by a field derivative interaction Hamiltonian. We showed that the class is physically acceptable by finding the corresponding class of metric operators in a closed form. We realized that the obtained equivalent Hermitian and the introduced non-Hermitian representations have coupling constants of different mass dimensions which may be considered as a clue for the possibility of considering non-Renormalizability of a field theory as a non-genuine problem. Besides, the metric operator is supposed to disappear from path integral calculations which means that physical amplitudes can be fully obtained in the simpler non-Hermitian representation.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2015; v1 submitted 8 May, 2008;
originally announced May 2008.
-
Will the $PT$ Symmetric and Non-Hermitian $φ^4$ Theory Solve the Hierarchy and Triviality Problems in the Standard Model?
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
Very recently, the Large Hadron Collider was turned on. There, the experiments are aiming to test different scenarios for elementary particles interactions from SUSY, Extra dimensions to others. In fact, SUSY was invented to kill the conceptual problems existing in the conventional Standard model \textit{i.e.} the Hierarchy problem. However, in recent years, certain theories which was rejected i…
▽ More
Very recently, the Large Hadron Collider was turned on. There, the experiments are aiming to test different scenarios for elementary particles interactions from SUSY, Extra dimensions to others. In fact, SUSY was invented to kill the conceptual problems existing in the conventional Standard model \textit{i.e.} the Hierarchy problem. However, in recent years, certain theories which was rejected in the past like the wrong sign $φ^{4}$ theory is now well known to be a truly physically acceptable theory. Here, we analyze the renormalization group flow of the different parameters in the theory. We find that, rather than the conventional $φ^{4}$ theory and because the theory is asymptotically free, it does not sufferer from the catastrophic blow up of the mass parameter for UV scales. This feature greatly recommend that this theory is a plausible candidate to play the role of the $SU(2)\times U(1)$ symmetry breaking in the standard model. If this picture will agree with the experimental results from LHC, then the Higgs particle was massless in the far past. Moreover, the cosmological constant problem as a Hierarchy problem may be solved too. However, when trying to calculate the metric operator, we expected that the equivalent Hermitian theory may attain non-remormalizabe terms and thus the theory is incalculable. In fact, we show that there exists a Hermitian and renormalizable equivalent theory though of indefinite metric. We reformulated the Klein-Gordon equation in such a way that the wrong sign in the propagator attains a new physical meaning that the Higgs particle is made from exotic matter.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2008; v1 submitted 15 December, 2007;
originally announced December 2007.
-
Exact Metric Operators as the Ground State functions of the Hermitian Conjugates of a Class of Quasi-Hermitian Hamiltonians
Authors:
Abouzeid. M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We generalized a class of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians which introduced previously by us in such a way in which every member in the class is non-\textit{PT}-symmetric. For every member of the class, the ground state is a constant with zero energy eigen value. Instead of using an infinite set of coupled operator equations to calculate the metric operator we used a simple realization to obtain the c…
▽ More
We generalized a class of non-Hermitian Hamiltonians which introduced previously by us in such a way in which every member in the class is non-\textit{PT}-symmetric. For every member of the class, the ground state is a constant with zero energy eigen value. Instead of using an infinite set of coupled operator equations to calculate the metric operator we used a simple realization to obtain the class of closed form metric operators corresponding to the class of non-Hermitian and non-\textit{PT}-symmetric Hamiltonians introduced. The trick is that, if $ψ$ is an eigen function of $H$, then $φ=ηψ$ is an eigen function of $H^{\dagger}$ with the same eigen value. Thus, knowing any pair $(ψ,φ)$ one can deduce the form of the exact metric operator. We note that, the class of Hamiltonians generalized in this work has the form of that of imaginary magnetic field which can be absorbed by the quasi-gauge transformations represented by metric operators. Accordingly, it is expected that the $Q$ operators will disappear for the whole members in the class in the path integral formulation. However, the detailed analysis of this issue will appear in another work.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2008; v1 submitted 17 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
A Novel phase in the phase structure of the $(gφ^4 + hφ^6)_{1+1}$ field theoretic model
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
In view of the newly discovered and physically acceptable $PT$ symmetric and non-Hermitian models, we reinvestigated the phase structure of the ($gφ^{4}+hφ^{6}$)$_{1+1}$ Hermitian model. The reinvestigation concerns the possibility of a phase transition from the original Hermitian and $PT$ symmetric phase to a non-Hermitian and $PT$ symmetric one. This kind of phase transition, if verified exper…
▽ More
In view of the newly discovered and physically acceptable $PT$ symmetric and non-Hermitian models, we reinvestigated the phase structure of the ($gφ^{4}+hφ^{6}$)$_{1+1}$ Hermitian model. The reinvestigation concerns the possibility of a phase transition from the original Hermitian and $PT$ symmetric phase to a non-Hermitian and $PT$ symmetric one. This kind of phase transition, if verified experimentally, will lead to the first proof that non-Hermitian and $PT$ symmetric models are not just a mathematical research framework but are a nature desire. To do the investigation, we calculated the effective potential up to second order in the couplings and found a Hermitian to Non-Hermitian phase transition. This leads us to introduce, for the first time, hermiticity as a symmetry which can be broken due to quantum corrections, \textit{i.e.}, when starting with a model which is Hermitian in the classical level, quantum corrections can break hermiticity while the theory stays physically acceptable. In fact, ignoring this phase will lead to violation of universality when comparing this model predictions with other models in the same class of universality. For instance, in a previous work we obtained a second order phase transition for the $PT$ symmetric and non-Hermitian $(-gφ^{4})$ and according to universality, this phase should exist in the phase structure of the ($gφ^{4}+hφ^{6}$) model for negative $g$. Finally, among the novelties in this letter, in our calculation for the effective potential, we introduced a new renormalization group equation which describes the invariance of the bare vacuum energy under the change of the scale. We showed that without this invariance, the original theory and the effective one are inequivalent.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2007; v1 submitted 13 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
-
Non-perturbative calculations for the effective potential of the $PT$ symmetric and non-Hermitian $(-gφ^{4})$ field theoretic model
Authors:
Abouzeid M. Shalaby
Abstract:
We investigate the effective potential of the $PT$ symmetric $(-gφ^{4}) $ field theory, perturbatively as well as non-perturbatively. For the perturbative calculations, we first use normal ordering to obtain the first order effective potential from which the predicted vacuum condensate vanishes exponentially as $G\to G^+$ in agreement with previous calculations. For the higher orders, we employe…
▽ More
We investigate the effective potential of the $PT$ symmetric $(-gφ^{4}) $ field theory, perturbatively as well as non-perturbatively. For the perturbative calculations, we first use normal ordering to obtain the first order effective potential from which the predicted vacuum condensate vanishes exponentially as $G\to G^+$ in agreement with previous calculations. For the higher orders, we employed the invariance of the bare parameters under the change of the mass scale $t$ to fix the transformed form totally equivalent to the original theory. The form so obtained up to $G^3$ is new and shows that all the 1PI amplitudes are perurbative for both $G\ll 1$ and $G\gg 1$ regions. For the intermediate region, we modified the fractal self-similar resummation method to have a unique resummation formula for all $G$ values. This unique formula is necessary because the effective potential is the generating functional for all the 1PI amplitudes which can be obtained via $\partial^n E/\partial b^n$ and thus we can obtain an analytic calculation for the 1PI amplitudes. Again, the resummed from of the effective potential is new and interpolates the effective potential between the perturbative regions. Moreover, the resummed effective potential agrees in spirit of previous calculation concerning bound states.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.