-
Galaxy Clustering and Dark Energy
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Cristiano Porciani,
Yun Wang
Abstract:
We study the evolution of galaxy clustering in various cosmological models with quintessence. We investigate how the analytical predictions vary with change of dark energy equation of state $w_X$. Comparing these predictions against available data we discuss to what extent the problems of galaxy biasing can be modelled. This will be key in constraining the dark energy equation of state with futu…
▽ More
We study the evolution of galaxy clustering in various cosmological models with quintessence. We investigate how the analytical predictions vary with change of dark energy equation of state $w_X$. Comparing these predictions against available data we discuss to what extent the problems of galaxy biasing can be modelled. This will be key in constraining the dark energy equation of state with future galaxy surveys. We use a compilation of various surveys to study the number density and amplitude of galaxy clustering from observations of the local universe at $z \sim 0$ to that of the Lyman break galaxies and Ly-$α$ emitters at $z \sim 4.9$. We find that there is a degeneracy between the dark energy equation of state and the way galaxies populate dark matter haloes; objects are more biased in models with more negative values of dark energy equation of state $w_X$.
We conclude that, while future all sky CMB observations will determine cosmological parameters with unprecedented precision, and cross correlation of weak lensing experiments and galaxy surveys will provide a cleaner and accurate picture of bias associated with collapsed objects, the rate of growth of large scale structure in such surveys can potentially constrain the equation of state of dark energy and the potential of the scalar field associated with quintessence. In particular, we show that the abundance and spatial distribution of galaxy clusters at intermediate redshifts strongly depend on the dark energy equation of state. When accurate measurement of galaxy clustering at high-redshit becomes possible, it will provide constraints on dark energy that are independent and complementary to type Ia supernova studies.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2004; v1 submitted 25 February, 2003;
originally announced February 2003.
-
Dark energy effects on the Lyman-alpha forest
Authors:
M. Viel,
S. Matarrese,
Tom Theuns,
D. Munshi,
Yun Wang
Abstract:
In quintessence models, the dark energy content of the universe is described by a slowly rolling scalar field whose pressure and energy density obey an equation of state of the form p=w $ρ$; w is in general a function of time such that w<-1/3, in order to drive the observed acceleration of the Universe today. The cosmological constant model LCDM corresponds to the limiting case w=-1. In this pap…
▽ More
In quintessence models, the dark energy content of the universe is described by a slowly rolling scalar field whose pressure and energy density obey an equation of state of the form p=w $ρ$; w is in general a function of time such that w<-1/3, in order to drive the observed acceleration of the Universe today. The cosmological constant model LCDM corresponds to the limiting case w=-1. In this paper, we explore the prospects of using the Lyman-alpha forest to constrain w, using semi-analytical techniques to model the intergalactic medium (IGM). A different value of w changes both the growth factor and the Hubble parameter as a function of time. The resulting change in the optical depth distribution affects the optical depth power spectrum, the number of regions of high transmission per unit redshift and the cross-correlation coefficient of spectra of quasar pairs. These can be detected in current data, provided we have independent estimates of the thermal state of the IGM, its ionization parameter and the baryon density.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2003; v1 submitted 11 December, 2002;
originally announced December 2002.
-
Joint Analysis of CMB Temperature and Polarization Power Spectra
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Anthony D. Challinor,
Olivier Doré,
Daniel J. Mortlock,
George P. Efstathiou
Abstract:
This paper has been withdrawn. It was an early draft submitted prematurely in error. A complete version is to be submitted shortly.
This paper has been withdrawn. It was an early draft submitted prematurely in error. A complete version is to be submitted shortly.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2002; v1 submitted 7 August, 2002;
originally announced August 2002.
-
How Sensitive Are Weak Lensing Statistics to Dark Energy Content?
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Yun Wang
Abstract:
Future weak lensing surveys will directly probe the clustering of dark matter, in addition to providing a test for various cosmological models. Recent studies have provided us with the tools which can be used to construct the complete probability distribution function for convergence fields. It is also possible to construct the bias associated with the hot-spots in convergence maps. These techni…
▽ More
Future weak lensing surveys will directly probe the clustering of dark matter, in addition to providing a test for various cosmological models. Recent studies have provided us with the tools which can be used to construct the complete probability distribution function for convergence fields. It is also possible to construct the bias associated with the hot-spots in convergence maps. These techniques can be used in both the quasi-linear and the highly nonlinear regimes using various well developed numerical methods. We use these results here to study the weak lensing statistics of cosmological models with dark energy. We study how well various classes of dark energy models can be distinguished from models with a cosmological constant. We find that the ratio of the square root of the variance of convergence is complementary to the convergence skewness $S_3$ in probing dark energy equation of state; it can be used to predict the expected difference in weak lensing statistics between various dark energy models, and for choosing optimized smoothing angles to constrain a given class of dark energy models. Our results should be useful for probing dark energy using future weak lensing data with high statistics from galaxy weak lensing surveys and supernova pencil beam surveys.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2002; v1 submitted 27 June, 2002;
originally announced June 2002.
-
Probing the Dark Side of Gravitational Clustering: Weak Lensing Statistics at Large Smoothing Angle
Authors:
Dipak Munshi
Abstract:
The weak lensing surveys have the potential to probe directly the clustering statistics of dark matter in the universe. Recent studies have shown that it is possible to predict analytically the whole probability distribution function (pdf) and the bias associated with the collapsed objects in the highly non-linear regime using the hierarchical ansatz. We extend such studies to the quasi-linear r…
▽ More
The weak lensing surveys have the potential to probe directly the clustering statistics of dark matter in the universe. Recent studies have shown that it is possible to predict analytically the whole probability distribution function (pdf) and the bias associated with the collapsed objects in the highly non-linear regime using the hierarchical ansatz. We extend such studies to the quasi-linear regime where the hierarchical ansatz is replaced by the tree-level perturbative calculations to an arbitrary order. It is shown how the generating function techniques can be coupled with the perturbative calculations to compute the complete pdf and the bias in the quasi-linear regime for the weak-lensing convergence field. We study how these quantities depend on the smoothing angle and the source red-shift in different realistic cosmological scenarios. We show that it is possible to define a reduced convergence whose statistics is similar to underlying 3D mass distribution for small smoothing angle but it resembles projected mass distribution for large smoothing angles. We have also compared our peturbative results with log-normal model for pdf and bias and found a good agreement between the two analytical results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2002;
originally announced April 2002.
-
A universal probability distribution function for weak-lensing amplification
Authors:
Yun Wang,
Daniel E. Holz,
Dipak Munshi
Abstract:
We present an approximate form for the weak lensing magnification distribution of standard candles, valid for all cosmological models, with arbitrary matter distributions, over all redshifts. Our results are based on a universal probability distribution function (UPDF), $P(η)$, for the reduced convergence, $η$. For a given cosmological model, the magnification probability distribution, $P(μ)$, a…
▽ More
We present an approximate form for the weak lensing magnification distribution of standard candles, valid for all cosmological models, with arbitrary matter distributions, over all redshifts. Our results are based on a universal probability distribution function (UPDF), $P(η)$, for the reduced convergence, $η$. For a given cosmological model, the magnification probability distribution, $P(μ)$, at redshift $z$ is related to the UPDF by $P(μ)=P(η)/2|κ_{min}|$, where $η=1+(μ-1)/(2|κ_{min}|)$, and $κ_{min}$ (the minimum convergence) can be directly computed from the cosmological parameters ($Ω_m$ and $Ω_Λ$). We show that the UPDF can be well approximated by a three-parameter stretched Gaussian distribution, where the values of the three parameters depend only on $ξ_η$, the variance of $η$. In short, all possible weak lensing probability distributions can be well approximated by a one-parameter family. We establish this family, normalizing to the numerical ray-shooting results for a $Λ$CDM model by Wambsganss et al. (1997). Each alternative cosmological model is then described by a single function $ξ_η(z)$. We find that this method gives $P(μ)$ in excellent agreement with numerical ray-tracing and three-dimensional shear matrix calculations, and provide numerical fits for three representative models (SCDM, $Λ$CDM, and OCDM). Our results provide an easy, accurate, and efficient method to calculate the weak lensing magnification distribution of standard candles, and should be useful in the analysis of future high-redshift supernova data.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2002; v1 submitted 9 April, 2002;
originally announced April 2002.
-
Harmonic analysis of cosmic microwave background data I: ring reductions and point-source catalogue
Authors:
Floor van Leeuwen,
Anthony D. Challinor,
Daniel J. Mortlock,
Mark A. J. Ashdown,
Michael P. Hobson,
Anthony N. Lasenby,
George P. Efstathiou,
E. Paul. S. Shellard,
Dipak Munshi,
Vladislav Stolyarov
Abstract:
We present a harmonic model for the data analysis of an all-sky cosmic microwave background survey, such as Planck, where the survey is obtained through ring-scans of the sky. In this model, resampling and pixelisation of the data are avoided. The spherical transforms of the sky at each frequency, in total intensity and polarization, as well as the bright-point-source catalogue, are derived dire…
▽ More
We present a harmonic model for the data analysis of an all-sky cosmic microwave background survey, such as Planck, where the survey is obtained through ring-scans of the sky. In this model, resampling and pixelisation of the data are avoided. The spherical transforms of the sky at each frequency, in total intensity and polarization, as well as the bright-point-source catalogue, are derived directly from the data reduced onto the rings. Formal errors and the most significant correlation coefficients for the spherical transforms of the frequency maps are preserved. A clean and transparent path from the original samplings in the time domain to the final scientific products is thus obtained. The data analysis is largely based on Fourier analysis of rings; the positional stability of the instrument's spin axis during these scans is a requirement for the data model and is investigated here for the Planck satellite. Brighter point sources are recognised and extracted as part of the ring reductions and, on the basis of accumulated data, used to build a catalogue. The analysis of the rings is performed iteratively, involving a range of geometric and detector response calibrations. The reconstructed spherical transforms of the sky form the input to the subsequent analysis stages. Although the methods in this paper were developed with the data processing for Planck in mind, many aspects should have wider application, such as in the construction of real-space pixelised maps. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2001;
originally announced December 2001.
-
Error Estimates for Measurements of Cosmic Shear
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Peter Coles
Abstract:
In the very near future, weak lensing surveys will map the projected density of the universe in an unbiased way over large regions of the sky. In order to interpret the results of studies it is helpful to develop an understanding of the errors associated with quantities extracted from the observations. In a generalization of one of our earlier works, we present estimators of the cumulants and cu…
▽ More
In the very near future, weak lensing surveys will map the projected density of the universe in an unbiased way over large regions of the sky. In order to interpret the results of studies it is helpful to develop an understanding of the errors associated with quantities extracted from the observations. In a generalization of one of our earlier works, we present estimators of the cumulants and cumulant correlators of the weak lensing convergence field, and compute the variance associated with these estimators. By restricting ourselves to so-called compensated filters we are able to derive quite simple expressions for the errors on these estimates. We also separate contributions from cosmic variance, shot noise and intrinsic ellipticity of the source galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2002; v1 submitted 31 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
-
Cosmic Statistics through Weak Lenses
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Peter Coles
Abstract:
Many recent studies have demonstrated that scaling arguments, such as the so-called hierarchical {\em ansatz}, are extremely useful in understanding the statistical properties of weak gravitational lensing. This is especially true on small angular scales (i.e. at high resolution), where the usual perturbative calculations of matter clustering no longer apply. We build on these studies in order t…
▽ More
Many recent studies have demonstrated that scaling arguments, such as the so-called hierarchical {\em ansatz}, are extremely useful in understanding the statistical properties of weak gravitational lensing. This is especially true on small angular scales (i.e. at high resolution), where the usual perturbative calculations of matter clustering no longer apply. We build on these studies in order to develop a complete picture of weak lensing at small smoothing angles. In particular, we study the full probability distribution function, bias and other multipoint statistics for the ``hot spots'' of the convergence field induced by weak lensing, and relate these to the statistics of overdense regions in underlying mass distribution. It is already known that weak lensing can constrain the background geometry of the Universe, but we further show that it can also provide valuable information about the statistics of collapsed objects and the physics of collisionless clustering. Our results are particularly important for future observations which will, at least initially, focus on small smoothing angles.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
-
Probing The Gravity Induced Bias with Weak Lensing: Test of Analytical results Against Simulations
Authors:
Dipak Munshi
Abstract:
Future weak lensing surveys will directly probe the density fluctuation in the universe. Recent studies have shown how the statistics of the weak lensing convergence field is related to the statistics of collapsed objects. Extending earlier analytical results on the probability distribution function of the convergence field we show that the bias associated with the convergence field can directly…
▽ More
Future weak lensing surveys will directly probe the density fluctuation in the universe. Recent studies have shown how the statistics of the weak lensing convergence field is related to the statistics of collapsed objects. Extending earlier analytical results on the probability distribution function of the convergence field we show that the bias associated with the convergence field can directly be related to the bias associated with the statistics of underlying over-dense objects. This will provide us a direct method to study the gravity induced bias in galaxy clustering. Based on our analytical results which use the hierarchical {\em ansatz} for non-linear clustering, we study how such a bias depends on the smoothing angle and the source red-shift. We compare our analytical results against ray tracing experiments through N-body simulations of four different realistic cosmological scenarios and found a very good match. Our study shows that the bias in the convergence map strongly depends on the background geometry and hence can help us in distinguishing different cosmological models in addition to improving our understanding of the gravity induced bias in galaxy clustering.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
Statistics of Weak Lensing at Small Angular Scales: Analytical Predictions for Lower Order Moments
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Bhuvnesh Jain
Abstract:
Weak lensing surveys are expected to provide direct measurements of the statistics of the projected dark matter distribution. Most analytical studies of weak lensing statistics have been limited to quasilinear scales as they relied on perturbative calculations. On the other hand, observational surveys are likely to probe angular scales less than 10 arcminutes, for which the relevant physical len…
▽ More
Weak lensing surveys are expected to provide direct measurements of the statistics of the projected dark matter distribution. Most analytical studies of weak lensing statistics have been limited to quasilinear scales as they relied on perturbative calculations. On the other hand, observational surveys are likely to probe angular scales less than 10 arcminutes, for which the relevant physical length scales are in the nonlinear regime of gravitational clustering. We use the hierarchical ansatz to compute the multi-point statistics of the weak lensing convergence for these small smoothing angles. We predict the multi-point cumulants and cumulant correlators up to fourth order and compare our results with high resolution ray tracing simulations. Averaging over a large number of simulation realizations for four different cosmological models, we find close agreement with the analytical calculations. In combination with our work on the probability distribution function, these results provide accurate analytical models for the full range of weak lensing statistics. The models allow for a detailed exploration of cosmological parameter space and of the dependence on angular scale and the redshift distribution of source galaxies. We compute the dependence of the higher moments of the convergence on the parameters Omega and Lambda and on the nature of gravitational clustering.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 1999;
originally announced December 1999.
-
The Statistics of Weak Lensing at Small Angular Scales: Probability Distribution Function
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Bhuvnesh Jain
Abstract:
Weak gravitational lensing surveys have the potential to directly probe mass density fluctuation in the universe. Recent studies have shown that it is possible to model the statistics of the convergence field at small angular scales by modeling the statistics of the underlying density field in the highly nonlinear regime. We propose a new method to model the complete probability distribution fun…
▽ More
Weak gravitational lensing surveys have the potential to directly probe mass density fluctuation in the universe. Recent studies have shown that it is possible to model the statistics of the convergence field at small angular scales by modeling the statistics of the underlying density field in the highly nonlinear regime. We propose a new method to model the complete probability distribution function of the convergence field as a function of smoothing angle and source redshift. The model relies on a hierarchical ansatz for the behavior of higher order correlations of the density field. We compare our results with ray tracing simulations and find very good agreement over a range of smoothing angles. Whereas the density probability distribution function is not sensitive to the cosmological model, the probability distribution function for the convergence can be used to constrain both the power spectrum and cosmological parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 1999;
originally announced November 1999.
-
Weak Lensing from Strong Clustering
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Peter Coles
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of weak gravitational lensing in the limit of small angular scales where projected galaxy clustering is strongly nonlinear. This is the regime likely to be probed by future weak lensing surveys. We use well-motivated hierarchical scaling arguments and the plane-parallel approximation to study multi-point statistical properties of the convergence field. These statistics…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of weak gravitational lensing in the limit of small angular scales where projected galaxy clustering is strongly nonlinear. This is the regime likely to be probed by future weak lensing surveys. We use well-motivated hierarchical scaling arguments and the plane-parallel approximation to study multi-point statistical properties of the convergence field. These statistics can be used to compute the vertex amplitudes in tree models of hierarchical clustering; these can be compared with similar measurements from galaxy surveys, leading to a powerful probe of galaxy bias.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 1999;
originally announced November 1999.
-
Bias and Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Peter Coles,
Adrian Melott,
Dipak Munshi
Abstract:
It is now well established that galaxies are biased tracers of the distribution of matter, although it is still not known what form this bias takes. In local bias models the propensity for a galaxy to form at a point depends only on the overall density of matter at that point. Hierarchical scaling arguments allow one to build a fully-specified model of the underlying distribution of matter and t…
▽ More
It is now well established that galaxies are biased tracers of the distribution of matter, although it is still not known what form this bias takes. In local bias models the propensity for a galaxy to form at a point depends only on the overall density of matter at that point. Hierarchical scaling arguments allow one to build a fully-specified model of the underlying distribution of matter and to explore the effects of local bias in the regime of strong clustering. Using a generating-function method developed by Bernardeau & Schaeffer (1992), we show that hierarchical models lead one directly to the conclusion that a local bias does not alter the shape of the galaxy correlation function relative to the matter correlation function on large scales. This provides an elegant extension of a result first obtained by Coles (1993) for Gaussian underlying fields and confirms the conclusions of Scherrer & Weinberg (1998) obtained using a different approach. We also argue that particularly dense regions in a hierarchical density field display a form of bias that is different from that obtained by selecting such peaks in Gaussian fields: they are themselves hierarchically distributed with scaling parameters $S_p=p^{(p-2)}$. This kind of bias is also factorizable, thus in principle furnishing a simple test of this class of models.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 1999; v1 submitted 19 April, 1999;
originally announced April 1999.
-
From Snakes to Stars, the Statistics of Collapsed Objects - II. Testing a Generic Scaling Ansatz for Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Peter Coles,
Adrian L. Melott
Abstract:
We develop a diagrammatic technique to represent the multi-point cumulative probability density function (CPDF) of mass fluctuations in terms of the statistical properties of individual collapsed objects and relate this to other statistical descriptors such as cumulants, cumulant correlators and factorial moments. We use this approach to establish key scaling relations describing various measura…
▽ More
We develop a diagrammatic technique to represent the multi-point cumulative probability density function (CPDF) of mass fluctuations in terms of the statistical properties of individual collapsed objects and relate this to other statistical descriptors such as cumulants, cumulant correlators and factorial moments. We use this approach to establish key scaling relations describing various measurable statistical quantities if clustering follows a simple general scaling ansatz, as expected in hierarchical models. We test these detailed predictions against high-resolution numerical simulations. We show that, when appropriate variables are used, the count probability distribution function (CPDF) and void probability distribution function (VPF) shows clear scaling properties in the non-linear regime. Generalising the results to the two-point count probability distribution function (2CPDF), and the bivariate void probability function (2VPF) we find good match with numerical simulations. We explore the behaviour of the bias associated with collapsed objects in limit of large separations, finding that it depends only on the intrinsic scaling parameter associated with collapsed objects and that the bias for two different objects can be expressed as a product of the individual biases of the objects. Finally we use hierarchal ansatz to develop a novel technique for correcting finite-volume effects in the estimation of multi-point statistical quantities from observational data (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 1999;
originally announced February 1999.
-
From Snakes to Stars, the Statistics of Collapsed Objects - I. Lower--order Clustering Properties
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Peter Coles,
Adrian L. Melott
Abstract:
The highly nonlinear regime of gravitational clustering is characterized by the presence of scale-invariant form of many-body correlation functions. Useful insights can be obtained by investigating the consequences of a generic scaling {\em ansatz}. Extending earlier studies by Bernardeau & Schaeffer (1992) we calculate the detailed consequences of such scaling. We generalise the two-point cumul…
▽ More
The highly nonlinear regime of gravitational clustering is characterized by the presence of scale-invariant form of many-body correlation functions. Useful insights can be obtained by investigating the consequences of a generic scaling {\em ansatz}. Extending earlier studies by Bernardeau & Schaeffer (1992) we calculate the detailed consequences of such scaling. We generalise the two-point cumulant correlators to a hierarchy of multi-point cumulant correlators (MCC). We introduce the concept of reduced cumulant correlators (RCC) and their related generating functions. Using analytical and diagrammatic method we show that every new vertex of the tree representation of higher-order correlations has its own reduced cumulant correlator. In the limit of large separations, MCCs of arbitrary order can be expressed in terms of RCCs of the same and lower order. We relate the generating functions of RCCs with the statistics of {\em collapsed} objects. We develop the hierarchy for the correlation functions of overdense regions. In this vein, we compute the lower-order cumulants and cumulant correlators for overdense regions. Our study shows how they vary as a function of the initial power spectrum of primordial density fluctuations (abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 1998;
originally announced December 1998.
-
Generalised Cumulant Correlators and Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Adrian L. Melott,
Peter Coles
Abstract:
The cumulant correlators, $C_{pq}$, are statistical quantities that generalise the better-known $S_p$ parameters; the former are obtained from the two-point probability distribution function of the density fluctuations while the latter describe only the one-point distribution. If galaxy clustering develops from Gaussian initial fluctuations and a small-angle approximation is adopted, standard pe…
▽ More
The cumulant correlators, $C_{pq}$, are statistical quantities that generalise the better-known $S_p$ parameters; the former are obtained from the two-point probability distribution function of the density fluctuations while the latter describe only the one-point distribution. If galaxy clustering develops from Gaussian initial fluctuations and a small-angle approximation is adopted, standard perturbative methods suggest a particular hierarchical relationship of the $C_{pq}$ for projected clustering data, such as the APM survey. We establish the usefulness of the two-point cumulants for describing hierarchical clustering by comparing such calculations against available measurements from projected catalogs, finding very good agreement. We extend the idea of cumulant correlators to multi-point {\em generalised} cumulant correlators (related to the higher-order correlation functions). We extend previous studies in the highly nonlinear regime to express the generalised cumulant correlators in terms of the underlying ``tree amplitudes'' of hierarchical scaling models. Such considerations lead to a technique for determining these hierarchical amplitudes, to arbitrary order, from galaxy catalogs and numerical simulations. Knowledge of these amplitudes yields important clues about the phenomenology of gravitational clustering. For instance, we show that three-point cumulant correlator can be used to separate the tree amplitudes up to sixth order. We also combine the particular hierarchical {\em ansatz} of Bernardeau & Schaeffer (1992) with extended and hyperextended perturbation theory to infer values of the tree amplitudes in the highly nonlinear regime.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 1998;
originally announced December 1998.
-
Cumulant Correlators in 2D and 3D Scale Free Simulations
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Adrian L. Melott
Abstract:
Shape dependence of higher order correlations introduces complication in direct determination of these quantities. For this reason theoretical and observational progress has been restricted in calculating one point distribution functions and related moments. Methods based on factorial moments of two point count probability distribution (cumulant correlators) were recently shown to be efficient i…
▽ More
Shape dependence of higher order correlations introduces complication in direct determination of these quantities. For this reason theoretical and observational progress has been restricted in calculating one point distribution functions and related moments. Methods based on factorial moments of two point count probability distribution (cumulant correlators) were recently shown to be efficient in subtracting discreteness effects and extracting useful information from galaxy catalogs. We use these cumulant correlators $Q_{NM}$ to study clustering in scale free simulations both in two and three dimensions. Using this method in the highly nonlinear regime we were able to separate hierarchal amplitudes $Q_3, R_a and R_b$ associated with different tree graphs contributing to third and fourth order correlation functions. They were found to increase with power on large scales. Results based on factorial moments of one point cumulants show very good agreement with that on cumulant correlators. Comparison of simulation results with perturbation theory and extended perturbation theory were found to be in reasonable agreement. Comparisons were also made against predictions from hierarchal models for higher order correlations. We argue that finite volume corrections are very important for computation of cumulant correlators.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 1998;
originally announced January 1998.
-
Skewness in the Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy from Inflationary Gravity Wave Background
Authors:
Somnath Bharadwaj,
Dipak Munshi,
Tarun Souradeep
Abstract:
In the context of inflationary scenarios, the observed large angle anisotropy of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) temperature is believed to probe the primordial metric perturbations from inflation. Although the perturbations from inflation are expected to be gaussian random fields, there remains the possibility that nonlinear processes at later epochs induce ``secondary'' non-gaussian feat…
▽ More
In the context of inflationary scenarios, the observed large angle anisotropy of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) temperature is believed to probe the primordial metric perturbations from inflation. Although the perturbations from inflation are expected to be gaussian random fields, there remains the possibility that nonlinear processes at later epochs induce ``secondary'' non-gaussian features in the corresponding CMB anisotropy maps. The non-gaussianity induced by nonlinear gravitational instability of scalar (density) perturbations has been investigated in existing literature. In this paper, we highlight another source of non-gaussianity arising out of higher order scattering of CMB photons off the metric perturbations. We provide a simple and elegant formalism for deriving the CMB temperature fluctuations arising due to the Sachs-Wolfe effect beyond the linear order. In particular, we derive the expression for the second order CMB temperature fluctuations. The multiple scattering effect pointed out in this paper leads to the possibility that tensor metric perturbation, i.e., gravity waves (GW) which do not exhibit gravitational instability can still contribute to the skewness in the CMB anisotropy maps. We find that in a flat $Ω=1$ universe, the skewness in CMB contributed by gravity waves via multiple scattering effect is comparable to that from the gravitational instability of scalar perturbations for equal contribution of the gravity waves and scalar perturbations to the total rms CMB anisotropy. The secondary skewness is found to be smaller than the cosmic variance leading to the conclusion that inflationary scenarios do predict that the observed CMB anisotropy should be statistically consistent with a gaussian random distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 1997;
originally announced August 1997.
-
Non-local scaling in two-dimensional gravitational clustering
Authors:
D. Munshi,
L. Y. Chiang,
P. Coles,
A. L. Melott
Abstract:
Using an ensemble of high resolution 2D numerical simulations, we explore the scaling properties of cosmological density fluctuations in the non-linear regime. We study the scaling behaviour of the usual $N$--point volume-averaged correlations, and also examine the scaling of the entire probability density function (pdf) of the fluctuations. We focus on two important issues: (i) whether the scal…
▽ More
Using an ensemble of high resolution 2D numerical simulations, we explore the scaling properties of cosmological density fluctuations in the non-linear regime. We study the scaling behaviour of the usual $N$--point volume-averaged correlations, and also examine the scaling of the entire probability density function (pdf) of the fluctuations. We focus on two important issues: (i) whether the scaling behaviour of 2D clustering is consistent with what one infer from radial collapse arguments; and (ii) whether there is any evidence from these high-resolution simulations that a regime of stable clustering is ever entered. We find that the answers are (i) yes and (ii) no. We further find that the behaviour of the highly non-linear regime in these simulations suggests the existence of a regime where the correlation function is independent of the initial power spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 1997;
originally announced July 1997.
-
Scaling in Gravitational Clustering, 2D and 3D Dynamics
Authors:
D. Munshi,
F. Bernardeau,
A. L. Melott,
R. Schaeffer
Abstract:
Perturbation Theory (PT) applied to a cosmological density field with Gaussian initial fluctuations suggests a specific hierarchy for the correlation functions when the variance is small. In particular quantitative predictions have been made for the moments and the shape of the one-point probability distribution function (PDF) of the top-hat smoothed density. In this paper we perform a series of…
▽ More
Perturbation Theory (PT) applied to a cosmological density field with Gaussian initial fluctuations suggests a specific hierarchy for the correlation functions when the variance is small. In particular quantitative predictions have been made for the moments and the shape of the one-point probability distribution function (PDF) of the top-hat smoothed density. In this paper we perform a series of systematic checks of these predictions against N-body computations both in 2D and 3D with a wide range of featureless power spectra. In agreement with previous studies, we found that the reconstructed PDF-s work remarkably well down to very low probabilities, even when the variance approaches unity. Our results for 2D reproduce the features for the 3D dynamics. In particular we found that the PT predictions are more accurate for spectra with less power on small scales. The nonlinear regime has been explored with various tools, PDF-s, moments and Void Probability Function (VPF). These studies have been done with unprecedented dynamical range, especially for the 2D case, allowing in particular more robust determinations of the asymptotic behaviour of the VPF. We have also introduced a new method to determine the moments based on the factorial moments. Results using this method and taking into account the finite volume effects are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 1997;
originally announced July 1997.
-
Modelling the evolution of correlation functions in gravitational clustering
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
T. Padmanabhan
Abstract:
Padmanabhan (1996) has suggested a model to relate the nonlinear two - point correlation function to the linear two - point correlation function. In this paper, we extend this model in two directions: (1) By averaging over the initial Gaussian distribution of density contrasts, we estimate the spectral dependence of the scaling between nonlinear and linear correlation functions. (2) By using a p…
▽ More
Padmanabhan (1996) has suggested a model to relate the nonlinear two - point correlation function to the linear two - point correlation function. In this paper, we extend this model in two directions: (1) By averaging over the initial Gaussian distribution of density contrasts, we estimate the spectral dependence of the scaling between nonlinear and linear correlation functions. (2) By using a physically motivated ansatz, we generalise the model to N-point correlation functions and relate the nonlinear, volume averaged, N-point correlation function $\barξ_N(x,a)$ with linearly extrapolated volume averaged 2-point correlation function $\bar ξ_2(l,a)$ evaluated at a different scale. We compare the point of transition between different regimes obtained from our model with numerical simulations and show that the spectral dependence of the scaling relations seen in the simulations can be easily understood. Comparison of the calculated form of $\barξ_N$ with the simulations show reasonable agreement. We discuss several implications of the results.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 1997; v1 submitted 27 June, 1996;
originally announced June 1996.
-
Skewness of Cosmic Microwave Background Temperature Fluctuations Due to Non-linear Gravitational Instability
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Tarun Souradeep,
Alexei A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
Skewness of temperature fluctuations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) produced by initially Gaussian adiabatic perturbations with the flat (Harrison-Zeldovich) spectrum, which arises due to non-linear corrections to a gravitational potential at the matter-dominated stage, is calculated quantitatively. For the standard CDM model, the effect appears to be smaller than expected previously a…
▽ More
Skewness of temperature fluctuations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) produced by initially Gaussian adiabatic perturbations with the flat (Harrison-Zeldovich) spectrum, which arises due to non-linear corrections to a gravitational potential at the matter-dominated stage, is calculated quantitatively. For the standard CDM model, the effect appears to be smaller than expected previously and lies below the cosmic variance limit even for small angles. The sign of the skewness is opposite to that of the skewness of density perturbations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 1995; v1 submitted 28 January, 1995;
originally announced January 1995.
-
Gravitational instability in the strongly nonlinear regime: A study of various approximations
Authors:
B. S. Sathyaprakash,
V. Sahni,
D. Munshi,
D. Pogosyan,
A. L. Melott
Abstract:
We study the development of gravitational instability in the strongly non-linear regime. For this purpose we use a number of statistical indicators such as filamentary statistics, spectrum of overdense/underdense regions and the void probability function, each of which probes a particular aspect of gravitational clustering. We use these statistical indicators to discriminate between different ap…
▽ More
We study the development of gravitational instability in the strongly non-linear regime. For this purpose we use a number of statistical indicators such as filamentary statistics, spectrum of overdense/underdense regions and the void probability function, each of which probes a particular aspect of gravitational clustering. We use these statistical indicators to discriminate between different approximations to gravitational instability which we test against N-body simulations. The approximations which we test are, the truncated Zel'dovich approximation (TZ), the adhesion model (AM), and the frozen flow (FF) and linear potential (LP) approximations. Of these we find that FF and LP break down relatively early, soon after the non-linear length scale exceeds $R_*$ -- the mean distance between peaks of the gravitational potential. The reason for this break down is easy to understand, particles in FF are constrained to follow the streamlines of the initial velocity field. Shell crossing is absent in this case and structure gradually freezes as particles begin to collect near minima of the gravitational potential. In LP particles follow the lines of force of the primordial potential, oscillating about its minima at late times when the non-linear length scale $k_{\rm NL}^{-1}\simeq R_*$. Unlike FF and LP the adhesion model (and to some extent TZ) continues to give accurate results even at late times when $k_{\rm NL}^{-1} \ge R_*$. This is because both AM and TZ use
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 1994;
originally announced August 1994.
-
Non-Linear Approximations to Gravitational Instability: A Comparison in the Quasi-Linear Regime
Authors:
Dipak Munshi,
Varun Sahni,
Alexei A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
We compare different nonlinear approximations to gravitational clustering in the weakly nonlinear regime, using as a comparative statistic the evolution of non-Gaussianity which can be characterised by a set of numbers $S_p$ describing connected moments of the density field at the lowest order in $<δ^2>$: $<δ^n>_c \simeq S_n<δ^2>^{n-1}$. Generalizing earlier work by Bernardeau (1992) we develop…
▽ More
We compare different nonlinear approximations to gravitational clustering in the weakly nonlinear regime, using as a comparative statistic the evolution of non-Gaussianity which can be characterised by a set of numbers $S_p$ describing connected moments of the density field at the lowest order in $<δ^2>$: $<δ^n>_c \simeq S_n<δ^2>^{n-1}$. Generalizing earlier work by Bernardeau (1992) we develop an ansatz to evaluate all $S_p$ in a given approximation by means of a generating function which can be shown to satisfy the equations of motion of a homogeneous spherical density enhancement in that approximation. On the basis of the values of we show that approximations formulated in Lagrangian space (such as the Zeldovich approximation and its extensions) are considerably more accurate than those formulated in Eulerian space such as the Frozen Flow and Linear Potential approximations. In particular we find that the $n$th order Lagrangian perturbation approximation correctly reproduces the first $n+1$ parameters $S_n$. We also evaluate the density probability distribution function for the different approximations in the quasi-linear regime and compare our results with an exact analytic treatment in the case of the Zeldovich approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 1994;
originally announced February 1994.
-
Non-Linear Approximations to Gravitational Instability: A Comparison in Second-Order Perturbation Theory
Authors:
D. Munshi,
A. A. Starobinsky
Abstract:
Nonlinear approximation methods such as the Zeldovich approximation, and more recently the frozen flow and linear potential approximations, are sometimes used to simulate nonlinear gravitational instability in the expanding Universe. We investigate the relative accuracy of these approximations by comparing them with the exact solution using second order perturbation theory. We evaluate the densi…
▽ More
Nonlinear approximation methods such as the Zeldovich approximation, and more recently the frozen flow and linear potential approximations, are sometimes used to simulate nonlinear gravitational instability in the expanding Universe. We investigate the relative accuracy of these approximations by comparing them with the exact solution using second order perturbation theory. We evaluate the density and velocity fields in these approximations to second order, and also determine the skewness parameter $S_3 = \langle δ^3 \rangle / \langle (δ^{(1)})^2\rangle ^2$ for each of the approximations again in second order. We find that $S_3 = 4, ~3, ~3.4$ for the Zeldovich approximation, the frozen flow and the linear potential approximations respectively as compared to $S_3 = {34/7}$ for the exact solution. Our results show that, of all the approximations considered, the Zeldovich approximation is the most accurate in describing the weakly nonlinear effects of gravity. Moreover, the Zeldovich approximation is much closer to the exact results for matter and velocity distributions than the other approximations if the slope of the power spectrum of density perturbations is $-3< n \le -1$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.
