-
From deconfinement to nuclear matter: mean-field approaches for effective Polyakov loop theories of lattice QCD
Authors:
Christoph Konrad,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Numerical studies of the QCD phase diagram at finite baryon chemical potential $μ_B$ on the lattice are impeded by a sign problem. Effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD via combined strong-coupling and hopping expansions are valid for heavy quarks only, but tractable with a significantly less severe sign problem. In this work, we apply three mean-field approximations to these e…
▽ More
Numerical studies of the QCD phase diagram at finite baryon chemical potential $μ_B$ on the lattice are impeded by a sign problem. Effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD via combined strong-coupling and hopping expansions are valid for heavy quarks only, but tractable with a significantly less severe sign problem. In this work, we apply three mean-field approximations to these effective theories, each incorporating local fluctuations to different degrees. We compare their predictions against Monte Carlo results for the deconfinement transition at high temperatures and for the baryon onset transition at low temperatures. In agreement with earlier effective theory simulations, we find a first-order nuclear liquid-gas transition with a critical end point for very low temperatures and moderately heavy quarks. While the location of fluctuation-dominated critical end points is expectedly inaccurate, the phase diagram of lattice QCD with heavy quarks can be determined qualitatively with entirely analytical methods.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2025;
originally announced September 2025.
-
Goldstone bosons across thermal phase transitions
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Temperature has a significant effect on the properties of quantum field theories (QFTs) with a spontaneously broken symmetry, in particular on the massless Goldstone bosons that exist in the vacuum state. It has recently been shown using lattice calculations for a $\mathrm{U}(1)$ complex scalar field theory that the Goldstone mode persists even when the symmetry is restored above the critical temp…
▽ More
Temperature has a significant effect on the properties of quantum field theories (QFTs) with a spontaneously broken symmetry, in particular on the massless Goldstone bosons that exist in the vacuum state. It has recently been shown using lattice calculations for a $\mathrm{U}(1)$ complex scalar field theory that the Goldstone mode persists even when the symmetry is restored above the critical temperature $T_{c}$, and has the properties of a screened massless excitation, a so-called thermoparticle. In this work, we continue the investigation of this theory by determining explicitly how the Goldstone mode evolves as the temperature is increased both below and above $T_{c}$. We find that the two phases of the theory are entirely characterised by the thermal dissipative effects experienced by the Goldstone mode, with the broken and symmetry-restored phases associated with weak and strong damping, respectively. These findings are consistent with the non-perturbative constraints imposed by spontaneous symmetry breaking, and provide a new way in which to characterise thermal phase transitions in QFTs.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2025;
originally announced July 2025.
-
Lattice Monte Carlo meets lattice functional Renormalization Group: A quantitative comparison
Authors:
Niklas Zorbach,
Jan Philipp Klinger,
Owe Philipsen,
Jens Braun
Abstract:
Lattice Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and the functional Renormalization Group (RG) are powerful approaches that allow for quantitative studies of non-perturbative phenomena such as bound-state formation, spontaneous symmetry breaking and phase transitions. While results from both methods have recently shown remarkable agreement for many observables, e.g., in Quantum Chromodynamics, an analysis of…
▽ More
Lattice Monte Carlo (MC) simulations and the functional Renormalization Group (RG) are powerful approaches that allow for quantitative studies of non-perturbative phenomena such as bound-state formation, spontaneous symmetry breaking and phase transitions. While results from both methods have recently shown remarkable agreement for many observables, e.g., in Quantum Chromodynamics, an analysis of deviations in certain quantities turns out to be challenging. This is because calculations with the two methods are based on different approximations, regularizations and scale fixing procedures. In the present work, we present a framework for a more direct comparison by formulating the functional RG approach on a finite spacetime lattice. This removes all ambiguities of regularization, finite size and scale fixing procedures in concrete studies. By investigating the emergence of spontaneous symmetry breaking and phase transitions in a $Z(2)$ scalar theory in $d=1,2,3$ spacetime dimensions, we demonstrate at the example of the local potential approximation how this framework can be used to evaluate and compare the systematic errors of both approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Pion condensation at non-zero isospin chemical potential with Wilson fermions
Authors:
Rocco Francesco Basta,
Bastian B. Brandt,
Francesca Cuteri,
Gergely Endrődi,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
In contrast to the case of non-zero baryon chemical potential, the isospin chemical potential does not introduce a sign problem and can be simulated on the lattice. When the isospin chemical potential is large enough, a phase transition to a Bose-Einstein condensate of pions takes place. Currently available results in the literature on the phase diagram and the equation of state in this setup empl…
▽ More
In contrast to the case of non-zero baryon chemical potential, the isospin chemical potential does not introduce a sign problem and can be simulated on the lattice. When the isospin chemical potential is large enough, a phase transition to a Bose-Einstein condensate of pions takes place. Currently available results in the literature on the phase diagram and the equation of state in this setup employ staggered fermions. We present preliminary results on the onset of the pion condensation phase in simulations with Wilson fermions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
The order of the chiral phase transition in massless many-flavour lattice QCD
Authors:
Jan Philipp Klinger,
Reinhold Kaiser,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
The nature of the QCD phase transition in the chiral limit presents a challenging problem for lattice QCD. However, its study provides constraints on the phase diagram at the physical point. In this work, we investigate how the order of the chiral phase transition depends on the number of light quark flavours. To approach the lattice chiral limit, we map out and extrapolate the chiral critical sur…
▽ More
The nature of the QCD phase transition in the chiral limit presents a challenging problem for lattice QCD. However, its study provides constraints on the phase diagram at the physical point. In this work, we investigate how the order of the chiral phase transition depends on the number of light quark flavours. To approach the lattice chiral limit, we map out and extrapolate the chiral critical surface that separates the first-order region from the crossover region in an extended parameter space, which includes the gauge coupling, the number of quark flavours, their masses, and the lattice spacing. Lattice simulations with standard staggered quarks reveal that for each $N_f < 8$, there exists a tricritical lattice spacing $a^\text{tric}(N_f)$, at which the chiral transition changes from first order ($a>a^\text{tric}$) to second order ($a<a^\text{tric}$). Thus, the first-order region is merely a lattice artifact and not connected to the continuum. By determining the associated temperatures $T(N_f^\text{tric},a ^\text{tric})$ at these tricritical points, we confirm the expected decrease in the critical temperature as the number of flavours increases. The obtained temperatures define a tricritical line which is connected to the continuum and terminates at a physical $ N_f^\text{tric}(a=0) $. Our data is compatible with a vanishing temperature at that point, $T(N_f^\text{tric}(a=0))=0 $.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2025; v1 submitted 31 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Finite density lattice QCD via effective Polyakov loop theories
Authors:
Christoph Konrad,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
For the exploration of the phase diagram of QCD, effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD provide a valuable tool in the heavy quark mass regime. Using mean field approximations these theories are evaluated in the high and low temperature regimes at finite baryon chemical potential. The resulting phase diagram is discussed.
For the exploration of the phase diagram of QCD, effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD provide a valuable tool in the heavy quark mass regime. Using mean field approximations these theories are evaluated in the high and low temperature regimes at finite baryon chemical potential. The resulting phase diagram is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Goldstone bosons at non-zero temperature
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Spontaneous symmetry breaking in quantum field theories at non-zero temperature still holds fundamental open questions, in particular what happens to vacuum Goldstone bosons when the temperature is increased. By investigating a complex scalar field theory on the lattice we demonstrate that Goldstone bosons at non-zero temperature behave like screened massless particle-like excitations, so-called t…
▽ More
Spontaneous symmetry breaking in quantum field theories at non-zero temperature still holds fundamental open questions, in particular what happens to vacuum Goldstone bosons when the temperature is increased. By investigating a complex scalar field theory on the lattice we demonstrate that Goldstone bosons at non-zero temperature behave like screened massless particle-like excitations, so-called thermoparticles, which continue to exist even in the symmetry-restored phase of the theory. We provide non-perturbative evidence for the functional form of the Goldstone mode's dissipative behaviour, and determine its corresponding spectral properties. Since the persistence of thermal Goldstone modes within symmetry-restored phases is predicted to be a model-independent characteristic, this has fundamental consequences for systems in which continuous symmetries are restored at high temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2025; v1 submitted 28 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Spectral properties of pseudo-scalar mesons through the QCD chiral crossover
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
We summarise recent progress towards the non-perturbative determination of thermal spectral functions for pseudo-scalar mesons in QCD by exploiting constraints imposed by micro-causality at finite temperature. For temperatures not much above the vacuum particle mass, continuous contributions from scattering, Landau damping and collective excitations are found to be negligible. This allows for a qu…
▽ More
We summarise recent progress towards the non-perturbative determination of thermal spectral functions for pseudo-scalar mesons in QCD by exploiting constraints imposed by micro-causality at finite temperature. For temperatures not much above the vacuum particle mass, continuous contributions from scattering, Landau damping and collective excitations are found to be negligible. This allows for a quantitative description of spatial and temporal lattice correlators in terms of thermoparticles, i.e.~vacuum excitations modified by medium effects, with resonance-like structures persisting for a range above the chiral crossover.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Non-perturbative constraints on perturbation theory at finite temperature
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
It has long been understood that the inclusion of temperature in the perturbative treatment of quantum field theories leads to complications that are not present at zero temperature. In these proceedings we report on the non-perturbative obstructions that arise, and how these lead to deviations in the predictions of lattice scalar correlation functions in massive $φ^{4}$ theory. Using the known no…
▽ More
It has long been understood that the inclusion of temperature in the perturbative treatment of quantum field theories leads to complications that are not present at zero temperature. In these proceedings we report on the non-perturbative obstructions that arise, and how these lead to deviations in the predictions of lattice scalar correlation functions in massive $φ^{4}$ theory. Using the known non-perturbative spectral constraints satisfied by finite-temperature correlation functions we outline why the presence of distinct particle-like excitations could provide a resolution to these issues.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2025; v1 submitted 3 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Quantum computational resources for lattice QCD in the strong-coupling limit
Authors:
Michael Fromm,
Lucas Katschke,
Owe Philipsen,
Wolfgang Unger
Abstract:
We consider the strong coupling limit of lattice QCD with massless staggered quarks and study the resource requirements for quantum simulating the theory in its Hamiltonian formulation. The bosonic Hilbert space of the color-singlet degrees of freedom grows quickly with the number of quark flavors, making it a suitable testing ground for resource considerations across different platforms. In parti…
▽ More
We consider the strong coupling limit of lattice QCD with massless staggered quarks and study the resource requirements for quantum simulating the theory in its Hamiltonian formulation. The bosonic Hilbert space of the color-singlet degrees of freedom grows quickly with the number of quark flavors, making it a suitable testing ground for resource considerations across different platforms. In particular, in addition to the standard model of computation with qubits, we consider mapping the theory to qudits $(d>2)$ and qumodes, as used on trapped-ion systems and photonic devices, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
On the (in)consistency of perturbation theory at finite temperature
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
A well-known difficulty of perturbative approaches to quantum field theory at finite temperature is the necessity to address theoretical constraints that are not present in the vacuum theory. In this work, we use lattice simulations of scalar correlation functions in massive $φ^{4}$ theory to analyse the extent to which these constraints affect the perturbative predictions. We find that the standa…
▽ More
A well-known difficulty of perturbative approaches to quantum field theory at finite temperature is the necessity to address theoretical constraints that are not present in the vacuum theory. In this work, we use lattice simulations of scalar correlation functions in massive $φ^{4}$ theory to analyse the extent to which these constraints affect the perturbative predictions. We find that the standard perturbative predictions deteriorate even in the absence of infrared divergences at relatively low temperatures, and that this is directly connected to the analytic structure of the propagators used in the expansion. This suggests that the incorporation of non-perturbative thermal effects in the propagators is essential for a consistent perturbative formulation of scalar quantum field theories at finite temperature. By utilising the spectral constraints imposed on finite-temperature correlation functions, we explore how these effects manifest themselves in the lattice data, and discuss why the presence of distinct thermoparticle excitations provides a potential resolution to these issues.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2024; v1 submitted 3 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Pseudo-scalar meson spectral properties in the chiral crossover region of QCD
Authors:
Dibyendu Bala,
Olaf Kaczmarek,
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen,
Tristan Ueding
Abstract:
Determining the type of excitations that can exist in a thermal medium is key to understanding how hadronic matter behaves at extreme temperatures. In this work we study this question for pseudo-scalar mesons comprised of light-strange and strange-strange quarks, analysing how their low-energy spectral properties are modified as one passes through the high-temperature chiral crossover region betwe…
▽ More
Determining the type of excitations that can exist in a thermal medium is key to understanding how hadronic matter behaves at extreme temperatures. In this work we study this question for pseudo-scalar mesons comprised of light-strange and strange-strange quarks, analysing how their low-energy spectral properties are modified as one passes through the high-temperature chiral crossover region between $T=145.6 \, \text{MeV}$ and $172.3 \, \text{MeV}$. We utilise the non-perturbative constraints satisfied by correlation functions at finite temperature in order to extract the low-energy meson spectral function contributions from spatial correlator lattice data in $N_{f}=2+1$ flavour QCD. The robustness of these contributions are tested by comparing their predictions with data for the corresponding temporal correlator at different momentum values. We find that around the pseudo-critical temperature $T_{\text{pc}}$ the data in both the light-strange and strange-strange channels is consistent with the presence of a distinct stable particle-like ground state component, a so-called thermoparticle excitation. As the temperature increases this excitation undergoes collisional broadening, and this is qualitatively the same in both channels. These findings suggest that pseudo-scalar mesons in QCD have a bound-state-like structure at low energies within the chiral crossover region which is still strongly influenced by the vacuum states of the theory.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024; v1 submitted 20 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Quantum Gate Sets for Lattice QCD in the strong coupling limit: $N_f=1$
Authors:
Michael Fromm,
Owe Philipsen,
Wolfgang Unger,
Christopher Winterowd
Abstract:
We derive the primitive quantum gate sets to simulate lattice quantum chromodynamics (LQCD) in the strong-coupling limit with one flavor of massless staggered quarks. This theory is of interest for studies at non-zero density as the sign problem can be overcome using Monte Carlo methods. In this work, we use it as a testing ground for quantum simulations. The key point is that no truncation of the…
▽ More
We derive the primitive quantum gate sets to simulate lattice quantum chromodynamics (LQCD) in the strong-coupling limit with one flavor of massless staggered quarks. This theory is of interest for studies at non-zero density as the sign problem can be overcome using Monte Carlo methods. In this work, we use it as a testing ground for quantum simulations. The key point is that no truncation of the bosonic Hilbert space is necessary as the theory is formulated in terms of color-singlet degrees of freedom (``baryons'' and ``mesons''). The baryons become static in the limit of continuous time and decouple, whereas the dynamics of the mesonic theory involves two qubits per lattice site. Lending dynamics also to the ``baryons'' simply requires to use the derived gate set in its controlled version.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Simulating $\mathbb{Z}_2$ Lattice Gauge Theory with the Variational Quantum Thermalizer
Authors:
Michael Fromm,
Owe Philipsen,
Michael Spannowsky,
Christopher Winterowd
Abstract:
The properties of strongly-coupled lattice gauge theories at finite density as well as in real time have largely eluded first-principles studies on the lattice. This is due to the failure of importance sampling for systems with a complex action. An alternative to evade the sign problem is quantum simulation. Although still in its infancy, a lot of progress has been made in devising algorithms to a…
▽ More
The properties of strongly-coupled lattice gauge theories at finite density as well as in real time have largely eluded first-principles studies on the lattice. This is due to the failure of importance sampling for systems with a complex action. An alternative to evade the sign problem is quantum simulation. Although still in its infancy, a lot of progress has been made in devising algorithms to address these problems. In particular, recent efforts have addressed the question of how to produce thermal Gibbs states on a quantum computer. In this study, we apply a variational quantum algorithm to a low-dimensional model which has a local abelian gauge symmetry. We demonstrate how this approach can be applied to obtain information regarding the phase diagram as well as unequal-time correlation functions at non-zero temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Phase Transitions in Particle Physics -- Results and Perspectives from Lattice Quantum Chromo-Dynamics
Authors:
Gert Aarts,
Joerg Aichelin,
Chris Allton,
Andreas Athenodorou,
Dimitrios Bachtis,
Claudio Bonanno,
Nora Brambilla,
Elena Bratkovskaya,
Mattia Bruno,
Michele Caselle,
Costanza Conti,
Roberto Contino,
Leonardo Cosmai,
Francesca Cuteri,
Luigi Del Debbio,
Massimo D'Elia,
Petros Dimopoulos,
Francesco Di Renzo,
Tetyana Galatyuk,
Jana N. Guenther,
Rachel Houtz,
Frithjof Karsch,
Andrey Yu. Kotov,
Maria Paola Lombardo,
Biagio Lucini
, et al. (16 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Phase transitions in a non-perturbative regime can be studied by ab initio Lattice Field Theory methods. The status and future research directions for LFT investigations of Quantum Chromo-Dynamics under extreme conditions are reviewed, including properties of hadrons and of the hypothesized QCD axion as inferred from QCD topology in different phases. We discuss phase transitions in strong interact…
▽ More
Phase transitions in a non-perturbative regime can be studied by ab initio Lattice Field Theory methods. The status and future research directions for LFT investigations of Quantum Chromo-Dynamics under extreme conditions are reviewed, including properties of hadrons and of the hypothesized QCD axion as inferred from QCD topology in different phases. We discuss phase transitions in strong interactions in an extended parameter space, and the possibility of model building for Dark Matter and Electro-Weak Symmetry Breaking. Methodological challenges are addressed as well, including new developments in Artificial Intelligence geared towards the identification of different phases and transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2023; v1 submitted 11 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Progress on the QCD deconfinement critical point for $N_\text{f}=2$ staggered fermions
Authors:
Reinhold Kaiser,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
The global center symmetry of quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential is broken spontaneously at a critical temperature $T_c$ leading to a first-order phase transition. Including heavy dynamical quarks breaks the center symmetry explicitly and weakens the first-order phase transition for decreasing quark masses until it turns into a smooth crossover at a $Z(2)$-critical point. We investig…
▽ More
The global center symmetry of quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential is broken spontaneously at a critical temperature $T_c$ leading to a first-order phase transition. Including heavy dynamical quarks breaks the center symmetry explicitly and weakens the first-order phase transition for decreasing quark masses until it turns into a smooth crossover at a $Z(2)$-critical point. We investigate the $Z(2)$-critical quark mass value towards the continuum limit for $N_\text{f}=2$ flavors using lattice QCD in the staggered formulation. As part of a continued study, we present results from Monte-Carlo simulations on $N_τ=8,10$ lattices. Several aspect ratios and quark mass values were simulated in order to obtain the critical mass from a fit of the Polyakov loop to a kurtosis finite size scaling formula. Moreover, the possibility to develop a Ginzburg-Landau effective theory around the $Z(2)$-critical point is explored.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 29 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Approaching the Continuum Limit of the Deconfinement Critical Point for $N_\text{f}=2$ Staggered Fermions
Authors:
Reinhold Kaiser,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential undergoes a first-order deconfinement phase transition at a critical temperature $T_c$, which is related to the spontaneous breaking of the global center symmetry. The center symmetry is broken explicitly by including dynamical quarks, which weaken the first-order phase transition for decreasing quark masses. At a certain critical quark mass, which…
▽ More
Quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential undergoes a first-order deconfinement phase transition at a critical temperature $T_c$, which is related to the spontaneous breaking of the global center symmetry. The center symmetry is broken explicitly by including dynamical quarks, which weaken the first-order phase transition for decreasing quark masses. At a certain critical quark mass, which corresponds to the $Z(2)$-critical point, the first-order phase transition turns into a smooth crossover. We investigate the $Z(2)$-critical quark mass for $N_\text{f}=2$ staggered fermions on $N_τ=8, 10$ lattices, where larger $N_τ$ correspond to finer lattices. Monte-Carlo simulations are performed for several quark mass values and aspect ratios in order to extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit. We present final results for $N_τ=8$ and preliminary results for $N_τ=10$ for the critical mass, which are obtained from fitting to a kurtosis finite size scaling formula of the absolute value of the Polyakov loop.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2023; v1 submitted 29 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Towards the phase diagram of cold and dense heavy QCD
Authors:
Amine Chabane,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
The thermodynamics of QCD with sufficiently heavy dynamical quarks can be described by a three-dimensional Polyakov loop effective theory, obtained after a truncated character and hopping expansion. We investigate the resulting phase diagram for low temperatures by mean field methods. Taking into account chemical potentials for both baryon number and isospin, we obtain clear signals for a liquid-g…
▽ More
The thermodynamics of QCD with sufficiently heavy dynamical quarks can be described by a three-dimensional Polyakov loop effective theory, obtained after a truncated character and hopping expansion. We investigate the resulting phase diagram for low temperatures by mean field methods. Taking into account chemical potentials for both baryon number and isospin, we obtain clear signals for a liquid-gas type transition to baryon matter at $μ_I=0$ and a Bose-Einstein condensation transition at $μ_B=0$, as well as for their connection when both chemical potentials are non-zero.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Mean field approximation for effective theories of lattice QCD
Authors:
Christoph Konrad,
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
For the exploration of the phase diagram of QCD, effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD provide a valuable tool in the heavy quark mass regime. In practice, the evaluation of these theories is complicated by the appearance of long-range and multipoint interaction terms. On the other hand, it is well known that for theories with such kind of interactions mean field approximations…
▽ More
For the exploration of the phase diagram of QCD, effective Polyakov loop theories derived from lattice QCD provide a valuable tool in the heavy quark mass regime. In practice, the evaluation of these theories is complicated by the appearance of long-range and multipoint interaction terms. On the other hand, it is well known that for theories with such kind of interactions mean field approximations can be expected to yield reliable results. Here, we apply this framework to the critical endpoint of the deconfinement transition and results are compared to the literature. This treatment can also be used to investigate the phase diagram at non-zero baryon and isospin chemical potential.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
The chiral phase transition at non-zero imaginary baryon chemical potential for different numbers of quark flavours
Authors:
Alfredo D'Ambrosio,
Owe Philipsen,
Reinhold Kaiser
Abstract:
The so-called Columbia plot summarises the order of the QCD thermal transition as a function of the number of quark flavours and their masses. Recently, it was demonstrated that the first-order chiral transition region, as seen for $N_f \in [ 3,6 ]$ on coarse lattices, exhibits tricritical scaling while extrapolating to zero on sufficiently fine lattices. Here we extend these studies to imaginary…
▽ More
The so-called Columbia plot summarises the order of the QCD thermal transition as a function of the number of quark flavours and their masses. Recently, it was demonstrated that the first-order chiral transition region, as seen for $N_f \in [ 3,6 ]$ on coarse lattices, exhibits tricritical scaling while extrapolating to zero on sufficiently fine lattices. Here we extend these studies to imaginary baryon chemical potential. A similar shrinking of the first-order region is observed with decreasing lattice spacing, which again appears compatible with a tricritical extrapolation to zero.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Non-perturbative insights into the spectral properties of QCD at finite temperature
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
In quantum field theories at finite temperature spectral functions describe how particle systems behave in the presence of a thermal medium. Although data from lattice simulations can in principle be used to determine spectral function characteristics, existing methods rely on the extraction of these quantities from temporal correlators, which requires one to circumvent an ill-posed inverse proble…
▽ More
In quantum field theories at finite temperature spectral functions describe how particle systems behave in the presence of a thermal medium. Although data from lattice simulations can in principle be used to determine spectral function characteristics, existing methods rely on the extraction of these quantities from temporal correlators, which requires one to circumvent an ill-posed inverse problem. In these proceedings we report on a recent approach that instead utilises the non-perturbative constraints imposed by field locality to extract spectral function information directly from spatial correlators. In particular, we focus on the application of this approach to lattice QCD data of the spatial pseudo-scalar meson correlator in the temperature range $220-960 \, \text{MeV}$, and outline why this data supports the conclusion that there exists a distinct pion state above the chiral pseudo-critical temperature $T_{\!\text{pc}}$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
On chiral spin symmetry and the QCD phase diagram
Authors:
Owe Philipsen,
Leonid Ya. Glozman,
Peter Lowdon,
Robert D. Pisarski
Abstract:
Recently, an approximate $SU(4)$ chiral spin-flavour symmetry was observed in multiplet patterns of QCD meson correlation functions, in a temperature range above the chiral crossover. This symmetry is larger than the chiral symmetry of massless QCD, and can only arise effectively when colour-electric quark-gluon interactions dynamically dominate the quantum effective action. At temperatures about…
▽ More
Recently, an approximate $SU(4)$ chiral spin-flavour symmetry was observed in multiplet patterns of QCD meson correlation functions, in a temperature range above the chiral crossover. This symmetry is larger than the chiral symmetry of massless QCD, and can only arise effectively when colour-electric quark-gluon interactions dynamically dominate the quantum effective action. At temperatures about three times the crossover temperature, these patterns disappear again, indicating the screening of colour-electric interactions, and the expected chiral symmetry is recovered. In this contribution we collect independent evidence for such an intermediate temperature range, based on screening masses and the pion spectral function. Both kinds of observables behave non-perturbatively in this window, with resonance-like peaks for the pion and its first excitation disappearing gradually with temperature. Using symmetry arguments and the known behaviour of screening masses at small densities, we discuss how this chiral spin symmetric band continues into the QCD phase diagram.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2022; v1 submitted 21 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Pion spectral properties above the chiral crossover of QCD
Authors:
Peter Lowdon,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Spectral functions encode a wealth of information about the dynamics of any given system, and the determination of their non-perturbative characteristics is a long-standing problem in quantum field theory. Whilst numerical simulations of lattice QCD provide ample data for various Euclidean correlation functions, the inversion required to extract spectral functions is an ill-posed problem. In this…
▽ More
Spectral functions encode a wealth of information about the dynamics of any given system, and the determination of their non-perturbative characteristics is a long-standing problem in quantum field theory. Whilst numerical simulations of lattice QCD provide ample data for various Euclidean correlation functions, the inversion required to extract spectral functions is an ill-posed problem. In this work, we pursue previously established constraints imposed by field locality at finite temperature $T$, namely that spectral functions possess a non-perturbative representation which generalises the well-known Källén-Lehmann spectral form to $T>0$. Using this representation, we analyse lattice QCD data of the spatial pseudo-scalar correlator in the temperature range $220-960 \, \text{MeV}$, and obtain an analytic expression for the corresponding spectral function, with parameters fixed by the data. From the structure of this spectral function we find evidence for the existence of a distinct pion state above the chiral pseudo-critical temperature $T_{\text{pc}}$, and contributions from its first excitation, which gradually melt as the temperature increases. As a non-trivial test, we find that the extracted spectral function reproduces the corresponding temporal lattice correlator data for $T=220 \, \text{MeV}$.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2022; v1 submitted 29 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Dihedral Lattice Gauge Theories on a Quantum Annealer
Authors:
Michael Fromm,
Owe Philipsen,
Christopher Winterowd
Abstract:
We study lattice gauge theory with discrete, non-Abelian gauge groups. We extend the formalism of previous studies on D-Wave's quantum annealer as a computing platform to finite, simply reducible gauge groups. As an example, we use the dihedral group $D_n$ with $n=3,4$ on a two plaquette ladder for which we provide proof-of-principle calculations of the ground-state and employ the known time evolu…
▽ More
We study lattice gauge theory with discrete, non-Abelian gauge groups. We extend the formalism of previous studies on D-Wave's quantum annealer as a computing platform to finite, simply reducible gauge groups. As an example, we use the dihedral group $D_n$ with $n=3,4$ on a two plaquette ladder for which we provide proof-of-principle calculations of the ground-state and employ the known time evolution formalism with Feynman clock states.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Towards the chiral phase transition in the Roberge-Weiss plane
Authors:
F. Cuteri,
J. Goswami,
F. Karsch,
Anirban Lahiri,
M. Neumann,
O. Philipsen,
Christian Schmidt,
A. Sciarra
Abstract:
We discuss the interplay between chiral and center sector phase transitions that occur in QCD with an imaginary quark chemical potential $μ=i(2n+1) πT/3$. Based on a finite size scaling analysis in (2+1)-flavor QCD using HISQ fermions with a physical strange quark mass and a range of light quark masses, we show that the endpoint of the line of first-order Roberge-Weiss (RW) transitions between cen…
▽ More
We discuss the interplay between chiral and center sector phase transitions that occur in QCD with an imaginary quark chemical potential $μ=i(2n+1) πT/3$. Based on a finite size scaling analysis in (2+1)-flavor QCD using HISQ fermions with a physical strange quark mass and a range of light quark masses, we show that the endpoint of the line of first-order Roberge-Weiss (RW) transitions between center sectors is second order for light quark masses $m_l\ge m_s/320$, and that it belongs to the $3$-d, $Z(2)$ universality class. The operator for the chiral condensate behaves like an energy-like operator in an effective spin model for the RW phase transition. As a consequence, for any non-zero value of the quark mass, the chiral condensate will have an infinite slope at the RW phase transition temperature, $T_{RW}$. Its fluctuation, the disconnected chiral susceptibility, behaves like the specific heat in $Z(2)$ symmetric models and diverges in the infinite volume limit at the RW phase transition temperature $T_{RW}$ for any non-zero value of the light quark masses. Our analysis suggests the critical temperatures for the RW phase transition and the chiral phase transition coincide in the RW plane. On lattices with temporal extent $N_τ=4$, we find in the chiral limit $T_χ=T_{RW}=195(1)~$MeV.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Chiral spin symmetry and the QCD phase diagram
Authors:
Leonid Ya. Glozman,
Owe Philipsen,
Robert D. Pisarski
Abstract:
Lattice QCD simulations with chirally symmetric quarks have recently established approximate $SU(2)_{CS}$ and $SU(2N_F)$ symmetries of the quantum effective action in a temperature range above the chiral crossover $T_\mathrm{ch}$, in which color-electric interactions between quarks dominate the dynamics. We show that such an intermediate temperature range between the chirally broken and plasma reg…
▽ More
Lattice QCD simulations with chirally symmetric quarks have recently established approximate $SU(2)_{CS}$ and $SU(2N_F)$ symmetries of the quantum effective action in a temperature range above the chiral crossover $T_\mathrm{ch}$, in which color-electric interactions between quarks dominate the dynamics. We show that such an intermediate temperature range between the chirally broken and plasma regimes is fully consistent with published screening mass spectra, which demonstrate the breakdown of thermal perturbation theory at the crossover between the partonic and the chiral spin symmetric regime at $T_s\sim (2-3)T_\mathrm{ch}$. From the known behavior of screening masses with baryon chemical potential, we deduce qualitatively how this chiral spin symmetric band extends into the QCD phase diagram. In the cold and dense region, we propose parity doubled baryons as possible candidates for chiral spin symmetric matter. This represents a special case of quarkyonic matter with confinement and restored chiral symmetry, and can smoothly transform to quark matter at sufficiently high densities. Finally, we discuss the potential of dilepton spectra to identify such matter forms.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2023; v1 submitted 11 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Coarse graining in effective theories of lattice QCD in 1+1d and 2+1d
Authors:
Christoph Konrad,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
In the strong coupling and heavy quark mass regime, lattice QCD dimensionally reduces to effective theories of Polyakov loops depending on the parameters of the original Wilson action $β, κ$ and $N_τ$. We apply coarse graining techniques to such theories in 1d and 2d, corresponding to lattice QCD at finite temperature and non-zero chemical potential in 1+1d and 2+1d, respectively. In 1d the method…
▽ More
In the strong coupling and heavy quark mass regime, lattice QCD dimensionally reduces to effective theories of Polyakov loops depending on the parameters of the original Wilson action $β, κ$ and $N_τ$. We apply coarse graining techniques to such theories in 1d and 2d, corresponding to lattice QCD at finite temperature and non-zero chemical potential in 1+1d and 2+1d, respectively. In 1d the method is applied to the effective theories up to $\mathcal{O}(κ^4)$. Using the transfer matrix, the recursion relations are solved analytically. The thermodynamic limit is taken for some observables. Afterwards, continuum extrapolation is performed numerically and results are discussed. In 2d the coarse graining method is applied in the pure gauge and static quark limit. Running couplings are obtained and the fixed points of the transformations are discussed. Finally, the critical coupling of the deconfinement transition is determined in both limits. Agreement to about 12% with Monte Carlo results of 2+1d Yang-Mills theory from the literature is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The QCD chiral phase transition for different numbers of quark flavours
Authors:
Francesca Cuteri,
Owe Philipsen,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
We present results from a comprehensive study of the location of the chiral critical surface, which separates regions of first-order chiral transitions from analytic crossovers, in the bare parameter space of lattice QCD with unimproved staggered fermions. We study the theories with $N_f\in[2,8]$ and trace the chiral critical surface along diminishing lattice spacing, with $N_τ=\{4,6,8\}$. This al…
▽ More
We present results from a comprehensive study of the location of the chiral critical surface, which separates regions of first-order chiral transitions from analytic crossovers, in the bare parameter space of lattice QCD with unimproved staggered fermions. We study the theories with $N_f\in[2,8]$ and trace the chiral critical surface along diminishing lattice spacing, with $N_τ=\{4,6,8\}$. This allows for an extrapolation to the lattice chiral limit, where the surface has to terminate in a tricritical line, employing known tricritical scaling relations. Knowing the phase structure in the lattice bare parameter space allows to draw conclusions for the approach to the continuum and chiral limits taken in the appropriate order. Our data provide evidence for the continuum chiral limit to feature a second-order transition for all $N_f\in[2,7]$. We perform an analogous scaling analysis with already published data from $N_f=3$ $O(a)$-improved Wilson fermions, which is also consistent with a second-order transition in the continuum. A modified Columbia plot reflecting those results is suggested.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The chiral phase transition from strong to weak coupling
Authors:
Francesca Cuteri,
Alfredo D'Ambrosio,
Owe Philipsen,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
The order of the chiral phase transition of lattice QCD with unimproved staggered fermions is known to depend on the number of quark flavours, their masses and the lattice spacing. Previous studies in the literature for $N_f \in \{ 3,4 \}$ show first-order transitions, which weaken with decreasing lattice spacing. Here we investigate what happens when lattices are made coarser to establish contact…
▽ More
The order of the chiral phase transition of lattice QCD with unimproved staggered fermions is known to depend on the number of quark flavours, their masses and the lattice spacing. Previous studies in the literature for $N_f \in \{ 3,4 \}$ show first-order transitions, which weaken with decreasing lattice spacing. Here we investigate what happens when lattices are made coarser to establish contact to the strong coupling region. For $N_f \in \{4,8 \}$ we find a drastic weakening of the transition when going from $N_τ=4$ to $N_τ=2$, which is consistent with a second-order chiral transition reported in the literature for $N_f=4$ in the strong coupling limit. This implies a non-monotonic behaviour of the critical quark or pseudo-scalar meson mass, which separates first-order transitions from crossover behaviour, as a function of lattice spacing.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The QCD Deconfinement Critical Point for $N_\text{f}=2$ Flavors of Staggered Fermions
Authors:
Reinhold Kaiser,
Owe Philipsen,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
Quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential undergoes a first-order deconfinement phase transition at a critical temperature $T_c$, which is related to the spontaneous breaking of the global center symmetry. Including heavy, dynamical quarks breaks the center symmetry explicitly and weakens the first-order phase transition. For decreasing quark masses the first-order phase transition turns in…
▽ More
Quenched QCD at zero baryonic chemical potential undergoes a first-order deconfinement phase transition at a critical temperature $T_c$, which is related to the spontaneous breaking of the global center symmetry. Including heavy, dynamical quarks breaks the center symmetry explicitly and weakens the first-order phase transition. For decreasing quark masses the first-order phase transition turns into a smooth crossover at a $Z_2$-critical point. The critical quark mass corresponding to this point has been examined with $N_\text{f} = 2$ Wilson fermions for several $N_τ$ in a recent study within our group. For comparison, we also locate the critical point with $N_\text{f} = 2$ staggered fermions on $N_τ= 8$ lattices. For this purpose we perform Monte Carlo simulations for several quark mass values and various aspect ratios in order to extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit. The critical mass is obtained by fitting to a finite size scaling formula of the kurtosis of the Polyakov loop. Our results indicate large discretization effects, requiring simulations on lattices with $N_τ> 8$.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Deconfinement critical point of heavy quark effective lattice theories
Authors:
Jangho Kim,
Anh Quang Pham,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Effective three-dimensional Polyakov loop theories derived from QCD by strong coupling and hopping expansions are valid for heavy quarks and can also be applied to finite chemical potential $μ$, due to their considerably milder sign problem. We apply the Monte-Carlo method to the $N_f=1,2$ effective theories up to $\mathcal{O}(κ^4)$ in the hopping parameter at $μ=0$ to determine the critical quark…
▽ More
Effective three-dimensional Polyakov loop theories derived from QCD by strong coupling and hopping expansions are valid for heavy quarks and can also be applied to finite chemical potential $μ$, due to their considerably milder sign problem. We apply the Monte-Carlo method to the $N_f=1,2$ effective theories up to $\mathcal{O}(κ^4)$ in the hopping parameter at $μ=0$ to determine the critical quark mass, at which the first-order deconfinement phase transition terminates. The critical end point obtained from the effective theory to order $\mathcal{O}(κ^2)$ agrees well with 4-dimensional QCD simulations with a hopping expanded determinant by the WHOT-QCD collaboration. We also compare with full QCD simulations and thus obtain a measure for the validity of both the strong coupling and the hopping expansion in this regime.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2022; v1 submitted 13 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The static force from generalized Wilson loops
Authors:
Viljami Leino,
Nora Brambilla,
Owe Philipsen,
Christian Reisinger,
Antonio Vairo,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
Recently a method to compute the static force with lattice gauge theory using an insertion of a chromoelectric field into a Wilson loop was proposed. We explore this method using the multilevel algorithm and discuss the renormalization of the chromoelectric field on the lattice.
Recently a method to compute the static force with lattice gauge theory using an insertion of a chromoelectric field into a Wilson loop was proposed. We explore this method using the multilevel algorithm and discuss the renormalization of the chromoelectric field on the lattice.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Lattice Constraints on the QCD Chiral Phase Transition at Finite Temperature and Baryon Density
Authors:
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
The thermal restoration of chiral symmetry in QCD is known to proceed by an analytic crossover, which is widely expected to turn into a phase transition with a critical endpoint as the baryon density is increased. In the absence of a genuine solution to the sign problem of lattice QCD, simulations at zero and imaginary baryon chemical potential in a parameter space enlarged by a variable number of…
▽ More
The thermal restoration of chiral symmetry in QCD is known to proceed by an analytic crossover, which is widely expected to turn into a phase transition with a critical endpoint as the baryon density is increased. In the absence of a genuine solution to the sign problem of lattice QCD, simulations at zero and imaginary baryon chemical potential in a parameter space enlarged by a variable number of quark flavours and quark masses constitute a viable way to constrain the location of a possible non-analytic phase transition and its critical endpoint. In this article I review recent progress towards an understanding of the nature of the transition in the massless limit, and its critical temperature at zero density. Combined with increasingly detailed studies of the physical crossover region, current data bound a possible critical point to $μ_B > 3T$.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
On the order of the QCD chiral phase transition for different numbers of quark flavours
Authors:
Francesca Cuteri,
Owe Philipsen,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
The nature of the QCD chiral phase transition in the limit of vanishing quark masses has remained elusive for a long time, since it cannot be simulated directly on the lattice and is strongly cutoff-dependent. We report on a comprehensive ongoing study using unimproved staggered fermions with $N_\text{f}\in[2,8]$ mass-degenerate flavours on $N_τ\in\{4,6,8\}$ lattices, in which we locate the chiral…
▽ More
The nature of the QCD chiral phase transition in the limit of vanishing quark masses has remained elusive for a long time, since it cannot be simulated directly on the lattice and is strongly cutoff-dependent. We report on a comprehensive ongoing study using unimproved staggered fermions with $N_\text{f}\in[2,8]$ mass-degenerate flavours on $N_τ\in\{4,6,8\}$ lattices, in which we locate the chiral critical surface separating regions with first-order transitions from crossover regions in the bare parameter space of the lattice theory. Employing the fact that it terminates in a tricritical line, this surface can be extrapolated to the chiral limit using tricritical scaling with known exponents. Knowing the order of the transitions in the lattice parameter space, conclusions for approaching the continuum chiral limit in the proper order can be drawn. While a narrow first-order region cannot be ruled out, we find initial evidence consistent with a second-order chiral transition in all massless theories with $N_\text{f}\leq 6$, and possibly up to the onset of the conformal window at $9\lesssim N_\text{f}^*\lesssim 12$. A reanalysis of already published $\mathcal{O}(a)$-improved $N_\text{f}=3$ Wilson data on $N_τ\in[4,12]$ is also consistent with tricritical scaling, and the associated change from first to second-order on the way to the continuum chiral limit. We discuss a modified Columbia plot and a phase diagram for many-flavour QCD that reflect these possible features.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2021; v1 submitted 27 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Lattice gauge theory computation of the static force
Authors:
Nora Brambilla,
Viljami Leino,
Owe Philipsen,
Christian Reisinger,
Antonio Vairo,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
We explore a novel approach to compute the force between a static quark and a static antiquark with lattice gauge theory directly. The approach is based on expectation values of Wilson loops or Polyakov loops with chromoelectric field insertions. We discuss theoretical and technical aspects in detail, in particular, how to compensate large discretization errors with a multiplicative renormalizatio…
▽ More
We explore a novel approach to compute the force between a static quark and a static antiquark with lattice gauge theory directly. The approach is based on expectation values of Wilson loops or Polyakov loops with chromoelectric field insertions. We discuss theoretical and technical aspects in detail, in particular, how to compensate large discretization errors with a multiplicative renormalization factor and the evaluation using a multilevel algorithm. We also compare numerical results for the static force to corresponding results obtained in the traditional way, i.e., by computing first the static potential and then taking the derivative.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022; v1 submitted 3 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Strong coupling methods in QCD thermodynamics
Authors:
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
For a long time, strong coupling expansions have not been applied systematically in lattice QCD thermodynamics, in view of the succes of numerical Monte Carlo studies. The persistent sign problem at finite baryo-chemical potential, however, has motivated investigations using these methods, either by themselves or combined with numerical evaluations, as a route to finite density physics. This artic…
▽ More
For a long time, strong coupling expansions have not been applied systematically in lattice QCD thermodynamics, in view of the succes of numerical Monte Carlo studies. The persistent sign problem at finite baryo-chemical potential, however, has motivated investigations using these methods, either by themselves or combined with numerical evaluations, as a route to finite density physics. This article reviews the strategies, by which a number of qualitative insights have been attained, notably the emergence of the hadron resonance gas or the identification of the onset transition to baryon matter in specific regions of the QCD parameter space. For the simpler case of Yang-Mills theory, the deconfinement transition can be determined quantitatively even in the scaling region, showing possible prospects for continuum physics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
QCD in the heavy dense regime: Large $N_c$ and quarkyonic matter
Authors:
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
After combined character and hopping expansions and integration over the spatial gauge links, lattice QCD reduces to a three-dimensional $SU(3)$ Polyakov loop model with complicated interactions. A simple truncation of the effective theory is valid for heavy quarks on reasonably fine lattices and can be solved by linked cluster expansion in its effective couplings. This was used ealier to demonstr…
▽ More
After combined character and hopping expansions and integration over the spatial gauge links, lattice QCD reduces to a three-dimensional $SU(3)$ Polyakov loop model with complicated interactions. A simple truncation of the effective theory is valid for heavy quarks on reasonably fine lattices and can be solved by linked cluster expansion in its effective couplings. This was used ealier to demonstrate the onset transition to baryon matter in the cold and dense regime. Repeating these studies for general $N_c$, one finds that for large $N_c$ the onset transition becomes first-order, and the pressure scales as $p\sim N_c$ through three consecutive orders in the hoppoing expansion. These features are consistent with the formal definition of quarkyonic matter given in the literature. We discuss the implications for $N_c=3$ and physical QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Deconfinement critical point of lattice QCD with $N_{\rm f}=2$ Wilson fermions
Authors:
Francesca Cuteri,
Owe Philipsen,
Alena Schön,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
The ${\rm SU}(3)$ pure gauge theory exhibits a first-order thermal deconfinement transition due to spontaneous breaking of its global $Z_3$ center symmetry. When heavy dynamical quarks are added, this symmetry is broken explicitly and the transition weakens with decreasing quark mass until it disappears at a critical point. We compute the critical hopping parameter and the associated pion mass for…
▽ More
The ${\rm SU}(3)$ pure gauge theory exhibits a first-order thermal deconfinement transition due to spontaneous breaking of its global $Z_3$ center symmetry. When heavy dynamical quarks are added, this symmetry is broken explicitly and the transition weakens with decreasing quark mass until it disappears at a critical point. We compute the critical hopping parameter and the associated pion mass for lattice QCD with $N_f=2$ degenerate standard Wilson fermions on $N_τ\in\{6,8,10\}$ lattices, corresponding to lattice spacings $a=0.12\, {\rm fm}$, $a=0.09\, {\rm fm}$, $a=0.07\, {\rm fm}$, respectively. Significant cut-off effects are observed, with the first-order region growing as the lattice gets finer. While current lattices are still too coarse for a continuum extrapolation, we estimate $m_π^c\approx 4 {\rm GeV}$ with a remaining systematic error of $\sim 20\%$. Our results allow to assess the accuracy of the LO and NLO hopping expanded fermion determinant used in the literature for various purposes. We also provide a detailed investigation of the statistics required for this type of calculation, which is useful for similar investigations of the chiral transition.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021; v1 submitted 29 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
The SU(3) spin model with chemical potential by series expansion techniques
Authors:
Jangho Kim,
Anh Quang Pham,
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
The $SU(3)$ spin model with chemical potential corresponds to a simplified version of QCD with static quarks in the strong coupling regime. It has been studied previously as a testing ground for new methods aiming to overcome the sign problem of lattice QCD. In this work we show that the equation of state and the phase structure of the model can be determined to reasonable accuracy by a linked clu…
▽ More
The $SU(3)$ spin model with chemical potential corresponds to a simplified version of QCD with static quarks in the strong coupling regime. It has been studied previously as a testing ground for new methods aiming to overcome the sign problem of lattice QCD. In this work we show that the equation of state and the phase structure of the model can be determined to reasonable accuracy by a linked cluster expansion. In particular, we compute the free energy to 14-th order in the nearest neighbour coupling. The resulting predictions for the equation of state and the location of the critical end point agree with numerical determinations to ${\cal O}(1\%)$ and ${\cal O}(10\%)$, respectively. While the accuracy for the critical couplings is still limited at the current series depth, the approach is equally applicable at zero and non-zero imaginary or real chemical potential, as well as to effective QCD Hamiltonians obtained by strong coupling and hopping expansions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2020; v1 submitted 8 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Complete leading-order standard model corrections to quantum leptogenesis
Authors:
Paul Frederik Depta,
Andreas Halsch,
Janine Hütig,
Sebastian Mendizabal,
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Thermal leptogenesis, in the framework of the standard model with three additional heavy Majorana neutrinos, provides an attractive scenario to explain the observed baryon asymmetry in the universe. It is based on the out-of-equilibrium decay of Majorana neutrinos in a thermal bath of standard model particles, which in a fully quantum field theoretical formalism is obtained by solving Kadanoff-Bay…
▽ More
Thermal leptogenesis, in the framework of the standard model with three additional heavy Majorana neutrinos, provides an attractive scenario to explain the observed baryon asymmetry in the universe. It is based on the out-of-equilibrium decay of Majorana neutrinos in a thermal bath of standard model particles, which in a fully quantum field theoretical formalism is obtained by solving Kadanoff-Baym equations. So far, the leading two-loop contributions from leptons and Higgs particles are included, but not yet gauge corrections. These enter at three-loop level but, in certain kinematical regimes, require a resummation to infinite loop order for a result to leading order in the gauge coupling. In this work, we apply such a resummation to the calculation of the lepton number density. The full result for the simplest "vanilla leptogenesis" scenario is by $\mathcal{O}(1)$ increased compared to that of quantum Boltzmann equations, and for the first time permits an estimate of all theoretical uncertainties. This step completes the quantum theory of leptogenesis and forms the basis for quantitative evaluations, as well as extensions to other scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2020; v1 submitted 4 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Constraining the QCD phase diagram at finite temperature and density
Authors:
Owe Philipsen
Abstract:
Neither the chiral limit nor finite baryon density can be simulated directly in lattice QCD, which severely limits our understanding of the QCD phase diagram. In this review I collect results for the phase structure in an extended parameter space of QCD, with varying numbers of flavours, quark masses, colours, lattice spacings, imaginary and isospin chemical potentials. Such studies help in unders…
▽ More
Neither the chiral limit nor finite baryon density can be simulated directly in lattice QCD, which severely limits our understanding of the QCD phase diagram. In this review I collect results for the phase structure in an extended parameter space of QCD, with varying numbers of flavours, quark masses, colours, lattice spacings, imaginary and isospin chemical potentials. Such studies help in understanding the underlying symmetries and degrees of freedom, and are beginning to provide a consistent picture constraining the possibilities for the physical phase diagram.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Large $N_c$ behaviour of lattice QCD in the heavy dense regime
Authors:
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
Combining strong coupling and hopping expansion one can derive a dimensionally reduced effective theory of lattice QCD. This theory has a reduced sign problem, is amenable to analytic evaluation and was successfully used to study the cold and dense regime of QCD for sufficiently heavy quarks. We show results from the evaluation of the effective theory for arbitrary $N_c$ up to $κ^4$. The inclusion…
▽ More
Combining strong coupling and hopping expansion one can derive a dimensionally reduced effective theory of lattice QCD. This theory has a reduced sign problem, is amenable to analytic evaluation and was successfully used to study the cold and dense regime of QCD for sufficiently heavy quarks. We show results from the evaluation of the effective theory for arbitrary $N_c$ up to $κ^4$. The inclusion of gauge corrections is also investigated. We find that the onset transition to finite baryon number density steepens with growing $N_c$ even for $T \neq 0$. This suggests that in the large $N_c$ limit the onset transition is first order up to the deconfinement transition. Beyond the onset, the pressure is shown to scale as $p \sim N_c$ through three orders in the hopping expansion, which is characteristic for a phase termed quarkyonic matter in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The Yang-Mills deconfinement transition from a high temperature expansion
Authors:
Jangho Kim,
Anh Quang Pham,
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
The high temperature expansion is an analytical tool to study critical phenomena in statistical mechanics. We apply this method to 3d effective theories of Polyakov loops, which have been derived from 4d lattice Yang-Mills by means of resummed strong coupling expansions. In particular, the Polyakov loop susceptibility is computed as a power series in the effective couplings. A Padé analysis then p…
▽ More
The high temperature expansion is an analytical tool to study critical phenomena in statistical mechanics. We apply this method to 3d effective theories of Polyakov loops, which have been derived from 4d lattice Yang-Mills by means of resummed strong coupling expansions. In particular, the Polyakov loop susceptibility is computed as a power series in the effective couplings. A Padé analysis then provides the location of the phase transition in the effective theory, which can be mapped back to the parameters of 4d Yang-Mills. Our purely analytical results for the critical couplings $β_c(N_τ)$ agree to better than $10\%$ with those from Monte Carlo simulations. For the case of $SU(2)$, also the critical exponent $γ$ is predicted accurately, while a first-order nature as for $SU(3)$ cannot be identified by a Padé analysis. The method can be generalized to include fermions and finite density.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
On the $β$- and quark mass dependence of the nuclear transition in the strong coupling regime
Authors:
Jangho Kim,
Owe Philipsen,
Wolfgang Unger
Abstract:
Lattice QCD in a dual formulation with staggered fermions is well established in the strong coupling limit and allows to perform Monte Carlo simulations at finite baryon chemical potential. We have recently addressed the dependence of the nuclear critical end point as a function of the quark mass $am_q$, and separately as a function of the lattice gauge coupling $β$ in the chiral limit. Here we pr…
▽ More
Lattice QCD in a dual formulation with staggered fermions is well established in the strong coupling limit and allows to perform Monte Carlo simulations at finite baryon chemical potential. We have recently addressed the dependence of the nuclear critical end point as a function of the quark mass $am_q$, and separately as a function of the lattice gauge coupling $β$ in the chiral limit. Here we proceed to determine the dependence of the nuclear transition on both, $am_q$ and $β$, on isotropic lattices and attempt to pinpoint the critical end point for various $β$ where the sign problem is still manageable.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Static force from the lattice
Authors:
Nora Brambilla,
Viljami Leino,
Owe Philipsen,
Christian Reisinger,
Antonio Vairo,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
We present a novel approach to compute the force between a static quark and a static antiquark from lattice gauge theory directly, rather than extracting it from the static energy. We explore this approach for SU(3) pure gauge theory using the multilevel algorithm and smeared operators.
We present a novel approach to compute the force between a static quark and a static antiquark from lattice gauge theory directly, rather than extracting it from the static energy. We explore this approach for SU(3) pure gauge theory using the multilevel algorithm and smeared operators.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Finite size and cut-off effects on the Roberge-Weiss transition in $N_\text{f}=2$ QCD with Staggered fermions
Authors:
Owe Philipsen,
Alessandro Sciarra
Abstract:
In the absence of a genuine solution to the sign problem, lattice studies at imaginary quark chemical potential are an important tool to constrain the QCD phase diagram. We calculate the values of the tricritical quark masses in the Roberge-Weiss plane, $μ=\imathπT/3$, which separate mass regions with chiral and deconfinement phase transitions from the intermediate region, for QCD with…
▽ More
In the absence of a genuine solution to the sign problem, lattice studies at imaginary quark chemical potential are an important tool to constrain the QCD phase diagram. We calculate the values of the tricritical quark masses in the Roberge-Weiss plane, $μ=\imathπT/3$, which separate mass regions with chiral and deconfinement phase transitions from the intermediate region, for QCD with $N_\text{f}=2$ unimproved staggered quarks on $N_τ=6$ lattices. A quantitative measure for the quality of finite size scaling plots is developed, which significantly reduces the subjective judgement required for fitting. We observe that larger aspect ratios are necessary to unambiguously determine the order of the transition than at $μ=0$. Comparing with previous results from $N_τ=4$ we find a $\sim50$% reduction in the light tricritical pion mass. The heavy tricritical pion mass stays roughly the same, but is too heavy to be resolved on $N_τ=6$ lattices and thus equally afflicted with cut-off effects. Further comparison with other discretizations suggests that current cut-off effects on the light critical masses are likely to be larger than $\sim100$%, implying a drastic shrinking of the chiral first-order region to possibly zero.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2020; v1 submitted 26 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
QCD in the heavy dense regime for general $N_c$: On the existence of quarkyonic matter
Authors:
Owe Philipsen,
Jonas Scheunert
Abstract:
Lattice QCD with heavy quarks reduces to a three-dimensional effective theory of Polyakov loops, which is amenable to series expansion methods. We analyse the effective theory in the cold and dense regime for a general number of colours, $N_c$. In particular, we investigate the transition from a hadron gas to baryon condensation. For any finite lattice spacing, we find the transition to become str…
▽ More
Lattice QCD with heavy quarks reduces to a three-dimensional effective theory of Polyakov loops, which is amenable to series expansion methods. We analyse the effective theory in the cold and dense regime for a general number of colours, $N_c$. In particular, we investigate the transition from a hadron gas to baryon condensation. For any finite lattice spacing, we find the transition to become stronger, i.e. ultimately first-order, as $N_c$ is made large. Moreover, in the baryon condensed regime, we find the pressure to scale as $p\sim N_c$ through three orders in the hopping expansion. Such a phase differs from a hadron gas with $p\sim N_c^0$, or a quark gluon plasma, $p\sim N_c^2$, and was termed quarkyonic in the literature, since it shows both baryon-like and quark-like aspects. A lattice filling with baryon number shows a rapid and smooth transition from condensing baryons to a crystal of saturated quark matter, due to the Pauli principle, and is consistent with this picture. For continuum physics, the continuum limit needs to be taken before the large $N_c$ limit, which is not yet possible in practice. However, in the controlled range of lattice spacings and $N_c$-values, our results are stable when the limits are approached in this order. We discuss possible implications for physical QCD.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2019; v1 submitted 8 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Hybrid static potential flux tubes from SU(2) and SU(3) lattice gauge theory
Authors:
Lasse Mueller,
Owe Philipsen,
Christian Reisinger,
Marc Wagner
Abstract:
We compute chromoelectric and chromomagnetic flux densities for hybrid static potentials in SU(2) and SU(3) lattice gauge theory. In addition to the ordinary static potential with quantum numbers $Λ_η^ε= Σ_g^+$, we present numerical results for seven hybrid static potentials corresponding to $Λ_η^{(ε)} = Σ_u^+, Σ_g^-, Σ_u^-, Π_g, Π_u, Δ_g, Δ_u$, where the flux densities of five of them are studied…
▽ More
We compute chromoelectric and chromomagnetic flux densities for hybrid static potentials in SU(2) and SU(3) lattice gauge theory. In addition to the ordinary static potential with quantum numbers $Λ_η^ε= Σ_g^+$, we present numerical results for seven hybrid static potentials corresponding to $Λ_η^{(ε)} = Σ_u^+, Σ_g^-, Σ_u^-, Π_g, Π_u, Δ_g, Δ_u$, where the flux densities of five of them are studied for the first time in this work. We observe hybrid static potential flux tubes, which are significantly different from that of the ordinary static potential. They are reminiscent of vibrating strings, with localized peaks in the flux densities that can be interpreted as valence gluons.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2019; v1 submitted 2 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
QCD equation of state at finite baryon density with fugacity expansion
Authors:
Volodymyr Vovchenko,
Jan Steinheimer,
Owe Philipsen,
Horst Stoecker
Abstract:
We explore the QCD equation of state at finite baryon density through an expansion in baryon number fugacity, making use of the recent lattice data on the four leading Fourier coefficients of the expansion. A state-of-the-art description of the lattice data at both imaginary $μ_B$ and $μ_B = 0$ is provided by the cluster expansion model (CEM). The CEM pressure function has three temperature depend…
▽ More
We explore the QCD equation of state at finite baryon density through an expansion in baryon number fugacity, making use of the recent lattice data on the four leading Fourier coefficients of the expansion. A state-of-the-art description of the lattice data at both imaginary $μ_B$ and $μ_B = 0$ is provided by the cluster expansion model (CEM). The CEM pressure function has three temperature dependent input parameters, which we fix by parameterizing the available lattice QCD data. This results in a crossover model of the QCD equation of state at finite baryon density, which can be used in fluid dynamical simulations of heavy-ion collisions.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Testing the strength of the $\text{U}_A(1)$ anomaly at the chiral phase transition in two-flavour QCD
Authors:
Bastian B. Brandt,
Marco Cè,
Anthony Francis,
Tim Harris,
Harvey B. Meyer,
Owe Philipsen,
Hartmut Wittig
Abstract:
We study the thermal transition of QCD with two degenerate light flavours by lattice simulations using $\mathcal{O}(a)$-improved Wilson quarks. Particular emphasis lies on the pattern of chiral symmetry restoration, which we probe via the static screening correlators. On $32^3$ volumes we observe that the screening masses in transverse iso-vector vector and axial-vector channels become degenerate…
▽ More
We study the thermal transition of QCD with two degenerate light flavours by lattice simulations using $\mathcal{O}(a)$-improved Wilson quarks. Particular emphasis lies on the pattern of chiral symmetry restoration, which we probe via the static screening correlators. On $32^3$ volumes we observe that the screening masses in transverse iso-vector vector and axial-vector channels become degenerate at the transition temperature. The splitting between the screening masses in iso-vector scalar and pseudoscalar channels is strongly reduced compared to the splitting at zero temperature and is actually consistent with zero within uncertainties. In this proceedings article we extend our studies to matrix elements and iso-singlet correlation functions. Furthermore, we present results on larger volumes, including first results at the physical pion mass.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
