-
Adaptive Stochastic Gradient Descent for Fast and Communication-Efficient Distributed Learning
Authors:
Serge Kas Hanna,
Rawad Bitar,
Parimal Parag,
Venkat Dasari,
Salim El Rouayheb
Abstract:
We consider the setting where a master wants to run a distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm on $n$ workers, each having a subset of the data. Distributed SGD may suffer from the effect of stragglers, i.e., slow or unresponsive workers who cause delays. One solution studied in the literature is to wait at each iteration for the responses of the fastest $k<n$ workers before updatin…
▽ More
We consider the setting where a master wants to run a distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm on $n$ workers, each having a subset of the data. Distributed SGD may suffer from the effect of stragglers, i.e., slow or unresponsive workers who cause delays. One solution studied in the literature is to wait at each iteration for the responses of the fastest $k<n$ workers before updating the model, where $k$ is a fixed parameter. The choice of the value of $k$ presents a trade-off between the runtime (i.e., convergence rate) of SGD and the error of the model. Towards optimizing the error-runtime trade-off, we investigate distributed SGD with adaptive~$k$, i.e., varying $k$ throughout the runtime of the algorithm. We first design an adaptive policy for varying $k$ that optimizes this trade-off based on an upper bound on the error as a function of the wall-clock time that we derive. Then, we propose and implement an algorithm for adaptive distributed SGD that is based on a statistical heuristic. Our results show that the adaptive version of distributed SGD can reach lower error values in less time compared to non-adaptive implementations. Moreover, the results also show that the adaptive version is communication-efficient, where the amount of communication required between the master and the workers is less than that of non-adaptive versions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Latency-Redundancy Tradeoff in Distributed Read-Write Systems
Authors:
Saraswathy Ramanathan,
Gaurav Gautam,
Vikram Srinivasan,
Parimal Parag
Abstract:
Data is replicated and stored redundantly over multiple servers for availability in distributed databases. We focus on databases with frequent reads and writes, where both read and write latencies are important. This is in contrast to databases designed primarily for either read or write applications. Redundancy has contrasting effects on read and write latency. Read latency can be reduced by pote…
▽ More
Data is replicated and stored redundantly over multiple servers for availability in distributed databases. We focus on databases with frequent reads and writes, where both read and write latencies are important. This is in contrast to databases designed primarily for either read or write applications. Redundancy has contrasting effects on read and write latency. Read latency can be reduced by potential parallel access from multiple servers, whereas write latency increases as a larger number of replicas have to be updated. We quantify this tradeoff between read and write latency as a function of redundancy, and provide a closed-form approximation when the request arrival is Poisson and the service is memoryless. We empirically show that this approximation is tight across all ranges of system parameters. Thus, we provide guidelines for redundancy selection in distributed databases.
△ Less
Submitted 27 November, 2021; v1 submitted 31 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Modeling Performance and Energy trade-offs in Online Data-Intensive Applications
Authors:
Ajay Badita,
Rooji Jinan,
Balajee Vamanan,
Parimal Parag
Abstract:
We consider energy minimization for data-intensive applications run on large number of servers, for given performance guarantees. We consider a system, where each incoming application is sent to a set of servers, and is considered to be completed if a subset of them finish serving it. We consider a simple case when each server core has two speed levels, where the higher speed can be achieved by hi…
▽ More
We consider energy minimization for data-intensive applications run on large number of servers, for given performance guarantees. We consider a system, where each incoming application is sent to a set of servers, and is considered to be completed if a subset of them finish serving it. We consider a simple case when each server core has two speed levels, where the higher speed can be achieved by higher power for each core independently. The core selects one of the two speeds probabilistically for each incoming application request. We model arrival of application requests by a Poisson process, and random service time at the server with independent exponential random variables. Our model and analysis generalizes to today's state-of-the-art in CPU energy management where each core can independently select a speed level from a set of supported speeds and corresponding voltages. The performance metrics under consideration are the mean number of applications in the system and the average energy expenditure. We first provide a tight approximation to study this previously intractable problem and derive closed form approximate expressions for the performance metrics when service times are exponentially distributed. Next, we study the trade-off between the approximate mean number of applications and energy expenditure in terms of the switching probability.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Optimal Pricing in Multi Server Systems
Authors:
Ashok Krishnan K. S,
Chandramani Singh,
Siva Theja Maguluri,
Parimal Parag
Abstract:
We study optimal service pricing in server farms where customers arrive according to a renewal process and have independent and identical ($i.i.d.$) exponential service times and $i.i.d.$ valuations of the service. The service provider charges a time varying service fee aiming at maximizing its revenue rate. The customers that find free servers and service fees lesser than their valuation join for…
▽ More
We study optimal service pricing in server farms where customers arrive according to a renewal process and have independent and identical ($i.i.d.$) exponential service times and $i.i.d.$ valuations of the service. The service provider charges a time varying service fee aiming at maximizing its revenue rate. The customers that find free servers and service fees lesser than their valuation join for the service else they leave without waiting. We consider both finite server and infinite server farms. We solve the optimal pricing problems using the framework of Markov decision problems. We show that the optimal prices depend on the number of free servers. We propose algorithms to compute the optimal prices. We also establish several properties of the optimal prices and the corresponding revenue rates in the case of Poisson customer arrivals. We illustrate all our findings via numerical results.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Load balancing policies without feedback using timed replicas
Authors:
Rooji Jinan,
Ajay Badita,
Tejas Bodas,
Parimal Parag
Abstract:
Dispatching policies such as the join shortest queue (JSQ), join smallest work (JSW) and their power of two variants are used in load balancing systems where the instantaneous queue length or workload information at all queues or a subset of them can be queried. In situations where the dispatcher has an associated memory, one can minimize this query overhead by maintaining a list of idle servers t…
▽ More
Dispatching policies such as the join shortest queue (JSQ), join smallest work (JSW) and their power of two variants are used in load balancing systems where the instantaneous queue length or workload information at all queues or a subset of them can be queried. In situations where the dispatcher has an associated memory, one can minimize this query overhead by maintaining a list of idle servers to which jobs can be dispatched. Recent alternative approaches that do not require querying such information include the cancel on start and cancel on complete based replication policies. The downside of such policies however is that the servers must communicate the start or completion of each service to the dispatcher and must allow cancellation of redundant copies. In practice, the requirements of query messaging, memory, and replica cancellation pose challenges in their implementation and their advantages are not clear. In this work, we consider load balancing policies that do not query load information, do not have a memory, and do not cancel replicas. Surprisingly, we were able to identify operating regimes where such policies have better performance when compared to some of the popular policies that utilize server feedback information. Our policies allow the dispatcher to append a timer to each job or its replica. A job or a replica is discarded if its timer expires before it starts receiving service. We analyze several variants of this policy which are novel, simple to implement, and also have remarkably good performance in some operating regimes, despite no feedback from servers to the dispatcher.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2022; v1 submitted 26 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Latency optimal storage and scheduling of replicated fragments for memory-constrained servers
Authors:
Rooji Jinan,
Ajay Badita,
Pradeep Sarvepalli,
Parimal Parag
Abstract:
We consider the setting of distributed storage system where a single file is subdivided into smaller fragments of same size which are then replicated with a common replication factor across servers of identical cache size. An incoming file download request is sent to all the servers, and the download is completed whenever request gathers all the fragments. At each server, we are interested in dete…
▽ More
We consider the setting of distributed storage system where a single file is subdivided into smaller fragments of same size which are then replicated with a common replication factor across servers of identical cache size. An incoming file download request is sent to all the servers, and the download is completed whenever request gathers all the fragments. At each server, we are interested in determining the set of fragments to be stored, and the sequence in which fragments should be accessed, such that the mean file download time for a request is minimized. We model the fragment download time as an exponential random variable independent and identically distributed for all fragments across all servers, and show that the mean file download time can be lower bounded in terms of the expected number of useful servers summed over all distinct fragment downloads. We present deterministic storage schemes that attempt to maximize the number of useful servers. We show that finding the optimal sequence of accessing the fragments is a Markov decision problem, whose complexity grows exponentially with the number of fragments. We propose heuristic algorithms that determine the sequence of access to the fragments which are empirically shown to perform well.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Tracking an Auto-Regressive Process with Limited Communication per Unit Time
Authors:
Rooji Jinan,
Parimal Parag,
Himanshu Tyagi
Abstract:
Samples from a high-dimensional AR[1] process are observed by a sender which can communicate only finitely many bits per unit time to a receiver. The receiver seeks to form an estimate of the process value at every time instant in real-time. We consider a time-slotted communication model in a slow-sampling regime where multiple communication slots occur between two sampling instants. We propose a…
▽ More
Samples from a high-dimensional AR[1] process are observed by a sender which can communicate only finitely many bits per unit time to a receiver. The receiver seeks to form an estimate of the process value at every time instant in real-time. We consider a time-slotted communication model in a slow-sampling regime where multiple communication slots occur between two sampling instants. We propose a successive update scheme which uses communication between sampling instants to refine estimates of the latest sample and study the following question: Is it better to collect communication of multiple slots to send better refined estimates, making the receiver wait more for every refinement, or to be fast but loose and send new information in every communication opportunity? We show that the fast but loose successive update scheme with ideal spherical codes is universally optimal asymptotically for a large dimension. However, most practical quantization codes for fixed dimensions do not meet the ideal performance required for this optimality, and they typically will have a bias in the form of a fixed additive error. Interestingly, our analysis shows that the fast but loose scheme is not an optimal choice in the presence of such errors, and a judiciously chosen frequency of updates outperforms it.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Adaptive Distributed Stochastic Gradient Descent for Minimizing Delay in the Presence of Stragglers
Authors:
Serge Kas Hanna,
Rawad Bitar,
Parimal Parag,
Venkat Dasari,
Salim El Rouayheb
Abstract:
We consider the setting where a master wants to run a distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm on $n$ workers each having a subset of the data. Distributed SGD may suffer from the effect of stragglers, i.e., slow or unresponsive workers who cause delays. One solution studied in the literature is to wait at each iteration for the responses of the fastest $k<n$ workers before updating…
▽ More
We consider the setting where a master wants to run a distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) algorithm on $n$ workers each having a subset of the data. Distributed SGD may suffer from the effect of stragglers, i.e., slow or unresponsive workers who cause delays. One solution studied in the literature is to wait at each iteration for the responses of the fastest $k<n$ workers before updating the model, where $k$ is a fixed parameter. The choice of the value of $k$ presents a trade-off between the runtime (i.e., convergence rate) of SGD and the error of the model. Towards optimizing the error-runtime trade-off, we investigate distributed SGD with adaptive $k$. We first design an adaptive policy for varying $k$ that optimizes this trade-off based on an upper bound on the error as a function of the wall-clock time which we derive. Then, we propose an algorithm for adaptive distributed SGD that is based on a statistical heuristic. We implement our algorithm and provide numerical simulations which confirm our intuition and theoretical analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Optimal Server Selection for Straggler Mitigation
Authors:
Ajay Badita,
Parimal Parag,
Vaneet Aggarwal
Abstract:
The performance of large-scale distributed compute systems is adversely impacted by stragglers when the execution time of a job is uncertain. To manage stragglers, we consider a multi-fork approach for job scheduling, where additional parallel servers are added at forking instants. In terms of the forking instants and the number of additional servers, we compute the job completion time and the cos…
▽ More
The performance of large-scale distributed compute systems is adversely impacted by stragglers when the execution time of a job is uncertain. To manage stragglers, we consider a multi-fork approach for job scheduling, where additional parallel servers are added at forking instants. In terms of the forking instants and the number of additional servers, we compute the job completion time and the cost of server utilization when the task processing times are assumed to have a shifted exponential distribution. We use this study to provide insights into the scheduling design of the forking instants and the associated number of additional servers to be started. Numerical results demonstrate orders of magnitude improvement in cost in the regime of low completion times as compared to the prior works.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Mode-Suppression: A Simple, Stable and Scalable Chunk-Sharing Algorithm for P2P Networks
Authors:
Vamseedhar Reddyvari Raja,
Parimal Parag,
Srinivas Shakkottai
Abstract:
The ability of a P2P network to scale its throughput up in proportion to the arrival rate of peers has recently been shown to be crucially dependent on the chunk sharing policy employed. Some policies can result in low frequencies of a particular chunk, known as the missing chunk syndrome, which can dramatically reduce throughput and lead to instability of the system. For instance, commonly used p…
▽ More
The ability of a P2P network to scale its throughput up in proportion to the arrival rate of peers has recently been shown to be crucially dependent on the chunk sharing policy employed. Some policies can result in low frequencies of a particular chunk, known as the missing chunk syndrome, which can dramatically reduce throughput and lead to instability of the system. For instance, commonly used policies that nominally "boost" the sharing of infrequent chunks such as the well known rarest-first algorithm have been shown to be unstable. Recent efforts have largely focused on the careful design of boosting policies to mitigate this issue. We take a complementary viewpoint, and instead consider a policy that simply prevents the sharing of the most frequent chunk(s). Following terminology from statistics wherein the most frequent value in a data set is called the mode, we refer to this policy as mode-suppression. We also consider a more general version that suppresses the mode only if the mode frequency is larger than the lowest frequency by a fixed threshold. We prove the stability of mode-suppression using Lyapunov techniques, and use a Kingman bound argument to show that the total download time does not increase with peer arrival rate. We then design versions of mode-suppression that sample a small number of peers at each time, and construct noisy mode estimates by aggregating these samples over time. We show numerically that the variants of mode-suppression yield near-optimal download times, and outperform all other recently proposed chunk sharing algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Optimal Source Codes for Timely Updates
Authors:
Prathamesh Mayekar,
Parimal Parag,
Himanshu Tyagi
Abstract:
A transmitter observing a sequence of independent and identically distributed random variables seeks to keep a receiver updated about its latest observations. The receiver need not be apprised about each symbol seen by the transmitter, but needs to output a symbol at each time instant $t$. If at time $t$ the receiver outputs the symbol seen by the transmitter at time $U(t)\leq t$, the age of infor…
▽ More
A transmitter observing a sequence of independent and identically distributed random variables seeks to keep a receiver updated about its latest observations. The receiver need not be apprised about each symbol seen by the transmitter, but needs to output a symbol at each time instant $t$. If at time $t$ the receiver outputs the symbol seen by the transmitter at time $U(t)\leq t$, the age of information at the receiver at time $t$ is $t-U(t)$. We study the design of lossless source codes that enable transmission with minimum average age at the receiver. We show that the asymptotic minimum average age can be attained up to a constant gap by the Shannon codes for a tilted version of the original pmf generating the symbols, which can be computed easily by solving an optimization problem. Furthermore, we exhibit an example with alphabet $\X$ where Shannon codes for the original pmf incur an asymptotic average age of a factor $O(\sqrt{\log |\X|})$ more than that achieved by our codes. Underlying our prescription for optimal codes is a new variational formula for integer moments of random variables, which may be of independent interest. Also, we discuss possible extensions of our formulation to randomized schemes and to the erasure channel, and include a treatment of the related problem of source coding for minimum average queuing delay.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2020; v1 submitted 12 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
A Systematic Approach to Incremental Redundancy over Erasure Channels
Authors:
Anoosheh Heidarzadeh,
Jean-Francois Chamberland,
Parimal Parag,
Richard D. Wesel
Abstract:
As sensing and instrumentation play an increasingly important role in systems controlled over wired and wireless networks, the need to better understand delay-sensitive communication becomes a prime issue. Along these lines, this article studies the operation of data links that employ incremental redundancy as a practical means to protect information from the effects of unreliable channels. Specif…
▽ More
As sensing and instrumentation play an increasingly important role in systems controlled over wired and wireless networks, the need to better understand delay-sensitive communication becomes a prime issue. Along these lines, this article studies the operation of data links that employ incremental redundancy as a practical means to protect information from the effects of unreliable channels. Specifically, this work extends a powerful methodology termed sequential differential optimization to choose near-optimal block sizes for hybrid ARQ over erasure channels. In doing so, an interesting connection between random coding and well-known constants in number theory is established. Furthermore, results show that the impact of the coding strategy adopted and the propensity of the channel to erase symbols naturally decouple when analyzing throughput. Overall, block size selection is motivated by normal approximations on the probability of decoding success at every stage of the incremental transmission process. This novel perspective, which rigorously bridges hybrid ARQ and coding, offers a pragmatic means to select code rates and blocklengths for incremental redundancy.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Minimizing Latency for Secure Coded Computing Using Secret Sharing via Staircase Codes
Authors:
Rawad Bitar,
Parimal Parag,
Salim El Rouayheb
Abstract:
We consider the setting of a Master server, M, who possesses confidential data (e.g., personal, genomic or medical data) and wants to run intensive computations on it, as part of a machine learning algorithm for example. The Master wants to distribute these computations to untrusted workers who have volunteered or are incentivized to help with this task. However, the data must be kept private and…
▽ More
We consider the setting of a Master server, M, who possesses confidential data (e.g., personal, genomic or medical data) and wants to run intensive computations on it, as part of a machine learning algorithm for example. The Master wants to distribute these computations to untrusted workers who have volunteered or are incentivized to help with this task. However, the data must be kept private and not revealed to the individual workers. Some of the workers may be stragglers, e.g., slow or busy, and will take a random time to finish the task assigned to them. We are interested in reducing the delays experienced by the Master. We focus on linear computations as an essential operation in many iterative algorithms such as principal component analysis, support vector machines and other gradient-descent based algorithms. A classical solution is to use a linear secret sharing scheme, such as Shamir's scheme, to divide the data into secret shares on which the workers can perform linear computations. However, classical codes can provide straggler mitigation assuming a worst-case scenario of a fixed number of stragglers. We propose a solution based on new secure codes, called Staircase codes, introduced previously by two of the authors. Staircase codes allow flexibility in the number of stragglers up to a given maximum, and universally achieve the information theoretic limit on the download cost by the Master, leading to latency reduction. Under the shifted exponential model, we find upper and lower bounds on the Master's mean waiting time. We derive the distribution of the Master's waiting time, and its mean, for systems with up to two stragglers. For systems with any number of stragglers, we derive an expression that can give the exact distribution, and the mean, of the waiting time of the Master. We show that Staircase codes always outperform classical secret sharing codes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Minimizing Latency for Secure Distributed Computing
Authors:
Rawad Bitar,
Parimal Parag,
Salim El Rouayheb
Abstract:
We consider the setting of a master server who possesses confidential data (genomic, medical data, etc.) and wants to run intensive computations on it, as part of a machine learning algorithm for example. The master wants to distribute these computations to untrusted workers who have volunteered or are incentivized to help with this task. However, the data must be kept private (in an information t…
▽ More
We consider the setting of a master server who possesses confidential data (genomic, medical data, etc.) and wants to run intensive computations on it, as part of a machine learning algorithm for example. The master wants to distribute these computations to untrusted workers who have volunteered or are incentivized to help with this task. However, the data must be kept private (in an information theoretic sense) and not revealed to the individual workers. The workers may be busy, or even unresponsive, and will take a random time to finish the task assigned to them. We are interested in reducing the aggregate delay experienced by the master. We focus on linear computations as an essential operation in many iterative algorithms. A known solution is to use a linear secret sharing scheme to divide the data into secret shares on which the workers can compute. We propose to use instead new secure codes, called Staircase codes, introduced previously by two of the authors. We study the delay induced by Staircase codes which is always less than that of secret sharing. The reason is that secret sharing schemes need to wait for the responses of a fixed fraction of the workers, whereas Staircase codes offer more flexibility in this respect. For instance, for codes with rate $R=1/2$ Staircase codes can lead to up to $40\%$ reduction in delay compared to secret sharing.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
On the Queueing Behavior of Random Codes over a Gilbert-Elliot Erasure Channel
Authors:
Parimal Parag,
Jean-Francois Chamberland,
Henry D. Pfister,
Krishna R. Narayanan
Abstract:
This paper considers the queueing performance of a system that transmits coded data over a time-varying erasure channel. In our model, the queue length and channel state together form a Markov chain that depends on the system parameters. This gives a framework that allows a rigorous analysis of the queue as a function of the code rate. Most prior work in this area either ignores block-length (e.g.…
▽ More
This paper considers the queueing performance of a system that transmits coded data over a time-varying erasure channel. In our model, the queue length and channel state together form a Markov chain that depends on the system parameters. This gives a framework that allows a rigorous analysis of the queue as a function of the code rate. Most prior work in this area either ignores block-length (e.g., fluid models) or assumes error-free communication using finite codes. This work enables one to determine when such assumptions provide good, or bad, approximations of true behavior. Moreover, it offers a new approach to optimize parameters and evaluate performance. This can be valuable for delay-sensitive systems that employ short block lengths.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
