-
Design Contradictions: Help or Hindrance?
Authors:
Aron E. Owen,
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
The need for innovative ideas in data visualisation drives us to explore new creative approaches. Combining two or more creative words, particularly those that contradict each other, can positively impact the creative process, sparking novel ideas and designs. As we move towards AI-driven design, an open question arises: do these design contradictions work positively with AI tools? Currently, the…
▽ More
The need for innovative ideas in data visualisation drives us to explore new creative approaches. Combining two or more creative words, particularly those that contradict each other, can positively impact the creative process, sparking novel ideas and designs. As we move towards AI-driven design, an open question arises: do these design contradictions work positively with AI tools? Currently, the answer is no. AI systems, like large language models (LLMs), rely on algorithms that engender similarity, whereas creativity often requires divergence and novelty. This poster initiates a conversation on how to drive AI systems to be more creative and generate new ideas. This research invites us to reconsider traditional design methods and explore new approaches in an AI-driven world. Can we apply the same techniques used in traditional design, like the double diamond model, or do we need new methods for design engineering? How can we quickly design visualisations and craft new ideas with generative AI? This paper seeks to start this critical conversation and offers practical insights into the potential of AI in driving creativity in data visualisation.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Towards Metrics for Evaluating Creativity in Visualisation Design
Authors:
Aron E Owen,
Jonathan C Roberts
Abstract:
Creativity in visualisation design is essential for designers and data scientists who need to present data in innovative ways. It is often achieved through sketching or drafting low-fidelity prototypes. However, judging this innovation is often difficult. A creative visualisation test would offer a structured approach to enhancing visual thinking and design skills, which are vital across many fiel…
▽ More
Creativity in visualisation design is essential for designers and data scientists who need to present data in innovative ways. It is often achieved through sketching or drafting low-fidelity prototypes. However, judging this innovation is often difficult. A creative visualisation test would offer a structured approach to enhancing visual thinking and design skills, which are vital across many fields. Such a test can facilitate objective evaluation, skill identification, benchmarking, fostering innovation, and improving learning outcomes. In developing such a test, we propose focusing on four criteria: Quantity, Correctness, Novelty, and Feasibility. These criteria integrate into a test that is easy to administer. We name it the Rowen Test of Creativity in Visualisation Design; We introduce the test, scoring system and results from using eight visualisation experts.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Towards a Generative AI Design Dialogue
Authors:
Aron E. Owen,
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
Traditional visualisation designers often start with sketches before implementation. With generative AI, these sketches can be turned into AI-generated visualisations using specific prompts. However, guiding AI to create compelling visuals can be challenging. We propose a new design process where designers verbalise their thoughts during work, later converting these narratives into AI prompts. Thi…
▽ More
Traditional visualisation designers often start with sketches before implementation. With generative AI, these sketches can be turned into AI-generated visualisations using specific prompts. However, guiding AI to create compelling visuals can be challenging. We propose a new design process where designers verbalise their thoughts during work, later converting these narratives into AI prompts. This approach helps AI generate accurate visuals and assists designers in refining their concepts, enhancing the overall design process. Blending human creativity with AI capabilities enables rapid iteration, leading to higher quality and more innovative visualisations, making design more accessible and efficient.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Fostering Creative Visualisation Skills Through Data-Art Exhibitions
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
Data-art exhibitions offer a unique and real-world setting to foster creative visualisation skills among students. They serve as real-world platform for students to display their work, bridging the gap between classroom learning and professional practice. Students must develop a technical solution, grasp the context, and produce work that is appropriate for public presentation. This scenario helps…
▽ More
Data-art exhibitions offer a unique and real-world setting to foster creative visualisation skills among students. They serve as real-world platform for students to display their work, bridging the gap between classroom learning and professional practice. Students must develop a technical solution, grasp the context, and produce work that is appropriate for public presentation. This scenario helps to encourage innovative thinking, engagement with the topic, and helps to enhance technical proficiency. We present our implementation of a data-art exhibition within a computing curriculum, for third-year degree-level students. Students create art-based visualisations from selected datasets and present their work in a public exhibition. We have used this initiative over the course of two academic years with different cohorts, and reflect on its impact on student learning and creativity.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Creating Data Art: Authentic Learning and Visualisation Exhibition
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
We present an authentic learning task designed for computing students, centred on the creation of data-art visualisations from chosen datasets for a public exhibition. This exhibition was showcased in the cinema foyer for two weeks in June, providing a real-world platform for students to display their work. Over the course of two years, we implemented this active learning task with two different c…
▽ More
We present an authentic learning task designed for computing students, centred on the creation of data-art visualisations from chosen datasets for a public exhibition. This exhibition was showcased in the cinema foyer for two weeks in June, providing a real-world platform for students to display their work. Over the course of two years, we implemented this active learning task with two different cohorts of students. In this paper, we share our experiences and insights from these activities, highlighting the impact on student engagement and learning outcomes. We also provide a detailed description of the seven individual tasks that learners must perform: topic and data selection and analysis, research and art inspiration, design conceptualisation, proposed solution, visualisation creation, exhibition curation, and reflection. By integrating these tasks, students not only develop technical skills but also gain practical experience in presenting their work to a public audience, bridging the gap between academic learning and professional practice.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Engaging Data-Art: Conducting a Public Hands-On Workshop
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
Data-art blends visualisation, data science, and artistic expression. It allows people to transform information and data into exciting and interesting visual narratives. Hosting a public data-art hands-on workshop enables participants to engage with data and learn fundamental visualisation techniques. However, being a public event, it presents a range of challenges. We outline our approach to orga…
▽ More
Data-art blends visualisation, data science, and artistic expression. It allows people to transform information and data into exciting and interesting visual narratives. Hosting a public data-art hands-on workshop enables participants to engage with data and learn fundamental visualisation techniques. However, being a public event, it presents a range of challenges. We outline our approach to organising and conducting a public workshop, that caters to a wide age range, from children to adults. We divide the tutorial into three sections, focusing on data, sketching skills and visualisation. We place emphasis on public engagement, and ensure that participants have fun while learning new skills.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Path-based Design Model for Constructing and Exploring Alternative Visualisations
Authors:
James Jackson,
Panagiotis D. Ritsos,
Peter W. S. Butcher,
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
We present a path-based design model and system for designing and creating visualisations. Our model represents a systematic approach to constructing visual representations of data or concepts following a predefined sequence of steps. The initial step involves outlining the overall appearance of the visualisation by creating a skeleton structure, referred to as a flowpath. Subsequently, we specify…
▽ More
We present a path-based design model and system for designing and creating visualisations. Our model represents a systematic approach to constructing visual representations of data or concepts following a predefined sequence of steps. The initial step involves outlining the overall appearance of the visualisation by creating a skeleton structure, referred to as a flowpath. Subsequently, we specify objects, visual marks, properties, and appearance, storing them in a gene. Lastly, we map data onto the flowpath, ensuring suitable morphisms. Alternative designs are created by exchanging values in the gene. For example, designs that share similar traits, are created by making small incremental changes to the gene. Our design methodology fosters the generation of diverse creative concepts, space-filling visualisations, and traditional formats like bar charts, circular plots and pie charts. Through our implementation we showcase the model in action. As an example application, we integrate the output visualisations onto a smartwatch and visualisation dashboards. In this article we (1) introduce, define and explain the path model and discuss possibilities for its use, (2) present our implementation, results, and evaluation, and (3) demonstrate and evaluate an application of its use on a mobile watch.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Feature-Action Design Patterns for Storytelling Visualizations with Time Series Data
Authors:
Saiful Khan,
Scott Jones,
Benjamin Bach,
Jaehoon Cha,
Min Chen,
Julie Meikle,
Jonathan C Roberts,
Jeyan Thiyagalingam,
Jo Wood,
Panagiotis D. Ritsos
Abstract:
We present a method to create storytelling visualization with time series data. Many personal decisions nowadays rely on access to dynamic data regularly, as we have seen during the COVID-19 pandemic. It is thus desirable to construct storytelling visualization for dynamic data that is selected by an individual for a specific context. Because of the need to tell data-dependent stories, predefined…
▽ More
We present a method to create storytelling visualization with time series data. Many personal decisions nowadays rely on access to dynamic data regularly, as we have seen during the COVID-19 pandemic. It is thus desirable to construct storytelling visualization for dynamic data that is selected by an individual for a specific context. Because of the need to tell data-dependent stories, predefined storyboards based on known data cannot accommodate dynamic data easily nor scale up to many different individuals and contexts. Motivated initially by the need to communicate time series data during the COVID-19 pandemic, we developed a novel computer-assisted method for meta-authoring of stories, which enables the design of storyboards that include feature-action patterns in anticipation of potential features that may appear in dynamically arrived or selected data. In addition to meta-storyboards involving COVID-19 data, we also present storyboards for telling stories about progress in a machine learning workflow. Our approach is complementary to traditional methods for authoring storytelling visualization, and provides an efficient means to construct data-dependent storyboards for different data-streams of similar contexts.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Challenges and Opportunities in Data Visualization Education: A Call to Action
Authors:
Benjamin Bach,
Mandy Keck,
Fateme Rajabiyazdi,
Tatiana Losev,
Isabel Meirelles,
Jason Dykes,
Robert S. Laramee,
Mashael AlKadi,
Christina Stoiber,
Samuel Huron,
Charles Perin,
Luiz Morais,
Wolfgang Aigner,
Doris Kosminsky,
Magdalena Boucher,
Søren Knudsen,
Areti Manataki,
Jan Aerts,
Uta Hinrichs,
Jonathan C. Roberts,
Sheelagh Carpendale
Abstract:
This paper is a call to action for research and discussion on data visualization education. As visualization evolves and spreads through our professional and personal lives, we need to understand how to support and empower a broad and diverse community of learners in visualization. Data Visualization is a diverse and dynamic discipline that combines knowledge from different fields, is tailored to…
▽ More
This paper is a call to action for research and discussion on data visualization education. As visualization evolves and spreads through our professional and personal lives, we need to understand how to support and empower a broad and diverse community of learners in visualization. Data Visualization is a diverse and dynamic discipline that combines knowledge from different fields, is tailored to suit diverse audiences and contexts, and frequently incorporates tacit knowledge. This complex nature leads to a series of interrelated challenges for data visualization education. Driven by a lack of consolidated knowledge, overview, and orientation for visualization education, the 21 authors of this paper-educators and researchers in data visualization-identify and describe 19 challenges informed by our collective practical experience. We organize these challenges around seven themes People, Goals & Assessment, Environment, Motivation, Methods, Materials, and Change. Across these themes, we formulate 43 research questions to address these challenges. As part of our call to action, we then conclude with 5 cross-cutting opportunities and respective action items: embrace DIVERSITY+INCLUSION, build COMMUNITIES, conduct RESEARCH, act AGILE, and relish RESPONSIBILITY. We aim to inspire researchers, educators and learners to drive visualization education forward and discuss why, how, who and where we educate, as we learn to use visualization to address challenges across many scales and many domains in a rapidly changing world: viseducationchallenges.github.io.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
EduVis: Workshop on Visualization Education, Literacy, and Activities
Authors:
Mandy Keck,
Samuel Huron,
Georgia Panagiotidou,
Christina Stoiber,
Fateme Rajabiyazdi,
Charles Perin,
Jonathan C. Roberts,
Benjamin Bach
Abstract:
This workshop focuses on visualization education, literacy, and activities. It aims to streamline previous efforts and initiatives of the visualization community to provide a format for education and engagement practices in visualization. It intends to bring together junior and senior scholars to share research and experience and to discuss novel activities, teaching methods, and research challeng…
▽ More
This workshop focuses on visualization education, literacy, and activities. It aims to streamline previous efforts and initiatives of the visualization community to provide a format for education and engagement practices in visualization. It intends to bring together junior and senior scholars to share research and experience and to discuss novel activities, teaching methods, and research challenges. The workshop aims to serve as a platform for interdisciplinary researchers within and beyond the visualization community such as education, learning analytics, science communication, psychology, or people from adjacent fields such as data science, AI, and HCI. It will include presentations of research papers and practical reports, as well as hands-on activities. In addition, the workshop will allow participants to discuss challenges they face in data visualization education and sketch a research agenda of visualization education, literacy, and activities.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Reflections and Considerations on Running Creative Visualization Learning Activities
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts,
Benjamin Bach,
Magdalena Boucher,
Fanny Chevalier,
Alexandra Diehl,
Uta Hinrichs,
Samuel Huron,
Andy Kirk,
Søren Knudsen,
Isabel Meirelles,
Rebecca Noonan,
Laura Pelchmann,
Fateme Rajabiyazdi,
Christina Stoiber
Abstract:
This paper draws together nine strategies for creative visualization activities. Teaching visualization often involves running learning activities where students perform tasks that directly support one or more topics that the teacher wishes to address in the lesson. As a group of educators and researchers in visualization, we reflect on our learning experiences. Our activities and experiences rang…
▽ More
This paper draws together nine strategies for creative visualization activities. Teaching visualization often involves running learning activities where students perform tasks that directly support one or more topics that the teacher wishes to address in the lesson. As a group of educators and researchers in visualization, we reflect on our learning experiences. Our activities and experiences range from dividing the tasks into smaller parts, considering different learning materials, to encouraging debate. With this paper, our hope is that we can encourage, inspire, and guide other educators with visualization activities. Our reflections provide an initial starting point of methods and strategies to craft creative visualisation learning activities, and provide a foundation for developing best practices in visualization education.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Visualization for Epidemiological Modelling: Challenges, Solutions, Reflections & Recommendations
Authors:
Jason Dykes,
Alfie Abdul-Rahman,
Daniel Archambault,
Benjamin Bach,
Rita Borgo,
Min Chen,
Jessica Enright,
Hui Fang,
Elif E. Firat,
Euan Freeman,
Tuna Gonen,
Claire Harris,
Radu Jianu,
Nigel W. John,
Saiful Khan,
Andrew Lahiff,
Robert S. Laramee,
Louise Matthews,
Sibylle Mohr,
Phong H. Nguyen,
Alma A. M. Rahat,
Richard Reeve,
Panagiotis D. Ritsos,
Jonathan C. Roberts,
Aidan Slingsby
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report on an ongoing collaboration between epidemiological modellers and visualization researchers by documenting and reflecting upon knowledge constructs -- a series of ideas, approaches and methods taken from existing visualization research and practice -- deployed and developed to support modelling of the COVID-19 pandemic. Structured independent commentary on these efforts is synthesized th…
▽ More
We report on an ongoing collaboration between epidemiological modellers and visualization researchers by documenting and reflecting upon knowledge constructs -- a series of ideas, approaches and methods taken from existing visualization research and practice -- deployed and developed to support modelling of the COVID-19 pandemic. Structured independent commentary on these efforts is synthesized through iterative reflection to develop: evidence of the effectiveness and value of visualization in this context; open problems upon which the research communities may focus; guidance for future activity of this type; and recommendations to safeguard the achievements and promote, advance, secure and prepare for future collaborations of this kind. In describing and comparing a series of related projects that were undertaken in unprecedented conditions, our hope is that this unique report, and its rich interactive supplementary materials, will guide the scientific community in embracing visualization in its observation, analysis and modelling of data as well as in disseminating findings. Equally we hope to encourage the visualization community to engage with impactful science in addressing its emerging data challenges. If we are successful, this showcase of activity may stimulate mutually beneficial engagement between communities with complementary expertise to address problems of significance in epidemiology and beyond. https://ramp-vis.github.io/RAMPVIS-PhilTransA-Supplement/
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2022; v1 submitted 14 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
3D Visualisations Should Not be Displayed Alone - Encouraging a Need for Multivocality in Visualisation
Authors:
J. C. Roberts,
J. W. Mearman,
P. W. S. Butcher,
H. M. Al-Maneea,
P. D. Ritsos
Abstract:
We believe that 3D visualisations should not be used alone; by coincidentally displaying alternative views the user can gain the best understanding of all situations. The different presentations signify manifold meanings and afford different tasks. Natural 3D worlds implicitly tell many stories. For instance, walking into a living room, seeing the TV, types of magazines, pictures on the wall, tell…
▽ More
We believe that 3D visualisations should not be used alone; by coincidentally displaying alternative views the user can gain the best understanding of all situations. The different presentations signify manifold meanings and afford different tasks. Natural 3D worlds implicitly tell many stories. For instance, walking into a living room, seeing the TV, types of magazines, pictures on the wall, tells us much about the occupiers: their occupation, standards of living, taste in design, whether they have kids, and so on. How can we similarly create rich and diverse 3D visualisation presentations? How can we create visualisations that allow people to understand different stories from the data? In a multivariate 2D visualisation a developer may coordinate and link many views together to provide exploratory visualisation functionality. But how can this be achieved in 3D and in immersive visualisations? Different visualisation types, each have specific uses, and each has the potential to tell or evoke a different story. Through several use-cases, we discuss challenges of 3D visualisation, and present our argument for concurrent and coordinated visualisations of alternative styles, and encourage developers to consider using alternative representations with any 3D view, even if that view is displayed in a virtual, augmented or mixed reality setup.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Learning Activities in Colours and Rainbows for Programming Skill Development
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts
Abstract:
We present how we have created a series of bilingual (English and Welsh) STEM activities focusing on rainbows, colours, light and optical effects. The activities were motivated by the many rainbows that appeared in windows in the UK, in support of the National Health Service at the start of the coronavirus pandemic. Rainbows are hopeful and are very fitting to be used as a positive iconic image at…
▽ More
We present how we have created a series of bilingual (English and Welsh) STEM activities focusing on rainbows, colours, light and optical effects. The activities were motivated by the many rainbows that appeared in windows in the UK, in support of the National Health Service at the start of the coronavirus pandemic. Rainbows are hopeful and are very fitting to be used as a positive iconic image at a time of much uncertainty. In this paper we explain how we have developed and organised the activities, focusing on colours, computer graphics and computer programming. Each lesson contains one or more activities, which enable people to take an active role in their learning. We have carefully prepared and organised several processes to guide academic colleagues to create and publish different activities in the theme. Which means that the activities appear similarly structured, can be categorised and searched in a consistent way. This structure can act as a blueprint for others to follow and apply to develop their own online course. The activities incrementally take people through learning about colour, rainbows, planning what to program, design and strategies to create colourful pictures using simple computer graphics principles based in processing.org.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Explanatory Journeys: Visualising to Understand and Explain Administrative Justice Paths of Redress
Authors:
Jonathan C. Roberts,
Peter Butcher,
Ann Sherlock,
Sarah Nason
Abstract:
Administrative justice concerns the relationships between individuals and the state. It includes redress and complaints on decisions of a child's education, social care, licensing, planning, environment, housing and homelessness. However, if someone has a complaint or an issue, it is challenging for people to understand different possible redress paths and explore what path is suitable for their s…
▽ More
Administrative justice concerns the relationships between individuals and the state. It includes redress and complaints on decisions of a child's education, social care, licensing, planning, environment, housing and homelessness. However, if someone has a complaint or an issue, it is challenging for people to understand different possible redress paths and explore what path is suitable for their situation. Explanatory visualisation has the potential to display these paths of redress in a clear way, such that people can see, understand and explore their options. The visualisation challenge is further complicated because information is spread across many documents, laws, guidance and policies and requires judicial interpretation. Consequently, there is not a single database of paths of redress. In this work we present how we have co-designed a system to visualise administrative justice paths of redress. Simultaneously, we classify, collate and organise the underpinning data, from expert workshops, heuristic evaluation and expert critical reflection. We make four contributions: (i) an application design study of the explanatory visualisation tool (Artemus), (ii) coordinated and co-design approach to aggregating the data, (iii) two in-depth case studies in housing and education demonstrating explanatory paths of redress in administrative law, and (iv) reflections on the expert co-design process and expert data gathering and explanatory visualisation for administrative justice and law.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
RAMPVIS: Towards a New Methodology for Developing Visualisation Capabilities for Large-scale Emergency Responses
Authors:
M. Chen,
A. Abdul-Rahman,
D. Archambault,
J. Dykes,
A. Slingsby,
P. D. Ritsos,
T. Torsney-Weir,
C. Turkay,
B. Bach,
A. Brett,
H. Fang,
R. Jianu,
S. Khan,
R. S. Laramee,
P. H. Nguyen,
R. Reeve,
J. C. Roberts,
F. Vidal,
Q. Wang,
J. Wood,
K. Xu
Abstract:
The effort for combating the COVID-19 pandemic around the world has resulted in a huge amount of data, e.g., from testing, contact tracing, modelling, treatment, vaccine trials, and more. In addition to numerous challenges in epidemiology, healthcare, biosciences, and social sciences, there has been an urgent need to develop and provide visualisation and visual analytics (VIS) capacities to suppor…
▽ More
The effort for combating the COVID-19 pandemic around the world has resulted in a huge amount of data, e.g., from testing, contact tracing, modelling, treatment, vaccine trials, and more. In addition to numerous challenges in epidemiology, healthcare, biosciences, and social sciences, there has been an urgent need to develop and provide visualisation and visual analytics (VIS) capacities to support emergency responses under difficult operational conditions. In this paper, we report the experience of a group of VIS volunteers who have been working in a large research and development consortium and providing VIS support to various observational, analytical, model-developmental and disseminative tasks. In particular, we describe our approaches to the challenges that we have encountered in requirements analysis, data acquisition, visual design, software design, system development, team organisation, and resource planning. By reflecting on our experience, we propose a set of recommendations as the first step towards a methodology for developing and providing rapid VIS capacities to support emergency responses.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
CoronaSurveys: Using Surveys with Indirect Reporting to Estimate the Incidence and Evolution of Epidemics
Authors:
Oluwasegun Ojo,
Augusto García-Agundez,
Benjamin Girault,
Harold Hernández,
Elisa Cabana,
Amanda García-García,
Payman Arabshahi,
Carlos Baquero,
Paolo Casari,
Ednaldo José Ferreira,
Davide Frey,
Chryssis Georgiou,
Mathieu Goessens,
Anna Ishchenko,
Ernesto Jiménez,
Oleksiy Kebkal,
Rosa Lillo,
Raquel Menezes,
Nicolas Nicolaou,
Antonio Ortega,
Paul Patras,
Julian C Roberts,
Efstathios Stavrakis,
Yuichi Tanaka,
Antonio Fernández Anta
Abstract:
The world is suffering from a pandemic called COVID-19, caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus. National governments have problems evaluating the reach of the epidemic, due to having limited resources and tests at their disposal. This problem is especially acute in low and middle-income countries (LMICs). Hence, any simple, cheap and flexible means of evaluating the incidence and evolution of the epidemic…
▽ More
The world is suffering from a pandemic called COVID-19, caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus. National governments have problems evaluating the reach of the epidemic, due to having limited resources and tests at their disposal. This problem is especially acute in low and middle-income countries (LMICs). Hence, any simple, cheap and flexible means of evaluating the incidence and evolution of the epidemic in a given country with a reasonable level of accuracy is useful. In this paper, we propose a technique based on (anonymous) surveys in which participants report on the health status of their contacts. This indirect reporting technique, known in the literature as network scale-up method, preserves the privacy of the participants and their contacts, and collects information from a larger fraction of the population (as compared to individual surveys). This technique has been deployed in the CoronaSurveys project, which has been collecting reports for the COVID-19 pandemic for more than two months. Results obtained by CoronaSurveys show the power and flexibility of the approach, suggesting that it could be an inexpensive and powerful tool for LMICs.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2020; v1 submitted 24 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
