Showing 1–16 of 16 results for author: Scheibner, C

Odd elasticity in driven granular matter

Authors: Rosalind Huang, Rituparno Mandal, Colin Scheibner, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Odd elasticity describes the unusual elastic response of solids whose stress-strain relationship is not compatible with an elastic potential. Here, we present a study of odd elasticity in a driven granular matter system composed of grains with ratchet-like interparticle friction and activated by oscillatory shear. We find that the system permits a time-averaged elasticity theory featuring nonzero… ▽ More Odd elasticity describes the unusual elastic response of solids whose stress-strain relationship is not compatible with an elastic potential. Here, we present a study of odd elasticity in a driven granular matter system composed of grains with ratchet-like interparticle friction and activated by oscillatory shear. We find that the system permits a time-averaged elasticity theory featuring nonzero odd elastic coefficients. These coefficients are explicitly measured using molecular dynamics simulations and can be predicted and tuned from microscopics. In the presence of disorder, our driven granular material displays distinctive properties ranging from self-healing grain boundaries in polycrystalline systems to chiral plastic vortices and force chain deflection in amorphous packings. Beyond granular matter, our work motivates the search for microscopic transduction mechanisms that convert periodic nonuniform drive into uniform elastic properties of active solids. △ Less

Submitted 30 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: See supplementary movies at https://home.uchicago.edu/~vitelli/videos.html

Universal wrinkling of freestanding atomically thin films

Authors: Jaehyung Yu, Colin Scheibner, Ce Liang, Thomas A. Witten, Vincenzo Vitelli, Jiwoong Park

Abstract: Atomically thin films, like transition metal dichalcogenides, can now be synthesized at wafer scale, achieving the same extreme aspect ratio (~10^8) that a sheet of paper would have if it covered an entire city. Yet, the intrinsic (i.e. unconfined) three-dimensional shape of these extreme membranes remains a mystery because of the very fundamentals of mechanical measurements: to measure such an ul… ▽ More Atomically thin films, like transition metal dichalcogenides, can now be synthesized at wafer scale, achieving the same extreme aspect ratio (~10^8) that a sheet of paper would have if it covered an entire city. Yet, the intrinsic (i.e. unconfined) three-dimensional shape of these extreme membranes remains a mystery because of the very fundamentals of mechanical measurements: to measure such an ultra-thin film, one first needs to simultaneously free it and stabilize it without introducing confining boundaries. Here, we introduce a counter-intuitive solution to this problem: place atomically thin films on water. Using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and Raman spectroscopy adapted to water's surface, we reveal that large-scale freestanding membranes spontaneously self-wrinkle into a universal mechanical state with long emergent length scales that follow robust scaling trends. Our analytical and numerical models suggest that these universal trends are controlled by mesoscopic parameters of the polycrystalline domains instead of atomistic details. Moreover, we demonstrate experimentally that the wrinkles result in a large and tunable reduction of elastic stiffness by up to 2 orders of magnitude. The present work illuminates the physical properties of the world's thinnest materials at length scales never probed before and highlights their potential for tunable strain-controlled nanomechanical devices. △ Less

Submitted 8 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: Includes main text with 4 figures and supplementary text with 10 supplementary figures

Trading particle shape with fluid symmetry: on the mobility matrix in 3D chiral fluids

Authors: Tali Khain, Michel Fruchart, Colin Scheibner, Thomas A. Witten, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Chiral fluids - such as fluids under rotation or a magnetic field as well as synthetic and biological active fluids - flow in a different way than ordinary ones. Due to symmetries broken at the microscopic level, chiral fluids may have asymmetric stress and viscosity tensors, for example giving rise to a hydrostatic torque or non-dissipative (odd) and parity-violating viscosities. In this article,… ▽ More Chiral fluids - such as fluids under rotation or a magnetic field as well as synthetic and biological active fluids - flow in a different way than ordinary ones. Due to symmetries broken at the microscopic level, chiral fluids may have asymmetric stress and viscosity tensors, for example giving rise to a hydrostatic torque or non-dissipative (odd) and parity-violating viscosities. In this article, we investigate the motion of rigid bodies in such an anisotropic fluid in the incompressible Stokes regime through the mobility matrix, which encodes the response of a solid body to forces and torques. We demonstrate how the form of the mobility matrix, which is usually determined by particle geometry, can be analogously controlled by the symmetries of the fluid. By computing the mobility matrix for simple shapes in a three-dimensional anisotropic chiral fluid, we predict counter-intuitive phenomena such as motion perpendicular to applied forces and spinning under the force of gravity. △ Less

Submitted 30 August, 2024; v1 submitted 26 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 33 pages, 8 figures

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 992 (2024)

Spiking at the edge

Authors: Colin Scheibner, Hillel Ori, Adam E. Cohen, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Excitable media, ranging from bioelectric tissues and chemical oscillators to forest fires and competing populations, are nonlinear, spatially extended systems capable of spiking. Most investigations of excitable media consider situations where the amplifying and suppressing forces necessary for spiking coexist at every point in space. In this case, spiking requires a fine-tuned ratio between loca… ▽ More Excitable media, ranging from bioelectric tissues and chemical oscillators to forest fires and competing populations, are nonlinear, spatially extended systems capable of spiking. Most investigations of excitable media consider situations where the amplifying and suppressing forces necessary for spiking coexist at every point in space. In this case, spiking requires a fine-tuned ratio between local amplification and suppression strengths. But, in Nature and engineered systems, these forces can be segregated in space, forming structures like interfaces and boundaries. Here, we show how boundaries can generate and protect spiking if the reacting components can spread out: even arbitrarily weak diffusion can cause spiking at the edge between two non-excitable media. This edge spiking is a robust phenomenon that can occur even if the ratio between amplification and suppression does not allow spiking when the two sides are homogeneously mixed. We analytically derive a spiking phase diagram that depends on two parameters: (i) the ratio between the system size and the characteristic diffusive length-scale, and (ii) the ratio between the amplification and suppression strengths. Our analysis explains recent experimental observations of action potentials at the interface between two non-excitable bioelectric tissues. Beyond electrophysiology, we highlight how edge spiking emerges in predator-prey dynamics and in oscillating chemical reactions. Our findings provide a theoretical blueprint for a class of interfacial excitations in reaction-diffusion systems, with potential implications for spatially controlled chemical reactions, nonlinear waveguides and neuromorphic computation, as well as spiking instabilities, such as cardiac arrhythmias, that naturally occur in heterogeneous biological media. △ Less

Submitted 14 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Comments: 31 pages. 15 figures. Supplemental videos available at: https://home.uchicago.edu/~vitelli/videos.html

Odd elasticity and topological waves in active surfaces

Authors: Michele Fossati, Colin Scheibner, Michel Fruchart, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Odd elasticity encompasses active elastic systems whose stress-strain relationship is not compatible with a potential energy. As the requirement of energy conservation is lifted from linear elasticity, new anti-symmetric (odd) components appear in the elastic tensor. In this work, we study the odd elasticity and non-Hermitian wave dynamics of active surfaces, specifically plates of moderate thickn… ▽ More Odd elasticity encompasses active elastic systems whose stress-strain relationship is not compatible with a potential energy. As the requirement of energy conservation is lifted from linear elasticity, new anti-symmetric (odd) components appear in the elastic tensor. In this work, we study the odd elasticity and non-Hermitian wave dynamics of active surfaces, specifically plates of moderate thickness. We find that a free-standing moderately thick, isotropic plate can exhibit two odd-elastic moduli, both of which are related to shear deformations of the plate. These odd moduli can endow the vibrational modes of the plate with a nonzero topological invariant known as the first Chern number. Within continuum elastic theory, we show that the Chern number is related to the presence of unidirectional shearing waves that are hosted at the plate's boundary. We show that the existence of these chiral edge waves hinges on a distinctive two-step mechanism: the finite thickness of the sample gaps the shear modes and the odd elasticity endows them with chirality. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 13 pages, 6 figures

Odd Viscosity and Odd Elasticity

Authors: Michel Fruchart, Colin Scheibner, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Elasticity typically refers to a material's ability to store energy, while viscosity refers to a material's tendency to dissipate it. In this review, we discuss fluids and solids for which this is not the case. These materials display additional linear response coefficients known as odd viscosity and odd elasticity. We first introduce odd elasticity and odd viscosity from a continuum perspective,… ▽ More Elasticity typically refers to a material's ability to store energy, while viscosity refers to a material's tendency to dissipate it. In this review, we discuss fluids and solids for which this is not the case. These materials display additional linear response coefficients known as odd viscosity and odd elasticity. We first introduce odd elasticity and odd viscosity from a continuum perspective, with an emphasis on their rich phenomenology, including transverse responses, modified dislocation dynamics, and topological waves. We then provide an overview of systems that display odd viscosity and odd elasticity. These systems range from quantum fluids, to astrophysical gasses, to active and driven matter. Finally, we comment on microscopic mechanisms by which odd elasticity and odd viscosity arise. △ Less

Submitted 30 June, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: 30 pages, 7 figures

Soft Metamaterials: Adaptation and Intelligence

Authors: Colin Scheibner, Michel Fruchart, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: We provide a perspective on soft metamaterials and biomatter with a special emphasis on future research directions at the interface between material intelligence and adaptation. We provide a perspective on soft metamaterials and biomatter with a special emphasis on future research directions at the interface between material intelligence and adaptation. △ Less

Submitted 3 May, 2022; originally announced May 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures

The odd ideal gas: Hall viscosity and thermal conductivity from non-Hermitian kinetic theory

Authors: Michel Fruchart, Ming Han, Colin Scheibner, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: The flow of momentum and energy in a fluid is typically associated with dissipative transport coefficients: viscosity and thermal conductivity. Fluids that break certain symmetries such as mirror symmetry and time-reversal invariance can display non-dissipative transport coefficients called odd (or Hall) viscosities and thermal conductivities. The goal of this paper is to elucidate the microscopic… ▽ More The flow of momentum and energy in a fluid is typically associated with dissipative transport coefficients: viscosity and thermal conductivity. Fluids that break certain symmetries such as mirror symmetry and time-reversal invariance can display non-dissipative transport coefficients called odd (or Hall) viscosities and thermal conductivities. The goal of this paper is to elucidate the microscopic origin of these dissipationless transport coefficients using kinetic theory. We show that odd viscosity and odd thermal conductivity arise when the linearized collision operator is not Hermitian. This symmetry breaking occurs when collisions are chiral, i.e. not mirror symmetric. To capture this feature in a minimalistic way, we introduce a modified relaxation time approximation in which the distribution function is rotated by an angle characterizing the average chirality of the collisions. In the limit of an infinitesimal rotation, the effect of the parity-violating collisions can be described as an emergent effective magnetic field. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 5 pages, 3 figures + SI

Limit cycles turn active matter into robots

Authors: Martin Brandenbourger, Colin Scheibner, Jonas Veenstra, Vincenzo Vitelli, Corentin Coulais

Abstract: Active matter composed of energy-generating microscopic constituents is a promising platform to create autonomous functional materials. However, the very presence of these microscopic energy sources is what makes active matter prone to dynamical instabilities and hence hard to control. Here, we show that these instabilities can be coaxed into work-generating limit cycles that turn active matter in… ▽ More Active matter composed of energy-generating microscopic constituents is a promising platform to create autonomous functional materials. However, the very presence of these microscopic energy sources is what makes active matter prone to dynamical instabilities and hence hard to control. Here, we show that these instabilities can be coaxed into work-generating limit cycles that turn active matter into robots. We illustrate this general principle in odd active media, model systems whose interaction forces are as simple as textbook molecular bonds yet not constrained to be the gradient of a potential. These emergent robotic functionalities are demonstrated by revisiting what is arguably the oldest of inventions: the wheel. Unlike common wheels that are driven by external torques, an odd wheel undergoes work-generating limit cycles that allow it to roll autonomously uphill by virtue of its own deformation, as demonstrated by our prototypes. Similarly, familiar scattering phenomena, like a ball bouncing off a wall, turn into basic robotic manipulations when either the ball or the wall is odd. Using continuum mechanics, we reveal collective robotic mechanisms that steer the outcome of collisions or influence the absorption of impacts in experiments. Beyond robotics, work-generating limit cycles can also control the non-linear dynamics of active soft materials, biological systems and driven nanomechanical devices. △ Less

Submitted 11 June, 2022; v1 submitted 19 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 4 Figures, Methods and SI. Supplemental videos at https://home.uchicago.edu/~vitelli/videos.html

Topological defects in solids with odd elasticity

Authors: Lara Braverman, Colin Scheibner, Bryan VanSaders, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Crystallography typically studies collections of point particles whose interaction forces are the gradient of a potential. Lifting this assumption generically gives rise in the continuum limit to a form of elasticity with additional moduli known as odd elasticity. We show that such odd elastic moduli modify the strain induced by topological defects and their interactions, even reversing the stabil… ▽ More Crystallography typically studies collections of point particles whose interaction forces are the gradient of a potential. Lifting this assumption generically gives rise in the continuum limit to a form of elasticity with additional moduli known as odd elasticity. We show that such odd elastic moduli modify the strain induced by topological defects and their interactions, even reversing the stability of, otherwise, bound dislocation pairs. Beyond continuum theory, isolated dislocations can self propel via microscopic work cycles active at their cores that compete with conventional Peach-Koehler forces caused, for example, by an ambient torque density. We perform molecular dynamics simulations isolating active plastic processes and discuss their experimental relevance to solids composed of spinning particles, vortex-like objects, and robotic metamaterials. △ Less

Submitted 29 December, 2021; v1 submitted 23 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 34 pages and 13 figures with Supplementary Information; Updated Journal Reference

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett., Vol. 127, Iss. 26-24, 20 Dec 2021

Stokes flows in three-dimensional fluids with odd and parity-violating viscosities

Authors: Tali Khain, Colin Scheibner, Michel Fruchart, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: The Stokes equation describes the motion of fluids when inertial forces are negligible compared to viscous forces. In this article, we explore the consequence of parity-violating and non-dissipative (i.e. odd) viscosities on Stokes flows in three dimensions. Parity-violating viscosities are coefficients of the viscosity tensor that are not invariant under mirror reflections of space, while odd vis… ▽ More The Stokes equation describes the motion of fluids when inertial forces are negligible compared to viscous forces. In this article, we explore the consequence of parity-violating and non-dissipative (i.e. odd) viscosities on Stokes flows in three dimensions. Parity-violating viscosities are coefficients of the viscosity tensor that are not invariant under mirror reflections of space, while odd viscosities are those which do not contribute to dissipation of mechanical energy. These viscosities can occur in systems ranging from synthetic and biological active fluids to magnetised and rotating fluids. We first systematically enumerate all possible parity-violating viscosities compatible with cylindrical symmetry, highlighting their connection to potential microscopic realizations. Then, using a combination of analytical and numerical methods, we analyze the effects of parity-violating viscosities on the Stokeslet solution, on the flow past a sphere or a bubble, and on many-particle sedimentation. In all the cases we analyze, parity-violating viscosities give rise to an azimuthal flow even when the driving force is parallel to the axis of cylindrical symmetry. For a few sedimenting particles, the azimuthal flow bends the trajectories compared to a traditional Stokes flow. For a cloud of particles, the azimuthal flow impedes the transformation of the spherical cloud into a torus and the subsequent breakup into smaller parts that would otherwise occur. The presence of azimuthal flows in cylindrically symmetric systems (sphere, bubble, cloud of particles) can serve as a probe for parity-violating viscosities in experimental systems. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2022; v1 submitted 15 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 39 pages, 12 figures. Supplementary movies at https://home.uchicago.edu/~vitelli/videos.html

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics 934, (2022)

Realization of active metamaterials with odd micropolar elasticity

Authors: Yangyang Chen, Xiaopeng Li, Colin Scheibner, Vincenzo Vitelli, Guoliang Huang

Abstract: Materials made from active, living, or robotic components can display emergent properties arising from local sensing and computation. Here, we realize a freestanding active metabeam with piezoelectric elements and electronic feed-forward control that gives rise to an odd micropolar elasticity absent in energy-conserving media. The non-reciprocal odd modulus enables bending and shearing cycles that… ▽ More Materials made from active, living, or robotic components can display emergent properties arising from local sensing and computation. Here, we realize a freestanding active metabeam with piezoelectric elements and electronic feed-forward control that gives rise to an odd micropolar elasticity absent in energy-conserving media. The non-reciprocal odd modulus enables bending and shearing cycles that convert electrical energy into mechanical work, and vice versa. The sign of this elastic modulus is linked to a non-Hermitian topological index that determines the localization of vibrational modes to sample boundaries. At finite frequency, we can also tune the phase angle of the active modulus to produce a direction-dependent bending modulus and control non-Hermitian vibrational properties. Our continuum approach, built on symmetries and conservation laws, could be exploited to design others systems such as synthetic biofilaments and membranes with feed-forward control loops. △ Less

Submitted 18 June, 2021; v1 submitted 15 September, 2020; originally announced September 2020.

Comments: Main text, 6 figures, methods, and supplementary information

Journal ref: Nat Commun 12, 5935 (2021)

Statistical mechanics of a chiral active fluid

Authors: Ming Han, Michel Fruchart, Colin Scheibner, Suriyanarayanan Vaikuntanathan, William Irvine, Juan de Pablo, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Statistical mechanics provides the foundation for describing complex materials using only a few thermodynamic variables. No such framework currently exists far from equilibrium. In this Letter, we demonstrate how thermodynamics emerges far from equilibrium, using fluids composed of active spinners as a case study. Activity gives rise to a single effective temperature that parameterizes both the eq… ▽ More Statistical mechanics provides the foundation for describing complex materials using only a few thermodynamic variables. No such framework currently exists far from equilibrium. In this Letter, we demonstrate how thermodynamics emerges far from equilibrium, using fluids composed of active spinners as a case study. Activity gives rise to a single effective temperature that parameterizes both the equation of state and the emergent Boltzmann statistics. The same effective temperature, renormalized by velocity correlations, controls the linear response through canonical Green-Kubo relations for both the familiar shear viscosity and the odd (or Hall) viscosity observed in chiral fluids. The full frequency dependence of these viscosities can be derived analytically by modeling the active-spinner fluid as a random walker undergoing cyclotron motion in shear-stress space. More generally, we provide a first-principles derivation of the Green-Kubo relations valid for a broader class of fluids far from equilibrium. Besides advancing non-equilibrium thermodynamics, our work demonstrates in silico a non-invasive microrheology of active fluids. △ Less

Submitted 19 February, 2020; v1 submitted 18 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: Supplementary movies at https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnzJw7B7T8cKLck3wSoMRJVTSFSdrExeh

Non-Hermitian band topology and skin modes in active elastic media

Authors: Colin Scheibner, William T. M. Irvine, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Solids built out of active components can exhibit non-reciprocal elastic coefficients that give rise to non-Hermitian wave phenomena. Here, we investigate non-Hermitian effects present at the boundary of two-dimensional active elastic media obeying two general assumptions: their microscopic forces conserve linear momentum and arise only from static deformations. Using continuum equations, we demon… ▽ More Solids built out of active components can exhibit non-reciprocal elastic coefficients that give rise to non-Hermitian wave phenomena. Here, we investigate non-Hermitian effects present at the boundary of two-dimensional active elastic media obeying two general assumptions: their microscopic forces conserve linear momentum and arise only from static deformations. Using continuum equations, we demonstrate the existence of the non-Hermitian skin effect in which the boundary hosts an extensive number of localized modes. Furthermore, lattice models reveal non-Hermitian topological transitions mediated by exceptional rings driven by the activity level of individual bonds. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2020; v1 submitted 14 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: Three figures with supplementary information

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 118001 (2020)

Odd elasticity

Authors: Colin Scheibner, Anton Souslov, Debarghya Banerjee, Piotr Surowka, William T. M. Irvine, Vincenzo Vitelli

Abstract: Hooke's law states that the forces or stresses experienced by an elastic object are proportional to the applied deformations or strains. The number of coefficients of proportionality between stress and strain, i.e., the elastic moduli, is constrained by energy conservation. In this Letter, we lift this restriction and generalize linear elasticity to active media with non-conservative microscopic i… ▽ More Hooke's law states that the forces or stresses experienced by an elastic object are proportional to the applied deformations or strains. The number of coefficients of proportionality between stress and strain, i.e., the elastic moduli, is constrained by energy conservation. In this Letter, we lift this restriction and generalize linear elasticity to active media with non-conservative microscopic interactions that violate mechanical reciprocity. This generalized framework, which we dub odd elasticity, reveals that two additional moduli can exist in a two-dimensional isotropic solid with active bonds. Such an odd-elastic solid can be regarded as a distributed engine: work is locally extracted, or injected, during quasi-static cycles of deformation. Using continuum equations, coarse-grained microscopic models, and numerical simulations, we uncover phenomena ranging from activity-induced auxetic behavior to wave propagation powered by self-sustained active elastic cycles. Besides providing insights beyond existing hydrodynamic theories of active solids, odd elasticity suggests design principles for emergent autonomous materials. △ Less

Submitted 20 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 15 pages including Supplementary Information, 5 figures. See https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnzJw7B7T8cIc1EjLVq3AU_hOe1PEAdt9 for Supplementary Movies

Journal ref: Nature Physics 16, 475-480(2020)

Discovery and Physical Characterization of a Large Scattered Disk Object at 92 AU

Authors: David Gerdes, Masao Sako, Stephanie Hamilton, Ke Zhang, Tali Khain, Juliette Becker, James Annis, William Wester, Gary Bernstein, Colin Scheibner, Lynus Zullo, Fred Adams, Edwin Bergin, Alistair Walker, J. H. Mueller, T. Abbott, Filipe Abdalla, Sahar Allam, K. Bechtol, Aurelien Benoit-Lévy, Emmanuel Bertin, David Brooks, David Burke, A. Rosell, M. Kind , et al. (43 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We report the observation and physical characterization of the possible dwarf planet \UZ\ ("DeeDee"), a dynamically detached trans-Neptunian object discovered at 92 AU. This object is currently the second-most distant known trans-Neptunian object with reported orbital elements, surpassed in distance only by the dwarf planet Eris. The object was discovered with an $r$-band magnitude of 23.0 in data… ▽ More We report the observation and physical characterization of the possible dwarf planet \UZ\ ("DeeDee"), a dynamically detached trans-Neptunian object discovered at 92 AU. This object is currently the second-most distant known trans-Neptunian object with reported orbital elements, surpassed in distance only by the dwarf planet Eris. The object was discovered with an $r$-band magnitude of 23.0 in data collected by the Dark Energy Survey between 2014 and 2016. Its 1140-year orbit has $(a,e,i) = (109~\mathrm{AU}, 0.65, 26.8^{\circ})$. It will reach its perihelion distance of 38 AU in the year 2142. Integrations of its orbit show it to be dynamically stable on Gyr timescales, with only weak interactions with Neptune. We have performed followup observations with ALMA, using 3 hours of on-source integration time to measure the object's thermal emission in the Rayleigh-Jeans tail. The signal is detected at 7$σ$ significance, from which we determine a $V$-band albedo of $13.1^{+3.3}_{-2.4}\mathrm{(stat)}^{+2.0}_{-1.4}\mathrm{(sys)}$ percent and a diameter of $635^{+57}_{-61}\mathrm{(stat)}^{+32}_{-39}\mathrm{(sys)}$~km, assuming a spherical body with uniform surface properties. △ Less

Submitted 4 March, 2017; v1 submitted 2 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 13 pages, 4 figures, accepted by ApJ Letters

Report number: Fermilab-PUB-17-027-AE