-
Amortized Bayesian model comparison with evidential deep learning
Authors:
Stefan T. Radev,
Marco D'Alessandro,
Ulf K. Mertens,
Andreas Voss,
Ullrich Köthe,
Paul-Christian Bürkner
Abstract:
Comparing competing mathematical models of complex natural processes is a shared goal among many branches of science. The Bayesian probabilistic framework offers a principled way to perform model comparison and extract useful metrics for guiding decisions. However, many interesting models are intractable with standard Bayesian methods, as they lack a closed-form likelihood function or the likeliho…
▽ More
Comparing competing mathematical models of complex natural processes is a shared goal among many branches of science. The Bayesian probabilistic framework offers a principled way to perform model comparison and extract useful metrics for guiding decisions. However, many interesting models are intractable with standard Bayesian methods, as they lack a closed-form likelihood function or the likelihood is computationally too expensive to evaluate. With this work, we propose a novel method for performing Bayesian model comparison using specialized deep learning architectures. Our method is purely simulation-based and circumvents the step of explicitly fitting all alternative models under consideration to each observed dataset. Moreover, it requires no hand-crafted summary statistics of the data and is designed to amortize the cost of simulation over multiple models and observable datasets. This makes the method particularly effective in scenarios where model fit needs to be assessed for a large number of datasets, so that per-dataset inference is practically infeasible.Finally, we propose a novel way to measure epistemic uncertainty in model comparison problems. We demonstrate the utility of our method on toy examples and simulated data from non-trivial models from cognitive science and single-cell neuroscience. We show that our method achieves excellent results in terms of accuracy, calibration, and efficiency across the examples considered in this work. We argue that our framework can enhance and enrich model-based analysis and inference in many fields dealing with computational models of natural processes. We further argue that the proposed measure of epistemic uncertainty provides a unique proxy to quantify absolute evidence even in a framework which assumes that the true data-generating model is within a finite set of candidate models.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2021; v1 submitted 22 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
BayesFlow: Learning complex stochastic models with invertible neural networks
Authors:
Stefan T. Radev,
Ulf K. Mertens,
Andreas Voss,
Lynton Ardizzone,
Ullrich Köthe
Abstract:
Estimating the parameters of mathematical models is a common problem in almost all branches of science. However, this problem can prove notably difficult when processes and model descriptions become increasingly complex and an explicit likelihood function is not available. With this work, we propose a novel method for globally amortized Bayesian inference based on invertible neural networks which…
▽ More
Estimating the parameters of mathematical models is a common problem in almost all branches of science. However, this problem can prove notably difficult when processes and model descriptions become increasingly complex and an explicit likelihood function is not available. With this work, we propose a novel method for globally amortized Bayesian inference based on invertible neural networks which we call BayesFlow. The method uses simulation to learn a global estimator for the probabilistic mapping from observed data to underlying model parameters. A neural network pre-trained in this way can then, without additional training or optimization, infer full posteriors on arbitrary many real datasets involving the same model family. In addition, our method incorporates a summary network trained to embed the observed data into maximally informative summary statistics. Learning summary statistics from data makes the method applicable to modeling scenarios where standard inference techniques with hand-crafted summary statistics fail. We demonstrate the utility of BayesFlow on challenging intractable models from population dynamics, epidemiology, cognitive science and ecology. We argue that BayesFlow provides a general framework for building amortized Bayesian parameter estimation machines for any forward model from which data can be simulated.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2020; v1 submitted 13 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The photon-ion merged-beams experiment PIPE at PETRAIII - The first five years
Authors:
S. Schippers,
T. Buhr,
A. Borovik Jr.,
K. Holste,
A. Perry-Sassmannshausen,
K. Mertens,
S. Reinwardt,
M. Martins,
S. Klumpp,
K. Schubert,
S. Bari,
R. Beerwerth,
S. Fritzsche,
S. Ricz,
J. Hellhund,
A. Müller
Abstract:
The Photon-Ion Spectrometer at PETRA III - in short, PIPE - is a permanently installed user facility at the "Variable Polarization XUV Beamline" P04 of the synchrotron light source PETRA III operated by DESY in Hamburg, Germany. The careful design of the PIPE ion-optics in combination with the record-high photon flux at P04 has lead to a breakthrough in experimental studies of photon interactions…
▽ More
The Photon-Ion Spectrometer at PETRA III - in short, PIPE - is a permanently installed user facility at the "Variable Polarization XUV Beamline" P04 of the synchrotron light source PETRA III operated by DESY in Hamburg, Germany. The careful design of the PIPE ion-optics in combination with the record-high photon flux at P04 has lead to a breakthrough in experimental studies of photon interactions with ionized small quantum systems. This short review provides an overview over the published scientific results from photon-ion merged-beams experiments at PIPE that were obtained since the start of P04 operations in 2013. The topics covered comprise photoionization of ions of astrophysical relevance, quantitative studies of multi-electron processes upon inner-shell photoexcitation and photoionization of negative and positive atomic ions, precision spectroscopy of photoionization resonances, photoionization and photofragmentation of molecular ions and of endohedral fullerene ions.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Imaging the square of the correlated two-electron wave function of a hydrogen molecule
Authors:
M. Waitz,
R. Y. Bello,
D. Metz,
J. Lower,
F. Trinter,
C. Schober,
M. Keiling,
U. Lenz,
M. Pitzer,
K. Mertens,
M. Martins,
J. Viefhaus,
S. Klumpp,
T. Weber,
L. Ph. H. Schmidt,
J. B. Williams,
M. S. Schöffler,
V. V. Serov,
A. S. Kheifets,
L. Argenti,
A. Palacios,
F. Martin,
T. Jahnke,
R. Dörner
Abstract:
The toolbox for imaging molecules is well-equipped today. Some techniques visualize the geometrical structure, others the electron density or electron orbitals. Molecules are many-body systems for which the correlation between the constituents is decisive and the spatial and the momentum distribution of one electron depends on those of the other electrons and the nuclei. Such correlations have esc…
▽ More
The toolbox for imaging molecules is well-equipped today. Some techniques visualize the geometrical structure, others the electron density or electron orbitals. Molecules are many-body systems for which the correlation between the constituents is decisive and the spatial and the momentum distribution of one electron depends on those of the other electrons and the nuclei. Such correlations have escaped direct observation by imaging techniques so far. Here, we implement an imaging scheme which visualizes correlations between electrons by coincident detection of the reaction fragments after high energy photofragmentation. With this technique, we examine the H2 two-electron wave function in which electron-electron correlation beyond the mean-field level is prominent. We visualize the dependence of the wave function on the internuclear distance. High energy photoelectrons are shown to be a powerful tool for molecular imaging. Our study paves the way for future time resolved correlation imaging at FELs and laser based X-ray sources.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Two-particle interference of electron pairs on a molecular level
Authors:
M. Waitz,
D. Metz,
J. Lower,
C. Schober,
M. Keiling,
M. Pitzer,
K. Mertens,
M. Martins,
J. Viefhaus,
S. Klumpp,
T. Weber,
H. Schmidt-Böcking,
L. Ph. H. Schmidt,
F. Morales,
S. Miyabe,
T. N. Rescigno,
C. W. McCurdy,
F. Martin,
J. B. Williams,
M. S. Schöffler,
T. Jahnke,
R. Dörner
Abstract:
We investigate the photo-doubleionization of $H_2$ molecules with 400 eV photons. We find that the emitted electrons do not show any sign of two-center interference fringes in their angular emission distributions if considered separately. In contrast, the quasi-particle consisting of both electrons (i.e. the "dielectron") does. The work highlights the fact that non-local effects are embedded every…
▽ More
We investigate the photo-doubleionization of $H_2$ molecules with 400 eV photons. We find that the emitted electrons do not show any sign of two-center interference fringes in their angular emission distributions if considered separately. In contrast, the quasi-particle consisting of both electrons (i.e. the "dielectron") does. The work highlights the fact that non-local effects are embedded everywhere in nature where many-particle processes are involved.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Ultrafast charge redistribution in small iodine containing molecules
Authors:
Maximilian Hollstein,
Karolin Mertens,
Nils Gerken,
Stephan Klumpp,
Steffen Palutke,
Ivan Baev,
Günter Brenner,
Siarhei Dziarzhytski,
Wilfried Wurth,
Daniela Pfannkuche,
Michael Martins
Abstract:
The competition between intra molecular charge redistribution and fragmentation has been studied in small molecules containing iodine by using intense ultrashort pulses in the extreme ultraviolet regime (XUV). We show that after an element specific inner-shell photoionization of diiodomethane (CH$_2$I$_2$) and iodomethane (CH$_3$I), the induced positive charge is redistributed with a significantly…
▽ More
The competition between intra molecular charge redistribution and fragmentation has been studied in small molecules containing iodine by using intense ultrashort pulses in the extreme ultraviolet regime (XUV). We show that after an element specific inner-shell photoionization of diiodomethane (CH$_2$I$_2$) and iodomethane (CH$_3$I), the induced positive charge is redistributed with a significantly different efficiency. Therefore, we analyze ion time-of-flight data obtained from XUV-pump XUV-probe experiments at the Free Electron Laser in Hamburg (FLASH). Theoretical considerations on the basis of ab initio electronic structure calculations including correlations relate this effect to a strongly molecule specific, purely electronic charge redistribution process that takes place directly after photoionization causing a distribution of the induced positive charge predominantly on the atoms which exhibit the lowest atomic ionization potential, i.e, in the molecules considered, the iodine atom(s). As a result of the very different initial charge distributions, the fragmentation timescales of the two molecules experimentally observed are strikingly different.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2016; v1 submitted 30 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Comment on "The role of wetting heterogeneities in the meandering instability of a partial wetting rivulet"
Authors:
Nima Fathi,
Keith Mertens,
Vakhtang Putkaradze,
Peter Vorobieff
Abstract:
Rivulets and their meandering on a partially wetting surface present an interesting problem, as complex behavior arises from a deceptively simple setup. Recently Couvreur and Daerr suggested that meandering is caused by an instability developing as the flow rate $Q$ increases to a critical value $Q_c$, with stationary (pinned) meandering being the final state of the flow. We tried to verify this a…
▽ More
Rivulets and their meandering on a partially wetting surface present an interesting problem, as complex behavior arises from a deceptively simple setup. Recently Couvreur and Daerr suggested that meandering is caused by an instability developing as the flow rate $Q$ increases to a critical value $Q_c$, with stationary (pinned) meandering being the final state of the flow. We tried to verify this assertion experimentally, but instead produced results contradicting the claim of Couvreur and Daerr. The likely reason behind the discrepancy is the persistence of flow-rate perturbations. Moreover, the theory presented in this paper cannot reproduce the states as considered and disagrees with other theories.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Active multi-point microrheology of cytoskeletal networks
Authors:
Tobias Paust,
Katinka Mertens,
Ines Martin,
Michael Beil,
Othmar Marti
Abstract:
Active microrheology is a valuable tool to determine viscoelastic properties of polymer networks. Observing the beads response to the excitation of a reference leads to dynamic and morphological information of the material. In this work we present an expansion of the well-known active two-point microrheology. By measuring the response of multiple particles in the viscoelastic medium in response to…
▽ More
Active microrheology is a valuable tool to determine viscoelastic properties of polymer networks. Observing the beads response to the excitation of a reference leads to dynamic and morphological information of the material. In this work we present an expansion of the well-known active two-point microrheology. By measuring the response of multiple particles in the viscoelastic medium in response to the excitation of a reference particle we are able to determine the force propagation in the polymer network.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Absolute cross sections for photoionization of Xe$^{q+}$ ions (1 $\le$ q $\le$ 5) at the 3d ionization threshold
Authors:
S. Schippers,
S. Ricz,
T. Buhr,
A. Borovik Jr.,
J. Hellhund,
K. Holste,
K. Huber,
H. -J. Schäfer,
D. Schury,
S. Klumpp,
K. Mertens,
M. Martins,
R. Flesch,
G. Ulrich,
E. Rühl,
T. Jahnke,
J. Lower,
D. Metz,
L. P. H. Schmidt,
M. Schöffler,
J. B. Williams,
L. Glaser,
F. Scholz,
J. Seltmann,
J. Viefhaus
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The photon-ion merged-beams technique has been employed at the new Photon-Ion spectrometer at PETRA III (PIPE) for measuring multiple photoionization of Xe$^{q+}$ (q=1-5) ions. Total ionization cross sections have been obtained on an absolute scale for the dominant ionization reactions of the type hν+ Xe$^{q+}$ $\to$ Xe$^{r+}$ + (q-r) e$^-$ with product charge states q+2 $\le$ r $\le$ q+5. Promine…
▽ More
The photon-ion merged-beams technique has been employed at the new Photon-Ion spectrometer at PETRA III (PIPE) for measuring multiple photoionization of Xe$^{q+}$ (q=1-5) ions. Total ionization cross sections have been obtained on an absolute scale for the dominant ionization reactions of the type hν+ Xe$^{q+}$ $\to$ Xe$^{r+}$ + (q-r) e$^-$ with product charge states q+2 $\le$ r $\le$ q+5. Prominent ionization features are observed in the photon-energy range 650-750 eV, which are associated with excitation or ionization of an inner-shell 3d electron. Single-configuration Dirac-Fock calculations agree quantitatively with the experimental cross sections for non-resonant photoabsorption, but fail to reproduce all details of the measured ionization resonance structures.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
The trapping and escape of buoyant vortex rings in sharply stratified fluids
Authors:
R. Camassa,
S. Khatri,
R. McLaughlin,
K. Mertens,
E. Monbureau,
D. Nenon,
C. Smith,
C. Viotti,
B. White
Abstract:
In this fluid dynamics video we study the dynamics of miscible vortex rings falling in ambient strongly (near two-layer) stratified fluid. Experiments and direct numerical simulations using the variable density Navier-Stokes (VARDEN) solver are presented and compared. Critical phenomena are identified depending upon the key parameters of the experiment (fluid and ring densities, upper layer vortex…
▽ More
In this fluid dynamics video we study the dynamics of miscible vortex rings falling in ambient strongly (near two-layer) stratified fluid. Experiments and direct numerical simulations using the variable density Navier-Stokes (VARDEN) solver are presented and compared. Critical phenomena are identified depending upon the key parameters of the experiment (fluid and ring densities, upper layer vortex travel distance, etc) in which the descending dense vortex ring may experience complete trapping, partial trapping, or fissioning into a cascade of smaller vortices. The interaction of the vortex ring with the upper layer fluids leads to viscous entrainment which alters the effective buoyancy of the ring. Upon impinging on a density transition, the entrained fluid imparts different dynamics as it attempts to regain equilibrium leading to the critical behaviors.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2011;
originally announced October 2011.
