Showing 1–33 of 33 results for author: Raue, F

A Coreset Selection of Coreset Selection Literature: Introduction and Recent Advances

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Arundhati S. Shanbhag, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Joachim Folz, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Coreset selection targets the challenge of finding a small, representative subset of a large dataset that preserves essential patterns for effective machine learning. Although several surveys have examined data reduction strategies before, most focus narrowly on either classical geometry-based methods or active learning techniques. In contrast, this survey presents a more comprehensive view by uni… ▽ More Coreset selection targets the challenge of finding a small, representative subset of a large dataset that preserves essential patterns for effective machine learning. Although several surveys have examined data reduction strategies before, most focus narrowly on either classical geometry-based methods or active learning techniques. In contrast, this survey presents a more comprehensive view by unifying three major lines of coreset research, namely, training-free, training-oriented, and label-free approaches, into a single taxonomy. We present subfields often overlooked by existing work, including submodular formulations, bilevel optimization, and recent progress in pseudo-labeling for unlabeled datasets. Additionally, we examine how pruning strategies influence generalization and neural scaling laws, offering new insights that are absent from prior reviews. Finally, we compare these methods under varying computational, robustness, and performance demands and highlight open challenges, such as robustness, outlier filtering, and adapting coreset selection to foundation models, for future research. △ Less

Submitted 23 May, 2025; originally announced May 2025.

ForAug: Recombining Foregrounds and Backgrounds to Improve Vision Transformer Training with Bias Mitigation

Authors: Tobias Christian Nauen, Brian Moser, Federico Raue, Stanislav Frolov, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Transformers, particularly Vision Transformers (ViTs), have achieved state-of-the-art performance in large-scale image classification. However, they often require large amounts of data and can exhibit biases that limit their robustness and generalizability. This paper introduces ForAug, a novel data augmentation scheme that addresses these challenges and explicitly includes inductive biases, which… ▽ More Transformers, particularly Vision Transformers (ViTs), have achieved state-of-the-art performance in large-scale image classification. However, they often require large amounts of data and can exhibit biases that limit their robustness and generalizability. This paper introduces ForAug, a novel data augmentation scheme that addresses these challenges and explicitly includes inductive biases, which commonly are part of the neural network architecture, into the training data. ForAug is constructed by using pretrained foundation models to separate and recombine foreground objects with different backgrounds, enabling fine-grained control over image composition during training. It thus increases the data diversity and effective number of training samples. We demonstrate that training on ForNet, the application of ForAug to ImageNet, significantly improves the accuracy of ViTs and other architectures by up to 4.5 percentage points (p.p.) on ImageNet and 7.3 p.p. on downstream tasks. Importantly, ForAug enables novel ways of analyzing model behavior and quantifying biases. Namely, we introduce metrics for background robustness, foreground focus, center bias, and size bias and show that training on ForNet substantially reduces these biases compared to training on ImageNet. In summary, ForAug provides a valuable tool for analyzing and mitigating biases, enabling the development of more robust and reliable computer vision models. Our code and dataset are publicly available at https://github.com/tobna/ForAug. △ Less

Submitted 12 March, 2025; originally announced March 2025.

MSC Class: 68T45 ACM Class: I.2.10; I.2.6; I.4.6

A Study in Dataset Distillation for Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Tobias Dietz, Brian B. Moser, Tobias Nauen, Federico Raue, Stanislav Frolov, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Dataset distillation is the concept of condensing large datasets into smaller but highly representative synthetic samples. While previous research has primarily focused on image classification, its application to image Super-Resolution (SR) remains underexplored. This exploratory work studies multiple dataset distillation techniques applied to SR, including pixel- and latent-space approaches under… ▽ More Dataset distillation is the concept of condensing large datasets into smaller but highly representative synthetic samples. While previous research has primarily focused on image classification, its application to image Super-Resolution (SR) remains underexplored. This exploratory work studies multiple dataset distillation techniques applied to SR, including pixel- and latent-space approaches under different aspects. Our experiments demonstrate that a 91.12% dataset size reduction can be achieved while maintaining comparable SR performance to the full dataset. We further analyze initialization strategies and distillation methods to optimize memory efficiency and computational costs. Our findings provide new insights into dataset distillation for SR and set the stage for future advancements. △ Less

Submitted 5 February, 2025; originally announced February 2025.

Distill the Best, Ignore the Rest: Improving Dataset Distillation with Loss-Value-Based Pruning

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Federico Raue, Tobias C. Nauen, Stanislav Frolov, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Dataset distillation has gained significant interest in recent years, yet existing approaches typically distill from the entire dataset, potentially including non-beneficial samples. We introduce a novel "Prune First, Distill After" framework that systematically prunes datasets via loss-based sampling prior to distillation. By leveraging pruning before classical distillation techniques and generat… ▽ More Dataset distillation has gained significant interest in recent years, yet existing approaches typically distill from the entire dataset, potentially including non-beneficial samples. We introduce a novel "Prune First, Distill After" framework that systematically prunes datasets via loss-based sampling prior to distillation. By leveraging pruning before classical distillation techniques and generative priors, we create a representative core-set that leads to enhanced generalization for unseen architectures - a significant challenge of current distillation methods. More specifically, our proposed framework significantly boosts distilled quality, achieving up to a 5.2 percentage points accuracy increase even with substantial dataset pruning, i.e., removing 80% of the original dataset prior to distillation. Overall, our experimental results highlight the advantages of our easy-sample prioritization and cross-architecture robustness, paving the way for more effective and high-quality dataset distillation. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2024; originally announced November 2024.

Just Leaf It: Accelerating Diffusion Classifiers with Hierarchical Class Pruning

Authors: Arundhati S. Shanbhag, Brian B. Moser, Tobias C. Nauen, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Diffusion models, celebrated for their generative capabilities, have recently demonstrated surprising effectiveness in image classification tasks by using Bayes' theorem. Yet, current diffusion classifiers must evaluate every label candidate for each input, creating high computational costs that impede their use in large-scale applications. To address this limitation, we propose a Hierarchical Dif… ▽ More Diffusion models, celebrated for their generative capabilities, have recently demonstrated surprising effectiveness in image classification tasks by using Bayes' theorem. Yet, current diffusion classifiers must evaluate every label candidate for each input, creating high computational costs that impede their use in large-scale applications. To address this limitation, we propose a Hierarchical Diffusion Classifier (HDC) that exploits hierarchical label structures or well-defined parent-child relationships in the dataset. By pruning irrelevant high-level categories and refining predictions only within relevant subcategories (leaf nodes and sub-trees), HDC reduces the total number of class evaluations. As a result, HDC can speed up inference by as much as 60% while preserving and sometimes even improving classification accuracy. In summary, our work provides a tunable control mechanism between speed and precision, making diffusion-based classification more feasible for large-scale applications. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2025; v1 submitted 18 November, 2024; originally announced November 2024.

Zoomed In, Diffused Out: Towards Local Degradation-Aware Multi-Diffusion for Extreme Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Stanislav Frolov, Tobias C. Nauen, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Large-scale, pre-trained Text-to-Image (T2I) diffusion models have gained significant popularity in image generation tasks and have shown unexpected potential in image Super-Resolution (SR). However, most existing T2I diffusion models are trained with a resolution limit of 512x512, making scaling beyond this resolution an unresolved but necessary challenge for image SR. In this work, we introduce… ▽ More Large-scale, pre-trained Text-to-Image (T2I) diffusion models have gained significant popularity in image generation tasks and have shown unexpected potential in image Super-Resolution (SR). However, most existing T2I diffusion models are trained with a resolution limit of 512x512, making scaling beyond this resolution an unresolved but necessary challenge for image SR. In this work, we introduce a novel approach that, for the first time, enables these models to generate 2K, 4K, and even 8K images without any additional training. Our method leverages MultiDiffusion, which distributes the generation across multiple diffusion paths to ensure global coherence at larger scales, and local degradation-aware prompt extraction, which guides the T2I model to reconstruct fine local structures according to its low-resolution input. These innovations unlock higher resolutions, allowing T2I diffusion models to be applied to image SR tasks without limitation on resolution. △ Less

Submitted 18 November, 2024; originally announced November 2024.

A Low-Resolution Image is Worth 1x1 Words: Enabling Fine Image Super-Resolution with Transformers and TaylorShift

Authors: Sanath Budakegowdanadoddi Nagaraju, Brian Bernhard Moser, Tobias Christian Nauen, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Transformer-based Super-Resolution (SR) models have recently advanced image reconstruction quality, yet challenges remain due to computational complexity and an over-reliance on large patch sizes, which constrain fine-grained detail enhancement. In this work, we propose TaylorIR to address these limitations by utilizing a patch size of 1x1, enabling pixel-level processing in any transformer-based… ▽ More Transformer-based Super-Resolution (SR) models have recently advanced image reconstruction quality, yet challenges remain due to computational complexity and an over-reliance on large patch sizes, which constrain fine-grained detail enhancement. In this work, we propose TaylorIR to address these limitations by utilizing a patch size of 1x1, enabling pixel-level processing in any transformer-based SR model. To address the significant computational demands under the traditional self-attention mechanism, we employ the TaylorShift attention mechanism, a memory-efficient alternative based on Taylor series expansion, achieving full token-to-token interactions with linear complexity. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach achieves new state-of-the-art SR performance while reducing memory consumption by up to 60% compared to traditional self-attention-based transformers. △ Less

Submitted 15 November, 2024; originally announced November 2024.

FedAD-Bench: A Unified Benchmark for Federated Unsupervised Anomaly Detection in Tabular Data

Authors: Ahmed Anwar, Brian Moser, Dayananda Herurkar, Federico Raue, Vinit Hegiste, Tatjana Legler, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: The emergence of federated learning (FL) presents a promising approach to leverage decentralized data while preserving privacy. Furthermore, the combination of FL and anomaly detection is particularly compelling because it allows for detecting rare and critical anomalies (usually also rare in locally gathered data) in sensitive data from multiple sources, such as cybersecurity and healthcare. Howe… ▽ More The emergence of federated learning (FL) presents a promising approach to leverage decentralized data while preserving privacy. Furthermore, the combination of FL and anomaly detection is particularly compelling because it allows for detecting rare and critical anomalies (usually also rare in locally gathered data) in sensitive data from multiple sources, such as cybersecurity and healthcare. However, benchmarking the performance of anomaly detection methods in FL environments remains an underexplored area. This paper introduces FedAD-Bench, a unified benchmark for evaluating unsupervised anomaly detection algorithms within the context of FL. We systematically analyze and compare the performance of recent deep learning anomaly detection models under federated settings, which were typically assessed solely in centralized settings. FedAD-Bench encompasses diverse datasets and metrics to provide a holistic evaluation. Through extensive experiments, we identify key challenges such as model aggregation inefficiencies and metric unreliability. We present insights into FL's regularization effects, revealing scenarios in which it outperforms centralized approaches due to its inherent ability to mitigate overfitting. Our work aims to establish a standardized benchmark to guide future research and development in federated anomaly detection, promoting reproducibility and fair comparison across studies. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2024; originally announced August 2024.

Comments: 8 pages, 1 figure

Federated Learning for Blind Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Ahmed Anwar, Federico Raue, Stanislav Frolov, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Traditional blind image SR methods need to model real-world degradations precisely. Consequently, current research struggles with this dilemma by assuming idealized degradations, which leads to limited applicability to actual user data. Moreover, the ideal scenario - training models on data from the targeted user base - presents significant privacy concerns. To address both challenges, we propose… ▽ More Traditional blind image SR methods need to model real-world degradations precisely. Consequently, current research struggles with this dilemma by assuming idealized degradations, which leads to limited applicability to actual user data. Moreover, the ideal scenario - training models on data from the targeted user base - presents significant privacy concerns. To address both challenges, we propose to fuse image SR with federated learning, allowing real-world degradations to be directly learned from users without invading their privacy. Furthermore, it enables optimization across many devices without data centralization. As this fusion is underexplored, we introduce new benchmarks specifically designed to evaluate new SR methods in this federated setting. By doing so, we employ known degradation modeling techniques from SR research. However, rather than aiming to mirror real degradations, our benchmarks use these degradation models to simulate the variety of degradations found across clients within a distributed user base. This distinction is crucial as it circumvents the need to precisely model real-world degradations, which limits contemporary blind image SR research. Our proposed benchmarks investigate blind image SR under new aspects, namely differently distributed degradation types among users and varying user numbers. We believe new methods tested within these benchmarks will perform more similarly in an application, as the simulated scenario addresses the variety while federated learning enables the training on actual degradations. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

A Study in Dataset Pruning for Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: In image Super-Resolution (SR), relying on large datasets for training is a double-edged sword. While offering rich training material, they also demand substantial computational and storage resources. In this work, we analyze dataset pruning to solve these challenges. We introduce a novel approach that reduces a dataset to a core-set of training samples, selected based on their loss values as dete… ▽ More In image Super-Resolution (SR), relying on large datasets for training is a double-edged sword. While offering rich training material, they also demand substantial computational and storage resources. In this work, we analyze dataset pruning to solve these challenges. We introduce a novel approach that reduces a dataset to a core-set of training samples, selected based on their loss values as determined by a simple pre-trained SR model. By focusing the training on just 50\% of the original dataset, specifically on the samples characterized by the highest loss values, we achieve results comparable to or surpassing those obtained from training on the entire dataset. Interestingly, our analysis reveals that the top 5\% of samples with the highest loss values negatively affect the training process. Excluding these samples and adjusting the selection to favor easier samples further enhances training outcomes. Our work opens new perspectives to the untapped potential of dataset pruning in image SR. It suggests that careful selection of training data based on loss-value metrics can lead to better SR models, challenging the conventional wisdom that more data inevitably leads to better performance. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2024; v1 submitted 25 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Latent Dataset Distillation with Diffusion Models

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Federico Raue, Sebastian Palacio, Stanislav Frolov, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Machine learning traditionally relies on increasingly larger datasets. Yet, such datasets pose major storage challenges and usually contain non-influential samples, which could be ignored during training without negatively impacting the training quality. In response, the idea of distilling a dataset into a condensed set of synthetic samples, i.e., a distilled dataset, emerged. One key aspect is th… ▽ More Machine learning traditionally relies on increasingly larger datasets. Yet, such datasets pose major storage challenges and usually contain non-influential samples, which could be ignored during training without negatively impacting the training quality. In response, the idea of distilling a dataset into a condensed set of synthetic samples, i.e., a distilled dataset, emerged. One key aspect is the selected architecture, usually ConvNet, for linking the original and synthetic datasets. However, the final accuracy is lower if the employed model architecture differs from that used during distillation. Another challenge is the generation of high-resolution images (128x128 and higher). To address both challenges, this paper proposes Latent Dataset Distillation with Diffusion Models (LD3M) that combine diffusion in latent space with dataset distillation. Our novel diffusion process is tailored for this task and significantly improves the gradient flow for distillation. By adjusting the number of diffusion steps, LD3M also offers a convenient way of controlling the trade-off between distillation speed and dataset quality. Overall, LD3M consistently outperforms state-of-the-art methods by up to 4.8 p.p. and 4.2 p.p. for 1 and 10 images per class, respectively, and on several ImageNet subsets and high resolutions (128x128 and 256x256). △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2024; v1 submitted 6 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Diffusion Models, Image Super-Resolution And Everything: A Survey

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Arundhati S. Shanbhag, Federico Raue, Stanislav Frolov, Sebastian Palacio, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Diffusion Models (DMs) have disrupted the image Super-Resolution (SR) field and further closed the gap between image quality and human perceptual preferences. They are easy to train and can produce very high-quality samples that exceed the realism of those produced by previous generative methods. Despite their promising results, they also come with new challenges that need further research: high c… ▽ More Diffusion Models (DMs) have disrupted the image Super-Resolution (SR) field and further closed the gap between image quality and human perceptual preferences. They are easy to train and can produce very high-quality samples that exceed the realism of those produced by previous generative methods. Despite their promising results, they also come with new challenges that need further research: high computational demands, comparability, lack of explainability, color shifts, and more. Unfortunately, entry into this field is overwhelming because of the abundance of publications. To address this, we provide a unified recount of the theoretical foundations underlying DMs applied to image SR and offer a detailed analysis that underscores the unique characteristics and methodologies within this domain, distinct from broader existing reviews in the field. This survey articulates a cohesive understanding of DM principles and explores current research avenues, including alternative input domains, conditioning techniques, guidance mechanisms, corruption spaces, and zero-shot learning approaches. By offering a detailed examination of the evolution and current trends in image SR through the lens of DMs, this survey sheds light on the existing challenges and charts potential future directions, aiming to inspire further innovation in this rapidly advancing area. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2024; v1 submitted 1 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Which Transformer to Favor: A Comparative Analysis of Efficiency in Vision Transformers

Authors: Tobias Christian Nauen, Sebastian Palacio, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Self-attention in Transformers comes with a high computational cost because of their quadratic computational complexity, but their effectiveness in addressing problems in language and vision has sparked extensive research aimed at enhancing their efficiency. However, diverse experimental conditions, spanning multiple input domains, prevent a fair comparison based solely on reported results, posing… ▽ More Self-attention in Transformers comes with a high computational cost because of their quadratic computational complexity, but their effectiveness in addressing problems in language and vision has sparked extensive research aimed at enhancing their efficiency. However, diverse experimental conditions, spanning multiple input domains, prevent a fair comparison based solely on reported results, posing challenges for model selection. To address this gap in comparability, we perform a large-scale benchmark of more than 45 models for image classification, evaluating key efficiency aspects, including accuracy, speed, and memory usage. Our benchmark provides a standardized baseline for efficiency-oriented transformers. We analyze the results based on the Pareto front -- the boundary of optimal models. Surprisingly, despite claims of other models being more efficient, ViT remains Pareto optimal across multiple metrics. We observe that hybrid attention-CNN models exhibit remarkable inference memory- and parameter-efficiency. Moreover, our benchmark shows that using a larger model in general is more efficient than using higher resolution images. Thanks to our holistic evaluation, we provide a centralized resource for practitioners and researchers, facilitating informed decisions when selecting or developing efficient transformers. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2025; v1 submitted 18 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: v3: new models, analysis of scaling behaviors; v4: WACV 2025 camera ready version, appendix added

MSC Class: 68T07 ACM Class: I.4.0; I.2.10; I.5.1

Dynamic Attention-Guided Diffusion for Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Sebastian Palacio, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Diffusion models in image Super-Resolution (SR) treat all image regions uniformly, which risks compromising the overall image quality by potentially introducing artifacts during denoising of less-complex regions. To address this, we propose ``You Only Diffuse Areas'' (YODA), a dynamic attention-guided diffusion process for image SR. YODA selectively focuses on spatial regions defined by attention… ▽ More Diffusion models in image Super-Resolution (SR) treat all image regions uniformly, which risks compromising the overall image quality by potentially introducing artifacts during denoising of less-complex regions. To address this, we propose ``You Only Diffuse Areas'' (YODA), a dynamic attention-guided diffusion process for image SR. YODA selectively focuses on spatial regions defined by attention maps derived from the low-resolution images and the current denoising time step. This time-dependent targeting enables a more efficient conversion to high-resolution outputs by focusing on areas that benefit the most from the iterative refinement process, i.e., detail-rich objects. We empirically validate YODA by extending leading diffusion-based methods SR3, DiffBIR, and SRDiff. Our experiments demonstrate new state-of-the-art performances in face and general SR tasks across PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS metrics. As a side effect, we find that YODA reduces color shift issues and stabilizes training with small batches. △ Less

Submitted 22 November, 2024; v1 submitted 15 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Comments: Brian B. Moser and Stanislav Frolov contributed equally

DWA: Differential Wavelet Amplifier for Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian B. Moser, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Sebastian Palacio, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: This work introduces Differential Wavelet Amplifier (DWA), a drop-in module for wavelet-based image Super-Resolution (SR). DWA invigorates an approach recently receiving less attention, namely Discrete Wavelet Transformation (DWT). DWT enables an efficient image representation for SR and reduces the spatial area of its input by a factor of 4, the overall model size, and computation cost, framing i… ▽ More This work introduces Differential Wavelet Amplifier (DWA), a drop-in module for wavelet-based image Super-Resolution (SR). DWA invigorates an approach recently receiving less attention, namely Discrete Wavelet Transformation (DWT). DWT enables an efficient image representation for SR and reduces the spatial area of its input by a factor of 4, the overall model size, and computation cost, framing it as an attractive approach for sustainable ML. Our proposed DWA model improves wavelet-based SR models by leveraging the difference between two convolutional filters to refine relevant feature extraction in the wavelet domain, emphasizing local contrasts and suppressing common noise in the input signals. We show its effectiveness by integrating it into existing SR models, e.g., DWSR and MWCNN, and demonstrate a clear improvement in classical SR tasks. Moreover, DWA enables a direct application of DWSR and MWCNN to input image space, reducing the DWT representation channel-wise since it omits traditional DWT. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

DartsReNet: Exploring new RNN cells in ReNet architectures

Authors: Brian Moser, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: We present new Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) cells for image classification using a Neural Architecture Search (NAS) approach called DARTS. We are interested in the ReNet architecture, which is a RNN based approach presented as an alternative for convolutional and pooling steps. ReNet can be defined using any standard RNN cells, such as LSTM and GRU. One limitation is that standard RNN cells were… ▽ More We present new Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) cells for image classification using a Neural Architecture Search (NAS) approach called DARTS. We are interested in the ReNet architecture, which is a RNN based approach presented as an alternative for convolutional and pooling steps. ReNet can be defined using any standard RNN cells, such as LSTM and GRU. One limitation is that standard RNN cells were designed for one dimensional sequential data and not for two dimensions like it is the case for image classification. We overcome this limitation by using DARTS to find new cell designs. We compare our results with ReNet that uses GRU and LSTM cells. Our found cells outperform the standard RNN cells on CIFAR-10 and SVHN. The improvements on SVHN indicate generalizability, as we derived the RNN cell designs from CIFAR-10 without performing a new cell search for SVHN. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Waving Goodbye to Low-Res: A Diffusion-Wavelet Approach for Image Super-Resolution

Authors: Brian Moser, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Sebastian Palacio, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: This paper presents a novel Diffusion-Wavelet (DiWa) approach for Single-Image Super-Resolution (SISR). It leverages the strengths of Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) and Discrete Wavelet Transformation (DWT). By enabling DDPMs to operate in the DWT domain, our DDPM models effectively hallucinate high-frequency information for super-resolved images on the wavelet spectrum, resultin… ▽ More This paper presents a novel Diffusion-Wavelet (DiWa) approach for Single-Image Super-Resolution (SISR). It leverages the strengths of Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) and Discrete Wavelet Transformation (DWT). By enabling DDPMs to operate in the DWT domain, our DDPM models effectively hallucinate high-frequency information for super-resolved images on the wavelet spectrum, resulting in high-quality and detailed reconstructions in image space. Quantitatively, we outperform state-of-the-art diffusion-based SISR methods, namely SR3 and SRDiff, regarding PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS on both face (8x scaling) and general (4x scaling) SR benchmarks. Meanwhile, using DWT enabled us to use fewer parameters than the compared models: 92M parameters instead of 550M compared to SR3 and 9.3M instead of 12M compared to SRDiff. Additionally, our method outperforms other state-of-the-art generative methods on classical general SR datasets while saving inference time. Finally, our work highlights its potential for various applications. △ Less

Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 4 April, 2023; originally announced April 2023.

Hitchhiker's Guide to Super-Resolution: Introduction and Recent Advances

Authors: Brian Moser, Federico Raue, Stanislav Frolov, Jörn Hees, Sebastian Palacio, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: With the advent of Deep Learning (DL), Super-Resolution (SR) has also become a thriving research area. However, despite promising results, the field still faces challenges that require further research e.g., allowing flexible upsampling, more effective loss functions, and better evaluation metrics. We review the domain of SR in light of recent advances, and examine state-of-the-art models such as… ▽ More With the advent of Deep Learning (DL), Super-Resolution (SR) has also become a thriving research area. However, despite promising results, the field still faces challenges that require further research e.g., allowing flexible upsampling, more effective loss functions, and better evaluation metrics. We review the domain of SR in light of recent advances, and examine state-of-the-art models such as diffusion (DDPM) and transformer-based SR models. We present a critical discussion on contemporary strategies used in SR, and identify promising yet unexplored research directions. We complement previous surveys by incorporating the latest developments in the field such as uncertainty-driven losses, wavelet networks, neural architecture search, novel normalization methods, and the latests evaluation techniques. We also include several visualizations for the models and methods throughout each chapter in order to facilitate a global understanding of the trends in the field. This review is ultimately aimed at helping researchers to push the boundaries of DL applied to SR. △ Less

Submitted 14 February, 2023; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: accepted by IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2023

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, 2023

Less is More: Proxy Datasets in NAS approaches

Authors: Brian Moser, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Neural Architecture Search (NAS) defines the design of Neural Networks as a search problem. Unfortunately, NAS is computationally intensive because of various possibilities depending on the number of elements in the design and the possible connections between them. In this work, we extensively analyze the role of the dataset size based on several sampling approaches for reducing the dataset size (… ▽ More Neural Architecture Search (NAS) defines the design of Neural Networks as a search problem. Unfortunately, NAS is computationally intensive because of various possibilities depending on the number of elements in the design and the possible connections between them. In this work, we extensively analyze the role of the dataset size based on several sampling approaches for reducing the dataset size (unsupervised and supervised cases) as an agnostic approach to reduce search time. We compared these techniques with four common NAS approaches in NAS-Bench-201 in roughly 1,400 experiments on CIFAR-100. One of our surprising findings is that in most cases we can reduce the amount of training data to 25\%, consequently reducing search time to 25\%, while at the same time maintaining the same accuracy as if training on the full dataset. Additionally, some designs derived from subsets out-perform designs derived from the full dataset by up to 22 p.p. accuracy. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Journal ref: 2022 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition Workshops (CVPRW)

Spatial Transformer Networks for Curriculum Learning

Authors: Fatemeh Azimi, Jean-Francois Jacques Nicolas Nies, Sebastian Palacio, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Curriculum learning is a bio-inspired training technique that is widely adopted to machine learning for improved optimization and better training of neural networks regarding the convergence rate or obtained accuracy. The main concept in curriculum learning is to start the training with simpler tasks and gradually increase the level of difficulty. Therefore, a natural question is how to determine… ▽ More Curriculum learning is a bio-inspired training technique that is widely adopted to machine learning for improved optimization and better training of neural networks regarding the convergence rate or obtained accuracy. The main concept in curriculum learning is to start the training with simpler tasks and gradually increase the level of difficulty. Therefore, a natural question is how to determine or generate these simpler tasks. In this work, we take inspiration from Spatial Transformer Networks (STNs) in order to form an easy-to-hard curriculum. As STNs have been proven to be capable of removing the clutter from the input images and obtaining higher accuracy in image classification tasks, we hypothesize that images processed by STNs can be seen as easier tasks and utilized in the interest of curriculum learning. To this end, we study multiple strategies developed for shaping the training curriculum, using the data generated by STNs. We perform various experiments on cluttered MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets, where on the former, we obtain an improvement of $3.8$pp in classification accuracy compared to the baseline. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

A Reinforcement Learning Approach for Sequential Spatial Transformer Networks

Authors: Fatemeh Azimi, Federico Raue, Joern Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Spatial Transformer Networks (STN) can generate geometric transformations which modify input images to improve the classifier's performance. In this work, we combine the idea of STN with Reinforcement Learning (RL). To this end, we break the affine transformation down into a sequence of simple and discrete transformations. We formulate the task as a Markovian Decision Process (MDP) and use RL to s… ▽ More Spatial Transformer Networks (STN) can generate geometric transformations which modify input images to improve the classifier's performance. In this work, we combine the idea of STN with Reinforcement Learning (RL). To this end, we break the affine transformation down into a sequence of simple and discrete transformations. We formulate the task as a Markovian Decision Process (MDP) and use RL to solve this sequential decision-making problem. STN architectures learn the transformation parameters by minimizing the classification error and backpropagating the gradients through a sub-differentiable sampling module. In our method, we are not bound to the differentiability of the sampling modules. Moreover, we have freedom in designing the objective rather than only minimizing the error; e.g., we can directly set the target as maximizing the accuracy. We design multiple experiments to verify the effectiveness of our method using cluttered MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets and show that our method outperforms STN with a proper definition of MDP components. △ Less

Submitted 27 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

AudioCLIP: Extending CLIP to Image, Text and Audio

Authors: Andrey Guzhov, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: In the past, the rapidly evolving field of sound classification greatly benefited from the application of methods from other domains. Today, we observe the trend to fuse domain-specific tasks and approaches together, which provides the community with new outstanding models. In this work, we present an extension of the CLIP model that handles audio in addition to text and images. Our proposed mod… ▽ More In the past, the rapidly evolving field of sound classification greatly benefited from the application of methods from other domains. Today, we observe the trend to fuse domain-specific tasks and approaches together, which provides the community with new outstanding models. In this work, we present an extension of the CLIP model that handles audio in addition to text and images. Our proposed model incorporates the ESResNeXt audio-model into the CLIP framework using the AudioSet dataset. Such a combination enables the proposed model to perform bimodal and unimodal classification and querying, while keeping CLIP's ability to generalize to unseen datasets in a zero-shot inference fashion. AudioCLIP achieves new state-of-the-art results in the Environmental Sound Classification (ESC) task, out-performing other approaches by reaching accuracies of 90.07% on the UrbanSound8K and 97.15% on the ESC-50 datasets. Further it sets new baselines in the zero-shot ESC-task on the same datasets (68.78% and 69.40%, respectively). Finally, we also assess the cross-modal querying performance of the proposed model as well as the influence of full and partial training on the results. For the sake of reproducibility, our code is published. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: submitted to GCPR 2021

Combining Transformer Generators with Convolutional Discriminators

Authors: Ricard Durall, Stanislav Frolov, Jörn Hees, Federico Raue, Franz-Josef Pfreundt, Andreas Dengel, Janis Keupe

Abstract: Transformer models have recently attracted much interest from computer vision researchers and have since been successfully employed for several problems traditionally addressed with convolutional neural networks. At the same time, image synthesis using generative adversarial networks (GANs) has drastically improved over the last few years. The recently proposed TransGAN is the first GAN using only… ▽ More Transformer models have recently attracted much interest from computer vision researchers and have since been successfully employed for several problems traditionally addressed with convolutional neural networks. At the same time, image synthesis using generative adversarial networks (GANs) has drastically improved over the last few years. The recently proposed TransGAN is the first GAN using only transformer-based architectures and achieves competitive results when compared to convolutional GANs. However, since transformers are data-hungry architectures, TransGAN requires data augmentation, an auxiliary super-resolution task during training, and a masking prior to guide the self-attention mechanism. In this paper, we study the combination of a transformer-based generator and convolutional discriminator and successfully remove the need of the aforementioned required design choices. We evaluate our approach by conducting a benchmark of well-known CNN discriminators, ablate the size of the transformer-based generator, and show that combining both architectural elements into a hybrid model leads to better results. Furthermore, we investigate the frequency spectrum properties of generated images and observe that our model retains the benefits of an attention based generator. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2021; v1 submitted 21 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

ESResNe(X)t-fbsp: Learning Robust Time-Frequency Transformation of Audio

Authors: Andrey Guzhov, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Environmental Sound Classification (ESC) is a rapidly evolving field that recently demonstrated the advantages of application of visual domain techniques to the audio-related tasks. Previous studies indicate that the domain-specific modification of cross-domain approaches show a promise in pushing the whole area of ESC forward. In this paper, we present a new time-frequency transformation layer… ▽ More Environmental Sound Classification (ESC) is a rapidly evolving field that recently demonstrated the advantages of application of visual domain techniques to the audio-related tasks. Previous studies indicate that the domain-specific modification of cross-domain approaches show a promise in pushing the whole area of ESC forward. In this paper, we present a new time-frequency transformation layer that is based on complex frequency B-spline (fbsp) wavelets. Being used with a high-performance audio classification model, the proposed fbsp-layer provides an accuracy improvement over the previously used Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) on standard datasets. We also investigate the influence of different pre-training strategies, including the joint use of two large-scale datasets for weight initialization: ImageNet and AudioSet. Our proposed model out-performs other approaches by achieving accuracies of 95.20 % on the ESC-50 and 89.14 % on the UrbanSound8K datasets. Additionally, we assess the increase of model robustness against additive white Gaussian noise and reduction of an effective sample rate introduced by the proposed layer and demonstrate that the fbsp-layer improves the model's ability to withstand signal perturbations, in comparison to STFT-based training. For the sake of reproducibility, our code is made available. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: submitted IJCNN 2021

AttrLostGAN: Attribute Controlled Image Synthesis from Reconfigurable Layout and Style

Authors: Stanislav Frolov, Avneesh Sharma, Jörn Hees, Tushar Karayil, Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Conditional image synthesis from layout has recently attracted much interest. Previous approaches condition the generator on object locations as well as class labels but lack fine-grained control over the diverse appearance aspects of individual objects. Gaining control over the image generation process is fundamental to build practical applications with a user-friendly interface. In this paper, w… ▽ More Conditional image synthesis from layout has recently attracted much interest. Previous approaches condition the generator on object locations as well as class labels but lack fine-grained control over the diverse appearance aspects of individual objects. Gaining control over the image generation process is fundamental to build practical applications with a user-friendly interface. In this paper, we propose a method for attribute controlled image synthesis from layout which allows to specify the appearance of individual objects without affecting the rest of the image. We extend a state-of-the-art approach for layout-to-image generation to additionally condition individual objects on attributes. We create and experiment on a synthetic, as well as the challenging Visual Genome dataset. Our qualitative and quantitative results show that our method can successfully control the fine-grained details of individual objects when modelling complex scenes with multiple objects. Source code, dataset and pre-trained models are publicly available (https://github.com/stanifrolov/AttrLostGAN). △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2021; v1 submitted 25 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: Accepted to GCPR 2021. Link to code: https://github.com/stanifrolov/AttrLostGAN

Adversarial Text-to-Image Synthesis: A Review

Authors: Stanislav Frolov, Tobias Hinz, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: With the advent of generative adversarial networks, synthesizing images from textual descriptions has recently become an active research area. It is a flexible and intuitive way for conditional image generation with significant progress in the last years regarding visual realism, diversity, and semantic alignment. However, the field still faces several challenges that require further research effo… ▽ More With the advent of generative adversarial networks, synthesizing images from textual descriptions has recently become an active research area. It is a flexible and intuitive way for conditional image generation with significant progress in the last years regarding visual realism, diversity, and semantic alignment. However, the field still faces several challenges that require further research efforts such as enabling the generation of high-resolution images with multiple objects, and developing suitable and reliable evaluation metrics that correlate with human judgement. In this review, we contextualize the state of the art of adversarial text-to-image synthesis models, their development since their inception five years ago, and propose a taxonomy based on the level of supervision. We critically examine current strategies to evaluate text-to-image synthesis models, highlight shortcomings, and identify new areas of research, ranging from the development of better datasets and evaluation metrics to possible improvements in architectural design and model training. This review complements previous surveys on generative adversarial networks with a focus on text-to-image synthesis which we believe will help researchers to further advance the field. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2021; v1 submitted 25 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Published at Neural Networks Journal, available at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0893608021002823

Journal ref: Neural Networks, 2021

Hybrid-S2S: Video Object Segmentation with Recurrent Networks and Correspondence Matching

Authors: Fatemeh Azimi, Stanislav Frolov, Federico Raue, Joern Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: One-shot Video Object Segmentation~(VOS) is the task of pixel-wise tracking an object of interest within a video sequence, where the segmentation mask of the first frame is given at inference time. In recent years, Recurrent Neural Networks~(RNNs) have been widely used for VOS tasks, but they often suffer from limitations such as drift and error propagation. In this work, we study an RNN-based arc… ▽ More One-shot Video Object Segmentation~(VOS) is the task of pixel-wise tracking an object of interest within a video sequence, where the segmentation mask of the first frame is given at inference time. In recent years, Recurrent Neural Networks~(RNNs) have been widely used for VOS tasks, but they often suffer from limitations such as drift and error propagation. In this work, we study an RNN-based architecture and address some of these issues by proposing a hybrid sequence-to-sequence architecture named HS2S, utilizing a dual mask propagation strategy that allows incorporating the information obtained from correspondence matching. Our experiments show that augmenting the RNN with correspondence matching is a highly effective solution to reduce the drift problem. The additional information helps the model to predict more accurate masks and makes it robust against error propagation. We evaluate our HS2S model on the DAVIS2017 dataset as well as Youtube-VOS. On the latter, we achieve an improvement of 11.2pp in the overall segmentation accuracy over RNN-based state-of-the-art methods in VOS. We analyze our model's behavior in challenging cases such as occlusion and long sequences and show that our hybrid architecture significantly enhances the segmentation quality in these difficult scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 7 November, 2020; v1 submitted 10 October, 2020; originally announced October 2020.

Revisiting Sequence-to-Sequence Video Object Segmentation with Multi-Task Loss and Skip-Memory

Authors: Fatemeh Azimi, Benjamin Bischke, Sebastian Palacio, Federico Raue, Joern Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Video Object Segmentation (VOS) is an active research area of the visual domain. One of its fundamental sub-tasks is semi-supervised / one-shot learning: given only the segmentation mask for the first frame, the task is to provide pixel-accurate masks for the object over the rest of the sequence. Despite much progress in the last years, we noticed that many of the existing approaches lose objects… ▽ More Video Object Segmentation (VOS) is an active research area of the visual domain. One of its fundamental sub-tasks is semi-supervised / one-shot learning: given only the segmentation mask for the first frame, the task is to provide pixel-accurate masks for the object over the rest of the sequence. Despite much progress in the last years, we noticed that many of the existing approaches lose objects in longer sequences, especially when the object is small or briefly occluded. In this work, we build upon a sequence-to-sequence approach that employs an encoder-decoder architecture together with a memory module for exploiting the sequential data. We further improve this approach by proposing a model that manipulates multi-scale spatio-temporal information using memory-equipped skip connections. Furthermore, we incorporate an auxiliary task based on distance classification which greatly enhances the quality of edges in segmentation masks. We compare our approach to the state of the art and show considerable improvement in the contour accuracy metric and the overall segmentation accuracy. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

ESResNet: Environmental Sound Classification Based on Visual Domain Models

Authors: Andrey Guzhov, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Environmental Sound Classification (ESC) is an active research area in the audio domain and has seen a lot of progress in the past years. However, many of the existing approaches achieve high accuracy by relying on domain-specific features and architectures, making it harder to benefit from advances in other fields (e.g., the image domain). Additionally, some of the past successes have been attrib… ▽ More Environmental Sound Classification (ESC) is an active research area in the audio domain and has seen a lot of progress in the past years. However, many of the existing approaches achieve high accuracy by relying on domain-specific features and architectures, making it harder to benefit from advances in other fields (e.g., the image domain). Additionally, some of the past successes have been attributed to a discrepancy of how results are evaluated (i.e., on unofficial splits of the UrbanSound8K (US8K) dataset), distorting the overall progression of the field. The contribution of this paper is twofold. First, we present a model that is inherently compatible with mono and stereo sound inputs. Our model is based on simple log-power Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) spectrograms and combines them with several well-known approaches from the image domain (i.e., ResNet, Siamese-like networks and attention). We investigate the influence of cross-domain pre-training, architectural changes, and evaluate our model on standard datasets. We find that our model out-performs all previously known approaches in a fair comparison by achieving accuracies of 97.0 % (ESC-10), 91.5 % (ESC-50) and 84.2 % / 85.4 % (US8K mono / stereo). Second, we provide a comprehensive overview of the actual state of the field, by differentiating several previously reported results on the US8K dataset between official or unofficial splits. For better reproducibility, our code (including any re-implementations) is made available. △ Less

Submitted 15 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Comments: 8 pages, 4 figures; submitted to ICPR 2020

P $\approx$ NP, at least in Visual Question Answering

Authors: Shailza Jolly, Sebastian Palacio, Joachim Folz, Federico Raue, Joern Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: In recent years, progress in the Visual Question Answering (VQA) field has largely been driven by public challenges and large datasets. One of the most widely-used of these is the VQA 2.0 dataset, consisting of polar ("yes/no") and non-polar questions. Looking at the question distribution over all answers, we find that the answers "yes" and "no" account for 38 % of the questions, while the remaini… ▽ More In recent years, progress in the Visual Question Answering (VQA) field has largely been driven by public challenges and large datasets. One of the most widely-used of these is the VQA 2.0 dataset, consisting of polar ("yes/no") and non-polar questions. Looking at the question distribution over all answers, we find that the answers "yes" and "no" account for 38 % of the questions, while the remaining 62% are spread over the more than 3000 remaining answers. While several sources of biases have already been investigated in the field, the effects of such an over-representation of polar vs. non-polar questions remain unclear. In this paper, we measure the potential confounding factors when polar and non-polar samples are used jointly to train a baseline VQA classifier, and compare it to an upper bound where the over-representation of polar questions is excluded from the training. Further, we perform cross-over experiments to analyze how well the feature spaces align. Contrary to expectations, we find no evidence of counterproductive effects in the joint training of unbalanced classes. In fact, by exploring the intermediate feature space of visual-text embeddings, we find that the feature space of polar questions already encodes sufficient structure to answer many non-polar questions. Our results indicate that the polar (P) and the non-polar (NP) feature spaces are strongly aligned, hence the expression P $\approx$ NP △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2020; v1 submitted 26 March, 2020; originally announced March 2020.

Fusion Strategies for Learning User Embeddings with Neural Networks

Authors: Philipp Blandfort, Tushar Karayil, Federico Raue, Jörn Hees, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: Growing amounts of online user data motivate the need for automated processing techniques. In case of user ratings, one interesting option is to use neural networks for learning to predict ratings given an item and a user. While training for prediction, such an approach at the same time learns to map each user to a vector, a so-called user embedding. Such embeddings can for example be valuable for… ▽ More Growing amounts of online user data motivate the need for automated processing techniques. In case of user ratings, one interesting option is to use neural networks for learning to predict ratings given an item and a user. While training for prediction, such an approach at the same time learns to map each user to a vector, a so-called user embedding. Such embeddings can for example be valuable for estimating user similarity. However, there are various ways how item and user information can be combined in neural networks, and it is unclear how the way of combining affects the resulting embeddings. In this paper, we run an experiment on movie ratings data, where we analyze the effect on embedding quality caused by several fusion strategies in neural networks. For evaluating embedding quality, we propose a novel measure, Pair-Distance Correlation, which quantifies the condition that similar users should have similar embedding vectors. We find that the fusion strategy affects results in terms of both prediction performance and embedding quality. Surprisingly, we find that prediction performance not necessarily reflects embedding quality. This suggests that if embeddings are of interest, the common tendency to select models based on their prediction ability should be reconsidered. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: submitted to IJCNN 2019

What do Deep Networks Like to See?

Authors: Sebastian Palacio, Joachim Folz, Jörn Hees, Federico Raue, Damian Borth, Andreas Dengel

Abstract: We propose a novel way to measure and understand convolutional neural networks by quantifying the amount of input signal they let in. To do this, an autoencoder (AE) was fine-tuned on gradients from a pre-trained classifier with fixed parameters. We compared the reconstructed samples from AEs that were fine-tuned on a set of image classifiers (AlexNet, VGG16, ResNet-50, and Inception~v3) and found… ▽ More We propose a novel way to measure and understand convolutional neural networks by quantifying the amount of input signal they let in. To do this, an autoencoder (AE) was fine-tuned on gradients from a pre-trained classifier with fixed parameters. We compared the reconstructed samples from AEs that were fine-tuned on a set of image classifiers (AlexNet, VGG16, ResNet-50, and Inception~v3) and found substantial differences. The AE learns which aspects of the input space to preserve and which ones to ignore, based on the information encoded in the backpropagated gradients. Measuring the changes in accuracy when the signal of one classifier is used by a second one, a relation of total order emerges. This order depends directly on each classifier's input signal but it does not correlate with classification accuracy or network size. Further evidence of this phenomenon is provided by measuring the normalized mutual information between original images and auto-encoded reconstructions from different fine-tuned AEs. These findings break new ground in the area of neural network understanding, opening a new way to reason, debug, and interpret their results. We present four concrete examples in the literature where observations can now be explained in terms of the input signal that a model uses. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Symbol Grounding Association in Multimodal Sequences with Missing Elements

Authors: Federico Raue, Andreas Dengel, Thomas M. Breuel, Marcus Liwicki

Abstract: In this paper, we extend a symbolic association framework for being able to handle missing elements in multimodal sequences. The general scope of the work is the symbolic associations of object-word mappings as it happens in language development in infants. In other words, two different representations of the same abstract concepts can associate in both directions. This scenario has been long inte… ▽ More In this paper, we extend a symbolic association framework for being able to handle missing elements in multimodal sequences. The general scope of the work is the symbolic associations of object-word mappings as it happens in language development in infants. In other words, two different representations of the same abstract concepts can associate in both directions. This scenario has been long interested in Artificial Intelligence, Psychology, and Neuroscience. In this work, we extend a recent approach for multimodal sequences (visual and audio) to also cope with missing elements in one or both modalities. Our method uses two parallel Long Short-Term Memories (LSTMs) with a learning rule based on EM-algorithm. It aligns both LSTM outputs via Dynamic Time Warping (DTW). We propose to include an extra step for the combination with the max operation for exploiting the common elements between both sequences. The motivation behind is that the combination acts as a condition selector for choosing the best representation from both LSTMs. We evaluated the proposed extension in the following scenarios: missing elements in one modality (visual or audio) and missing elements in both modalities (visual and sound). The performance of our extension reaches better results than the original model and similar results to individual LSTM trained in each modality. △ Less

Submitted 7 December, 2017; v1 submitted 13 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: Under review on Journal of Artificial Intelligence Research (JAIR) -- Special Track on Deep Learning, Knowledge Representation, and Reasoning