Empirical Evaluation of Project Scheduling Algorithms for Maximization of the Net Present Value
Authors:
Isac M. Lacerda,
Eber A. Schmitz,
Jayme L. Szwarcfiter,
Rosiane de Freitas
Abstract:
This paper presents an empirical performance analysis of three project scheduling algorithms dealing with maximizing projects' net present value with unrestricted resources. The selected algorithms, being the most recently cited in the literature, are: Recursive Search (RS), Steepest Ascent Approach (SAA) and Hybrid Search (HS). The main motivation for this research is the lack of knowledge about…
▽ More
This paper presents an empirical performance analysis of three project scheduling algorithms dealing with maximizing projects' net present value with unrestricted resources. The selected algorithms, being the most recently cited in the literature, are: Recursive Search (RS), Steepest Ascent Approach (SAA) and Hybrid Search (HS). The main motivation for this research is the lack of knowledge about the computational complexities of the RS, SAA, and HS algorithms, since all studies to date show some gaps in the analysis. Furthermore, the empirical analysis performed to date does not consider the fact that one algorithm (HS) uses a dual search strategy, which markedly improved the algorithm's performance, while the others don't. In order to obtain a fair performance comparison, we implemented the dual search strategy into the other two algorithms (RS and SAA), and the new algorithms were called Recursive Search Forward-Backward (RSFB) and Steepest Ascent Approach Forward-Backward (SAAFB). The algorithms RSFB, SAAFB, and HS were submitted to a factorial experiment with three different project network sampling characteristics. The results were analyzed using the Generalized Linear Models (GLM) statistical modeling technique that showed: a) the general computational costs of RSFB, SAAFB, and HS; b) the costs of restarting the search in the spanning tree as part of the total cost of the algorithms; c) and statistically significant differences between the distributions of the algorithms' results.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
On simulating nondeterministic stochastic activity networks
Authors:
Valmir C. Barbosa,
Fernando M. L. Ferreira,
Daniel V. Kling,
Eduardo Lopes,
Fabio Protti,
Eber A. Schmitz
Abstract:
In this work we deal with a mechanism for process simulation called a NonDeterministic Stochastic Activity Network (NDSAN). An NDSAN consists basically of a set of activities along with precedence relations involving these activities, which determine their order of execution. Activity durations are stochastic, given by continuous, nonnegative random variables. The nondeterministic behavior of an…
▽ More
In this work we deal with a mechanism for process simulation called a NonDeterministic Stochastic Activity Network (NDSAN). An NDSAN consists basically of a set of activities along with precedence relations involving these activities, which determine their order of execution. Activity durations are stochastic, given by continuous, nonnegative random variables. The nondeterministic behavior of an NDSAN is based on two additional possibilities: (i) by associating choice probabilities with groups of activities, some branches of execution may not be taken; (ii) by allowing iterated executions of groups of activities according to predetermined probabilities, the number of times an activity must be executed is not determined a priori. These properties lead to a rich variety of activity networks, capable of modeling many real situations in process engineering, project design, and troubleshooting. We describe a recursive simulation algorithm for NDSANs, whose repeated execution produces a close approximation to the probability distribution of the completion time of the entire network. We also report on real-world case studies.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2007; v1 submitted 28 December, 2006;
originally announced December 2006.
