Showing 1–35 of 35 results for author: Schatz, M F

Hysteresis and ribbons in Taylor-Couette flow of a semidilute non-colloidal suspension

Authors: Changwoo Kang, Michael F. Schatz, Parisa Mirbod

Abstract: In this study, we numerically investigate hysteretic behaviors of secondary bifurcations in the Taylor-Couette flow of a semidilute, neutrally buoyant, and noncolloidal suspension. We consider a suspension with a bulk particle volume fraction of 0.1, a radius ratio of 0.877, and a particle size of 60. The suspension balance model (SBM) is introduced for numerical simulations to model the dynamics… ▽ More In this study, we numerically investigate hysteretic behaviors of secondary bifurcations in the Taylor-Couette flow of a semidilute, neutrally buoyant, and noncolloidal suspension. We consider a suspension with a bulk particle volume fraction of 0.1, a radius ratio of 0.877, and a particle size of 60. The suspension balance model (SBM) is introduced for numerical simulations to model the dynamics of particles undergoing shear-induced particle migration with rheological constitutive laws. The suspension flow transitions from circular Couette flow (CCF) via ribbons (RIB), spiral vortex flow (SVF), and wavy spiral vortex flow (WSVF) to wavy vortex flow (WVF) with the increase of suspension Reynolds number. The primary transition arises very slowly with an oscillatory critical mode and appears through a supercritical (or non-hysteretic) bifurcation. However, we find hysteretic behaviors in subsequent bifurcations (spiral vortex flow (SVF) to wavy spiral vortex flow (WSVF) and WSVF to wavy vortex flow (WVF)) during increasing-Re and decreasing-Re procedures with a rapid-step change near the transition boundaries. The WSVF and WVF states are more sustained below the transition boundaries when the Reynolds number is rapidly decreased in stages. However, the SVF and WSVF become WSVF and WVF more sharply with increasing Re, respectively. To conclude this study, we also examine in detail, a standing wave of weak counter-rotating vortices that occurs as the primary instability and analyze the wave that oscillates in time but is stationary in space in the RIB state. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Observing a Dynamical Skeleton of Turbulence in Taylor-Couette Flow Experiments

Authors: Christopher J. Crowley, Joshua L. Pughe-Sanford, Wesley Toler, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Recent work suggests unstable recurrent solutions of the equations governing fluid flow can play an important role in structuring the dynamics of turbulence. Here we present a method for detecting intervals of time where turbulence "shadows" (spatially and temporally mimics) recurrent solutions. We find that shadowing occurs frequently and repeatedly in both numerical and experimental observations… ▽ More Recent work suggests unstable recurrent solutions of the equations governing fluid flow can play an important role in structuring the dynamics of turbulence. Here we present a method for detecting intervals of time where turbulence "shadows" (spatially and temporally mimics) recurrent solutions. We find that shadowing occurs frequently and repeatedly in both numerical and experimental observations of counter-rotating Taylor-Couette flow, despite the relatively small number of known recurrent solutions in this system. Our results set the stage for experimentally-grounded dynamical descriptions of turbulence in a variety of wall-bounded shear flows, enabling applications to forecasting and control. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2022; v1 submitted 21 August, 2022; originally announced August 2022.

Data-driven detection of drifting system parameters

Authors: Logan M. Kageorge, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Data taken from observations of the natural world or laboratory measurements often depend on parameters which can vary in unexpected ways. In this paper we demonstrate how machine learning can be leveraged to detect changes in global parameters from variations in an identified model using only observational data. This capability, when paired with first principles analysis, can effectively distingu… ▽ More Data taken from observations of the natural world or laboratory measurements often depend on parameters which can vary in unexpected ways. In this paper we demonstrate how machine learning can be leveraged to detect changes in global parameters from variations in an identified model using only observational data. This capability, when paired with first principles analysis, can effectively distinguish the effects of these changing parameters from the intrinsic complexity of the system. Here we illustrate this by identifying a set of governing equations for an experiment generating a weakly turbulent fluid flow, then analyzing variation in the coefficients of these equations to unravel the drift in its physical parameters. △ Less

Submitted 23 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures, as reported at the 74th Annual Meeting of the American Physical Society's Division of Fluid Dynamics

Transforming the Preparation of Physics GTAs: Curriculum Development

Authors: Emily Alicea-Muñoz, Carol Subiño Sullivan, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) are key partners in the education of undergraduates. Given the potentially large impact GTAs can have on undergraduate student learning, it is important to provide them with appropriate preparation for teaching. But GTAs are students themselves, and not all of them desire to pursue an academic career. Fully integrating GTA preparation into the professional devel… ▽ More Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) are key partners in the education of undergraduates. Given the potentially large impact GTAs can have on undergraduate student learning, it is important to provide them with appropriate preparation for teaching. But GTAs are students themselves, and not all of them desire to pursue an academic career. Fully integrating GTA preparation into the professional development of graduate students lowers the barrier to engagement so that all graduate students may benefit from the opportunity to explore teaching and its applications to many potential career paths. In this paper we describe the design and implementation of a GTA Preparation course for first-year Ph.D. students at the Georgia Tech School of Physics. Through a yearly cycle of implementation and revision, guided by the 3P Framework we developed (Pedagogy, Physics, Professional Development), the course has evolved into a robust and comprehensive professional development program that is well-received by physics graduate students. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: Accepted in Physical Review Physics Education Research

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Phys. Educ. Res. 17, 020125 (2021)

Robust learning from noisy, incomplete, high-dimensional experimental data via physically constrained symbolic regression

Authors: Patrick A. K. Reinbold, Logan M. Kageorge, Michael F. Schatz, Roman O. Grigoriev

Abstract: Machine learning offers an intriguing alternative to first-principles analysis for discovering new physics from experimental data. However, to date, purely data-driven methods have only proven successful in uncovering physical laws describing simple, low-dimensional systems with low levels of noise. Here we demonstrate that combining a data-driven methodology with some general physical principles… ▽ More Machine learning offers an intriguing alternative to first-principles analysis for discovering new physics from experimental data. However, to date, purely data-driven methods have only proven successful in uncovering physical laws describing simple, low-dimensional systems with low levels of noise. Here we demonstrate that combining a data-driven methodology with some general physical principles enables discovery of a quantitatively accurate model of a non-equilibrium spatially-extended system from high-dimensional data that is both noisy and incomplete. We illustrate this using an experimental weakly turbulent fluid flow where only the velocity field is accessible. We also show that this hybrid approach allows reconstruction of the inaccessible variables -- the pressure and forcing field driving the flow. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: Under review at Nature Communications

Capturing Turbulent Dynamics and Statistics in Experiments with Unstable Periodic Orbits

Authors: Balachandra Suri, Logan Kageorge, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: In laboratory studies and numerical simulations, we observe clear signatures of unstable time-periodic solutions in a moderately turbulent quasi-two-dimensional flow. We validate the dynamical relevance of such solutions by demonstrating that turbulent flows in both experiment and numerics transiently display time-periodic dynamics when they shadow unstable periodic orbits (UPOs). We show that UPO… ▽ More In laboratory studies and numerical simulations, we observe clear signatures of unstable time-periodic solutions in a moderately turbulent quasi-two-dimensional flow. We validate the dynamical relevance of such solutions by demonstrating that turbulent flows in both experiment and numerics transiently display time-periodic dynamics when they shadow unstable periodic orbits (UPOs). We show that UPOs we computed are also statistically significant, with turbulent flows spending a sizable fraction of the total time near these solutions. As a result, the average rates of energy input and dissipation for the turbulent flow and frequently visited UPOs differ only by a few percent. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. Lett

A novel subcritical transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow with counter-rotating cylinders

Authors: Christopher J. Crowley, Michael C. Krygier, Daniel Borrero-Echeverry, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow often occurs via a sequence of supercritical bifurcations to progressively more complex, yet stable, flows. We describe a subcritical laminar-turbulent transition in the counter-rotating regime mediated by an unstable intermediate state in a system with an axial aspect ratio of $Γ=5.26$ and a radius ratio of $η=0.905$. In this regime, flow visual… ▽ More The transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow often occurs via a sequence of supercritical bifurcations to progressively more complex, yet stable, flows. We describe a subcritical laminar-turbulent transition in the counter-rotating regime mediated by an unstable intermediate state in a system with an axial aspect ratio of $Γ=5.26$ and a radius ratio of $η=0.905$. In this regime, flow visualization experiments and numerical simulations indicate the intermediate state corresponds to an aperiodic flow featuring interpenetrating spirals. Furthermore, the reverse transition out of turbulence leads first to the same intermediate state, which is now stable, before returning to an azimuthally-symmetric laminar flow. Time-resolved tomographic particle image velocimetry is used to characterize the experimental flows; these measurements compare favorably to direct numerical simulations with axial boundary conditions matching those of the experiments. △ Less

Submitted 3 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Heteroclinic and Homoclinic Connections in a Kolmogorov-Like Flow

Authors: Balachandra Suri, Ravi Kumar Pallantla, Michael F. Schatz, Roman O. Grigoriev

Abstract: Recent studies suggest that unstable recurrent solutions of the Navier-Stokes equation provide new insights into dynamics of turbulent flows. In this study, we compute an extensive network of dynamical connections between such solutions in a weakly turbulent quasi-two-dimensional Kolmogorov flow that lies in the inversion-symmetric subspace. In particular, we find numerous isolated heteroclinic co… ▽ More Recent studies suggest that unstable recurrent solutions of the Navier-Stokes equation provide new insights into dynamics of turbulent flows. In this study, we compute an extensive network of dynamical connections between such solutions in a weakly turbulent quasi-two-dimensional Kolmogorov flow that lies in the inversion-symmetric subspace. In particular, we find numerous isolated heteroclinic connections between different types of solutions -- equilibria, periodic, and quasi-periodic orbits -- as well as continua of connections forming higher-dimensional connecting manifolds. We also compute a homoclinic connection of a periodic orbit and provide strong evidence that the associated homoclinic tangle forms the chaotic repeller that underpins transient turbulence in the symmetric subspace. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2020; v1 submitted 11 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: Supplemental Videos Showing Heteroclinic and Homoclinic Connections Are Available

Unstable Equilibria and Invariant Manifolds in Quasi-Two-Dimensional Kolmogorov-like Flow

Authors: Balachandra Suri, Jeffrey Tithof, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Recent studies suggest that unstable, non-chaotic solutions of the Navier-Stokes equation may provide deep insights into fluid turbulence. In this article, we present a combined experimental and numerical study exploring the dynamical role of unstable equilibrium solutions and their invariant manifolds in a weakly turbulent, electromagnetically driven, shallow fluid layer. Identifying instants whe… ▽ More Recent studies suggest that unstable, non-chaotic solutions of the Navier-Stokes equation may provide deep insights into fluid turbulence. In this article, we present a combined experimental and numerical study exploring the dynamical role of unstable equilibrium solutions and their invariant manifolds in a weakly turbulent, electromagnetically driven, shallow fluid layer. Identifying instants when turbulent evolution slows down, we compute 31 unstable equilibria of a realistic two-dimensional model of the flow. We establish the dynamical relevance of these unstable equilibria by showing that they are closely visited by the turbulent flow. We also establish the dynamical relevance of unstable manifolds by verifying that they are shadowed by turbulent trajectories departing from the neighborhoods of unstable equilibria over large distances in state space. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Assessing a GTA professional development program

Authors: Emily Alicea-Muñoz, Joan Espar Masip, Carol Subiño Sullivan, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: For the last four years, the School of Physics at Georgia Tech have been preparing new Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) through a program that integrates pedagogy, physics content, and professional development strategies. Here we discuss various assessments we have used to evaluate the program, among them surveys, GTA self-reporting, and end-of-semester student evaluations. Our results indicate… ▽ More For the last four years, the School of Physics at Georgia Tech have been preparing new Graduate Teaching Assistants (GTAs) through a program that integrates pedagogy, physics content, and professional development strategies. Here we discuss various assessments we have used to evaluate the program, among them surveys, GTA self-reporting, and end-of-semester student evaluations. Our results indicate that GTAs who participate in the program find its practical activities useful, feel better prepared for teaching, make use of learner-centered teaching strategies, and receive higher scores in teaching evaluations. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 4 pages, accepted to Physics Education Research Conference Proceedings (PERC 2017)

Forecasting Fluid Flows Using the Geometry of Turbulence

Authors: Balachandra Suri, Jeffrey Tithof, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The existence and dynamical role of particular unstable Navier-Stokes solutions (exact coherent structures) is revealed in laboratory studies of weak turbulence in a thin, electromagnetically-driven fluid layer. We find that the dynamics exhibit clear signatures of numerous unstable equilibrium solutions, which are computed using a combination of flow measurements from the experiment and fully-res… ▽ More The existence and dynamical role of particular unstable Navier-Stokes solutions (exact coherent structures) is revealed in laboratory studies of weak turbulence in a thin, electromagnetically-driven fluid layer. We find that the dynamics exhibit clear signatures of numerous unstable equilibrium solutions, which are computed using a combination of flow measurements from the experiment and fully-resolved numerical simulations. We demonstrate the dynamical importance of these solutions by showing that turbulent flows visit their state space neighborhoods repeatedly. Furthermore, we find that the unstable manifold associated with one such unstable equilibrium predicts the evolution of turbulent flow in both experiment and simulation for a considerable period of time. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2016; originally announced November 2016.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 114501 (2017)

Exploring University Students' Engagement with Online Video Lectures in a Blended Introductory Mechanics Course

Authors: Shih-Yin Lin, John M. Aiken, Daniel T. Seaton, Scott S. Douglas, Edwin F. Greco, Brian D. Thoms, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The advent of MOOCs has stimulated interest in using online videos to deliver content in university courses. We examined student engagement with 78 online videos that we created and were incorporated into a one-semester blended introductory mechanics course at the Georgia Institute of Technology. We found that students were more engaged with videos that supported laboratory activities than with vi… ▽ More The advent of MOOCs has stimulated interest in using online videos to deliver content in university courses. We examined student engagement with 78 online videos that we created and were incorporated into a one-semester blended introductory mechanics course at the Georgia Institute of Technology. We found that students were more engaged with videos that supported laboratory activities than with videos that presented lecture content. In particular, the percentage of students accessing laboratory videos was consistently greater than 80 percent throughout the semester while the percentage of students accessing lecture videos dropped to less than 40 percent by the end of the term. Moreover, students were more likely to access the entirety of a laboratory video than a lecture video. Our results suggest that students may access videos based on perceived value: students appear to consider the laboratory videos as essential for successfully completing the laboratories while students appear to consider the lecture videos as something more akin to supplementary material. We found there was little correlation between student engagement with the videos and the performance in the course. In addition, an examination of the in-video content suggests that students focus more on concrete information that is explicitly required for assignment completion (e.g., actions required to complete laboratory work, or formulas/mathematical expressions needed to solve particular problems) and less on content that is considered more conceptual in nature. The results of the study suggest ways in which instructors may revise courses to better support student learning. △ Less

Submitted 10 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Bifurcations in a Quasi-Two-Dimensional Kolmogorov-Like Flow

Authors: Jeffrey Tithof, Balachandra Suri, Ravi Kumar Pallantla, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of the primary and secondary instabilities in a Kolmogorov-like flow. The experiment uses electromagnetic forcing with an approximately sinusoidal spatial profile to drive a quasi-two-dimensional (Q2D) shear flow in a thin layer of electrolyte suspended on a thin lubricating layer of a dielectric fluid. Theoretical analysis is based on a 2D… ▽ More We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of the primary and secondary instabilities in a Kolmogorov-like flow. The experiment uses electromagnetic forcing with an approximately sinusoidal spatial profile to drive a quasi-two-dimensional (Q2D) shear flow in a thin layer of electrolyte suspended on a thin lubricating layer of a dielectric fluid. Theoretical analysis is based on a 2D model (Suri ${\it et al.}$ 2014), derived from first principles by depth-averaging the full three-dimensional Navier-Stokes equations. As the strength of the forcing is increased, the Q2D flow in the experiment undergoes a series of bifurcations, which is compared with results from direct numerical simulations of the 2D model. The effects of confinement and the forcing profile are studied by performing simulations that assume spatial periodicity and strictly sinusoidal forcing, as well as simulations with realistic no-slip boundary conditions and an experimentally validated forcing profile. We find that only the simulation subject to physical no-slip boundary conditions and a realistic forcing profile provides close, quantitative agreement with the experiment. Our analysis offers additional validation of the 2D model as well as a demonstration of the importance of properly modelling the forcing and boundary conditions. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2017; v1 submitted 2 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: 30 pages, 13 figures

Analysis of Kolmogorov Flow and Rayleigh-Bénard Convection using Persistent Homology

Authors: Miroslav Kramar, Rachel Levanger, Jeffrey Tithof, Balachandra Suri, Mu Xu, Mark Paul, Michael F. Schatz, Konstantin Mischaikow

Abstract: We use persistent homology to build a quantitative understanding of large complex systems that are driven far-from-equilibrium; in particular, we analyze image time series of flow field patterns from numerical simulations of two important problems in fluid dynamics: Kolmogorov flow and Rayleigh-Bénard convection. For each image we compute a persistence diagram to yield a reduced description of the… ▽ More We use persistent homology to build a quantitative understanding of large complex systems that are driven far-from-equilibrium; in particular, we analyze image time series of flow field patterns from numerical simulations of two important problems in fluid dynamics: Kolmogorov flow and Rayleigh-Bénard convection. For each image we compute a persistence diagram to yield a reduced description of the flow field; by applying different metrics to the space of persistence diagrams, we relate characteristic features in persistence diagrams to the geometry of the corresponding flow patterns. We also examine the dynamics of the flow patterns by a second application of persistent homology to the time series of persistence diagrams. We demonstrate that persistent homology provides an effective method both for quotienting out symmetries in families of solutions and for identifying multiscale recurrent dynamics. Our approach is quite general and it is anticipated to be applicable to a broad range of open problems exhibiting complex spatio-temporal behavior. △ Less

Submitted 22 May, 2015; originally announced May 2015.

Peer Evaluation of Video Lab Reports in an Introductory Physics MOOC

Authors: Shih-Yin Lin, Scott S. Douglas, John M. Aiken, Chien-Lin Liu, Edwin F. Greco, Brian D. Thoms, Marcos D. Caballero, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Assessing student performance becomes challenging when course enrollment becomes very large (~10^4 students). As part of a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) in introductory physics offered by Georgia Tech in 2013, students submitted video reports on mechanics labs. Peer evaluation of these reports provided the primary method for evaluating student laboratory work. This paper describes the methods… ▽ More Assessing student performance becomes challenging when course enrollment becomes very large (~10^4 students). As part of a Massive Open Online Course (MOOC) in introductory physics offered by Georgia Tech in 2013, students submitted video reports on mechanics labs. Peer evaluation of these reports provided the primary method for evaluating student laboratory work. This paper describes the methods developed and used to guide students in evaluating each other's video lab reports. We also discuss how students' peer evaluation behavior changed with different interventions provided in the course. △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2014; v1 submitted 17 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures, submitted to 2014 Physics Education Research Conference Proceeding

Peer Evaluation of Video Lab Reports in a Blended Introductory Physics Course

Authors: Scott S. Douglas, Shih-Yin Lin, John M. Aiken, Brian D. Thoms, Edwin F. Greco, Marcos D. Caballero, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The Georgia Tech blended introductory calculus-based mechanics course emphasizes scientific communication as one of its learning goals, and to that end, we gave our students a series of four peer-evaluation assignments intended to develop their abilities to present and evaluate scientific arguments. Within these assignments, we also assessed students' evaluation abilities by comparing their evalua… ▽ More The Georgia Tech blended introductory calculus-based mechanics course emphasizes scientific communication as one of its learning goals, and to that end, we gave our students a series of four peer-evaluation assignments intended to develop their abilities to present and evaluate scientific arguments. Within these assignments, we also assessed students' evaluation abilities by comparing their evaluations to a set of expert evaluations. We summarize our development efforts and describe the changes we observed in student evaluation behavior. △ Less

Submitted 14 October, 2014; v1 submitted 11 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 table, 2 figures, submitted to Summer 2014 PERC Proceedings

Student Use of a Single Lecture Video in a Flipped Introductory Mechanics Course

Authors: John M. Aiken, Shih-Yin Lin, Scott S. Douglas, Edwin F. Greco, Brian D. Thoms, Marcos D. Caballero, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: In the Fall of 2013, Georgia Tech offered a 'flipped' calculus-based introductory mechanics class as an alternative to the traditional large-enrollment lecture class. This class flipped instruction by introducing new material outside of the classroom through pre-recorded, lecture videos. Video lectures constituted students' initial introduction to course material. We analyze how students engaged w… ▽ More In the Fall of 2013, Georgia Tech offered a 'flipped' calculus-based introductory mechanics class as an alternative to the traditional large-enrollment lecture class. This class flipped instruction by introducing new material outside of the classroom through pre-recorded, lecture videos. Video lectures constituted students' initial introduction to course material. We analyze how students engaged with online lecture videos via 'clickstream' data, consisting of time-stamped interactions (plays, pauses, seeks, etc.) with the online video player. Analysis of these events has shown that students may be focusing on elements of the video that facilitate a 'correct' solution. △ Less

Submitted 22 September, 2014; v1 submitted 9 July, 2014; originally announced July 2014.

Comments: 4 pages, Physics Education Research Conference Proceedings 2014

Velocity Profile in a Two-Layer Kolmogorov-Like Flow

Authors: Balachandra Suri, Jeffrey Tithof, Radford Mitchell Jr, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: In this article we discuss flows in shallow, stratified horizontal layers of two immiscible fluids. The top layer is an electrolyte which is electromagnetically driven and the bottom layer is a dielectric fluid. Using a quasi-two-dimensional approximation, we derive the depth-averaged two-dimensional (2D) vorticity equation which includes a prefactor to the advection term, previously unaccounted f… ▽ More In this article we discuss flows in shallow, stratified horizontal layers of two immiscible fluids. The top layer is an electrolyte which is electromagnetically driven and the bottom layer is a dielectric fluid. Using a quasi-two-dimensional approximation, we derive the depth-averaged two-dimensional (2D) vorticity equation which includes a prefactor to the advection term, previously unaccounted for. In addition, we study how the horizontal components of velocity vary in the vertical direction. For a Kolmogorov-like flow, we evaluate analytical expressions for the coefficients in the generalized 2D vorticity equation, uncovering their dependence on experimental parameters. To test the accuracy of these estimates, we experimentally measure the horizontal velocity fields at the free-surface and at the electrolyte-dielectric interface using particle image velocimetry (PIV). We show that there is excellent agreement between the analytical predictions and the experimental measurements. Our analysis shows that by increasing the viscosity of the electrolyte relative to that of the dielectric, one may significantly improve the uniformity of the flow along the vertical direction. △ Less

Submitted 16 August, 2013; v1 submitted 23 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: 18 pages, 5 figures

The Initial State of Students Taking an Introductory Physics MOOC

Authors: John M. Aiken, Shih-Yin Lin, Scott S. Douglas, Edwin F. Greco, Brian D. Thoms, Michael F. Schatz, Marcos D. Caballero

Abstract: As part of a larger research project into massively open online courses (MOOCs), we have investigated student background, as well as student participation in a physics MOOC with a laboratory component. Students completed a demographic survey and the Force and Motion Conceptual Evaluation at the beginning of the course. While the course is still actively running, we have tracked student participati… ▽ More As part of a larger research project into massively open online courses (MOOCs), we have investigated student background, as well as student participation in a physics MOOC with a laboratory component. Students completed a demographic survey and the Force and Motion Conceptual Evaluation at the beginning of the course. While the course is still actively running, we have tracked student participation over the first five weeks of the eleven-week course. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2013; v1 submitted 9 July, 2013; originally announced July 2013.

Comments: Accepted to PERC Proceedings 2013

Understanding Student Computational Thinking with Computational Modeling

Authors: John M. Aiken, Marcos D. Caballero, Scott S. Douglas, John B. Burk, Erin M. Scanlon, Brian D. Thoms, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Recently, the National Research Council's framework for next generation science standards highlighted "computational thinking" as one of its "fundamental practices". 9th Grade students taking a physics course that employed the Modeling Instruction curriculum were taught to construct computational models of physical systems. Student computational thinking was assessed using a proctored programming… ▽ More Recently, the National Research Council's framework for next generation science standards highlighted "computational thinking" as one of its "fundamental practices". 9th Grade students taking a physics course that employed the Modeling Instruction curriculum were taught to construct computational models of physical systems. Student computational thinking was assessed using a proctored programming assignment, written essay, and a series of think-aloud interviews, where the students produced and discussed a computational model of a baseball in motion via a high-level programming environment (VPython). Roughly a third of the students in the study were successful in completing the programming assignment. Student success on this assessment was tied to how students synthesized their knowledge of physics and computation. On the essay and interview assessments, students displayed unique views of the relationship between force and motion; those who spoke of this relationship in causal (rather than observational) terms tended to have more success in the programming exercise. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2012; v1 submitted 7 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: preprint to submit to PERC proceedings 2012

Journal ref: AIP Conf. Proc. 1513, pp. 46-49 (2012)

Integrating Numerical Computation into the Modeling Instruction Curriculum

Authors: Marcos D. Caballero, John B. Burk, John M. Aiken, Scott S. Douglas, Erin M. Scanlon, Brian Thoms, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: We describe a way to introduce physics high school students with no background in programming to computational problem-solving experiences. Our approach builds on the great strides made by the Modeling Instruction reform curriculum. This approach emphasizes the practices of "Developing and using models" and "Computational thinking" highlighted by the NRC K-12 science standards framework. We taught… ▽ More We describe a way to introduce physics high school students with no background in programming to computational problem-solving experiences. Our approach builds on the great strides made by the Modeling Instruction reform curriculum. This approach emphasizes the practices of "Developing and using models" and "Computational thinking" highlighted by the NRC K-12 science standards framework. We taught 9th-grade students in a Modeling-Instruction-based physics course to construct computational models using the VPython programming environment. Numerical computation within the Modeling Instruction curriculum provides coherence among the curriculum's different force and motion models, links the various representations which the curriculum employs, and extends the curriculum to include real-world problems that are inaccessible to a purely analytic approach. △ Less

Submitted 17 November, 2013; v1 submitted 3 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: 6 pages, 3 figures, accepted to The Physics Teacher

Fostering Computational Thinking

Authors: Marcos D. Caballero, Matthew A. Kohlmyer, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Students taking introductory physics are rarely exposed to computational modeling. In a one-semester large lecture introductory calculus-based mechanics course at Georgia Tech, students learned to solve physics problems using the VPython programming environment. During the term 1357 students in this course solved a suite of fourteen computational modeling homework questions delivered using an onli… ▽ More Students taking introductory physics are rarely exposed to computational modeling. In a one-semester large lecture introductory calculus-based mechanics course at Georgia Tech, students learned to solve physics problems using the VPython programming environment. During the term 1357 students in this course solved a suite of fourteen computational modeling homework questions delivered using an online commercial course management system. Their proficiency with computational modeling was evaluated in a proctored environment using a novel central force problem. The majority of students (60.4%) successfully completed the evaluation. Analysis of erroneous student-submitted programs indicated that a small set of student errors explained why most programs failed. We discuss the design and implementation of the computational modeling homework and evaluation, the results from the evaluation and the implications for instruction in computational modeling in introductory STEM courses. △ Less

Submitted 21 December, 2011; originally announced December 2011.

Comments: 4 pages, 1 figure, Accepted to Proceedings of the 2011 Physics Education Research Conference

Implementing and assessing computational modeling in introductory mechanics

Authors: Marcos D. Caballero, Matthew A. Kohlmyer, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Students taking introductory physics are rarely exposed to computational modeling. In a one-semester large lecture introductory calculus-based mechanics course at Georgia Tech, students learned to solve physics problems using the VPython programming environment. During the term 1357 students in this course solved a suite of fourteen computational modeling homework questions delivered using an onli… ▽ More Students taking introductory physics are rarely exposed to computational modeling. In a one-semester large lecture introductory calculus-based mechanics course at Georgia Tech, students learned to solve physics problems using the VPython programming environment. During the term 1357 students in this course solved a suite of fourteen computational modeling homework questions delivered using an online commercial course management system. Their proficiency with computational modeling was evaluated in a proctored environment using a novel central force problem. The majority of students (60.4%) successfully completed the evaluation. Analysis of erroneous student-submitted programs indicated that a small set of student errors explained why most programs failed. We discuss the design and implementation of the computational modeling homework and evaluation, the results from the evaluation and the implications for instruction in computational modeling in introductory STEM courses. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2012; v1 submitted 26 July, 2011; originally announced July 2011.

Comments: 14 pages, 1 figure, 6 tables, submitted to PRST-PER

Comparing large lecture mechanics curricula using the Force Concept Inventory: A five thousand student study

Authors: Marcos D. Caballero, Matthew A. Kohlmyer, Edwin F. Greco, Eric R. Murray, Keith R. Bujak, M. Jackson Marr, Richard Catrambone, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The performance of over 5000 students in introductory calculus-based mechanics courses at the Georgia Institute of Technology was assessed using the Force Concept Inventory (FCI). Results from two different curricula were compared: a traditional mechanics curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. Post-instruction FCI averages were significantly higher for the traditional curriculu… ▽ More The performance of over 5000 students in introductory calculus-based mechanics courses at the Georgia Institute of Technology was assessed using the Force Concept Inventory (FCI). Results from two different curricula were compared: a traditional mechanics curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. Post-instruction FCI averages were significantly higher for the traditional curriculum than for the M&I curriculum; the differences between curricula persist after accounting for factors such as pre-instruction FCI scores, grade point averages, and SAT scores. FCI performance on categories of items organized by concepts was also compared; traditional averages were significantly higher in each concept. We examined differences in student preparation between the curricula and found that the relative fraction of homework and lecture topics devoted to FCI force and motion concepts correlated with the observed performance differences. Limitations of concept inventories as instruments for evaluating curricular reforms are discussed. △ Less

Submitted 3 July, 2012; v1 submitted 6 June, 2011; originally announced June 2011.

Comments: 21 pages, 4 figures, submitted to Am. J. Phys. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1112.5593

Journal ref: American Journal of Physics -- July 2012 -- Volume 80, Issue 7, pp. 638

Non-equilibrium Pattern Modes Extracted from Experimental Data

Authors: Adam C. Perkins, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: We describe a method to extract from experimental data the important dynamical modes in spatio-temporal patterns in a system driven out of thermodynamic equilibrium. Using a novel optical technique for controlling fluid flow, we create an experimental ensemble of Rayleigh-Bénard convection patterns with nearby initial conditions close to the onset of secondary instability. An analysis of the ensem… ▽ More We describe a method to extract from experimental data the important dynamical modes in spatio-temporal patterns in a system driven out of thermodynamic equilibrium. Using a novel optical technique for controlling fluid flow, we create an experimental ensemble of Rayleigh-Bénard convection patterns with nearby initial conditions close to the onset of secondary instability. An analysis of the ensemble evolution reveals the spatial structure of the dominant modes of the system as well as the corresponding growth rates. The extracted modes are related to localized versions of instabilities found in the ideal unbounded system. The approach may prove useful in describing instability in experimental systems as a step toward prediction and control. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2011; originally announced May 2011.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Comparing the Matter and Interactions Curriculum with a Traditional Physics Curriculum: A Think Aloud Study

Authors: Keith R Bujak, Richard Catrambone, Marcos D Caballero, M Jackson Marr, Michael F Schatz, Matthew A Kohlmyer

Abstract: Physics curricula across the US fail to prepare students adequately to solve problems, especially novel problems. A new curriculum, Matter and Interactions (M&I), was designed to improve student learning by organizing concepts around fundamental principles. Despite this, students taught in traditional classes continue to outperform M&I students on force concept questions. This study aimed to deter… ▽ More Physics curricula across the US fail to prepare students adequately to solve problems, especially novel problems. A new curriculum, Matter and Interactions (M&I), was designed to improve student learning by organizing concepts around fundamental principles. Despite this, students taught in traditional classes continue to outperform M&I students on force concept questions. This study aimed to determine the underlying issues related to the performance differential. Students from both courses solved questions from the Force Concept Inventory (FCI) while verbally describing their reasoning. Analysis of the transcripts revealed that M&I students failed to employ the fundamental principles, and traditional students used simple physics facts to help identify the correct answers. Neither of these methods would be sufficient for solving more complex problems. △ Less

Submitted 24 November, 2010; originally announced November 2010.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures, 2011 AERA Conference Proceedings

A Tale of Two Curricula: The performance of two thousand students in introductory electromagnetism

Authors: Matthew A. Kohlmyer, Marcos D. Caballero, Richard Catrambone, Ruth W. Chabay, Lin Ding, Mark P. Haugan, M. Jackson Marr, Bruce A. Sherwood, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: The performance of over 2000 students in introductory calculus-based electromagnetism (E&M) courses at four large research universities was measured using the Brief Electricity and Magnetism Assessment (BEMA). Two different curricula were used at these universities: a traditional E&M curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. At each university, post-instruction BEMA test average… ▽ More The performance of over 2000 students in introductory calculus-based electromagnetism (E&M) courses at four large research universities was measured using the Brief Electricity and Magnetism Assessment (BEMA). Two different curricula were used at these universities: a traditional E&M curriculum and the Matter & Interactions (M&I) curriculum. At each university, post-instruction BEMA test averages were significantly higher for the M&I curriculum than for the traditional curriculum. The differences in post-test averages cannot be explained by differences in variables such as pre-instruction BEMA scores, grade point average, or SAT scores. BEMA performance on categories of items organized by subtopic was also compared at one of the universities; M&I averages were significantly higher in each topic. The results suggest that the M&I curriculum is more effective than the traditional curriculum at teaching E&M concepts to students, possibly because the learning progression in M&I reorganizes and augments the traditional sequence of topics, for example, by increasing early emphasis on the vector field concept and by emphasizing the effects of fields on matter at the microscopic level. △ Less

Submitted 29 May, 2009; originally announced June 2009.

Comments: 17 pages, 11 figures

Transient Turbulence in Taylor-Couette Flow

Authors: Daniel Borrero-Echeverry, Randall Tagg, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Recent studies have brought into question the view that at sufficiently high Reynolds number turbulence is an asymptotic state. We present the first direct observation of the decay of turbulent states in Taylor-Couette flow with lifetimes spanning five orders of magnitude. We also show that there is a regime where Taylor-Couette flow shares many of the decay characteristics observed in other she… ▽ More Recent studies have brought into question the view that at sufficiently high Reynolds number turbulence is an asymptotic state. We present the first direct observation of the decay of turbulent states in Taylor-Couette flow with lifetimes spanning five orders of magnitude. We also show that there is a regime where Taylor-Couette flow shares many of the decay characteristics observed in other shear flows, including Poisson statistics and the coexistence of laminar and turbulent patches. Our data suggest that characteristic decay times increase super-exponentially with increasing Reynolds number but remain bounded in agreement with the most recent data from pipe flow and with a recent theoretical model. This suggests that, contrary to the prevailing view, turbulence in linearly stable shear flows may be generically transient. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2009; v1 submitted 4 May, 2009; originally announced May 2009.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures v2: Addressed referee comments for PRE. Made some cosmetic changes. Added inset to Fig. 4

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 81, 025301(R) (2010)

Homological Characterizations of Spiral Defect Chaos in Rayleigh-Benard Convection

Authors: Kapilanjan Krishan, Marcio Gameiro, Konstantin Mischaikow, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: We use a quantitative topological characterization of complex dynamics to measure geometric structures. This approach is used to analyze the weakly turbulent state of spiral defect chaos in experiments on Rayleigh-Benard convection. Different attractors of spiral defect chaos are distinguished by their homology. The technique reveals pattern asymmetries that are not revealed using statistical me… ▽ More We use a quantitative topological characterization of complex dynamics to measure geometric structures. This approach is used to analyze the weakly turbulent state of spiral defect chaos in experiments on Rayleigh-Benard convection. Different attractors of spiral defect chaos are distinguished by their homology. The technique reveals pattern asymmetries that are not revealed using statistical measures. In addition we observe global stochastic ergodicity for system parameter values where locally chaotic dynamics has been observed previously. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2009; originally announced April 2009.

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures

Estimating the State of Large Spatiotemporally Chaotic Systems

Authors: Matthew Cornick, Brian Hunt, Edward Ott, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: Data assimilation refers to the process of obtaining an estimate of a system's state using a model for the system's time evolution and a time series of measurements that are possibly noisy and incomplete. However, for practical reasons, the high dimensionality of large spatiotemporally chaotic systems prevents the use of classical data assimilation techniques. Here, via numerical computations on… ▽ More Data assimilation refers to the process of obtaining an estimate of a system's state using a model for the system's time evolution and a time series of measurements that are possibly noisy and incomplete. However, for practical reasons, the high dimensionality of large spatiotemporally chaotic systems prevents the use of classical data assimilation techniques. Here, via numerical computations on the paradigmatic example of large aspect ratio Rayleigh-Benard convection, we demonstrate the applicability of a recently developed data assimilation method designed to circumvent this difficulty. In addition, we describe extensions of the algorithm for estimating unknown system parameters. Our results suggest the potential usefulness of our data assimilation technique to a broad class of situations in which there is spatiotemporally chaotic behavior. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2007; originally announced May 2007.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Modal Extraction in Spatially Extended Systems

Authors: Kapilanjan Krishan, Andreas Handel, Roman O. Grigoriev, Michael F. Schatz

Abstract: We describe a practical procedure for extracting the spatial structure and the growth rates of slow eigenmodes of a spatially extended system, using a unique experimental capability both to impose and to perturb desired initial states. The procedure is used to construct experimentally the spectrum of linear modes near the secondary instability boundary in Rayleigh-Bénard convection. This techniq… ▽ More We describe a practical procedure for extracting the spatial structure and the growth rates of slow eigenmodes of a spatially extended system, using a unique experimental capability both to impose and to perturb desired initial states. The procedure is used to construct experimentally the spectrum of linear modes near the secondary instability boundary in Rayleigh-Bénard convection. This technique suggests an approach to experimental characterization of more complex dynamical states such as periodic orbits or spatiotemporal chaos. △ Less

Submitted 7 April, 2007; originally announced April 2007.

Comments: 5 pages, 6 figure

Homology and symmetry breaking in Rayleigh-Benard convection: Experiments and simulations

Authors: Kapilanjan Krishan, Huseyin Kurtuldu, Michael F. Schatz, Marcio Gameiro, Konstantin Mischaikow

Abstract: Algebraic topology (homology) is used to analyze the weakly turbulent state of spiral defect chaos in both laboratory experiments and numerical simulations of Rayleigh-Benard convection.The analysis reveals topological asymmetries that arise when non-Boussinesq effects are present. Algebraic topology (homology) is used to analyze the weakly turbulent state of spiral defect chaos in both laboratory experiments and numerical simulations of Rayleigh-Benard convection.The analysis reveals topological asymmetries that arise when non-Boussinesq effects are present. △ Less

Submitted 20 January, 2007; originally announced January 2007.

Comments: 21 pages with 6 figures

Convective instability on a crystal surface

Authors: Navot Israeli, Daniel Kandel, Michael F. Schatz, Andrew Zangwill

Abstract: The distinction between absolute and convective instabilities is well known in the context of hydrodynamics and plasma physics. In this Letter, we examine an epitaxial crystal growth model from this point of view and show that a strain-induced step bunching instability can be convective. Using analytic stability theory and numerical simulations, we study the response of the crystal surface to an… ▽ More The distinction between absolute and convective instabilities is well known in the context of hydrodynamics and plasma physics. In this Letter, we examine an epitaxial crystal growth model from this point of view and show that a strain-induced step bunching instability can be convective. Using analytic stability theory and numerical simulations, we study the response of the crystal surface to an inhomogeneous deposition flux that launches impulsive and time-periodic perturbations to a uniform array of steps. The results suggest a new approach to morphological patterning. △ Less

Submitted 5 October, 2000; originally announced October 2000.

Comments: 4 pages + 5 postscript figure files

Onset of Surface-Tension-Driven Benard Convection

Authors: Michael F. Schatz, Stephen J. VanHook, William D. McCormick, J. B. Swift, Harry L. Swinney

Abstract: Experiments with shadowgraph visualization reveal a subcritical transition to a hexagonal convection pattern in thin liquid layers that have a free upper surface and are heated from below. The measured critical Marangoni number (84) and observation of hysteresis (3%) agree with theory. In some experiments, imperfect bifurcation is observed and is attributed to deterministic forcing caused in par… ▽ More Experiments with shadowgraph visualization reveal a subcritical transition to a hexagonal convection pattern in thin liquid layers that have a free upper surface and are heated from below. The measured critical Marangoni number (84) and observation of hysteresis (3%) agree with theory. In some experiments, imperfect bifurcation is observed and is attributed to deterministic forcing caused in part by the lateral boundaries in the experiment. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 1995; originally announced July 1995.

Comments: 4 pages. The RevTeX file has a macro allowing various styles. The appropriate style is "mypprint" which is the default

Report number: UT-CNLD-95.3

Long-Wavelength Instability in Surface-Tension-Driven Benard Convection

Authors: Stephen J. Vanhook, Michael F. Schatz, William D. McCormick, J. B. Swift, Harry L. Swinney

Abstract: Laboratory studies reveal a deformational instability that leads to a drained region (dry spot) in an initially flat liquid layer (with a free upper surface) heated uniformly from below. This long-wavelength instability supplants hexagonal convection cells as the primary instability in viscous liquid layers that are sufficiently thin or are in microgravity. The instability occurs at a temperatur… ▽ More Laboratory studies reveal a deformational instability that leads to a drained region (dry spot) in an initially flat liquid layer (with a free upper surface) heated uniformly from below. This long-wavelength instability supplants hexagonal convection cells as the primary instability in viscous liquid layers that are sufficiently thin or are in microgravity. The instability occurs at a temperature gradient 34% smaller than predicted by linear stability theory. Numerical simulations show a drained region qualitatively similar to that seen in the experiment. △ Less

Submitted 7 July, 1995; originally announced July 1995.

Comments: 4 pages. The RevTeX file has a macro allowing various styles. The appropriate style is "mypprint" which is the default

Report number: UT-CNLD-95.4