-
Analysis of a household-scale model for the invasion of Wolbachia into a resident mosquito population
Authors:
Abby Barlow,
Sarah Penington,
Ben Adams
Abstract:
In areas infested with Aedes aegypti mosquitoes it may be possible to control dengue, and some other vector-borne diseases, by introducing Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes into the wildtype population. Thus far, empirical and theoretical studies of Wolbachia release have tended to focus on the dynamics at the community scale. However, Ae. aegypti mosquitoes typically dwell in and around the same hous…
▽ More
In areas infested with Aedes aegypti mosquitoes it may be possible to control dengue, and some other vector-borne diseases, by introducing Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes into the wildtype population. Thus far, empirical and theoretical studies of Wolbachia release have tended to focus on the dynamics at the community scale. However, Ae. aegypti mosquitoes typically dwell in and around the same houses as the people they bite and it can be insightful to explore what happens at the household scale where small population sizes lead to inherently stochastic dynamics. Here we use a continuous-time Markov framework to develop a stochastic household model for small populations of wildtype and Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes. We investigate the transient and long term dynamics of the system, in particular examining the impact of stochasticity on the Wolbachia invasion threshold and bistability between the wildtype-only and Wolbachia-only steady states previously observed in deterministic models. We focus on the influence of key parameters which determine the fitness cost of Wolbachia infection and the probability of Wolbachia vertical transmission. Using Markov and matrix population theory, we derive salient characteristics of the system including the probability of successful Wolbachia invasion, the expected time until invasion and the probability that a Wolbachia-infected population reverts to a wildtype population. These attributes can inform strategies for the release of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes. In addition, we find that releasing the minimum number of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes required to displace a resident wildtype population according to the deterministic model, only results in that outcome about 20% of the time in the stochastic model; a significantly larger release is required to reach a steady state composed entirely of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes 90% of the time.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Epidemiological dynamics in populations structured by neighbourhoods and households
Authors:
Abby Barlow,
Ben Adams,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
Epidemiological dynamics are affected by the spatial and demographic structure of the host population. Households and neighbourhoods are known to be important groupings but little is known about the epidemiological interplay between them. In order to explore the implications for infectious disease epidemiology of households with similar demographic structures clustered in space we develop a multi-…
▽ More
Epidemiological dynamics are affected by the spatial and demographic structure of the host population. Households and neighbourhoods are known to be important groupings but little is known about the epidemiological interplay between them. In order to explore the implications for infectious disease epidemiology of households with similar demographic structures clustered in space we develop a multi-scale epidemic model consisting of neighbourhoods of households. In our analysis we focus on key parameters which control household size, the importance of transmission within households relative to outside of them, and the degree to which the non-household transmission is localised within neighbourhoods. We construct the household reproduction number $R_*$ over all neighbourhoods and derive the analytic probability of an outbreak occurring from a single infected individual in a specific neighbourhood. We find that reduced localisation of transmission within neighbourhoods reduces $R_*$ when household size differs between neighbourhoods. This effect is amplified by larger differences between household sizes and larger divergence between transmission rates within households and outside of them. However, the impact of neighbourhoods with larger household sizes on an individual's risk of infection is mainly limited to the individuals that reside in those neighbourhoods. We consider various surveillance scenarios and show that household size information from the initial infectious cases is often more important than neighbourhood information while household size and neighbourhood localisation influences the sequence of neighbourhoods in which an outbreak is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2024; v1 submitted 9 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Branching random walk with non-local competition
Authors:
Pascal Maillard,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We study the Bolker-Pacala-Dieckmann-Law (BPDL) model of population dynamics in the regime of large population density. The BPDL model is a particle system in which particles reproduce, move randomly in space, and compete with each other locally. We rigorously prove global survival as well as a shape theorem describing the asymptotic spread of the population, when the population density is suffici…
▽ More
We study the Bolker-Pacala-Dieckmann-Law (BPDL) model of population dynamics in the regime of large population density. The BPDL model is a particle system in which particles reproduce, move randomly in space, and compete with each other locally. We rigorously prove global survival as well as a shape theorem describing the asymptotic spread of the population, when the population density is sufficiently large. In contrast to most previous studies, we allow the competition kernel to have an arbitrary, even infinite range, whence the term non-local competition. This makes the particle system non-monotone and of infinite-range dependence, meaning that the usual comparison arguments break down and have to be replaced by a more hands-on approach. Some ideas in the proof are inspired by works on the non-local Fisher-KPP equation, but the stochasticity of the model creates new difficulties.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2024; v1 submitted 29 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
A branching process with deletions and mergers that matches the threshold for hypercube percolation
Authors:
Laura Eslava,
Sarah Penington,
Fiona Skerman
Abstract:
We define a graph process $\mathcal{G}(p,q)$ based on a discrete branching process with deletions and mergers, which is inspired by the 4-cycle structure of both the hypercube $Q_d$ and the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ for large $d$. Individuals have Poisson offspring distribution with mean $1+p$ and certain deletions and mergers occur with probability $q$; these parameters correspond to the mean number…
▽ More
We define a graph process $\mathcal{G}(p,q)$ based on a discrete branching process with deletions and mergers, which is inspired by the 4-cycle structure of both the hypercube $Q_d$ and the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ for large $d$. Individuals have Poisson offspring distribution with mean $1+p$ and certain deletions and mergers occur with probability $q$; these parameters correspond to the mean number of edges discovered from a given vertex in an exploration of a percolation cluster and to the probability that a non-backtracking path of length four closes a cycle, respectively.
We prove survival and extinction under certain conditions on $p$ and $q$ that heuristically match the known expansions of the critical probabilities for bond percolation on the lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ and the hypercube $Q_d$. These expansions have been rigorously established by Hara and Slade in 1995, and van der Hofstad and Slade in 2006, respectively. We stress that our method does not constitute a branching process proof for the percolation threshold.
The analysis of the graph process survival is considerably more challenging than for branching processes in discrete time, due to the interdependence between the descendants of different individuals in the same generation. In fact, it is left open whether the survival probability of $\mathcal{G}(p,q)$ is monotone in $p$ or $q$; we discuss this and some other open problems regarding the new graph process.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Genealogy and spatial distribution of the $N$-particle branching random walk with polynomial tails
Authors:
Sarah Penington,
Matthew I. Roberts,
Zsófia Talyigás
Abstract:
The $N$-particle branching random walk is a discrete time branching particle system with selection. We have $N$ particles located on the real line at all times. At every time step each particle is replaced by two offspring, and each offspring particle makes a jump of non-negative size from its parent's location, independently from the other jumps, according to a given jump distribution. Then only…
▽ More
The $N$-particle branching random walk is a discrete time branching particle system with selection. We have $N$ particles located on the real line at all times. At every time step each particle is replaced by two offspring, and each offspring particle makes a jump of non-negative size from its parent's location, independently from the other jumps, according to a given jump distribution. Then only the $N$ rightmost particles survive; the other particles are removed from the system to keep the population size constant. Inspired by work of J. Bérard and P. Maillard, we examine the long term behaviour of this particle system in the case where the jump distribution has regularly varying tails and the number of particles is large. We prove that at a typical large time the genealogy of the population is given by a star-shaped coalescent, and that almost the whole population is near the leftmost particle on the relevant space scale.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Genealogies in bistable waves
Authors:
Alison Etheridge,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We study a model of selection acting on a diploid population (one in which each individual carries two copies of each gene) living in one spatial dimension. We suppose a particular gene appears in two forms (alleles) $A$ and $a$, and that individuals carrying $AA$ have a higher fitness than $aa$ individuals, while $Aa$ individuals have a lower fitness than both $AA$ and $aa$ individuals. The propo…
▽ More
We study a model of selection acting on a diploid population (one in which each individual carries two copies of each gene) living in one spatial dimension. We suppose a particular gene appears in two forms (alleles) $A$ and $a$, and that individuals carrying $AA$ have a higher fitness than $aa$ individuals, while $Aa$ individuals have a lower fitness than both $AA$ and $aa$ individuals. The proportion of advantageous $A$ alleles expands through the population approximately according to a travelling wave. We prove that on a suitable timescale, the genealogy of a sample of $A$ alleles taken from near the wavefront converges to a Kingman coalescent as the population density goes to infinity. This contrasts with the case of directional selection in which the corresponding limit is thought to be the Bolthausen-Sznitman coalescent. The proof uses 'tracer dynamics'.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Brownian bees in the infinite swarm limit
Authors:
Julien Berestycki,
Eric Brunet,
James Nolen,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
The Brownian bees model is a branching particle system with spatial selection. It is a system of $N$ particles which move as independent Brownian motions in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and independently branch at rate 1, and, crucially, at each branching event, the particle which is the furthest away from the origin is removed to keep the population size constant. In the present work we prove that as…
▽ More
The Brownian bees model is a branching particle system with spatial selection. It is a system of $N$ particles which move as independent Brownian motions in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and independently branch at rate 1, and, crucially, at each branching event, the particle which is the furthest away from the origin is removed to keep the population size constant. In the present work we prove that as $N \to \infty$ the behaviour of the particle system is well approximated by the solution of a free boundary problem (which is the subject of a companion paper), the hydrodynamic limit of the system. We then show that for this model the so-called selection principle holds, i.e. that as $N \to \infty$ the equilibrium density of the particle system converges to the steady state solution of the free boundary problem.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A free boundary problem arising from branching Brownian motion with selection
Authors:
Julien Berestycki,
Éric Brunet,
James Nolen,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We study a free boundary problem for a parabolic partial differential equation in which the solution is coupled to the moving boundary through an integral constraint. The problem arises as the hydrodynamic limit of an interacting particle system involving branching Brownian motion with selection, the so-called Brownian bees model which is studied in a companion paper. In this paper we prove existe…
▽ More
We study a free boundary problem for a parabolic partial differential equation in which the solution is coupled to the moving boundary through an integral constraint. The problem arises as the hydrodynamic limit of an interacting particle system involving branching Brownian motion with selection, the so-called Brownian bees model which is studied in a companion paper. In this paper we prove existence and uniqueness of the solution to the free boundary problem, and we characterise the behaviour of the solution in the large time limit.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Global existence for a free boundary problem of Fisher-KPP type
Authors:
Julien Berestycki,
Eric Brunet,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
Motivated by the study of branching particle systems with selection, we establish global existence for the solution $(u,μ)$ of the free boundary problem \[ \begin{cases} \partial_t u =\partial^2_{x} u +u & \text{for $t>0$ and $x>μ_t$,}\\ u(x,t)=1 &\text{for $t>0$ and $x \leq μ_t$}, \\ \partial_x u(μ_t,t)=0 & \text{for $t>0$}, \\ u(x,0)=v(x) &\text{for $x\in \mathbb{R}$}, \end{cases} \] when the in…
▽ More
Motivated by the study of branching particle systems with selection, we establish global existence for the solution $(u,μ)$ of the free boundary problem \[ \begin{cases} \partial_t u =\partial^2_{x} u +u & \text{for $t>0$ and $x>μ_t$,}\\ u(x,t)=1 &\text{for $t>0$ and $x \leq μ_t$}, \\ \partial_x u(μ_t,t)=0 & \text{for $t>0$}, \\ u(x,0)=v(x) &\text{for $x\in \mathbb{R}$}, \end{cases} \] when the initial condition $v:\mathbb{R}\to[0,1]$ is non-increasing with $v(x) \to 0$ as $x\to \infty$ and $v(x)\to 1$ as $x\to -\infty$. We construct the solution as the limit of a sequence $(u_n)_{n\ge 1}$, where each $ u_n$ is the solution of a Fisher-KPP equation with same initial condition, but with a different non-linear term.
Recent results of De Masi \textit{et al.}~\cite{DeMasi2017a} show that this global solution can be identified with the hydrodynamic limit of the so-called $N$-BBM, {\it i.e.} a branching Brownian motion in which the population size is kept constant equal to $N$ by killing the leftmost particle at each branching event.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2018; v1 submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Branching Brownian motion with decay of mass and the non-local Fisher-KPP equation
Authors:
Louigi Addario-Berry,
Julien Berestycki,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
In this work we study a non-local version of the Fisher-KPP equation, \begin{equation*} \begin{cases} \frac{\partial u}{\partial t}=\tfrac{1}{2}Δu +u (1- φ\ast u), \quad t>0, \quad x\in \mathbb{R}, u(0,x)=u_0(x), \quad x\in \mathbb{R} \end{cases} \end{equation*} and its relation to $\textit{branching Brownian motion with decay of mass}$ as introduced by Addario-Berry and Penington (2017), i.e. a p…
▽ More
In this work we study a non-local version of the Fisher-KPP equation, \begin{equation*} \begin{cases} \frac{\partial u}{\partial t}=\tfrac{1}{2}Δu +u (1- φ\ast u), \quad t>0, \quad x\in \mathbb{R}, u(0,x)=u_0(x), \quad x\in \mathbb{R} \end{cases} \end{equation*} and its relation to $\textit{branching Brownian motion with decay of mass}$ as introduced by Addario-Berry and Penington (2017), i.e. a particle system consisting of a standard branching Brownian motion (BBM) with a competitive interaction between nearby particles. Particles in the BBM with decay of mass have a position in $\mathbb{R}$ and a mass, branch at rate 1 into two daughter particles of the same mass and position, and move independently as Brownian motions. Particles lose mass at a rate proportional to the mass in a neighbourhood around them (as measured by the function $φ$).
We obtain two types of results. First, we study the behaviour of solutions to the partial differential equation above. We show that, under suitable conditions on $φ$ and $u_0$, the solutions converge to 1 behind the front and are globally bounded, improving recent results of Hamel and Ryzhik (arxiv:arXiv:1307.3001). Second, we show that the hydrodynamic limit of the BBM with decay of mass is the solution of the non-local Fisher-KPP equation. We then harness this to obtain several new results concerning the behaviour of the particle system.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
The spreading speed of solutions of the non-local Fisher-KPP equation
Authors:
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We consider the Fisher-KPP equation with a non-local interaction term. Hamel and Ryzhik showed that in solutions of this equation, the front location at a large time $t$ is $\sqrt 2 t +o(t)$. We study the asymptotics of the second order term in the front location. If the interaction kernel $φ(x)$ decays sufficiently fast as $x\rightarrow \infty$ then this term is given by…
▽ More
We consider the Fisher-KPP equation with a non-local interaction term. Hamel and Ryzhik showed that in solutions of this equation, the front location at a large time $t$ is $\sqrt 2 t +o(t)$. We study the asymptotics of the second order term in the front location. If the interaction kernel $φ(x)$ decays sufficiently fast as $x\rightarrow \infty$ then this term is given by $-\frac{3}{2\sqrt 2 }\log t +o(\log t)$, which is the same correction as found by Bramson for the local Fisher-KPP equation. However, if $φ$ has a heavier tail then the second order term is $-t^{β+o(1)}$, where $β\in (0,1)$ depends on the tail of $φ$. The proofs are probabilistic, using a Feynman-Kac formula. Since solutions of the non-local Fisher-KPP equation do not obey the maximum principle, the proofs differ from those in Bramson's work, although some of the ideas used are similar.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Branching Brownian Motion, mean curvature flow and the motion of hybrid zones
Authors:
Alison Etheridge,
Nic Freeman,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We provide a probabilistic proof of a well known connection between a special case of the Allen-Cahn equation and mean curvature flow. We then prove a corresponding result for scaling limits of the spatial $Λ$-Fleming-Viot process with selection, in which the selection mechanism is chosen to model what are known in population genetics as hybrid zones. Our proofs will exploit a duality with a syste…
▽ More
We provide a probabilistic proof of a well known connection between a special case of the Allen-Cahn equation and mean curvature flow. We then prove a corresponding result for scaling limits of the spatial $Λ$-Fleming-Viot process with selection, in which the selection mechanism is chosen to model what are known in population genetics as hybrid zones. Our proofs will exploit a duality with a system of branching (and coalescing) random walkers which is of some interest in its own right.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
A central limit theorem for the spatial Lambda Fleming-Viot process with selection
Authors:
Raphaël Forien,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We study the evolution of gene frequencies in a population living in $\mathbb{R}^d$, modelled by the spatial Lambda Fleming-Viot process with natural selection (Barton, Etheridge and Veber, 2010 and Etheridge, Veber and Yu, 2014). We suppose that the population is divided into two genetic types, $a$ and $A$, and consider the proportion of the population which is of type $a$ at each spatial locatio…
▽ More
We study the evolution of gene frequencies in a population living in $\mathbb{R}^d$, modelled by the spatial Lambda Fleming-Viot process with natural selection (Barton, Etheridge and Veber, 2010 and Etheridge, Veber and Yu, 2014). We suppose that the population is divided into two genetic types, $a$ and $A$, and consider the proportion of the population which is of type $a$ at each spatial location. If we let both the selection intensity and the fraction of individuals replaced during reproduction events tend to zero, the process can be rescaled so as to converge to the solution to a reaction-diffusion equation (typically the Fisher-KPP equation, as in Etheridge, Veber and Yu, 2014). We show that the rescaled fluctuations converge in distribution to the solution to a linear stochastic partial differential equation. Depending on whether offspring dispersal is only local or if large scale extinction-recolonization events are allowed to take place, the limiting equation is either the stochastic heat equation with a linear drift term driven by space-time white noise or the corresponding fractional heat equation driven by a coloured noise which is white in time. If individuals are diploid (i.e. either $AA$, $Aa$ or $aa$) and if natural selection favours heterozygous ($Aa$) individuals, a stable intermediate gene frequency is maintained in the population. We give estimates for the asymptotic effect of random fluctuations around the equilibrium frequency on the local average fitness in the population. In particular, we find that the size of this effect - known as the drift load - depends crucially on the dimension $d$ of the space in which the population evolves, and is reduced relative to the case without spatial structure.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2016; v1 submitted 18 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Branching Brownian motion and Selection in the Spatial Lambda-Fleming-Viot Process
Authors:
Alison Etheridge,
Nic Freeman,
Sarah Penington,
Daniel Straulino
Abstract:
We ask the question "when will natural selection on a gene in a spatially structured population cause a detectable trace in the patterns of genetic variation observed in the contemporary population?". We focus on the situation in which 'neighbourhood size', that is the effective local population density, is small. The genealogy relating individuals in a sample from the population is embedded in a…
▽ More
We ask the question "when will natural selection on a gene in a spatially structured population cause a detectable trace in the patterns of genetic variation observed in the contemporary population?". We focus on the situation in which 'neighbourhood size', that is the effective local population density, is small. The genealogy relating individuals in a sample from the population is embedded in a spatial version of the ancestral selection graph and through applying a diffusive scaling to this object we show that whereas in dimensions at least three, selection is barely impeded by the spatial structure, in the most relevant dimension, $d=2$, selection must be stronger (by a factor of $\log(1/μ)$ where $μ$ is the neutral mutation rate) if we are to have a chance of detecting it. The case $d=1$ was handled in Etheridge et al. (2015).
The mathematical interest is that although the system of branching and coalescing lineages that forms the ancestral selection graph converges to a branching Brownian motion, this reflects a delicate balance of a branching rate that grows to infinity and the instant annullation of almost all branches through coalescence caused by the strong local competition in the population.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2016; v1 submitted 11 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
The front location in BBM with decay of mass
Authors:
Louigi Addario-Berry,
Sarah Penington
Abstract:
We augment standard branching Brownian motion by adding a competitive interaction between nearby particles. Informally, when particles are in competition, the local resources are insufficient to cover the energetic cost of motion, so the particles' masses decay. In standard BBM, we may define the front displacement at time $t$ as the greatest distance of a particle from the origin. For the model w…
▽ More
We augment standard branching Brownian motion by adding a competitive interaction between nearby particles. Informally, when particles are in competition, the local resources are insufficient to cover the energetic cost of motion, so the particles' masses decay. In standard BBM, we may define the front displacement at time $t$ as the greatest distance of a particle from the origin. For the model with masses, it makes sense to instead define the front displacement as the distance at which the local mass density drops from $Θ(1)$ to $o(1)$. We show that one can find arbitrarily large times $t$ for which this occurs at a distance $Θ(t^{1/3})$ behind the front displacement for standard BBM.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2015; v1 submitted 4 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
